2023-10-19 Somerset County, NJ YouTube / Board Meeting transcript source: youtube Board Meeting 10-18-23 · passage 1
all right you are live all right you are live good evening everybody and welcome to our meeting for September happy to see all of our students and Educators back in the auditorium looking forward to recognizing our students and educat the uh but for now let's start with some regular Ro administrative stuff and the Pledge of Allegiance is the first thing up after we do the reading of the open public meeting statement which says that the New Jersey open public meetings law was enacted to ensure the right of the public to have advance notice of and to attend the public bodies at which time any business affecting their interests is discussed and AC upon in accordance with provisions of this act in Board of Education policy 0162 the Board of Education of the buau of Bound Brook has caused notice of this meeting to be host in the board office and at Bound Brook High School and mailed orax to The Courier News Bound Brook B clerk bound BR Board of Education and any person who has requested individual Mr Mr here here Mr here M here Mr minus here m h Mr bulmer here and Mr janoi here Bo president you have a quum present this evening thank you very much uh I will actually just skip right over the president's comments so that we can get to my favorite part of the meeting of superintendent Dr Freeman thank you Mr President uh it's good to see everybody Welcome to our October board meeting uh tonight is the first night that we be recognizing our employees of the month and our students of the month but before we do that I just want to give a shout out to all of our administrators and teachers this year we're in our 29th day we're at the point now where all the changes are Place uh things are running well and it wouldn't be possible without the uh strong effort from our Administration and our teachers so I want to give them a shout out for that if you can give them a round of [Applause] [Music] applause teachers for we're celebrating Hispanic Heritage Month and the teachers are really pushing in celebrating the uh accomplishments of our uh Latino American community members and what they done done for our community to really push that issue to teach our kids to celebrate the culture and how important our diversity is how how strong diversity makes us so I want to commend him for that as well so without further Ado as president said we're going to move on to our students of the month I would ask Dr s to come for us to introduce the Lamont students of the month good evening congratulations to Leonardo balanos Leonardo Leonardo has two older siblings um his favorite subject is learning the alphabet and playing on the playground he loves playing soccer basketball he loves to run play with his big brother and watch TV um his career plans is I want to be a famous soccer player um his teacher misso wanted me to read this um I chose Leonardo for this student of the month because of his positive and upbeat personality leadership skills and caring personality from the moment Leo walks into the school until the moment we leave for the day Leo's the happiest student in the room Leo is always a supportive and caring friend his classmates comes in every day at school ready to ask many questions and participates during instruction he enjoys building blocks and playing with table toys with his friends no matter what time of the day it is you can always find Leo with a big smile in his face and ready to learn congratulations Leo [Applause] no oh how [Music] nice bud okay good [Applause] round for the kindergarten Lamont Lamont Annex School congratulations to Hanna cabara annna has a two-year-old little sister named Goldie her favorite subject is literacy lab because she likes to pick up pick out books to read from the school's library she enjoys going to endur play places um when she grows up she wants to be a nurse to help people like her grandma hanay was selected for student of the month because she's an active participant in class and always a helpful friend to her classmates congratulations hannay [Applause] beauti [Applause] and next up forette we [Music] [Applause] have good evening our first student of the month is uh Seline Cordo queres she has a twin sister Sophia Rose her favorite school subject is math her favorite hobbies are cretive and doing crafts and she wants to be an artist when she grows up [Applause] congratulations Round of [Applause] Applause our next student of the month is Victor Medina gdy he has a younger brother his favorite school subject is math art and physical education he loves drawing and playing soccer and he wants to be an artist as well when he GR [Applause] one last round of applause and next up for small School Miss [Applause] Carbone our third grade student of the month is theago Torres Rodriguez H excuse me theago Torres Ramirez he is in third grade in Miss es Vito's class um he has one older sister his favorite subject is math he loves to play video games and he wants to be a soccer player or a basketball player when he gets older congratulations [Applause] [Music] [Applause] Thiago guys are nailing it [Applause] today Small's fourth grade student of the menth is Caitlyn Velasco Dominguez Caitlyn has one older brother Allan and and another older brother Benny and they're both at the middle school Caitlyn's favorite subject in school is math and writing her favorite hobbies are drawing hanging out with friends and making bracelets when she gets older she says I want to sell houses and be a realator congratulations [Applause] Kaitlyn you back up a little there you [Applause] go the SMY Elementary School fifth grade student of the month is cor Kama conteras she is in fifth grade in Miss Riley's class and she has one younger brother her favorite subjects are math in ela and for favorite hobbies she says I love to read when coriyama gets older she would like to be a lawyer congratulations Cor [Applause] up [Applause] SMY Elementary School sixth grade student of the month is I I just saw him Dylan as monosa Rodriguez Dylan has one little brother he says I like history or phizz he loves to play soccer as his favorite hobby and when he grows up he wants to be a soccer player congratulations [Applause] [Music] thank you Mr next up we have Mr s Ser from Community Middle School hello everybody of course I'm got two and I'm out of order our first student of the month from Community Middle School is Hugo [Applause] Morales hug Hugo's sis sibling is Alana and his favorite subjects are film PE science Ela and social studies so that means everything but math everything but math a favorite hobbies are soccer Xbox hanging out with friends and board games with family and when Hugo grows up would like to play professional soccer but it says if that doesn't work out Computer Engineering congratulations [Applause] you [Applause] congratulations last but not least for our high school oh our eighth grade student of the month is Alisa Gurley come on down come on down Lisa was nominated by her teacher Mr ratl oh yeah you gotta come on come get you so Alisa siblings are Anthony Amir Elijah Isaiah Assan and Autumn favorite subject Ela never seen you bash this is a book favorite subjects are cheer and sports and wants to be a teacher or a lawyer when you grow [Applause] up last but not least Mr Smith all right good evening all right the Crusader citizen of the month award is in recognition of students demonstrating positive Crusader citizenship traits such as responsibility respect kindness Integrity cooperation tolerance and perseverance our first recipient is Andrea trilo [Applause] menar okay Andrea has 13 siblings seven women and five men her favorite subject is English favorite hobbies are um listening to music sleeping eating and dancing and career plans when she graduates from high school she would like to study um criminal justice and hopes of becoming a [Applause] policeman [Applause] our next recipient is beus Aruda uh beatric has one sibling a brother her favorite subject is history favorite hobbies are ice skating being with friends and eating and future career plans she hopes to become a teacher teacher so congratulations [Applause] teachers wow [Applause] great all right our next re recipient Vlad Rudy uh Vlad has one sister Victoria Rudy his favorite subject is personal Wellness his hobbies are playing sports running in particular and hanging out with friends uh in the future vad hopes to secure a position in a STEM related [Applause] field let's have one last round of [Applause] applause all right last but certainly not least our last recipient Jackson [Applause] Jackson has six siblings and out of them he is the oldest he loves social studies modern world history in particular he loves to play a lot of basketball in his free time play video games with friends and listen to music in the future he hopes to play basketball in college and hopefully one day play in the [Applause] NBA big smile there we go thank you all right with everybody with all the students of the month come up with parent so we can get a group photo we doing it on stage [Music] conat come right along the front row come on down you can get right in front of them you're fine worry about it sco a little bit lot of us here now I'm like exposed again there you go some look at Sydney [Music] good love the dress really got dress I love feel better I don't want thank you okay next up we're going to recognize our educator and support staff of the month we will start with Miss CER our district Employee of the Month would you please come [Applause] forward some well prepared descriptive words of who she is and what she does for our kids and Community I'll try to talk as fast as I can um Corey hater is a dedicated employee of the Bound Brook School District for over three years she's consistently demonstrated exceptional commitment and a positive attitude she arrives at work each day with a warm smile and a willingness to help earning her the admiration of all of her colleagues describe Corey as sweet kind caring and an outstanding team player her sorry her teaching approach is marked by Innovation and creativity as she designs engaging lessons for her students notably Corey stepped up recently to cover teach for a teacher whose start date was initially scheduled for October she embrac the class as her own and goes the extra mile to ensure all students Thrive her genuine concern for the students extends to advocating for their academic social and emotional needs making her a true champion for their success Corey is a collaborative team player who consistently Works alongside her fellow teachers she's not only kind and attentive but also a great listener offering her colleagues a safe and supportive space for discussions and risk-taking when it comes to communication planning and teaching with her exceptional dedication and contributions to the Bound Brook School District Corey hater is a deserving candidate for Employee of the Month the district is indeed fortunate to have her and Lafayette Elementary School is even lucky to luckier to benefit from her outstanding presence congratulations to Corey for her well-deserved [Applause] recognition thank [Applause] you next up we have our Sports staff with Once miss Kiss Dr s will come up and say a few words miss Kiss would you please come [Applause] forward so congratulations to miss Kiss this month's Jem's recipient miss Kiss is a teacher assistant lont school and she's constantly goes above and beyond for her students in the community her dedication and willingness to help when Ever Needed are greatly appreciated by all during this summer miss Kiss volunteered her time to assist with open house and decorated our school showing her commitment to creating the warming welcoming environment she also contributed by creating buting boards and assisting for various office tasks throughout the school year miss Kiss plays a crucial role in morning arrivals this misso bus Duty much more she's constantly engaging with the students ensuring that they stay on track and have a fun learning experience her helpful attit to extend to the current office where she frequently offers her assistance to staff members Miss kid has great energies truly passionate about about early childhood education we are incredibly fortunate to have her as a valuable member of our team and her dedication enthusiasm make a positive impact on our school Community thank you Miss kiss for your outstanding [Applause] contribution congratulations thank you I just want to recognize some of our other teachers who volunteer their time to come out to support their colleagues Mr tone if you would please stand Miss [Music] Helman [Applause] Lopez so congratulations again to all of our students of the month and educators of the month uh at this point we're going to transition over to our committee report so for those of you who are really here for the awards take it personally if you decide to quietly exit out the doors to your I apologize you're right we're not doing the committee reports yet because we have Mr Ross us presentation [Applause] yes you good there okay so I am here Mr Ross I'm the supervisor of Career Technical education work-based learning I'm going to be telling you about our data our data is not widgets it's human beings and so there's something behind this that it means a lot so that's why we have up here you'll see committed inclusive intentional it's our three words that we came up during our summer team administrative work it's the good work that we're doing that translates into the numbers that you're going to see and it also is why I have academic Excellence empowering student emotional well-being we want education to empower students to have resources in their life to be better and stronger so this data means something to us um even though I default to English I have a growth mindset and I sat down with the supervisor of math and I learned a lot about percentages to understand this in more detail for you so let's take a look here's the goal for the presentation there's a big overarching goal which is to make data actionable information right so with this data we are doing things for you this administrative team here is doing stuff for you and I know the teachers are doing stuff for you for the students so what does it look like first There's a summary of The District data there's a full detail of all this data 60 pages of it with the subgroups broken out by Race by gender by social economic demographics we're disaggregating that data on our own and we're using that to Target those subgroups but what I wanted to do here was focus on some specific growth some positive developments that we are using to help every student not just those who are proficient or succeeding so what I'm doing is I specifically looked at njsla showing you the proficiency results and Trends from 3 through n for njs LA and then with the NJ GPA graduation ready results and Trends pilot year it was a pilot year last year for 2021 with the test and this year was something that counted for the students in 20223 so we want to look at those Trends then the last two slides are really going to just show us the intentional next steps that we are already taking everything that you're seeing is already starting as Dr Freeman said we're 29 days in these things have been on our plate since we saw these numbers um really back in June when we were starting to first get them first develop them then we did talk about them over the summer and then we have implemented specific actions like I ready like ISL um like our irns interventions and reflecting on those pieces so as I go through the slides I will show you the data and I'll show you also what we're doing with it so first an overview with New Jersey student learning assessments that's our three through nine piece so we're looking at seven grades for ELA grades four seven eight and nine all show growth in students who met proficiency and we're above proficient so we're either proficient or highly above proficient so that's an important element with math grades four five six seven and nine that's if I'm counting right five out of the Seven Grade of that grade band who showed growth from 21 to 22 from 2122 to 22 23 that's an important element for us because we want to say why that's happening and then we also want to be able to look at how do we help those students who aren't yet there next with the MJ GPA New Jersey graduate proficiency assessment the percentage increased from 2122 22 23 in ela by 200 21% that's amazing and that's partly due to sat tutoring that we were providing it was partly due to um tutoring for NJ GPA that was provided Mr Smith myself the supervisor of math we're working on that and that really helped students get invested in their education and also something where we were making sure everybody was focused so that was key math had a 10% increase Maybe not as strong but still we're looking at a postco development and we're looking at how we understand the world a new so despite these increases we know there's room for growth so that's why when I get to the data review I broke it up into 1819 preco and then I broke it up into 2122 and 22 23 so what we can see is where we were pre-o and what do we look like for two year the past two years postco and that will help to give you context for this data right to say okay what was the world like before we had everything shut down and where are we post that all right so what are we going to use it for we're going to strategically sorry support those that did not I guess we could say did not or partially or are approaching we are certainly going to be paying attention to those students and you will see what we have in place for it um we will also inform use this data to increase academic rigor social m intelligence and build curricular relevance that's something that I take very personally because I want the students to know that their math matters that their English matters that their World Language matters it helps you develop yourself it helps you have resources when you're at home because most of the time you sit at home what are you doing look at your phone well here maybe you want to read this book maybe you want to get interested in that so we are making sure that this data leads to something important in their life so here we go NJ s laa here's our numbers Ela and math 3-9 so I don't know they have you have a copy you see able to see that yeah folks see that up in the air so here's where things really start to look important I went with 20189 which is preco and then there's two years P where we can compare what students are doing if we look at oops sorry go back if we look at the third grade group they were struggling why because they didn't have the benefit of uh Dr s's program and the support of being in class K1 and two that's your Co group so your people who are third grade here were missing out on that direct instruction with teacher so we can see that compared to where they were in 2122 and where they were in 20189 so these are some of the things that we we have to look at how do we go about supporting that group who missed out on Direct instruction and that's something we're thinking about we look at the next grade band level and you can see we increased here in fourth grade from last year to this year but if you look at the group here which is number 33 in 201819 they would now be seventh graders so on this they are right here so to give you comparison this cohort right here 33 scored 30 see what I'm saying so for me yep so here's so I guess I should break it down for us so there's three ways that we can look at this data either this tells us how the curriculum's going how the teaching is going and how the cohort is going so when we look at one year to the next and we see that we're moving up it shows us that our curriculum and our teaching is moving in a positive direction and then what I also wanted to map for you was we have this grade in 201819 right here would have been fourth grade if we move up the count the years right so in 20 1920 they would have been in 1819 they were in fifth grade sixth grade seventh grade so this group here moves here four five six seven right does that make sense so here's what I'm trying to show you is this group of students right here this and I didn't break it out this way int intentionally but I just wanted to show you a sample of it is that these kids right here are these kids right here so there is not showing a big learning loss right so they go four five six seven so you're in fourth grade 2018 19 you're in fifth grade grade in 20 in 1920 you're in sixth grade in 2021 and you're in seventh grade in 2122 so here they were taking this test the learning loss is not there they have a strong you know retention of growth that's important for us so that's what we're looking at so with this data we can see that preo and postco we're remaining strong and in some places we even growing Beyond preo times can I interrupt you absolutely question comment so the idea of reviewing this from a cohort perspective mind mind intuitively and I really appreciate the remarks that you're making because for me I look at seventh grade y right seventh grade Red Bar will be 2122 y right but that's now our eighth grade yellow bar that class up almost 20 percentage points yeah right from one year to the next yes amazing right so the key for me with this because I was looking at only two years one because the NJ GPA doesn't exist beyond that so I broke it down for the njsa for only two years normally I'd give you a fiveyear data picture um but what I wanted also to show is that we do talk a lot about coid learning loss what does it mean what does it look like so here is a the blue band is where we were prior to co and then here we are for the past two years and like you were saying which was this um group here in 21 22 if you can see with my pointer they're at 46 and then they're at 41 and9 so they're dropping a little but they're staying consistent right the 30% here are the 49% here that shows growth right so this data is telling us that our programs are working it's telling us that we are you know in some areas needing to focus on well what happened during Co and how can we return to this new system return to getting them back on track so for English as you can see we really maintained sorry a strong level base because here we dropped a little we went up Dro somewhat of the drop up up and up so the fact that we're consistently growing is something positive for us to review so same thing with the math the math is very very impressive why 28% compared to 14 19% compared to 9 16 to 15 22 to6 this group here is a is a point where is there's no good or bad data there's just information right so now it's a matter of we take this information and we go okay what's going on with this group where did it come from right where were they in the year prior they were at 16 so they did drop what happened what do we need to do how do we address so none of this data is either good or bad it's just do we need to work on our curriculum do we need to work with our teachers do we need to work with tutoring um and what is it that we need to do to address these issues but what I really need to stress with this data is the growth that's still there and that's an important element for us next is the G NJ GPA so this grade 11 assessment is new it's difficult and it's a bit of a challenge but it's two years in so here's our comparison this to me was impressive so even though math only went up statistically in percentage wise um 10% right out of 100 I just learned from the math supervisor the percentages are all out of 100 right so thank you math people so this is what I'm saying when I sat down to do this data for you I made I made sure that I went to our content specialist she informed me that look will when you're doing percentages it's always out of 100% so that is 10% growth from the 27 to 30 it's 221 per about for or more for the E English that's insane and I think that's due directly to our putting in new programs like tutoring um like are looking at increasing the books that we have available for our curriculum and developing a better connection between the grades so I think that's clearly being seen so what are our intentional next steps want to wind it up for you because I did just read this whole big book on doubt and after reading it I have no doubt that we're doing good things come on now I have no doubt try here so right after reading this book on doubt I have no doubt we're doing good things so what are we doing so the administrative team with this data that you saw because this conversation that we just had um right here is one that I've already had with English and math and other and curriculum supervisors the administrative team pre2 is working with teachers to um Norm focused lesson plans so we've been revamping objectives with teach in the classroom student centered activities in the classroom in order to better meet students individual needs we also have been hitting with you know I don't know more than a three point point whatever 3.0 batting average whatever that is the highest batting average ever probably this ISL teachers are utilizing ISL and I ready to work on preent skills to get grade level subject matter and they're utilizing this data to really set up small group construction they set up tutoring in the High School to have people working during study hall onl and all grade levels it's allowing them to have the students work at their own pace to figure out where they can grow and what skills they need so this ISL initiative has been something that been working on a lot and it's from this data next is the administrative team is looking at disaggregating the data to better align instructions with standards so we talk about if the students aren't proficient what standards are they not proficient in how do we help them those conversations are window that was weird Okay so that was um you know the gong show I'm getting pulled off so I want to be quick um anybody remember the gong show all right so um we're encouraging staff to adopt problem based learning model and encourage start invention so we are asking them to do problem based learning rather than um recall questions rather than fill in the blank questions where with problem based we're giving them something to work through in the classroom this is a through 12 next is we're monitoring students progress using benchmarks we've established in-house benchmarks we use ISL as benchmarks we do fall winter spring and we target instruction based on that so we're not only using the njsla or the NJ GPA bless you we are also working with ISL data as well and the last thing is I want to focus on for you to make sure you know that this data means something all of these jarn here jiren something that ends with an ing what we're doing is we're expanding we're implementing we're recalibrating we're targeting we're updating we're increasing we're applying and we're providing right we're expanding small group of instruction this has been an initiative since Dr Freeman came here uh talking about how do we get people to work together to meet the needs students who were otherwise not approaching so those people who weren't those students who weren't proficient were working on how can you be more successful implementing New Jersey high impact tutoring program that we have applied for it's really focused for three through four but we're looking to model it and extend it K through 12 so that there's extra help for our students tutoring tutoring tutoring is a way that we transcend the co issue we we want to work on recalibrating our irns program so that we identify students earlier who need supports who need 504s who strategically need IEPs so really supports is the key model there so that we don't necessarily need a 504 or an IEP and we want to catch students as early as possible we want to Target our PD and we've been doing that we've been having great PD sessions where we work on highly effective instructional strategies and we've been really working with teachers to think about their teaching in the classroom and to not do what I'm doing right now which is taught at you updating g&t curriculum which has gone uh over the past year I've been hearing about this and it's really been an exciting thing where the stem the g&t uh depart programs are expanding we're getting new teachers for it we're making sure that it is something that is prominent throughout the curriculum then we are increasing personally for me this is where is one of my proverbial babies so to speak increasing our dual credit courses we recently shift from rvcc alone to work with Stockton University a four-year University so we now have 17 courses from Stockton University and that's important that's going to help us manage this data help how do we help these kids succeed on these assessments and then we are also applying for a DCC grant for $100,000 why so that we can make sure we pay for all students to take these courses here also the program works to set up a grant where we potentially have 18 teachers getting master's degrees in content area to make them more dynamic in the classroom and that it was through the gr and then finally there's an initiative that's ongoing right now providing eight to 10 teachers grade um all grade levels ESL certificates via fairly differ in University very important here so that we can address all of our students so here's the nuts and bolts looking at where we were preco to where we are postco we are making strides the numbers for me do look good but the numbers also for me tell us that we need to make sure that we have these conversations and we figure out the strategies to help the kids who are struggling at all levels so we want to help everybody the lower the middle the high level student in every way and that's pretty much the data as it stands for this year questions concerns major malfunctions any questions or comments I guess I will first um first of all Mr R is beautiful thank you I do a lot of presentations that' done thank you so K so quick question for you um this slide is different than the one that we received a few days ago okay so the data that you were looking at from the NJ so so that is what I mentioned earlier so absolutely so the full data the link data reports that you're getting shows all the subgroups so for the purpose of this moment I mean if we want to break down subgroups we can look at ethnicities we can look at special head we are sitting that and I just want to assure you that that's what I just did here was look at okay Co versus where we are now so is that the total number that you're mentioning here for grade three grade four those numbers are yeah because your total numbers are different than the ones that I got from those reports for proficiencies which proficiencies are you looking at so um scores of four and five together yeah so what I'm looking at only is scores of four and five put together so yeah it may not be the apparent number there because they're separated sometimes depends on how so the way the link people had presented the data is there a reason why one two and three are not included there's a reason why um yes because what I'm trying to show is the way that we're making students College ready the way that we're making students proficient and how we're managing that and then the other part for me is with knowing where we are with the proficiencies we want to look at the strategies we use for them so that we take it to all students because on average based on the percentages that were provided in the reports um 60% of the students are in levels one two and three so what you're showing here on this graph only represents 40% of your grade yes yes I mean so at this point yes there are some of the students those students are being taken care of based on us knowing best practices for them and that's why we get to here is ultimately we look at the scores and we go these are the students who are making it what standards are they achieving how are they're achieving it then we need to make sure that we do that for all the students who are there so the piece for me is also in looking at data because data is only numbers not information we need to pay attention to how we are growing and so I can break this down and disaggregate how we are growing even for other groups it's smaller so the key for me is if this proficiency is getting bigger the other side that you were mentioning the ones the twos of the threes or getting ones two threes get smaller so that isn't made apparent so I could work on doing that in a better way next time for sure where showing that because we went up that much that means that there's so many people who are not in that lower category anymore you're absolutely right the thing is the thing that you mentioned four FES the fives to me are actually going down either just staying the same right so yeah I mean so for me I don't see how the for May but overall they're do great but then when you break it down to lower that subset to just level files only yep it seems pretty stag the groups of Fes are in a stagnant place and something that we need to address absolutely so again like I said before data is not good or bad yeah so again so for me for the sake of time I focused on a specific area and that was looking at how we were doing over time so your point is well made um so for me when I look at the four we definitely are are growing there when we look at five that's exceptional and that's where we want to be but our big issue has always been making sure everybody's Beyond too proficient and that's been our question why is science why is science there because I was not I mean able to pull up everything quickly because I was bringing this fair enough it does take a while yeah I wasn't able to P so I could pull that in to you and if you want me to give you that I can certainly that out the other part about science as most people who are teachers who know they all say it's going to count and it never does so here's the problem with that data if we want to really get into it is it's a little bit bogus because the students know that it doesn't count per se for graduation Readiness and it's been a big thing that's I've been in this game for 26 years now they've been saying it's going to count since I started in 2005 here in New Jersey and guess what science doesn't count so you're right um I didn't have the time to get to that one this Mr Ross I just wanted to say being an educator I am very impressed I am very very thankful and I'm humbled by the work you've done in compressing all of this data I think the board is appreciative where we're at and where we're going and I think that if you look at this globally you're giving us really good outlook from a Layman's point of view you're giving us a really good outlook of that you know the the growth is being made and I think you said it really good we're not dealing with widgets we're not dealing we're dealing with children yeah and you know the fact of the matter is is that to see with everything else we have going on this growth thanks to you thanks to your administrative team thanks to everyone thanks to our teachers I I I I have to say is that it it I'm humbled by what I'm seeing I thank you from the bottom of my heart because this is phenomenal thank you no I thank you and thank you for your questions I mean seriously I mean I didn't cover everything here and if I did I you can as you can tell I could keep going really quick I had one comment and then um something to clarify um first I think I can't believe it's been a year already but last year we sat here and I know we had a big conversation when we saw this president presentation that people were talking about we need growth now we need 100% And I know the teachers up here sat here and said if we get 3% right if we get 5% that's amazing right and you're showing us 221 per on I mean granted that's one test but that's I mean that's amazing that's a major test for when I saw that bar when you sent it to me I thought it was a mistake I was like that can't be true there's no way that's amazing so first of all this incremental growth it's going to take years but this is an amazing first step let's start there now the one that's concerning when you look at it is the eighth grade math right but my question to you is so everybody understands the eighth graders are that take math are broken up into math 8 and algebra okay so let's talk about why that number looks the way yeah so that's key I'll let Robin I'll default to her wisdom on that yeah so the eth grade is deceiving because um we have students who take algebra and those kids were tested with the ninth graders they take the ninth grade test so um you know it looks like the performance is lower but our top performing students actually didn't take the eth grade test they took the nth grade test so we're losing you lose your top we're losing 28 to 35 kids actually yes so that's a good point and Jill did tell me to make that point so sorry Jill I'm on YouTube I didn't make that point she did point that out to me specific specifically that yes and thank you for bringing up is that those 30 kids do make a dent because they are not take they not yes so you know I mean maybe if the state was Savvy they'd say look take both I don't know let's torture kids that's what we need is kids taking more tests yeah there we go no let's torture children so for me as a non educator to make sure I understand um and guys to be honest here um so if your is algebra you take the grade n because it's a nth gr but then if you're not taking Al you're doing the regular you it's called eighth grade curriculum math yeah that's yeah so that's a great point so thank you for highlighting that and I was supposed to say that get my back um so thank you for the questions I mean thank you for the hard questions thank you for the you know the support and again I'm finished thank you everybody out here for one more anybody else yeah just want to Echo the comments of the board we've all been party to the conversation about all the good instructional work that's going on um in the district so my question was about the next steps when we look at the subgroup DAT seems our students with disabilities and our multilingual kids are really struggling and not maybe realizing as much growth as we hope for U can you speak to how these steps um will be um sort of enacted with those groups of kids in mind what that might look like for multi I think with a lot of our subgroups we're seeing that so when you break down you know by Race by gender and social economic again is a big indicator as well as as a struggle and certainly that's where we need to provide extra supports for our students and simple things like um executive functionings and figuring out what's a school workspace look like in your home we're having those conversations do you have a desk at home do you work anywhere on your your work besides your bed um and that simple conversation is part of all of this stuff that we're doing certainly the ISL which is really a guided learning practice that helps a student to go at their own pace so it's adaptive it's so fancy for those non-educators it's adap testing so whatever you do it you along your path so ISL is a very strong support for our kids who are struggling or who are not meeting grade level who are needing to get to proficiency so that's what's that's doing I think also us looking at the subgroups like you were saying we are very aware of okay next yes so um you know one of the things that we wanted to do to address the multilingual Learners and our teachers ability to service them properly was um starting with this es certification program the more Educators who are trained on how to work with students um at our language Learners the stronger they'll be in their academic classes and um you know this stretched all across the grade span um another thing was um recalibrating our inrs process and also looking at um identifying students earlier who are struggling and then coming up with um Improvement plans for them on how to get them closer to where they need to be um with the tutoring that we can Target the students more specifically based on their individual needs um the small group instruction we really um working on focusing on um strengthening the tier one um interventions within the classroom in addition to um increasing the tier 2 interventions in the classroom um in addition to outside of the classroom and um oh and then even um we have some students who um might be actually gifted or Advanced students who are um multilingual Learners and specialed students students and we're trying to do a better job of identifying those students so we can provide them with the stem activities and the enrichment activities which will hopefully help to um you know increase their um their confidence and get them more engaged academically yeah I second that piece because for me that comes from personal space was a dyslexic adht kid who was in AP classes in high school but Po in C pluses was still went to to a state school and then you know got got into I leads um it's possible so I think it's really important that we're identifying students for what it is is this a learning issue is this a language issue is this a behavioral issue and really identifying them so it's it's it's not only personal but it's important for student there one other thing uh in the change we made to our program one of the things we found is that children were having difficulty learning the academic we were teaching English but we weren't using they weren't sound or strong in their native language so by changing our bilingual program to where they focus on the native language and then each year they start to increase the percentage of English that the class are taught in that's one of the major Keys now that's going to take two or three years for it to happen but we find it when we get to the point where we have children who are strong in their native language after fourth grade fifth grade will start to see the jump in their ability to handle the academic language and therefore do better on the assessment that's a major piece that we put in you approved uh a lot of training we have ongoing training and coaching for our B teachers it was a big adjustment for the this year uh it was something totally new it's a big adjustment for parents but now that we've gotten into the program for 29 days people are starting to see the purpose behind it the kids are happier they're more confident and are starting to do better academic already that will continue and that will without a doubt increase our ability for of our students to do up these assessments I just want to close with one observation I'm the second M said which is I think when we received this presentation last year we were hopeful that there will be progress to show for year to year and I think we've seen that but personally as the board member I'm really excited for seeing the levels of integration coordination with some of the new ideas that we have uh in year two of our new Administration now between the new assessments not just relying on the Statewide assessments but we have the IR um and the EXL and how quickly that's translated into feedback to students feedback to teachers feedback to parents and are continuing education of D and how it's all ring through so I don't you know cautiously optimistic but I think this is just the start of what we're expecting to see in years to come and for me it's really exciting so thank you guys well than you for the presentation thank [Applause] you we are up to item number three student board m um I just want to start off by talking about our certain sports teams our football teams currently one win and six losses with their last game against Manville on Friday the boy soccer team have their last game on Saturday with a current record of five wins 10 losses at one time the girls tennis team finished their season last Friday with a record of three wins 14 losses and one tie the girl soccer team currently have a record of wins six losses at one tie with three more games to go that being blown on Friday cross country team are ending their season next week with their next competition being tomorrow at Pleasant Valley Park the girls volleyball team have a record of six wins and 10 losses in two more games to go the next will be home tomorrow 22 and for our winter teams both basketball and wrestling teams have been hosting events to prepare for their upcoming Seasons which include triy outs and events that help out the younger team at the middle school in other other news uh there's going to be a college fair at the school on October 23rd and a career fair on November 15th um and on October 26th uh our students will be taking the P or the a or the act of all these students and off for tutoring for these tests for this month well every month until I believe January I'll be interviewing one of the principles from each of the schools in the district uh for this month I had the honor of talking with missas got the principal of lafette despite how early into the year the interview was she was excited and positive about the upcoming school year she was an assistant principal in the New York Brad for 13 years where she managed 600 students and 100 staff members by the main principal of that school who her who taught her all that she knows and how to be fair and just she came to bber because she thought that bber challenged her that the Bron didn't in her short time here she has seen her staff exceed their responsibilities and expectations while also being inclusive and keeping a positive attitude even when the situation wasn't the best her current plans for the upcoming school year include building a trust and relationship with staff and parents primarily through social media using her expertise to develop and push her staff and curriculum further lastly she's keen on having students Express their learning goals that is key to their future success excellent thank you for all the upates uh at this point we can start on the review of our committee meetings like to start uh sure we had a great Education meeting a couple weeks ago uh we focused on uh two new diagnostic programs and assessments the district using one is called I ready one is called I excel so I ready primarily en rolled out K to six please correct me if I'm incorrect I excel um really at all levels and what's neat about these programs is they many of them are adaptive meaning that as students answer questions correctly they become more difficult um and as students are struggling they receive questions that are at their level so what's exciting is the data that the teachers and the students get afterwards um so if you imagine yourself as a classroom teacher with 20 to 25 children before you your task is to design lesson to meet all those kids where they are and what these programs do is it gives very targeted data about how to group students into small groups and provide them with really tailored instruction we spent a lot of our time in our committee meeting talking about goal setting and the value of students being able to know and articulate um the specific goals they're working on to become better mathematicians better readers better writers and how the teachers can use those goals to provide the kids with really targeted feedback based upon how they're doing work on the assessments um there's also great parent components where parents can be made aware of these reports um I Exel is a great program that allows for skills to be practiced um the general culture of the district seems to have responded well to these programs um the reports that we get indicate that teachers are finding them useful um sometimes it's great to take assessments but it can be overwhelming to get all the data and know what to do with it but the initial feedback is that the data is user friendly and useful and able to help the teacher figure out a way to meet the needs of all of their students in class so there's a lot of excitement about the potential of small group instruction having kids own their goals and being able to give teachers uh resources that allow them to better Target the needs of individual um students and we're also excited that these programs have components in English and Spanish so they are useful for assessing our large multilingual population as well what we're finding out is it really a reading issue or a math issue as opposed to is this test a reflection of the child's language skills so we had a productive meeting and we're excited about things to come excellent thank you Mr Dawson any questions from the members regarding education I will just make one comment and I share this with Mrs G she's leaving the meeting um it's actually point of great pride for me that there is basically standing room only in our education committee meetings because of all the excellent work that you guys are doing and the content that you're sharing and how just energizing and important all of it is so thank you very much for the hard work and for the board members who aren't on that committee not taking anything away from anybody else but if you have the time and the interest I would encourage you to attend if you're not a m let's just make sure that we don't break any fors because they're just outstanding outstanding um with that govern Mr okay so we had a lot of policy updates as you can see in tonight's agenda um most of them are State mandated so you can read through those a lot of it's just language changes there were a few things that we had questions about um one of which I had to reach out to Gwen about is that they are um recommending that we change change our requirement to 90 days after being elected to receive your initial training as a board member um we had some concerns that there was going to be enough training available to board members to make that happen but Gwen assured me through email that um there is a self-paced online course that is available at all times so if you don't make it to one of the training sessions you can always do it online this year they're also having um new member orientations in January and February so they'll have two live sessions available Within those 90 days for those who are elected traditionally at the or I should say or um become board members in January so if you're elected in November you're you're covered with two live plus some online options um the other stuff was really really language related where where we decided um for instance one where we decided to give Dr Freeman a little bit of Fe say um we talked about the sick Le last meeting and the new rules about that and they recommend where they ask there are options I should say where a district can choose if we want to ask employees for seven days notice when they are able to give that notice if they're going to be using using that those additional types of what we'll call sick leave but but leave because it's not really traditional sick Le and we decided it was best to use the phrase may require they you can say will not require may require or will require so we stuck with may require to get Dr his the discretion so that he can apply it fairly in all situations that's just one example but it was a lot of language like that but the most important thing that happened uh at our meeting was we talked about our strategic plan and how to move forward we saw presentations from uh they were sent to us they weren't live with us we were sent presentations from njsba and um thought exchange right thought exchange um both were good but we thought that njsba was just way more thorough especially in the planning phase not to mention it's quite a bit of savings financially so with those two things uh we thought it was best to recommend that we stick with njsba um with the board's you know approval tonight we also noticed that their timeline starts in September which means we are already behind so we will have to accelerate the timeline just a bit at the beginning to catch up on that but that's something we're willing to do uh to to Implement a good strategic plan and the last thing we very briefly discussed in the last five minutes of the meeting um Mr zuo will be very happy about this we are definitely looking to bring back Ed Council one more time we're going to try it again um we talked just a little bit about what that might look like Dr Freeman is really going to look into what he thinks it should look like but I know that that was also discussed in negotiations one thing that we do want to start with is is to make sure that are holding advisory Council meetings at the building level first and make sure that's going on in the district um I think maybe yeah Mr Ji has a little bit more information on this sure and just add I think in general we want to support our building Lal administrators and Empower them to address issues that are happening on the ground in real time if at all possible but we also wanted to enable this mechanism for uh you know our teachers to say if there are districtwide issues that are causing grief or observations that you have that would allow us to make it a better place to work right um then we want the opportunity to entertain those as a board you know as quickly as we possible certainly don't want to wait you know the next 35 years before we go back to negotia on the contract so um I'm very excited I think the climate is right for us to reintroduce it and um I think we'll be able to make a lot ofs and that was my whole report great any questions from Mr B okay hearing UN Human Resources way back in September and so admin is continuing to monitor our open positions and ship way then District re attended Kean University Care Affair earlier in September with the whole said it would bring in more potential Subs while their students wer completing their education exit surveys for staff that have um resigned or left during the 2223 school year been compiled there were common thingses like job satisfaction stress um work rated support commun hire and higher wages um some of the things that were brought um came out in the exit surveys for things that had been noticed such as staff not feeling supported and had been addressed and then we are um they're reviewing job descriptions for supervisor special ad curriculum and inclusion to better align the job descriptions with districts with districts ince finally on this past Monday negotiation committee met and I flaked out on it sorry missed it um but happy to say that we have a tenative handshake agreement um and hopefully present meting thank you very much for the update U one quick comment that I would make in terms of the job descriptions just for everybody's this those are on on our agenda tonight to vote on so just as you consider kind of the thought process that we led to this point had been created they've reviewed and endorsed by the HR committee and now they off um any comments or questions on the H Mr Russ I think you got all the questions you got question you go operations Mr Z this was really a pleasure weu to very impressed the Expansion Project committee expressed very encouraging we looked at all the Aesthetics and the condition we asked about cost ining CH as well as comple everything answered very thoroughly Adra so I I I just think that that's fantastic to help our student population we also have some busing news that I'm going to hand over Mr that can thank you Mr Z um as many of you know B Brook is a walking district for transportation the two areas that we focus on servicing our special education rounds and co-curricular and athletic rounds and we have reached pretty much full capacity on all of those runs so Mr Januzzi and the Board of Education formed an committee which is an ad hoc committee I'll steal a little bit of Miss Gaz Thunder and in that um last two meetings um Mr steel was present and he talked about some of the challenges that we're facing with athletic runs and co-curricular runs with regard to Transportation limitations and the inability to have vehicles and drivers stamp um those extra runs so This Is Not Unusual a lot of school districts are struggling with this we also spoke separately from the committee with Mr DeMarco our special education um director and he pointed out that some of ours are are overcrowded under servant and students and and we have the need for expansion so with those um we discussed with Dr Freeman um the need for some budget resources to be transferred immediately for two large unbudgeted purchases because there is a shortage on right now on buses there's a one to twoyear wait where you get a purchase order in to have your bus manufactured and delivered so we thought we would get ahead of that and we've been reaching out to several bus manufacturing companies and we were fortunate that we were um able to secure a brand new 24 passenger bus and also a brand new 54 passenger bus both of these are 2024 models the price on the 54 passenger bus is a little over 138,000 and the 24 passenger bus is 116,000 um so we have a resolution on the agenda tonight for the board to authorize the purchase for those two buses which were unbudgeted with the use of surplus that Dr Freeman and I have identified other budget accounts and this will better serve the athletic Co curricular needs of our district as well as the special education Transportation needs and will also enable us to even solicit some joint chur and that's where um we would reach out to the transportation directors of other school districts and see if we can share rout in any way where we could share the cost so I couldn't have said it better myself thank you sir that's all for operations any [Music] questions simp question do we know the the basement has been waterpro at question was was the Bas waterproof at and they said we field trip the walls were correct again I'm G to have to send it over to my buddy Mr G Mr gski can you Enlighten us on that uh I wish I could Mr zco but I'm gonna have to phone a friend also and ask our architect because this project was designed the previous administration but I'll get you an answer we are also changing architecture Architects are being changed Reserve com congratulate the any other comments or questions for Roger on operations yes ma'am one is a 24 passenger bus that's the $116,000 price T passenger bus is 138 so one question um to continue deal with the buses um so understand purchase was done that the buses will arrive the next one to two years no we're fortunate uh these vehicles are now in the factory getting their air conditioning systems installed and they should be ready for delivery about a month's time 2024 yes 2024 model is brand new solar power solar power no are a traditional diesel have air conditions they do have one one Improvement of that is our our depreciation schedule for our transportation Vehicles is aging so this will Infuse some U needed lifeblood into the earlier end of that so that we don't have all of the buses maturing at the same time even though the state has extended the life cycle for buses to up to 20 years now um many times after uh 10 to 15 years they curi what are the AG of 2015 and another one is a 2008 Vans are up there too so the plan L board we have currently four vehicles 254 passenger vans 224 um buses and what we're going to do is we one of the current 24 passenger vans has a a defective engine and transmission it's working but it's not reliable and it's left us uh reasonable so what we're going to do is we're going to trade in that vehicle and then we're going to use the new 54 passenger van right into the two and from school schedule so that's going to get a little and we're going to take the oldest up the 54 passenger vehicles and we're going to use that as a spare and a dedicated vehicle for athletics and Co regular runs field trips and things like that which I'm sure the principles here great deal for the has there been any thought of the older aging Vans um I remember a while back um I forgot how back but um some of the parents were were questioning whether or not we could use some of the Transportation yeah we took care of that we took care that shortly after um we provide transportation the question was transportation from uh too no problem let me just add that uh it was almost an impossible task to find uh a bus that we could buy we went out to the uh Comm who was saw the US the Press were too high we were only able to do it because of Mike's connection with the uh with the distributor so his network is what allowed us to do that being by not saying it but I thought Mike and I'll just make one comment and it kind of ties into the update on curricular I think if I've learned anything from Dr Freeman and his approach to you know um the changes he's making with the administrator that we shouldn't be afraid to be nle and react quickly the situation works so I think the idea that we were able to get feedback uh through our Athletics and co-curricular ad hoc committee that said Transportation was the number one pain for uh the majority of our coaches and that we could translate that into freeing up additional resources and then having our bus to take action to make that a reality in in the span of weeks you know maybe you know months uh I think it's something we all need to start to realize is an opportunity is an option what we should be aspiring so there are some things that will take a long time right and there are some that we should be able to keep show the time we shouldn't be afraid of trying to do it and so rolling into Athletics and co-curricular I think our meeting our last meeting is probably wup meeting but we really just reaffirmed our three highest priorities Transportation being among them facilities and making some additional facilities hopefully available uh in the future as we look at our long range plan for both facilities and a strategic plan for the district uh and then investing in uh General uh physical education strengthening condition and opening up a new s position uh so those are really the three outcomes that I expect from from that committee uh as more or less a final report and we will transition starting to operationalize some of those things um we talked a little bit about some research that Mr St would do in terms of other life positions in other districts that we could potentially model starting to understand what those S of grades might look like and really on that obviously you CED about Transportation um and the then identification of um and investment in facilities is a much bigger conversation we can we'll get into that in future budget planning and future strategy any quick comments on Athletics in unfortunately su's not with us tonight so we are going to skip the SCC report uh and before I close any other comments or questions regarding the committee's deep breath fantastic reports for all the committee chairs the work that you guys are doing is fantastic um just the the volume of activity you guys are through the content again to so thank you thank you for all of your extra effort at this point we are open to the public for agenda items only so Tom while you check online I will just read the notes that we have here so in Accords with District policy 0167 governing public par ipation board meetings members of the public will sign in at the podium or online provide their name address and uh public participation is limited to three to five minutes in duration and no participant may speak more than once on the same topic until all others who wish to speak on that topic have been heard with that being said anybody from the room do you want to talk about something on the agenda or just it was something that was said during come down test by the way that's the on file good evening um kyman I am the vice president of bbea I just want to say thank you um for working collaborative collaboratively and cooperatively with us to settle our contract and we look forward to presenting it to our members thanks for coming K thank you for all your hard work have a good night thanks for staying you have no agenda items questions online thank you very much here item number 6.1 approval from approval of minutes from 8223 be resolve that b Board of Education superintendent approves the meetings approves the minutes of the following meetings regular executive session from August 21st 2020 have a motion motion thank you Mr B second second thank you Mr any discussion1 feel there Mr Ji that that change will be reflected thank you any other comments questions suggested EVS is we're not voting on 6.2 there no correct since there were no attachment attachment in the agenda we will not be voting on 6.2 we just push that next all right hearing n can we do aoll call please Mr B yes Mr dawon yes M Gazo yes Mr Z yes M yes Mr Min yes motion pass to item 7.1 resolve that the superintendent recommends for approval resolutions as outline District personel resolutions this 7.2 through 7.53 May I have a motion motion thank you Mr second second thank you m any discussion I just have one quick question and I say it's probably think everybody to find it um um 7.32 this is Middle School extracurricular positions there are two positions noted as advisors um can we just confirm that those are seven and gr advis split advisory the first two the fs are split is that is you're talking about can I say the names is that okay yeah yes it's for pish and Bennett yes they split it that's why the the 0.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Monmouth County, NJ YouTube / Brielle Elementary School transcript source: youtube BOE Meeting - October 18 2023 · passage 1
there has been adequate notice of this meeting provided by the Board of Education in the January 9th 2023 and January 12th 2023 notice in the as press and the co-star setting forth date time and location of this meeting similar notice has been posted in the bur Hall the Bri website and the Burl clerk has been Mr Becker Dr Mrs Jones yes Mrs mcdevit Mr Milano Mrs weed here Mr vital here Mrs Walsh here Mr Walman [Music] hereit States [Music] and if someone make a motion for the approval of the minutes I'll the motion I'll second Mr Becker yes Dr de brosio Mrs Jones yes Mrs we yes Mr V yes Mrs Walsh yes Mr W yes and presentations this evening uh the New Jersey SLA presentation evening everyone know my name isor instruction I started here officially very so today um and I here to present to you our um scor n njs l um that our students took in the spring of 20123 there's quite a few slides to go through so questions end certainly happy to answer them for you so the ersy department of has all public schools in New Jersey 3 through 11 participate in the stage assessment and questions that are given area ly Ma and one Al and geometry and our students partipate in all asps of those t for so those are talking about we also had students in science and gr 5 they also took to them reported five levels for BL and math four levels for science so you'll hear a lot about exceeding meeting approaching meeting and not yete so we as District are aing for and with our students so that is where we are for our students to so these are some of the things talking about tonight right into it so there's a couple I know there's a lot of numbers up here and but this first slide show our and we compar to the state is at the very very top and the state is so you can see um you can see here is these right here are for all of our grade levels all together this is seven and thir grade so we definitely do want to talk about and celebrate our um strengths with our students we also want to look at areas that we need to hone in on and work with our teachers and our students and we'll get into that as the presentation goes on on this next slide you can see um a little bit more how we compare to the state by level so overall we had the state was 51% of the students were meeing or exceeding and in in we were at 77% so that is good news we were above where the state is we always want to do that but if we look here so if we look and most of our grade models there's a pretty good discrepancy um we're higher than the state but if you notice here in grade three that's a little bit too close for us we certainly want to look at that fourth grade Cort now previous previous year and maybe work closely on what is going on in that area that students looking closely curriculum and talk more about this slid on just to give you an idea of where we are so here we look at mathematics and in area mathematics again higher than the state we were 77 with meeting suceeding of students overall and in the state was 51 so one of the um so if you see here again um one of the areas that is not um for public knowledge is because we in Geometry we had less 10 students and if there's an area or group whether it's our race or class size less than 10 students beity reason but I can't report that all of our geometry students seeded so that's you just won see that Public Presentation but we look again and we can see some discrepancies but we can see again we did much better than um did over here this over here is algebra um so you can as students did extremely wellar and then grade Sade and then again we do see that our current fourth grade um is an area of place that we want to look to strengthen what is going on with our students there and Target them more appropriately here grade eight for algebra we had 93% we exceeding for meaning um 35 the state and 8th grade was 40 to 18 grade was 37 to 34 it's another grade level that we are looking to um work a little closely with that's our current eth grade and six grade was 35 State 58 forade 40 for the state 61 44 and3 46 so again a little bit closer than we would like to see so we'll talk what we're moving forward these are the science scores grad five and eight and ourth grade um fth grade um 62 of our students get met exceeded um and 8th grade 46 of our students that areed overall 54 of our students um of our students that areed and only 23 so one of the things that we look at that does seem a little bit low 46% than half but if look at only 18% pass so when we look at that educator like is it the kids or is it the T I do we do know that is reworking the science um test very closely because of the scores that have come out the past couple of years around science so we are Happ our students did very well espe so that is good news for us that and here is overall if you look across the board um for our class our classes with all of our 77% 51% [Music] 61% compared to 23% so that justes a general overview of what how our students perform the next part of the presentation I'm sorry so bad so so this is the district demographic are required by the state to report on certain groups um of students within our school district so because some of our um groups of students are less than 10 you see we are not able to again like for the geometry reasons St so some of the areas that we will report and in um so this is for sub is divided and and so you can see where we the numbers are and then have and then it's a little bit cly what we want to to here approaching and so many of them were homeless passing so when we look at that as Educators and school leaders and teachers we can really delve into the data and look at the standards and really look exactly where they work proficient and work very closely with those students so the teachers have access to this data as well we're working really closely with them to help the teachers work with our students and small groups to maybe get those scores up a little bit higher so here is the for mathematics you can see again the this is our [Music] science and this only one because of the amount of students that took then this is some interesting this is and one of theie really celebrate is there's of equity and one scores here if we look at the female students over here and the males are over here so this is 49% and 49% for many expectation and then start suceeding with 30 and 26 so that's very close and that's really good news School leader because sometimes you do see a great discrepancy between boys and girls um in education in different subject areas and that we don't see it here is very it's really good it means that our teachers are teaching as as possible across the curriculum especially in when we look at math we see similar scores um again pretty close we have the the girl at 47% the males at 54% is a little bit lower at s and a little bit higher at 12 we kind of laugh not necessarily here so that's another good point one of the things that we want to look here we do have 35% of the females in our school we're just not quite meeting expectations so again that's important data for us to consider as we move forward we have science and see similar as as the final category demogra by program program special ed so we have our students um in special ed have I and we have our students that have 504s and also students that have plun and students but those two are supressed we don't have students in that category we look at our next [Music] slide this section right here this is our students so you can see that 37% of them our me expectations 26% are exceeding this grp here is our specialed are students that currently have I and right here we have 35% so this is an interesting bubble that we want to look at because we have so many students post I were really looking at each individual data like there were a couple students like point or two away from Reading expectation so we're going to talk about a little bit at the end of like what we can do to really work with those kids right there they just needed that little bit extra push of instruction and these students over here this is our general population and how they so% meeing subps students and when we look this I look at this you celebrated course C we want to celebrate that we had 57% of our fin four students meeing but we do have a level right here 3.5% of them not so what could we do to increase scores there and then again here is our special population 27% here and then over that not approaching and then we had 42% that and then sorry right here is our approaching 20% is meeting and then we have 4% exceeding that's really to be celebrated too because sometimes we think our social students you know might not but they really are and we want and then here our general Ed and our general Ed numb were 11% exceeding matics and 6% and last science all either approaching at 40% and then 30% and 30% for meeting anding our special ed students um right here 29% we're not meting 50% were approaching meeing and 4% exceeding and then for our general population 33% sorry categories and 4 efficient and 14 were adved so what does all of this mean so we like of course look at last year but we really want to make sure that we're taking consideration start so we're going to take very quick look at the past few years of dat that we have and you'll notice the the break and time because the last time before our students took the test was 2018 2019 then we had the break 2020 and then we back to it 21 22 22 23 so before I present this I just want is to make sure we certainly know that we are celebrating all the fluid that's going on for me but I do think that it makes a lot of sense that we look back where we were and where we want to be so when we look at these umph this so this is this is four five six seven and then these are all of our gr so if we look at very general terms and we look at this last column you can see in 2018 this is for seing we had 85% then in 21 we were at 82% and we at 76% so still very very good but certainly there is dip and we want to as a staff really think about that what what could caus that absolutely reason um you know we think back we had several months were no students were school then the following school year in 2021 some students were hybrid some students were home made was very disconnected the education piece for many families so we absolutely look at that but we also do want to look at some of our other areas of concern we're reducing some of our levels that Here and Now current grade so at 95% at 71 big drop that we and then again current they had very big at 73% down to 47 last year so we are working on it we are working together with the teachers to make sure that we're figuring out what's going on there is it curricular instructional grings like what we look at to so that'sa and then here's M and again you can see the levels and we do see again you know some of a drop at 71% overall 64 and then 59 and then we have another that we have only on which is our current rate eight you can see that some of those scores are cly lower we like to see our albra one student usually would perform pretty well that EX in area so again just some dat for us to kind of ponder think about where we've been and where we like to be and the last slide here is our science and again just gr levels we did very well science overall so [Music] that2 that's [Music] good5 [Music] science this is most important part presentation so we have all this data and we are certainly a very bment District as we should be but I think one of the things that is so important for us all to take away just a piece of the time this is one piece of data that we have about our students and our school of instruction curriculum we are very fortunate here that we do have other platforms that we use for data to collect data about our students and what's going on in the classroom and we take all that consideration and we use we use summative data in the classroom informative data teachers ongoing throughout the day weeks units U teachers OBS teacher observations we um pieces to this so I really think that we want to make sure that we are cogent of that this is just one area we want to celebrate the good we want to some of the questions that we use as administra team to guide next how we use tool to address areas in need of improvement or enhancement how can we best use the tools and platforms that we already have most effectively and have to provide additional resources and support to meet the learning needs of all our students so those our foring questions pretty much with everything we do revolving around instal leadership when we to help our teachers so some of the ways that we are using this um this data is first and foremost we have our address Group compath which I know all of you know that we use for our curriculum curricular units we use for planning purposes we have already used quite a bit of our professional development time the direction of posture myself to delve into what these units look like how we can improve them are we linking them to assessment are assessments rigorous enough standards covered the wonderful thing about this platform talking about is it's just so data Rich you could just really use this PO like we got a rical with it because there's so much there um so we are working closely with our teachers PD during PLC times during individual meetings to make sure that they really know that they have this valuable tool what can we do to put our instruction PL the other platform that I this not use linkoln and to go through all the data points that we would have was so time consuming and it was important work and we had to do it was very T and very tin link is just an amazing platform I just every day I find something do with it it delts into groups grade levels individual students individual assessments goes right down to the standard of what a teacher really pull down in to make sure that the students are getting exactly what they need so this is just is a kind of just a little clip for you of what teachers would see and this I thought was really interesting to show this a link it has three benchmarks Benchmark a b and c and a is given in the fall B is in January and C is at the end of the year so the D that you're looking at right here this is Benchmark and these are individual students so a right here this is what was given in the in September and they use the same type of language just La meeting exing approaching so the yellow is um approaching and the orange they use bubble and nla doesn't say bubble but we like to really look CL our bubble those are really really close to passing and la and end so we really love this dat because you can see how it progresses across very good into the these are so it's a really interesting indicator to show where students are a couple times throughout the year so this is a platform that our teachers have worked a lot with and we continue like I said there's so many pieces to it so we're just continuing education with that so that we're using it to the best of our ability their ability this just gives you another example of what blinket gives to us um reports this right here this is AIC standard standard and then it goes to the question the number of question what the question was and what the students how they scored and so a teacher can pick when they give an assessment they can go through and see exactly which questions the students didn't get right and then the computer will group it for them so when we will talk about T Construction I'll talk a little bit a couple minutes they know exactly grp right there so they're not kind of going through the right there it's a really amazing tool instruction the other platform that is new to our district this year another really amazing now our students in karten through fifth grade of the areas of I'm sorry fourth grade for bla and Ma and then 5 to8 we also have the science and social studies component the wonderful thing about L is similar to link diagn test they take the beginning of the year but they continually work on so we call itag when we talk like it's SM enough to know where you are actually adjust to the students level as they work so unlike Lincoln which they take three times a year I Exel they take continually they can take practice teachers can um assign stent skills and standards so if there's a specific skill CH help with they can that to them when they do small group work individual time with them they for homework they on I know you can't see this is an example of a class you can see how students fall over the place you know just to give you all an idea of what our teachers are dealing with this is one class you can see like they're all different so our teachers certainly have a challenge of reaching each student but with all these tools it does make that just a little bit easier and this is an example of how um one student where they would tell them what they need studer and they click on that and that would give them practice in that like very specific skill so operations foll to that so what are we doing with all of this so in a very short time and like I said I feel like been here for a long time writing it's good work um we've really thought about all this data that we have and what we can do to make our school better make our educational program more proficient and more efficient and more Equitable for all of our students so some of the things we've already started our teachers have um been in professional development in the multier system of supports which be another acronyms is nothing new to the state of New Jersey it is a little bit new to here really what it does is just make sure that we are working through the tiers of instruction so in a very simple terms there's three tiers tier one is our general education population which is all of our students regardless of what uh label they might have the disability they might have all our students are first general ed students and they all receive tier one high quality targeted instruction in the classroom some of our students might need a little bit more we call that tier two and those are our students we start to identify with this data okay so they didn't pass nsla and now we really need to work Clos with them but in one area not just m different where so those are our tier two students tier two instruction should and does happen in the classroom with small groups but it also can look like an intervention is pushing in intervention is calling out and then we have three which is that that most intensive level those are students that really need the most support that they just continually come up from all these data points that they just are in need of more support in the area of reading Ela writing and those students would definitely be flaged for intervention either again an intervention is out but the classroom teacher is still responsible for giving that high quality instruction across the board and work small grp they just need that little extra the other piece is we're helping our staff to really look at our students from a much wider lens which is academic um I think a lot of you know my background is in counseling and I really do feel that we can have students learn effectively if they don't feel safe if they don't feel comfortable if they don't like being in school so that is first and foremost that we want to feel good about to be the best on our and when we look at a student that might be startling academically it might not be an academic issue and we need to figure that out so that's where we have our counselors our CST working closely with our staff to make sure they understand that part of their their children class um this is poster apply for the high impact tutoring Grant withj um which is a competitive Brant we have not yet found out if we haveed it yet we should have known by now but as more other very they didn't all the applications so the unfortunate part of that is it was supposed to start at the end of October um we don't know if we received it yet we hope that we do because one of the pieces to it I'm sure but one of the pieces was either um they first recommended to use outside tutor tutoring companies we didn't really feel like that was the way that we wanted to go we didn't know who it would be so we were able to some of our staff actually apply to want to do this which is wonderful so supp a couple days her office and really went through all this data and what kids can benefit the most from this extra tutoring within the school day or after school or before school and we target four or five primarily in the areas of M right now so fingers crossed that we get this grant because I really think that that would be another level of support for our students in addition to everything else that we do here professional platform toget students supping what we talk St platform another piece that was pretty major was information ofcs which are professional learning communities subject are discussion ande that meaning instruction so that is something that wasn't Happ consistently before and now is our teachers have embraced it they send an agenda every week sometimes give them a Tas Ure myself might St in team members might go in to talk to them it's just professional learning time they collaborate with each other and talk about these things that need to be discussed look at assessments look at data what's exp so that has been a really important shift for our teachers Prof [Music] development earlier while uring our s the rig and outcomes we have created scheduling committee to look at instruction are and we have a goal of increasing our communication and collaboration and making sure we're as transparent as possible our parents about about the data about how students are placed um all of that so that's a really important piece that parents feel that they are part of what goes on here at school and understand the why know as a parent that's really important they understand why things are done the way they are and this is just an example this is a um this is your parents know that this is the state report that parents several weeks ago through the mail that explain stor to them and at any time the parents can also talk to teachers myself they have any questions and what they they ENT thank you for bearing with me I know it's a lot of slides I think it's really important inform me for everyone to know and before we close any questions yeah first of all thank you especially appreciate the fact that went you know historically back before you asked about a long time um first time actually and looking at what you sawal you know study of those youy um only question is have you coordinated with we you coordinated with similar sending districts for compar that's a really good question not yet it was just made public and the districts this probably this month is usually because I know have mentioned in mad I think we did it last night but that will be a pretty big part of what happens next it's almost like everybody kind of waits to see you know what what's going to but but we don't have that data yet because it has been published until official at the board meeting like tonight they they can men sure absolutely yes are requ post it should happen after their board meeting go up tomorrow and then other districts that are presenting during the month be but we will have those collaborative conversations well districts work pretty closely together so yeah it is and it's an interesting comparison you know to see um and you know definitely collaborate with administrators even on um uh October 9th you know there is some when that was one of our days there is some collaboration among sen districts in that matter the curriculum you know through the county there a lot of collaboration in November um 15 is they just approved teport today but State finally approved the new bla ands today officially will they did like last week but now they're public so that is going to be like a a community um conversation countywide of what we're going to do with the standards and how we're going to adjust our curriculum so I know like I'm looking at Kristen she and I will be at that meeting together sending district will probably work really closely together to kind find we're doing since we're all had more collaboration I think of the last few months than I've ever in all my years in it's exciting I think that was science science science yes science did I did skip a year right in 20 one year might have been newer standards first year new science test so the kids took it right and that does happen too during the um some school districts are just randomly picked to take field tests and sometimes like you'll see that your child might have an extra day of testing and it's just a field test we don't really know which one is but that do happen prob at the you're showing us what action with this indry um and the um mtss um I really like that taking a close look at sometimes it is an AC kids you know sometimes it is um an emotional situation problem so I'm glad that you're talking that [Music] thank you everybody how forunate we are that Chris and working so closely together so oober to together and share so we don't have any other questions um we're g to move on to visitors business uh visitors committed to comment on agenda items only at this time uh please name and address so we're GNA we move on to correspondence none no one sending [Laughter] [Music] us all right so um we'll move on to committee reports then District Operations okay and uh representative to manisan Joe is not here so we'll move on to curriculum and programs there is no report and Human Resources Joe's not here and so we'll move to policy thank you um policy committee met yesterday October 17th attended by missra Miss Adam trus um as well as myself Dr Rio and and joined us as well have conflict um we have three items on the agenda the first is that signifant progress on the board dos policies there is a delay TR another few weeks toiz them but they are making progress have section Z through 200 and they all draft policies are searchable right now that that platform uh operational um we also discussed policy 2460 which is special ucation and specifically um we are researching modifying current restriction that prohibits use of electronic mail to request uh formally request an intervention some quickly and say be look at how other districts have adopted this policy um and this this little background if a parent is making a referral or request for um investigation for special education services for the student um that typically is required to there has to be timeline that starts once that requests made and there there's a concern that it comes in by email when does the clock start so we discussed you know there be a process to print that letter out um because currently we only accepted either in person via mail or fact and so electronic mail U final piece which took the majority of the meeting we were joined by Phil Mastro owner of stra Esme stra Esme is a service that we use for um policies they review state federal uh statutes and regulations and advise School boards on policies that they need to need to have this concerned um not not only policy 5756 transgender studs but also just in general as we discussed last meeting we had questions as that service provides us with um sometimes quarterly sometimes more frequently updates St these policies they have an internal classification of whatever the policy is U mandatory recommended or abolished that's an internal classification and so we ask for more clarity in know summarizations so that we're very very clear on which parts of the polic were actually mandated by the statute and which parts are coming from guidance which may not be we did touch on policy 5756 in particular and Mr mccastro gave us a historical riew of that policy and explain um how the policy evolved from the legislature enacting the statute having it signed by Governor Christie and then how the doe commissioner um govern Murphy put forth um guidance which informed this policy uh we are putting policy 5756 modification to it forward for the second reading tonight uh which keeps a majority of the policy in place but does include a change to address a concern that was raised by community members that as a matter of practicality as a uh student as we have develop the confidentiality plan with the student that we are to involve the student's family in that process so that policy would be up SE T questions community relations Sal ad so it's been a very busy month here uh we've had some great um experiences with our students um had a great walk to school day it's really nice to see the drop off L really short that day but I did have gone smoother too um so that that was a really nice event for everybody um we had Fire Prevention Week recognition of that with their youngest students fire department came over with fire truck did a great assembly for our students over in the part um on the other side of the school uh our fall enrichment program is underway thanks to PTO we have really great offerings for our students and you know many of them are fully subscribed so we're very thankful for PTO for helping us uh run that program um I did send our Halloween letter out to give parents an idea of what the expectations are for Halloween so people should be looking for that uh we have parent teacher conferences coming up the letter will be going out shortly for parents be able to sign up for parent teacher conferences you know I encourage parents to take advantage of the time to have that dialogue um and to you know gain an understanding of how their children are doing and how we can work together with parents and I hope to see many parents here for parent teacher conferences uh we had a really great PD day on October 9th revolving around a lot of what you saw here today um it was a very full day um not only looking at Ela and map and and I say this quite frequently you know that all of us support those skills in our students it's not just our Ela and our Math teachers so we also engaged in you know deide looking at and providing time for teachers to really learn that platform better we spent a lot of time in the other content areas really of digging into our assessments uh how well are they aligned with standards we compl some assessment matricies and we'll continue that work as as the year goes on um to ensure that in all of our subject areas that's support our student skills that we are you know raising bar and providing an appropriate level of challenge um as Miss Pierce said we are waiting on word from the high impact sharing Grant the date is well behind their timeline in terms of what they planned and you know it's surprising to me that they're putting money out there they don't expect people to ask for it so you know my only concern with that is that you know will uh will they be in a position similar to what they do with the RS right where they put money out there and then they don't anticipate how many people are going to apply and all of a sudden what you thought may be available if the pot is a lot smaller than what you thought so that's my only hesitation but we hope to hear good reads on that within the next month or so um and and lastly as as Miss Pearson also mentioned the state did finally adopt the newa math standards um doesn't seem like there are significant changes in those but certain areas where you know if you've been following some of these issues publicly are not a surprise you know in Anya a little bit more explicit on terms of things like bonics um you know and things that are tied to science reading and then in math interestingly enough um an introduction of data analysis younger age which I think also reflects where we are as a society it's very well present so we will be certainly getting up to speed on those as well taking theary steps to adjust back well look you know I think you know as we were pointing out tonight link it is relative new tool here Rubicon is relatively new tool here is a new tool here right so just really digging in these platforms and starting to use them as constructively as we can we'll also go long way towards helping us move our students forward um keep in mind also boards supported to more interventionists this year so that is also very helpful and we will you know certainly maximize their time this um so F have any other questions promise we'll move on to reports and so we move on to action items itation inant curricul thank you [Music] I'd Mr Becker yes Dr cambia yes Mrs Jones yes Mrs G yes Mr vital yes Mrs wol yes Mr wal yes and next we have District Operations Mr Becker yes Dr Gia yes Mrs yes Mrs we yes Mr Vali yes Mrs Walsh yes Mr W [Music] yesy like request the board um approve policy 5756 for second um at this time I'd like to actually policy yes discuss um we have to have a second discuss so my concern uh even after the meeting Y is just that the wording uh that we included still does not flow with the guidance um and I could open us up to be susceptible um because it it just kind of go against the guidance the guidance that we provided but our our board attorney is the one that came up with this word she's she protects us against against these sorts of things so I don't I don't I understand that but I mean even in the meeting yesterday when we spoke with uh yes yeah you said that that could possibly us up for my my recollection was that um there wasn't the inconsistency between part of the the guidance that second language that we had a Dy that we had a duty to inform that the guidance says the district does not have a duty to Legal obligation to inform and we are saying as a matter of practicality that our policy is for when when we're trying to in the student's best interest create confidentiality policy that we will include parent and Miss Adam explained if those are not E Systems I've been we will said that's probably part of the process also it also starts that provision by saying you will only report it as it will not be reported unless Allowed by law something like that that's what's being litigated so that's and the part that we have says and it doesn't say that would mean are included included in what and supporting the student and then right below it it says the school district shall keep confidential a current VI of perspective students transgender status so if it's saying it would keep it confidential after plan okay so the part that is is highlighted last I think what we talked about was that this is this is going to be an evolving thing and there's probably going to be changes moving forward especially once the litigation pans out and I guess the state takes a stand one way or the other or the I mean the guy from very clearly said the the language that we presented could open us up he said any change polic yes he said does he think it would happen maybe not but I mean that to me but his but his role his his role is not to give us advice legal advice to how we can stay protected that's matters well I to to me I think we this this is my opinion I'm one board member I would suggest we do this and then we modify it as necessary depending upon what happens in the court I I don't see a reason I don't see a reason to to postpone this I don't think it's going to one way or the other I I think we we talked about this for quite some time we want to have this in there what we decided together we wanted to do I don't think tabling is going to uh going to change that other than just not having the scenar which further delays you know the community concern that the parents are his you know he he's coming he's coming at it from a point of view that he doesn't want to sh he payes to provide a service for us he doesn't want us to come back and say that he's either not providing the service for us or he's gonna open up Str as make a litigation from us saying that he well you said that if we put this in there that we weren't going to get sued yeah so that's but that's not his but that's not his prerogative that's why we have our own gr not representing us she is and when we talked about what's mandated what's not that they always recommend that the board makes modifications solation with attorney I was working with they want I didn't a change but I'm working with theard somebody [Music] inter distri St notif that's from the I'm sorry what does it what does it mean it means there's no requir no legal requirement for the school based on what it's saying saying there's no legal requirement that the School District staff notify that's that is that's not it's to me it's the same thing affirmative duty is legal the only way you arise for Duty [Music] with could someone do that yeah I mean you can this is a this policy language is something that the board adopts but it's based this language specifically was based upon the I think these two expressions something okay I guess I'm not saying it the same way but that's because I am so I mean if I look at something as an affirm doing means there's something that mandate you do them so that's why I'm saying legal is it accurate to say that guidance say are not legally required to re form but our policy is consistent with that but our policy does give us the flexibility for practical a confidentiality to I think the uh I think that the policy the additional L that you're talking about recognize the practicality but it doesn't demand that apparent says that the idea the idea is to work with the student in their interest and conect their safy wellbe by trying to work with them and you know with the family eventually it doesn't to me it I understand I understand what some people's concerns about policy so yeah so when it's when it's interpreted in so many different ways here to me then we need to work on it to make it less on interpretation are you is your concern that legally we're not protecting myself or is your concern the actual policy itself um I think both well those are two very different things right so one one in one instance you have a problem with the advice that based on what we talked about that our attorney is giving us and the other you're against the Poli so those hold on there those are two different things one requires you to rewrite the policy the other requires you to go against it you disagree with now to postp right so that would be the first because I'm not saying that to me the way it is Rewritten near the way the language was changed does not go along with the rest of the DI I I hear that you're saying that but I guess I don't understand it because there's only one attorney here and she she she did not write that she agreed but in her but in her opinion it is congruent with the letter of the policy that it's not it does not disagree with the other parts of it that's her interpretation based on what we asked her to put into I know you didn't no no I'm saying I was trying to accommodate what you wanted to accommodate but with the practicalities of what you have the school applying to your own but in no way should this be interpreted as a provision that says a parent must be notified that's not what it says to me and that's not what I intended to first so I understand if you're saying you're confused by what but that wasn't the intention because that's currently not what the law said but you me the sentence it's the sentence where it says advise to work with the student and the student house M that would mean both not the student and then with the family or however it's decided upon by the counselor and the administration which is what we would all hope occurs to me and me and with together you know I mean and that kind of with the confidential guidance that Tes it it doesn't seem to be the same one is saying there's no legal responsibility and we have our policy that's not consistent can I the rules question so we're a board of committees the committee has recommended this policy for second read and it's the motion to so that when you finish discussion on that motion then you'll vote on the postponement and then depending on the outome of that'll either vote on the policy or that's how proed um I just want to I mean we've been talking about this policy for some time now and um and so I think that when we first started talking about this policy we thought about I I think about the student I you know I I think about a child walking in into a classroom guid's office um coming to an adult here and sharing something very personal something uh private um you know these are this is a very still in this age day and age is still a sensitive um topic when we're talking about anything related to transgender lgbtq any of that it's it's a very sensitive thing you have a child coming into talk to an adult shares this type of information either they want to change their name or they're thinking about this and so when we first talked about this we said that okay the the policy back then the way I understood it said if the the conversation took place it stay there because uh the teacher the adult was not allowed to go and share that information with the parents um or anyone else we felt that we needed to change that because we didn't want it to just stay there we didn't want that child to go home and then that's it and just for that adult to have to to have that it's difficult for that adult it to to be told this type of thing where do they go with it so then we talked about okay what happens next let's let's put some next steps in place because we're responsible for that child so let's put some steps in in place and we talked about okay so let's let's write it where let's change the language where then um that teacher or that adult has to go to the superintendent you know to let the superintendent know and then the superintendent will then meet with the with the um with the the the counselor who's a professional who's trained to work with things which children and these type of things like this so we put that in place we changed the language um and I think that we all felt more comfortable because we just weren't leaving the kid you know with with you know no direction and so um then guidance comes out and the guidance says and it's changed over the years and yesterday we saw when when Phil uh Castro gave us that um evolution of this policy um and said no you're really not supposed to tell the parent I understand that because sometimes children are so afraid to have this conversation with their parents so then that puts us in a position of oh my gosh do I tell the parent and this child is afraid and they're going to go home and and who knows what's going to happen when they get home that's another thing we got to think about um so then we went back to the drawing board Sean has done a lot of work with this we've had a lot of conversations about this so then we try to word it in a way that and we looked at the guidance but we try to word it in a way that we that's why we put the word advised the principal or designate is advised not that they must they're advised to work with the student and the students's family to create an appro rate confidentiality plan regarding the students's transgender or transitioning status we're just trying to create a safe place for this child it comes back to the child not politics or anything like that it comes back to this one child that has shared this information with an adult that they trust so instead of just leaving it there we we're trying to create a safe place here in where elementary school for this child and we're bringing we want to bring in the parents to to be a part of this conversation and it just doesn't end there we're still going to be a part of you know not being B but you know the count the the guidance counselor uh Mrs postra the even the nurse if if need be we're we're we're still going to be working with this child to to help them na through this um I think that for me I mean that's that was my understanding about this I keep going back to the Chart now this page where it says the second page that Ted was referring to this is verbatim from what the state Advanced which is and it says here parental consent is not required it's not saying you don't have to do it it's not required but you can still do it as like I'm I'm not an attorney but it's not saying no you're you can't do it at all absolutely not it's not allowed it's saying it's not required you know so I think that right there when I when I read that okay it's not required but on the other page we're saying we're advising don't I can't agree that that one says you have to accept what the student the parent doesn't have to agree in terms of what the student identify fact that the parent doesn't agree for that the student has the ability to so that has to do with the actual decision in terms of gender and that's where parent consent is not okay I think you're referring to the father of that thank you there's no affir Duty for any District toy student's P for the students transtion and and you know I think that um and the Educators and and the room will understand this when a student comes to you and confines you know and it could be anything um and at that moment you you you make a a decision you know especially if if the student is saying that they're afraid to go home or they were afraid when the student says that then there are things that we that are in place that we need to do um but so I mean there there's been a and that's why I make sure that our policy allows uh the adult uh could possibly be getting that information better to make the best decisions for that no very clearly our policy does not say that our policy does not that that that policy requires to go that's why we changed this months ago because we had a concern that no staff member in this school should be should be charged with holding that secret and witholding that information from a student's parent we have guidance counselor we have administrators to go through specific training to be able to prve them the proper support to be able to figure out what the next step I should never be a see the teacher other staff member and it's just gentle parental unawareness or as a concern I know we like to say is it something we're hearing about that parents are concerned about this policy not at all so we're changing it because we feel that grou wor people are concerned I haven't heard it other than I'm confused as to how it's elevated to a portion of our community and yet the administration isn't hearing it I'm not hearing it but some is is this a community concern a third of the community who showed up and so I have to imagine that he's not only one that that is Raising this has that ever come to the administration did they show up and not speak at there were quite a few people here right I'm not sure what the reasons for here I could give a ton of I'm just concerned that we have not bet it this properly based on the actual Community concern I I hear what you're saying we everything Mall just said is exactly where this language came from we we've spent a lot of time going over this and the the entire the entire concept around this was really to support and and to say that we haven't fed this enough I don't think is AC because we we've been nothing but from mon um the policy um and you know to your other point you know this is a very small school and we've got a lot of young children here I I don't think that fact that Stacey has hasn't heard someone directly ask her if there's an issue with this particular thing I don't think that that is going to dictate how we how we have a policy I think there's there's concerns about this is obviously a very charged issue right where we're mandated by the state to have this policy yeah see I me personally I don't I don't have people I don't want to do it for me it's not a charge issue I'm just reading it to me you would change a policy I think with Kur where Kurt's going you would change a policy if you have a lot of people that are expressing concern over the way it was wording and if that's not there and we're changing the wording and the wording seems to not FL with the guidance for the rest of the policy I I don't to me it this is another change which may be appropriate it may me something that conern but I'm just not hearing and and like Julie it's not a chice so I guess I'm still having trouble reconciling whether or not our problem is with the policy or with the way it's written from a legal standpoint because I'm hearing two different things here and I I'm not sure how to I'm not sure how Drive there's a number of problems with the policy and and as I said going to to take this we are elected representatives of this community and I think fundamentally I guess the question is you you think families and parents have a right to be informed and have this information the benefit of their children or not and you can vote Yes or No publicly what you that you should information should be going to parents or not that's the fundamental problem the policy is not it's not about the parents the policy is about students and to me the policy is being changed and the wording is not focusing on student I just don't I don't understand why we're not just focusing on what the student means it's providing and we we did we made changes earlier based on the students needs and how we can them the buing maybe it's philosophical think schools better that's a debate that's not what we're debating that's a Val and I almost tend to go back and forth and someone PR with you on that is not what this policy is is defining any other subject if I go to teacher and say Hey I want keep this secret that teacher is not obligated to keep secret any other so yes I believe the parents right to know the condition or status what have you stent is this is one specific one where they say it's something that the student expresses privacy then we're to follow if you're broadening that to the whole subject of hey I have a secret that I'm tell you I to tell you that's we're talking about we're talking about sure maybe we help go back discuss this about what that confidentiality plan looks like why we do it why it's student interest it's it would be individualized for the student and I don't think my own belief is that adding that sentence doesn't change what your Administration is going to be doing whether it's in there or not in they're going to meet with the student they're and the two of them are going to meet with the student and and discuss with the student what this students wishes are as well as what the practicalities of living uh in a different with a different gender identity in a small community in one school and that try to work with the student to facilitate having a confidential but supportive plan that doesn't put them at some risk of home so that I think they'll be doing the same thing the initial discussion about this was because the discussion was repealing the and that I did advise against because even though it's not technically a mandated policy in the language it does reflect the laws and there's litigation going on and you don't want to put another Target on your Bel so that was the facilitation of the discussion on how can we recognize the concerns of the committee that you raising about working with the family and not excluding return so but I don't think that that puts any different responsibility than your Administration already have just the point of record we did not recommend or suggest well that was the discussion based on the newspaper articles about whether really was necessary I didn't say you recommend it I said that was how it came up based on all the location where districts either repal mon so in since you work in a committee structure and V on the table to table it what would that look like you know moving forward sounds like more numers one go through it really well You' have to you have to decide when it's going to be postponed furthere whatever work in executive committee together on can't really work in executive committee on a policy no it would have to go back to committee it would have to go back to the committee and the policy committee would have to one one quick question do we have the um we don't have the original part you said it was changed it wasn't that the other change is not in that se completely just and students that's besides the change seems to sounds like school's decision know there's no affirmative Duty that's school that's not say I don't know seems that's only that sentence at the bottom would you think it should so so it's got to be it sounds like the intent is coming from a higher body us that's not what it says so oh oh believe me I realized that the department met was very ambiguous in the way they because they could have said you may not unless the student can put bold language they didn't because that's why there's litigation because they're not quite sure how it should be interpreted in terms of the statute itself and then the NS that came in I would and that's for instance a parent who says that you didn't tell me yeah no that's that's the whole debate that's what's going on that's what's being liated it's going to be but not us should yeah well that's I think that's what they intended to say and in a way not but I'm not surprised [Music] like you can revise anything about the policy but that specific sentence comes from the GU so depending if you're trying to change meeting then you may or may not be subject to what is it meaning and you said it's the same interpretation as which me a well I think it's based upon the idea that it's up to the student as to both the gender identity and how it's shared or what is shared so that's why I think they made this langage saying thus you don't have any duty to report when you hear this from the student to the parent but they they didn't go so far as to say what they could have made clear that's that's true I mean and that's why there's litigation by both sides because some want to include it some don't want to follow all some say is no stat requirement for any school district M notify I don't think that I would have no problem with that because I think it means the same thing to me but um that's not what we're talking about right now yeah I just want to be clear on that if that's something you want to talk that would be a whole separate meeting discussion and another first reading second reading later meeting that's already in your poliy that's that's already Carri that we're talking about today is we've already passed out but to me what Ted brought up the idea that could a family sue us and adding that and the suing his family does that t worried about suing us for not telling yeah that's that's to do I'm I'm conc I'm concerned about the difference in interpretation no affir that school say St dep yeah they took that that sentence that directly from the statute doesn't say one way or another that the state department but it's but but then again it's guidance like when we spoke with um Mr nastor yesterday and the way I understand a guidance is guidance we can accept it or not [Music] change you're not F when you're reviewed AED or whatever they're going to be looking at that if somebody challenges that they're going to say well the agency is charge with administering the schools has this guidance you're not following so that's a RIS but you're right it's not a law it's not a regulation which is what I think Ted is saying that it's not because correct me if I'm wrong Ted you're saying that the way it's that it's written it almost sounds like a law he says it's n [Music] understand I just just sounds District decision that's sounds and that is something that we commit will definely take that up [Music] another [Music] com no well had a question about that table how does that table vote sued the up and down vote it does because if the table is successful then matter if it's not successful then the matter is Ved so what we're voting on right now isie and on the and then is unsuccess [Music] then this is on the table yes Mr Becker uh with confidence that the committee will come to conclusion Dr de no Mrs Jones Mrs re yes Mr V yes Mrs wal Mr wal motion so now I'd like to make a motion to put forth items D1 through D6 yes Dr Mrs Jones yes Mrs Reed yes Mr Mrs W Mr W yes and at this time we have visitors business visitors are permitted to comment on agenda and non-agenda items at this time please state your name and can I speak hi everyone um I didn't expect uh to have a comment tonight my name is Jessica Waka I'm an employee here um at the B school and um I've been listening to your uh spirited conversation about this policy which I think if I'm hearing you right is really about whether or not it's in policy to uh inform a child's parents or include their family if they come out to an adult here at the school um I just want to share that as a member of the lgbtq community plus all of it um I did not come out to my parents until I was 37 they don't speak to me anymore my sister doesn't speak to me my brother doesn't speak to me and I am a full grownup who is educated and able to advocate for myself and live on my own Spirit of the laws are to protect children because if parents if children felt comfortable telling their parents first they would and at 37 years old when I fell in love I can tell you my parents or my family were not the first people I told because I didn't trust that they would take it well and based on all of the events that happened after that they didn't so for children who have to go home to a family that may or may not support them or think that they have other things to do I think that putting it in the policy for the purpose of um one man and a I think we're talking about the same meeting that in January I was at um I'm sorry I didn't speak at that meeting because it was very difficult to listen to um and I just think that if a child's coming to tell somebody at the school and they didn't tell their parents first there's a reason and putting it in the policy that you have to tell the parents is just really not necessary I think that the idea of coming together and speaking to the officials at the school to support the child is wonderful and perfect um but putting it in the policy to have to tell the parents is unnecessary and not safe or smart thanks thank [Music] you thank you for tabling it because I think that try also trying to uh have it and then like push it through uh that's a pretty important thing that is being litigated on in a lot of places so to do it today um I think would not be giving it uh or doing your own due diligence to uh see how it plays out when right now there's really not a reason based on nobody else hearing it or or administration at this point at least one other board member heing in the community that there's no rush for it hello my name name is Kimberly Dreer my address is 404 Morgan Parkway and this is my first board meeting so um it took so much to get here I'm really glad I got here but um I feel nervous standing up here I apologize if things aren't as smooth or um as I'd like them to be but I for me when I was sitting here listening to the debate um there there I feel like there for me that there's separate issues like there's the issue of what the policy is daating okay and that you know can be voted on or debated in a different like forum and then there's the issue of putting in this statement that addresses like a parent a community member's concern and I first want to say I appreciate that when somebody stood up and gave their concern that you gave it a legitimate consideration and trying for it but whether I agree on their policy or not not I don't think that that matters what I think is a little bit disturbing for me is that if this language were to be approved it sounds as though you are placating the parent and saying you know the parent reads that and thinks okay like I would be informed I I have knowledge I I my school district is going to bring me into a meeting and like whether it's about this topic or about drugs or alcohol or some other like very serious topic that parents expect to understand and know about their children I feel like this language makes the parent feel as though they would have um like um the support of the school in that when in reality they don't legally it says that they don't right and what I'm hearing from um the the board attorney is that the school cannot tell the parents so if this language goes in the way that it sounds like the way I heard it at least I feel like it's not transparent it doesn't it's like trying to like appease somebody but it really is not effective in anyway and appeasing them because the law is the law and to me I feel like if you are going to reconsider the language it should be considered in a way that is very very transparent to explain to the parent what the right of the child is as opposed to trying to make them feel better that they would know or be involved in some kind of um plan I hope that was clear thank you and um I guess there's just one more one more thing um for me as I I stated before I'm this is like my first board meeting I have a 5-year-old and um I'm starting to become more and more aware of like how the school oper oper Ates and how different um types of Education um facilities operate and how decisions are made um but I don't think it's safe to say like if you're not hearing about an issue from the community that it's not really important to the community because for me I'm I'm I'm I think tonight I really was being more aware of this policy than I had been in the past I guess you know I I I don't think it was a Charged issue for me but like maybe I thought I had a right as a parent to know what was going on with my child and I really didn't realize or understand that in this particular case there's law that specifically says that they would that that the school would make sure to keep confidential If the child wants it to be confidential right so I think that there's could be a lack of awareness especially with like the new parent or the the parents of the younger people or that the parents that are like working and aren't able to like make it to these types of meetings so um I appreciate that even though that one person stood up you're at least trying to make that concern like a real concern and not and I ask that you please don't dismiss it just if there's only like one or two people that say something but um anyways I appreciate that part thank you thank you please sorry I have one more thing sorry I had a terrible terrible experience at drop off and um it was rectified um but I feel like even though there's lots of communication about the drop off um it continues to feel very very like chaotic for for me and my family I have um like a 22-month-old baby and um like I'm having to like move the car sheets around or whatever but it's really like I told my husband like I like the baby on that side I don't want my 5-year-old on that side I want to be able to like reach over and make sure that that baby like you know or whatever like so for me I was like okay you know I don't love the idea of people like opening the door and then here's my baby and then I'm trying to get out and and it obviously causes like problems so I've tried other Solutions like um parking on um like Avenue walking over here and and different things like that and it just seems like kind of a chaotic mess because like we' have to walk all the way halfway down to go across and then come all the way back up here and my child's like oh I don't want to walk and I have to carry him so for me it's just been like really really hectic and chaotic and I know that school needs to start on time but I'm just kind of expressing maybe some frustrations that other parents might be feeling that it's just this is a difficult situation it would be nice to have um maybe an update as to what may maybe happening with the parking over at the um municipal building I know like that was where I used to park to drop my child off and it didn't seem like it was that chaotic so as a parent it feels like all of a sudden something that was working is now um taken away and and it for me it's just not working very well so just laying out there and I hope that maybe um we could get like an update status update as to if that situation will be rectified and that we can um drop off on the other side for the younger children I just want to clarify that the town passed an ordinance that prohibit parking in that lot now so they the town took steps to close that lot for people to park their place to school so I don't want to sound ignorant but I do live in this town but like was I supposed to vote on that like I I'm sorry gotp a they had decided a town council meeting to close that Municipal lot to anybody who was not doing business right I understand it wasn't the school's decision right like I I feel like um there was a communication and I I apologize I don't I meant to like get it ready but um it felt like the communication said like oh we're working with the town to see if there's like a way we can maybe I maybe that was my hopeful think okay I don't know okay well anyway def off the table okay so in terms of like the way that the cars come in right here is there any analysis as to how that's working I mean is it working well for everybody mear Mr and I out there every morning um I think it's gotten much better um you know and and really what we're finding now is you know um the doors are open we pushed it back 10 more minutes to and H monitors to try to provide people with more time to drop off um people are taking advantage of that I still think we have too many people showing up like right at 810 812 and trying to like get in at the last minute The Home Room Bell is 85 the door is Clos at you at 84 you have one minute to get to I just want right now actually can you explain that can you explain that for me like if my 5-year-old comes come she's in here no kindergarteners are held in here with the morning monitor these U cones are put out so they know exactly where to line up and wa with their teacher and like I said we pushed it back 10 more minutes hired morning monitor so that we could get more people through the line uh when we are out there at 8:15 when we go to close those doors there's really nobody left so everybody is dropped off between that 8 and 8:15 we have some stract once in a while we had six kids who came in after8 today so I would say it is working quite well at this point and I encourage parents I remind them the doors are opening up at 8 so you know it's not just 810 to 8:15 right so if you feel like you need a little bit of time sometimes we're out there I go out there right at 8 o'cl and there's nobody out there yet you know but our doors are opening and kids are healthier so you know if you can get here earlier and you want to avoid the rush I would say closer to 8 the better that's when it's Le crowded um and then you know the kids are in here supervised until they're walk down to their homes at 8:15 but this morning at 8:15 when we closed the door there was not a car dropping off okay well it's good to know you know because I I know that you extended the the morning time but um I guess I just thought it was going to be busy the whole time and I'm usually on the leader end I'm not going to lie and S stand up here and say I'm not I'm like so what I can do I'm rushing I'm rushing I'm doing my best I'm doing my best I have a fiveyear old right but okay so I mean um I think for me like I will definitely work on trying to yeah I just know from observing when the traffic is light it's lighter earlier and I still feel way safer than people doing K turns in that e side L morning um and this has been working you know okay and thank you for extending the the time so it's not just that five minutes I appreciate that and I will take advantage of it see you at eight tomorrow I think it's important to note real quick that uh despite the topics whether it's pick up and drop off or [Applause] [Music] transgender we we really do a good job as a board the community and I just want to show my appreciation to the board members for that it means a lot to me it helps discussion as well as community members let alone community members and teachers so thank the cility of it helps a lot and I'm confident through that and with the players we will get to an end that meets the best needs of not only students but the the [Music] all right payment of the bills motion 2066 Mr Becker yes Dr D brosia Mrs Jones yes Mrs we yes Mr vital Mrs Walsh yes Mr wal yes motion car and then secretary certification that and so discussion old bus so I was gonna say this earlier but so um I wanted to talk um to the community about um we've had last board meeting we had uh parents come out and express concerns about the playr and so we've been discussing we've met about the playground we've been discussing it and so um last board meeting um our would vice president um Joe Lance and I were talking about and so and we were talking about what are our options for this and um so he talked about um he suggested which I thought was a really good idea was to create an Adon committee so um we discussed it and um then I met with um Mrs postom and she thought it was a good idea so what we've started doing was um we are going to create a playground committee and so this committee um will involve um Administration it will involve teachers which um Miss postra has been working on selecting teachers that are knowledgeable and experienced uh with working with the younger children and um and so we are asking um and we're also going to have board members so any board member that is interested in being part of the the committee uh if you could send me an email and um I'm going work on that uh and also uh I'm asking I would like parent involvement and so if there are any parents uh that are interested and joining the committee um you can send me an email um if I could have the email by Friday um only because we're trying to get moving on this uh that would be great so any parents out there that are interested in joining our playground committee uh please send me an email um and a letter of interest um we review it and then notify which parents are selected I mean of course I would like to have all parents involved but uh we'll be selecting a couple of parents um but we wanted to do this because we thought it was an opportunity for um to involve are people from different people from our real learning ums yes Mrs Jones has also reached out to the PTO and I believe as well to see if they have Representatives who would be interested um and you know I've gotten great response from our staff um mely who's our occupational therapist on it couple of PE teachers some of our younger age teachers so I think just looking at you know a wide variety of of stakeholders and getting input um will certainly help us make the best choice for this project and so any [Music] comments be all inclusive all so all right so thank you for that and so now we are going to we will be having an executive session um this evening um we will be discussing um board and [Music] I'd like to make a motion session second
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Ashland Select Board Update Oct 4, 2023 · passage 1
hello and welcome to the select board update for the meeting that happened on Wednesday October 4th I was not in attendance I was off on vacation but I was able to preview and watch the meeting after the fact it was great to see the start where the presentation of citizen of the year and Grand Marshall were done with Ashlin day being cancelled so congratulations to Bernie Temple for our citizen of the year and it was great to see all the Scouts in attendance for that and then also congrat ulations to area ashin residents for equity and action uh who were the Grand Marshal for Ashland day uh again uh let's go take a look and a listen to those presentations good for you uh but your dedication to this troop over the years and and I can attest since being uh on the board for a number of years having attended many Eagle Scouts not not just a single Scout but many and we found out how many over 52 Eagle Scouts over those years W quite the distinction my friend and that's the leadership of the troop and that comes from you and comes from everybody that's part of that troop leadership but more importantly enjoy Scouting For over the years that you continue doing it and it's it's this is it right here this is our this is our heritage this is the history of Ashland right here with Scouts like you Eagle Scouts that's what you that's what you strive for and Ashan has been very fortunate to have great leadership with the Boy Scouts to become Eagle Scouts so I can see a good portion of you working hard to become an eagle scout and it's because of the efforts of Bernie and all the other staff members of The Troop um now therefore we the select board do hereby Proclaim Saturday September 23rd 3rd 2023 as Bernie Temple day we urge all residents to make known their appreciation for his Devotion to scouting and to the town of ashin we wish him good health and good fortune signed Robert shair chair ashin select board congratulations Bernie that what do you sad I want to hear a all right September 23rd 2023 area ashon residence for equality and action we present this from the Ashen dat committee and we want to thank you for your efforts we as leaders of the community uh they they thought to establish this program and you folks taken it by the horns and you have taken it to levels that we never expected to happen but you folks with your commitment and dedication to this to this topic and this serious topic we greatly appreciate so we wanted to at least honor and recognize all your efforts Alan I know you're up there congratulations so where is Ashlin residence for equality and action area has been chosen as a field Grand Marshal for Ashland day 2023 um the Ashland Day committee selected area for a number of reasons including their dedication and Devotion to the well-being of the community um I won't go through every point in here so Joe talked a lot about it uh whereas area Works ensure that people of color have a voice and are represented on local boards and committees and area works with the school to ensure people of color are represented and have a voice and whereas area promotes people of color to run businesses in Metro West and highlights these businesses as economic development agencies and now therefore we the select board do hereby Proclaim Sunday September 24th 2023 as area day we urge all residents to make known their appreciation for the devotion uh to Residents businesses and employees of the town of Ashen we wish you all good health and good fortune sign Robert Sher chair Ashen like board congratulations to all of you very good here this and go ahead and there was other couple of highlights from the meeting that I think it's good to sort of bring forward here and that is the discussion about what was going to be potentially happening with Cadillac paint so that property has been uh worked on and the buildings have been taken down and there was a PR presentation about creating an Ashlin Arboretum go ahead and watch that there was also discussion about the potential warrant for town meeting and a few other items so go ahead and watch the full meeting and you can get caught up just as I did that's the update for today for the select board meeting from October [Music] 4th
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board - Hybrid Meeting Wednesday, October 18, 2023 · passage 1
now that we all stay cool stay calm but never forget what's going on and the atrocities that are going on over there whether you like it or don't like it and want to see it end and I hope it ends sooner than later um but it's those voices and you folks from area carry on those voices with with equity and pride and we just you know we wanted to thank you for all the work that you do as well so with that uh Mr chair thank you and so I believe uh we representative Jack Lewis and um a representative from Senator spilka's office Karen Adelman is here so if you folks want to come up together maybe and would that make sense and do your do your thing do our thing yeah thank you so much for this invitation let's make sure we get some pictures too we we're here it's all good it's all good I was with uh the town manager when we got the notification that ashon day had to be canceled because of the weather forecast and uh after the pandemic and a couple years with without ashle and day definitely were're very much looking forward to it uh but I think we all saw the postponed and got really excited but then when we realized it was postponed till next year we're going to keep the excitement going keep it going keep it going and you a big part of that day is being able to celebrate members of the community and so uh you get two celebrations uh last meeting and this meeting so it works it works well uh Bernie I just want to say I I I got to know you shortly after getting elected I was invited to my first eagle Scout court of honor uh and I I think I even said that day it was my first time in 12 years that I had walked into a room relating to scouting uh I had left scouting as a young adult Say Never Again uh done uh got your email or got somebody's email uh from The Troop inviting me in my capacity of course I had to say yes I got a citation uh and in the years that followed you all got me thinking about Scouts again uh so much so that the last couple Court of honors I've shown up in my uniform uh my kids have moved on to other things uh but for the last five years uh they've allowed me to be their their den leader uh Den Chief den no den leader I forget what the patch says uh but Bernie you do so much for the community uh but I just want to say for me you helped me get me back uh into scouting uh and I try to make all the Eagle Scout court of honors uh but as Joe said the things you do for the community are nearly impossible put into words so uh on behalf of myself the speaker of the house all of my colleagues uh I have an official citation uh from the Massachusetts House of of Representatives uh I'll read it uh the Commonwealth of Massachusetts the House of Representatives be hereby known to all that the Massachusetts House of Representatives offers its sincerest congratulations to Bernard Bernie Temple and recognition of being named ashlin's 2023 citizen of the year uh the entire membership extends its very best wishes and expresses the hope for Future Good Fortune and continued success in all Endeavors uh signed by myself the speaker and dated September 23rd which might have been Ashlin day uh that that date sounds familiar uh so again congratulations all right yeah why don't we do yeah taxing we'll do the Senate so yeah so come up here we'll do this'll do the one as well thank you thank you so much for having us the Senate President would have loved to have been here I mean on a week with so much heavy news as Clark manani said we think about how people in the Community Serve each other and it lifts everybody up so it's a huge privilege to be here and it was a huge privilege to meet you in the hall I don't have a history with you but you seem like uh certainly a shining light in this community um and it's really a huge pleasure to give you this official citation from the Senate which I will also read the Commonwealth of Massachusetts state senate official citation be it known that the Massachusetts Senate hereby extends its congratulations to Bernie temple in recognition of being named 2023 Ashen city of the Year excuse me citizen of the year for your outstanding commitment and service to your community and be it further known that the Massachusetts Senate extends its best wishes for continued success that this citation be duly signed by the president of the Senate which it is and attested to and a copy thereof transmitted by the clerk of the Senate which it has been so this is for you congratul great [Applause] congratulations well let's do ARA yeah Bernie what's you told me you had a long speech ready to go I didn't hear the one last time so I keep it short all right I got kind get sidetracked last uh couple weeks ago wasn't quite expecting this this here is it means a lot um there was a lot of hours that get put in with Boy Scouts I also work with the Lions and uh we do a lot of uh Eagle projects uh we just working on this one this last weekend so um somebody told me that my involvement with eagle uh Scouts has been the numbers like 52 or 53 at this point 53 I've been do this for I probably 15 years or so uh I got involved with when my son got into CB Scouts and the first day I showed up for the Boy Scout meeting when he crossed into the Boy Scouts they handed me a shirt and I was like I was very adamant that I didn't want the shirt but here I am this probably the third this probably the fourth or fifth shirt I've had now so but uh we do enjoy doing work with the community we do in in with a food pantry we get involved we have a great pancake breakfast is uh we do it in March um you guys are more than welcome to all come it's a good time great breakfast um and it's it's good to work with these guys sitting up here too I mean they they do a lot behind the scenes um and I'm appreciative of all of you thank you very much thank you for one more citation yes I always getet how much more verbose the like Senate ones are I should add a little flare to to this one uh no it's good no it's good okay I'll keep it I'll be um I'll be as boring as possible no uh so we also have a citation for the area group for everything you've done in Ashland and continue to do as the grand field Marshall with one l i that I looked at that like 30 times I'm assuming it's right Marshall for the ashin day event as is it two Wells this is a collector's item because there is a um but uh I I'm on your email list and I know you do so much more you're never shy about grabbing me at the farmers market or around town when you see me but uh I think you know it but you filled a a gap that existed uh in Ashland you're supportive of folks who maybe didn't always feel like Ashland was a community that looked like them or welcomed them uh but as somebody who's watched from afar tried to been supportive in the ways I can you've you've resisted the urge to just look Inward and be insular uh you've engaged the broader convers or broader community and conversations uh that sometimes can be messy and uncomfortable uh and somebody has to do it because if you don't we won't have them uh and so so so grateful to see that you're being celebrated in this way uh I just hope You' keep it up uh I look forward to the next email to learn about the activities you're having uh and the the vital conversations that that you're facilitating uh similar verbiage uh to to bernes but so the Massachusetts House of Representatives be hereby known to all that the Massachusetts House of Representatives offers its sincerest congratulations to the Ashland residents for equality and action area and recognition of serving as the grand field Marshall uh for Ashland day 2023 the entire membership extends its very best wishes and expresses the hope for a future good fortune and continued success in all Endeavors signed myself as your State Rep the Speaker of the House Ron Mariano and dated on September 23rd what would have been our uh flooded out Ashlin day so again congratulations very I have both L's I'm just gonna say I don't okay so also from the Senate Senate's get spell check the me Commonwealth Massachusetts state senate official citation be it known that the Massachusetts Senate hereby extends its congratulations to Ashland's Ashland residents for equity and action area in recognition of being named Grand field Marshall of 2023 Ashland day in gratitude for the support and awareness you've provided throughout the community and be it further known that the Massachusetts Senate extends its best wishes for the continued success of area that this citation be du signed by the president of the Senate which it has been and attested to and a copy thereof transmitted by the clerk of the Senate which it has been so congratulations all right all the area folks you guys anybody else want to come up yeah let's have a group shot we'll get after I think she'll say something you should hold your citations and maybe um Margaret uh introductions um are you gonna make another speech or you have anything you want to say should I say that now before yes why don't you do it now we'll take some pictures afterwards yeah do that picture and then we'll all right he is good yes that looks great hi good evening everyone uh thank you so much for being here today uh area we're humbled and uh we don't take this slight lead to be here and uh receive the grand field Marshall award and also um the recognition from uh the uh the state sorry the Senate and the House of Representatives um I would like to read our um our mission uh area is a group of people of color and their allies working together to ensure that voices are represented in the local Civic organization ations government and the schools we also support and promote people of color run businesses in Metro West area or uh as engines of economic development that benefit our community at large through Community Action we want to make Ashland a safe and inclusive community for all and first I would like to thank uh God thank my family for supporting me through this and I would love to thank the area board Cara Terell is not here but when I told her about what I wanted to do she was like I want to do this with you and this was 3 years ago we called a few of our friends and everybody in this room the Ashan Community um C uh all local clubs and committees in asheland and I feel like our entire Community came on board to try and support us we really didn't have a book how to do this but we had uh the urge and uh um so to make sure that you know di efforts are kind of you know brought to life in town of Ashland through the schools we've we appreciate the collaborations with the uh Ashan Police Department uh congratulations uh Cara Chief Cara on your appointment and we look forward to you know doing more work with you um thank you everyone for your guidance uh we want to thank the Ashland School Department for you know collaborating with us as well and hearing us and you know our suggestions and ideas and um we also want to thank um uh Beth is not here but she's also been a big p in terms of helping the business of people of color kind of you know uh shine a light on them as well and I would love to thank the select board uh Ashland de committee for having us uh Town manager I I guess like um representative Jack said we meet at the uh the town you know the farmers market and we have some inform foral conversations and we really feel like um our town has become really inclusive we feel comfortable and we have the new generation here the Young Generation we've made sure that they involved in uh a lot of activities we do we usually you know bring them along um you know asheland is your home and uh what a beautiful um town to be in and you know beautiful spirit so we're very appreciative and we don't take this lightly and the work just continues so great well thank you so much did you yeah thank you Margaret very nice all right and this is if um anybody else okay you good if you guys if if you're ready this is the time we usually do you want to say anything or oh this is the time we usually take our big group photos so we'll all come out and take a picture with you if I'm assuming that's okay with the board sure let's go and we'll we'll all get together and I think if you want to join us for the picture you're welcome it's somebody we need somebody with technical expert [Music] over okay everybody one two three one more [Music] time twoes [Music] know yeah we have to [Music] ask you come on I'll sit down before I no photo boming in the back [Music] would just got inv I'll forward to you it's THS the 26 I'll forward the email that I okay I need to figure out what I did with the sheet that I printed out and hopefully brought is the board all back here I think we're back sir [Music] pleasure all right I'm going to call us back into our regular agenda if everybody's ready um so uh one thing I asked to just to have this put on the agenda to give this is as as we're all aware and as um as Joe mentioned earlier about the uh the events in Israel in the Middle East uh that started last week we did Issue a statement and I just want to um read that statement and part of the reason I'm doing this is because um one of the things is due to the limitations of the open meeting law this was a statement that I worked on with Michael and we did consult with Yolanda briefly on it uh but we uh just issued it and our feeling of what um should be said but um I also wanted to make sure I gave other board members uh a chance if they wish to to comment or add anything um and so I'll just read the statement that was posted I think on Facebook um that the town made um uh we are deeply Disturbed and horrified by the recent events in Israel and our hearts go out to all those who are grieving and those desperately waiting awaiting news of their loved ones while we recognize legitimate rights and aspirations of people worldwide we strongly condemned acts of terrorism brutality and inhumanity they have no place in the goal of a lasting and just peace in the Middle East um and also we issued that and then Michael at that time we also spread the news of a community vigil that was held last week um and the only thing I wanted to just add um to that statement I think in light of subsequent events that uh this is my individual thoughts I would just that that hope that people with power such as the state of Israel and the United States would use that power uh with humanity and wisdom when it comes to also the welfare of the palestin Palestinian civilians in Gaza so I just wanted to add that to that statement um so I just turning over the rest of the members if you wish to uh say anything or you don't don't feel like you need to if there's anything um you wish to State cuz you unfortunately weren't able to when we issue these kind of statements I like to have a group discussion and consensus but we weren't able to do that so any any any other board members wish to say anything or add to that you know I'll just you know say thank you very much for putting that together on our behalf um certainly uh this type of humanitarian crisis um is you know shatters my soul um you know there's no other words to use um it it's uh just um hard to understand how we here we are in this world in this St and age and that we uh still live with such barbaric um behaviors and such terrorism and uh and we have you know groups here where we I I just don't understand sometimes how uh people can do what they do to one another so thank you very much for putting that together thank you anybody brandy or um so I would also just say thank you for for putting that together on our behalf um I was at the vigil along with Rob and Michael um and I think that felt like something that we had to do as a community was to come together and and um and grieve together because that's what that felt like um and I've had conversations with friends of mine who um have family and friends in Israel and um people that are now serving in the Army and and in the military there and children who are fearing for their lives and so it it's um it is it's heartbreaking to imagine uh a world where where you know there first of all there's there's there's no no easy solution to it um and I think that when we think of the Next Generation just breaks my heart um so but I do think that um what we can do together as a community is um support one another through all of this and understand that people are coming um at this from different places and be understanding and give people a little bit of Grace um and just understand that the this is a tough time for for many people for many different reasons so that's all thank you Joe thank you Mr chair I briefly expressed my concerns and my feelings about this earlier uh I commend and thank you for uh Drafting and and presenting that letter uh publicly uh I think it's how we all feel uh it's not something that uh um we've grown up with this conflict ever since I can remember um and it's it's unfortunate I don't know if there's going to be a solution to this um we all say that we would love to see it but it's up to it's up to two governments they need to get together and settle their differences and I don't know if that's ever going to happen um someone needs to take the first step and it's not throwing bombs at one another it's it needs to cooler heads should Prevail and hopefully um with what's going on over there today and having our leadership over there now trying to help diffuse this if it can be done um we just need ask everybody to pray I guess that's basically it for coola has to Prevail and people realize that uh this is not the future for our kids to be to be involved in um it's it's a sad State of Affairs and hopefully it doesn't grow larger into something that turns into a world conflict that you know it's it's just sad it's it's really sad and uh it's frustrating and I'm sure it's more frustrating to those folks that live there and you know under severe you know worry as to what's going to happen in not just the next day or the next hour but within within minutes of what's going on over there so again let's hope that our leadership prevails and uh their leadership and hamas's Leadership can get together and try to resolve it it it did once so it's not that it's not able to happen is are you willing to make it happen so let's hope it does so that's all thank you thanks Yolanda do you have anything you want yeah I just want to say that um I remember when we heard about this as we were coming off our vacation and just the idea that people can do this to each other is is very hard to understand as other people have said here on the board and I would just say that I think we as a community are showing that we can care for each other even if we have differences and my hope would be that those countries and those people can find a way to resolve their differences granted it's a lot harder and a lot bigger but um I think we just have to work the way we can here in our community to keep supporting each other as we move forward with this thank you Michael you anything else you wanted to add just I have to say Michael wrote most of that statement I did a few at I tried to take credit we knew wow wow this is a tough audience tou I you know it just amazes me because human beings have like the capacity to be the most compassionate and warmest organisms on the planet and yet you have some people who just choose cruelty and destruction as as a way of life and you know as humans we also have the capacity rationalize things but I just don't understand how you can rationalize some of the some of the things that have have happened I just I don't know how your mind can twist in that way um and I think all we can do is model the behavior that we hope others um will eventually emulate and be tolerant of one another and be willing to work out our differences without using violence or you know resorting to anger trying to keep cooler heads in these situations but um it's a sad State of Affairs for sure it is all right thank you and uh all right so I think and um so we'll move on to the next item in our agenda so which is um well before cens parci yeah um before we do citizens participation I've actually we've got an actual uh human being in the meeting with us who is on our consent agenda so why don't you come up forward you're Josh right come on up here and um stand up to the podium uh I would just add he's on the consent agenda right right now he's on the consent agenda can we ask to take them out of the consent agenda and um I move that we remove item hold on D from the consent agenda and discuss it now all right second on that all those in favor say say I hi all right Josh you were yeah we were you were just going to be a routine consent agenda now we're going to interrogate you so you know okay bring it on all right great if you would mind being moved up in the agenda so I brief you know I reviewed your uh Talent Bank form seemed very well qualified so we're you know happy to have you um so I don't go ahead uh tell us a little bit about yourself and thanks for coming forward to do this sure happy to you know uh Barbara and Paul at waa asked me if I'd be interested in the position of course I happy to do it and uh you pending your approval so I appreciate it and uh basically I've been an Ashlin resident for close to 20 years I have two children in the school district one a senior one in the Middle School um and all three of us actually have been longtime volunteers with waca announcing ashin High School sports oh that's right yeah just about every one of them including swimming during Co so at this point you know Chase started when he was was my older son Chase started when he was in sixth grade and swimming uh announc an okay okay and actually we uh we learned about the opportunity at Ashland Day so a little call back earlier in the meeting great yep and uh yeah they were they were happy to have a sixth grader beyond the air of course you with some supervision and uh it's been wonderful it's been a great opportunity for him a great Growing Experience and skill development not just you know being on air but being able to express himself and think on his feet thing things like that he's inspired his younger brother who has jumped in a number of times as well including a girls lacrosse game earlier this year so that's great yeah thank you very nice questions or thoughts from the board anybody else want to I I just want to add I um I had a nice conversation with the folks from waca and they were uh very uh high on your on your list of doing wonderful things and they're looking forward to working with you you um there are some personalities there that I'm sure you'll know and uh and appreciate and you I think you'll do them just fine and look forward to your additional uh leadership with uh with the cable advisory C thank you very much anything else no I'll just say that I I've had the pleasure of hearing some of you play byplay and uh and thoroughly enjoyed it and bring brings a you know a nice um additional uh layer to our Sports so I appreciate that and uh I think your sons neither would need much um oversight in in that sort of a situation I and uh they both to I you know know that they both have the skill to uh speak publicly it's not always the case with with kids at at such young ages so uh thank you for stepping forward thanks Claudia I just I think it's great that you've had the experience doing work for table to then step up and be on the board because you understand some of the issues that they're dealing with in regards to Staffing and just trying to cover everything that they're doing so thank you for being willing to step up and be on the board thank you yeah I'm really looking forward to it I'm really hoping we can establish more of a partnership with the school district and be able to pull more kids into this program and more participation I really enjoyed working with Steph marks over the years and I'm looking forward to working with Kevin as well uh the new athletic director oh great great and I would just note you're taking the place of Kim Wales who has resigned correct correct she's the one that and so I wanted to thank Kim for her service and also um and she resigned my understanding is because she's now one of the registar of Voters and felt she's been a registar of Voters and in reviewing some of our bylaws she felt she couldn't be a registar as well as be on the waca C advisory that's really so so thank you Kim for your service as well and just um just go ah real quick just I've known Josh for for for a little bit of time these days little bit um and I just I was so excited to see that you had um put your name in for this because I think that you will become a s a strong advocate for cable access which is um really needed um I think waca does an amazing job and I think that um between the coverage of of the sports and our town government and I mean honestly we couldn't we couldn't have functioned as as a board without the support of waca during Co and you know we we rely heavily on um on all the the types of you know live streaming and all sorts of communication that that wacka brings because we know that that people get their information and get their entertainment from waca so um so thank you for for all the work that you've done you know on the the on the one side of the mic and and um and we look forward to to seeing what uh what's going to be the next chapter for waa so thank you thanks Brand so we ready to sure I move that we appoint Joshua Abrams to the waca board of directors effective November 1st 2023 for a term that will expire on October 31st 2026 I'll second that motion's been made and seconded all those in favor say I I okay congratulations congrat thank you Mr chair if I may yeah U just one of the things I wanted to bring up is uh Barbara had reached out to me yesterday and I think it's only fitting to you know say this now that actually Friday October 20th is community media day oh and um so again thank you so wacka and Josh thank you for your service and continued service and um yeah so let everybody know Friday Beauty media day very good and don't forget Ashlin Hopkinson football Thanksgiving Day live on waca TV all right there he goes this involves a ra Now is it going to be live oh that's cool the football games are live streamed yeah yeah W all right this is a home game right yeah we only do home games we don't have the budget to travel all right get your bus to thank you play playoffs we travel yeah I was going to say right yeah thanks again thank you so now we're ready yeah real person yeah yeah very good trust me that's a good thing so so now I think we're ready for Citizens participation do I see anyone uh see Mark your hand is up go ahead Mark I think can he unmute unmute himself okay yes I can unmute myself I I noted by now good evening Mar Sony 49 haon Road Mass uh three things all all came up in the uh so far in the meetings is that thank you about the appreciation and um consolement about what's going on in Israel brother if Israel and Gaza could think Family Ties and and all that that all this will never be started but they have their own idealisms that shouldn't flash what it does and this is what's going on with them right there two is to say about the as cable is the um if it wasn't for the being on the town for the town license committee ACA would never been around but it's been around and has grown to be all positive all going good local channels for the town itself and for the home citizens and to see how it's grown in in inexpensively and greatly is a good thing for for for what's going on in the future three is my usual question to the man Town manager I know the compion plan meeting is tomorrow night correct and yes I am gonna be there I have almost given up on the idea of being on Zoom because I know that I could not participate unless I'm there in person so I am very grateful that I can I can be participate in person with the group once they break them off into groups and I appreciate the ground rules that are VI I put up last time that's good four this house is my dad is still up and around 98 years old Sue got a good heartbeat a 130 over 86 blood pressure wow 96 to 97 oxygen in his body a caregivers that come here all throughout the day morning afternoon and night of course I still stay up at about 3:00 in the morning to be the night hour but all those all good things and it Israel could think like I think in my house and this family this war would be very short so thank you all right thank you thank you Mark thank you Mark okay so um so our next item is under old new business is the comprehensive Plan update so who's doing the update I I can start it off and Yanda and brandy if you want to chime in um so as um as Mark mentioned we do have our next meeting tomorrow night um and what is planned on the agenda is we have some administrative items that we're going to take care of but then uh our consultant JM Goldson is actually going going to lead us through an exercise uh really the steering committee is starting to dig into some of the planning aspects of it so that looks good um website is up and running uh had a few tweaks that we needed to make um and that's happening and uh so the data requests that uh JM Goldson has asked for which was pretty voluminous um Peter and I have been working on that and we've got most of that done and completed uh that's you know back data and reports you know older reports and uh so yeah that's about it from my perspective I know there's other things but I figured Yolanda and Brandy you'd want to add to it so I would add let you go first you the market so um so the comprehensive plan was at the Farmers Market on the 7th on October 7th um we had some really good conversations there was um a lot of activity around our table which was good um so thank you to to the members of the comprehensive plan that volunteered their time at the the farmers market and thank you to everyone that came out to to to chat with us um we have a couple of asks from um for you know public asks one of which is um we are starting to collect photos of um special places for um that are going to be part of the comprehensive plan itself and so I don't know if the the um we have a flyer with with the the address I don't have it with me but but basically um I know that the website was having some some like kinks in it with the uploading of the pictures that has been fixed that has been fixed so we will be putting out a call to folks to um to submit photos and be a part of the comprehensive plan and um and just in general like we're going to be having a um I don't know if we we're going to be discussing a date tomorrow night for the December Forum but just to remind folks that we're going to be having a community visioning Forum in December um that we want the public to make sure that they're um coming out and being a part of because that's our first real um so we'll have to think about that because later we talk about the Valentine Forum as well so let's keep that in mind so but I think I think we're the the first meeting that we I mean I know we kind of talked about it I think the last time um our first meeting with Goldson was I thought really great I think that they are group that will um really help us pull this together in a really cohesive way and it will um be very representative of Ashland I think that their skill set is going to be on the the community engagement side and I think we're going to be um as we really dive into this process I think I think we're going to to come come out with a um a really great result because of it so but that's my perspective I would just add as well that I think it was interesting the beginning of our last meeting was a little tough of our comprehensive plan but then when JM Goldstein when they did their introductions and got us all engaged I feel like it sort of smoothed out some of the concerns that some of our members had the the one thing I'm going to recommend tomorrow at our meeting and it's been discussed for with a couple different people is we just had a Mendes meeting last night and it happens at the Mendes cafeteria and I know one of the concerns trying to move out of the library is there's not many other buildings in town that have the technology to either have projection and the internet and zoom and things like that and I think the mes cafeteria would be a perfect place for us to have our meetings and it would allow a lot more public to come and sit and listen and participate than it does at the library because at our last meeting at the library we have our table around and that fills up the space and then for people to come and sit so I'm going to make that recommendation tomorrow at our comprehensive plan that we move from the library which has been a great location but as we try to expand public to want to come and listen to our meetings I think the Mendes cafeteria is going to be a lot better so I think we should review that tomorrow night and then if we if people think that's okay then we just have to get on the calendar at the mes and Paul Kendall has offered to take a few of us through some of the technology it's pretty straightforward to plug in and stuff like that but I think it would be a great thing to do we were talking about that at the market so I so mes is good for virtu like people could be virtual and yeah because you can have your so Michael or you know someone would have a computer and you plug in so you'd have your you know Wi-Fi to be on zoom and you'd still use your owls for some of it but then you can project onto a pretty large screen so you could see people they'd see us through the owls but then if you're sharing information there's a lot more real estate to share that so that's great so if that works there may other events or forums there might be other forums that we say instead of doing them at the community center because we want to be able to do them virtually and if the library is a little small that we look at having them at the mes cafeteria so potentially even the Valentine event so that's all I have to add for comp thank you and uh surveys went out I got one someone apparently said I was an expert on Transportation so I'm going to wonder about their you know something you're well you're the upper Charles Trail guy that's it Transportation they're looking at me expert what do you mean so that's what they said in the email I don't know I'll do my best so and but so there how many of those went out um I think there were uh three six n 12 probably 15 so it's it's broken down by category um the different elements of the comp a Ser a survey I haven't really looked at it yet but um so that's good yeah great all right thank you all so next oh a date to hold the public forum on the Valentine so that's a good segue seg public forum out so now we're talking about two big public forums maybe in December or what's our thinking here well originally we talked about the Valentine uh Forum being in uh November I think that we're going to be hard pressed to do that um December might actually be pretty difficult too and just to give you an update you know we talked about it at at one of the sele board meetings um I talked about it at the Historical Commission meeting had a good conversation with them they brought up all kinds of things that we didn't necessarily think of um and then I met with a number of our staff to kind of okay you know we got like this big picture thing let start putting some details to it um you know you don't want to go too far because you want to make sure that you're going in the right direction but at the same time there's some simple things that probably need to be answered and uh um I don't know I would say January is probably a much there's no real urgency to get it you know like we have to get it done in December I would say January is probably a much better date I guess my only con not concern but something to consider is as we start looking at our 2025 budget if some of the things that you've talked about doing in regards to the W Department moving there then some of that we may want to include in our budget and if we're too far along in the planning and Andor the budget are we then having to go back and the other thing that I mentioned to you as you said Michael is I'd hate for us to be so far down into the details and then go to the public and say this is what we're thinking and have the public go oh well I don't want you to go that way or how you know so that that's it's finding that balance of getting public input on your plan and having enough detail or too much detail for them to go well you've already decided what you're going to do so you're not going to listen to my input anyway so it's finding that balance that I'm concerned about if we wait you know or do we wait to do any of the more detailed work that you're talking about until we have the Forum and then go into it yeah I mean I'm hoping that we've minimized that risk simply because basically all that proposal is is from the original public input um but still yeah I think we you know we don't want to go too far down the road before before we get um okay an idea but I I I would suggest that January would probably be um and I can come up with a better better date by our next meeting and um okay that people pretty much thinking that's yeah so December will be the comprehensive plan form in January the Valentine that makes sense then okay um you know my only my only question is with the comprehensive plan Forum um because I mean that's that's really Goldson that's running that correct well um they would put together the program on our basically our Direction because so there's a couple of things that we have to think about uh with regards to that we have to think about first of all do we want to try to piggyback it with an event that's already happening in December and if that's the case what do we want that form to look like do we want it to be like a traditional Forum where you have you know set aside two hours and people sit at a table and listen to a presentation for a few minutes and then provide or more than a few minutes and then provide input or we do we want to have something that's a little bit more flowable and um you know people can walk in provide input and walk out as they're part of like the Holiday Stroll if that's ultimately the decision we want to go in um but I will say you know talking to Goldson that they can come up with the program but they want the steering committee to take an active role in um EX in facilitating you know the discussion however it it plays out and I would say that as you know having been on the comprehensive plan in the past and you were on this the the you know the Strategic plan one that people respond better to them you know their peer you know their peers and fellow citizens to Michael's point I think Goldstein will help us sort of lay out what it's going to look like but we're going to need to be there and take turns probably to to f facilitate and listen and and sort of draw things out that we might know better than Goldstein about different things Goldson I'm having a hard time with names ton some nights are are easier than others for sure all right okay so okay so we done with that um January yeah and the other reminder is we have a special town meeting in November right so yeah that's going on 28 the Tuesday yeah um okay the next item is the uh discuss Grant programs the baa Grant and select board Community Grant and um uh Susan had raised some questions and I think um Brandy you and sure want to discuss those yeah so so if you all remember um I think it was a couple months ago at this point we had um approved sort of a new program for the baa grants um where the we basically we broke it out into two two separate programs because um historically we've always had what we call the baa grants but the funding mechanism for um from the runner account was always only to um official 501c3 organizations because that's legally what we can provide um so we would open it up to the whole community and um a couple of things were were happening one um was that we weren't we weren't utilizing the funds in a in a really productive way we had a large account balance um at the end of each um after we allocated all the spring uh spring grants and so part of it was was trying to figure out a better way to utilize the funds ALS so um for those organizations that weren't 501c3 we had funded that out of the select board's gift account um which has a different funding mechanism which is the the Warren Conference Center fees which does not have quite the same um level of funding as the the runers account so that being said we we changed it so that the baa grants uh people could apply instead of 2500 to 4,000 um and up to 6,000 per um basically for over the course of two Grant Cycles is what we had approved and for the select board Community Grant groups could apply for up to um a thousand with a total of 1,500 for over the the two Grant Cycles so it's a little bit of a more complicated process um absolutely and so Susan had put out the the call to folks to apply for the grants and one of the the things that had kind of come up from it was that um um like an organization that had applied the last Grant cycle in the spring was saying that they weren't eligible for this grant cycle because they had received 2500 last spring where in reality because because they would fall under the Community Grant side um where you know in my in my frame of reference and this is kind of why I wanted to discuss it was you know I was thinking that this program was like a clean slate like we were starting from you know not looking back at the last Grant cycle because this is a new program it's got kind of new rules um and so you know my thought and again I want feedback from you guys is that um you know should we should we make this policy retroactive at all or if we I think it's cleaner if we just kind of on a go forward basis say you know this is the maximums per cycle per per two cycles um that way people understand sort of what what they can apply for so when you I'm sorry so when you say two cycles you're actually talking about one year because you have a spring and you have a fall Grant right okay so it's one year I think that's where the confusion was a little bit respect to that yeah well so one of the things that Susan had asked was whether whether or not it could be changed to a calendar year which I understand it would probably be easier from a from a you know kind of the only issue is that we're starting this in the fall so it's hard to kind of do a calendar year because we're starting it in Fall so you know my suggestion is this is a new program we start fresh everyone can apply for 4,000 for the the 501c3 or for $1,000 for the the community Grant and that the the maximums kind of get applied in the in in the spring if they decide to apply again so it would never matter um where in say an annual cycle you were so if you might apply in the fall and then again in the spring or you could apply in the spring for the first time and then again in the fall um so it wouldn't ever matter whether or not they were it's just whenever you applied the first time that's your first time and then you know Claudia and I as the subcommittee would just look at what was allocated the last time around just to make sure that the maximums weren't weren't you know weren't over right we weren't over on the max so it' be rolling yes ESS it' be rolling okay Dand does that make sense I know it's kind of I know it's really it can be confusing to kind of think about it but so I like the idea that we're setting these new amounts that we start with this cycle with that new program I can understand from Susan's perspective that it's easier on the calendar year but I also think that there are going to be some people who aren't going to apply now because they don't need the funds now and they'll apply again in the spring and then they can go two cycles if they want or there might be some people who apply now and they might not need the full 4,000 so they might apply for something less and then they can apply up to so I I think that it should be effective as of this grant cycle splitting out the two and then as Brandy said that as the subcommittee they'll have the list list of who got stuff in the fall when they go to look at stuff in the spring and not worry about what happened in May of this year but started as of this year this this grant cycle and just let it be on a rolling basis depending on when people apply and then I know Susan has asked that if that's what we're going to do that we extend the um application timing so that it's it can be made clear so I would I would almost recommend I think right now the application deadline was was on the test the 10th of October so I would say we push it to the end either the end of October or the first Friday in November one of the two right the 31st is a Tuesday if we extend it to that Friday that might be better yeah I like the Friday I like the Friday because then we'd get a couple of bites at Michael's newsletter right there you go oh right yeah um I just said so um does anybody here remember the the kind of the balance in the community Grant I know it's a small low do we know just generally what we're talking about I know I know we set the ,000 yeah I know we set or you suggested $1,000 based on the balance but I want to say it was like 32 I want to say it was pretty L like we just had we also allocated so the the gift account we use for other things too like we just allocated 5,000 for the Niza Memorial site um um if you give me a minute you got ahead and keep talking yeah that was through the gift account okay so um the gift account being the community Grant or the yes yes oh okay so the community Grant is associated with with organizations that are not nonprofits because the baa wants us to do funding for nonprofits so and that's what I'm T so I've had like a couple discussions or a couple incidents recently where where people of town committees have come to me or we've just been discussing need for funds one was the The Cult Council and the other was a town Forest committee where they were thinking about funds and so I guess I'm wondering so if a town committee is looking for funds out of the gift account right now their Max is a th000 and I think the twole 48,000 in my notes that's probably for sounds about right 48 a little bit of money for the gift or the baa for the gift okay right so if if it's a town committee they're not a 5013c they can do a th000 and then if they go come again in the second cycle they can do another 500 right so I guess what I'm but and we just had the example of the Niza um Memorial that we we voted more so I guess that that was outside of the grant process that was us just seeing the need and well so that's my question you mean if we if I if I'm we're talking to a a um a committee and say wow it' be great to give them some money is that outside of this policy or how would that work or should we look at putting language in a policy that allows for something like that I guess that's my my question so I mean do we want to make an exception for Town committees on involved in Special Projects or allow that possibility so I think that gets a that that gets to be clui because for instance the ashin public library um applies for uh a grant and they are not they would be under this they would be under the Community Grant yeah because the friends are the friends group can apply under a 5011 but I think if we start saying certain committees can and certain commit like I just think I think it's cleaner if we stick to the grant cycle right and then if there's something outside of that then we handle that as a oneoff separately as a board someone would come and make a request to the whole board outside of your SubCom like for instance if if like the Town Forest had that um they had wanted that ATV years ago and you know that's a separate that's almost like a capital you know a capital purchase anyway so I guess depending on what they're looking for you know but if they're just looking for funds to to fund walks and to fund speakers and things like that they should be able to work within the the grant the gr all right so I think as as long as we have that understanding if someone's coming for a really a larer ask and feels they they should get more funds that's something that we'll handle um discuss as a full board outside of this process is that what we're kind of how we're seeing it working so if a group comes in I'm sorry and this would be a town a town of Ashlin government group of some sort that's that's my definition that's what I'm you know so one of the concerns that I that I have and I in your Lon you just said something and I hope I didn't misunderstand you you just mentioned that the baa is looking to looking for the towns to spend their money in non 5013c groups was that's part of their that's one of the isues that we had in the past is if they're not a nonprofit We can't use the baa funds that's why we split it out now okay we did it before but it would be the same process right everyone would fill out the same Grant and Susan would look at it and go okay we can use these funds or we can use these funds gotcha and now we're separated we're making it much cleaner from our perspective as well as for people sorry as well as people applying for funds that they know if they're a 5013c they can look to get more funds than if they're you know if they're not 5013c now and the one thing I would recommend is we look at if we're allowing um up to $6,000 per group per cycle at some point we may want to look at increasing the amount of money we ask people to raise because we're only getting you know we have what we have 66,000 66,000 coming in so Oh you mean the runners how the runners right at some point if we keep doing $6,000 per group depending on what we get we may run you know that's only six groups 11 groups so if a group comes in in November and I'll just use the wrong fingers gets $1,000 or request $1,000 and the committee allows them the $1,000 now in 202 four is that that a new Cy spring we were just saying that it's going to be a rolling C two consecutive so if someone comes in now and applies for applies for they're they're not a 5013c yeah so they apply for $1,000 if they decide to apply again in the spring they can only apply for $500 if they don't decide to apply in the spring then come the next then well and even if they do apply in the in the fall they can still they can go back again for another okay because it's nobody can it would be more than 10 groups because nobody gets $6,000 that cycle right but but our $66,000 is what we get for the year right right but I'm just saying it involves more yeah we'll monitor the levels of course right and we had said that if we ever get to a point where we're at 50% of the balance or more than 50% of the asks are more than 50% of the balance that we would Everybody by the same percentage right I think that's a good idea rather picking and choosing okay um so I think we're ready to um do a motion I mean I just want to make we need a motion I think I think we voted all this before this was just a we're going to move we're going to move dat so we're moving the due date to that Friday after Halloween which I think is the 3D I think it is the third right so November 3rd second third yep so November 3rd will be the deadline it's a Friday and then we're starting this CLE as the first CLE for the new process so if you apply this fall for the full amount as a nonprofit when you apply in the spring you can only get another $2,000 and if you applied this past spring you're still fine clean sleep y yeah um and then so what we'll plan on then is so if we close out the grant applications on the 3 then Claudia and I can meet that following week and we can plan to have it on the agenda for the November 15th meeting what what what meeting did you say November 15th we'll have we'll have the the full votes on the November 15th we'll have the recommendations for the gr R okay very good all right great um okay that brings us to the consent agenda motion to approve the consent agenda with item D having been removed I have a second by Joe and so all those in favor of approving the consent agenda say I I I oppos None great and micheel did you want to say anything about Britney L assistant Recreation director um actually no because uh we recently found out cu she is actually not going to accept the position oh sorry to hear that then we should have pulled her I think it's it's a moot point it's a moot point that's too bad okay it's uh labor is difficult and good news and bad news it's tough to keep people yeah probably got a better offer the only I just you know it's um thanks for Debbie and MOA for uh reupping for the cultural Council that's great um any other questions on the consent agenda before we move on no okay so that brings us I think to town manager's report yeah and I think we can be fairly Fair fairly brief here um so yeah just the fire department had an unbelievable movie night um I don't know if you saw the pictures but we had about 180 180 people come to that um yeah they had to like move they had to move the you know more trucks out of the Bays they ran out of cotton candy even after Lynn went and got some more so congratulations to them I know their public what were the movies uh PAW Patrol PAW Patrol oh Paw Paw Patrol and uh they had a great open house too as well so had plenty of people there pretty funny so it's nice it's nice to have a new building that has an apparatus Bay that can can hold trucks and kids wow that's something it's pretty awesome um just an update on the downtown project they should be moving to um finish up the bricks on the medians soon and uh from that we'll move move towards the punch list um on the streetcape work and simultaneously we're going to go through the um we're going to start the process of putting the bid documents out for the connections um at some point in the near future I did find out that Verizon has started pulling their cable they were kind of the last hold out so and then again once that's done then you it's taking the poles down so um it's really really getting there it's um pretty exciting um update on it we're still thinking spring is kind of the sort of Target for that spring y okay um so also on the budget uh you know I took a look at uh at our budget we seem to be we're in good shape only one I'm a little bit concerned about not necessarily yet but I'm just going to keep an eye on really closely is the um legal budget especially if we starting you know doing some of the actions that we've talked about that's accordingly got some expense associated with it if it's not covered through Maya and then um also we got notification of our free cash approval oh yeah I saw that yeah um are you all on that I got it did everyone else get it you might get it as the chair oh you know I might have you know and I kind of thought oh we should talk about this and I forgot about it but that was quite yeah do you want to yeah so our our free cash certification not cash yes not free not cash um is 1.7 million that's something um so about half a million less than last year which is fine that's actually fine um and then also retained earnings in our water Enterprise fund um it's about 1.5 million and for our sewer Enterprise fund it's about uh 1.45 million um our Solid Waste Enterprise fund it's 293,000 and uh finally for our athletic fields excuse me not finally but for our athletic fields 107 175,000 um 213,000 for the cable access Enterprise fund and now finally uh 213,000 for our stormw water Enterprise fund that's great so um healthy healthy numbers nothing um to be alarmed uh nothing to be alarmed at that's great so just so you know you know the free cash will divide it um accordingly um according to our policies so we will be putting more money uh this time in the special education stabilization fund which uh we've only done one time before um the good news is is that we took 250,000 out we're only going to have to put 200,000 in because the interest it it generated um puts us up above the cap so good news there that's great and were all those numbers in the letter that we received okay so we could forward it to these guys around to be helpful yeah absolutely I'll remember if I so it came a couple weeks ago and I said wow this is great news then I then I got went on to other things but so should have remembered that so well that's when I'm here for Rob except my memory is sometimes questionable um and then finally uh provided for you tonight just a hard copy of an update on the priority projects uh that we decided on during the select board retreat um one department head wasn't able to uh to update it in time any more of those do I does everybody else have okay um but I think it's pretty self-explanatory just you know some notable things um you know upper Charles Trail you know we have completed an analysis of the town-owned properties and some restrictions that we have there um you know Valentine property we did talk about the Forum but we didn't talk about the barn that's almost done should be done by the end of the month and it's looking really good um nice it's looking sharp um change that public forum to January yes I'm going to come back to you at the next meeting with a more specific date um um I did get an update on the NBTA station oh yeah I was wondering about that um so I didn't get an update on an anticipated opening day but um I did get an update on the work that's been done so on the outbound side all the concrete has been chipped out and removed all the sand blasting had been completed uh the steel pans had been removed and about 90% of those have been replaced uh the awning has been removed and some of the steel cross beams are being replaced placed now on the inbound side that's had all the concrete removed and the pans removed and the contractor is sand blasting the steel and evaluating what steel needs to be replaced so then they will start removing the metal awning on that side um in the next couple of days actually working it's hard to tell it's hard to tell it really is because you go there it doesn't look any better so it's going to look worse before it gets better doesn't look any worse either at least from Michael I had a question CU I wound up driving down into to the parking lot the other day and it was available so are we are people allowed to park there or not I think still not I think that was by mistake okay yeah I did the same thing I went by oh that's open let's go check it out it's hard to see anything though yeah yeah I I think that they they're moving equipment and that that's sometimes cuz at the access road is open at times too that and you I've seen them moving equipment down there did you get a feel are they actually going to do something on the part that potentially replace the the cross crosswalk that's my understanding yeah that's that's going be a big deal if they do that um they might just you know I think they're evaluating exactly like like I said if if how much of the sand blasting would actually help or if they just need to go through and there was I don't know what they were doing today but it was smoke coming out I don't know if that was sand sand blasting okay it's really cool sand blasting is really fun it really is looks like it so um is is it going to you know I mean is it going to be painted look better I mean what's the end do we have a picture of the end product anywhere no we don't um and it's been difficult to really kind of get something it's been difficult to get updates right frankly um clock or blue painted blue because then you you don't want to paint it blue because then you have to they have to maintain it and it's going to deteriorate again so you want as simple as possible clean and simple as possible I would think yeah I mean you want to have you want to protect the steel right somehow so you don't end up in the same situation but um yeah well I'm sure there's there is to Joe's Point there's probably ways that could be attractively painted yeah if it was if it was painted I would think that would provide some protection I'm sure they're going to paint it the question is what you know it'll be the same ugly gray that that's Battleship Gray you know that kind of thing um also pretty soon Clover Road Brewery uh that will be moving forward to the uh boards and committee stage so that's great contracts signed anything lease has been lease has been um we just need to get the signatures on those and like I said then then we can move forward with boards and committee when when are they expected to open spring fall goes well oh good nice so planning board and conservation I believe just they might have to go to conservation for a storm water permit but um and to us for licensing yeah for the worker licensing and stuff okay okay okay so relatively straightforward is it just site review for planning board or is it think are they asking for special permit site plan Jen do you yeah can you chime in yeah yeah it's site plan and they'll they'll need a storm water permit so they will be going to conservation okay so okay so we'll see how that goes job um and uh that's about it if you have any questions on these I'll obviously reach out to it I want to say thank you for this I know it takes a little while to do this update but if every couple of months we could get this I think it would be helpful the one question I did have in looking at this quickly when you gave it to us is there's a couple of them that says waiting for info on funding yeah I I didn't get a chance to really review that that came in really late today so okay we have funding that's allocated as you can yeah because like there's money next to it so okay okay you can tell that comes from one department head yeah well you know their their name is next to a lot of items so it's understandable okay thank you you're welcome right and um that's is what I had J JB did you have anything not unless you I mean do you want to touch upon Citizens Academy you want to put that on our next meeting um no I think we can touch base on it um so one of the things that we talked about at the retreat is doing a Citizens Academy um so that's an opportunity to take a class of of citizens and um basically teach them about the inner workings of government and different departments and it's you know over a period of months and Jen has really been working with the department heads on putting that together and um just kind of the curriculum if you will and Jen do you want to go into a little bit more detail on that uh sure um so what we're hoping is that um our first class would be um probably limited to maybe 10 to 15 people just so that we can work out um sort of logistics and make sure that we're meeting meeting everybody's um interest and needs and that we can kind of make it an interactive process so that we want to make it you know pretty interesting make sure we can have opportunity to answer questions have maybe tours of some of the facilities so keeping it reasonably small um you know we're thinking about maybe doing a preference to um community members that maybe haven't served on boards or committees um for the just for the mere fact of maybe access to some of the Town departments and maybe um those folks that haven't yet been involved would have um some questions and not know necessarily how to access that information and maybe also um garnerish some interest in future board or committee work um once they go through the academy so right now we're sort of looking at maybe an 8 to 10 week um program will break up by departments um or sort of um like um services or functions or operations um I'm hoping to put out um just a very quick almost like a talent B form um for an application um in November and then sort of work through that and have it kicked off in January and that would allow us to go through um basically an 8 to 10 week class that will bring us right up to town meeting I'm hopefully getting people engaged at on things that would be on the warrant you know perhaps ending with um a ceremony at the select board where we can sort of um recognize people for completing the program but we were thinking about doing sort of an overview of what your government looks like at a local level and then talking to department heads so breaking it up by Public Safety Public Works Finance um Health and Human Services and some of our programmatic work and then obviously Community Development and probably having to split that up where it would be building Economic Development and planning one week and then Health conservation and probably sustainability on another week um and then sort of working with some staff that kind of interweave all of that such as it and figuring out how you know we can show their support and then having town clerk elections and talking about town meeting at the tail end of the of the program so trying to line it up with real life um exercise so that people can sort of see how how and when they can be engaged um with all of us okay question one yeah just a question SL comment so would that also include maybe a session or somehow tied into maybe the town clerks about running for office what offices there are what that means and yeah I think potential you know have a select board member that is there or someone elected Finance you know not Finance they're not elected but sort of talking about the elected board and what they mean kind of thing yeah one of the things we'll cover is like our government structure and and what that looks uh what that looks like you know go through the open town meeting process cover the elected boards the appointed boards and stuff for sure yeah I was going to you know you know what kind of curriculum would you have for like all the different committees all the volunteers and the elected officials and how that all works in the town government would be good part right others so question um so is this something that is going to be like what is the time commitment like per week for the average person because I assume most of these are during the day right or is this like an evening be evening oh okay okay yeah so good question I mean Brandy we've been trying to figure out how do I mean I think you started to do some of the um sort of thought process around you know how do you boil down um zoning you know down to uh a manageable amount of information and keep people engaged so what we were sort of thinking is that if we have small groups um like departments doing presentations that we'd be able to do it on a Wednesday evening alternating Wednesday evenings I think in Michael's newsletter we had put out one of the questions about you know what kind of time commitment Could you um see yourself um committing to and so you know twice a month seemed doable and that way there's some momentum um so Wednesday evenings maybe for an hour and a half two hours and that would be their commitment twice a month um and obviously different staff would be um presenting so there's their commitment would be a little bit different would this be hybrid or in person or in person person in person so no not a hybrid option correct why not like what's your thinking there um I think you know I think some things well first of all we're going to be on location in a number of of places so you know when we're doing the public safety module it'll probably be held at the public safety building if DPW would probably hold hold it out like maybe the water treatment plant um so you know just having that type of Technology carry around with you would be would be difficult well there might be some like I mean you could on Zoom you could record things so you'd have people's presentation available for other people to look at well like I think about like from my experience with leadership Metro West the value was was going to different locations and kind of understanding what people do in those in those spaces so you know rather than just like a a PowerPoint presentation I think people need to kind of really understand what you know in in order to get engaged I think people need I think I think it's a great idea I think it's I think it's I would piggy back up on on that and that in person you get that cohesiveness with your group whereas some if some are are via virtual and I mean all that was great during coid and I know some people still have issu you know health concerns but I think especially for the first one in person if it's a twice a month commitment and I love the idea that it would be for people who aren't already on committees or boards or have been on committees or boards that we really try to get new people engaged so when that goes out you know let's publicize the heck out of it and I would send it make sure we reach out to the schools and ask them that whatever flyer we have we can ask them to send it through their school emails um you know put the flyer out there as well the the only issue with the school flyers I don't know how much you know is that they they no longer go out in the in the emails there's there's like a yeah you have to connect yeah it's really not I would I would as a parent I've gone on it once and it was only to see if the comprehensive plan flyer there's not even a list of what's in there it is basically a you know a folder and it has all these different um you know informational Flyers how else would we get it I mean unless we do an email to people on a list an right I mean there's got to be well maybe if maybe if Michael wrote a little blurb and sent it to Jim or to the principles maybe as them to do something different yeah with a the link to I would also say if we can get it into the next edition of town pages I don't know yeah you know like yeah unfortunately really yeah it is part of um we're doing Ashlin access that will be coming out in the beginning of November and so a little there's a little blurb on that and then we'll build out a website that just has sort of information there um we've been trying to ask questions in the poll for Michael's newsletter and ter of you know what what what topics within some of the Departments are most interested to you so that we can make sure that if we're doing presentation so we'll be taking that data but sort of you know starting to sort of tease that out um through the newsletters but it will be there will be a small article in the ashin access okay okay great sounds good thanks jie all right so Michael are you that's it I'm done very good okay all right so that brings us to board reports want to start with Claudia are you ready sure um yeah I don't have too much we had a a school building committee meeting last night um I think the exciting this is always something exciting happening over there these days but um you know is the they've been working on the fever feverishly uh on the playground and indeed the playground um will be available to students within a few weeks and it looks looks great um I saw them today they were putting another coat of paint on the I think the the paint at self is actually some kind of special paintting the in the uh underneath it is um some kind of rubberized uh material so is a Battleship Gray paint no it's blue and green um it makes me want to be able to go play on the playground again yeah it's pretty nice and there'll also be a basketball court that will be available at this that time um as well it won't have its the lines painted um but and then the uh the Bus Loop is being completed and the bus Loop is going to be um you know finished soon and again at the same schedule these projects are all will be available I believe turned over to the town basically um at the same time and uh that will get the buses and the parent drop off completely separated the way it should be yeah I mean that's the way it was designed um so so really you know great progress um they're got a few other things they're working on on over there um next week I've been invited uh by Senate President Spa's office to the citizens legislative seminar for a couple of days um so I'm headed uh in there and uh so I'm looking forward to that great great all right Brandy um thank you so um a couple of things one one thing that I was thinking about um I had seen a post on one of the Myriad of bulletin boards on Facebook um that was talking about you know leash issues dog leash issues in the town forest and um the post was basically saying oh the town should you know enforce and you know it there's a myriad of issues with enforcement because you have to be in the right place at the right time and you know other things but it got me thinking a little bit about um you know how we communicate our leash laws and what the ramifications of dogs being off leash could potentially become because we see that when we when we have dangerous dog hearings which are um by far in a way the most awful thing we do yeah because it ruins everyone's lives um and it's it's difficult so um I wanted to see if the board would um support kind of like I'm happy to work with like our Communications team and trying to put together some social media posts some information out there about just just letting people know what they should be doing and what they should be aware of because we're not going to be able to enforce every single offleash dog but we can help communicate what the ramifications of that could potentially be um and what to do if what to do if you're bit what to do if your dog is attacked what to do if um you know like because there is a process in place to to reach out to animal control and file report so just making sure people are aware of it so if if the board and Michael were supportive of that I'd be happy to kind of work on that a little bit do do you want to be on the agenda for the next meeting to discuss this or well just let us know I guess because I think this is important enough it should be on the agenda when you're ready to discuss or whatever I think you know so sure so just let us let us know when you're ready but that's I mean that sounds good to me I just think I think the more information we can put out there the better and then um you know I I I think people don't think through I don't think people understand no the ramifications if you know people are like oh my dog's well behaved I'm like well my dog's a sweetheart but but you know just once just once so you know and I would never let her off leash because she's a maniac but um but sh I think it's a great idea because I I saw that post too and of course people are like well if it's the state park you got to reach out to DCR and I would say that this applies to all property in Ashland right any of our open space you know stuff like that I would also recommend you touch base with Donna Walsh our Animal control officer she may have some information that so that you're not recreating it yeah she may have some information or that she has access to from the state or something like that also you want her to buy into or you know whatever we put yeah absolutely she should like understand and okay F discussion yeah okay so but I think you know if if you guys are supportive of that we can do that and then put it on a future meeting actually okay thank you um and then the only other thing I wanted to just say was we had um we closed out Corner Spot with Fall Fest this last weekend and um there were I don't know know how many people but hundreds of people at fallest I saw the picture 400 um the Drone pictures were amazing that's what so thank you Paul Paul did the Dr pictures I was wondering who the who the Drone who the Drone was controlled by um so I just wanted to uh thank um Beth Reynolds and U Melissa Hayes for a really great season at Corner Spot um and then you know we've seen so much success come out of Corner Spot and has just become a real Community Place not only for these sort of signature big events but also for movie night and for um cultural things like the ashin Indians um use use Corner Spot and The Mom's Club and so it's really become this this major Community spot so just wanted to thank them for all their hard work this this past season also the Ashen Farmers Market is closing out their regular season this next Saturday and I just wanted to thank all the volunteers in the board for all the work that they do all the high schoolers that show up um exceptionally early in the morning to set up the tents and uh deal with us cranky people at that's great uh at me so um and then also just there's trick-or-treating happening next week here in town hall and and around um so next Wednesday from what 4: to 6 um yes and if if you don't mind just go ahead it's it's actually being um expanded a little bit from what we've done in previous years so kids will come here and they'll get a pass that they can then use to go to Subzero uh Crossroads physical therapy and get candy and treats there and then end up at the Ashland Public Library but um I would encourage you between now and then to go downstairs um and see what uh what the finance team has it's got to be Britney oh downstairs I'll to do that that's tonight after the meeting we can go down there so just wanted to wish everyone a happy happy Halloween and and uh come on out to town hall in the the general downtown next week it'll be it'll be a fun fun time so that's it for me great thank you Joe thank you Mr chair um couple of quick things uh this past Saturday uh yolander and I uh worked the farmers market needless to say it was a great day with no rain which was the first one in a long time and um some of the concerns that people had um when they came and spoke to us on the uh at our table um had to do with some uh Street um conditions uh on Green Street and hildo Road area some of the ruts and uh turrets that were they were concerned about because especially on Green Street there was a deep drop down there and they were worried about that area yeah the back area there uh be Green Street is that right off of um the one that the area I know it's real steep yeah right where you hit um the road H yeah they they were concerned about that okay there there's a construction site there they're building a home there right um how they able to get a home in that little section of property that's I'm sure they got a special permit I'm sure anyway um housing housing I know housing uh there was some sad War concerns uh gentleman came and was a little concerned about some of the sidewalks downtown and uh it it wasn't funny but it was the way the way he made his made his concerns but uh it was we we understood and we told him that some of these things are on a uh you know a list of the B to get everything done and resolved so he was he was specifically Cherry Street yeah no sidewalks on Cherry no sidewalks on Cherry it's on the list yeah and we the explanation was provided but I don't think he was satisfied with the explanation but it was provided anyway um and then um a young uh couple came in uh with their with the young children you had just left and I wish you were there but uh they were worried about uh speed around town especially in some of the uh developments and the cut through uh in Algonquin uh was a concern for them with they live down in a condo area and um I said you know it's one it's it's a private area it's posted 25 mil an hour but you know we'll talk to uh Chief Rosy and make sure we can you know get some you know visibility down there with traffic and they were very pleased about it and they they were thankful and they were happy about it um I'll put this up uh this is our annual Town Halloween parading party it's going to be a third Thursday this year um first kids nights out is the Friday before Halloween this year and uh so that so we had to change everything around which was which was that's not a problem with us that's always a great event and uh you know having having worked it a number of years years ago I'm sure it's just as great as it was back then as it is now and um so uh 6 o'clock to 8:00 is the uh the time we meet at uh Montenegro Square and if it's good weather we will parade down to the new mindz school I still have to find a path to make sure that we don't cut across anything that's being worked on uh so we'll everything's pretty fced in fced in right now so yeah so we'll probably go up to the main entryway with the sign is and go that route yeah so that's I think that's what we'll do and everybody gets uh boie bags they get apple juice they get uh Duncan munchkins and and all the good things and first first first and second uh Place prizes and different age groups get uh $25 gift certificate to Target and moms and dads if they get dressed up too they get U there's a costume uh award for them and it's a $50 gift certificate to uh brenham's men oh good so you know so if you can do it that would be great and uh lastly I would just like to say that um I just I I get concerned about what's going on in this world and I and I and I pray every night that this gets resolved and cooler heads prevail as I worry about not only my children but my grandchildren and um you know so and we all need to worry and and hopefully cooler heads prevail and we end up in a world of love there was a sign I saw it said why do we wish people rest in peace when we should be living in peace great thought and I'll leave at that thank you Joe thank you a couple things so I'm actually going into Boston for my MMA policy meeting this Friday which should be good and we are going to be discussing the governor housing Bond bill so we've got some details on that so our next meeting I'll I'll bring that uh discussion back and where things are with that uh next week on Thursday we have our Metro West Regional collaborative Trails meeting this should be a really good one it's uh taking place at luring Arena um if people are interested they can either email me and I can forward them the invite it's a discussion about the trails and how they're connected not only in our region but through the Massachusetts and how they're going different places Framingham has made some real progress in their connection to the Bruce Freedman Trail North so it should be it's always a great event to hear what other communities are doing what time is it when is uh I believe it's 8:30 to 11 8:15 to 11:30 on Thursday the 26th next so I'll forward my invite and that's and that okay thanks and that's an inperson it's an in person yeah because what they do is they have a discussion and then if you have the time they're going to take people on a walk of the new part of the trail in Framingham okay sounds interesting and then the last thing is I'm on the board of both the hopkington Center for the Arts and the Metro West YMCA and they have partnered for an Halloween event called The Haunt and it is a haunted town called Dead Woodville it is taking place at the ropes course at the outdoor YMCA and it's not super scary it's it's a performance per se as well as some scary things but nothing too scary this is its first year the price is pretty pretty low for what you could what you'll get um it's you can either go to the hopkington Center for the Arts site or the Metro s YMCA site or you know you just look for the haunt and it should be a lot of fun and if you go you will see me there but I won't tell you where okay that's funny so I will be there Friday I'll be there more than just Friday and Saturday but the the tickets are available for Friday night Saturday night and Sunday and on Sunday they have a familyfriendly version the first hour so 5:30 to 6:30 so if you don't really like scare but you still want to go to it this interesting that you can go a little bit earlier um so cool no they will not make kids cry I mean it is recommended 12 and up but the familyfriendly version a little bit younger but they do they should be it's not really conducive to strollers cuz it's literally in the ropes course so you're walking through the trails and through the ropes course and the ropes course is used so I'll leave it there there is no rain date if it's pouring down rain it won't happen but even if it's drizzly it'll be happening yeah yeah what's the day done is it did you say it's multiple the yeah it's three nights the 27th 28th and 29th starts from it's from 6:30 to 10: the last walk through starts at 9:30 that's interesting okay and Sunday it starts an hour earlier and like I said it's a kid-friendly EV event and uh I'm glad some of the things are Digs at Hopkinton and N us that's good all right very good if you go through it they deserve you'll see that elevated bike lane so the uh the dangerous streets I was I was actually told told that because of the new configuration in downtown hopkington their public their emergency vehicles cannot get through oh because of the fix not yet so anyway that's wild yeah I made the I made the mistake of driving up 85 to Hopkin in center today and the traffic is backed up all the way down the hill there they got it worse than us they're still doing a lot of we're going to get ours done before theirs yeah well that's great I'm not going but I'm just generally after that Legacy Farms their traffic's tough yeah yeah anyway that's all I got all right thanks Yolanda I just um just a housekeeping thing um in December I just wanted to just at least touch on our December meeting schedule so you know usually we're the first and third traditionally we have we considered not meeting twice in December so right now we're scheduled for December 6th so um what's the thinking should we just keep that one date for December and not schedule anything else um you know with the thought that if something comes up we'll we'll meet but is that sound good to everybody that makes sense rather than trying to shift it and you know people have other all right so just so for your planning so we'll meet December 6 and right now we don't have any other schedule for December okay um the I um Micha totally fine yeah all good you can live without check my calendar now yeah right um the uh MBTA uh commu rail committee and the um which I chair and the sustainability Committee of the advisory bill um Advisory Board had a joint um meeting on think on Monday uh with um to to listen about the mbta's commuter rail electrification and schedule update so I we had a long meeting but I think um just a quick update they are serious about electrification or moving ahead on other lines are not really uh the Framingham Wier line is really just slated for uh what he called good repair um and improvements in the short term so there's no distinct electrification uh was my understanding but they are looking at uh the other big news was the locomotives are um that they all that they required I guess in the 70s and 80s are approaching end of useful life and we'll need wholesale replacement uh early in 20 2034 something like that so that's a big budget Capital Cliff that they're they're approaching but they seem to be um you know sincere about electrification moving forward apparently there's a new kind of diesel fuel which is a lot less carbon in it and less particulates which sounds great um and um and they did talk about the schedule a bit there was some kind of apologies for the way they implemented it without a lot of without enough information um and they are um and we talked about some of the issues with the new schedule which is kind of uh but we did uh did get a commitment from them to deal with us directly uh with The Advisory Board directly when reviewing the schedule and to increase their public Outreach about it in general and there if you remember well Pride brand Andy knows this uh I don't know if the others but you know trying to get the new schedule ahead of time was very difficult and um so that was something I said okay so what's the new schedule you couldn't find it so anyway but so that was just that's just a quick update so they did commit for better public Outreach and more uh discussion and then some review with The Advisory board so that was good um the only the other thing is um you know uh the upper Charles Trail implementation team is meeting tomorrow with the town manager or he's Michael's part of that of course and I think who else is is um and um Peter Alvaro and Jen great that's we got the All-Star crew so we're moving ahead uh on on that um so I'll give an update next meeting um we all got the notice about the Diwali event so kg is very good about inviting and telling us about things so that's uh November 5th so for us to think about um I did want to do a shout out to Carl and uh Carl hackinson and Greg wans for their Warren Woods uh event I was not able to attend but I heard it was very nice and it was great for them to to do that so um and the other thing was the ashin public library has is having an event tonight that we couldn't go to but um they they're a great crew and uh hopefully they're having a good event they also had their online auction oh did they yeah for romance books and things like that how to work out to I don't know I bit on a couple things I'm going have to see if I oh did you I don't know it ended at 8 so hope doing really well the first like day or two Happ some of the items went for some real money I was like wow yeah well that's something speaking of events there's the Town Forest um conference I think Saturday right yeah is anybody yep uh I any anybody go I know Michael's there m seeing anyone else attending I'm I'm not so seems like a good event so uh I did uh you know while we're talking about events I I have been suggesting to people that if they uh if they're holding an event and they want us to attend it doesn't hurt to send us an invitation yeah uh like kg's very good about that and like people may think oh I'm you know I'm doing a lot of publicity but we sometimes we miss things you know and it doesn't hurt to ask you know especially if you want a long speech from me you know we get invited to the flu clinics too oh that's good that's and I'm early yeah all right so I think um that's it for for me Mr chair I forgot to add one thing my bad on it uh just an update on the uh MB uh ta uh zoning group oh yes very good and um it was a very uh productive meeting and uh looking at the uh GIS maps that we've been utilizing through um DPW uh some of our work may not be you know as as rough as we thought it was going to be that's great to hear so uh at our next meeting we'll have more of a definitive group should we put you on the agenda or why don't you wait and let let us know give us another meeting to go through that and that way we'll have more definitive that's great you know answers questions yeah but it's moving in the right direction and uh we're very uh very pleased with how it's how it's going around now if ugc can uh pull through that would be even nicer yeah so that's it thank you all right thank you if there's no other item motion toj second all those in favor of adjourning I or adjourn thank you all thank you thanks J
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT YouTube / BPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education Meeting · passage 1
[Music] I turn that thank good evening everybody no it's just um I'd like to call the uh regular meeting of the Brookfield board of education for Wednesday October 18th 2023 to order um please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the FL of the United States of America and to the rep for it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all okay we have all seven members of our our board here today and before we jump into the agenda I'd like to say a couple of things about our membership uh first um we didn't do this last meeting and I and I kicked myself because I felt we should have and uh and I'd like to do it now um Sharon bhau who's been a member with us for the last two years um due to personal reasons had to resign after uh in the early part of September and uh and I just want to publicly acknowledge Sharon and all the hard work she did on this board of education and uh you know all of you see what we do here at meetings but that's the tip of the iceberg I mean Sharon served on multiple interview committees on uh Union negotiations on subcommittees and was always a vocal participant speaking her own mind at our meetings here she was a hugely valuable uh member of our committee and I think all of us uh will miss her um on this committee and we wish her well so offer any any the other board members anything they'd like to add to that okay so Sharon thank you I'd also like to introduce Mrs halah hanani who's joined us here tonight Hala um Hala um is uh we've met over the last couple of weeks um uh to appoint uh uh Hala to uh serve out the remaining two years of the term and for those of you who don't know when a um uh when uh somebody uh resigns from the Board of Education or any other board uh the remaining members of the board uh actually appoint the successor until the next election with the timing of what this was they had missed the timing for this this November's election so Mrs herani will serve until November of 2025 and uh we unanimously and wholeheartedly uh uh uh appointed Mrs herani who brings a huge amount of uh experience uh both life experience uh professional experience in education and professional experience in the business world uh to this board and uh had we had a fabulous interview with Mrs Sani so Hala welcome to the board thank you I'm really glad to be here thank you okay with that we are going to uh jump in um and our first item on the agenda tonight is the student Spotlight for Candlewood Lake Elementary School Dr bril would you like to say a couple of opening remarks thank you Mr Beldon um I'd like to First invite Dr peps saski up to get ready for introductions of uh his team coming up here um and this is not only the first Spotlight of the new school year but it is the first ever historic Spotlight of Candlewood Lake Elementary School so Mr Dr excuse me pep sasi please take over thank you and along those lines it will be the best CS Spotlight ever so uh I reached out to staff and I said it's it's C's time to do the spotlight and one of my we call them super staff because they are all superstars D Pearson who is amazing getting a little choked up de you're so amazing and I'm out of breath uh so de who models you know we talked about the Brookfield se de models that on a daily basis and had this amazing opportunity for collaboration with the upper school and the lower school and we're always looking for those opportunities so without further Ado D Pearson to introduce you and your crew and the awesome Media Center book buddy extravagant that you've [Applause] created right I'm short I'm G to move this down um thank you so much for having us I do want to go through I believe we have a little slides we have a few slides that I'll put through um as as we're speaking today first of all I wanted to say thank you for having us here thank you for everything you've done to get us this amazing new beautiful school it's fantastic um my friends that are here with me today we have you guys going to introduce yourselves right we have Anna Clifford and what grade are you in Anna uh I'm in fourth grade Okay evan Jack and I'm in fifth grade Elijah heing and I'm in fth gradey and I'm inade our wonderful new primary librarian Nicole Guerrera who came from the high school thank you for giving her to us she's fantastic um actually has parent teacher conference is tonight with her daughter so she was not able to be here but she really wanted to um so what we did is we tried to find a way that we can make our huge building feel more like a like small neighborhoods that do things together and one of the great ways we can do that is in the media center because we have this stairwell that connects our spaces so Nicole was struggling with how to get Littles how how to get the little kids book shopping and how to do it nice well what if I bring my upper grades down we have the same schedule I'll bring a class down and we'll start a little book buddy program well it really took off I've got phone calls from parents I've got emails from parents and teachers saying this is the kids can't stop talking about it they absolutely love it so to in tell you a little bit more about it Anna is going to tell you what we are doing an I wanted to come over here I I'm going to kind of slip through slides while you do that we are going downstairs and helping the kindergarten first grade and second graders shop for books teaching how to use a shelf marker learn where books are in the new library and how to check out a book and reading with our buddies next we have Evan who's going to tell you how we are doing our program we are we go downstairs and wait on the stage we meet our buddies and introduce ourselves we ask them what type of book they would like and then we help them find it we are trying to we try reading some to see if they like it or not before we check the books out then we take the Shelf markers and either check out the book or look for something else all right now now Eli is going to tell you why we decided to do this program it's great to be able to help someone else with book shopping and reading it's a big school and a big new library it could be scary and confusing if you had to do it alone it helps us feel connected to each other it it teaches us responsibility when we help someone else and finally Elena is going to tell you about some of the results we've gotten and the reactions we've had to the program um so I think that the little kids really like it and uh I'm noticing that having someone older than them is is going to make it easier for them and U make them feel more comfortable in the new library and I and when the Buddies read in funny voices I think it makes the reading fun for them I think the coolest part about having about being a buddy is um in the hallways or whenever they see you they smile and they wave and they say hi and it makes the uh older kids feel appreciated and important does anyone have any questions for the kids about what we're doing does anyone have any questions for the kids about what we're doing how do you become a book buddy how did how did you get recruited um there you go we're usually in a line and whoever comes up next they um usually um pick a Budd that's next in line so we we've been doing it as whole classes so if I have a fifth grade they might pair with a first grade or a second grade it's wh whomever our schedules align with Cole and I um and then let's see no you guys are so your fourth grade is your we have first grade you have a first grade kindergarten kindergarten your kindergarten and Elena what about you a kindergarten kindergarten and okay so I'm gonna ask a question what's the biggest challenge you've had so far sometimes they don't always come up to the microphone yeah sometimes they don't always know what book they want so we don't we're not used to like the library down there so we have to look through look for the Shelf markers and Elena what else I bet you have something to add to that um so sometimes they have they can pick a stuff animal and um sometimes while we're reading the book they ask if they could change their stuan get up and um and um sometimes um they forget where they put their book uh their shelf marker or um they don't put it in and then they forget where to put their book bag did you have something Anna I think it's a little hard because it's a new library and you wouldn't know where any of the books are you have something to add um and also um the kids um sometimes choose out two complicated books for their grade and um they don't know how to read it except they still choose it anyway maybe mom or dad will read it at home right yeah and by the way everything the kids generate everything they said today today were those were their words that they generated just with some questions that I asked them so I've I've got I always tell people I have the best job in the world I love what I do every day and this is why are you guys having fun all right can I ask one more question sure what are some of the favorite books that you recommend to the younger students we get a lot of um dinosaur and Lego books so um Mo Willams and the pigeons the like that don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus um I think they mostly choose short books like elephant and piggy um usually they pick um my book buddy picked um Lego or space and now they the little littles want to know when they get to come upstairs and shop and I said when you're in third grade all right thanks guys you did a great job thank you guys great job Candlewood Lake Cubs nice work on the first Spotlight thank you D you know when we design that and I remember you guys first uh brought us a picture of what the libraries would look like with that internal stairwell I you know it's amazing how quickly that has connected the upper and the lower it is it really is amazing and and kudos to miss Pearson because she was a big part of we have mentioned over the years user groups and so our teachers working to help design the school and give input to The Architects D was incred part of of the upper and the lower Library so thank you Dave great job thank you guys another another round of applause for the guys all right next up on our agenda is public comment um the Board of Education welcomes public comment each speaker has up to three minutes and for those of you were speaking I got my handy dandy little hourglasses I don't I don't go crazy on it but it's a visual cue for whoever's speaking uh um at the start of every meeting we have a maximum of 20 minutes allotted for a comment on any item that's included on the agenda and at the end of every regular meeting we have time that's allotted for any item that's within the board's broad jurisdiction um which and and that would include any overflow time if we needed to um discussion of school individual School Personnel individual students or individual members of the board is prohibited so we have two people signed up and uh I will call you up to uh make your comments and uh and I just need your name and address before you address the board so first us up is Omar good evening my name is Omar Nar and I'm a freshman here at Brookfield High School today I would like to add advocate for a long awaited change in our school calendar including and as a school holiday in all Brookfield schools and are two significant religious and cultural holidays celebrated by 1.8 billion Muslims worldwide marks the end of Ramadan a month of fasting prayer reflection and expressing support for the less fortunate a feast celebrate sacrifice and obedience to God I believe that recognizing and celebrating and as a school holiday is a matter of religious accommodation and an opportunity to promote inclusivity diversity and an understanding within our school Community it is important to acknowledge the diversity within Brookfield Community we live in a society that values and celebrates cultural differences our schools should create an environment where every student students feel respected and includ included regarded of their regardless of their background or beliefs recognizing and as a school holiday is a step towards demonstrating our commitment to diversity to diversity and inclusivity neighboring towns such as Waterberry Bridgeport Trumbo and Fairfield have already adopted these as school holidays other states have also implemented this holiday including New York and New Jersey making and school holidays will send a powerful message to our school students and their families that the religious beliefs and that the religious beliefs are respected and valued this creates a sense of belonging and encourages a positive relationship between the district and the Muslim Community it shows that we care about the well-being of all berkfield students and their ability to practice their faith without feeling excluded or burdened by academic responsibilities additionally having and as a school holiday can be seen as an education opportunity just like other religious holidays such as Hanukah Rashana and Christmas it allows students of all backgrounds to learn about this holiday's Traditions customs and significance it promotes cultural awareness and understanding by learning about and celebrating different cultural religious holidays we equip our students with a broader perspective and the ability to interact with people from various backgrounds with empathy and respect I understand that some may be concerned about the potential impact on our school calendar however it is worth noting that we already observe various holidays and breaks throughout the year for different cultural and historical reasons I believe adding and to this list is a matter of fairness and continuation of our tradition and of recognizing and celebrating diversity I believe recognizing and as a districtwide holiday is a step in the right direction it aligns with our community values of inclusivity and diversity promotes understanding among the students of Brookfield and sends a message of regard to the Muslims within our schools let us Embrace this opportunity opportunity to strengthen our community and encourage a more inclusive learning environment for all thank you thank you okay our next speaker is uh Mariana good evening my name is miam Aziz I am a youth leader at the alh mosque Omar and his family attend I'm an author poet and member of the E Coalition me Omar and many of the students today in your school district are second generation American Muslims born after September 11 my generation is still haunted by this horrific attack and we have to endure fear anxiety and emotional distress starting from as young as Elementary School we feel a deep otherness in the way we are treated and the racist remarks that are constantly being made leading to Muslim Students wanting to hide and creating a struggle with their identity the rise of islamophobia and bullying and hate my brothers and I faced at school LED my parents to homeschool us after we attended a few years of school at elementary level I found myself at the age of 11 wanting to dismantle bullying I used my words to author a children's book and visited many school libraries including here in Brookfield and towns nearby to read to children and teach a message of kindness and inclusion unfortunately the horrific war in the Middle East and the constant stream of news is contributing to a rise of hate and islamophobia that has made our parents more than ever before concerned about our safety since some of our children are seeing an increase in of bullying and hostility from peers across different school districts a six-year-old Muslim boy in Chicago was murdered with 26 stabo 2 days ago by his neighbor with law enforcement characterizing this as a hate crime another man was charged with terrorism on October 16th for threatening to hunt down all Arab and Dearborn with all of this animosity recognizing the two eids as school holidays goes beyond simply accommodating religious practices it provides an opportunity to promote cultural awareness and understanding among students of all backgrounds by celebrating diverse holidays we encourage dialogue and an environment of inclusivity allowing students to learn about different cultures and traditions and nurturing and appreciation for diversity also also research research shows that students are better positioned to S succeed academically feel a sense of belonging and retain a healthy state of well-being in school climates that Embrace students diverse backgrounds schools across the US are increasingly moving to recognize Eid as New York City was the first big city school district in 2015 to close its Public School in observance of the holidays other districts in New Jersey Florida Cali California Philadelphia Vermont Ohio Missouri and many other states began to recognize the holiday as well Connecticut is not an exception with Fairfield Bridgeport Trumbo Stamford Norwalk and Waterberry all taking off for both Eid holidays the E holiday has been recognized in many districts as far as back as 1990s when schools closed for the religious occasion in Detroit the Brookfield district has been exemplary in the past in being inclusive generous and comp passionate Brookfield students of the Leo Club worked with a youth at the alhada Islamic Center not more than 10 minutes away from this high school to help refugees in Connecticut Brookfield was one of the first towns in the area to welcome refugees and help them resettle in the early 80s the Muslim Community in the Brookfield area would gather at the Brookfield Library to prepare before any of the four mosques in the area existed the character traits of leadership that Brookfield showcased could build a world of peace that is needed now we urge you to continue showing leadership of kindness inclusion and understanding by considering the eat holidays as off in your school district thank you thank [Applause] you okay um we will be coming back to school calendar as a topic on our agenda later um so um we'll we heard you so um all right so Ava you ready to give us a report hi is this on I hope everyone's doing well tonight I have a report to give about what's going on at the high school we kind of have a have had a busy month this past month so starting with some things that happened in the past couple weeks um seniors painted their parking spots um they came last week all the designs were pre-approved by Mr Buckley along with student government who help to coordinate this entire event I think it looks really nice um I didn't do I'm not super artistically inclined so I didn't do my parking spot but um my some of my friends did it and they really enjoyed it um on October 6th the senior class went on a trip to Lake compounds um our class advisers Mrs how and Mrs negre coordinated this event it was a lot of fun and everyone had a really good time um we had the club Fair a couple weeks ago too which was another great successful event um all the clubs that I'm in we had a lot lot of new memberships and a lot of clubs are using like QR codes and other types of Technology um to have people join their group me or join their Google Classroom um in an easy and convenient way so some events that are happening currently are coming up this week is Spirit Week um our themes for this week are USA day twin day today was on Wednesdays we were pink pink out for breast cancer awareness um Adam Sandler day and blue and gold day um on Friday we have our pep rally at the end of the day that's always a great school spirit event all the sports do some games and everything um also on Friday night is the homecoming Carnival before the football game um some clubs will come and do little small booths with little games or fundraisers there's usually a dunk tank um with some teachers and the homecoming dance is on the TW October 28th at the am room the tickets just went on sale um a lot of seniors including myself are really busy with college applications but we have a great counseling staff we have a college and career counselor Mrs Usher who's a great resource I know she's meeting with students back to back over the past couple weeks um along with the rest of the counseling department who's just getting all the letters of recommendation and transcripts all in line for everyone um some things that we're all adjusting to with this start of the school year um even though it's somehow already been like a month and a half um the new school start time we're getting some feedback from students some people really like it um some people don't love it it's really mixed feelings from what I've been hearing from students um cuz I know it gets difficult um with everything interfering if they have Athletics or work commitments um the roof construction finished up a couple weeks ago so the counseling and social studies Wing is back open and the new field and track are all done the track was just they just had the ribbon cutting ceremony yesterday um in terms of Athletics we have uh our football homecoming game a home game on this Friday um and like I said last time I'm the senior captain of the dance team team so I can speak a little bit about that we're doing some fundraisers we're selling pom poms at the football game and we're doing a trivia night fundraiser too um we're doing a lot combined with cheer it's like a school spirit promotion so we're performing with them at the game on Friday and finally I can talk a little bit about the clubs I'm in I'm in National Honors Society so we're getting our year started off everyone's getting their community service opportunities in line and the National Honor Society does a tutoring program every year where we help students um who might be struggling in their classes so that whole program is getting coordinated we're learning all about um the importance of like having a good relationship with the student and just some tips on how to make tutoring successful um I'm also in Spanish Honor Society and we right now our current project we're doing a booth at the homecoming Carnival which is a Hispanic food sampler so everyone's making some foods and we'll bring them to the fair on Friday and finally I'm in the Brookfield youth commission which is more more of a government level School group um we're running the candidate Forum on October 24th um where we'll um students are able to have a little question and answer session we pre-approve all the questions beforehand um and they're able to hear from the people running for positions in the Board of Ed Board of Selectmen and board of Finance um and going along with that the other week Mr Banda presented a slideshow at ilt about just what our local government does to give some background um before this event and that went really well it was nice because it was a remote event everyone just did it individually in their own classroom projected on the board it was like a Google meeting so we didn't have to get coordinate getting all the students in one room and that went really well and I think that brings me to the end of my report thank you so much does anybody have any questions for any questions for Ava I have a question for the um meet the candidates is the youth commission coming up with the questions or is there an opportunity for people to submit questions yeah so um Mr dula who is one of the adult advisor on youth commission sent out a Google form to all the Brookfield students after the presentation about local government um and that had like a ranking of what students think are the most uh relevant or important issues to them that they want to hear from all the candidates and then students also had um the opportunity to say like specific questions that they wanted so from the data from that uh Google form we compiled like the most frequent questions or like grouped them together um in maybe a more broader range um so we just had a meeting today where we Consolidated all those and we have like two or three questions per board of AD Board of Select Min and board of Finance um for each of their designated responsibilities whatever the questions um aligned with great awesome I can't wait I have a question um aside from the Meet the candidates event is the youth commission planning or could they do anything about maybe encouraging students to tell their parents to make sure that they vote I we don't have any projects like that in the works but I think that's a really good idea um just getting involved because we do a lot about like youth getting involved with like Civic engagement and everything but obviously voting is such an important thing I think that would be really beneficial so I can defin itely bring that up at our next meeting yeah great great any other questions Ava thank you again for a great report no problem thank you so much for having me okay next up is written correspondence hi Chris Dickson and Melissa Jagger wrote regarding the board vacancy Anna preny wrote regarding a concern Shannon Riley wrote regarding parent communication Greg preny wrote regarding grievances Austin Montero wrote regarding a petition and the VAC VY process Andy Korea wrote regarding process concerns and advice on filling the vacancy and a foyer request Deborah C wrote regarding Sports Transportation issues and Christina Zimmerman wrote regarding school start times okay thank you uh next up is approval of board minutes I'll move that the board approve the minutes from the regular meeting on September 20th and the special meeting on October 5th and the special meeting on October 12th second okay it's moved and seconded uh uh any questions or comments on the minutes okay all in favor of approving the minutes please say I I I okay uh all right superintendent update Dr burill I'll turn it over to you all right thank you Mr beldin um so congratulations and welcome Miss herani very nice to have you here welcome um I also uh hope everybody noticed and I know Dr P alluded to it a little bit the uh really the exemplification of the Brookfield seas and portrait of The Graduate work from our strategic plan and uh just the uh all of our students tonight who spoke in all different capacities they're really incredible and a lot of great learning going on in our schools I'm so excited um couple of things I wanted to just touch base with you on tonight um as an uh update uh regarding our Brookfield Board of Education subcommittee our security task force we'll be be meeting on October 26 at the end of the month for our first meeting of the school year our really um main topics for that meeting um one will be um how we're doing with Candlewood Lake Elementary School as we open it up uh Staffing in general specifically Staffing in security and our SRO uh the police chief will be there the uh Kelsey our SRO will be there we're just going to have a nice conversation with Dr pep saski about that Mr Renda is also invited because we want to talk about um the evacuation plan for whiner middle school regarding iroy and some of the work they're doing over there with natural gas we want to make sure we're up to date on our plans uh in also related to security it's uh really happy to share that our Brookfield all hazards plan which is is a annual plan we need to update for the district and all of the schools this year obviously having the one elementary school so we had to build a brand new plan uh is complete signed off on by all of our uh emergency responder leaders in town and we'll be submitting that to the state uh quite soon um and we work directly with a consultant from the uh Department of Emergency Management and Homeland Security so we really have a well done and upto-date plan I thank our principles and Mrs gramling and Mr Caldwell for really working hard on that in addition to that I spent some time uh this morning at a uh emergency planning scenario event with Sarah Palmer our new uh uh crisis uh manager for the town and we were with police chief and Fire Chief and all of our First Responders and it was really a great meeting to make sure we're all communicating we went through a couple of scenarios so it was good opportunity to meet with those folks um and connect the school in with town planning a really exciting opportunity the districtwide PTO is being revitalized have to thank Mrs Newman uh the PTO president of BHS she's really spearheading getting uh all three schools together um in early November we're actually going to meet with the three principales and we're going to talk about some things that we'll talk about later today such as uh beautifying and updating our schools uh parent and student and uh faculty engagement and some other activities so we're really really excited about that um and I'm just so so uh appreciative of all their dedication because they're they're going to be putting in a lot of time and they're really enthusiastic along with our principles to move things forward uh Mr Roland our special ed director and I attended uh Brookfield cares Community Forum last week on Thursday uh there uh Mrs uh Sturm provided the ass asset inventory results that the board heard a while back from the asset survey that the kids uh took last fall and we really got a lot of good Community input as to some things the town could do or the town could uh students and families could Avail themselves of services from the town uh in support of those uh needs that are demonstrated in that particular survey so that was just really a nice event and I thank bill for attending uh in Brookville cares for all their dedication there um I'm actually right now it would be ho us to bring up Bill uh if Mr Roland could come up I'd like him to give a quick special education update pupil services update on strategic plan uh work for the Department itself and progress on uh the recommendations from the last correct report and let us know a little bit about what's upcoming in the next month sure thank you Dr Burl good evening members of the board um just to to start with um earlier this month we had our uh initial uh special ed PTO meeting uh septo uh right here in this room was very well attended with many parents um got a chance to meet and greet with many parents I haven't met and many parents I have met um we talked about concerns and questions they had we talked about future topics including strategies for for uh parents at home who have students with disabilities bringing in some guest speakers who can help speak about um behavioral strategies in general um the IEP process CT saids um and it was a very good give and take of uh ideas that parents had ideas that I had and just speaking to the future of collaborating with families and communicating with families and it was an excellent chance to have uh a large group of people in one room to kind of hear their concerns uh in general Also earlier this month during our professional development uh as it was noted in the CCT report in terms of professional development for um IEPs and IEP writing we began our year-long IEP quality training which is a partnership with that Advance we had two Consultants come in again to this very room with our special education department and walk through how to write appropriate goals and objectives they also folded in some of the new features in CT sets because as you know uh the state's uh IEP system switched from IEP direct which a lot of us use to uh CT saids that has a lot of updates on a regular basis there there are changes almost weekly that the state is giving us um talked about how to write more appropriate goals how to do progress monitoring data collection things like that which we're going to continue on in terms of professional development during the year the important part with data collection and progress monitoring is it gives our parents opportunities to see how their children are reaching their goals and objectives not just anecdotally but through trials of four out of five times uh the student will be able to read specific words or take a specific behavioral Choice that's appropriate and positive those things parents have been asking for in terms of I want to know how often it happens where it happens how it happens and through our professional development we're writing goals that will allow uh PPT meetings to be even more collaborative so that the the teams can share uh that information not just anecdotally as in your child's doing well in class they're doing really well what does that look like and so data collection was a piece of that um in terms of building visits uh as the correct report spoke about communication I'm in regular contact with um the principls as well as the staff and the teachers in the building it gives me great pleasure to go into classrooms and see the students learning and and engaging and in conjunction with that when I receive a call from a parent or um um speaking with parents at PTO meetings or just in even at the Brookfield cares uh meeting it's my ability to say oh I met your son I met your daughter I saw them in the class they were doing great doing this or this and it just gives me the ability to connect with parents more having a connection with their children in the schools that's also a piece of the of the CCT report that I've been um working on excuse me I'm sorry and finally the Strategic plan um earlier at the septo meeting earlier this month I welcome parents to join we have a group of parents that are going to be joining us next week for our uh initial meeting meting for the Strategic plan to lay out a framework uh a vision and kind of gather feedback on what the framework should look like going forward we have several teachers uh related services staff from all three buildings uh also joining us so it's going to be a great opportunity for us to get together and align special education plans with the existing District strategic plan so that's just my kind of a a brief maybe not so brief overview of of uh the last couple months since and in the month since um I presented to you last time so I thank you for the opportunity this evening and can you tell us about the next board meeting who's going to be here yes so so um spoiler alert at the next board meeting um we have Dr Coro uh who was here last year speaking about the correct program review the special ed District review she's collaborated with us on a second piece which you were aware of in terms of specialized program reviews in District and out of District programming um in terms of what we can do uh internally to not only uh assist and support our students in District but look at the out of District placements and what the satisfaction is for those placements as well as kind of laying the groundwork and seeds for what can we do to build some of those existing services in District again early days but for November 15th I'll be presenting more about what I spoke about tonight and Dr Corville will be presenting her report that uh I spoke about with her since uh I I was on board but in the last couple weeks it's become a draft form we're working through it and be ready to present it to you on at the November 15th board meeting thank you any questions for Bill while he's up here good all right okay thank you Bill thanks everybody uh next on my superintendent report I'd like to in uh invite up BHS principal Mark Banda uh while it is uh remains at the school level there was a book challenge right before the end of the school year um and Mark in the Mark put together a committee and uh he's going to share a brief overview of the results thank you Dr bril uh so we met uh on the book fun home a uh family tragic comic uh we the committee officially made its decision uh now two weeks ago I think or end of last week I think was when it was finally published um but we went through a similar process what we did with the previous book that was uh Rec up for reconsideration uh I convened a committee we did change the makeup of the committee this time around so there were some people that were the same from the previous one uh we also invited uh two different teachers and one different um student services professional somebody else came so we had three different people on the committee from where we had the first time around uh we spent time in the first meeting September 7th um orienting to the process and to the terms of what the challenge was uh about we went through the actual challenge itself and then distributed the book and set a meeting uh the second meeting was September 28th uh it was rescheduled from September 18th um you know because we had some water issues and had to leave the building early so uh that was why that happened on September 28th and then that was a a robust discussion uh and so we decided that we needed more time uh to continue the conversation so we had another meeting uh to continue the discussion on uh October 4th went through in detail the reconsideration Forum from start to finish um and then came up with our final decision we voted anonymously so the people could U feel comfortable the decision at that point I did not vote but the committee of six it was a five to1 decision five to ones saying that there we take no action and the book remains in the collection uh one person did say uh that they thought the book should uh be removed from the collection so I forwarded that information uh and also a report to the superintendent uh into the group that submitted the reconsideration report uh leaving it now at this point and there hands to determine if they would like to take the next step which would be to reach out to the superintendent to continue the process if they'd like to um and I'm that's where we're at a standstill at this point thank you much welcome any followup questions for Mark so I just want to according to our policy your decision stands unless it's further challenged correct correct that's why that's why want to make sure we're all clear thank you Mr you made a decision that's why I uh prefaced uh Mike before inviting Mark up here to let everybody know that it's at the school level at this point well it's not at this point that the the school made a decision yeah so that's so it's it's that unless there's a further challenge right so I just I got we got to make sure it's not viewed as just a step along the way correct right the decision we' like to have the decisions taken at the school level if we can I'm really glad that you brought in six professionals plus yourself into that discussion so and we'll have to see if there's a further challenge yep so so at this point the book does remain in the collection so thank thank you Mr B for the the overview um just quick question so the person that challenged they were told all this information and then Mr B sent it directly to the folks and they were told that if they had a further challenge to okay yeah they they're very aware of the process yeah so was you Mr BL you ran the committee because you didn't you didn't get a you didn't vote so I facil facilitated the committee so I'm the one who did all the the led the discussion asked questions went through the things that you know look in board policy and those sorts of things if there was a need to go to a like a tiebreaking vote then I would absolutely have done that thank you okay thank you all right okay have just a couple more items I wanted to give a uh overview of a couple of uh key items uh I think folks might be waiting with baited breath on regarding Candlewood Lake in terms of us getting ready to have it the project fully completed um as we know there's a lot of interior finish work that's being uh completed um and then the exterior grounds driveway parking lot there's still a lot of work that's that's going on there uh the first thing I want to let everybody know I'm going to walk through three three holidays that are upcoming it's some lines for us to remember things playscapes um are ordered manufactured and ready to be delivered um until the installer is on site you don't deliver the playscapes that's how that works it's all part and partial so the playscapes are um due to come to us Halloween week which is that dece uh October 31st November 1st that week um and then it's about a twoe installation process as we understand so I know Dave and the team are very excited over there the kids while they're playing in those areas I think they're imagining where the playscapes are they can't wait to be go get going on that uh secondly um in terms of the parking lot and driveway let's think about Thanksgiving when the asphalt plants close we are very hopeful that the um not only the debris clearing of the demolition of Huckleberry and there's only some foundation work left I understand probably about 10 work days of finishing up the demolition of the remaining Foundation um the drain work is being done the soft soils are being removed those kinds of things um then they really start on the parking lot build of that north parking lot um so that's the right side of the building for people who are picturing the school and the site um when the north lot uh is uh uh done curved and asphalted that plan is supposed to be prior to to Thanksgiving which is around the time asphalt plants close if we have a very mild fall that could go into the first week in December if it gets snowy and cold that they close earlier it all depends on the on our Connecticut weather so um that's the plan is I would love to see that done so we could have good clear areas for plowing in the winter but also have our faculty staff um closer to the building not have to be in that temporary Lot close that's a long walk in and also have a um larger and clearer path not only for buses but for our parent to pick up and drop off so that's that's the second piece of information the third piece uh is a lot of folks are asking when are we going to be able to get the public in there and and do a building uh dedication ribbon cutting which I can't wait to do I'm so looking forward to really having that formal celebration there are two really big projects in addition to the uh kind of finished trim work that's going on everywhere those are the bleachers in the gym and the main stairwell all that tazzo flooring both jobs require the uh the contractors to be there for multi mle days um with a lot of setup and it's just not efficient for them to set up and then break down and then have to reset up the next day while school is in session for evening work so those are those jobs are scheduled to be done over the Christmas break um my hope would be that when we come back from the Christmas break the uh the winter recess we would be able to um start to think about when we're going to schedule that building dedication um so th those are the biggies uh for um Candlewood Lake and then and I'm shared some things with Miss herani the other day Mrs herani the other day um we all know that we're going to have four new board members um uh for the December F uh December 6th Board of Education meeting after the election and so uh both Lisa and I worked with cab we've ordered the uh initial uh welcome board packet from cab um the principles are updating their annual uh organizational charts so it's very easy for board members to understand the whole Dynamic of the uh of the uh District um and we also have a lot of legislation that occurred in the last couple of years so we have a legislative document that we want to share with the board members as well so they could really see you know the things that we were recently implementing things that we might will have to implement because with with the budget coming up in the next fiscal year and then down the road another year or two from now what's what's uh coming down the Horizon so we want to make sure our uh board members are set up for Success ready to go because the first board meeting in December is a really big board meeting I uh present the budget recommendation for 2425 and as we know our budget is uh in in the area of $50 million that's a lot of responsibility for seven board members and we want to make sure we'll have joy and Rosa with us who are the veterans but we'll have uh Miss herani who just getting started and a bunch of new board members so we want to make sure everybody's ready to go um speaking of that just as a forecast for the evening there's a lot of reports that'll come out tonight the case load report the enrollment report the achievement report Capital planning report that we're going to go through tonight all of those feed into planning for next year's work and so that budget presentation in December will really be a function of what we start to talk about tonight so just I want everybody to kind of frame this a very important meeting in that regard finally it's not on the uh superintendent report but I do want to share that uh Dr man and I uh got to meet with uh the track coaches and Mr Baldwin uh Mr Conlin uh put some drone video together and took some pictures for us we got to be with the student athletes yesterday we christened with a ribbon cutting for the opening of the track the track student athletes were down there and they took their first uh ceremonial lap if you will so we're just so excited we thank the facilities committee and we thank the NBC for all the hard work on the locker room the field the track and that if you want to take a look when you get a chance the new concrete slab is down for the tennis courts as well so a lot of great work is going on then they got to eat pizza yes lots of pizza then burn it I saw that in the picture yeah and that's all I have for tonight so thank you for your time um relative to preparing for new board members and a big meeting on December 6th it strikes me that we should have a uh uh what do we call them a retreat ret a retreat in November so we can have the existing board with the new board members we could have there's going to be so many new board members it's chance to have existing like the board chairs walk through what does our committee do right so that is that they established new committees they're not walking in cold right um talk a little bit about foia with our our attorney get to know um the principal so could you take a to-do to start checking on date availability in November um that to do that and I would suggest that once we establish a date we can attend that uh that you reach out to all the candidates and check to see that they can attend and there are six candidates out there so we'll do the four of them will be elected okay I would also suggest because we did it when I first became a board member but that was we haven't done it since um is reaching out to Dan and see if he's available um because I remember giving him a lot him giving us a lot of really good advice in terms of like like what's legally our responsibility and sure that would be a great resource to have there yep yeah we just saw a plan to do it I just don't want to wait until after that December 6th meeting and you have some existing board members I mean I could picture Debbie talking about what do you do in policy and Mike talking about what do we do in Cape and it's a great education with some of the experience we have right um to walk through that with all the board members there both new and old right it's a nice transition Lisa and I float some dates we'll talk to Dan Murphy we'll get it all see we can get together in the next couple days yep that would be great thank you okay thank you any questions for Dr bro okay thanks everyone so we're move on to subcommittee reports um Mike you've got two of them so I'll let you just do both of them okay it'll be pretty quick too uh as the September 18th meeting uh was largely a presentation on the Desa results which we got at the previous board meeting so uh in is very in detail thank you Dr man for that uh very in-depth presentation the Des results were uh the inaugural Administration so there's one in September or sorry not September there was one in the spring there's going to be one in the fall and we're going to do another one in the spring uh the review of curriculum projects at the CLE uh the development of the ELA reading program K through2 and the three through five uh illustrative math programs being implemented that's going to sound familiar in a second uh the uh whiskin middle school projects uh more Ela from 6th 7th and 8th grade a review of non-fiction material uh units and a PE Wellness uh adjustment to the curriculum but based off the time frame of uh of the new school schedule now that the school is now grades 6 through 8 uh and then we had a presentation incorporating new text the AP environmental science and AP World History books that we approved environmental was a few Ms ago but AP was uh the AP World History was like two meetings ago and then we had one last week via Zoom uh and Dr man's going to go over a lot of that findings today so I'm not going to go into too de uh too deep a detail uh Dr man Dr farious sorry Dr man Mrs farious presented a preview on annual spring testing results SBA ngss and the SATs so covering the uh elementary school middle school and high school and then we got an update on the curriculum uh instruction the AP statistic textbook there is no update it's just going to be a new addition uh so that's that's nice that we're using a book that already is uh checks a lot of boxes uh we went next on professional development the professional development day was October 9th uh and major topics were pathway pathway again is aligning all of the schools elementary through High School in their curriculum and some specific illuster of math U professional learning uh for grad three for five bringing that back and that's the highlights okay any questions for Mike okay thank you Mike all right uh policy and Communications okay uh the policy and Communications committee met on September 20th um it was just Amy and I with Dr burill and Lisa gramling because uh Sharon had already left at that point and we did not have a new member so Amy and I trudged onward um we really spent a lot of time the bulk of the time talking about the two policies that are actually part of our agenda tonight so uh like Mike I won't go into too much detail now but we um really finished our discussion on policy 61 6251 survey of students we had been we had asked um attorney Murphy for some clarification on a couple points that we had been waiting for so we got that feedback from Dr burill and finalized um how we wanted to handle that policy so that's in the packet for tonight and then um we continue our discussions on policy 6563 School library media um in response to the petition that we received from Brookfield Children's Advocacy Council um we reviewed the information that we heard from Mr Banda and Miss um Jen Roa at our August 16th meeting and made a couple um adjustments to the regulation for policy 6563 which again we'll talk about later and then um Dr burill updated us on the ribbon cutting ceremonies and everything he talked about just a few minutes ago for clees and we um talked a little bit about public engagement efforts and the healthy school start times so that was it okay any questions for Debbie all right next is facilities Joy okay we met on October 1st so a lot of updates the GU swing roof here at the high school the RO is near completion pretty much finished up on September 27th we're just waiting for some exterior flashing which is expected any day now um interior ceiling tiles will need to be replaced oh your mic's not on oh mic's not on Joy sorry should I start again I'll start again so we met on October 1st um update on the guidance Wing roof here at the high school it's near completion it finished up on on September 27th we're just waiting for some exterior flashing which it is expected any day now interior ceiling tiles will need to be replaced and we should have an estimate for that soon and but we need to be really clear about where that money is coming from for this that the media center here uh we're looking to review the bid specifications with marks Cubo since the structural and roof work specifications drove up the price we're hoping to do that by next week some Capital project updates the bathrooms at the high school school and paving at the high school middle school is complete yay it's exciting uh security the high school wrapped up the door alarm project on October 1st and whis skiner was scheduled for the following day United alarm came out and installed the touch pads for the security door alarms uh the locker room here at the high school is nearly complete some mill work is needed some door hardware and lock cores have been ordered are and are in transit the boiler feed here at the high school it's finished and ready to be used update for CES CES the keys documents and reports have all been turned over to the town and some new business we reviewed the capital reports and recommendations also the 10-year Capital plan all these reports and recomendations were based on the review of the building conditions study provided by Marx a Cubo so it's important to mention that BHS and whis skiner are an overall solid condition with proper maintenance over time the buildings will continue to serve our community well so the focus moving forward will be on roof Replacements ceiling tiles unit ventilators funding for an engineering study for AC funding for architectural services for conceptual design schematics oil tank removal bathroom Renovations a rooftop AC unit to the BMS system and a boiler replacement so only a few things but Casey will uh go into more detail later in the agenda so I don't want to talk too much about it she's got a wonderful presentation to follow any questions for Joy we'll get those done real quick okay okay um so now that's it uh well let's do the consent agenda so consent agenda I will move that the board approve the items on the consent agenda which are new hires and resignations second Dr any comments on the consent I do not have any I just had a question um I see that for resignations only one is being replaced so the other Paras will they be replaced those positions or do we have anyone inter I can't give you a direct answer on that TR what I would tell you is there as as we all know going through these each month there's a lot of puts and takes so it could be a timing issue as we look at this in terms of alignment so we have position control and we're going through all of that but we could check that specific question for you um but I can't give you that answer right now okay but if we have an open position we typically po to fill it absolutely I was very excited to see Mrs stabil coming back oh yes you know I probably should say that so um there there is um and uh this has to do with uh you know our uh frankly our um teacher shortage in Connecticut and across the nation that we are able to weather because of the kind of community we are and um areas like technology and Spanish um or World Language I should say um and special education uh physics are areas that are shortage areas and very hard to find people uh in Brookfield thankfully uh we have um uh a u um a contract that's valued by those from the outside uh in terms of what is collectively bargained for teachers and so uh those folks who sometimes may want to return or are uh veteran teachers um it's still is a positive uh decision for them to come back to us or to transition from another District Maybe a little further east of our location uh and come join us so we're really excited to have Mrs back and uh you know when she was doing her paperwork I got a big fat hug and it was really nice to see her so she is starting quite soon right uh Dave over started she actually started she actually started that's right so we're really excited to have her there and uh we also just recently hired a veteran uh special education teacher that'll be joining us in the next couple of weeks to fill that uh the opening over at the elementary school as well so I should have said something thank you did we ever um consider asking teachers that have retired to come back you know kind of temporarily we sometimes uh we do sometimes have teachers who have retired who do come back and help us out in some of these interim areas uh most aren't looking for long-term uh placements temporarily they like temporary and if if they could have Tuesday Wednesday Thursday they really like that um but it's great to have them back when they come back and the kids love seeing them so and I don't know New York just um amended their regulation for enl certification MH um it's can you can have get a temporary certification because it's an area that is such in high demand I need so you just need to take the state test and if you pass it you can be certified in enl so I don't know if that was something that ktic is looking to Institute or there are there are some opportunities for cross certifications uh here in Connecticut to do just what you're talking about where you take the state test and are able to pass uh additionally we have something it's a process we have called a daap when a educator has um a particular degree or a particular speciality they can we can help them if we really want them to come on to our team we work with the state and they can provide a temporary certification while they work on their formal certification so we do have mechanisms like that in Connecticut do you have anything else to add I was just going to say that we actually have have we have two um teachers who just received their daap um who started with us in the very beginning of the year and we just got um the state must be churning out these daps in the last week CU we they got them all processed very quickly so yeah so so we do and those are in special education so we we're excited about those employees yeah so so we continue you know we're we're very fortunate we continue to weather the teacher shortage um there was just a news story The the other day I saw and um just here in Connecticut and uh our neighbor Danberry and some of even our other Suburban areas are still having difficulty filling positions and we're in a very fortunate position right now and just to clarify because I know sometimes we get into our jargony oh deap is District shortage area permit alphabet soup my apologies thank you Anna it's my shout out to Dr Mike any other comments on the this is the most comments on a consent agenda that I think we've had since I've been Mrs stel we're glad you're back there you go she heard us any other comments or questions all right all in favor of approving the consent agenda please say I yes okay um so funny all right um i' just like to before we jump into new business I'd like to make a a motion to adjust our agenda a little bit if you guys are okay um considering we have uh public speakers and family members who are here to hear about what we're doing on calendar I'd like to in respect for the fact that we have students here move that to the next item on our agenda from old business up to new business uh that's one secondly uh Item B under old business I'd like to move up into new the last item in new business the survey of students that's showing in here as a second read because uh we talked about it once before long long time ago I think we need to bring it back to being a first read and starting that process again so I'd like to move it up to new business as a first read if you're okay and then Amy and that's the only motion and then Amy uh uh on item G I think you when you make the motion note that it's a first read right on that one cuz it that wasn't in the draft motion um so a motion to move uh the calendar up to the next item and the item B to item I in new business second seconded and seconded all in favor okay so we're going to adjust the calendar here all right so next up is school calendar and uh Dr bril I'll uh let you give us an update from our last discussion sure so at our uh last meeting uh we presented the calendar just as a reminder for everybody we have a calendar committee uh that annually we work with made up of secretaries teachers administrators and uh others in the district we've received a lot of tremendous input and input from all of those groups is reflected on this calendar um the other anecdotal input that we had from families and staff was they love starting after Labor Day this year so we took all of that into account with our typical calendar um typical holidays uh typical breaks Etc uh PLC days professional development days and developed what what you saw last month um there was uh there was the only feedback uh from board members over the last month was to um put some color on the calendar for uh the indication of uh uh conferences and early dismissals those kind of things so uh Lisa thank you for finding a color that wasn't already used so we could discern um and that that's what we have uh and uh it's really with the board now to decide and this is probably a month or two earlier than we typically uhing the calendar forward we had the opportunity uh with timing this year so I thought we'd Bring It Forward last month so let me uh we had a public speaker this evening right two public speakers this evening thank you both for speaking to us um have has your committee had a chance to deal with this before it came to us on the board uh no we followed the the traditional calendar that Brookfield has followed I understand so you this issue had not been brought to you or the committee cor no all right so can I think we should probably forthrightly address that right and think about it uh with the right group of people and I I I don't know about you all but i' if we have time I'd like to table this and come back to it with after you've had a chance to digest this is that a fair approach yeah it just it would be helpful to get some clarity like what that would look like what would be the dates of the what would the dates in the 2024 25 I actually did look at it um the first eat holiday is April 9th which is the Wednesday before our traditional April break the second eat holiday of the year uh is June 17th is that correct is that correct which is after school dis for next year you're talking about yeah for the calendar that for 25 yep so April 9th is in the middle of the week beforeand so and then June 17th is after it's after the end of the school year unless we have snow days unless we have snow days or Plumbing days and in this I didn't have a chance since it was just left for us today do we actually have the dates for all the coming years in here um cuz it was a 22-year report I got to I got to I I will say it was a 22-year report that's great to have but I don't but there were no dates listed so um I think we hyper it by accident but we can forward you the actual link maybe like through email or something so you have the um website that has all the does it varies by year okay so I think you should send it to Dr BR because if the board asks I will bring it to the committee so thank you so yeah that'd be great there's also a couple things I would like to know um and I don't know if it's if we're privy to that kind of information um but I would like to know the proportion of our student population that may celebrate these holidays I don't know if that's information we could gather because we don't really collect that information the other thing I would like to know um and this is sort of talking to anybody out there that does celebrate these holidays um if it's more valuable to encourage our um District leaders Administration some people at the school to purposefully on these holidays um incorporate education about them culturally their significance if that's more meaningful to you um and of course I would also strongly support giving a every accommodation possible to anybody you know that um needn't be in school that day because they're celebrating um I would like to know if what would be more valuable to to the people that that do observe these holidays so in the Muslim um Community we the day we go to the mosque we meet people we meet family it's a day of rest and celebration so I think the Muslim Community would prefer I'm just from my personal experience having the day off and then if we had maybe like some sort of incorporation of Education the week before if that was something that you guys are interested in um just so that students would know what it is um that would be fine with us too but um also like if it's stated on the calendar the specific holiday and uh students have that day off I think a lot of students or parents that look at the calendar the school calendar will search up what the what the holiday is and learn about it a little bit about it themselves um yeah that's just my personal would you mind sending those comments over to Dr bur as well so that collectively when he talks with his committee he can filter that information up to us sure thank you thank you so I think to build off what Rosa said you know for example it's veterans say it's not right it's correct kind of a different but it's a similar comparison like it's just been very it's been great for the students to stay in school and learn about it and do all these celebrations and things like that to honor that day which is nice a nice way to um honor the and celebrate the the holiday also there was there was a lot of school districts that were mentioned I remember Trumble something down here Trumble Waterberry Bridgeport um maybe we reach out to them and how they hey we decide this because of or get their calendar get their calendar yeah it's in the news too can sear it in the news y yeah we ought to do it in a more formal way though I think how many school districts are doing it uh and what what uh you know how do they make the decision what uh deposit isn't the negatives right it's always it's always useful sounds like the board is going to ask me to do that formally I think I think you're going formally asked I'm going to be very candid um I might not have anything ready for next month uh just giving people schedules we will try but I'll do my best but I don't know that we're going to be able to have it ready for next month when do we need to finalize the calendar we've we've um approved this calendar in my this is my ninth year here I think one year it was in either February or late February early March very late but in another year maybe even last year November it was done so I mean it's really up to the board um well it would be good to actually also have the new members of the board be part of the desion process it's a calendar that they will live with so like if it goes into early December that doesn't bother me to tell you the truth so um good I'd rather do it right and uh and it was nice we had the bones of the the calendar bones of the C great good feedback from everybody else's feedback that starting after Labor Day and still ending on June 13th that's a that's a good calendar so sure um so okay and uh and we'll go from there all right okay happy to do so I will make a motion that the board table this item I just have one thing okay go ahead um tiny little thing for Lisa um I see with the new colors for conferences I don't see the purple conferences added on the calendar itself I see the green but the fall ones aren't in October and November yep you are correct all right okay good catch thank you arts and crafts good arts and CRA go scrapbooking after later tonight um I had the big box of Crayolas you have the big box of Crayolas you know the colors all right I make a motion that this item be tabled uh pending The Comeback on the um on the E and Al second all in favor hi okay we wanted to get that done so that students can go home get homework done and go to bed unless you want to stay but uh um please stay if you'd like and uh we will come back to this uh just watch our agenda um we will we'll discuss it at the next time we talk about school calendar thank you all for coming all right next up is the district enrollment report all right and this is an action that we receive a report from the superintendent anything have to be read in or I can start I want to make sure we're good okay so um annually uh as of October 1st um and it's October 1st in all of our school districts in the state because that's when the state likes us to take our snapshot in individual school districts for our student enrollment um we bring this to the board obviously student enrollment impacts is has the greatest impact on our staffing uh plans and our budgeting um and we typically have uh on this report four years um together for everybody to have a a little brief history to analyze and uh the board has had this since Friday in their board packet to take a look at um uh we also uh make sure that not only we do our school in grade enrollment we also take a look at um our students who are outplaced and take a snap snapshot students uh place out of District in addition to the high need areas of free and reduced lunch our multilanguage Learners and special education students so it's a comprehensive uh document that uh the public will be able to uh read uh online everything has been posted um so as you can see different than in years past uh Lisa and I uh worked on combining our older Huckleberry uh Center School and fifth grade data uh to make a Candlewood Lake report for everybody to take a look at and just did a compare by grade there you can see um and in total our enrollment uh right now is 1,16 students at Candlewood Lake Elementary school that does include prek that's 29 total more students in those grades than we had last year in those grades um at whiskin ear um you can see that we are um down to three grades so changed so I modified the whis skiner report from four grades to three and so you have your grade level comparison there and we're approximately from last year that the data isn't there but it's about 200 less kids per you know per grade so uh We've right sized whiskin at 591 students if we compare it to the three grades last year um it's uh it's less by uh by about 12 students and then at the high school we are very so we're pretty so we're up a little bit at the elementary level uh quite steady at the middle school level like I said we're down 12 students this particular year and um comparing just three grades not four and then at the high school um we're very steady we're only net down one student at the high school at 871 for our four grades at the high school um in on campus in total we have 2568 students for a net of 16 more students than last year at this time our students that are educated off of Campus uh is right now 29 students that's three less than last year um that number has always hovered around 30 um and again there's lots of puts and takes with students programs changing kids graduating those qualifying for uh necessary Services out of District uh etc etc um grand total students uh that the district is responsible for um is 2597 which is up 14 from a year ago um I do want to um before I get into the high the students who are identified as high needs it's important to know because we're going to talk about a kindergarten policy about that September one date uh uh date that the the legislation is recently put out for next year if in this year's and I'm just going to say it now and then we'll talk about it again current kindergarten class where we have 163 students if the new kindergarten legislation was applied this year where students couldn't go to school if they're born September 1st or later um that would be 45 students of our we looked at the birthdays of our 163 kids that's 27% of the kids talk about an impact on families and specifically our families that are planning for next year I'll talk about it uh when we get to policy there's a waver that's required in the legislation as well as an assessment the state has given us really no guidance on that we're waiting for guidance from the state department of Ed to help us all with that because bethl new town uh Brookfield we really shouldn't we should have similar things we're looking for we shouldn't have different assessments but at the end of the day the students are going to be our students no matter when they start so we need to be thinking they are Brookfield kids how do we best educate them and right now um we just don't have enough information so as we speak I want everybody to know as we look at enrollment there's there's not some automatic oh Kindergarten is going to be 27% less kids next year it's we have to plan differently and have less kindergarten teachers can't go there right now because the reality is there's a a very high likelihood that we will have those students with us through a waiver process through an assessment process Etc and parents certainly can make their choices all the way up to the child's seven years old so there's a lot to talk about we'll talk a little bit more about that but I wanted to mention it because enrollment is a big deal and it's a big number and like I said this is a big impact on families we're here to support our families and our students so we need to be mindful of that I'm going to jump into the bottom of the chart that I shared with you um in our high need area and these are uh State Department uh state of Connecticut identified areas the high need areas it's really important to think about the Dynamics of our community and how things have been changing um I'll start with our multilanguage Learners um we have 114 students identified as uh MLS this year that's up 16 students from last year which seems like a lot and it is percentage wise but the net that we're up because you need to think about frankly what a great job our multilanguage team does with our students with last year's number of 98 students we exited from the program 20 kids so 20 kids received Services last year they did so well we exited from a program so 20 went out 20 came in and another 16 is what you see there so it's a net 36 new students qualifying for services so that's a that's a huge it's 30% increase really net when you look at that so the the Dynamics of the community are changing so there's a lot of services there and we will be talking um about the the need for uh bilingual services in Portuguese because that language has also increased to 20 at kandlewood Lake and when you have 20 the next year you have to have a bilingual program so that's another piece uh to our planning for the budget uh you'll see that in the budget and priorities and assumptions document the next uh area I want to look at is free and reduced lunch um free and reduced lunch 6 133 students out of our 2600 are qualified for free and reduced lunch um that means their families are struggling and they're coming from uh struggling situations right now and uh that's up 70 students from last year so you could do the math on that that is a significant increase and we obviously know that language is a barrier to learning in a different language and certainly uh coming from an impoverished or challenging or traumatic situation is another barrier to learning so there's a lot of work we're doing with these uh particular students in addition to that um which is an interesting number that stayed steady is our students that are identified with special needs if you look at that over the last four years that number is really spoton uh in terms of identification 363 total students identified with special needs last year 365 this year an increase of two students um so there was a lot of talk about people uh through uh anecdotal thinking conversations that lots more kids because of the pandemic or any other reason we're qualifying that numberers stayed the same again students uh uh testing out students testing in and those kinds of things um so it's really really interesting when you start to look at these numbers so I just wanted to highlight a couple of things and I don't know if anybody has any things they ahas they may have noticed or uh questions they may have I don't know if we have the numbers do we have how many students are attending the magnet school like chog you know we could get that uh information for you but those students are not technically enrolled with us so they're not our students we have no access to their power school information or anything like that once parents choose for their kids to go there they're not our students AIS students when they come back they're they're our students again they're disenrolled and I guess it's helpful to know those numbers because they could come back yeah we can get those for I actually I want to think top of my chog might be about 13 kids there right now usually I couldn't tell you AIS off the top of my head though and then how many are homeschool I know you give us a report you'll get a home school report uh next month yeah it just seems pertinent to put that information on here yeah we haven't done that in the past but I certainly can get that information to you absolutely I wouldn't put it in our formal report because they're not our enrollment so but I think it's important that we have that in our budget book right as we you know bring forward our our plans okay thank you for that you're very welcome any other questions from anyone on the board on this or observations this is where we obviously derive class size and how we allocate staff so that's why it's so important to share this uh early in the year okay we'll move on to the next item uh next is special services case load the action here is to receive a report uh from Bill Roland and so as Bill comes to the podium um what's really important and we must acknowledge when I was sharing about the ident students identified with special needs as a a steady number what you'll see in the numbers that Mr Roland presents tonight is our case load numbers and our ratios really are are strong and that's because of this board's investment in uh people services and special education over the years I mean for a long period of time adding a special education teacher in a year a social worker recently whatever it might be and so you'll see um through this report uh again it's an annual report that the board receives and again it's about staff allocation and what we need for our kids we're really in a fortunate Place uh with this area of this particular department so bill please take it away thank you Dr BR and again I want to Echo Dr bur's sentiment that I'm great ful for the investment that the board has put in to our our special education services and programs as you can see uh as I'll go through the numbers um the case loads are uh appropriate and acceptable there's one area I want to explain and and that will be on on page two it seems disperate but it's not when I when I explain the the population there um the case loads across the board we'll start with with Candlewood Lake where um from preschool through K5 um you know case loads in in prek are 6.67 round off to seven um in K5 the the average case load is about 20 uh with six teachers our exceptional Learning Center which is a specialized program that includes both a K2 level and a 35 level with teachers with two teachers one for each level uh the average case load is 98 and these are high needs students uh with multiple needs um that are being um Serv not only through the teachers there but as you see through the related Services uh folks that I will get to as we go down the um down the list and finally again another specialized program at CES the social emotional program where there is one teacher with also multiple service providers uh supporting that classroom uh eight uh students and again High needs uh high intensity but also um very intensive Services as well so the the the case loads at at kandlewood Lake are consistent with the investment that the board has made and with the the mission and vision of the district as well as our need to provide uh high quality special education services to these to these students as we move to to whis skaner again you can see in in the 6 through eight level uh case loads are on average I'm going to round up to about 10 that's a really good uh case load size um given the amount of teachers and the the team-based approach in each grade level um that they can reach them and they can work with and collaborate with the general education teachers in terms of modifying and uh uh differentiating the instruction for those students uh in collaboration with the case managers again the exceptional Learning Center the ELC program at wisener one teacher five students again with with multiple supports of related services and Pars in the room uh again case lootus 5 one teacher uh and the SE program there again one teacher seven students but again as with candle as with Candlewood Lake Elementary these are high need students high intensity um requiring uh a more intensive approach in terms of time and attention and specialized instruction at the high school you'll see that again as we switch from a middle school to to the high school the the vision changes a little bit as case managers I was a case manager at high school for most of my career you know an average case of 16 is really acceptable because you're working with students in multiple classes you're working with multiple content teachers but also you're working in sort of a resource setting in order to help uh differentiate that instruction work with the the general education teachers on how to modify that in their classrooms uh and different models and approaches so again talking uh from a perspective of somebody who once had 30 on their case load uh 16 is an acceptable uh and reasonable amount for uh case managers to be able ble to navigate collaborate and and work with the related service providers and the general education teachers and the life skills as with the ELC and social emotional programs in in whiner and CES one teacher six students again High needs multiple service providers multiple needs being addressed excuse me so those case loads for teachers are remarkably consistent and in in line with what we would expect again given the investment that the board has made we move on to the related service providers uh speech language Pathologists and uh speech language Pathologists work in a variety of contexts including uh working one-on-one with students in some cases working in a social skills group and collaborating with uh social work or school psych uh in order to kind of work on the expressive and receptive language that that students use on a daily basis uh their service time can include that one-on-one it can also include uh pushing into a classroom and it can also include collaboration time so for the students at CES uh case loads are around 24 that again is reasonable within the scope of what a speech language pathologist does on a daily basis in terms of who they're working with it's not necessarily working with students all day as a as a classroom teacher might but pushing in collaborating working in small groups uh and so it varies on a on a daily basis and the case loads reflect that as well uh at whiner again two um speech language Pathologists for a case load of 36 as students move um up from from elementary into a middle and high school uh often times speech services will be reduced or the time will be reduced in terms of you might have a larger case load but again smaller chunks of time with those students As you move on same piece with the high school where we have one and a half and again case loads of 28 and 20 and I want to mention this as I move through this um these are these case loads are done collabora collaboratively um with each other and with the supervisors and with with program staff in order to divide up what who who is who's has the most need who's better suited with one versus the other and so making an equitable uh division of these case loads is also part of making sure the student students get what they need and that one staff member is not overloaded in in favor of another and I say that as we move towards um school pyes and social workers so School psychologists perform a variety of roles as you know in buildings uh not just performing uh trianal and referral testing initial referrals but also working on counseling and again School psychologists are collaborating with supervisors principes case managers counselors um and they they provide a variety of services to a variety of constituencies within the building including the students um including observations including data collection including kind of professional development working with teachers on strategies that might work for a student um reinforcing Behavior plans during um kind of collaboration time things like that so if we look at the at the um number of staff and the number of students who either have IEP special education counseling or 504 counseling as an accommodation um the case loads are again ranging from 28 to 44 um with 32 uh and a half divided at CES I want to speak for a second to the districtwide uh school psychologist at the botb she is not only considered a bit of a floater in terms of the seven that she has within District but she's also uh helping across the district and she's also the person that I turn to for District uh referrals testing and and checking in on the services there and collaborating with the ad of District placements so while it seems that her case load is low it's really not in terms of the the services that she provides uh both districtwide and to our students who are in out of District placements so I've talked about this in in multiple ways on page one and half of page two if you look at the social work um division in CES it looks incredibly disperate that there is that it's it's uneven uh but it's really not and I'll explain that when Social Work consult or or uh one-on-one counseling the 110 is for students who have um I'll give a range you might see a social worker once or twice a week 20 minutes 30 minutes at a time for specific goals and objectives in your IEP the 38 are the more intensive students uh so the social worker at CES that has 38 those 38 are the ones that I mentioned on page one which are intensive need um behaviorally challenged um in terms of needing more intensive Services more frequently so if we look at the 110 versus the 38 again this was done collaboratively so it's not like we divided up and said you get 110 you get 30 it's based on need based on what the students need and based on the program that programs that are available to the students there and how we can best um service and provide services to these students uh in an appropriate way whis skaner there is there is one with a case load of 26 and at uh at the high school again divided pretty evenly 24 and 26 but again I think when you talk about elementary um you're also talking about students who are newly identified uh Services might be more um there might be more services discussed at that point as students get older some will still require the multiple Services some might not so you might see a a a waning of services based on need at that point as well finally um some of some of our unsung staff members who do an amazing job uh OT and PT occupational therapy and physical therapy I just draw your attention for one second to the uh acronym Koda I know Dr bro was talking about alphabet soup before and I if I laps into jargon I apologize in advance Kota is certified occupational therapy assistant they work under uh the occupational therapist in terms of providing support and in terms of providing those services so that we you know we have those Services being provided under the guidance and supervision of an OT without having an extra OT in the budget or or uh required through IEPs the Koda is is entirely appropriate um for these Services um sometimes they are less intense sometimes they are the ones that require student that might require more of a consult and again in a lot of cases with OT and PT it might be a consult where you're working on how the availability of services would look like in the classroom what can a teacher do um so in terms of direct service and in terms of indirect service the case loads for these are also appropriate across all three schools and including a coda who can be um divided between the two schools in terms of providing those services that are almost and I say this in terms of just numbers spill over but they are getting the same quality services that other students are getting from the from the OT officially and finally uh our physical therapist has uh is a point8 but has a case load of 31 again it's a combination of direct service indirect service and consult so again these are numbers that are within range and speaking to directors in other um in other districts um we are fortunate and I am grateful that the investment that's been put in to these services and these staff members have resulted in acceptable an acceptable range and we are not struggling to try to figure out how we're going to manage uh an explosion of of new students we're not there we have a consistent case load and in terms of um the ability of the all of these staff members to collaborate within each building and be part of the team and as you know that's something that we've wanted to make sure happened more frequently this year and uh the collaboration that I've seen as I go into the schools and visit with the principles and the classrooms um these are all folks that are working very hard to support our students and doing an admirable job of providing the services they're uh mandated in their IEPs thank you Bill right open questions goad so I just want to be clear so average case load is that how many students they're servicing or are they considered or you lumping that in with the case management could I ask a clarifying question which which case loads would you be looking at because I can tell you well in general any well so you're saying yeah so for a teacher uh if if I'm if I'm a special education teacher my case load is 20 I have 20 IEPs that I'm working on and collaborating with uh it could be at CLS it's a grade level or it could be I'm pushing into classrooms or I'm co- teing so in terms of a case load for teaching that's what that would look like right so oh okay so a speech language pathologist so yeah that and that's that's where it gets a little different in terms of speech language pathologist can provide services in multiple areas as you know um it can be one-on-one it can be a social skills group that's collaborating depending on the goals in the IEP they also can do observations in the classroom to kind of see what the instruction is and what the students um uh abilities within their goals and objectives are and then work on those in in a social skills group or in oneon-one or in in a a small group working on a goal that can then be um integrated into the classroom in collaborating with the with the Genet teacher so essentially it's who they service right correct what degree it depends correct and and again and it's it's more fluid than it may even look because when we start talking about related Services it takes many forms and it takes many shapes whereas with a case manager as a teacher you have your case load and you have your hours that you're servicing with um related services within a PPT sometimes it can take the form of we're going to do this through consult we're going to do this through pushin we're going to do this through um collaboration we're going to do this in a small group we're going to do this in um a combination with social work so again related Services has a little different um take on it than than a general General special education case manager would so I guess so so for school psychologists let's say so at the high school so do they have 44 IEP that they with with goals in there that are behavioral um counseling um in terms of seeing students um for counseling they might say like bill needs uh 30 minutes twice a week and I am one of 44 that they might see in the course of a given week or in some cases it might not be weekly it might be once a month it might be a check-in it might be every two weeks but so that student let's say that one student Mr Bill sure might also have speech and language absolutely so who's the case manager so or it depends so if a if a student is receiving special education services as academic goals and objectives the teacher is the case manager and then collaborates with the related Services there are students who receive let's say speech only and so the the the case manager in that case would be the the speech P speech and more often than not the social worker is not the case manager because it's usually in conjunction with the academic goals and objectives so to give a a long answer to an appropriate and short question it's um it depends on which way the service is going if it's academic the case manager is the one who is kind of conducting the orchestra okay managing that and if it's something individual um it's it's a little different okay and my last question was like does all of this fall within the guidelines and recommendations of the correct report yes yes yes they do yes and and again in speaking with Dr corvo in preparation for November uh we also reviewed this last week just to give her kind of a sense of where we were at in terms of the other things I was doing and this does fall in line with what she was recommending okay great thank you so just a followup to that um are there any of these that are approaching the high end of the range or or are is everything fairly comfortable everything's fairly comfortable I mean I you know I think when you're looking at numbers it's difficult for us standing apart and looking at numbers to tease out what a what a 20 a case load of 20 looks like what a case load of 15 looks like unless we're looking at Specialized programs in which case we're looking at something intensive I don't see anything in here that that is um beyond what would be an average range um you know the the average range within a special ed teachers world can be anywhere from 15 to 25 is a case man like I said it did 31 year um that's another story for another time but um when we're talking about average case loads you are given a case load that is manageable in order for you to collaborate with those general education teachers and related services and all of the other pieces of the students program which you want to make sure again as I said before you're collecting data you're communicating with parents so you're looking at 2020 is reasonable okay thanks thank you I had actually two questions the first one is very broad it's are you having any difficulty delivering the services that are in kids IEPs and 504s no 504 actually no we are we had a uh I had a discussion with counselors last week about 504s and we're planning some PD for admin as well as staff in terms of what accommodations could look like in the classroom so but those are all in place it's just my question is are you having any staffing issues in delivering Services no okay I figured it was a yes no question and then the second question was just a numbers question I noticed that in the special ed teachers the average case load for K5 was 20 68 was 9.7 and 912 was 16.2 N I heard what you said about the high school uh it it spreads out a little bit and that's okay I just was curious if the 20 it was odd to see the the CES number to be higher case loow than the middle school and I just was curious if you comment yeah I mean I I can get more information on it for you but I do think that when the model changes from an elementary to a middle to a high the case load numbers where 20 you might be dealing with and working with 20 kids in a grade level um as you move up you might be dealing with a lower case load but you're dealing with more teachers okay so that there's a there's a a difference in the 20 that you're working with let's say in fourth grade you're dealing with maybe two teachers that you're working alongside with as a high school case manager when I had a case load of let's say 15 of those 15 it was I had a science teacher I had an English teach I had different kids you had multiple teachers for each multiple teachers at multiple levels in multiple grade levels so got it that can that the lower case load doesn't necessarily mean a lower amount of work work and and which direction you're going in I got it I got it okay I I understand a little bit point I'm sorry are you done yep um to that point it might be not that you have time to do this but um it might be more valuable to have instead of just average case load numbers because we've talked a lot about trying to understand and unpack what that really means is to have some kind of like a weight value you know like instead of like a teed almost a tiered system in a way like assigning so that we can see okay each each person has an about the same like weight you know what I mean that's a great idea that's actually effort that goes or the amount of hours or work that goes into and the intensity of the surfaces and things like that because it gets a little subjective because you can you can kind of like feather the numbers up or down depending on you know like you just said you know if there's um you know related services or and I think Rosa that that's a great point you make and Bill you might not even be aware of this Al you've had a lot of EXP in other districts a number of years ago we actually internally we didn't go advertising it but we did weight values when we were really trying to uh equitably divide up the intensity of student needs among staff in a way that would make sure we were delivering on the IEP which reminder for the public and everybody else here IEP stands for individual education plan and that's why when Bill is trying to answer um it can become quite confusing quite fast and almost as if is is he really answering the question because there's a lot there and I thank you Bill for your time tonight because uh it is individual but we're servicing 2,600 kids and you know nearly 400 students with IEPs so all of that scheduling all of that individual work is not only complicated but it's complex um the other piece I I know that Dr P and Mr Banda certainly are eyeing the special education teachers at whiskin ear saying hm I'm looking at my average there Dean do you want to send anybody over to me so we do need to remind everybody that special education teachers and many of these servic providers are are certified prek to 12 or K to 12 so they're very flexible in each during even during the year not just at the beginning of each year we could move staff around as student needs change um or um I'll just leave it at that so there's there is flexibility in this to that regard which is why it boiled down to me of are we able to deliver the services in the IEPs you know if the answer to that is yes I'm generally okay if it's too if there's too much staff I would have a different reaction but uh but uh in the end I find the average is sometimes hard to understand because of the variety of big and little and different mixes of things sure and there was there was in the end it comes down to Services exactly can we deliver the services there was a time here at meetings like this where we're getting into budget season and we were really using this data to fight for lowering these case loads we had we can go back to the one year there was some huge case loads speech speech and language teachers with 40 50 kids on their case load uh special education teachers getting near that 30 range well into the 20 so we we we have made incredible strides and I can't than the community in the board enough for supporting that okay any other questions on this report okay thank you Bill thanks Bill okay next item on our agenda is uh grants approval there's a motion on this one no test scores oh did I oh test scores I'm sorry next is test scores I went so too fast I went right pass the biggest item on the agenda and if you don't mind I'm going to move around so I can look at the screen and it's really important as Dr man begins to initiate her presentation as a reminder that our our main focus last year we had really two big folky and uh one was learning recovery coming out of the pandemic and uh our faculty and staff uh in Administration really worked incredibly hard all year um and generally there are some really exciting uh areas of significant cohort Improvement that we're um really proud of and there's obviously a couple of areas that we'll be sharing with you um there's still plenty of work to do K through 12 and uh we're prepared to do that but we're really excited about the strides we've made um and uh in learning recovery and we're going to continue to work on that as we go how's that sorry I'm getting um advice on whether I should turn off or Keep On The Lights Mr Beldon do you have a preference I would turn them off okay very okay very light for someon project very pale interesting okay well thank you very much and I know I'm standing in the dark so I look a little little enigmatic here but um as Dr bril was saying you know I was thinking about last year uh my the title of my presentation was establishing the Baseline and that Not only was because I was I was new so it was establishing my Baseline but also because it was really our first opportunity to get kind of a um you know a sense of where we were after resetting um post pandemic so now this is this year I'm excited to deliver kind of now this annual update on student achievement with test scores uh State Testing um but also to kind of show some more of the details about how the Strategic plan will provide a foundation for um what we're going to do in terms of of kind of specifically aligning to student achievement in reaction to these this data um and I just want to uh reiterate that you know there so this is specific to the state data and so everything we're talking about tonight is um kind of within that context however um we also want to make sure we're continuing to think about and align to our our five-year strategic plan so the overall uh the overview of the presentation tonight is kind of in two chunks um the first is the high stakes testing achievement scores and the takeaways from those so we will be going over these smarter balanced assessments or sbas for both Ela and math as well as cohort comparisons from 2122 so um you know kind of looking at where our students are doing in terms of their growth uh from third to Fourth 5ifth to 6th Etc as well as the Next Generation uh science standards assessment results that's the ngss and then the SAT results both for uh evidence-based reading and writing as well as math um and then we'll think about kind of the some the responses to this data in particular and that will lead us into our um the next steps in terms of alignment to from the school level the district imp implementation plan um for the Strategic plan so our school Improvement plans as they align to uh the district strategic plan so just to kind of reiterate we brought this idea uh to forward to the board in the summertime at our a at our August meeting about uh being grounded in purpose and um but also inspired by Vision so if we're going back to kind of that narrative Arc that we looked at last year kind of refresh ing now we're turning the page to a new chapter um and that you know so at the beginning we're really that grounded in purpose is the adoption of our our strategic plan of action so really where are we um and where do we want to go in terms of um you know kind of that sense making and envisioning and order to lead us to our our in Inspiration which is the to establish a worldclass school experience for our students for our community and a place where everyone can Thrive um and the way we're kind of working on that is by looking at pieces of data such as this as well as looking at our current School practices thinking about the Continuum of curriculum instruction and assessment and then how we can support our uh our professional staff throughout all of that in order to make them their uh be able to deliver the best instruction possible so our first uh major uh accountability Stakes high stakes test is the smarter balance assessment or SBA and there as just as a reminder uh we went over this last year and I know that you've heard about it many times prior to that it is in two content areas Ela English language arts and math um the SBA is administered in the spring time uh during a window of um time to all students in grades 3 through 8 and then it is scored on um four different achievement levels from does not meet approaching to meets and exceeds and our goal is always to get all of our students to those meats and or exceeds level um because we know that they have the that they have that capacity so we want to help them realize that capacity so these are our um Ela our English language arts uh grade our um percentage results at met or exceeded for students in grades 3 through eight so on the Le hand side is just a snapshot the visual um uh graphic on the right hand side and again I know that you folks can't see that over there but and you probably can't see it because it's in the dark um so I will just go through uh quickly that our third graders were at 56.7% met exceeded fourth graders at 56.1 fifth grade was at 67.2 student uh percentage of students were met exceeded sixth grade was at 66.7 7th grade was at 66.8 and e8th grade was at 55.3 um but what I want to also point out is where our growth was so you'll see third grade from 2022 into fourth uh was pretty much the same 56.1 the fifth graders uh when they were in the year before and uh fourth grade they uh were at 58.6 and they grew to 67.2 our our sixth graders gr Grew From 49.5% of students meeting or exceeding the year before to 66.7 um and then sixth graders to seventh Grew From 59.1 to 66.8 seventh grade um fell by just over two percentage points from 57.7 in 7th grade to 55.3 um so we've seen some some nice growth in many of those grades we're definitely interested in why there was kind of a stagnation with uh the fourth graders and also with those current um ninth graders now those eighth graders last year um but and we also are what I wanted to point out that growth and also identify the fact that we are not satisfied with these percentages we we believe strongly that our students can achieve um much greater than this but we are proud of the work that they did and that's a testament to the hard work of our teachers last year using a variety of um methods which I'll get into in a little bit so here are the um SBA scores by uh for math by grade and again rather than going through every single one I will just go with the growth index um so for our fourth graders the year prior to um in when they were in third grade they were at 58.6 and they grew just about two percentage points to 60.2 our fifth graders uh had a slight dip from 52.1% the year in while they were in fourth grade to 46.9 when they were in fifth grade here's a huge success story our sixth graders when they were in fifth grade they were at 28.3% uh meeting or exceeding they grew to 62.8% so they go they all they more than doubled their um capacity at met exceeded exceeded the seventh graders grew slightly from 54.4 to 56.8 and then our eighth graders also grew slightly from 43.5% to 46.6 so again just looking at that data there are some definite issues that we want to look at and dig into a little bit and we also want to continue to work on the um the strategies that we implemented last year um to see even greater growth as we move forward for our next Generation Science assessment um they as a reminder this is given to all students in the springtime in fifth 8th and 11th grades um and it is based on the uh standards that were um rolled out in roughly 2015 2016 and I'm just kind of as a reminder for next Generation science standards they are uh the whole they are predicated on a phenomenon-based experiential learning uh approach so rather than kind of Stand and Deliver um science information to students the concept is that students discover based on phenomenon so they have full units uh around a phenomenon based uh approach so um it starts kind of more with an essential question such as you know what why do hurricanes happen and then students go and figure out all of the science behind that concept so it is much more experiential which has an impact on the assessment um in terms of the way the assessment is uh created and then also delivered so it is um an Adaptive assessment and it is also these are also all uh computer based as we have they always have been um so our achievement by grade level um again and these are not comparisons because these aren't cohort comparisons um but our in 2023 our uh fifth grade students they were at 70.1% met are exceeded the previous years fifth graders were at 51.9% so again those students who had never taken an assessment like this before um because they were they had there was no assessments given in their third or fourth grade this was their first goar around but last year's students in fifth grade um were at 70.1% last year's eighth graders were at 60.8% up uh slightly from the year before where the eighth graders were at 50 5 4% and then our 11th graders were at 45.9% down from the year prior um when they when this the students who graduated last year were at 57.6% at met exceeded okay so now we're going to get into our last uh standardized assessment that the state uses um and again these are all state assigned assessments that we are you know beholden to um so the SAT has been was chosen about roughly uh 9 years ago I say Mr Blanda um when cap went away when the Connecticut uh academic performance test went away and um the state of Connecticut was very interested in trying to I don't know what that was was trying to um uh figure out the best way to continue standardized measurements for our students um so it is administered to all 11th grade students similar to um the SAT historically um across uh Connecticut in March of each year as part of the testing regimen um their students are tested in into General well three general areas I suppose but two bunched into two assessment tests evidence-based reading and writing and then math um the scores continue to range and as they have historically from 400 to 1600 um however I want to just point out that last year's assessments were was the first time that the SAT was conducted online um this year it's and the but the PSAT which we administer to our students um in 8th 9th 10th and 11th um as well as Middle School uh was not given online so it was the traditional paper and pencil test and then in the springtime it was not only administered online it was also similar to the SBA and the ne Next Generation Science assessment uh schools were offered the opportunity to do it within a range a window time time frame um which kind of uh changed the way that we or it it we we altered the way we have delivered the test historically because we were trying to figure out the best way to administer to our students um so I would but I also want to point out the last bullet on here before I get into the text box which is that according to the website Fair test 85% of school of second post-secondary schools colleges and universities continue to be test optional for either sat or act so that means that 85% of the class of the schools across our country do not require a standardized measure for admissions they students can elect to send them but they are not a requirement and I will say that as a parent of someone who just went through this process last year I didn't buy it I thought it was kind of a whole you know rout R row to um you know still continue to weed kids out but going through the process and really exploring these admissions office they genuinely do not require it it is often used for um uh after post uh post acceptance um for scholarships or for honors colleges or that kind of thing but it is not it truly is not a measure or part of the package when they're when students are applying um so I think that a lot of these things have impacted and we've see across actually if you look at the data across the state many uh school districts had some varying uh results with their from their baseline from the year before um so I'm going to talk a little bit when we get into it and Mr Banda can join me um after the presentation about talking about the test format and the administration um so rather than uh than having it all the students do it on one testing day where every comes everyone comes in and sits for the SAT uh the school the B BHS staff decided to try during ilt time or through ilt uh pardon me not during the time but through ilt um that different cohorts of students would take the test over a series of days so one group would do it one day another group would do it another day um which I'm not sure if that had any kind of anecdotally we're we're trying to collect some information from our students who are current seniors um about whether that had an impact um but that I I suspect uh did have an impact on how our students viewed the test going in again this is just a range um College Board which is the uh organization that runs the SAT um looks at uh Readiness or um you know for post-secondary uh schooling and so if a student scores Below in um evidence-based reading and writing 450 then they are considered not necessary neily that the uh they have less success at postsecondary than if they're at 460 or above and then for math um if they achieve 510 or above then they have greater success in college according to their correlational data so for our evidence-based reading and writing our students in 11th grade last year they were at 67.4% either met or exceeded so again at that um that post that higher range um with an average score of 522 the state average just for context is 52.4 uh of students met or exceeded in evidence-based reading and writing excuse me with an average score of 493 um for our SAT Math our students uh were at 40.6% so 40.6% were met or exceeded for uh the uh a for SAT Math with an average score of 514 and that's compared to the state average 34.1% with an average score of 482 so let's do a little bit of comparison um from previous years and again these are not cohorts these are just previous year data so um the the seniors who graduated last year when they took the sat in the spring of 2022 which was paper and pencil and was traditional um our evidence-based reading and writing students that there are 73.3% uh met or exceeded that goal versus last year's uh Juniors who were at 67.4 so again you can kind of see the comparison in terms of the total uh the average score our math our students in math from 2022 in the traditional uh setting were at 50% of them met or exceeded and that dropped to 40.6% so we really have some questions about what's going on with our students because our goal is to prepare our students so well that it doesn't matter what assessment or test or challenge they face that they're always going to be so regardless of the State uh throwing out a new test or regardless of college board changing the way that they administer a test our students are prepared to meet that challenge regardless so we know that we have work to do uh where with regard to that and building that student efficacy as well as being able to perform at any given place so that leads me into this kind of what are what are the takeaways the summation um at the elementary and middle levels uh we're making good progress but like I said we still have work to do we are not satisfied with being in the 60 to low 70% range we know our students have the potential and we know our teachers are working really hard to help them realize that potential so there are some a variety of ways that uh the schools are are working on their school Improvement plans to align with the expectations of the district strategic plan um and some of those include the implementation thank you very much to the board for uh adopting the new instructional tool of illustrative math um we also have on here and we do write them out in later on but interim assessment blocks we talked about this uh a bit last year um but the interim assessment blocks are releas are uh are uh tools released by the state that are directly aligned to the smarter balanced assessment um that can be used not only as formative assessments for teachers to see where their students are as benchmarks as they bleed up through the um school year but also really more importantly instructional Tools in a very meaningful and intentional way um last year whis skiner staff really focused in on using interim assessment blocks this year as part of the school Improvement plan which you'll see um from CES that is one of the strategies that they're going to be implementing um in terms of science we need to kind of do a deep dive particularly at that 8th and 11th grade so what's happening where our you know our fifth graders really made strides and I have some um some kind of ideas behind that you know really taking the time um to align to the Next Generation science standards in a very you know kind of um to roll that out in a very strategic way um and really looking at where our eighth graders are in terms of this looking at the curriculum that we have and the instructional approach we we use and then again at the 11th grade um this year we have seen our 11th graders even in terms of their uh what they're looking at taking you know how many students take physics versus take environmental science or U those kinds of things is there a good a better way to have a scope and sequence so we're working with Mr Hill um on looking at that and and kind of analyzing that as far as the SATs you know we there's no no question about it the scores are not where they should be um particularly in math and we want to as I said again uh figure out what the reason is for that we also understand that this is one measurement there are a variety of impacts on uh you know kind of the culture around sat that probably have influence our our students um scores however as I said if our goal is that our students are so well prepared it doesn't matter what you throw at them then it won't matter what they that what we throw at them um and we will address this both through instruction and tast test day Logistics you know we kind of learned from the approach last year um this year both through PSAT which of course um was last week and there oh it's next week okay well the good news is it wasn't last week when the first day of um the window the entire uh College Board site crashed and so everybody had to deal with that at Trumble High School I know that for a fact um so at least we they worked out all the Kinks so our kids are going to benefit from that but they are all going to take it on the same day and um at the same time uh and then however and I know Mr Banda is anxious to mention this so I'm going to do it first um but this year one of the differences with the SAT is that it is adaptive so similar to how the SBA um it as you do as you perform as you go through the test it will adjust the questions that you are being asked college board has now decided to change that and make the SAT an Adaptive test as well so um our students will so you all start in the same kind of at the same point and then depending on how you are responding you will get different uh questions so it's become an Adaptive test for the SAT so that's going to be another thing to consider and um there's not a lot of information that we have yet on how that is going to roll out so we'll be kind of um doing our best to preview that before it comes out um and then again cons Cons considering the uh Continuum of the K12 uh correlation with correlation performance not just how our students are doing over time but also the Continuum of curriculum instruction and assessment and how we can Shore up that Continuum so again our kids can perform to their best in any given situation I'd like to ask Mrs FAS to come up um to talk a little bit about some of the K8 things that we're doing and don't want to trip so I'm going to go that way this is what dropped good evening thank to Dr man for inviting me up to speak about the um some additional actions um that we've been taking in uh k through eight so in terms of curricular and instructional um adjustments or basically that's relating to teaching and learning um I know Dr man already spoke um at length about the illustrative math um Dr Mike spoke about it as well from the cap meeting so I won't belabor the point but um the illustrative math program that we've uh implemented in grades uh 4 through 8 have really um allowed our mathematicians to Grapple with math um it's very um collaborative and it really um engages kids in um really constructing meaning and new learning from relevant um experiences so um the feedback that we're getting from teachers and from students are very positive and our math coach has been working um every day in the classrooms um with the teachers um we are going to be piloting also in grades K through three at least one unit um as well and we have some uh training in that area as well which I'll talk about in the next slide um so in terms of instructional coaching integration as as you all know um our instructional coaches really help to support teachers from really basically moving from research or professional learning um into practice into implementing in the classroom so it's really a job embedded professional development that really affords um teachers the opportunity to learn um together in collaboration with the coaches um and in terms of assessment approaches based on the right to read legislation U mandates from the state we needed to um look at our assessment systems as well as our um reading programs to in order to look at the um approved menu of options that are available to us we elected uh mclass Dibbles um and the math assessments the mclass Dibbles are really not that much different than the uh reading assessments we've been using for the last you know fiveish years at the elementary level um there are a couple of additional tests that really um are a little bit better at giving us some uh greater information um in terms of word reading fluency which deals with really more high frequency words and uh decoding so those are new Universal screeners and some progress monitoring tool as well as uh Dr man already spoke about the uh interim assessment blocks um and we're looking forward to be really um digging a little bit deeper at the elementary level and using those in grades um three through five as a formative assessment which Dr man um uh spoke about as well informative assessments basically something to inform instruction versus summative which is really at the end of a unit um or a year such as the state assessments um and we continue to focus focus on um supporting all of our subgroups and um I know that uh Dr Brill spoke in his superintendent report about um the designated um High needs populations and we continue to look at um servicing all of our students whether um High needs or non-h high needs um let's move this I can't even see it's so dark all right uh so we continues to also leverage professional development certainly we're committed to talent development and developing our professional because obviously to get to the students we need to make sure that our teachers are equipped with what they need in order to support and serve the students um as best as possible so uh the PD Pathways I'm not going to get too in depth with that because it's forthcoming on an on an ex slide um but that was conceived of by the professional development and evaluation committee PC which is comprised of Administrators teachers um and really the teachers um have really taken a leadership role in this and facilitate um with the um administrators um that are on the teams as well um the uh eight different Pathways that are aligned to the Strategic plan uh also in terms of some Grant funds that we're using to support professional development in both reading and math um based one of them is the right to read Grant which again I spoke about that legislation um that we're um making sure that we're um adhering to and uh We've uh actually embarked on the first uh kickoff of our letters training today um to prepare for science of reading um instructional tool integration which is really um a reading program um that will be coming to you all with um hopes of uh being able to get uh for the 2024 and 2025 um school year and letters stands for language Essentials for teachers of reading and spelling uh illustrative math um K8 PD um for orientation and the integration um of the K8 math uh tool and we already had uh one halfday training um for grades three through five and we have another um two halfday trainings coming up and uh the instructional coaching PD to support the instructional approaches districtwide so we've also invested some um time in providing some PD for instructional coaches um so that they can um really be working very effectively and efficiently with the teachers all right allow me please do there you go thank you all right so as I said um we're this you know this is kind of the second part but it's all within the context of uh our our student achievement data um so as we move through the school Improvement plans that I'm really going to highlight um the aspects that are directly related to uh student achievement data so you've seen this before this is our one pager I'm not going to ask everybody I'm certainly not going to read it but I'm not because I'm not going to read to readers and you have it in your packet um you're going to so this is our regular one pager that we use to as our alignment document but what the reason I wanted to put this up here is because you'll see one of the kind of just aspects of alignment that uh the principls came up with was to actually structure their school Improvement plans the overview of their school impr Improvement plans in the same format as the one-pager so for Candlewood Lake Elementary um the differences are in the different colors right so their uh mission is for Candlewood Lake um and then the bottom band where we have our uh you know our kind of action plan for this year that is the real P portion of the school Improvement plan um so what is highlighted that you will be able to see with your uh phone cameras or phone uh um flashlights is that uh as part of the um aspect of student achievement uh data the CES folks will be really focusing and on purposely purposefully incorporating iabs within the 35 curriculum and instruction so um that's kind of one of the direct alignments to the student achievement data results that we have seen at whis andir as I as I mentioned earlier last year there was a very strong P strong push led by Dean and the instructional coaches to very intentionally incorporate the interim assessment blocks um as both formative checkpoints and instructional tools and they are going to continue to integrate the iabs as formative checkpoints for student mastery incidentally I was at the performance matters Workshop at the state level last week and um they are they continuously are revamping the efficacy and the the um effectiveness of the interim assessment blocks in math Ela and Next Generation science standards and they actually are able to see um um they actually can monitor not by necessarily District but in general um by subject how many iabs are used because it is also done through the uh website and last year um there were over 10,000 uh more than that probably I don't even remember the the number but many many many um iabs were used last year which is a huge increase over the time that they have uh used interal assessment blocks another focus of the middle of the middle school is to look to create vertical alignment of Standards to build off of each other each year and that um is not only aligned to the district uh uh implementation plan but it also is it will um nicely mirror what we're doing through the PD Pathways which I'll speak about in just a minute oh sorry then at the high school um you know along with all the other focuses in terms of making um meaningful and authentic connections for students uh they're going to be exploring uh uh ways to create instructional assessment context to meet the needs of students so that's specifically designed um and as I said if we PR prepare our students um to the best of their ability then no matter what we throw at them they'll be um able to perform and then really also establishing successful testing environments for the high high stakes testing including ngss PSATs SATs APS Etc so then this is the um what we mentioned earlier uh throughout the kind of end of the summer into the beginning of the school year and what I really wanted to kind of highlight as one of the direct alignments to um not only assessing our student achievement data but also our overall uh District Improvement plan so um as Debbie mentioned the profess profal development and evaluation committee last year was really looking at the making our PD time that the board so generously offers us meaningful and intentional to directly support the work of um teachers so that we can impact students in the highest leverage possible and so um we came up with one of the things that we heard this idea that it's very difficult for teachers to know exactly where um their kids what their kids were doing earlier or where their kids are going to so under the idea and I know that spoke about this at Cape last year and that um Dr Mike reported on it with um some minutes uh from Springtime meetings but we came up with these eight different Pathways um one of them is the is really outlining and defining the dispositions of the Brookfield Seas the portrait of The Graduate and fleshing that out um which will be the kind of backbone and infrastructure of everything that we do it's heavily uh focused on in our uh strategic plan it will I believe strongly that it will have a high impact on our student experience and therefore our student uh performances on achievement another one I wanted to highlight is our curriculum exploration so in this pathway teachers are from prek through 12 having the opportunity to have discussions with each other about the purpose of curriculum how it serves as the backbone of assessment and our instruction and so um that's just those are just two examples that I highlighted but you can see that all of these really do kind of align directly not only to student achievement um results but also to our strategic plan so back to the beginning right and um I didn't have the uh principles come up to talk about their own uh sips but they are here to answer any questions so as you're getting ready with your questions please don't forget that crowd over there on the side um but just we wanted to really kind of you know remind everybody that our ultimate goal is to help students develop the skills aligned to the Brookfield Seas so that they are prepared for Life Learning work Beyond school and any challenge that is thrown their way and academic preparation is a huge part of that and that is what our our main Jam is and that's what we're focused on our strategic plan is um where we are grounded in our purpose but we are inspired by the vision of becoming a worldclass school district and we are excited about the work that is ahead of us and we um look forward to your questions and I'll turn on the lights because now you buddy blink your eyes a little bit thank you Dr man now you have it right there so thank you just remind me again uh what grades are using Smithsonian Smithsonian um are 8th grade k k K8 K8 okay so you said something really useful oh good in there particular more useful than the presentation on the data which is we want all our kids to be prepared for anything that's thrown at them the scores in the SBA in the in the 60% I'll just use that as a round number probably not there how do you use the standardized test to drive culture change that would help the kids get into the 75s and then into the 80s and into of the '90s on those I just I just I'm just I'm trying I'm struggling with how do you grab that and then use it to drive well I think that that's it's a really good question and it's important to REM to consider the context right so it is a good kind of jumping off point um and I know that that's what the principles do at the beginning of each year um to kind of again kind of establish that Baseline but we also and teachers are very aware of this it is data that is by that time 4 to 6 months old um it is also a snapshot in time and so it is a good um kind of frame of reference and because it's standardized and all of our students have to take it across the state um it's an opportunity for us to kind of just get that General sense of of where Brook Field is um but it also gives us the opportunity to kind of dig into the more individual pieces and collect more relevant data and um timely data so such as through mclass or through interm assessment blocks um or individual uh course assessments that are in the high school um in order to really it's more of that it it helps us focus in on it so it helps us Inspire teachers to um identify that oh we really have some work to do here um and then get more relevant data that can then spur on the is our is our interim testing you know the the spot testing that we do through the year is it was it telling us the same things that we saw in the in the more high stakes testing at the end of the year I I not anybody want to come up and join me I mean were we seeing 2third of onethird of the kids just not achieving um as we went through the year were our interim saying oh no we're doing really well and then we were surprised that that's I guess the question I was having so the way it the way it works is it's not we don't give it a big S like a big test so it's correlated the same way I guess you could say it's based on more on topics so it may be like on adding fractions or something like that we didn't we use it in different ways some of the times we would use them for students to just do a couple of the problems to get a sense like we do a problem of the day I'm thinking like with math because it's concrete and that's I was a math teacher um and we would do things like that um so we didn't necessarily use it as kids are coming in today and they're going to take a 30 minute test you know or anything like that wasn't I wasn't asking I wasn't asking that I was asking are we were getting indications that kids were not me not getting there it depend on what it was it was it could be so so the way I'm looking at it is we noticed that kids uh had a hard time with numbers six seven and 8 so then our teachers would look at that say okay what are those questions asking how was it in context so what then we do is then change instructionally what we're doing you know it's not about getting that answer correct it was more about understanding part partially the the way that the test is the questions are written what is the type of question they're asking because that that's really big too in that we had a conversation the other day in um Happ to be in the math department meeting that we need to use our questions for our regular assess I'm not even talking IBS to be similar to Smarter Balance testing questions so I guess my point to you is that there's nothing that's a real correlation we didn't notice that you know the kids 60% of the kids were passing doing well on this this part of the tester or that I I guess I could say and we didn't use them in the entirety is what I was I think I would just also add that we didn't really have a universal screener that we felt was um Direct ly an indicator of where students were going to be we used star last year um but that was uh the the teachers did not see the um direct correlations in the the way that they that we were administering it um or the the results that we were getting rather um and so we didn't have like an indication going into um March through May when the tests were given um that we were only at 60% for any given topic I would think that if you did regular spot testing on topics and things like that you would have with data analysis said oh I've got a third of my kids are are struggling right they're they're over and over and over again not not achieving and they're probably going to have a problem at the end of the year it's not anyone it's not a summative right we know that but you would have at least been able to look at data and said oh yeah there's something coming and uh and I would think that that would then dictate Behavior with a high bar that says how do we really bring in the troops to help and I think maybe maybe to to I I have a feeling um Dean may not have known exactly where you were going this Bob and I think the direction is in terms of intervention work additional reading support additional math support for students when you think about your srbi or now mtss you know in terms of sorry for the alphabet suit but that's the intervention that that we do with the extra and additional support for students when you think of your percentage of students in a grade level you know is it 5% of the kids 10% of the kids is it more students than that you know nearing 20% of the population in any given grade that's having some trouble and that alone that throughout the year as you continue to work with them and they continue to make progress sometimes the kids make a lot of progress but they're still not at a place where they're going to perform at the end of the year so were we looking at you know if 70% of our kids are hitting the goal was there 30% 10% 20% that maybe Deb you're looking at answer that question yeah I mean yeah you're you're asking um the same questions quite frankly that we were asking of ourselves and each other um looking at this data at the elementary level the universal screeners that we use are really giving us information relative to reading foundational skills right in terms of decoding being able to lift print you know off of um paper to read so that's not going to give us the same type of information right at grade three and four where they're taking these you know the summi of State tests because that's reading to learn right so it's it's different in terms of then the skills that they're that they need are background knowledge um and comprehension right so in terms of at the elementary school that's one of the reasons why we're looking at these focused interim assessment blocks because quite frankly at the elementary level um there's more work to do to integrate those into instruction and into curriculum because these summative tests are really giving you information about curriculum and instruction um it's not really where where you can use for student um data really um in terms of these tests so we really kind of need to look at um really what we refer to as tier one in the multi-tiered systems of supports which is really your core General um instruction because you know an effective core instruction really you should have 80 to 85% of your students meeting goal right so when you have 60 70% then you need to look at the effectiveness of core instruction which is why we're looking at um you know new programs new curricular programs um in terms of the math and in terms of the reading um that in the reading curriculums that we're going to be looking at are going to be able to incorporate the uh word study as well as vocabulary comprehension all the you know the Big Five areas of reading into the reading Block versus having a word study block and then a reading block where then students are learning skills in isolation and don't necessarily transfer those skills into context so what we're going to be looking at is using the coaching as we spoke on on those slides I think 15 and 16 um to use the the coaches to really help with um taking the um you know taking this professional development and helping teachers to then embed it into the core instruction so the focus is on Effectiveness in in the core and then also looking at your tear 2 tear three as Dr bro was saying in terms of your all of your multi-tiered systems of supports um to really look at as at effectiveness of instruction so those are the kinds of reports that we can get in the mclass tibbles um and those are the kinds of reports that we're going to be looking at and working with teachers and coaching with teachers um and using all of our support service staff as well as well in terms of um the multil language the multilingual multilanguage Learners uh staff to also work with us um and support teachers um as well that's very promising to me because uh you know we've spent over the eight years I've been on this board everything has been going all the PD has been going to getting everyone lined up on standards how do you build curriculum around standards how do you assess against standards how do you take actions when kids are not achieving on those standards I mean it has been extensive investment that we've done on this um and I do know where kids are coming out of Co right now so it's still it takes a couple years to see the decline it takes going to take a couple years to come out and I'll go back to my first question is how do you incorporate the thought that uh Dr man had which is we want all our kids to be able to uh add work at a high enough level that they can be ready for just about anything and I've got to figure the iabs or any other tools that we're using are driving the actions and and that's what I'm not feeling yet right is where do I need to bring in uh extra help where do I need uh uh really sit down with a teacher and say oh we we you know I'm seeing a trend right you know you got a third of your classes struggling right um and it might be an individual teacher it might be a group of teachers I I don't know but that data Centric how do I and and I'm not a teach to the test kind of guy and I'm not a you can't and and I'm not a I'm not I don't think there's a a a silver bullet that says here's how you fix things but I just think that when you set a high standard there's a set of actions that are different than when you're setting a when you're when you're driving to a 60 something percent I I totally agree and it's got to be much more incisive and more more uh here's how I'm going to go bring all everybody else and and some of the actions that we are taking that weren't necessarily in the slide I think also speak to what you're talking about um just systems and structures that support a data informed right and a DAT and a outcom driven model so during um plc's which is professional learning communities which is where we have teachers that come together to collaborate and and uh you know on a number of different things um once a month at uh kwood Lake Elementary School PLC meetings are going to be dedicated really talking about multi-tiered systems of supports looking at data again the coaches really coaching in um to the data and supporting teachers um with that as well I mean as as you all know you know some of you are teachers um some of you no teachers um the job of a classroom teacher an elementary teacher is very challenging you've got every single subject area that you're teaching um with a very uh Dynamic and diverse set of students um so we're going to be looking at um having conversations about differentiation right um so that all students can access the curriculum um we're excited about the math curriculum and it's it really is um you know uh some positive feedback in terms of really helping students to construct new meaning um in relevant contexts and we're excited about getting in a new rooting program and some of the other things that we are working on um that we haven't really Illustrated here is really also working to try to integrate social studies and um science into the ELA because one of the things I think also that could be contributing to some of the um data that we're seeing is um again we've worked so hard on teaching kids how to read how to decode um but we now we have to work on helping with background knowledge because if students don't have um you know a lot of background knowledge and experiences um it's hard for them when they're reading a text with unfamiliar words um or in contexts that they have no background knowledge for um so social studies is the perfect content area that can really introduce a lot of background knowledge and a lot of the texts that are in some of these summi of um you know tests are in fact social studies related so if the students aren't don't have the background knowledge it's going to be harder for them to make meaning of text um so those are the kinds of things that we have to look at and make sure that we're including in instruction and the other piece with the iabs is as teachers are getting more familiar with the iabs which is basically the blueprint of the summi of exam um there are some AAA moments right it's like wow this is what kids have to be able to do so we have to make sure that not just the curriculum is supporting that but that the instruction and what the kids are going to be doing in class each day and being exposed to excuse me I'm losing my voice um is helping them to be successful so it's not teaching to the test it's making sure that they have opportunities um in curriculum instruction and assessment to be able to understand and learn basically and be and be a creative and critical thinker right and those Brookfield seats to help them to be successful when they have to put together skills that they've learned in isolation into real world context and I and I think I want to go back to Bob's original question he asked about how do you how do you inspire and drive that change and something um that I've seen this year that I haven't seen since prior to the pandemic is an uh an inspiration uh in a lot of our faculty um it's it's very clean and different year I think Dr man has been here for a year and had an opportunity to really establish trust um I think bringing the staff together of Candlewood Lake right sizing the middle school all of these pieces has kind of brought on you know its own stresses but also its own excitement and I'm I'm feeling that and hearing that anecdotally so I don't know if that Anna you could talk to a little bit because she didn't spend a lot of time on the pathways and the teachers are owning the PD they're creating the PD they're coming up with the concept and so I think think that ownership is also inspiring that um excitement and motivation that aha that you're talking about as well Deb well and I I I appreciate that I do want to make sure that thanks okay um to that the the idea that this all you know everything is kind of part and parcel of the larger hole which is going to help uh create this environment that we want for our students but just to kind of get back to what U Mr beldin asked um the two points that I wanted to make is that um as far as the teaching to the test or um you know that kind of thing you know we want to make sure we are teaching based on standards and the test is based on standards and so if we are doing that in a really with a high fidelity and strong impactful way um and that and that means that regardless of whether it's an internal assessment block or a teacher created or or team created assessment if we can look at where our students are struggling and know our a third of our kids or you know 40% of our kids are struggling in this particular standard then we can dig into that and that whether that means through intervention or Tutors or support or that tier one everybody gets that depending on what the particular standard is you're doing you're just doing standardized uh standards based reporting for parents now so you ought to just jump out right who's who's achieving standards the other thing I wanted to mention is that last year was really the first year that the Middle School used um interm assessment blocks so that was really that orientation and getting used to using it as an instruction instructional informative tool and this year is really the the year that they can dig into really look at those now that they're they're clear on kind of the connection between the standards and those interm assessment blocks now they can start really analyzing that data on a more realtime basis okay so I have a second question sure right hopefully it's not as long as the first question in your SBA you had a couple of grade levels that were red right you showed the co cohort movement which by the way was really useful because you could see a lot of good movement uh coming out of uh Co right on many of the grade LS we had a couple though that were going the wrong way what are you doing Special to dig into those specific red areas so I will call up um Dr P and Mr Renda to talk a little bit about their uh School Improvement plans because those kind of directly correlate just like it to focus in on that was a 8th grade I was going to say English and fifth grade math if I remember gradea fifth gradea too e8th grade ELA that went down by 2.4 percentage points and fifth grade math and then the fifth grade math that went which are now high schoolers 8th graders are now e graders are now high schoolers correct right and the fifth graders are now sixth graders so um do you want to speak specifically or no well eighth graders I'm like my e so for the eighth grade that went down well this one here it was fourth to fifth could speak to it so is that the one you're talking about you're talking about this one so one where she these are our current these are current ninth graders yep so I mean you can see honestly they went down um a couple percentage points um I'm trying to remember when we looked if it what the big difference was I mean a lot of times we try to look at students that in the cohort how many kids were at goal last year are go at goal again and what's interesting sometimes when you look at those things we have kids that just make goal like you know what I mean they're like they're right on that that cusp and then the following year they may go down to here so it's not like a big huge decrease I'm not saying it's all the kids but sometimes we see it like that when we just barely make it here our numbers a little bit higher but there's about 10 or 15 kids that are right on that cusp that with one or two problems wrong they can bump down below so I I can't speak specifically um to the those two percentage points but um I I I don't know how else to well I'm going to say it differently I'm going to say it differently because this we're talking about eighth graders and so n they're in nth grade they're in ninth grade so Mark what are we doing about special supports for that group who declined in our reporting at the coming out of middle school and now are ninth graders who might be finding themselves in a whole new environment and struggling do we have we identified who they are and are we getting them the help they need so uh a couple things so you know knowing that they're eighth graders TP nth graders excuse me typically you know we don't spend a lot of time with SBA data and identifying the individual kids right that's typically we're looking at um you know our screeners that we may use or our PSAT data that sort of thing um that being said in terms of what we can what we do for our nth graders in particular um there are a significant number of interventions that we have um I think you know we're already seeing some of these issues are coming up we have we do have weekly meetings um which are srbi meetings which we identify would teachers bring forward kids that might be struggling so even though we haven't I couldn't say you know we took the list of students from Dean and looked at those specifically they're they've already surfaced right in a short amount of time and so then now we're implementing different interventions whether it be working with the math interventionist our reading specialist we actually expanded um knowing that we were going that we saw some of these concerns in both math and in literacy we expanded our literacy program and we changed it from what it was in previous years so it's now touching more than just students that have IEPs we're now working with kids that have identified reading struggles so our um Dr Spencer who is our Humanities curriculum specialist actually worked with our reading specialist to work with the reading specialist down the at the eth grade to talk about incoming kids and identify those kids we also for kids that are typically struggling a little U more in some of the math areas we actually do a um it's a it's a um they have their algebra one class they have right but they'll also have um a uh foundations in algebra like a an actual double block essentially so that first semester of the school year to get them started started to get them Prime for those deficient skills that they may have they're in foundations of algebra as well at the same time taking Algebra 1 so it reinforces Concepts to make sure that Foundation is better so while we haven't explicitly done that and that's something I'm writing down going yeah we need to be better about ident we know who those kids are they've already floated to the top and we can access some information as well through uh edite secure right which we have access to which is a different level than Ed site that the public can see edite secure allows us to really dig a little deeper into specific kids so we can pull some of that information but we those kids have come to the top and so we have some interventions in place already srbi meets every week you know we're having these conversations with school counselors that are brought up um you know based looking on grades and performance on assessments so they're they're coming and we're giving them some intervention but it's always an area that we need to improve on I mean and that that um articulation between Dr Spencer and the Middle School reading teachers just started happening last year right they they've been having like generalized conversations it's more been with the um the conversations have generally been between reading teachers right and there's there's a limited amount of things that they a reading teacher reading specialist is able to do I can have a conversation with joy to say okay they're coming up to you and that's great unless we have a structure in place from the administration side that's going to say okay let's do something to address some of those issues otherwise you're just doing the same thing you've been doing and so that's where Dr Spencer being more involved in that literacy program this year has helped expand it to touch to be able to reach to more kids do we get information on what specific standards kids are struggling with off the back of these Summit of Assessments no no I know we do in New York I mean been St the standards of the from the tests I would think that we should right um so they don't give us that level of um of detail from on on edite secure we used to get that you know we used to get the the soaz report from the PSATs that's but that went by the wayside a long time ago so we don't even get that but I my understanding is that the new PSAT is going to have a performance report um similar to that summary of of um academic skills I think kids coming out of 8th grade and into n9th grade that would be extraordinarily useful information as you think about where what support you have to put in on day one as well as um yes right as well as the initial you know screener assessments and and observations of teachers but go ahead about P um we're going to find out a lot more about the PSAT and the SAT this is the first time this adaptive test is being given okay um you know so it is it's no next week on Wednesday next week on Wednesday um you know it speaks to a lot of different things as the College Board struggles to remain relevant in a lot of ways um the state has adopted as their test but when you see what you saw up there in terms of 85% of schools are saying it's really not that big it's not a factor necessarily uh I think one of the challenges you see the SAT has dropped the time it takes to take the test all four sections 2 hours and 14 minutes start to finish wow so that's that is from down from 4 and a half 1.5 and a half hours so that is the entirety of the SAT and the PSAT is now 2 hours and 14 minutes that's two sections for Math and two sections for evidence-based reading and writing it's and the way they're giving it is everybody gets that initial module with a mix of hard and easy questions the way they're calling it and then based on how you do on that first section then they kick you over to another module and based on how you're answering those questions it'll go harder and easier what that's the structure it's been explained to us is how it's supposed to work I don't know how they're coming up with the score I don't know what magic elfs is somewhere that's going to have the algorithm to make it happen but they're going to come out with something that's going to have a score um and the information we're going to get from that we'll see I'll probably get it earlier because my own child took it um so I'll be able to get some of that information and play around with it and see in the back end but um it's going to be interesting because the SAT is going to be the same way in the spring so um these kids have been through multiple iterations of a test that just continues to it's three different versions paper and then computer and then adaptive computer so I'm also going to ask Mark to quickly talk about the um some information that the the school counselors are gathering um based on some feedback that we got from Cape last week yeah so we started uh I got some feedback from uh Dr man from the cap meeting uh so I actually put out a survey to seniors I think I have 83 responses at this point uh asking various questions on the SAT PSAT and the NGS test specifically to our seniors the class of 2024 it's an anonymous who this this group here so it's an anonymous survey you don't have to put their names there's no expectation um there's a little bit of we behind it because the principal does send it out so I hope that there you know more kids are answering it which is helpful um but the questions range from um you know their attitude towards taking the test uh specific questions about uh did you feel prepared questions about cour workk did you feel your coursework really helped you uh prepare for the test what did you do to improve like once you had your scores what you know so it's going to give us some some points and some information to see where what areas we can improve in one that I will share is quite interesting and specifically with the SAT of those 78 kids or so that answered the the survey close to 75% of the students said they they did not send those their SAT scores to any school or college nor did they plan to and I and the other combination is or they super scored meaning they took one test one section more appropriately so 75% of the kids that responded so far said they had no it was so I'm and listen I I want to be completely transparent I get sick to my stomach when I look at these scores and you know I keep going back you know we often say oh we know that kid's a smart kid that's that kid's a smart kid and it s it's like a feeling it's a gut but I I know what's going on in classes I know the alignment to standards in terms of teaching I know where a curriculum is right right and it teaches heart of algebra expression of ideas words and like it we teach our kids those things so where like what happens in that translation from the content and the skills we know we're teaching them that I can see and I can talk about administrators who also going to classes and so it's there but it's not being translated so that's what Dr man was getting to as well and talking about the seriousness taking it all at once putting some you know they're not going to take the test for me as much as I would like them to say take it seriously it really matters I have to go in front of the board next October and have another conversation about this it's not necessarily going to matter to them but they will take other tests right there are other tests that kids are going to take as much as I we don't want to teach the test and I appreciate that statement we don't want to teach the test we know it's standards aligned but at the same time they have to recognize and help we need help them find that balance to understand in life there are going to be higher Stakes tests right there are going to be times to take assessments like this doesn't matter whether you're in a trade or you're in a career these things happen you think about the test to become an electrician or there's you know to become a journeyman like my father father-in-law is it's an extensive test so when we brought last year we brought midterms back and finals because we started talking about we got rid of it and kids didn't have the stamina to take the test they didn't have the comfortability with taking such a large volume right that had such you know waight on their on on their grade and so we saw when we brought those back there's a lot of consternation but it was important for kids to get used to taking those kinds of tests because they still do exist so we have to find that balance between the importance of yes I know you may not need it for college I I I can't just have that number of 85% and say it really matters but the skill of taking the test the pride in saying it shows what I know um and you never know it might help you to that end get a scholarship right it might help you do those other things so you know and it makes my next October a little bit easier if we do better too but that is we're we're trying to find that teenage brain and I that's why I went back I'll go back to that conversation about sat the fact they shortened the test means kids don't have the stamina anymore they're just not doing it they can't sit for a 4H hour test they won't and so there's a lot of things that we're doing on our end um once we get the results back from the PSAT next week going to have a lot more um we've already done I've spent I did a whole session uh with the Juniors I know uh Ava talked about the the um youth commission that I did that session with them about the foundations of government did a very similar one last week about uh the PSAT and getting us all set and ready to go for the applications and those things we have another one next Tuesday the day before the test we're doing an inperson conversation when I talk about we're going to amp up and make it you know important and have kids understand is what it's about you'll see more of that as we continue to go through okay thank you thank you thanks M anybody else I pushed on a couple of points and it took a long time I'm just going to say um you didn't want to It Up is on is it on now okay um as as I was listening to you uh talking about going to digital and you know everything that you've said um one thing about the digital is that kids can't go back and change an answer they can't go back so um that's one huge difference between paper and pencil and digital that's one thing the other thing is I'm going to agree with Mark Banda because my other thought immediately was if you look at the SAT scores um and the percentages in the high school and you compare that even to the elementary and middle schools it's a huge difference and there's a reason for that and the reason is just that what's the incentive you know if the if the colleges don't care about it I don't really feel like taking it what's the incentive so I guess I would just throw out what is the incentive and it's it's really nice to talk about we're going to make them feel like hey this is important in life and whatnot but um there might be some answers to some more tangible incentives and I'm not talking about like you get a candy bar you get some money I'm not talking about that I'm talking about portrait of The Graduate or making making it some uh you know something along the lines of it may be a graduation requirement to get to a certain um level something that's that's going to matter and um because I I agree you said we know they can do it well we know they can do it so then there's a gap between what we think they know they can do and what we've seen happening in the classrooms and what these test scores are showing and I really think the answer is that um kids and I'm just talking from experience they just don't see the relevance or the importance of of so what if I I'm not going to send it to colleges anyway and then the only other thing I would say is that um in terms of incorporating into the curriculum not necessarily teaching to the test but exposing them to format um and so that I think uh has uh you know what I've seen is that that helps tremendously if you're not compared to the if you're not prepared for the kinds of questions um or the format that that already puts you at a disadvantage um and I I said that was going to be my last one but I do have something lastly um lastly that there the the test does divide I've seen it where it does divide into the standards so you can get that information um I know we've used it to take a look at very specific questions and what that question is measuring which standard it's hitting and if there is a deficit then uh into the curriculum well let's let's see if we can address those specific standards so um that's it thank you I just wanted to ask I'm curious to with the um I think the number that jumped out at me and probably everyone else was that 40% for the SAT is there any data with their PSAT scores that they took is there any the the math for yeah the current seniors here here's an information that's going to surprise you they went up from their PSAT in nth grade they consistently went up PSAT 9th grade was I forget the level I have it written down up again the 10th grade and then up again to the so that is a jump with benchmarks even shifting as you continue to go up and they continue to go up so um it was an interesting um Dynamic to look at it from that perspective when you look at it the 40 was shocking and um if you can imagine the hole that um uh Mr Hill is wearing in his office as he just paces and circles trying to figure out what we're going to do next with math um because he sees that and owns that but it was interesting to see that that definite change um across there so it actually was an increase thank you okay anyone else well this kind of goes back back to what you were saying Bob is that there's one thing I've learned on the on being part of the cape committee is that this is very Dynamic uh constantly so this for example the star assessment now we're switching to mclass Dibbles it's finding the information from the assessment to work off so me I mean I might be over set my balance on but the star data wasn't great and that's what we were using for I don't know how how much before I got here yeah before I got here too so data wasn't great now we have m-class dibles now we have better data okay good so it's I think that that's a a part of this uh another another U thing I want to bring up excuse me throat's really dry is that the teachers are being assessed differently now so it's not I think this was your it's not so much punitive so much is focused on growth um and so that doesn't make it softer in my opinion I I didn't think I didn't get that from what you were saying uh but assessment of the teach teachers going back to teaching the test this might that'll be interesting to see what goes forward now that teachers aren't assessed so heavily on on Raw data and rather rather on growth so this just goes back to my first one it's very Dynamic and everything is kind of interrelated for sure yeah and we haven't quite made that switch completely yet but this is that transition year um where but teachers have for the last couple years been able to focus um more uh Less on student learning outcomes that are solidly quantitative they can also incorporate those qualitative goals so that is also something to to consider and maybe help guide teachers to really dig into this information and how can that inform some of their their instructional goals um can you explain and maybe at not at the high school level but obviously at the elementary and middle school level how formative assessments are used like I know um Mr Endo was talking about how like if a kid takes a a topical test and it's um you know they get all the a few questions that are you know assessing multiplication of fractions right and so the teacher then goes and um you know adjusts instruction is that Revisited with the student like are they reassess so that we can actually see that the alteration in instruction has worked yep okay so I mean the whole idea is and I appreciate you saying like I I'm a big believer and too they need to understand the format types of questions there are things like that but based on something like that we the teachers would give that that data the excuse me the assessment get the data from it do maybe reteaching it may not be the whole entire class it may be the class dependent it could be a small group and some of our interventions like Dr bril was saying are specific to that and then what they do is they assess because you don't want don't always want to give the same exact type of question right just you want to give similar types of questions because they're going to be different anyway in the ESC so then what they do is they'll say maybe give them five questions just to to see where they are based on what they retaught I guess is the way I look at but they don't necessarily give the same exact thing and actually isn't the same thing when you do take it again it is different and and the way that the multi-tiered systems of support works is that you know if you do an assessment um a formative assessment adjust your instruction continue um kind of focusing on the development of that student and that student continues to struggle with that particular standard or that particular strand that's where a tier 2 intervention may be and you're saying that we're identifying or we're able to identify more students so that they can get multi-tiered instruction because I think that that to me still sounds like it's a very small percentage of our overall student population right I mean you can't take half of the student class and give them tier 2 instruction right which you wouldn't do Under the multi-tiered systems of support um need something more but that's where we have to adjust our instruction right so we have to right yeah so that's that's where that so um they're related but it's not as though once you have a student who doesn't get something you kick them up into tier two and say well I don't I don't know what your problem is you're got to go figure it out on your own with a with an interventionist it's okay so how am I going to adjust my instruction based on the needs and the differentiation so it's not necessarily the entire class but um differentiating um between among your students and then But continuing to keep an eye on them so that those the students who really are need some more they continue to be in tier one but they also need some you know intervention at tier two so and there there we're you know we're kind of like talking about all these different things in terms of m-class Dibbles or arcadians at the older grades or um multi-tiered systems of support or interim assessment blocks these are all you know in a kind of a comprehensive approach these are all used to to support this effort right so it's not one single thing that's going to do the trick it's going to be a a looking at and as Debbie talked about those data teams those PLC is really digging into that information at the um Elementary School and also the team meetings at the middle school and srbi throughout looking at those um that those data points for students and you feel that those changes at least at this juncture is enough to improve these you know we believe strong in this plan and that we are going to you know address the the variety of of concerns that this that some of this data is bringing to us but also the Readiness for learning that our Stu that we see in our students and also the the progress that we're seeing on our students so yes this is one of these pieces but we're looking we're also continuing to look at the whole picture um and we can definitely guarantee the process and we are hoping that we are going and we're going to we're going to focus on the interim information so that we can continue to monitor the progress MH so we should see another big step next year that's what we're going we're going to see that's what we're shooting for the other thing I just want to mention I'll close with this I didn't say shoot for yeah I want us to set a high bar that's the goal absolutely and last year at this time I talked about it and Anna talked about it today academic Focus focusing on our core subjects and making sure we're making those strides and through a major initiative the IBS there was significant growth in those grades that we saw and that's a strategy that worked we're going to continue with that and Dave is adopting that down at the elementary level I like that it is a it is a foundational key strategy what is um the homework policy at um maybe the middle school I know in in elementary school it's kind of teacher specific but is there is it like that at the middle school as well when you say homework policy meaning General uh like you say an hour to an hour and a half at each at each grade level yeah I mean I I am also aware of the fact that the culture of high stakes testing extends well beyond the school walls and there's a whole familial like you know culture in terms of I mean I know there's a lot of parents that are just dead against high stakes testing and they don't um they really don't push the rigor of of these types of tests and maybe School in general and that can also lead to I think some of the complacency but um I'm I'm thinking if there was if we're expecting more out of our students that they will rise to the occasion um and so I was just curious as to you know how can we increase the rigor of of things that students have to do in all grade levels well I I look at it I mean you increases the rigor in the classroom when you're there giving homework doesn't in my eyes doesn't necessarily increase increase rigor right because again depending on you know what the assignment is that you're bringing home are they finishing something is it is it um practicing the skill or something I believe in that obviously um but it's not something like you know I look at things like in math is it if the kid could do 10 of them does do they really need to do 20 of them if they can get you know that Concept 10 of them 10 of them correct um but we don't have like again we have a time like an hour to an hour and a half we have kids that I think what you just said we have kids that will spend hours on homework then we have other kids that will you know kids that we're we're keeping after school to try to make sure that they do the homework so we we have all those variances but that doesn't change I guess my point is that doesn't change I'm not not giving homework because I'm worried about the kid who's not doing homework I guess is my point we don't do that just because of that number we we give homework when it's necessary and it's necessary to go back over the lesson Andor necessary for something that might be the next day's lesson or down the road okay so not just to give homework to give homework okay guys purposeful thank you D oh thank you is there any other questions that we should do tonight should we move on I think we can move on we've let let you stand up there long enough keep on pushing this is I'm going to repeat something I said last year this has to be the number one priority in our school district and sometimes it doesn't feel that way because there's so many other things that come in right and uh and you whatever support you need to make this successful you got the board's 100% behind you thank you that's appreciate that's definitely number one priority for me every day yeah I got that okay so we're going to move on to um this time we'll move on to Grants approval go ahead Amy I will move that the board approve the attached list of Grants as recommended by the Director of Business and operations Casey de and superintendent Dr John Burell second moved and seconded um okay Casey do you want to give us a brief overview of what this is or John you have it I just need a microphone oh so I'm sorry sorry um yeah so these are um primarily entitlement grants that we um receive every year um this is I guess this is something that the the board has requested um annually um and to to approve and adopt um what is new here is the arpa right to read Grant which has been mentioned earlier um thanks to Anna and her team Dr Dr man and her team for securing that grant that was a competitive Grant um these are Mo most of these grants are two Spann uh two years so they won't all be expended um in this fiscal year but um yeah if there's any questions I'd be happy to answer there's no other significant changes in the content of these no okay and these grants are incorporated as you know uh Grant Line yeah and the grants L to the budget yep and just to clarify the the right to read Grant was a response from the St State um so it's actually not competitive it's just an interim um you know kind of entitlement they just in in response to uh the Hue and cry of how expensive it was going to be to incorporate the new reading programs um and so that's why it's actually an interesting date uh December 23 to December 24 um is a strange or 20 22 par of me to December 24 um is a weird timing but it was basically because they want schools district to be able to roll in their new purchases that are quite so this is specifically aimed then at rolling out this new curriculum the K3 reading okay cuz that's not the way it reads here this sounds about I guess it does so I'm sorry it does okay there any questions on the grants no okay all in favor of approving hi hi all right we'll go on to the next item which is budgets assumptions and priorities ities this is an action to receive the budget assumptions and priorities document yes so um given given the late hour I'll I'll kind of ask how much detail you'd like me to go in I could kind of highlight this um as we prepare I don't why don't you hit the these are very similar to we what we've done every year so just what's new sure so the first page the assumptions sets the stage for the budget and Frames it out but it's not new so I think for this board as a veteran board we can skip through that um if you go to the second page um where it says curricular instruction assess and assessment excuse me there are a number of things that are continues uh in terms of continuing the investment in curricular tools of a digital nature digital texts um and the support for technology in the classroom uh in addition to that we continue to support professional learning um some of the new pieces are um talking about supporting uh various uh Frameworks in curricul ulum uh and in professional development all based on everything we talked about tonight in addition to that we talk about supporting findings uh from recommendations from the correct report uh and the secondary correct report that's coming out in November as well as the special education strategic plan also supporting our uh K3 reading uh material purchase K3 uh math materials purchase in addition to that I had mentioned during my enrollment report number 10 that this year uh we literally have 20 students at kwood Lake Elementary School who uh their first language is Portuguese which will necessitate an adjustment in our um multilanguage learner um FTE so we're examining how we might be able to deliver that next year programmatically so that'll be something that comes up in the budget discussion in December John H how available are Portuguese multi- um they're all the this area of certification is extremely extremely it was hard enough with Spanish I just an extra year to find Spanish um uh a Spanish bilingual teacher so the the one thing we do have is we did some Forward Thinking uh two summers ago when we were hiring someone in a different position and we found out that they were certified as a bilingual Portuguese teacher so that helped their candidacy quite well in addition to their certification we were seeking at that time at that time so um that's probably where we might first yes yes we're we're always trying to look around the corner uh for the community uh the others is um any any um results from the uhal assessments that we've done uh Dr man talked about the Des assessment results of the initial assessment this year um anything we find that we want to adjust in our uh budget and our resources for the kids we'll do that and then in addition to that I talked about um and we'll have it in under policy I talked about um the kindergarten legislation and if there's going to be an impact on the budget with that uh that's curriculum instruction assessment the next page uh gets into leadership and uh operation and Facilities we continue to work with our leadership development to build capacity um in ensuring that we uh develop engaging instructional practices we're just talking about that all evening in addition to that really working on that culture of belonging in the climate we build in our um uh in our schools uh in addition to that Mike talked about and it's a big part of I think what I'm seeing when I talk about that inspiration and motivation and excitement from the the teachers that I'm seeing um cl to what Mike was talking about with teacher evaluation and the big changes you know the last Dozen Years was very challenging with the high stakes ratings that we were giving teachers and we're obligated under the law to do that um with the state department but now with that changing there's a albatross I think that's been a feeling of relief from our teachers um and so um we want to support the new model and there's a lot of work that's already ongoing in that under operations and facilities and we'll talk a lot about that when we get to Casey's report on the capital plan um continue to uh support our technology again in terms of the investment in Chromebooks uh we're going to have to M maintain our new website that we'll get this year next year um there's some uh operational monies that need to be put aside for continuing to update our infrastructure such as servers and so forth um Eric is leading a technology strategic plan with that committee and so there um there's going to be some uh items from Eric that come forward uh for our budget for that um of course uh anything to do with uh utilizing K policy services to support the work we've been doing for many years to update our policy manual the ARP Esser Grant number seven is probably our biggest investment going into next year next year is the Final Phase in to the operational budget of the ARP Esser Grant and we use that mainly with summer school and our instructional coaches and so for the coming year as we plan this year for next year we have to um have the Final Phase in of our technology integration specialist compensation gets rolled into the budget summer school gets rolled into the budget all of it there's a math tutor um and a 0.5 occupational therapist um and that was talked about actually in uh Bill's report tonight so those need to get phased into the operational bu was about 200 and something thousand 20 230,000 maybe something like that oh it's 210 okay so there you go yep um and then we have to there is another uh piece that we're going to be looking at over the next couple of months is before I present the budget which is uh we're evaluating the the model uh that we have in the human resources department and we may come to you with a different proposal on a bit of a re organization there um of course the CIA Athletic program review uh a number of steps have been taken uh to get that review underway since last spring the visit will be between the fall and the uh winter semester and then from there we'll get the rest of those recommendations we will bring that report to the board and share that um and so any resources that uh we need to bring forward we will continue to support um the results of our insurance company kerma that provided a full security uh uh program review for us and we went over that last year with the security task force a lot of the Investments are in the capital plan but there are some training uh and other human factor things we need to do uh to continue to maintain um our very safe and secure schools uh continue to work with Parks and Rec Department on our facilities um I am going to bring forward a uh uh a dollar figure for an enrollment study next year you know the big changes we made in the district it's time for another enroll full comprehensive enrollment study and um we're also looking Casey's going to talk to this 13 and 14 increasing our maintenance budget to really be proactive at whis skiner and at uh Brookfield High School and so there's a there's a whole comprehensive kind of exciting concept Joy was talking to that the other day at our last week at our facilities committee and so was Bob so I'll save that for Casey's report tonight that's the priority so this is really th this document is the harbinger of what's to come in our budget planning in December any comments all right let's move on thank you I just have actually one comment on um the page that on operations and Facilities number 11 continue to advocate for a collaborative action plan with parks and wreck for the upgrade of grounds athletic fields and Facilities I I mean I'm not sure what that really I don't know what the backstory is when you say continue to Advocate but I would love to see that be a more actionable thing like develop an action plan and like where does it stand and why are we just advocating it sort of sounds like we're saying you know someday we'd like better fields or well there's there's you've heard a lot about concession stands a lot about more bathrooms a lot of those things and I can't develop a plan for a town agency so it's I've got a it's important that it's a priority that as the leader of the school district we support that uh Laura has been incredible uh our new parks and rec director obviously you can see the work that has been going on these were obviously P projects that were in the pipeline um but there are upgrades we still need uh and so that's it's it's a statement um of advocacy okay um and and does that include um replacing the fields that were lost when that's part of the uh Candlewood Lake Project okay the whis fields and the fields that were at Huckleberry and that whole that's a whole field study that's part of the Candlewood Lake Project working with Parks Parks and Rec and the NBC are technically collaborating and in charge of that project okay but existing Fields like the the backgirl softball field here is not included in that it would right now like that drainage project is is not funded it's something we've been asking for yeah because the fields get wet then you have to cancel games and it just is I'm very familiar very so John I'm thinking it would be powerful to have a integrated ground rounds plan that maybe Laura and or Paul you know with Casey's leadership they bring in a here's what the grounds plan so we get a chance to review it and give direct input and they right now there's been we've been so focused on the fields Outback Laura may be actually starting to really work on that now in terms of the capital investment as we're working on the capital investment on our side i' love to have something that we could show to our families that says here is everything that's out there and here is what we're doing and yes this is owned by parks and wreck and this is owned by the schools and this is owned by the uh the plan but we talk around it a lot well and I think the concrete actions especially as we focus on the secondary work because let's be candid we finally got our school in place albeit the especially the exterior is not finished yet but we're in and that took s years of hard work a lot of work we'll leave leave it at that um I don't have enough hair for another new school project I can tell you that it's that kind of a project but it's time we all know and we're really excited about it we talked about our facilities last week and Casey will talk to it today to really get focused on not only the schools themselves but taking a look at our grounds and and continue to develop that so it's all part and partial that we tend to not talk about the grounds because it's not our budget and I think we ought to make it an an event there right we just may make it an event right I agree so that's that questions on this one nope okay um so next up is uh the 10-year Capital plan and then we have one two three first reads on uh on policies and John if you're okay I'm going to defer the executive session to a future date sure okay with that yep yeah I just figur it's getting it's getting late you get drive thank you it's fine with me I'm sensitive to that all right you got a better blue I did I learned can you see it from is it better okay I'm going to come around though okay and you Al you also have copies of the slides um at your at your seat so I think this has been really teed up very nicely for me I think everybody including um Ava our student rep who gave the the guidance Wing roof a shout out that was that was good um so I'm here tonight to talk to you about the 10-year prioritized prioritized capital projects and some facility upgrade opportunities that that come along with that before I talk about the specifics of what the plan looks like going forward I think it's really important just to talk about and make mention of the fact that there was a lot of work and and thoughtful forward thinking that was um already taken place by this board of education particularly the facilities committee um even before the new school was completed um knowing that the new school will be opening this year the board um very thoughtfully um decided to make an investment in a um building facil build building condition study um which uh began in February of 20 2023 this year uh when they when you all engag Mark sakubo um to peror the building condition study of whiner middle school and berkfield high school in May um Marx Kubo completed all their site work um very intensive um uh uh detailed work um at each facility inside outside the building is looking at all the Mechanicals the the grounds um in any um exterior work that needs to be completed and those studies were presented the to the facilities committee um in July of 23 so I arrived in September and I think the first day I was told you're going to meet with Mr Caldwell and you're going to go through all these reports and and really get to know them um which was a really exciting uh first project for me to tackle um Mr Caldwell and I spend a lot of time together um in the in the month of September really teasing out um the details of those building conditions reports for both the middle school and the high school and we pulled out um any items that we believed could be incorporated and absorbed into our operating budget and the importance of that is because it makes um maintaining the the buildings a top priority annually year-over-year it's being really proactive about maintaining um the good parts of the school that we already have the other part of that is the larger capital projects um and that's what the focus um this evening is going to be but um as Dr Burl pointed out um the operating pieces will be um discussed during during the budget so these two building condition studies serve as the basis for the the 10-year Capital Improvement plan um there are some diff some differences you're going to have access to all of the detailed reports from Mark zbo um which you'll know are slightly different from what we proposed in the 10 10year Capital plan there were items on there such as you'll see oil tanks that didn't make it into the marks thebo report but we are aware because they have been carried forward on our existing 10year plan um that they are in need of replacement so the good news from these reports is that the building the buildings are as Joey pointed out in solid shape um they are generally in good condition overall so there's no need to build a new high school or middle school there's no need for a renovate as new project but it will require you know significant investment um into these buildings to maintain what we have and improve you know the needs of the infrastructure um so that the buildings can continue to serve Brookfield students um for decades to come but there's more good news which was talked about um quite a bit this evening um thanks to the J support of Brookfield taxpayers so much work has already been done over the last 5 years to address the capital needs at whiner and the high school over the Last 5 Years whis skiner um saw Paving projects curbing repairs security upgrades an upgraded building management system an electrical service upgrade which is still in progress um and the exterior wall of the gym was also replaced Brookfield High School saw a lot of the same projects completed um Paving concrete repairs uh security upgrades a new building management system the boys locker renovation which is very near completion um new tennis courts track and fields which talks speaks to what we were just talking about about cor incorporating the um the whole campus of our schools that Park and re wreck is very involved with um those are really exciting uh projects that impact our students um the guidance wing and office roof replacement and bathroom refurbishments we've currently updated five bathrooms in the high school to date so some exciting pictures uh of the ribbon cutting was that just yesterday yesterday yesterday at the at the new track um and it's really important to note that that while these are not as we said Board of Ed capital ests and projects they do serve the the community and our students and it's so important that we do have um an engagement with the the larger Community to see these projects come to to come to completion so where does that lead us um in the over the next 10 years we've put together a plan that costs roughly $12 million sounds very expensive it's much much less expensive than a new high school or a new Middle School um whiner middle School built in 1970 um it had uh several Renovations um in its history between 1981 and 2001 it's approximately 117,000 Square ft things that this building needs over the next uh 10 years improvements to the roof to the windows and doors this is all what the envelope of the building is which is really critical because if you have a secure envelope nothing inside will be damaged so that's that's an important thing to tackle um sooner rather than later if you have issues interior for whiskin we're looking at a gym floor ceiling tiles as we as we move along and replace roofs mechanically uh whis skaner needs a new boiler uh an oil tank needs to be uh removed and replaced this plan does include a domestic water service upgrade um as you know the facilities committee has been looking at some water issues off and on over sometime so this would um alleviate that recurring issue um H HVAC equipment upgrades unit ventilators fire alarm control panel fire pump and controller and this also doesn't address a Wi-Fi infrastructure upgrade um in some of the outy years Brookfield High School built in 1959 um a little bit of a higher investment over 10 years uh just under n um just under $7 million this building has had a couple of Renovations several Renovations between 1962 and 2007 um and it's just under 200,000 sare ft it needs a lot of the same um upgrades and maintenance as uh whis skiner does the the the envelope of the building addressing roofs windows and and doors interior we're going to continue improving restrooms try to keep that pattern of two to three restrooms year-over-year um it does make a big impact um I think to students when they just have a fresh restroom um and it and it and that's good um mechanically a lot of a lot of the same things oil tank as well is is scheduled to be replaced over the next 10 years HVAC equipment unit ventilators lighting fire alarm control panel retr commissioning of mechanics Mechanicals and you'll see that the retr commissioning of the Mechanicals is pushed back a little bit farther in the plan because some of the Mechanicals first need to be um upgraded and or or fixed um mechanically from that perspective and also a Wi-Fi infrastructure upgrade at the high school so that's what we need to do um to keep the you know the facilities um in in good working order um but what we started talking about at the facilities um committee meeting and which is an exciting part of um what is being proposed in the year one of the capital um plan is this opportunity to improve the overall experience for brookfield's middle and high school students by pairing what we already know are needed capital projects with facility upgrades to enhance the look and feel of whiner middle school and Brook field high school so this is this is um well let's this is a $50,000 request um in the first year of the capital plan for architectural services to develop a conceptual design plan with the goal of incorporating these projects into the needed Capital repairs and they don't all have to be costly we were sort of um spitballing a lot of these different ideas um in the in the committee um it can be as simple as having the architect come through and understanding that we need to replace this whole section of Windows in this time time frame well what is that what is the suggestion for the fenestration anybody the arrangement of windows and doors on that facade that might bring in more natural light or might give it a more welcoming appeal so while in this Capital plan there are not specific Investments requested in the out years for what those projects may be because a lot of that work is going to be informed by the needs of the computer community and Dr bur mentioned that the districtwide PTO is is being um restarted they'll they'll probably have a a big say in that um students in the community so that could be a really really exciting um start to to an investment to really make make Brookfield High School the flagship school and and and improve this um this whole experience for for students and the community um all right so you do have the draft Capital plans in your board packets and I'm going to try to open them here um oh no all right well you have the packets in you have the the the um I'm not signed in this me that's okay um you have the plans in your in your um board packets and you'll you'll notice that there are there are two color codes I'm sorry the color of the the one section doesn't show up too well in these um in these these photoc copies but rest assured um the um the link that you'll see online is very clearly labeled what I've done in the 10year plan is I've paired um uh Capital requests that all have to do with say the conceptual design investment so that would be a plan would come out of that investment that $50,000 investment in a um conceptual design and so what would inform that is all of those areas that you see in blue the timing of perhaps all of those window replacements or the timing of where we address Lighting in the in the building as we go so while while these are the the recommended investments from the Marx akubo report the timing of them might be informed a little bit differently based on the outcome of this initial investment in the architectural services does everybody follow me there okay there's a whole another um another section of items that are going to be informed they're they're really related to the envelope and the HVAC of the building if we replace a roof section then we have air handlers and um unit you know V there's so many different you know all the mechanical stuff that goes on the roof right you want to address that all together and so um the Marx a Cubo report is recommending that we invest um $25,000 in each of our buildings for an engineering um design for a feasibility um study to see about adding air conditioning to all the areas of the building that currently do not have air conditioning and so that would inform whether you know we do this section of roof and we have to work to do integrate that air conditioning Improvement as well so all of those things are grouped that way for that reason as well all the items on the bottom they are not highlighted those are sort of a standalone projects um and they are um placed in this Capital plan based on the recommendations of Mark cbo's report and also what we know to be true of the needs of the building is there any specific questions on any of these items that I can answer so these aren't necessarily grouped in priority order they're really no they are they are they are in priority order um the way they are laid out right now is is the priority that that the building conditions study recommends okay all I'm suggesting is that if there are um if the engineering design for the the air conditioning um feasibility plan says it's best to do um this section of air conditioning we may the timing of some of those roof repairs might be just shuffled a bit um but the way it's laid out right here is exactly how um the Marx a Kubo is recommending and all of these costs do include a 3% escalation Factor year-over-year um they also include so in the window replacements in the marks Au Cubo report you may see you'll see a different you will see a different number for the window replacement but further down in their um spreadsheet you'll see that they also recommend 20% contingency for the window replacements and a 30% factor for um vendor mobilization profit margin all that stuff so anytime there's a recommend recommended um add-on to that project I it is Incorporated in these numbers you'll also notice that in the early years of the roof replacement for example in year one of the plan um it is recommended to replace um the library roof here at the high school that number is different from the number that you'll see in the Marx a Kubo plan because we just did the guidance Wing roof and and that was needed that was highly damaged needed to be completely torn off um you know in insulation replaced I use that square footage price to figure the the um the cost to do this roof as well it's roughly the same square footage um but I did base it on the square footage price of the guidance swing roof because that's the most up-to-date number we have and we know that this roof is in comparable shape to what the guidance room uh Wing roof was the other the outer years of the roof Replacements it's a much lower square footage cost because those roofs aren't in quite as bad shape um those are not um intended to be full tear down to you know see through like the guidance swing was right and it's not replaced with as thick of an insulation Mark sakubo said you can increase the insulation the spec of the project will impact the square footage price but they recommended because those roofs are not in as bad shape and if you build in over time a continuous um roof maintenance plan you can just you can use that dollar amount to just replace sections as you go so you'll see a little bit of of difference in these numbers versus what the Marx AO report reads any other questions so just to be clear the goal of air conditioning all the schools is the goal is here but the dollars to enact that goal are not in here yet or are they um so I think there is there is money to do all the unit ventilators it's I think it's more of the ducting work any any connecting and I am not I am not a facilities expert so you'll have to forgive me some but um all the ducting work to connect all the parts is is likely not in here that would be informed by the engineering design but the replacement of um a lot of the the heavy equipment the rooftop units um a lot of those HVAC units are Incorporated in here to be replaced either at the end of their useful life but it's just hooking hooking them up into um and I don't know the difference between honestly a rooftop condenser and an air conditioning condenser right like so there there could be differences there it's a capacity question so it's we may have air conditioning units today but they don't cool the whole building so do we have enough we don't have the money and to expand our amount of air conditioning stud will inform that will that correct there's no new air conditioning units in this plan it's replacing uh what we currently have that's right good question one thing that stood out to me from a safety perspective was the fire alarm control panel for 337,000 but it's out in year five yep so there's no issues with that right now that is just the projected end of its useful life it may be that we can we get to year five and that may be able to be moved out another year or two if it's if it's in very good working order so they the the study really went through all of our Mechanicals all of our systems all looked at all of our roofs all of our doors and said based on what we're seeing based on the the information and data we have on all of these pieces of equipment how much longer how much longer life do they have and so that's where this um replacement Falls in this it does not mean that there's anything wrong with it today at all yeah because if if there was we would move that up to a sooner year of course yeah I guess just because it said the Manu manufacturer discontinued it makes me think there's a better one well it probably is probably is there like there likely is um it's discontinuous not being manufactured anymore it doesn't mean that it it um it doesn't it's not to imply that it doesn't still function you know perfectly fine but I could see why that would that would raise a a flag for you yep any other questions so uh has the town given us any indication of when they need this plan from us uh not I have not received any indication yet I know there's a capital um Capital committee that has has it has not been reformed it's not I didn't think so um I think that I whenever that is reformed I think we'll have more information on when on when they're looking at Marsha and I have been in in um in conversation she knows that you know we're working on this and she was helpful to give me the historical um information on what the requests have been um Over The Last 5 Years um from the board for these capital projects okay so at this point we've just had we're receiving this report we're discussing it but we don't have to approve it until it's more closer to being needed is that a fair I that's that's a that's a fair point if the facility committee um and you know having gone over this a little bit more of a fine tooth we spent more time last week along with the board is comfortable with this report at this point we certainly can approve it to move it forward because November is the timing typically when the town needs it that's something what what I'm thinking John is uh you know you're continuing to work on things and you know give it a chance before we lock it down we ought to approve it as close to when it's just needed there's new learning right there's new information that comes or issues that arise yeah so if we approved it in the October meeting or even the November meeting it would be a opportunity I'm sorry this is the October meeting in the November meeting or even if they're not ready in November and they want it in December right we could do it there depending because I'd hate to lock in and then have you come in say after amend it right that's all and we are in a great place as you can see we have a very comprehensive report here based on uh mark Kubo and all the other work we' put in so um we're ready to go on it but uh things are changing all the time so we could flex and adjust as we get closer and we don't have that date from the town yet and just to be clear these are not especially even in the year one um you know Capital requests these are not estimates from vendors to to perform the specific work I just want to be super clear on that um this is estimates that that was G provided to us by Marx aubo and also what we like I said with the roofs right like what we know currently um so there there can be some some changes there and so I think yeah probably ought to think about um how do we flesh out um some of the higher ticket items for year one because they will the board of finance will want that by the time they get to their evaluation of the budget um which is of course in March right so we have some time to work that but uh but I do think they are all always asking do you have any documentation that you've gone out and ask people to get you a up to- dat cost and how much contingency do you have and things like that so it's probably worth thinking about how to kick that off and frankly not having that town date Bob to your point it just gives us the gift of time to do some of that vendor some okay local pricing on this stuff so unless there's any other questions we'll take this as input to us and uh we'll we'll keep it on the old business in case there's any updates thank you thanks Casey everyone okay with that yep all right all right um so we've got three uh policies and I'll just remind everyone these are all first reads so and uh for the public who's listening the the process we have on policies is we get it we get it from the policy committee as a first read we can talk at about it at a high level here but that gives the board a chance in the next month to give input and so when we meet a month from now we would then go do final approval it also gives the public a chance to look at what we're looking at and also give input as well so the time is about giving the board a chance to look at it and also the public a chance to see what's being brought to the board um so I think um well we'll do those one at a time so each one of them has a motion and uh then Debbie I'll turn it over to you to give a level overview I will move that the board approve new policy number 5112 ages of attendance as recommended by the policy and communication subcommittee second okay moved in second and Debbie for a first read oh this is for a first read right you said that right did you say for first read or no didn't say it on there should say first read oh yeah this says to approve so yeah no we have to approve it as a first read as a first read okay okay so just I'll move that we amend the uh motion that was just made to include for a first read I'll second the amendment all in favor of the amendment I I okay so it's now an amended motion so go ahead okay so um John touched on this earlier and this is a new policy that we are required to enact based on changes to the Connecticut General statute regarding ages of attendance for CH uh children entering kindergarten um the law says now that children must be five by September 1st to enter kindergarten so we are recommending that we do a straight adoption of Cab's policy um it's very straightforward it establishes you know all the required dates and the requirements for residency um so we didn't make any changes or see the need to make make any modifications to Cab's policy really and I think Dr burill will go into some more detail about the context of it and the implications but really the purpose of it is to make sure that we're supporting the families who maybe had planned on sending their children to kindergarten um so we we have some more work to do that John will sort of talk about but we thought it was important to get the policy in the pipeline and get moving on it rather than delaying that you want so I'll recap some of what I talked before um talked about before this is it's a huge impact in Connecticut I mean it's a it's a it's a full sweeping change and like I said if our current kindergarten class uh parents had to experience this 45 kids out of our 160 plus students uh would not be eligible um this year which is 27% of the class obviously enrollment impacts um uh Staffing uh but in addition to that there are caveats from the State Department of Education that we're looking for guidance on because there excuse me there are caveats in the legislation that talk about a specific assessment without giving us any guidance on what that assessment is uh also an opportunity for the the district to provide a waiver um under particular conditions November 1st we're attending a workshop Ed Advance is putting on to help understand that we anticipate over the next couple of weeks we know we we are made to understand that the state department is meeting literally as as we speak uh over the next couple of weeks to determine and give some guidance for us um like many of the things from the csde there's sometimes contradictory information convoluted information um competing information so we hope we get some clarity on that um and I'm working with my colleagues in the Western Connecticut superintendent group to try to understand this um but in speaking with Council um the advice was let's get the the policy moving forward we could always go back in and make any adjustments we need once we have the policy in place um but it does Drive budget decisions so it's really important we know sooner than later um and we need to be able to communicate with our families um given what's the the caveat people actually go out go and read the legislation I do not think this is going to be like the B5 by January 1st rule that has been in Connecticut where that is absolutely a hard line um this is going to be a very very um Gray Line um that we're going to need to think about and work with so there's a lot to it thank you so structurally I'm just thinking policy structure is it possible for us to adopt this policy and have you incorporate details of how we would do assessments and things like that into an accompanying regulation that is a possibility cuz that might be an easy way for for us to adopt a policy but then you put the next level down on how are we going to handle waivers how are we going to handle uh exceptions how we going to handle assessments and if I know that in another you know month or so we could stay on our typical schedule it might take through December to have that information but we could have this in the me that sets the Baseline policy right I think that might be a structure that would work so all right so I think the policy is much more simple than a regulation and how we're going to actually implement this and the impact on our community y yeah okay um Debbie when do you need input by um our next policy meeting is before our next regular board meeting on November 15th so I was thinking if we could get comments the Friday before which I think is the 10th okay so input input to Debbie by November nov 10th on all of these right okay I don't know if it's it's not really specific commentary I just in reading this I just found to be incredibly wordy but um I mean it's not convoluted or anything but I don't know if because it's not convoluted it might just be easier to just adopt the entire policy as is but it is just excessively wory lawyer wrote it C tends to have wordy uh wordy policies but it really is I don't want to call it a monopoly but that's that's who we work with and that who you know that's our can Association of boards of Education where we get our root policies from foundational doc okay all in favor of accepting this one as a first read please say I hi hi any opposed all right we'll move on okay you want to move on to the next one the next one is uh approval regulation number 6563 School library media I will move that the board approve approve regulation 6563 School library media for a first reading as recommended by the policy and communication subcommittee second moved and seconded that me okay um this one we've been batting around for some time um the the actual policy doesn't have um changes to it but it's the regulation that has um some changes that we are recommending based on the petition that we received from the child advocacy group um they're minor changes but they are um bouncing between two copies here I think Lisa highlighted the one's in yellow and one's in green and one's in green right so um this was again based on some requests that were made of us through the petition and also based on the feedback from our um library media specialist okay any discussions on that I did send you by the way my thoughts on edits and things like that today I copi the board so you all had a copy of what I was suggesting so is there is there a reason why we're approving a regulation the policy the regulation in the addendum have been part of in some policies like bullying and it happens to be in this particular one that this has been the board's purview to give Administration very clear and specific direction of how to handle and implement the policy okay so that's why General regulations are approved by John but on this one I think we've had a we did when we did the updates you know um what two years ago now right we were looking at all of them together as a group I think these are pretty simple changes m y okay any other comments on this all in favor of accepting it as a first read I yep and uh the third item is survey of students I will move that the board approve policy number 61 16251 survey of students for a first read is recommended by the policy and Communications subcommittee second moved and seconded um uh Debbie okay this is another one that's been around for quite a while we actually made we went through several rounds and made pretty significant changes to our previous policy um going back almost a year um but then C right after I think we did a first first read the next day C had a sample policy that was a little clearer sent us a brand new policy um so we tweaked it a bit and we asked for some input from Council and um some clarity on things and so what you have here is that final version based on um Dan's input and what was presented to us from C recommended from cab so we all feel pretty good about it um it does you'll see there are forms attached that clearly um allow parents the right to opt out of surveys or provide consent for surveys so we think we covered um all the bases that parents and board members um had concerns about okay my not thank you all right any discussion tonight all right all in favor of accepting it as a first read please say I I okay same dates right yep okay so so this one I'll just remind everyone it's been a very sensitive point for us and I do think we all ought to read all through all of these library books this one read them very carefully uh because they have been hot hot spots in uh in town and I fully expect the five the January 1 U start date is going to be a hot spot in the town before we're done soing out is a hot spot huh well there was big discussion about opt in opt out um on the on the uh Brookville care survey right um you know do you you know do you do you do it as a I I have the right to opt out of it or do I have to ask everybody to opt in um and so we had a lot of discussion about that I want to say earlyer this year or late last year I and also providing parents an opportunity to see surveys before they're administered yeah more opportunities to see surveys before they do have the opportunity but more flexibility in the hours and things like that right okay that's it for our main agenda there's nobody here for public comment we at 11:00 at night we've scared them all away um next up is three main points um I was thinking that there's a lot here I was thinking that uh the special services case load report was important to summarize as well as um Dr man's standardized test scores and school Improvement Plan update and then I thought maybe I would try to combine the 2425 budget assumptions and the capital project discussion sort of I I would just do the capital project okay I would too yeah okay those the budget assumption is a standard document we'll we'll talk we'll talk about that 10 times before we're done yeah then it's just it's just the uh capital projects yeah oh and I think just getting the message out that the schools are the two schools are solid right aren't going to need to build a new school in there is I think there's so many people go around this town talking about we're going to have to no now we built that one school we're going to go build two more right it's and that's not true so unless John wants to do John wants to head the project well John doesn't have any hair left there's no hair there's no hair left he had more hair he would okay okay great all right and up uh upcoming events okay I don't does anyone know I had this Brookfield student showcase is that still going on at JJ stocks on Friday I don't know yeah that was on my radar but I didn't get it from any of the secretaries didn't when I yeah so that's maybe that maybe there was low turnout because of that on the 24th though we do have the youth commission candidate Forum um which is here at 700 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT YouTube / hatters tv transcript source: youtube 10/18/23 Community Relations Committee Meeting · passage 1
um and we are ready to begin our community relations meeting uh we've got six things on the agenda here board members assigned to school PTO budget projections superintendence ADI advisory Council Family University update acmy of danburry upcoming community events and National family engagement month of November so Mike do you want to take it away is he back I am back thanks let me pull up my agenda so I have it here um where did I put it okay all right well we're waiting for Kevin to jump on um you mind if we jump around the agenda here [Music] Michelle that's fine but Kevin is on he's in the car but he is on oh okay I'm here yeah I so whatever you whatever order you'd like to go and sure okay well uh if everyone's here I think we could just take it from the top so number one was board members assigned uh to school PTO um I can pull up the list let me share this with the group here so Kevin you won't be able to see it but I know you you've spent some time with this list already right and and it's really just an update uh for the board um as leaon to schools um I've asked Cara to include two lines in there so it should be updated uh with not only the PTO president um but also the name and um address of the uh family liaison as well uh we did learn uh through Tim that we do have a couple of schools that do not have an active PTO yet um and so if you see a blank space in some of those schools that is the reason why and and again that should be shared with you um in a Google doc so you can everyone can have access does everyone have uh have the link to this I can I can send it right after this meeting to uh to all the board thank you Mike that'd be great okay all right and and that's that's all that was for me Mike it was just really an update for everyone so you can have access to access school people PTO president and family Le okay great the next one is budget projections I think we have two different programs and do you want to lead off with with your department Mike one second you don't mind we do we put this list in the welcome packet will we be putting something like this in the welcome packet or is it already included when somebody comes to register I'm just wondering I think it would be helpful um I don't know if we talk through that uh and Kevin do you have any thoughts on that I think I think the family liaison are part of the welcome packet and could confirm um the PTO presidents I think they changed so much we may not have it at the time of print um but but certainly the liaison if it's not in there it should be but I I think it is but I I totally agree with Michelle it it should be if it's not but I see Ann's face just I can follow up on on that so um when warri connector does the last part with the families she does give the um perspective of the newly registered families a sheet to their school that they're going to has all the contact information on it uh principal assistant principal um social worker nurse school psychologist and family leison um we will update the pto's now that we're closer to having a more solid list for this year but that parents do get that um you know that's part of the pass off um to having parents know who to contact the school when they get there um and have yeah no I was just wondering if we wanted to include the Board of Ed members maybe after the new after this next election obvious something like that that way you know we just keep them closer hand at it but okay thanks perfect absolutely sorry thanks Mike all right Madam Chair by me my hand is up oh I didn't see that hi Al hi uh yes that the list Mike posted uh we we will have access to that yes I'll share it right when the meetings ever okay yeah just uh for a little closer connection with with Miley aison I attended uh the PTO for King Street last night and uh yeah it was interesting it it's something that fell off because of coid but it needs to be reestablished over and out all right so the next item up here is um budget projections so I think we have Adult Ed and then an do you have some from your department um for family l no I I I can speak to aison and Mike can you project the um the adult ed ones I can speak to them okay yes so so one um as the committee and board members are looking at the screen um You Might Recall last night um there was a conversation about the budget calendar for the 20 23 24 school year with a look ahead for next school year and so what I'm attempting to do with the team um through your meetings is make sure you have an opportunity to ask questions uh regarding any recommendations for next year's budget uh we were trying to identify what positions would be appropriate on the community relations and in this case uh the two big positions or departments that we thought were appropriate were uh adult education and the family liaison the family liaison it's a it's a little interesting turn that I want to update the board on so you're actually not going to see a presentation from them um so I wouldn't be able to speak to that um but regarding the adult that I did want to I did ask Rick to provide um an itemized look for existing costs for this year and what those projected cost would be next year um so let let me just start and talk about there are three positions from his Department um and then I think you will also see his the chief of schools also in there as well um and so it's him his assistant um and the secretary um and so going from left to right and then you'll also see Anna Rocco and I'll will explain that line as well um all of these positions are supporting um adult education and there is actually also a reimbursement associated with these positions as well so if you go north to south for 2324 you'll see their their salaries for this year in the cost um and then you'll see projected cost for next year um and these same items will be part of our budget book um when we collect all of these so we will be doing the same thing with car camiro um through her the curriculum department and then uh positions throughout the district um you'll also hear a presentation from Kelly trus and we'll probably do both of these big ones through uh the finance committee meeting on during sites and Facilities you will hear from Mike on behalf of security facilities and it and again these These are the positions or departments we thought were appropriate under um community relations so sorry just going back to you have on screen right so it's the director's position and his salary for this the same with his um with his assistant director and which is called the facilitator and then the secretary um and then at the bottom you will see Board of Ed funding and I just want to explain that a little bit Board of Ed funding and cooperating District support and so we have um meaning funding from us um it cost The District 3 uh $225,000 but you see those salaries add up to uh the salaries and benefits add up to 300 42,000 well some of those monies are offset by the fact that we receive tuition and fees from their participating districts and you'll see the below where it says Beth Brookfield Easton New Fairfield all of those districts pay into our district as cooperating districts because our adult ed program actually serves the entire region or western region of um of Connecticut for adult ed um and so that's why so you'll see one number and then you'll see a different number in terms of what the bill is for Danbury public schools um and so 3 325 for 2324 uh with the projected costs um staying flat for 2425 and you'll see some of the reasons why up top um yes the salaries are uh uh going up as you can see from R salaries and benefits um to the facilitator's position as well as a secretary uh but those things are offset uh by by tuitions and fees that we have coming in and our new arrangement in partnership with Milford is actually what's helping to to cut down our cost significantly um and so we you you'll see for next year anyway that we have a cost neutral number for 2425 but that's why it's because of this uh unique Arrangement that we have for milit that is bringing down our costs so I just wanted to uh review that with the board before we go on to talk about family liaison um but understandingly I understand it might be questions about here and hand happy to answer them if I can any questions so I have a question thank you you said that the chief um chief of schools was a line item for adult ed budget am I correct hello did I did you hear my question I think he might have gone through I did hear I did hear it I'm sorry I was muted I didn't realize I was muted but I did hear it so uh because the supervisor um is working with adult ed for a small percentage of the time we're actually getting reimbursed um a couple of thousand dollars for that as well and so obviously we're not able to en charge the entire salary to adult dead U but we are able to charge it is eligible to charge up to 5% because of the supervisor in there and so that's another reason why we're actually seeing a little bit more return and again it's bringing down the cost for the grant um also Rick is quite frankly because he's growing the program we're bringing in um you know more monies and more tuitions and fees uh through that work um so we're we're really are benefiting and and this is one of the reasons why it's cost neutral despite the fact we have you know the despite the fact that the salaries are going up awesome thank you no thank you laen good question um Kevin so you mentioned Milford like once or twice but I don't see that on the line item is that because it's a new um relationship or partnership or is it just it it may have been miss I mean it is a new partnership but it should have been there um and you know this is one of our celebrated new Partnerships if you will because it's allowing us to get uh new online programming through this partnership um of Rick and a facilitated salary because one day a month and I'm sorry two times a month uh they are available for the myth Milford adult dead program and that's Fridays when typically our folks are not here in person it's it's actually working out really well in that regard okay I I missed a little bit of that because it was breaking up but it seems like you explained it Mich I Just sh a quick note to Rick about Milford I I do think what Kevin said it just it just was left off the list but I confirmation in a minute here from him yeah no because I saw typing going on in there so I just figured I didn't know if we just left it out or if it was just a new relationship so thank you all right thank you so next up is uh superintendent advisory Council um um Kevin do you want to take this one September meeting recap and future meetings for January March and June I think he's still driving we'll give him a second to get out of his his Zone there so Kevin hang on I have a meeting um with Community leaders if you want to call them that Kevin hang on a second you're you're you're not coming through is that is is this any better Mike I can hear you you guys can't hear me that's better yeah you were you were garbled there for a second go ahead you can hear me now Mike I just heard that part nothing before can you hear me now I can hear you fine the whole time can you hear me okay we got you yep okay great um so I'm sorry where did we leave off uh just start from the top Michelle you're muted too okay yeah if you could start from the beginning I'm sorry you were so no problem no problem so the community leader program and can you just give me some give us some background on the communities that they represent sure do you want me to talk a little bit about purpose as well too until you're inine no I'll I'll I'll I'll do the purpose you just yeah I'll do the purpose you okay so we were able to invite folks in from um uh churches and clergy Community organizations um others that Supply or provide services to our schools in the way of mental health parenting classes um different things like that some families are some uh representatives of different corporations and parents as general thanks Ann and so I I asked an to um begin to put together a group who represents uh the various members of our community so I can um find ways number one similar to what we try to do with Citywide PTO uh similar to what we try to do with Collective impact although a little different um and similar to what we try to do in any type of parent engagement uh but in this regard try to do it with some of our community leaders and uh we have and you'll see as you see on the agenda um a number of commitments uh with our community members that were calling coffee with Kevin um in this in in this regard with Community um and we had our first meeting in September and have subsequent meetings since then then um and so I am hoping uh that we can have a board representative at these meetings um I was happy to see the turnout and participation at the first meeting of the year and anticipate um some very strong and really good dialogue around some of the challenges we're facing here in the community um at our last meeting we talked about chronic absenteeism uh specifically we didn't even make it talk about quite frankly anything further um there was um a collective um kind of concern around what needed to be done to help ensure our kids uh success in this school district and um I would um love the opportunity to make sure we have as we continue to fill out this group have some rep representation from the board as well um you know understanding um understanding how important it is for the entire community so you'll see there in those dates uh for the remainder of the school year it looks like we have commitments from everyone and again with with with the hope that any kind of initiative that's coming across the district's plate we can share it with this group to not only communicate it but get support and see if we can help communicate communicated through our community leaders channels um chronic absenteeism it could be anything it could be Chism it could be you know issues relative to health and safety um it could be issues relative to the acmy of Danbury model um but we're hoping uh we this could be another vehicle for us to communicate and connect with our community so I just wanted to push that out for thoughts uh reactions and just the more people who would be who we think we might benefit from having at the table I think it's a great idea is there any board member committee members that um would like to comment on their thoughts well I myself Kevin I'm very interested in being a part of that I know that's uh January AR so we might be switching things up around here I think there's a couple of members that are on the call myself and and Lisa for sure maybe you know would like to participate but um I guess when we get a little bit closer to that part of the year we'll know you know who's in what seed and and who would like to participate but I know I would love to be a part of that that would be great okay I I will make sure I just continue to put it in front of the board and um and we can find out who will be the representatives for the for this because I I think there's a really good opportunity for us to continue to strengthen our Partnerships with community members I agree thank you anybody else any non-committee members that want to ask a question or make a comment okay I guess not thank you Mike you want to keep going yeah if if you don't mind I can jump back and answer the question about Milford so I just got a note here from Rick uh we have an agreement on file with Milford but they are not yet considered a cooperating District um by the state standards so we provide administrative services and have access to their programming but they're not technically yet a co-op District so that might be coming down the line so it's kind of a loose affiliation at this point but not officially a partnership so then that will bring in more funds actually than what we're looking at right now it's what you're saying potentially yeah yeah great than well I'm sorry I just want to clarify the the agreement is there so the the fees are still coming to the district as of right now um but I I think what I'm hearing as a formality they're not officially part as a member and that's why he doesn't have them listed as a member okay but the numbers reflect are you saying the numbers reflected although it's not um correct correct correct so the good news is the money's coming in uh but they're not officially a member and cooperating member yet but just not the name at this time okay good to know thank you all right um four five and six Ann I think these are all yours um you just want to just go through them oops here we go so let me just pull up my agenda here so the first thing that we have coming up is this Saturday is Our Family University we have just about a 100 people registered uh families registered for it so there'll be a track for parents to take uh two different workshops of their choosing and there'll be all kinds of activities um for students to do um this time because of the time timing that we have um for the parent University we're starting at 9: with a quick breakfast followed by the first workshop and then a break and then the second Workshop the workshops are about an hour and 15 minutes long we'll be done by 12:30 um we're not doing resource tables and a lot of those different types of things though we will hand out things to parents resources for parents um but parents really wanted this time um because of schedules that they have going on in sports they really wanted um a shorter day from some of the um uh feedback that we had received from last year so um feel free to come by feel free to come and see it um we'll be there by 8:30 to set up and breakfast um served by our food provider at nine o'clock and then we'll go into an opening Kevin will speak and then they'll go into the workshops um we have a uh wonderful lineup of workshops um my child is driving me crazy which is a way a positive discipline to work with your child there's a growth and development um let's see we have Rich Marsh coming down from the Woodberry Police Department to do his very special Internet safety workshop and then we have our curriculum coordinators coming in um from both the math and um English or literacy side and they will be working with parents to help parents understand their children's ey ready and Dibbles reports and then give them activities that they can do um at home um they'll also be given a tracking device and then we'll be able to track them um or the parents will be able to track the time spent um to to show that we know that the time spent um working with your child at home is a reflection in better um scores um you know we saw that last year so the workshops that we do around the literacy and math we really focus in on having parents partner with their schools partner with their teachers um to be able to um expand the work that's done in the classroom into the home environment so that's an exciting um piece um and then the last one on my part is the um November is National family engagement month oh go ahead yeah I'm sorry just Quicken is there a tutorial or something that the committee members or board members could utilize or see how that works like are you going to videotape that um experience with the you know parent and the we haven't videotaped it but you're more than uh welcome to come to it and sit in on a workshop yeah yeah I was was wondering if there was like any kind of tool that you know we haven't but that that's not a bad idea to tape some of those and then be able to add them to curriculum nights and things like that the schools are doing paring Square as like a tab like you know what I'm saying because then we even as committee members could really just kind of get our feet wet unfortunately I have a commitment at seminar at s in the morning that thing so I won't be there I've been to a few and I I think it's great if any board member here or Committee Member would go just to even stop in um I'm going to do my best to try to get there before the end but um I just was wondering when you had said that that might be interesting if there was some sort of a tutorial I yeah no I hear you I'll throw that out to the team absolutely absolutely um so November is National family engagement month and so um we looked at the different seminars that parents have asked for many of our schools through their parents Square have reached out to the parents and saying what workshops really interest you we also looked at things that are happening within the district and within the community and so we will be doing a set of four different workshops our first one the first week of November will be um stem and the relationship between stem and our careeres so since we have Career Academy um different things coming up in the public our day at the uh Dome and things like and events like that we figured this was a good Workshop to really get people thinking about um this the stem or this the steam Fields um families that attend will all get a kit afterwards they'll be able to pick up the kit for to be able to do things at home um our second week then is conferences in the school so we didn't want to um make people's schedules totally crazy so we don't have any Workshop that week but we really highly encourage families to attend their child's conference and I can tell through parent Square many of the schools have set up the online registration through parent Square for parents to sign up so um and it's also been a a wonderful way for any parent that isn't totally signed up our office phone has been ringing off the hook with parents requesting help on how to get um signed up so that they can do the online registration um our third week will be a workshop um that we are um been given from a couple other organizations put it together all on attendance and of course that's a a crucial need of ours right now and a focus of our awareness campaign and so we'll offer that Workshop I'm not sure whether we're going to um do it in person or online but that will also um be coming up and then our fourth one that week or that month will be one around social emotional learning and that will be done by the um Empowerment Center which is the um previous name or is the new name for the Women's Center they'll be coming in to do a workshop on that um to support families around that SEO so that is the kind of the rundown of what's Happening um in our office at the face Center any questions committee members um I have a question um hi Ann it's Lauren Hi how are you good how are you in the beginning you said there were a hundred families signed up so is that 100 like families are 100 people just so I can it's 100 it's 100 families right now and some of them you know it's a husband and wife or it's a wife with five kids a husband and wife with you know three or four children children so we'll have you know quite a rendition of children and uh families there for the day or the morning great yeah great yeah the one on April 6 that sat a Saturday in the spring that will be a day long one we'll probably go to 3:30 that day we'll do a regular keynote and many more different things but um families are finding it hard to be able to you know attend to something a full day with all their other commitments between sports and work and things like that so um and the schools have really been doing a great job on offering different workshops for their parents so we don't want to oversaturate our families but at the same time we know there's a need out there so having different days and different times and a weekend event um really helps families to plan um the activities that they want to attend and partner with our schools and can I ask you one question um what what age group are you marketing or like the for the stem and Career Academy are you looking at a certain like grades is it open to everyone because I know that's that's so the people that are doing it we met at a conference in Kansas City last week and they will do it for all ages because there's really no um perfect age to start introducing stem of course you know we know from when children play with pots and pans in the kitchen that's you know making noise putting pots together in Lids that stem right there um you know the whole visual perception what matches what doesn't match um and so we want to get our families thinking from a very young age around stem we also need our families or our families have said you know don't tell us about college and high school you know we're new to this we're many families are new to the American system or the system we have here in the United States and so they they want to hear over and over and over again about career opportunities um for their students so the earlier we can start that type of you know presentation and to get people really thinking about what their children want to do um Beyond high school or in high school and then beyond High School is always a good idea and certainly the research shows us um that the more parents hear about it and can have discussions with their children the better their children are going to do as well great I know that we were looking to try to engage them as young as possible about the whole idea yeah absolutely yeah yeah that was it for me Kevin did you have anything I think you're on mute you're muted sorry I'm on two different devices here um I just want to applaud an and the team for seeking out this opportunity for our families um and our kids obviously um but we're hoping this is going to serve as the type of um incentive and encouragement um that our that our students need to enter this growing field at an earlier age um and I'm hoping these these seeds that we will be planting in these programs uh willc encourage our families and students to do that very thing and that's to to to have a better understanding clear understanding of U the type of fields that stems offers and hopefully uh planting no seeds at an earlier age will will give us will yield in the type of um agent that we need as kids move up the system to middle school and high school so so thanks an and thanks for bringing in this type of program we really appreciate it thank you all right that's the full agenda um any last thoughts or questions all right Michelle turn it back um is there a motion to adjourn so moved second by Lauren and second and by Al thank you so much everyone par
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 10/… · passage 1
uh I will now call to order the regular Board of Education meeting for CH Unified School District for October 18th 2023 it is 5:02 pm and we will be going into close session at this time uh seeing that there is no public comment uh we'll go into close session and return to open session at 6 pm thank you it's like we all know how to behave in a classroom um awesome great well let's get started uh welcome back to open session uh the board has been in closed session since 5:00 pm this is the regular board meeting for CH Unified School District for October 18th 2023 um it is now 6:06 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Somerset County, NJ YouTube / Board Meeting transcript source: youtube Board Meeting 10-18-23 · passage 2
five calculation it's one one position split co-advisors yes cois so that's for just one grade or for both grades that's for the middle school student council for the whole yeah and I so I was confusing you have context I thought they were class advisers because I know we talking about that but this is not that and the title in in their current contract is this Middle School class advisor which serves as our student counsel got thank you for the clarification any other comments or [Music] questions all right hearing then can we do a roll call please Mr pal yes Mr Dawson yes M cazino yes Mr zco yes m m yes yes Mr Minas yes Mr vmer yes Mr janzi yes motion passes thank you item 8.1 resolve that board of education approves the resolutions as outlining District education resolutions this is 8.2 through 84 I have a motion motion thank you Mr B second second thank you Mr any discussion none call please Mr B yes Mr Dawson yeso yes Mr zco yes yes Mr Minas yes and Mr hmer yes Mr J yes motion yes thank you item 9.1 be resolve that b Board of Education approves the resolutions as outlined in board action resolutions thought seven was long this is 9.2 through 9.57 can I have a motion motion thank you Mr B second second thank you m too late any discussion I maybe I'm talking as a parent here from 9.35 the Life Touch um were they the only ones that we that were that apply to become a district phph continue have you have well I can talk as I know from some families they um some the pictures for the kids they have claimed to have they got [Music] B one of my kids has happened three times so and every time we talk to them they always say We'll rectify the situation make sure it doesn't happen again but I feel like that's like they're waiting off a telop and just addition to give that response every you know seeing it happen once okay you know we'll let it pass but a second third time at that point is like I'm sorry especially I mean it's happen three times um that's why I'm kind of but at the same time it's other parents I mean other families with their children important so I mean we can talk about this I just wanted to thank everyone for the [Music] donations right I was appreciate appreciate clothes supplies everything is really you don't know the smallest if you think it's a small donation it's tremendous to our our district I really appreciate it thank you to all those who thank you Roger yes sir question 917 on the field there's $177,000 charge to rep place is this something that was already done by them damaged or is something EX Mr J the field Turf piece was a addition to the project where it was identified that a a long Chun area needed to be replaced also and there was some safety issues with the existing one project this is [Music] exra TR thank you thank you Mr any comments or questions 936 may have the floor just introduce briefly 93636 yes sir approve Health yes sir 9.36 in the agenda is to approve Maru health for um uh Services Board of Education I'm going to read a very brief statement from our health insurance broker the Maru plant is unique solution to providing Mental Health Services to employees in the public sector market so unlike the employee assistant plan that we currently have where an employee can call up and seek immediate counseling from provider this plan is uh unique traditionally designed for a group starting with 4,000 employees um breaking into the New Jersey Market program contains multiple paths to Ure employees uh that need help receive proper levels of treatment of Mental Health Care it all starts with the intake to R what the issues are with the staff number and then help decide what level of treatment would work best this has four levels of treatment where the current Employee Assistance Plan has one this goes all the way up to level and have counsel daily basis coordinate with Physicians start care or them in the 8 toe programs the program is built around providing daily support not just 45 minutes every week or two the program will not only address mental health but would also address phys physiological response we have during mental stressful events by identifying these Trigg either and help limit the severity but even if it is a severe case it can offer a much higher level of offer Dr identified an available Grant fund here with Esser funds that came out during Co where this district has had difficulty spending approximately $50,000 of water so the price tag for this was designed to fit and it was was actually reduc and we are going to work with our HR department and roll out materials all staff because this is this is Cutting Edge I'm not aware any other such intensive questions yeah the question who pays for this um it's being paid for by federal s fund thank you Mike thank you very much foration um and I just want to highlight this was one of the items I think there was in weekend six you so thank you Dr making sure that these items are to theard MERS uh any other questions on anything in section number n 9.22 sure yeah Communications are they working for us yes and they're increasing we're we're in the process of working with them on a project to start to advertise the programs that we have going the district so I've met with them just email the principles to start to at publicize our programs those things so they are so no one oh no actually they are there'll be more of that there's going to be something on uh you know the the uh engineering program theual program all those things so people really get an idea of the great things that are going on in the district because I think we have too many things that because people aren't in the schools they don't know about so so the one obervation I I think this was part of our original plan um it was kind of dependent on restructuring the websites and it may be something that they've de prioritized in their work or maybe we didn't have to to do the idea of having our administrative team have U more freedom May a little bit more freedom in getting content out on school sites as well and I know that there was a line in uh proposal for that but maybe refocusing them on training resources support to make sure that we take a little bit of the load off Central distribute for any other questions about 9.22 any other questions about anything in section n General can we have a roll call please Mr yes Mr Dawson yes M Gazo yes Mr zco yes m l yes Mr Min yes Mr bmer yes Mr J yes motion thank you sir we are up to item number other matters to come from the board I just want to congratulate the uh Middle School worlds I was at a game last night and I so happy undefeated straight so far and uh the community support for our team the sportsmanship that our our team presented um I it made be very proud and I wanted to thank the coaches the staff and parents that have help helped us all so excellent I think the the Middle School athletics programs right now in general are doing really well uh including the two new soccer teams that we started I think [Music] great things um I want to thank the robotics team for what they did at the bridge M Mall while back um we went there on a Sunday and my seven-year-old had a complete blast to the point now he's went around the house acting like a robot and talking like a robot so like if I I actually have to a little to punch into my phone a command for him to do something so he had a had a and yeah was awesome that's great thanks for Shing at this point to the public for General discussion I will forego the reading of the entire statement but just note that if you would like to address name address and affiliation you have no comments online com it number 13 move to go into exec session under items one so just one and three tonight oh I'm sorry sorry can I have a motion motion thank you second second is not clean they unmuted all right welcome back we are up to item 14.1 being resolved at the B of [Applause] Education this is item 142 have a motion motion thank you Mr B second second thank you Mr Zoll Mr B yes yes M cazino yes Mr zco yes yes Min yes yes thank you be it resolved that the Board of Education approved the resolutions and outlined HIV cases under middle and elementary schools this is 152 I have a motion motion thank you Mr B second second thank you Mr Dawson thank you roll call please Mr B yes Mr Mr yeso yes yes yes Mr yes yes to item 16.1 I will entertain a motion to adjourn motion than Mr B second second thank you m all in favor
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT YouTube / BPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education Meeting · passage 2
and on the 25th is the meet the candidates event at the whiner um cafeteria I believe at 7:00 p.m. there's a trunk retreat at the volunteer fire department on the 28th election day is Tuesday November 7th and there is no school for students on that day um CES has the book fair coming up next week October 19th to the 27th starting this week actually and early release for conferences next week the 25th 26th and 27th and whiskin has the wathon tomorrow the book fair October 23rd to the 27th and they also have conferences and an early release on November 15th and 16th and as we said before BHS has the homecoming Carnival in game this Friday October 20th the homecoming dance at the Amber Room the 28th and they also have conferences with an early release on November 15th and 16th that's all I have okay okay so that's it for our meeting tonight I want to thank everybody who was watching for uh sticking in there this was probably one of our longer meetings that we've uh I think had with this board for a while um and meeting first meeting right God bless you um and uh without unless there's an objection we are adjourned thank you are we having our next meeting at C going to right there [Music]
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 10/… · passage 2
and we will convene with Open Session the board took no action during Clos session and with that we will move on to item 3.3 which is the flag salute so please stand States all righty uh moving on to student reports so like we always do at our regular board meetings we are going to start off with some student reports and I would like to introduce Jessica Camp from Marsh and I see students ready right up in the front of the room so this is GNA be fun well I will say you're definitely in for a treat um I don't get to get up here often so I would just like to thank a few people um first of all I want to thank our community for passing prop 28 that went to support our music education that allowed us to purchase some additional instruments um as well as um repair some instruments that were in desperate need so thank you for that um the you know the amazing thing about music is it's really something that is super inclusive and really takes down the barriers allowing students to explore and learn and um it is often shown in studies that music also helps with academic performance because it really is like learning another language um and tonight I am so excited to introduce to you our Marsh Gators and they are going to be doing a some drumming from our drumming class Jessica are these the new instruments we bought your money went to a much better cost but I will tell you um students start off on these and they also get to use the much larger drums in our concert performances hello hello my name is Trey Petty and I'm pleased to introduce our Marsh drumming class in our class we learn the basics of reading Rhythm drum technique and perform etiquette we are excited to perform three songs for you this evening our first song is a duet called sideways d [Applause] my name is Aaron Meadows and I would like to introduce our second song it is another duet called two-headed monster [Applause] my name is Kate Mt Gibbon and on behalf of our class I would like to thank our principal Jessica camp for inviting us to perform tonight and to the Chico Unified School District Board of Directors for allowing us to do so thank you everyone in the audience for letting us share our hard work and progress our final song uses an electric backing track and it is called superbeat I hope you enjoy and have a lovely evening e [Applause] I would like to introduce our members Trey JJ William Jasper Aaron and Me Kate do you have any questions um Mr King and Mr crispino and Jessica C can we ask for some of our favorite songs and you guys could play them for us maybe thank you guys very much excellent presentation thank you Mr King you can come back anytime that was great okay while they are clearing out I'm going to invite up Emma Wilson principal Courtney Conley I'll wait I know it's dangerous hi everybody thank you so much for having us tonight we're super excited uh we have our third grade students and team here tonight to present about uh a longstanding tradition at Emma Wilson um I won't spoil any of the surprises I'm going to invite my third day third grade team to come up and students come on up and I'll let them introduce themselves and explain a little bit about what we do I'm just gonna bend down here everybody's Elementary SC size tonight um good evening thank you guys so much for having us we are third grade representatives of Emma Wilson Elementary School third grade focuses heavily on but County history and every year we do a month-long thematic unit on the Mau tribe of BU County students have been learning about pre-old Rush era clothing homes artifacts and tools they've also been studying the culture beliefs and customs of the Mau tribe both past and present we have a few students here tonight that would like to share some of their in-class creations with you tomorrow night all of our third grade classes will have a mighty Museum night in our classroom rooms where families are welcomed to come to school from 6:00 to 6:30 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-19 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 10/… · passage 3
to see their students learning come to life we would love if you would attend hi my name is Aubrey and I'm going to share with wait hi my name is Aubrey and I'm going to share with you about the might clothing in the summer the ma do wore a few pieces of clothing the men wore breach cloth made from buck skin or wire grass the women wore aprons made from grass Willow buck skin or shredded bark both men and women wore deer skinn moccasins in the winter the mighty wore more clothing to keep warm they wore deer skinn leggings and fur and the fur was to turned toward their legs for warmth they also wore fur robes and woven Ducker Goose feather blankets the mighty stuffed their moccasins with grass to keep their feet warm and dry women wore basket hats during ceremonies the special and special Gatherings men put their hair in hair nets made from plant fibers the men also painted their bodies for these events some Mau had tattoos on their faces and upper body they also wore belts headbands made from feathers both men and women had long hair they also wore jewelry such as necklaces bracelets and anklets the jewelry was made from bone shell feathers and wood here are some examples of ma do doll dress for summer and winter this one is Summer and this one is [Applause] winter hi my name is Paige and I'm going to share with you about the M's homes the maer built different kinds of homes depending on the seasons the mountain might lived in bar covered houses to build these homes the M made a circular frame of upright poles then they cut large slobs of Redwood or Cedar workk they tied the bark to the frame then theyed the door with animal fur in the summer these hos kept out the hot sum allowed the early morning or late night breezes to cool the inside and the the Mau who lived in the base of the mountains lived in Earth in homes to build these homes the maer first dug a hole in the ground then they built a wooden frame Over the Hole they covered the frame with woven Tuli mats or grass they then they packed Earth on top of the MS this allowed them to stay warm and dry during the Rainy Seasons families would enter these homes through the smoke hole at the top of the Dome here are some examples of the earn home and the hubot I built an earn home this one's an earn home and this one's a hubo hi my name is NOLA and I'm going to share with you one of the MA's tools twice a year salmon come up into the streams and rivers to lay eggs during this time there are lots of salmon in the water it was the best time for the Maru to trap net or spear lots of f fish the problem with catching so many fish at once is that they can't all be eaten there are just too many the ma do have a way of keeping the meat fresh so they could use it later in the year they saved the fish by drying it out to dry the fish first the ma cut the fish into big pieces the pieces were put on dry racks each rack was made out of wooden poles tied together with grass or strips of leather the rack of fish was set up in the sunshine the heat of the sun was made out of sun made all of the water in the meat disappear sometimes the Heat and smoke of the fire was used to help dry the meat the he cooked the water off the meat uh and the smoke of a fire was used to help dry the meat the the heat when the meat was all dried out the pieces were packed on a rock and pounded they pounded and pounded until all that was left was the meat powder meat powder put into baskets and stored until the mighty wanted it here's a model of the drawing rack I built [Applause] thank you for having [Applause] us just a estimate to how far our teachers will go uh when preparing for lessons um Alicia did go up to where was it went up by the res and in harvesting some of the wood for the uh for the um for the structures um she was attacked by a swarm of ground wasps so we appreciate the dedication do you have any questions for us um how many members of the local Maud tribe uh actually come in person to talk about some of this stuff I have a student whose family is a tribal member and their uncle is going to zoom with us on Monday he lives in Washington um every year we usually have at least you know a handful of students that so you want to use the microphone we can't hear the responses um also every year depending on um what resources are available last year we went on a field trip to Chico State because in one of their museums they had some resources um pre campfire we used to go to the gold nugget Museum and they had a whole ma day there so every year it looks a little bit different but we do um try to incorporate the ma tribe as well um if one of you wants to reach out to me I I have I know an old woman here in town who is a Mau and grew up in Mau community in the mountains so I'd be happy to put you in touch with her and I'd like to think she might want to come talk to the class thank you so much I'll send you an email tomorrow and I just want to compliment your students on their public speaking skills it is tough to get up in front of an audience and be live streamed and you get they were just wonderful public speakers thank you so much very proud of you girls did a great job thank you again for giving us some time tonight so I'm gonna do a quick transition here while we have Courtney at the microphone okay she'll be right back thank you Phil because I don't know if I can keep that posture for very long um and so thank you again we have the opportunity tonight to um honor one of our staff members for the superintendence award um again I'm Courtney Connelly the principal at Emma Wilson this is Antonia rothy she is our office manager and she's going to be helping me share some kind words um about our targeted case manager miam Mariam would you like to join us up here we're lucky we got her here tonight she uh she almost she almost tricked me um so we really appreciate the time um and opportunity to honor one of our most loved and appreciated people on campus at Emma Wilson Miriam baldit uh as you may know over the last five years we've had a lot of transition in our front office and Miriam has been the constant um she's been the consistency that keeps theol keeps the school running we joke about her institutional knowledge because she's been there longer than any of us um and she's been there the whole time um but she really is the person that holds the knowledge of what we've done what's worked what hasn't worked uh what we should never do again um and she always comes to the table with ideas about how we can make things better she really is focused on she's solution focused all the time uh many staff families and students wanted to contribute thoughts uh and stories about um how important Miriam is to our school family and our school community Miriam is a gift to our school site her humble quiet welcoming heartfelt and efficient work behind the scenes as an amazing support for our students and families she truly cares about our staff and students she provides incentives for students to be at school to be on time or even to complete tasks at home she is a role model and a mentor for many of our students she magically delivers sorry she magically delivers snacks to classrooms for Hungry students in need the Stray alarm clock for a student to independently get to school bus passes rides holiday gifts clothes help connecting with medical supports she creates charts for parents to help with home routines and even provides a kind listening ear for parents who need support with all of the home things that ensure success at school one time she actually furnished a complete apartment for a family that was just transitioning onto their to in their on their own um she's that good she really she really really dug into our resources at school and and it was it was awesome Miriam is such a wealth of knowledge she always has the answer to everything not sure how she does it but she does and being the primary Spanish Spanish translator at school she has really become a pillar to our Spanish speaking families at school she has become the connection for them uh to really feel connected to really feel a part of the school Community our team is so appreciative of her knowledge of special education she has been an invaluable invaluable resource when helping our Spanish-speaking families learn about their child's IEP she is great at diffusing tense situations and will willing to reach out to families and help them with any needs they have we are so fortunate to have such an amazing amazing colleague and friend at Emma Wilson if anyone embodies the heart of Emma Wilson it's Miriam she is such a fabulous advocate for our students and their families she goes above and beyond to break down barriers for parents Bridging the home to school connection for those who have not had positive experiences with education Miriam's door is always open and if it's not I just knock on the wall because we share a wall uh she has the biggest heart and she approaches situations with a genuine compassion and thoughtfulness she is quick to jump in with impactful Solutions and ways to help families in need of support um and she is just always a safe space to go to for advice or for a laugh Miriam is one of the most hardworking caring compassionate thoughtful generous empathetic and kind people I know we are so blessed to have her as a part of our Emma Wilson team and from families Miriam makes us feel welcome at school she's helped us get the things we need to help our children we appreciate Miss Miriam when we were new at Emma Wilson she made us feel like we were at home and from students Miss Miriam makes it fun to be at school she is my favorite person when we really need help we go to miss Miriam I love it when she is in The Lunchbox and I love hanging out with her while I wait for the bus students families and staff all count on Miriam for a friendly smile empathy knowledge and practical Solutions Miriam truly makes the world including Emma Wilson a better place I mean she's just incredible in addition to taking care of and supporting 77 staff members 617 students and countless families each year she's also an amazing wife daughter granddaughter sister friend and mother and on a closing note dear dear Mom my mom is kind she makes me pancakes she reads stories at night I love my mom love Angelo we all love you Mariam you're wonderful and we couldn't do it without you thank [Applause] you the the things that we received from people so uh I knew you didn't want me to talk all night but I could if if you'd let me we let her dry her eyes before we get a picture thank you so much thank you we appreciate [Applause] you if I might ask how many years have you been been at Emma uh Miriam I'm sorry how many seven oh thank you it's like they knew exactly how long to make their Spiel before to make her to make her tear up because she almost made it okay well while we're spreading good news I'd next like to invite up Shannon Payne thanks Phil for the mic raise for those of us who are a little taller um good evening board Miss da in cusd community uh we're always trying to trick our staff members into coming here because as you know teachers in a general rule are humble um and they don't always like to be celebrated publicly um so I got away with it all the way until Mrs Lumberg saw all our friends so I'm going to invite Shelby up here because she's not mad at me [Applause] anymore I could talk about Shelby lomberg for a hundred years um but I'm going to keep it quick um it's an honor to sh celebrate Shelby Lumberg tonight who we tricked into coming because she thought she was going to be speaking about language arts instruction in kindergarten she's passionate about it um I want to start with she is truly one of the humblest teachers that I know um I've worked with many teachers over the years and she is truly amazing at what she does and I have the highest respect for kindergarten teachers because that's where it all begins for our children she's a 16-year veteran I could be off by a year or two she did a few of those years in East LA and then she came to Citrus and she's been at Citrus for 13 years teaching kindergarten uh no other grade creates the impression on a family that kindergarten does do um this is the Imp this impression is critical to the relationship between the school and the family for years to come Shelby embodies the epitome of relationship building compassion warmth in her classroom that is needed to form deep bonds with each family she supports in her room with a firm but gentle demeanor and genuine love for her young learner she creates a nurturing environment where each child feels valued and understood Shelby quite simply said is a warm demander skillfully balancing high expectations with empathy and encouragement motivating her students to strive for excellence in their academic and personal growth which we know there is a lot of in kindergarten her instructional approach is a testament to her dedication to providing top tier education to all Learners as she tailors lessons to meet each of the diverse needs of her students all while fostering a love for learning from the very first day they step into her kindergarten classroom beyond the classroom Mrs Lumberg is a deeply Community oriented person she is always engaging parents to create a more supportive Network for her parent for students and our school beyond the classroom Shelby builds our Citrus Community through her acts of service to our PTA and as our site union representative she is in fact our number one recruiter for parents on the PTA board yes I don't know what we would do without Shelby in this position um but if you're a parent in Shelby Lumber's kindergarten class she's got work for you Shelby acts as a compass for our school as one of the longest tenure teachers at Citrus she is deeply respected by all she guides both students and fellow Educators myself as an administrator with her wisdom experience and dedication to the betterment of her Citrus community and her family and I will say she is a mother of three busy children and she still has all this to give I have no idea where she comes up with it all Shelby's impact reaches far beyond the walls of her classroom at Citrus and I am incredibly grateful to work with you every day thanks [Applause] Shelby [Applause] and I will turn it back over to you madam president all right thank you that was a lot um congrats on the awards we are doing such good work out there we as in everybody else I'm just here to help run the meetings um uh I'm really grateful I'm just G GNA take this time for a second to our district and the elementary schools as a parent who is now looking at putting my kid in school next year for TK it's hitting me really hard at how hard of a decision I have to make for my kid and how impressed I with everybody that works in this District so I appreciate all that you do especially coming from a growing up mother um and with that uh number six is announcements um with with that comment um next week on Tuesday we have the TK kindergarten um Roundup um Fair thank you I hopefully there's information in everybody's hands about that who do have kiddos going into TK or kindergarten next year it's a good opportunity to meet and greet um all the folks from all the schools and um get a feel for what your kiddos is going to be entering into um next year uh are there any other announcements from board members this evening all right um seeing none we'll move on to number seven items from the floor uh items number floor is for speakers from the public who wish to address the board regarding a topic that is not currently agendized uh this evening at this time we'll take public comment from speakers who wish to address the board for for those topics that are not agendized lots to celebrate out there um as a reminder speakers have three minutes to um address the board and a bell will ring at 30 seconds um which is an indication that you have that much time to wrap up your thoughts and um then at the end of the three minutes um your time is up uh so we do have four uh folks signed up for items from the floor this evening um we have a student and so I will call that person up first and then three more folks um so up first would be Ida patino followed by Carrie Park hi my name is Ida patino I'm a fourth grader at rosale uh so last week we were lining up for recess when the boy in front of me was pulling his eyes back and badly imitating the Japanese and Chinese language and saying I'm a pretty Japanese girl another time we reading something about indigenous peop when a girl asked I wonder what their language sounds like probably something like some other kid responded before makinging up a bunch of nonsensical words if you're wondering what I'm getting at or what my point is it's that these kids aren't just white and honestly not many of them are even trying to be mean you see many kids don't know what racism is and don't know the impact on their their words may have on their classmates a lot of kids don't or just can't understand the difference between fun and games and races which is why I propose anti-racist education now my class and I'm pretty sure all the other fourth grade classes do something called Second Step it's where twice a month the counselor comes in and talks about how to navigate your feelings and uh how to stand up to bullies stuff like that well one thing that they never talked about is racism now now I get that some parents might argue but this would just teach about how to avoid accidentally hurting someone's feelings in Second Step they use the world racism sometimes but they never actually Define it or explain how to avoid it I'm here today today on my on behalf of my classmates at rosale asking you all elected representatives to invest in or provide anti-racist education to all K to2 students in our district I want school is to be a safe place for everyone especially the bip students who seem to be the butt of these racist jokes freed alone without being judged by things we simply cannot control that are skin Hue how we talk and the families we come from thank you for your time I know I'm just a kid but I hope you prioritize this and put it on your next agenda and again thank [Applause] you thank you AA up next we have Carrie Park followed by Mele Benz hello uh I'm a mother to six children my youngest four are in your District at four different schools three are thriving and one is barely surviving his academic team last year recommended he attend this particular school and program in order to best support his academic and emotional uh needs while he was anxious he was also very excited to start a new chapter and meet new friends he woke early on the first day dressed to look his best that was also the first day The Bullying started and it has only increased my son is African-American and transgender and the most courageous child I know day after day he marches onto that school campus with his head held high only to have kids call him names including the n-word too many times to count they intentionally misgender him they've threatened multiple times to beat him up and one kid even told him he should kill himself he frequently begs me to not let him go to school twice I have allowed him to stay home for mental health days this child is smart and a critical thinker he loves math and science yet I confirmed at a meeting with several administrators last week that he hasn't actually learned anything this week this year due to the bullying in an attempt to keep my child safe the school has tended to move him around isolate him in safe places like the library and other rooms where no students happen to be that period he's missing out not only on learning but on social aspects too it was even suggested that I transfer him to another school within your District where he might have more allies moving my child on an hourly or daily basis does not solve this problem the problem is highly significant and deeply rooted this is not an issue of a dozen out of control bullies on one campus this is serious hate motivated Behavior which is rampant on many campuses I respectfully implore the board to take an unambiguous stance against hate motiva Behavior across the district consistency and mandated action from the top will be far more successful than leaving each school to figure out their own solution I'm speaking tonight only about my amazing son and I know firstand there are other parents who could stand here and share their similarly sad story about their child as uncomfortable as it is for me to stand here in front of you all my child deserves to have his rights fought for before he becomes a statistic all our children have the right to be safe at school thank [Applause] you I M Ben next followed by Dr Christine lner good evening I'm here tonight with the noral anti-racist ISM coalition to follow up on requests we've made to the board and to District leadership on August 21st our Grassroots organization sent a letter to the board requesting you to review and update board policy 5145 point9 this policy's purpose is to protect students families and staff members from hostility related to their identities as our group reviewed the policy we saw that it was lacking in a number of ways our group formed last spring after Chico unified's bipac elcap meetings revealed unmet needs in our community tonight you're hearing about a student whose intersectional identity can be marginalized in Myriad ways he is experiencing bullying in his Junior High and his administrators are struggling to find Solutions I can empathize as a former administrator we are asking you the board to take action to create safe and supportive learning environments by strengthening your policy we have provided samples that serve as models in terms of clarifying what hate motivated behavior is the samples also explain how to respond and they show how to prevent hate be hate through evidence-based practices and ongoing training when we met with Miss dby and Miss Robinson last month we didn't hear a commitment to action we heard in instead that there are practices underway that will improve outcomes for students of color while we see there are promising programs like PBIS and mtss we have asked the district to provide data that allows us to serve as accountability Partners we are concerned that action specific action needs to happen to support students from marginalized communities we've asked for this data uh four months ago we made our first request and we still haven't seen it we wonder how can a multi-tiered system of support work towards Equity when the data we're asking for is unavailable once again we are asking the board to agendize this policy we see a board with in congruent lived experiences from our own and NCA ncac offers our collaboration to help you work across different the time is now to support your staff and your students no one should have to face hate motivated Behavior without a strong system of support thank [Applause] you all right up next is Dr lyser I'm a part of the NorCal um anti-racist Coalition because I believe that everyone should be anti-racist racism hurts everyone it's it's a known fact that racism stifles Innovation there's a wealth of evidence that racial and ethnic diversity is beneficial to companies by enhancing creativity reach and Ingenuity research suggests that individuals that reflect anti-racist attitudes that Encompass high levels of informed empathy have high levels of Multicultural education more racially diverse friend groups more support for affirmative action in high levels of cultural sensitivity I'm here today because of the variety of stories I've heard about students parents and even staff stories where non-white students are being bullied and harassed at school by their peers their white peers torment them using hate speech the reaction by the district administrators is to wait until the child being bullied acts out in self- protection and then the district punishes the victimized child with no repercussions to the peers using the hate speech or what about the nonwhite teachers who are afraid of punishing white students who use racial slurs against them for fear of retaliation from the district or their parents stories like these are heartbreaking and we need stronger policies one we need a zero tolerance policy for hate speech any child on any campus who uses racialized hate speech should be suspended I don't care if their family is a good or decent family it's embarrassing that smaller districts with less resources can handle this better than we can for example in a small school in our region a child used a racialized slur targeting the latinx community the staff knew that this situation needed to be handled differently than other issues with students the parent of the victimized child was consulted by the school administration to provide feedback about how administrators could handle the situation in order to keep the victimized student safe this led to significant consequences for the student that used the racialized slur at the end of the day the student student created an unsafe learning environment and having these strict consequences will allow also set an essential boundary for parents who also use hate speech number two this brings me to the second policy point we need a robust and inclusive social justice education we need to teach all of our kids how to be good citizens how to have empathy for others how to treat other human beings with respect and dignity we need to teach our kids to be bystanders to stand up for other peers who are being bullied and discriminated against three all administrators need ongoing comprehensive training regarding anti-racist practices in the classroom again racism hurts us all all of our students administrators need to be equipped to handle hateful situations effectively without doing more harm or worrying if they will be punished for their actions thank [Applause] you okay thank you for everybody who signed up to speak um with that we will move on to number seven items from the floor sorry number just kidding I'm looking at the wrong thing sorry number eight consent calendar uh ex sorry uh I have you signed up to speak for 9.1.1 which is the Department of Education ethnic studies mandate did you sign up for two different items okay yeah I have you on the list for the next yeah thank you um okay so uh we're on consent calendar are there any um is there anybody who would like to pull an item from consent for further discussion okay um do we have a motion for consent I move the consent calendar second all right we have a motion from Member tennis and a second from Member conin we'll do a roll call vote starting with Mr Lando Lando I tennis I Dolby I Robson Robinson I con and I um it's unanimous it passes uh then next up after that my gosh make sure my numbers are all yeah I skipped the page already thinking I needed to go to the next page and the numbers were off for me uh we're on uh number nine our discussion action calendar we'll start with um Educational Services 9.1.1 is an informational item uh on the California Department of Education ethnic studies Mandy uh presented by Pedro Caldera good evening how we doing tonight I hope everybody's doing great want to start off with the California culturist class uh that we have begun discussing about uh between PV and Chico High we have five teachers from PV um you able to scroll up just the other way please uh up up up that's going down okay so um we have three teachers from PB and two from Chico high and we have been coming together approximately um once a week for the past four weeks to be able to take the California educational ethnic studies framework and put together a course recommendation please keep in mind that this course is not slated to start until the 25 26 school year and won't be required until the 20 uh 30 um graduating class so with that uh we have come up with the recommendation right now where we're currently at is the creation of a semester long class encompassing uh four uh groups if you will um and I'm just want to read over the course course over again this is directly from the California uh Department of Ved ethnic studies curriculum which states the California cultures course emphasizes African-American Cho Chana uh Chana X Latino Latino x Native American and Asian-American and Pacific Islander studies the focus on the experience of these four disciplines provide an opportunity for students to learn of the histories culture struggles and contributions to American society giving California's diversity the course in addition to the above disciplines can include ethnic uh disciplines that represent our community to include unique history struggles and contributions to our state and to Chico so what's important I think is how uh the rec recommendations have come across from our teachers if you look at in terms of timeline we're starting they'd like to start with the Native American uh group that was here before us so let's go with unit one and if we can go down to the next keep scrolling for me then we'd like to cover the Cho Chana Latino Latina uh experience then after that if you don't mind thank you right there our Asian-American and Pacific the paic Pacific Islander studies uh and then finally our African-American studies and so with that please know that we are still in the process of reaching out to community members and working with our constituents out in the public to be able to get resources to be able to provide some of these uh units for our students and for our teachers what are your questions what do you know about the uh I scroll up a little bit sure and I know this didn't come from you you didn't write this did you Mr cder you didn't like write no no no no like I said directly from the California Department of Ed framework like what do you know about environmental justice being on there why is environmental justice on an ethnic studies program in your opinion well it's very complex uh and you're asking for my opinion so I will give you my opinion there are certain environmental impacts that have compassed or or have taken Place throughout history um and how it has it affected Society you can start with agricultural uh homelands you can start with uh um uh any type of land if you will and land use and how that's been um well how that's been used throughout history um it's very complex and and so if you're asking me with the environment I'm giving you a response that it has to do with land and there's a lot of history through that and therefore these for ethnic study groups and how that has materialized throughout uh California and specifically for our case how that's materialized here in Chico yeah um thank you ped I in looking over uh what was in looking over what was going to be covered in the semester class I was concerned and I I did Express this to you about um how to get all of this stuff covered in these units in a semester class I was very impressed with the um backup materials for where the instruction was being built from I have um viewed and uh really enjoyed a lot of the um uh contributions from uh PBS from the uh okay the documentary is from PBS Dr Lewis Gates who's one of my heroes um and I wondered have they look they our teachers the ones you've been working with looking at this framework and believing that they can pull it together melt it down would be my impression I I do want to and I think you and I share the same ideas here there is a lot of content yeah um and I mean I I say this people do their doctorate uh studies and and I mean just one single discipline that's shown up there it's a lot of Education um in the conversation with our teachers the number one thing that keeps popping out is our teachers able to drive through with um making an impact um and create understanding and create thinking about the history and it doesn't necessarily mean taking everything because you're not going to be able to that's pretty much impossible but you can take certain sections of that history and have students learn from it and grow from it and that's really the intent of this class is to be able to create some Unity amongst the schools create understandings within our public so that we become stronger together yeah I the importance of this I don't think can be overstated yes that is correct I I am so looking forward to the impact that this course of study is going to haveen some of the things that we are witnessing and living through right now in our schools I think would have been um helped avoided our students having more um empathy and understanding for people of other races of other cultures that's missing my opinion I'm you know and um we need this I agree we do need this but I also do not want to discredit a lot of the work that our teachers have been doing over the years um to bring about very tough situations in our history and our society and um I I can honestly State I I work with the gentleman by the name of David McKay we started the soul program together and we work with nothing but uh diverse students and I mean to create understanding with them um to create uh historical significance and provide that to our students we weren't the only ones plenty of teachers across Chico high and PV that are reaching out to our students to try to connect with them through historical significance uh it's just never been like done the way it's done across the state so my next question is at what um you know we have different levels uh of coursework of course presentation and expectations what level is this projected to um you know we we my concern is that all our students no matter what their ability to read and understand you know what's being presented that their level of being able to do that is um going to keep them not only involved but deep understanding this course is that comment or question that's a comment what level is the course so that course is 9th through 12th grade ad G yeah so there it's a ad G okay yeah I can say just to kind of step in on that is that um right now like Health they can take it in nth grade 10th 11th and 12th most of our students takeen in ninth grade um they they have the opportunity to takeen in any one of those grade levels but most likely a lot of them will um um do health and then ethic studies as a you know um one class first semester and the second class second semester one way or the other I would imagine that's the way it'll play out but um again the students have can choose what grade level that they take the course in also do want to state that um both schools and our Representatives took this uh course took it through their leadership uh took it to admin took it to the registers to be able to discuss what is the best way to implement this course that's mandated by the state so we're trying to get everybody's ideas and input into this so as it stands right now um next semester will bring forth this recommendation it being a semester long class I just need to say that I'm I this Falls really flat for me I am almost zero% impressed with this outline and I don't have the words formulated well enough besides the emails I I the email I sent out earlier with my questions but there seems to be no room for context about what has happened with these cultures historically that has led to what we see how we see this play out today the people who are present today living their experiences and why those experiences have been shaped by the atrocities that have been imposed upon these cultures in the past um or present and I just don't feel very supportive of this whatsoever looking through the um the linked document that goes to like other course approvals I found one half semester one one semester course um from gold Golden Valley and even they do it better um with starting with an intro at ethnic studies as an identity and at least talking about what identity means this outline others to me there's a very big aspect of othering and not taking a look at and dissecting what it means to live in in a society where these cultures are all interacting and every person's experien is based on the the the history of of their um lived experiences um as a as a as a culture um I don't have more to say at this time because I'm just a little bit amped up from not only our public comments that just took place but also just feeling like there's so much more that can be put into this and done with this looking at it from the perspective of of you know a mandated course just checking the box is I think an atrocious approach rather than taking the approach of what's going to be the most meaningful for our students moving forward in this society that we are living in today and with that I'm gonna just step down for a second thank you um and I don't want to pile on recognize this is um a process and um as first draft SCH gives us some place to start abolutely I'm trying to walk a line here because on the one hand wearing the board member had right now when I'm also a social studies teacher and this is really near near to my heart um but it does um it reads more like a survey of California disper California histories than an actual um ethnic studies class I think maybe instead of having each um individual identity block as a unit doing something thematic instead with an emphasis on howby said how all that affects us that people living in St today um there's a lot to say I would love to see um how this shapes up in the future we're all looking forward to that we as this being an introductory class or sorry the beginning of this class it's going to take our teachers some time to build up to it and to know it and understand it there was conversations uh within our group it's like okay great if we go from semester long class how did we turn it into a year-long class to be able to go into more depth and detail um and so that's a topic of conversation that still continues and will probably continue once the class gets started I know there's a lot of history to the development of this specific thing and um a lot of people weighed in there was an initial version of it that sort of got rejected and heavily revived and you know one common criticism of it is that uh or has been that you know there's a lot of ethnic groups that aren't given as as much treatment as some of the ones that are you know um you know the Jews come to mind for example um Thomas Elias who's featured in our local paper writes about this with some frequency actually but um that's just by way of observation I mean it's a big broad topic and I agree that this looks like a little bit like um a bit of a mish mash um I thought environmental justice piece particularly kind of jumped out to me as like not necessarily a direct hit on ethnic studies given that there are so many different ethnicities in California I mean we've got to be one of the most diverse places in the world you know um and uh so my hope for the district would be that we would try to approach this in a a global manner that would give uh you know a regard and consideration to you know all the different ethnicities that are that are among us because there are many yes there are um I can tell you that the guideline did specify to be able to answer your question is to be able to uh concentrate it with the uh the most uh I guess uh bigger groups of the diversity groups if you will within the community so therefore these four there are plenty of more ethnic um minorities in Chico plenty plenty more and they can be interwoven uh Within These for example the M uh Within These um Middle East can be uh interwoven um and that may be um that being said you know just following the California Department of Ed guidelines and framework that's that's where we're at I'm still scrolling through the very long document um uh I'm on 671 uh of of the other course outlines that have been submitted and approved by CDE um and something that stands out to me is uh Missing besides just the intro and talk about what is identity and culture um are um our Muslim and Arab units um I don't see that addressed at all and that seems like a pretty big portion of folks that are are are impacted that do live live that live live all around us with our society I'm othering right now this is the way I'm speaking I have not been able to formulate my thoughts completely um but as a very minor example um a student of mine from the past very dear to me reached out last year asking why aren't our schools talking about the Armenian gen genocide and you know that's a big deal there's genocides that are happening right now and why aren't we talking about that in the context of multiple cultures and why some of these families have immigrated here even as recent as this year because of those things that are happening and how that impacts us as a society and a culture and and you know just making sure that we're all presently aware of of everybody else's lived experiences and understanding that everybody sees their experience through their own lens and understanding that we need to take that into consideration just as as citizens of this community I agree wholeheartedly with that statement um granted that you it's it's going to be impossible to incorporate every single minority within this even if it was a year-long class even if it was a two or three yearlong class it'd be very difficult what you do do as Educators you create um if you will relationships and you create understanding and when you create understanding you also create a sense of oh my gosh I got this in with you oh my gosh I got this in common with you I can stand up here and as educator I can give you thousands of examples but let me just give you one um I was an NE teacher at Chico High my very first job ever in NE was I had a group of nine mon students if you remember when um our our we you know Chico UniFi received a gift we'll call them the M population and I had these students in my class these awesome students and communication was difficult but once we got there there was a beauty you name it that that was just incredible now and one of those things it's called um the guena which means 40 days in the mon culture there was 40 days after a woman gave birth that they could only eat chicken and I know that sounds like okay well that's whatever ever the beauty in all that is that was the same thing in certain places of Mexico for example in my father's and my mom's small hometowns in Mexico where it was the exact same thing we're talking thousands of miles apart yet the commonality was there and what that created was unity and what that also created was understanding when they started sharing commonalities within themselves it also created acceptance we're not going to be able to hit every single thing but we can create understanding and acceptance and so I think that's important not to forget the focus of that because it's just impossible sure and I think that that circles back a little bit to what Mr Lando was saying about a thematic approach you know it kind of opens up the opportunity to make those connections a little bit more purposeful I guess maybe but I'm not a social studies person either per se although I am involved in politics so I guess it makes me a little bit involved with social studies um Mr tennis I can address the environmental justice thing but we don't have to do that right here thanks for sharing that yeah absolutely thank you oh I don't know if you're done I was you I was just saying thank you all right I get more opportunity to talk well you have some catching up to do because you know you're new so we have to keep keep you in the hot seat as much as we can absolutely keep you warmed up ped yeah any other questions or comments for now what's oh go ahead oh my my question comment is not a question it's a comment um I really appreciate the input from other board members and from your additional input for this this is complex complicated but so important so all of us keep contributing yeah and I I would add to that something that you had said a moment ago Mr Caldera is that um while this is new and you know we're looking at implementing a brand new thing in our schools we're not the only ones and the wheel has already been created you it's not like we have to reinvent the wheel either that is correct yeah so I would also encourage everybody to keep that in mind um because it's already a slow roll out in my opinion so things to keep it even slower is not not in my best opinion that is why we started early and uh of course the class does not need to be implemented until 25 26 uh but the goal is to start early uh involve our community and um get ideas and and grow from it so on that note what are the next steps in terms of getting input from the community and getting another draft together next step is taking your recommendations and going back to our group and having that discussion and please tell them I'm grateful I'm not just here to like them and I hope that they don't at me right now bet I'll do that they're not it's hard work but it takes it takes everybody with everybody's shared perspectives to make something as meaningful as a well-rounded ethnic studies program yeah we know and when we took this song we know it wasn't going to be easy um and we kept going back to you know the most impact we're going to be get from all this is what our teachers doing in the classroom and we know that so I think that yes and the potential for greater growth in our students and better outcomes as Citizens that this opportunity May provide so the relationship classroom yes and what that what the product of that will be it was really substantial anybody else okay sorry all right going once twice you're excused all right thank you all right just kidding thank you P um all right so it is informational only um we have one speaker signed up for this it item and we will um call Gina back up at this time um for public comment um I know that you know the the Spiel and the drill and I've never been here before I don't know what I'm doing okay good evening well I'm going to talk about latinx I'm here to request the term latinx not to be used to refer to people from Spanish speaking Origins as mentioned on your ethnic study course this term is Walken latinx is a pronoun Latina in Latino is the correct description of our ethnicity here is the thing every Spanish noun has a specific gender either masculine or feminine but they can also be singular or plural so every word for person place thing or idea is either masculine or feminine sorry that's just basic grammar now let's talk about how Hispanics really feel about being called Latin X the gender neutral term promoted by progressives to describe people of Spanish speaking origin in support of his Hispanics LGBT members Ruben gajo head of the Congressional Hispanic costos campaign arm announced in December of 2021 his Congressional staff is not allowed to use latinx in official Communications the Miami Herald one of the most prominent newspapers within the Hispanic Community also denounced the term and urge left leaning activist to just drop it latinx has failed to gain byin from the people it is supposed to empower it is time to retired from official use the Miami Herald editorial board wrote and Domingo Garcia president of the league of United Latin American citizens the nation's Olden oldest Latino civil rights organizations have instruct staff and board members to drop the dra the word latinx from the group's official Communications now let's talk about polls according to 23 percentage of USA adults who self-identify as Hispanic or Latino have heard of the term latinx and just 3% say they use it to describe themselves P Research Center found in 2020 bendixen and amandi international a Miami based firm focusing on Latinos found only 2% us it a poll conducted in recent years listen I don't know any Abita grandmother that calls her grand her granddaughter hey you latinx come here and need your rice and beans just doesn't happen Okay to close my statement I would like to remind this board that Latinos and Latinas also called Hispanics are people who are very proud of our culture and Origins and we want to pass that to our children what we care is about improving our quality of life for our families and future Generations not gender neutral terms thank you all right we will move on to item 9.2 business service uh 9.2.1 is a discussion action item for the 2223 un audited actuals shice good evening um Sharice and I are excited to present the 2223 un audited actuals Perfect all right um the UN audited actuals is actual revenues and expenditures for the year it's not a budget we're usually here to present budgets to you um and it's the true financial performance measurement um and this is the numbers before the annual audit is complete we did have the Auditors out to our site um the first week of October uh it seems like it's going well uh we haven't been informed of any audit adjustments at this point okay this is the um actual versus funded average daily attendance slide you guys are used to seeing this um as you know average daily attendance is how we're funded our lcff is calculated off of that that's ual kids in seats um preo we would kind of hang our hat at being around 95.5% um of actual Ada as a percentage of actual enrollment uh we haven't really gotten back there uh we're kind of inching our way that direction um the state recognized this so they're letting us use a three-year averaging method so you you can see on the slide on the left um there's that real dip in average daily attendance in 2122 but the slide on the right you can see that it really smoothed out our actual funding so that was a big help all right this is the income statement we separate unrestricted from restricted because the restricted uh revenue and expenditure are kind of um they are self-balancing accounts so sometimes we get all the funding in one year but we really are spending it over uh a multi multiple years so um the change in fund balance tends to dip up and down on the restricted side um for unrestricted we had an ending change in fund balance of 6.8 million all right let's look at our total revenue um local control funding formula is 65% this is total revenue um unrestricted and restricted so I took a look at um 1920 and in 1920 local control funding formula was uh 75% so we're seeing that more influx of uh restricted programs um with the co dollars uh you guys are aware over yes I'm sorry din but you just said something that I have a feeling just went way over my head okay you said in uh 2020 you I think you said 1920 but 1920 yes uh 1920 our local control funding formula was 75% of our total revenues and now it's down to 65% of our total revenues and that's because there's so many new restricted programs that they're giving us money for so back when uh lcff was created they were trying to take away all of the categorical funding and what we're seeing is a lot of that categorical funding is coming back didn't they take it away in in 2013 when we went to it started yes that's when local control funding formula came into to play but um it was kind of a slow progression to get up to that formula and now um now there's a lot of Grant funds coming back into the district what um impact is that having on our ability to control how we spend what we have does that make sense that question I mean with the coid funding that was a large influx it was um 60 million um and it allowed us to add a lot of things and that was I think you know the response the schools needed to respond to coid and what was happening with learning loss and whatnot so it allowed us to build up our programs and then we're still seeing some kind of replacements for that coid funding coming down the pike like learning a recovery block grant so that's grant money that's coming to replace all of that Co impact money that and is it coming in the form of state or federal or a combination combination but a lot of state right now okay thank you all right yeah okay and this is the look at our total expenditures um this is unrestricted and restricted and something I noted on this uh slide this usually you see this in the form of just unrestricted dollars um with the addition of restricted money our the needle didn't really move we're still spending the uh Lion Share of salaries and benefits expense on salaries and benefits um and that's because with the coid funding with a lot of the extra funding we're still we're still uh paying for people out of that funding we added counselors uh reading teachers class size reduction um site supervision uh expanding after school programs so so a lot of that money went towards salary anyway and this is uh unrestricted this is the slide you're used to seeing so unrestricted and special ed salaries and benefits is 89% of total expenses when you're just looking at unrestricted all right my last slide is uh the coid oops coid relief funding um this is the last year you'll see this slide from me because um the coid funding is sunsetting um in 2223 we spent 13 million 13 million on coid funding and we have 10 million remaining uh we will spend that by the end of this school year so items still funded out of coid uh we have counseling reading Pals uh replacement technology like uh the vionics and um after school support at the junior high schools and professional development so that's all for me Shar good evening I'm gonna that's slide is what number on is that eight that one should be eight yes and you just gave us some additional information on the 2223 or did you give us information on the total that's remaining that's really both years we funded the those things out of 2223 and what is still remaining and where is the list of what we funded you you you gave it to me verbally but I don't see it it's I can provide that to you but it's not on this slide oh okay I was looking for it yes if you if you could absolutely thank you yeah a follow on to that um just knowing that there's onetime money being used for those things and what are we exploring to continue funding those where are those funding sources going to be coming from that's kind of a broader concern I think to yeah and we'll actually we'll speak to that a lot when we come back to you with um first interim in December also and just talk about the programs that we're continuing on with different grant funding as well so we can make sure that we have a list of that as well yes okay thank you and I would just pipe in it's a very strong collaboration between the business service side and the ed services side with Jay and his team to make sure that everyone's aware of what positions were funded with onetime money because it's usually uh somewhat risky for districts to do so we just need to make sure that we're fully aware of what those positions are and then can they be funded with alternative funding or do they need to be eliminated at this point uh thank you that that's my big concern I've been there done that and um we've got a lot of stuff that's working that we funded with the coid dollars so I really as much lead time as possible to know what we're looking at in the way of what's not going to be if it helps e we've been having those conversations with ed services since the implementation of wasn't there I know but we can definitely share that as well with you when we come back for our next budget update that's my yep my biggest concern no you you should definitely I'm mostly concerned about Kevin bolon not coming back and telling me I told I told you so I told him we would I think you're probably think you're probably safe at this point gitlin okay just Kidd so part of year en close what we do is the last budget that we brought to you was in June we call estimated actuals um and that's the column on the left there and then we have un audited actuals which is where we actually ended the year so we like to make sure that we are doing an analysis to see what the differences were between our last budget and where we ended to make sure that everything looks like we didn't make some huge mistake or anything like that so amongst those different es um in lcff Revenue this was due to a prior year adjustment of inl taxes um the state did a wonderful thing and helped with our um attendance percentage they gave us some relief they also did that to the charter schools so this inl payment has to do with Charter school property taxes that we passed through and we didn't know about the factor that they were going to get for attendance until June so that makes it difficult for us to estimate in May um yeah go ahead I me oh okay just laughing at this okay well good I like to be entertaining so that makes me happy um state revenue that was a difference in the lottery rate increase um local Revenue we have to do an adjustment um per per the state and Per County um so they give us a percentage that basically says this is what your cash would be valued at if we had to close the everything right now and you know turn everything into cash and so um we had to do an adjustment there uh salaries and benefits those differences were due to overestimation of classified sick time um extra Duty and vacation payouts as well as stir and purs overestimations um books and supplies we tend to run into this unfortunately every year especially lately with uh with supply chain issues and so we hope that we're going to get stuff by June 30th but sometimes that doesn't happen and so those expenditures get rolled over into the next year um Services were lower due to rate switches we have a huge project uh John Vincent Our IT director just told me today that we got those switches so that makes me very happy um so that will actually hit this 23 24 school year but that affected our services as well as our books and supplies um and then transfers and contributions this de decrease um was due to a little bit of money that we got from the county office and then as well as um an overestimation of benefits so we do our best but sometimes we overestimate we're a little too conservative so that happened this time um as well as some contracts with other agencies that uh were lower than we estimated okay I'm raising my hand again transfers and contributions decreased due to a lower contribution to special ed than anticipated correct so we didn't have to contribute as much as we thought we were going to because we overestimated our expenditures and we got a little bit of extra money from the Sala so that meant less money going from the general fund into special ed in the amount of about $500,000 last year that encroachment was huge and scary and it's still huge and scary we just it was a little less than we thought it was going to be when we came to it at at estimated actuals okay does that help yes well well so speaking of that yeah so our transfers in from other funds um we have the Redevelopment agency revenues that we get um that was about 3.7 million as well as 3% of our developer fees that we collect over the course of the year um our total was about 1.78 million of collected developer fees which is down from prior years so it looks like development slowing down a little bit which makes sense because we had huge developer fees coming in for quite some time um this is the part you were talking about Eileen so the contributions to restricted programs we ended at about 25.7 million and the big chunk of that is Ed our contribution was about $20 million yeah okay so we have luckily we have very healthy reserves yes go ahead I I'm that kid in the back of room again you're fine um we've also in years past I'm not sure if I remember if there was any last year but we've made um we've had impact from our um Food Services Department are we now now because of uh free meals for all that started a few years ago we haven't had to do a contribution to nutrition services for the last few years Vince must be happy he's doing a great job with the money that he has and so he's actually Surplus money we're going to do a big project um he's actually we it came to the board the freezer project that he's doing that's because of the money that we're getting and the amazing program that he's running so no we didn't have to do a contribution okay okay great thank you okay so this shows a breakdown of um our ending or our unrestricted ending balance by com by year by comparison just so you can see so as you can see um we have very healthy reserves which is fantastic um I don't know how many of you are aware of this but on Monday they actually delayed taxes again so the due date is November now which makes it hard for the state to know exactly what revenues are going to look like so this will help us a lot to weather any storms that we might have to deal with okay and then this is just a breakdown of our restricted ending fund balance by program um so that um expanded learning opportunities program those will be spent by the end of this year um educator Effectiveness that we are using over the course of four years um and it will help to maintain our counselors that we were just talking about so these are the funds that we're looking at uh when we're thinking about long-term what what programs can we continue maintain out of the staff that we added with the co funds okay and then you guys have seen this chart before as well um cash we have very healthy cash as well right now uh which is great in case the state has deferrals um it has pretty much the same pattern every year so we have a dip in November and March and then we get an influx of property taxes in December and April all right so conclusions um Revenue Revenue was driven by Ada or Revenue that is driven by Ada has been more stable uh luckily this last year they enacted the three-year averaging funding method so there's two there three now different funding methods that you can have with Ada it's either prior year current year or a three-year average yes I'm that kid again you're good um having a a little bit of background in attendance I know that yes we were at 95 when Co hit and that was wonderful it was very I mean it was very good it was as far as comparing us to the state it was very good and I know that it's gone down yes and we're at now but we need to be up how much do we lose between the 93% and the 95 that we used to have even with the um so if you're talking about about about a 2% change it would be probably about 2.7 million would be the the loss of funding that we would have yes so is it easy to in a chart or a graph or something show um you know like how many how many kids we're talking about because this is this is kids that parents are sending to school every day instead of missing once a month or Miss is there a way of providing that to us in a a chart form so that we know how important and not only we right the five of us but the attendance clerks at the school sites they pay a lot of attention to why it's important to get the kids to school not only because of their educational impact correct but I think it's important to help them by knowing right you know all those phone calls you make and and all of those you know alarm clocks that you provide right makes a big difference because it makes what that child is coming to school for uh flourish yeah the classroom is is the effects that would occur if you absolutely and I think that the classified employees having that information helps it's also at least I used to use it as a tool when talking to parents about you know the importance of attending every day or at least not missing one or two days in a month because parents get it when you talk about the money not going to the classroom impact yeah they do and it matters yeah um so it's an important bit of information to get to our staff as well as to our parents yeah Mr Robinson can I just clarify youring talking about a graph of what can you further explain just so we can provide you the correct information yeah um when um when attendance goes up when that when the uh when a school runs a an attendance data report you you will see um fluctuations in like times of year when there's more kids present than times of year when a a lot of our are not a lot some of our population go to Mexico for three or four weeks in January and we could see that reflected on the graph that I would run at the school site showing that absences were up and they tend to be up during uh right after probable failure notices come out and they tend to increase absences increase at the end when students have figured out I'm not going to pass that class anyway so I'm not going so for clarification so if I'm hearing you correctly basically the attendance percentage districtwide for every month in Aries and track that over multiple years to see when the dips and the higher rates are yes that's what I used to do and that would be wonderful okay so um the other things that we're thinking about is we're going to be cons continuing to spend down the remaining Co 19 relief dollars as Marie mentioned earlier uh 2324 will be the last year of those expenditures um as you saw a couple slides ago we have large restrict restricted ending fund balances which will help us to maintain some of our program um as I said we're looking with ad services to keep the learning recovery social emotional learning uh supports that we've implemented the last few years um and then just so you guys know we will come back to you in January with the audited financial statements um and that's all I have for you so any questions yep um oh my gosh old age just sit in I have no idea the question I was going to ask I have that problem too but it's not old age down I don't have question okay we will need approval of the unaudited actuals and Eileen if you think of your question you can always email me later okay um I see no public comment on this so I will ask the board if there's a motion yeah oh you got one here we go we found it it's because I stepped away rememberers at oh your mic's not on your mic's not on we had dedicated grant writers do we still have dedicated grant writer yeah Michelle Bunch oh Michelle is our gr writer yes yes very good okay I believe we have a motion by Mr Lando to approve the yes that un audited actuals I'll second that motion fantastic um any further discussion uh our last vote was unanimous so all those in favor please say I I I I I opposed it's unanimous it passes thank you uh moving on to 9.2.2 discussion action resolution number 161 9-23 the Gan Appropriations limit yes the Gan limit so um every year after approval of the UN un audited actuals we bring the Gan limit to you um it's uh generated by the Sach system and it was part of the big un audited actuals report that was included in your packet um the gan's really a formality at this point so um it doesn't really tell us anything it was established in 1979 to constrain the growth in state and local government but um it doesn't really do that at this point so anyway we are asking for approval of the Gan and there is a resolution um in there for you as well um I think I've moved this item in the past and I'm proud to do so again um I move resolution number 161 9-23 the gam Appropriations limit I'll second that motion see no further discussion all those in favor I I I I thank you thank you um 9.2.3 is discussion action oh how do you even pronounce that acronym amim am I IM amim discretionary block grant expenditure plan yes so the um um amim for shorts um which is the Arts music instructional materials that discretionary block grant um was approved with AB 181 and then there was some um changes related to AB 185 when the amount was um changed or taken back from the state as a way to have some budget savings at the state so we finally have our final um appropriated value which is 7.1 million so this plan does require board approval um at a public meting meeting it can be spent on four things which is standards aligned professional development and instructional materials diverse book collections any operational expense or cost which is the discretionary portion or any coid 19 related expenditures so in front of you this evening um is a proposed discretionary block grant plan um which in involves equipment replacement at our Center for Fine Arts at the CFA the entry and buzzer system um to be implemented at all Sites right now we currently only we have it at Park View and Emma Wilson um the other piece in here is increases to electricity we've seen um astronomical increases to PG the last several years um just between 2021 and 2122 it was up 700,000 and it was up another another 1.3 this last year um so we're looking to use some of these Monies to kind of offset that increase um temporarily in our budget um the other piece that we'd like to look at is uh 1350 East lass Avenue our tenants in the second building um vacated on September 30th so we no longer have tenants in that building um so we need to go into that building we need to paint flooring pull cabling um U redo the Ada entrance so it's the primary entrance out front um to get that up and running um to be used as a facility for chica unified and then lastly um 3.3 million allocated to our special ed program so that program um is flourishing of a large student population um last year it was up 7% this year it's up 9.3% the number I got as of this morning was 2,188 students um of our 12,000 students are students with IEPs um so looking to aark this 3.3 million to offset some of those expanded programs for those new students in our district and that's the 7.1 million that would be spent over the next three years before the 26 deadline June 26 deadline going back to the you mentioned a PG Bill going up a lot um you said that you gave a dollar amount that it had inreased do you have any percentages where it's up by block block oh it's between 15 and 20% over the last how many years two years it's significant and what we're seeing is time of day billing definitely impacts school systems so between I think it's 3 pm and 8:00 pm is like peak time and you think oh school's not in session except we have after school programs at almost all of our sites and we have sports um that are also at our facilities and so our facilities are really utilized Sunrise to sundown and then some um and so that is definitely playing a role um in this as well and just PG rates hikes themselves those have gone up 7% annually for the last couple years and I know they're going to the Public Utility Commission again I believe in January for additional increases do we um try to manage the um I'm assuming we have some protocols for trying to manage that so for examp for example if after school was program was going on over here in this building you know and you were using maybe one room of this building over here and you know there's some thought being given to this we're not just wanly you know just running everything into correct we have an energy management system that has set points for each classrooms and time of day so that it's not running 247 um that they end at a certain time they come in they kick on in the morning whether that's AC or um heating as we get into the cooler months um so that's all Reg ated through our energy management system yes and the other piece we are running programs longer into the summer as well which historically we haven't done other than the exception of esy um and now we're running our after school programs all June for nine hours a day and does any of that get allocated uh over to after school program costs this last year we did allocate a portion of it yes because the people funding I guess in some cases that would be us after school programs yes would want to know that cost was there yes and we did do that this last year okay thanks M Dy do you know um this is really just a kind of off hand question is there ever a um educational Presence at the Public Utility Commission meetings talking about this kind of thing addressing um you know PG needs normal and wanting money grabs I do not know the answer to that I put a thing on the agenda yet because I got to fill out a form but that might be something be interested in doing at some point later down the road and I can look into see whether any of the professional organizations are doing that casbo access thank you yeah some kind of advocacy or even if again if we could do like a letter of Yeah the more the more voices we can put out there for advocacy that that are we hope that someday the DC will stand up to them I don't have any faith in that it seems like the csba might have some regulatory lobbyist or something like that who would supposed to be paying attention to that kind of thing they certainly have lobbyists and I can ask whether or not this is something that's on their radar but it is impacting everyone so I'm sure it is uh so just for clarification you're asking for us to approve this expenditure plan that is correct and then we can spend accordingly okay um seeing that there's no public comment on this item do we have a motion from the board I move approval of the amim discretionary block grant expenditure plan oh second that motion okay we have a motion and a second uh do we have further discussion board yes please um so the first word in am am is Arts correct um and the specific text from the CDE uh talks about am I am grant funding being used for V foring Arts World Language math science English language arts history social studies ethnic studies financial literacy media literacy computer science I say that because I know we need these things it is really frustrating that we're spending $7 million of an Arts Grant with 50,000 of going to Arts so the voters last November um passed prop 28 and that's where we're getting our Arts and Music money so at the elementary level we hired um we got rid of sub based prep time for our elementary teachers and we hired additional Fine Arts and Music prep providers so that students are with a certificated positional teacher um throughout the day versus having a sub come into the classroom um when the teacher is taking prep so a lot of the dollars went there and then additionally at the Junior High in high school we have three years to spend the current year allocation so at the Junior High in high school they're spending some on supplies right now as you saw with our Marsh program not the supplies here tonight but as the marsh alluded to it um and then I know that at the secondary sites um they've allocated money to get additional Consultants to help with like marching band and the choreography related to that um so that's really where the Arts and Music money is coming from is an Al alternative pot and that pot is ongoing that py is in that money is in statute until the voters say we want to put it back on the ballot to say no we don't want that anymore this money is one time so I feel like it's more fruitful from an ongoing program perspective that we use ongoing dollars for that versus one time dollars I hear that again I understand we have operating costs and we need to cover them I just uh especially since we were talking about the ethnic studies um you know plan in the future it' be nice to have a funding plan to make that a really robust program at any I'm putting out there so it's on the record I know what we're doing thank you uh what's the timeline on on needing to approve this well the dollars have to be spent by June of 26 um but no dollars can be spent until the the plan has been approved by the governing board mam Madam president just making note of the fact that our entry camera and Brer system is one of the items on this list yep yeah and you said for all schools that need them yes this 375,000 will get us an entryway um camera and buz system for all of our school sites and that'll help us basically offsets what costs would have been gone from come from our bond correct yeah I'm I'm still mulling over something that uh that you said Mr Lando um about you know just even how small of a chunk could be carved out for additional consulting services for like the ethnic studies program if it was something that was would be beneficial um as a one time I mean that's a onetime expense also what could be a onetime expense do you have any do you want to expand on those thoughts or ideas anymore not at the moment I'm feeling fairly bad to not talking St about this ahead of time and just bringing on email sometimes there's lot of Ming pieces and like this list makes sense to me for sure but also you know knowing that there's there's other things that we could also be doing with it and it is extremely infuriating that we need to allocate $3 million towards electricity so that's where I would say is where we should be frustrated the most um or at least I am okay well if there's no other points of discussion now we can vote we were unanimous with a voice last time we were um okay well let's go ahead and do um actually just in case I want to do a roll call vote because there might be some NOS um Mr tennis I'll start with you since you made Mo tennis I uh Doby I Robinson I conen I Lando I reluctant okay thank you uh we'll move onward to 9.3 um 9.3.1 sorry let me get closer to my mic it's not a sensitive tonight which is nice but also I forget that I need to be closer uh 9.3.1 discussion action approval of resolution number6 620-2330 school year thank you president Doby it's a long title anytime the district no longer needs or no longer has the funds for a classified position uh we bring a resolution to the board to approve the elimination of that position um so our recommendation is for the to uh adopt a resolution to eliminate the single position I would like the board to note that is a vacant position position and uh we bring these to you each time we either no longer need it or no longer have the funds to support the position so since the funds are no longer available for the position those funds are being utilized elsewhere I'm assuming correct yeah and and again I want to note that the the position is banking as you can see in the uh the adoption uh the resolution document um it's an aid position at one of our elementary schools if the position wasn't vacant but then there was no funds for it what what's the protocol then do we just make it work well we'd get a hold of Michelle bunch and write a grant um we're always looking for options right always trying to because if the position is there and it's vacant and it's viable and serving kids we're going to figure out a way to make it happen so this position would you say this position is needed not but not filled so right it's not filled people haven't applied to have these point it's not even a full-time position but um but so so is there still a need for this at the school it's my understanding that there's not a need for this position okay thank you I was looking at Mr suven to see if he had any other answer but it's my understanding a lot of okay in this situation it's not needed okay thank you any other questions from the board public comment signed up motion I move approval of resolution number 1620 d23 I second okay we have a motion by member Robinson and a second by member conin uh we were unanimous last time uh this time we can uh any further discussion no okay uh Voice vote is fine um all those in favor please say I I um no opposed so it passes unanimously and thank you um onward to 9.4.1 um Mrs is under board discussion action approval of the revised updated new board policies so board policy 6174 education for English Learners was brought forward at our October 4th board meeting and it is now back for a second reading and approval we already asked questions about this last time I do believe I asked a question between meetings um uh about who who at the district level is uh in charge of administering the policy and um was there a second this particular policy will be um I think I helped answer that question did this particular and Mr suan obviously could speak to this too but this um policy here is overseen by ed services um and our team U Mr Sullivan ALS also oversees our eel programs and we also have two e coaches that we have that are uh teachers on special assignment that oversees our e programs that help supports our elementaries and our secondary sites on the on these programs and then each one of our site administrators also making sure that this policy is being followed Anna Mayfield and kayin rice are the kind of the coordinators that Jay was referring to the tosas that work with high schools down to the elementary schools with implementation of this policy a lot of meat in this policy it's they they are busy yes and and with that said they also have some support with some of those things like we have we call them blue jacket positions to kind of monitor student progress on their lpac scores so there's other folks involved with kind of monitoring some of these things as well that's built into our budget with some of those positions thank you um okay seeing no other questions for clarification and no public comment do we have a motion sure I move adoption of board Poli 6174 I'll SEC all right I'll second that motion we have a motion by Mr Lando and a second by Miss Robinson um all those in favor of adoption say say I I I opposed the pass is unanimous uh 9.4.2 is discussion action setting the date of annual organizational meeting of the governing board of a chica Unified School District proposed date December 13th 2023 you to keep giving me these long titles I know it this is the time of the year when we have to set our organizational meeting at the organizational meeting the board will determine the officers of the board you will set the meeting dates and times and the agenda format so we are proposing that that would be on December 13th the second Wednesday of the month due to the winter break as opposed to the sixth just because so typically we only have one board meeting in December and we put it in that second week and this I believe has to be set after a certain time in December okay got it great I don't have any more questions anybody else no no public comments uh motion I'll call for a motion I move approval of this item second we have a a motion yeah we have a motion by Mr tennis and a second by Mr Lando uh all those in favor I I None opposed it passes is uh moving on to where's my numbers 9.4.3 discussion action of CH Unified School District board self- evaluation presented by you go ahead I can speak to that yeah um the board this year has asked that we get input from the public and that would be our staff and parents and um other members that are interested in in providing input so we put together a draft survey and that is in your packet and we would send this out electronically and gather input and then have this ready to come back to the board for discussion at our November meeting would we get the results before or at the same time as we submit our own self- evaluation I know we talked about like what a timeline would look like to try to does that make sense so the results would need to come forward at the board meeting and so that everybody gets the information at the same time okay and that would be at the same time that we have already done our own self- evaluation is that right so the community would be one piece and then you guys could and that's up to the board do your own self- evaluation as you have done those in the past I think I was working under the assumption that we would still do that aspect of it yeah I like the survey succinctly puts together what the board does and what our charge is and kind of what we don't do are there any other questions or comments um no public comment do we have a motion appr of theity survey survey I'll second it I think it's a good place to start we've never done this before before at least that I know of um so it'll be interesting and I think insightful to put it out there and see what kind of response we get I think it'll be insightful just to see the number of responses that we get how many people want to give us feedback on how we're doing um and so yeah is it going to be pushed out just like we would any other type of community survey same channels and all Yes uh at the site level as well as at the district level we can s it out to all of our staff we can post on social media we can send it out to all of our parents um the social media link would be the way for community members that wanted that maybe didn't have children in the system to have access yeah okay and media in general correct to like Enterprise record and all those good folks okay yeah I assume that Erica's gonna plug it into all of her NK you would assume correctly all right um any further discussion or questions all right let's vote uh all those in favor of uh moving forward with this say I I I I all right pass is unanimous great thank you and uh moving on to the next item I'm fading uh items from the floor do we have any additional um speakers for items from the floor none from our community that are present okay um number 11 is board member requests to agendize item uh we have 11.1 discussion action um uh proposal for uh student citizenship and respect for authority Mr tennis thank you um let me just pull my sheet up here for a second sorry um yeah I I have heard from senior staff cabinet I guess recently in conversations that teachers have expressed concern about uh safety on campus relative to student behaviors um I've heard comments about social media and people filming dramatic events that occur on campus um I've heard of um violent instances sometimes Gang Related where uh cameras come out and and large audiences amassed to observe you know altercations I've heard of police coming on campus and having students uh obstruct them as they're trying to create safe campuses um I think this kind of thing is um frankly toxic it disagrees with my sensibilities for wanting to have an orderly atmosphere for Learning and and citizenship at schools um additionally our lcap goals are very clear that we want to have you know healthy positive campus climates and um this sort of like uh you know sort of mob mentality type stuff you know yelling cursing at police um is against that so I think that we need to understand the extent of the problem and make sure that we're doing everything we can to encourage a positive School climate and good citizenship to create a good learning environment so um and and at the heart of part of it all is safety we want safety for our staff safety for our students and we need to fulfill our mission and um I want to kind of hone in on the things that might be diminishing from that do you have a succinct motion I move that we place an item on a future agenda discuss student citizenship and disciplinary measures and other tools we might employ to foster a positive and productive School climate I'll second giving I was giving Erica time to type [Laughter] it um okay so since this would be a future discussion um item we this is not the time to necessarily flush it out now as a discussion um but I think that it's appropriate to you know add any um small thoughts if needed or we could just move right into a vote sure mam if you all would go back to the minutes of our last meeting where we talked about where Caitlyn brought up something very similar regarding uh student behavior and safety in the context of lunchtime I think all those exact same issues can be brought up here so you already got me on on on record to follow that i' say it's a good idea regardless of who brings it up and I think to um to the point to Mr tennis's Point um that it's it's it really is falling under the time that we're responsible for these kids so yeah um is there any any more direction from the staff needed for this item or you can always Circle back with yeah I think as we start putting this together we'll need to get some more specifics but from what I'm hearing is a a synopsis of the type of issues that we're facing on campus the behavior issues that we see most often and we can look through discipline records um are areas to look at that uh as well as tools that we have to utilize to address those behaviors yes uh Miss sty that your last statement was what I raised my hand for is I want to see some brilliant ideas about Solutions we would be open to hearing some additional ones for sure um and I so also um while I value hard qualitative quantitative data um I I do think that there are some some concerns that don't get translated into Aries very well um so if there's anecdotal things to share I think that that that would be valuable as well um teacher experiences and concerns or staff I should say staff experiences and concerns student experiences and concerns what are you hearing from kids when you're visiting campuses did you have a comment we do we do school climate surve and we can share that data as well um yes I I had one other concern is that we take a look at anything that might uh turn into a negotiable item issue in dealing with this subject matter change in working conditions change in you know for both of our bargaining units um since this is a truly itemized um that's not the right word this is agenda item um we we can take public comment if you would like to speak so I spend a lot of time on campuses um and there is definitely I feel there's levels of disrespect that need to be fixed and improved upon but I feel it's not necessarily something completely at the school level that can be fixed because the big problem is social media kids love social media they love their Snapchat their Tik Tok all the things um and that's like the goal on social media is like to go viral kids like are drawn to that that's what they're focused on that's what they want they want to be the next best thing they want to be influencers whatever so um just sitting here and thinking like do we focus on teaching kids social media like positive social media behaviors like I feel it doesn't happen at home well let's just be honest doesn't happen in every household those discussions about social media and what makes good social media and bad social media and how you should act on social media if it's not happening at home granted it's not the school's responsibility to teach that but I also feel like it's a pretty important thing to be discussing with our kids is the social media and that and like when when you put something on the Internet it's there like it does not go away that's like the day and age we live now and I feel there needs to be that educational component for our students especially our junior high students and our high school students but also starting at elementary too like just finding ways to start those conversations so when they get to that age when they have a phone when they have that social media they're prepared for it because again it doesn't happen in every household kids they know how to be sneaky too let's be honest you think you have an honest kid and you know they do something that surprises you and so um I think that needs to be included in any type of discussion that we have is like what can we do at the school level to help prepare our students for this world of social media that we're in now that's it thank you all righty um let's vote all those in favor for agiz this on a future item uh yep that's what I'm trying to say that's fine uh please say I I hi please help get me out of here um it's unanimous that passes thank you um and there's no additional items for um agendize for the future at this time so I will call for a motion to adjourn yeah all right we have we have a motion so we will adjourn thank you
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Renters Commission Meeting 10/19/23 · passage 1
yes okay so I'll get started here uh welcome everyone to the October 19th 2023 meeting of the anabor renters commission the purpose of the renters commission is to advise the city council and the city administrator in matters affecting renters in our city uh our commission is made up of voting members who are appointed by the mayor and approved by city council two non- voting city council Liaisons two non- voting members representing different landlord perspectives and a non- voting representative from the University of Michigan Student Legal Services to speak during any one of the Public Public comment opportunities you'll be able to speak through the webinar link or by phone for phone access please call 877 85352 47 and enter meeting ID 935 8801 941 it's 935 941 uh to be called on to speak callers must press star9 if you're calling in by phone or use the raise hand feature if you're doing it through the web link which is a2gov.org renters commmission meeting the first letter of each word is capitalized so renters commission meeting uh you will then be called on by staff and you can give um a three-minute comment um City staff will indicate when callers have 30 seconds left of your three minute comment and then after which you will be placed on mute so we can go to the next speaker so moving on to roll call uh which is item two please State the uh the city that you're calling from um so we'll go to list commissioner Chen is not here commissioner Peterson is not here commissioner Kelly here calling in from an Arbor Michigan welcome Patrick commissioner dran present from an arbor welcome commissioner Els here in an arbor very nice to see you commissioner Lowe is not here commissioner Tibbits is not here commissioner Rose is not here commissioner Ratcliffe is not here uh commissioner Thomas is not here commissioner Pitts here from an arbor so nice to see you Cam commissioner good here Ann Arbor welcome um I am also here calling in from an arbor Comm council member redina is not yet here council member Harrison I'm here from an arbor I'm um off camera because I'm under the weather but I'm here welcome good to see you all nice to hear you okay item three and I hope you feel better soon um thank you item three approval of our agenda at this point we can't approve our agenda right since we don't meet Quorum okay however we can and we can also not approve our minutes from the previous uh meeting which is item four so we move directly on to uh item five which is our first general public comment period which uh I think we should still do all right public comment can be made by phone at 877 85352 47 or 888 78899 and ing the meeting ID 935 881 941 can also address the renters commission using the web link and that is um sorry a2gov.org runers commission meeting um and if you are joining with the web link you can use the raise hand feature um or if you're calling in you can press star n we'll give it just a second if you'd um like to address the renters commission for up to three minutes go ahead and raise your hand we'll call on you no attendees have okay thank you Kristen uh we can move on to item six which is old business uh we had talked or we had asked for an update about the um recommendation that the commission had made back in it was April um to ban pre- tenancy fees uh this is in response to the weit list uh fee issue in the city um and so I guess I'll I'll ask um our council member here today um if there are any more updates on that um no updates on that we're working on it um I think we were uh well we're in the process of meeting with Zachariah and um who else are we Gail yes um so we will bring to you two first and um yeah but we are we're making uh progress so that's the only update there thank you um are there any comments or questions about the proposal from April Jordan I think my um I'm glad we're working on this as we are getting into wasting season this is you know we're hearing these stories already um being at the capital a couple of times over the last couple weeks and hearing about the bills that are working on there it doesn't sound like they're going to be very fast so I think it would be good for us to get going on these kind of things here um the one thing I just kind of you know I read the recommendations in April and read them again just I want to be I hopefully we can be very clear on that um the second recommendation about the verbiage of the the leasing um we weren't as clear as reading it again now and kind of going a few more months with all of the stories and knowledge I think that we we need to be clear on what we're requesting of city council and I assume that you guys are I just kind of wanted to verbalize the with the timelines and the when you can hand someone a lease and what situations you can hand someone Elis is still kind of um unclear to to folks in the community so I think it would help to clarify that was my only thought I was reading through it again today yeah thank you Jordan I can pull up the two recommendations made and you were referring to the second recommendation which uh was to consider clarifying the language in uh the early leasing the amended early leasing ordinance yeah I think you know we say here that it doesn't say that the landlord shall shall not offer a lease I mean there are situations in which the landlord could offer a lease if that you know they've given the renewal offer it's requested by the tenant unless we're changing the ELO to me when I read this I wasn't clear were we saying we want to change the ELO to say for example you can't even get a renewal lease until 180 days or are we saying that you this is just to prevent the counter signing situation do you get what I'm saying like I I read this again and I couldn't remember back from April what we were what we were thinking with this specific bullet point because um sh not offer a lease to a prospective tenant for signing um if the tenant's requesting it that's fine as the way things are right now so I wasn't sure I wasn't sure what we were saying uh in this bullet point I guess looking at it now okay yeah my understanding is that we were saying that it shouldn't that Council should consider just making it not allowed to for landlords to even offer leases and and then would we say until 180 days I just felt like there was a piece you know what I'm saying like that there was a piece yeah I think we should talk more on that yeah thank you Julia um well I don't know do we want to talk more about that because mine was a different question um well let's I want to hear your question I think let let's hear your question and then we can loop back around if um I think I need some time to think about what Jordan said personally okay I um saw the uh kind of report about the junk fees and stuff and but I don't recall ever seeeing any draft legislation is there any draft legislation the commission didn't draft any legislation yet my understanding is that yeah go ahead CIA yeah that's what we're working on with um Mr Riser okay um and I guess if there's any way we could help with that I you know I'd appreciate it if you bring it back to the commission I think we will be we will be we're going to meet with we're meeting with Zachariah and Gail and then we will at that point bring it to the commission okay great any other questions or comments I think um put my hand up but um I think as I'm looking at this the specific case that we were trying to outlaw here is when a brand new tenant not somebody who's renewing was getting offered a lease um way earlier than it was allowed for someone to for the landlord to sign it right and that doesn't seem right to me that they should be able to to say they have an occupied unit and they have a perspect you know a new tenant who's interested if they offer it to the new tenant and they know that they can't sign up for months and they get the signature from that new tenant and then they take that and refuse to counter sign it that that that's just the case we think that as we as we were writing that the recommendation I think we came to the conclusion that it wasn't right that the landlord could offer the lease to that prospective tenant knowing that they couldn't sign it for months and not even knowing if the current tenant was going to renew or not in many cases so we I think that's why we said we don't even think that they should be able to offer it at that at that stage to a brand new tenant not not for Renewal gaale so I realize I'm coming in in the middle of this but I am seeing I am seeing those that happen already where landlords are offering leases that the tenants will sign and and and the landlord says they can't counter sign until March or whatever you know and and of course the problem with that is that you know arguably the tenant is now bound to the lease even though the landlord is is not um you know so a tenant who changes their mind may not be able to go someplace else because they've already signed the lease even though the lease hasn't been countersigned so that's you know it I'm I'm I'm slowly starting to see some right to renew early leasing ordinance issues and questions and stuff right now um not a not a ton but this is this is one of them so just putting that out there yeah I think we had talked about oh sorry I think we had talked about 10 like making a I don't know I thought it was this meeting one of them making it like the landlord must sign the leas within 10 days or so I thought at one point we had had some discussion surrounding language of like if a lease is signed by a tenant a landlord has to sign it within 10 days or or something at some point in one of our conversations but they they can't because of the early leasing I mean you well that's what I'm saying so you couldn't you couldn't that that language then would prevent them from I mean I think we were talking about different ways to go at it and I thought at one point we had considered that right and then this this is another ISS sorry zachari I so this is another issue I'm seeing we're starting to see and maybe this isn't the time for this discussion at all but you know we're starting to see issues where and you tell me if it's not and I'll wait um where where landlords are and maybe we talked about this last year too where landlords are saying you know I'll renew I'll renew your lease you don't have to let me know until 150 days from the end of the lease but I'm willing to um you know give it to you have you give it to you in a much lower rent if you sign now so I don't know if that's come up or if now's not a good time for it or whatever Zachariah is smiling I'm not sure what that means but I'll let you go well um Julia you're next go ahead um I was just gonna mention that kind of thing because I've definitely heard some of the larger landlords in town saying yeah we can't sign a lease yet but we'll give you this discount if would get your commitment now those kinds of things so I think that this number two would help current tenants too I'll point out that you know there's no guarantee that the discount that they're giving isn't just the regular rate and that the regular rate that you would be getting if you waited longer is just a hiked up rent you know and so I think from the perspective of a tenant it's like not oh you're giving me a discount now if I sign early it's if you if I don't sign early and if I don't exercise my right to wait you'll be raising my rent and I think that when we talked to Nick RL who was on this commission um he thought that there was a good chance that that was not legal given the language of right to renew because that's in his eyes not good faith negotiating not a good not a good faith offer yeah no I I agree with him I just didn't know if that was something that we discussed here and it may be that we have to litigate it to make you know to determine if that's allowed or not and maybe maybe we're heading there soon but I just didn't know if you guys discussed it if that was if that's come up at all I don't know if other people are seeing it in their worlds but I'm starting to see it for sure yeah we we have not we we discussed it since I I know that some landlords did this last year I know cppo dco did that um among others but I think it right is there an alternative to testing it in the courts I don't know I mean last last year the the issue was there was or or another issue was that um you know there was a dispute about whether or not the right to renew ordinance sorry sorry the dog say BR or something whether or not the right to renew ordinance um was in effect for leases that had already been signed so nothing happened last year now that I mean it's it's clear that the right to renew ordinance is in effect for leases that are currently in effect so that other argument's taken away um yeah and I don't know if there's another way to resolve this outside of outside of litigation but but I'll take all thoughts thanks SC any other questions thoughts about the recommendations of the report or the process that we're going through now um with our council members I mean I don't have any additional thoughts other than what's been discussed already some of these um methods that landlords are use I mean they don't sound it doesn't sound it sounds predatory to me so that's my opinion just sounds like a way to skirt around you know to skirt around it so thanks Cynthia um yeah I really hope that we can get something implemented as soon as possible because I think this has been going on for you know two and a half years or so and it pains me to see that uh especially seems to have a greater effect on student tenants but it's not just student tenants um to see them have to go through that is very uh unfortunate and I don't hope we can address it yeah we definitely will I'll um you know talk with uh I'll reach out to Mr Riser about that as well and we can we can discuss as well the four of us when we meet yep thank you so as for the second recommendation there I know Jordan you that you brought up um I'm not sure if we want how we want to continue their conversation if we think we should um yeah I mean I I I think your goal right I think I agree I think your goal was to to deal with this counter sign thing I mean we have two big issues right we have the the counter signing thing which seems like next level predatory because these students are trapped I mean it could be six months that these students are trapped thinking they have an agreement and also thinking they have a house without knowing I mean that was the other issue last year I signed a lease but then I was told I didn't actually have a house um and so then they're they're panicking and as late as April I heard some so that's one issue and the other thing is is the you know the dealing with the timing and the the increasing the rent the predatory I'm going to increase this over time and so I don't know if you I mean if you guys are working on it I don't think we necessarily need need to come back to the conversation right now as long as city council isn't going to put something through without bringing it back for all of us to have a peek at and say no no this this wouldn't cover this situation um I think right I don't know that we need to spend more time on it or is there I guess Cynthia and Zachariah and Gil is there anything that you that that I've said that you want more clarity on or is there anything that would be helpful to the three of you if not I don't I don't think we need to be laborate if we're going to see it again before it's good I think there's any needs to be clarified I'm not sure if that was on the topic on the agenda for discussion for our future meeting I think we were just talking about the Banning of fees but I think it definitely should be on the agenda so uh if we have the time we certainly will discuss it when we are able to meet yeah that sounds good great any other questions comments on that point 6-a okay we can move on to uh item seven which is our new business uh we have a report from tenant our tenant education committee can someone who attended that committee please give like a brief summary of what you remember us talking about um I think I'm the only one here uh and I was trying to look at my notes I remember it was said um coming out of the last commissioner's meeting we had talked a little bit about education and people said they didn't feel fully up to speed on evictions and on security deposits um as two areas as Commissioners we wanted our own personal information on um so there was a bit of discussion whether it makes sense to have uh you know a session just for Commissioners or whether it makes more sense to do a broader public um education Forum kind of thing where Commissioners could go but also any general tenants that wanted to go um I think with evictions the decision was because we uh have a video on evictions um from uh legal services south central Michigan that we would ask all the Commissioners to view that and then at next month's meeting if people have any questions or would like any further detail um we'll have um eviction law on the agenda for the next meeting so this is a request for everybody to please watch that and then security deposits we're going to talk about at the next meeting so we kind of booted that one um there were a couple of things in the scope of evictions besides just general law this is the way it works you get a 7day notice you go to court blah blah blah um there's also uh I was going to follow up with um Hawk which handles money in the county to help with eviction prevention um so try to get statistics from them and see what where they're at now that the uh Federal money um from the pandemic is gone and uh there was going to be some checking in with other groups too Jamie was going to talk to Poverty solutions to see if they have any updated stats on evictions in an arbor and Zachariah was going to talk to the county to see where if they're taking any movement towards a addressing evictions with something like an eviction diversion program so that was probably a longer report than you wanted but once I started it was hard to stop thank you so much Julia that was a very good report I thought um I Jordan I know you were there too was there anything that uh Julia didn't catch she covered all of what I remember as well so I did contact the County Commissioner and uh we're going to see if we can get a staff member from the County government to come and talk to us about what they're trying to do on the issue of housing generally um I'm waiting to hear an update but they it sounded like there there was definitely a possibility and I know that at yesterday's County Commission meeting they I think they had a work session and they were talking about a lot of really relevant issues uh rosanita who was on the commission um made me aware of that and um I was not able to watch that meeting but if you're interested you can check it out any questions for um the people who attended the the committee meeting I was just going to ask about the the link to the the video on evictions um would that be sent around uh after the meeting Kristen or has it already been sent around and maybe I missed it yes I plan to send it out after this meeting thank you um I I brought this up at the tenant education committee meeting um that since we were talking a lot about evictions and you know we're talking about eviction diversion program we also talked about a right to counsel program these things can help people who are facing evictions um and I'm just wondering if it I want to gauge your opinions about engaging other bodies like other parts of the city government on the issue of exploring these these policy options of eviction diversion and right to counsel um I was thinking of sending an email to hsab and the Human Rights Commission but I don't know who else I should contact or I mean if does anyone have think that that's not a good idea or think that other people should be invited to that conversation isn't uh Jeffrey our representative on the Human Services one it's a good point I think I should definitely ask Jeff about that I don't have any concerns about about um reaching out and think it think it' be be a good idea okay great I saw that rosanita was just able to join us so we have we do have a quorum now um so welcome rosanita hi sorry I'm late I had a another meeting before this that every month I never get to the end to so I figured I needed to actually stay for that one once understandable glad to have you um you know um Kristen at this point should we go appr approve the agenda in the minutes that would be great yeah okay so I'll just take R for you rosanita you're obviously here where are you calling from oh I'm calling from Ann Arbor great welcome so we have Quorum um do we have a motion to approve the agenda we've been going through I'll move to approve the agenda thank you res I need a second second second by Julia um all in favor say yay yay yay y all oppos say a okay we just approved the agenda and then we can move on to the approval of our minutes do have a motion for to approve the last meeting's minutes uh that's September 21st meeting's minutes on motion thank you Patrick motion by Patrick um second second second by Julia um all those in favor say yay yay y I post a nay okay so we approved our minutes great um and then we'll just continue with the the agenda where we were so oh I'm sorry you know I totally missed that we did have the right to counsil on the agenda I we should have discussed that at that point I apologize okay we can move on to 7-b and update from the green Fair event we had a table there um would anyone like to give an update Julia and Kim both of you were there on night table as well um you know it it was a pretty lowkey event um but a fair amount of booklets people did come by and pick up the you know City booklets from us um and I you know it was less than a dozen I think people came and talked about specific um questions on issues they were coming up with I don't remember what the tally was on that little board yeah I think we weren't really prompting people to to do the board we were just mostly talking with people so yeah but definitely you know uh the bulk of the complaints were about how hard it is to live in an arbor because it's so expensive and it's it's expensive without being good you know it's not like it's upscale expensive and like oh it's worth spending extra of my income because it's so nice you know it's kind of like oh my God it's barely possible and I'm paying all my income anything you want to add Kim um I just thought it was a good turnout actually you know because I did walk around a little bit so it was nice to see the people um and uh you know I was surprised that people would walk up and start you know I think you engaged them a lot Zachariah so I think that was important and you you were able to pull information out because I I thought they were pretty nice you know people didn't come in and start yelling or complaining they just you know were very interested in who we were you know as well so yeah I was I was excited about it yeah ready for next year I think I'll be ready thank you Kim well I certainly had a great help engaging people um I I know one tenant came up and talked to us about having an eviction on his record and he wanted to know what to do because he was going to move to an arbor soon and he was looking for tips on that and I truthfully didn't know what to tell him but Julia thankfully had some good tips um you want to share those just so we all know what to you know a good way to respond when somebody says asks a question like that Julia uh specifically with the eviction record yeah I you know I I think it's just the general life kind of advice when you're upfront and honest you usually get a better reaction um and if it's you know if it's a a credit kind of issue to be able to come and and say look at you know this is what my credit score is this is where I'm at I've got a good job now you can call them for a reference I'm GNA be a good tenant um just kind of to make that speech for yourself yeah thanks juliia um yeah so overall I was very happy with just talking with people I think it's a great thing to go out and table and have those kinds of conversations uh so I hope we can consider doing another tabling event um just maybe at Liberty Plaza or some someplace like that just talk to people okay anything else on that the green Fair okay we can move on to 7-c um which is discussion about landlords asking tenants to act as agents so in an arbor you need to have if you're if you're the landlord you have to either live in or near the city and be your own agent or hire an agent I believe I got that right is that right Jordan and and Bob yeah okay Jordan you want correct the record okay TR to make sure um so what you can't do is if you're totally outside of the city you can't just buy a property and rent it to somebody without having someone locally um to act as the agent um and apparently City staff is saying that tenants are now being asked to act as the agents which is a new phenomenon to my knowledge um Jordan yeah I mean I that's not entirely unusual I'm not sure it's a new phenomenon I think there's a couple ways that happens right um students are desperate for housing and they want to get a leg up so students think that if they and I haven't heard of this outside of students so that's why I'm using the term students if they think that they can go knock on a house and say hey are you renewing and the tenants say no we're not they say can we look at your house your home and we're here and then they walk them through the house now this is obviously a huge safety risk I don't know why anyone would feel comfortable with this on either side but it happens all the time and I can tell you that in all the parent groups right now that's the answer parents are giving other parents just have your kid go around and knock on doors of a house that looks wellmaintained so in some ways this the renters do this they seek this out I think we're probably talking about a little different thing but it would be remiss not to mention that that there are times that that's happening now I we email all of our tenants we say do not show the house to anybody do not tell them if you're releasing do not say anything yet you know it's just we haven't asked you yet first of all if you're renewing and so please don't don't let people into your house do not feel pressured to even answer a door if someone knocks you're not expecting it Etc not everyone does that so that's kind of one situation um the other situation is I think they they do say you know oh you can go knock on the door some landlords do tell tenants they can do that very thing um or uh probably in terms of inspections though I haven't heard this directly I usually hear it more in terms of leasing there's an inspection you know can you be home the inspector's coming on this day at 3 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Passaic County, NJ YouTube / CPS TV transcript source: youtube October 19, 2023 - Clifton Board of Education Meeting · passage 1
e like to call the regularly scheduled meeting of the clion board of education for Thursday October 19th 2023 to order if you'd all please rise for a salute to our flag followed by a brief Mona silence I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with li and justice for all and if we could all just pray for peace in our world thank you roll call please Mr abjo here Mr aad miss bassford here Mr brunak here Mr Mia here Mr Paris here Mr Santiago do it again here vice president Danny uh coming late president Smith here we have a quorum um Richie uh Mr commissioner M would you read the mission statement please the mission of Clifton School District in an open and reciprocal Community Partnership is to provide all students with a quality education to develop the the skills necessary to become literate lifelong Learners who are responsible and productive citizens contributing to a Democratic Society in an Ever Changing world the open public meetings act in New Jersey open public meeting law was ened to ensure the rights of the public to have advanced notice of and to attend the bodies of public uh at which any business affecting their interest is discussed or acted upon in accordance with the provisions of this act the Clinton board of education has caused notice of this meeting to be publicized by having the daytime and place thereof posted at the city clerk's office Clifton Public Library administration building senior citizen Nutrition Center on cable TV and the local press on the district's website and mail to presidents of parent teacher organizations this meeting will be tape recorded in accordance with policy 0168 uh the board is going to move into executive session at this time uh for uh Personnel matters um Mo and a legal matter is a motion to go into executive please by Mr abaj jaabo second by Mr Mahia roll call please Mr yes M bassford yes Mr brunak yes Mr Mia yes Mr Paris yes Mr Santiago yes president Smith yes motion passes okay if the public would just please vacate the room so that we could stay here for our executive session thank you oh there are they say okay sorry e okay we're going to uh get ready to start so uh cheering section will have to hold off for a little while just a little bit all right are there any people standing outside do you need a seat ma'am oh she's rocking okay because we do have a seat up front if somebody needs a seat okay um like to call the uh board back to uh order from executive session roll call please Mr Rober jbo here M bassford here Mr brunak here Mr Mia here Mr Paris here Mr Santiago here vice president Danny here president Smith here we have a quorum um so the board had uh had already opened their meeting uh at 5:30 we met an executive session no we're coming back from executive session so that's why you don't have to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance we did that uh already all right so we're going to continue on with the board's agenda uh we're starting um at number four uh the open public meetings law was enacted to ensure the rights of the public to have advanced notice of and to attend the meetings of public bodies at which any business affecting their interest is discussed or acted upon in accordance with the provisions of this act the Clon board of education has caused notice of this meeting to be publicized by having the date time in place thereof posted at the city clerk's office Clifton Public Library administration building senior citizen Nutrition Center on cable TV and the local press on the district's website and mail to presidents of parent teacher organizations this meeting will be tape recorded in accordance with uh R policy 0168 okay the first part of the meeting is going to be public recognition this portion of the meeting is open to Residents and non-residents of the city of Clifton for the purpose of addressing any subject matter pertinent to Andor directly related to the operation of the Clifton Public School System residents and non-residents are requested if in person to sign the register provided for this purpose all speakers are asked to State their names municipality in which they leave in subject matter before they begin speaking comments are limited to 5 minutes per person issues raised by members of the public may or may not be responded to by the board all comments will be considered and a response will be forthcoming if and when appropriate your questions may or may not be answered by board members the board asked that members of the public be courteous and mindful of the rights of other individuals when speaking specifically comments regarding students and employees of the board are discouraged and will not be responded to by the board students and employees have specific legal rights afforded by the laws of the state of New Jersey the board Bears no responsibility nor will it be liable for any comments made by members of the public members of the public should consider their comments in light of the legal rights of those affected or identified in their comments and be aware that they are legally responsible and liable for their comments okay we'll start with um virtual Callin is there anyone there okay motion to close motion by Mr abrao second by Mr Santiago okay now we'll have in person um if you wish to address the board please come up to the podium sign the register state your name municipality subject matter and you will have a timer starting for five minutes to be fair good evening board members again and the Clifton Community my name is Joseph Ceno and I am number four on the ballot running for a seat on the board of education on November 7th as this is the the final board meeting before the election I would like to take a few moments to outline my priorities for my candidacy first and foremost I am deeply committed to securing increased funding for special education as I wholeheartedly understand the crucial importance of providing adequate support and resources for students with special needs additionally I believe in the power of early learning and its impact on a child's education as a member of the Early Childhood advisory Council I am well-versed in the benefits of Early Education I am dedic D at to expanding options and opportunities for early learning within our community I recognize that as a new member of the board there will be a learning curve however I am fully committed to working closely with the board members and seeking their guidance every step of the way by attending every meeting and actively participating in board activities I will ensure that this position has my undivided attention collaboration is at the heart of my Approach I am a devoted team player and will always maintain Ain an open door policy for the community it is my mission to listen and address any concerns raised by community members I will be their voice at board meetings advocating for their needs in addition to my involvement in Early Education I am actively engaged in various Community organizations I am proud to serve as the newest elected president of the friends of the athenia veterans Deputy Grand Knight for the Knights of Columbus Regina Monday 3969 Council and a member of the action Clifton committee and the beautification committee I am also dedicated to working with the power one organization assisting in any way I can I humbly ask for your support and consideration in the upcoming election if you have any questions or concerns please do not hesitate to reach out to me at any time I am here to address any inquiries you have furthermore I invite the public to a meet and greet the event this Saturday the 21st from 10:00 a.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Monroe County, IL YouTube / KCHS transcript source: youtube Columbia CUSD4 Board of Education October Regular Meeting · passage 1
all right time is 7 P.M we'll call the meeting to order welcome everyone to the October edition of the Columbia school board meeting we'll start with a roll call please norina is abent tonight Adam hkin here Andre Cory here Kelly Moyer here Greg Meyer here Lisa schoemer here Tyson sirar here all right we have a quum everybody would stand and repeat the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you all right well we don't have any visitors tonight so welcome to everyone that's tuned in through YouTube appreciate you join us this evening so we don't have any visitors in house again um we're going to start right into it with the uh our public hearing hearing so this would be our Bina hearing our Bina hearing our Bina hearing and this is for the sales of of bonds um we're intending to sell 10 to 11 million in bonds for the construction renovation at the high school um this will be to get us started and will be structured based on the estimated monies we'll need to complete the project one of the key things that we talked about with the um the sales of these bonds that I want to point out is one as the bonds that we had passed or fall off we want to bring these new Bonds on without increasing the tax rate we want to keep that level if not drop it a little bit um the second thing is is that we are going to try and take advantage of Arbitrage and the first 10 million if you if you do under 10 million in bonds you don't have to worry about a timeline on Arbitrage which is good news so um this will be the first selling of bonds and then we will structure the future sellings of bonds when we've got a clearer picture of how much we need and um do that so that again the tax rate stays nice and level and we don't um lose all of the opportunities that we're getting with this so uh questions comments on the sales of the bonds I will and just for the public um anybody's watching Arbitrage is basically where we can borrow money cheaper than we can invest so the district would benefit from the fund so we actually make money on the money while we're waiting for the construction to begin so yes kind of different concept right well we have no public so I have no questions any questions from the board all right and that I'd entertain a motion to adjourn our public hearing I'll make a motion to adjourn thank you Andrew second thank you all right roll call please ad yesy yes yes yes yes search yes all right that concludes our public hearing now we'll start with our regular SCH scheduled school board meeting and we will call that to order at 7:03 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Hampden County, MA YouTube / ELCAT01028 transcript source: youtube ELHS Spartans Field Hockey vs. Mohawk LIVE · passage 1
flipping this [Music] way [Music] oh wait um and then enter go don't forget to restart [Music] [Applause] [Music] it something beautiful [Music] two nothing already one minut so for the second I the microph so hope you hear me what's that place is packed like yeah whole there probably the most people one of the meetings yeah was in the why they do this in aori there's a place to sit there a lot of people [Music] standing behind one person next to the last three games next they do announcements or lineups or anything announcing the 10 goals [Music] I [Music] [Applause] on number 23 Grace rapold with the gold number 13 a g with the assist what happening like Corner oh Che last night was awesome they were 11 one and they won their league they only lost toon their first game of the year I won I think they expected to us that's awesome I think we're g go back missed the assist number 13 with the goal number 28 test the with the [Applause] assist [Music] with oh go [Music] like AG tomorrow on senior night at oh Josh their signs are right in there I didn't grab it when I ran out I was gonna grab a sign on my way out in the cafeteria that mean is GNA be going on for a long time huh that me you'll be going on for quite a while [Music] grab one yeah listen if you want maybe I'm but I may we may leave at half this continues so I think they maybe four might be when we scored stay on your toes that's good yeah tomorrow will be good though good start raining tomorrow all weekend we a nor Easter oh good like six kid it's the Bel down strategy oh oh another one sh by the so if I ever wanted to like announce ex how do how do how do I let I bring the headsets with me every game okay ellin I it does it does so especially you can have uh your daughter help you get her on the mic Kayla you're up next [Music] week what [Music] got I've never been so nervous to speak in a group you did very well took a long time I I I Tred okay on message I up there first Greg didn't even go if anybody wants to start to I was G goes I guess you're first [Music] oh [Applause] s [Applause] go [Music] [Applause] [Music] J it's like that cing right oh yeah cing one the alltime most interesting Winter Olympic Games I'm [Applause] just ni follow Ellie [Applause] [Music] good idea [Music] you Wonder no oh [Music] Je you have one for them yeah and I imagine there's different parts of town that are zon differently that you can have that's the other part he wants to make it so that all residential can have them because right now like two or three zones that it just can't for no reason really yeah like the zones the smallest ones entire time like good Lord what's going on I a faint I told Don help me break down after field hockey he's like I don't think it'll be that long lot of people that wanted to speak a lot of people that speak off tough in redundant of previous people usually without a microphone so what happened to the old building inspector what his name his name is yeah it was he he he gave me a a warning said if you don't pull permits tomorrow you will be shut down and with $1,000 fine cas you are shut down today and you will receive $1,000 I bought the fix for uper house yeah and I was like do it mostly myself and then one of my buddies a general contractor so then all of a sudden it reached like the crescendo of like what the hell is going on I'm at school I get a phone call I get a phone call um from uh Jason SAR who was doing contract there the building inspector at your house you got to get over there I show up there's six trucks in the driveway like work trucks from all different places they were dumping another dumpster and dropping another one off the building Spector was you have trucks coming in you're on the main room trucks have been coming in out of here all like for weeks you're pulling dumpsters out of here I think what's this your third or fourth I'm like yeah he you haven't pulled a single permit so I'm not here to screw you I'm here to make sure you don't get screwed I said well my contractor told me you're here to screw what was his name chubby yeah yeah drove like the blues [Music] mobile that that car is still I don't know where he went guy talks like really slow the accent people asking questions complain and he launched in on this story about when he was a kid growing up Withers every when it's interrupting you give us the number he's like two it was actually six was it six yeah somebody was like I'm out of [Music] here I never knew I would have just gotten chickens and just like got a hoop so you gotta get them registered huh they got get tags [Music] tags they CH street she has a lot of chickens and I walked into that meeting and I was like people like her are going to be here they're going to be mad about their chickens she was the first person walk B [Applause] [Music] oh please don't do [Music] that I think we should take think we should take course she injur yeah we don't want any Mohawk kids getting sced D could you bring in the nail gun that you second Mar nail is taking their kids a little long to build a set with like hammering like a little nail like yeah I walk I walked down he goes oh thank you so much he goes the girls aren't even here today he goes and tomorrow's not going to be good either because they have some Mee and then I'm away next week like I need it back at some point I tried to help the boys make a costume and then they ended up just buying one did so much work they're just gonna buy one which Bo the afternoon class oh what are they doing for a movie they are doing a movie about a sasquash lighting in the woods fil the Sasquatch in the woods so they were like oh there costume on Amazon for $90 I was like guys we can make something just get a blanket like got a blanket we cut it out taped it together I pinned it together and they're like just get a shag that's is like a BL BL Chewbacca costume someone's got to be Chewbacca yeah a big grp in the afternoon this is so to do before tomorrow night Spartan Gold by number one Sophia Shamira we don't even have a [Music] r good good come on [Music] Jame I hope we get the new schol just so we get new announcing grou that's not filled with water every time it rains know it maybe some running water that I'm surprised the town Board of Health hasn't shut the Food Shack down for having no running water on premise we designed our own little elat cubby did you H the new booth Dory like asked us what we wanted like what we' seen in other places I think he only runs the second half need a CL I believe Jennifer Jenny Mack I'm going she ripped it SP Gold by number seven Nina cluck so have you seen like a design for the thing oh you have yeah so are they keeping these stands these no these are G all these stands are oh these stands sorry [Music] um yes but Booth is gone we're making a brand new Booth it's longer and it's going to be separated oh yeah like the colleges do with a glass yeah and the coach is on [Music] top I'm surprised they don't have a good cover Indo where it's not swing or rain that so they originally wanted them in but then the coaches said we want to be awayes getting they got push back from the they don't know about the bleachers say that I why would they these are good shape yeah and then there's another turfield going in the back I think cool all flat and you see everything out front [Music] around get it's a team effort Josh team effort you got to stay there is this is for you [Music] the [Music] there e [Music] m you're [Music] any other exciting bylaws coming up from meetings or I think just that one I never realized how many people chickens [Music] oh [Applause] [Music] and so [Music] watch picking the pocket oh cut through did it Jame oh d you're I wouldn't even know what slow songs in the year 2023 they would play at a high school dance if they do any slow [Music] songs Jennifer question for you in the year 2023 if you go to a high school dance what slow songs do they play these days do they play slow music anymore at dances are they can you name one single one that you'd be like no rock bands I think Ed Sharon has a new one Ed Sharon yeah Sam [Music] Smith girl five dedic Mohawk are they having a dance uh they have them coming up uh junior senior semi I think in November shun absolutely not her boyfriend will bar barely come to our house anyway as it [Applause] is Yo what's up you back yeah we're recording the whole thing hi what's up coming out to support the crew I was I went to yesterday's game I come to a lot of yeah that was a good one I was stressing yeah that was fantastic one of the most enjoyable victories either of my kids have ever been a part of I don't like very much oh who scor Jane yeah Lisa or 33 33 that's J yeah Spartan gold number 33 Jane pelleter I missed the um assist it's okay I'm actually when Grace isn't talking to me actually using pretty good at seeing the assist and all thing he probably from watching way too much film throughout my coaching life is this Mohawk or Mahar mwk they yeah committed huh you going to AG him tomorrow in the rain [Applause] [Music] oh my goodness oh my [Music] God I don't even know who scored I don't even have a roster Dan Reed is myed right now I'm actually kind of happy for three goals is all the only difference that it makes how does m k right [Music] now subing everyone out oh he he's SC he's putting his hands to his mouth right now he is [Music] I [Music] is whole season yes oh that's the first goal you've been up in League All Year know the only goal all year that be good fuel for [Music] tomorrow's is rate get like hey Grace ask Emma who scored for don't yell Emma go right down the fence and [Music] just just what what's your name it's only the fourth FL year like the see face office number three Avery Johnston Mohawk Gold by number three Avery [Applause] Johnston first goal they've given up in the season it's been scored on them all year so they were out they were an independent game oh so we had two League games left against them today and Monday in Frontier is the only other team that's scored oh is about to kill somebody good oh sure CL it on [Applause] that 20 [Applause] [Music] ccle oh I play [Music] oh God I hate the drives it makes me nervous oh it's the best thing I I know but I feel bad for anybody who's on the receiving end of those shots yeah were you here for that game the girl hit left were like while she was still down no after when they started playing it was [Music] very stop after the first they played probably another two minutes maybe and they stopped yeah oh yeah the first quarter that Happ they were just like no they did they were just Disturbed the teammates were her sister was on the team also and they were just like so oh so then they they pretty quickly we had another shot and they were like and SC on ited they like that was what was that penalty shot oh I didn't see the girl back there hch we at the Summer League Championship no and we beat L on a [Music] [Applause] shootout number 12 Ellie Hutchin with the goal she is entertaining when her and Olivia do some dance on the sideline it's pretty funny how's the softball Squad G be this year we going to get a title to win a championship no I would like to hope so but I don't think's how many seniors are this year then there's three Juniors I feel like I feel like in the next after this year or the year after that we should be like decent but this year who's going to be the new pitcher is the Young s Gavin on my golf Squad this year gav Gavin M he's only a Yeah well yeah Riley is gonna be pitching but then we don't know who's gonna play first because she was our first baseman while sof was pitching and I third I've beening out myman year and I actually I play my what position and like I feel Center is like my spot I yeah Center's probably the best position yeah I lay I love getting in the gaps and throwing people out just get like one hot shot at me and then it's like and I don't I don't Mas so my makes mear also even at third yeah want it's frustrating especially like it's my senior year and I'm position how do you like the new coach coach web yeah I love her because I think she was went to school of Abad I think and yeah when they couldn't find a new Co he helped R to yeah [Music] um driving I was driving through the rotary and um she almost T I was like of all was she just too intense was she just like all business way to said a lot of things that she shouldn't have and did a lot of things like behind the scenes that she also should now um for one so the coach's gift has like is supposed to be like it's co thing um she was trying to get like $500 from my booster club for a coaching because she deserve to get paid but she's paid by the school yeah and she wanted more money so she tried to get money from the because in the previous years she the coaches get booster club like when my sister was playing they gave her like $250 as a coaching gift because she was there for a while she was like I coached boys ofr for nine years I never got a single gift ever and they said they liked me I'm like I never got it I actually got a gift my senior Year Joe Mar about me a set of beer mugs that said map with the CR sticks on I was like Joe thank you this is the first gift I ever received it's sad oh she want a card right oh she was nuts about she would take a bat and push it into your chest push you back I forgot she was a crazy she told us we had to do like a blind survey of who was vaccinated who wasn't and then um so we all closed our eyes and we said our thing and it was Andor M and Kayla ran I I think KY too um all rais her hand saying that we weren't and then she was like you supposed to be and she so how come you you [Applause] getting I she just it was awful like she even though the glass were like not enforced anymore oh they were optional and she made forced us that's right I forgot about that and Rory senior year right she was a junior um yeah I was a um and then she bullied my sister off te um because my sister told one of the other she was like she's like he nice I think she us had nice shapes was like s apologize and even was like I didn't any teammate was like no she gave like what and she was like no she needs to apologize or she sister apolog because like so my sister that bench wasn't hitting was playing my sister was a start benman year like she was playing third and so my sister was like I'm not doing this for the rest of my high school I'm so there's a lot of stuff that went on but yeah so we kind of like it was time it was time she was there for a while and nobody lik her she also had passive like it was bad did you like the uh field trip today did you go I not because I get outly any and I really to go and then get back at like 13 and when I could have been home what did you do at home nap took a nap instead of going to the corn maze was a good nap [Applause] come on Ellie we want a hat I think she two yeah she had yeah she had one first oh it's in oh it's out is it in nobody knows they do it's in that's a hatrick right I think so I won't say it Jen always has your back number 12 Ellie Hutchins with the [Music] [Applause] goal think she wasn't there at the meeting huh my wife I know she be critiquing me the whole time I was talking she said why is your voice wavering you pansy we never ask people each other to proof read anything because we have completely different writing styles her has like it's like 45 to 50 words per sentence lots of descriptives of like bullet four words all right one last song what's one last song from the 80s in the 1980s huh I did not play that I played skid robe warrant while they crew in Guns and Roses Jen you can pick one last [Applause] song why why why Journey Maroon Five Stevie Smith Sam Smith what's his name journey joury journey who journey journey yeah all right we got Only the Young Don't Stop Believing Wheel in the Sky Faithfully Who's Crying Now that could be a good one for the pre P talk oh my God that'd be for Coach Reed for for Coach read that's his walk up prob not happy that's his walk up song you know how like teachers make you choose a walk up song [Music] on like it just shows your first Jen hey let's let that die okay wasn't the best decision Katie what do you want to hear for the ending screw her don't stop belie yes that's good we've been saying that oh my God that's all I get it was a real big comeback too Katie what time are you leaving tomorrow oh [Music] s quiet the speaker my phone's pranked
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 10-19-23 · passage 1
here here here here here thank youone to ask we stand for the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the repic for which it stands one nation and justice for all welcome everyone it's nice to see many happy smiling faces in the audience for a change um I'm sure there'll be public comments we're looking forward to that but before we get to that part um Ella and Andrew welcome again these are for folks that aren't aware these are a new student representative for school year so what do you have for us tonight what's your student report about all right well we have a lot for tonight so starting off just kind of with some extracurricular things going on at Chester high school now that we're kind of a few months in a lot of our clubs are in full swing uh next weekend the best buddies Club is having their annual Spooktacular and all the students from chesher are invited to come around and get the candy and everything it's such a sweet event um all the political clubs are getting ready for election day um there are the school newspaper is working on their first print edition and the fall play through the drama club which we spoke about last time they're getting closer to their performance it's the show is called deadline it's going to be on November 16th 17th and 18th I didn't think we met before then so I wanted to get that in this week um speaking of the drama club the spring musical was just announced two weeks ago and our director was very excited to announce Mean Girls so that the high school version of course so that is an exciting thing at teser high school we also recently had the class of 70 70 something they came for their 50th reunion so that was 73 73 that was very exciting they came and watched the football team win big against Glastonberry and then they came for a student L tour and one of the people organizing it actually even emailed our assistant principal Mrs pels how touched they were that they were able to come back and that the students were so eager to really show them around and really see all the awesome improvements that have happened in this 50-year span of time so that was really nice um going back to some other things around the school Music in Motion occurred the weekend of October 7th and that is always a success you guys know our band is awesome and let's see tonight there is a hypnotist show at the high school it's a fundraiser for all four grade levels the student go representatives were able to reach out to the grade and advertise and people could purchase a ticket to come see this person uh kind of put on a show and like audience interaction it's a really cool experience for students uh and one of the last things on my end is that we have had the incredible opportunity for this past week to host German exchange students through the AP German class at our High School uh I'm not sure exactly how many but personally in my classes I've had one in at least I would say four out of eight of my classes and they all seem to be having a really really great experience at chesher they've been coming to not only the classes but also club meetings the football game on Friday and other things going around in chesher and now tomorrow will be their last stay with us before they head to New York City but they seem to really have a blast so I'm glad we were able to bring them here Andrew and um I'll be talking about the sports end of things at our school um so recently at Amity High School our unified soccer team um had a had an event it was an awesome experience for all involved um it provides opportunities for kids with intellectual intellectual or developmental disabilities um and it provides many opport opportunities for them they love it um similar last night at the high school the Middle School sports unified soccer tournament happened um the girls and boys soccer teams and the best buddies Club helped set um helped organize and run it um and the football team helped set up the Nets tables cones and other supplies necessary for it um on the um on the Varsity Sports Teams uh senior nights are coming up throughout um we've already had various um teams host their senior night um it's a very special night for seniors um as they are honored it's their final home game match or meet um mine is coming up soon against West Haven for football um I'm kind of sad about that in a way to leave uh leave football behind but there's other things in the future obviously um our cross country teams last night dominated the uh Southern Connecticut conference by wi the boys place third third place and the girls placed first place um we had two boys Dand Souza and Tyler Karen who placed on the all SEC team and all seven girls on our girls cross country team placed on the all SEC team um additionally at the Freshman race after the Varsity race two of The Freshman played first and second place so um the future is bright for cross country at our school um and overall chesher has 40 wins nine losses and two ties which is in my opinion pretty amazing so far um and and I speak on behalf of football as I'm a football player um that we're six and0 and we have the best start since 2014 so we hope to look uh for more wins and hopefully States and beating Southington um and yeah that's it thank thanks Al Andrew uh any questions from board members an yes hello I'm wondering if um either one of you could speak to um what the schools are doing with the chesher food drive we have a lot of parents and and students here and um so it would be just nice to spread the word here tonight while they're here yeah yeah so there are various sports teams and um classes that are hosting food drives um or sponsoring food drives they happen every year throughout the entirety of the year um I've been a part of many of them in the past they're an awesome opportunity to um donate to the food pantry as they are always in need of food items especially since Thanksgiving is coming up um so we are encouraging and um and advertising the food drive to get as many as of now Thanksgiving items in as possible thank you yes ma' please so will we be expecting one of you or both of you in the cast of Mean Girls coming up I hope to be in the cats of Mean Girls good luck and I think there's a leaf breaking of event too this weekend as well for connected to the food drive or no so I believe the leaf raking event is the one that is organized through Treasure high school will be November 11th so it's a little further off into the future and clubs are encouraged to sign up and get a group together and um senior citizens in town are able to sign up to have their yard as a part of the event and clubs are assigned to a specific yard to go to but that specific event happens in November yeah and I was talking to our assistant principal today about it um so there are 30 senior citizens homes and towns that we go around in rake leaves for um we encourage all sports teams um clubs and just individuals to go help out um and even like even out the work um amongst all 30 houses um and it's an awesome event um we do it every year and it it's a great turnout every year thank you Ella and Andrew I appreciate the update uh presentation puts us in a good spirit time you guys show up so thank you so much uh you don't have to stay you know I probably a lot of homework stuff to do but you're welcome to uh no pressure there yeah there you go yeah that's actually a lot more fun uh than our than us up here so thank you so much thank you you're very welcome you to enjoy your night as well up next we have a presentation at the school partnership award I believe Mr Martelli uh will be helping present that with you Mr jeffre Mr Jeff okay all right good evening everybody um Cara Scotty dargus and her therapy dog Chloe joined the Highland community in September 20121 and completed their service in June of 2023 Cara and Khloe are part of an organization called called pet partners disappointed she upside over the past three years Cara and Khloe have been coming to Highland School to visit classrooms throughout the building students have had an opportunity to spend time with Khloe during regular classroom visits on some occasions Khloe has enjoyed independent reading where students have enjoyed reading their books to Khloe there's an immediate response of Joy when the students see Khloe enter their classroom Khloe is a nine-year-old Shepherd Husky mix who loves to be around the students Chloe and her Handler Cara have dedicated their time to students and staff of Highland School and for that we are forever grateful Cara and Khloe retired this past spring your service to our community has left a lasting impression and positive impact on the overall climate of the school thank you so much thank [Applause] you this our you want to come [Music] over oh sit [Applause] thank you sure thank you so much for having us [Music] true that's the first for me on the board that's awesome yes Samantha I do want to ask Dr Sol if there's a succession plan to follow with this Scott you guys have support still right at the at Highland or are we between yeah we're between pets right now at Highland but we do have pets at other schools uh yeah yeah yeah but you can see the energy in the room change with the dog and we see that you know we have actually one of the world's largest rabbits I think at Dary uh is the Kim's here right what's that she'll be heing March so this is uh Animal Kingdom meets Board of Ed meetings this year so look forward to that that's awesome I think we need one for the board yeah so up next we have uh audience public comment I assume most of you here tonight to dress the board so uh the way this works our policy allows uh three minutes per speaker I think we have public comment is 30 or 45 minutes I don't recall in length but we could accommodate that as things go forward just be mindful that while the board we may not as exactly answer your questions or be able to take action we are listening I think we'll be able to respond in some manner if need would kind Soliz so anyone that wishes to address the board you're more than welcome to to come to the microphone and we'd love to hear from you all we ask you state your name and um address sure a Ben Paladino 25 the clerk AB cheser Connecticut do I I need to say or is that okay okay all right all right good evening I want to thank all school school community and board members who are present tonight for allowing us this opportunity to speak and for all the work that you do tonight you're going to hear from members of our community parents alumni coaches and most importantly student athletes my wife and I moved to this community because as two Educators we believe the Chester school system was doing it right we believe that Equity was system was Sy systemic throughout all portions of the educational system I was surprised when I discovered that fencing an Olympic sport was only a club our Fen has put in just as much time as other athletes who are recognized at the varsity level the fencing team participates in a league where most schools recognize their fenters as Varsity athletes in fact there's a leag champ chionship at top Spencers have an opportunity to be named first and second Team all conference last year Chester placed three athletes on the All Conference teams but their accomplishments were not celebrated in the herald the patch or even as a school Community because of their status as a club activity there's also a state tournament that encompasses all schools regardless of their size they recognize the top eight F finishers as all state and their respective weapons class it is embarrassing when I enter another school in our league and I see an entire trophy case dedicated to the sport of fencing and we have none it is embarrassing when parents and students need to carpol when other schools pull up in a team bus it is embarrassing when I enter a gymnasium they're going to away meet and fencing Championship Banners are displayed alongside their fellow Varsity equals but our state champions from 2011 and 2013 are not recognized in the wall of Honor with a banner in our gymnasium it is also embarrassing when as a parent when I see our athletes having to coach themselves because we have no paid staff living in a town like chesher educational budgets are often passed because we as a community value academic and extracurricular activities it is a mark on our reputation as an inclusive and caring Community when other schools in our league do not take us seriously because we are not a Varsity Sport remember what we permit we promote students and their families are disenfranchised because our failure to recognize the hard work dedication and commitment of these student athletes the time is now to act you will have the numbers you will have all the reasons to finally recognize these students as Varsity athletes one bus coed meets satisfying Title 9 one budget that Services 40 male and female athletes meets and practice held in the calf that do not conf they don't conflict with the gymnasium time plus by recognizing feny a vars fencing as a Varsity Sport you will not only affect the current fencers in our program but you'll also validate athletes and their sacrifices from the past and ensure that future fencers are not marginalized I thank you for your time and pray for the board to amend inequity that has existed far too long thank you thank you hello I'm hea can sorry Heather Von Fisher 428 cook Hill Road all right so hello everyone um I'll lead in I'm probably GNA talk fast so I'll try to slow down a little bit um my name is Heather Von Fisher I'm here to propose that the Fencing Club at chesher high be promoted to be a funded Varsity Sport that's our purpose my husband formed treasure fencing and we've maintained it since 2003 with invaluable commitment from so many others beginning in 2003 with a bunch of fifth graders the club evolved from Park and wreck and YMCA programming to a recognized Club at chesher high because those kids advocated for themselves they wanted this club to exist in the past 15 years at chesher high the club has introduced fencing to hundreds of boys and girls these fencers have attained state championship titles and consistently rose up as top finishers in novice JV and varsity state tournaments and we've seen dozens of students advance to compete at the college level as a member of chaffa which is the Connecticut High School fencing Association Along with 30 other uh plus other schools our club is recognized at the state level this the state of Connecticut is divided into three uh conferences we are part of the central conference which includes Guilford North Haven Daniel Hand Morgan North Branford and Simsbury we also fence cheser Academy and Hopkins the club Services 30 to 45 boys and girls regularly who have in incredibly diverse set of interests from music and arts to science and sports it's a broad scope last season we fielded all six Varsity squads along with some JB squads the greatest challenges come with the lack of recognition and the access to the benefits offered to other sports we don't have consistent access to transportation for our way events and this limits student participation because we're relying on Parental transportation we don't have access to gym space we make the calf work for practices and matches the students are not recognized at the sports Banquets I am responsible for um attaining The Varsity certificates the letters and the pins for the eligible fencers because we do recognize them internally because they are eligible we need to um and then also we need to re um we need the ability to retain paid coaches fencing coaches are not a commodity and there's only so long that someone can volunteer because of these limitations chesher runs at a disadvantage with the other schools this club has been self-funded for all these past years and has relied on fundraising donations and clubs we've produced procured thousands of dollars worth of equipment to afford students the opportunity to experience fencing we reached the ability to lend a full uniform and access to Club weapons for those interested in trying it out for for approximately $20,000 per season we estimate that fencing at chesher high school could become a more inclusive and stronger program that 20,000 would go towards coaches Transportation equipment and overall competition fees I respectfully ask that you consider promoting the Fencing Club to be a Varsity Sport at Treasure high school thank you thank you [Applause] he good evening my name is Kathy Paladino and I'll be sharing with you the testimony of a former CHS student who couldn't be here tonight to the chesher town board my name is semantha Bosque I attended chesher High School from 2016 to 2020 I was an epe women's fencer all four years and a co- Captain for two years I want to begin by giving my gratitude to Heather Ron Fischer as well as to my coaches and my teammates throughout the years fencing gave me structure and Leadership opportunity fencing gave me activity strength training joy and fencing to this day I am still in connection with members from my team and I am so thankful to have met them I unfortunately cannot be here this evening being the captain of the fencing team led me to the confidence in becoming a student leader and has inevitably been one of the reasons that I reside as Clark University's student body president overseeing our student council when I entered chesher high in 2016 I was welcomed with a warm embrace by my captains I never had the athletic build or experience but I was encouraged and supported to become a fencer from absolutely nothing I went on to compete in tournaments win points for our team and eventually become co- Captain for two years in a row and every aspect we were a sports team we held our senior night picked our captains had consistent practices and meets if anything we worked much harder than a varsity sports team because we were given no support by the school our coach es were so kind and dedicated to always bring equipment including uniforms and blades for anyone to try without needing to make a purchase they brought the electric strips to every practice in every meet we had to practice in the evenings throughout the winter semester because we couldn't have access to practice spaces as other sports teams did Chester fencing was run on sheer dedication and passion it is safe to say that the way Chester fencing operates now is not sustainable to put all the work on our coaches and especially Heather Von Fisher is unfair and unnecessary fencing is a fantastic sport that could be putting chure on the rankings as a sports team if we were fully recognized and given proper support funding and storage as much as I enjoyed my four years of fencing I knew that other schools never took us seriously because we were a club even with the top finishers in many tournaments chesher High did not recognize our accomplishments I had no official athletic records to send to colleges except for any tournaments I entered on my own as an individual I also had no guidance through chesher high that could have led to my recognition as a student athlete when I went to college it is a huge loss to any student to put so much work into an Olympic sport yet have no school supported records to submit to college I deeply hope you will all consider allowing students to show you how much success a varsity chesher team would bring to the high school I cannot think of what could be holding the district back from the success and excitement that a varsity fencing team would bring to our town thank you for your time Samantha BOS thank you thank you and thank you to Samantha as well would I anyone else like to please you're welcome to Kim O'Donnell 20 Mount Sanford Road um I my husband and I had two kids who fenced for chesher high school Jim also volunteered as a coach my husband did but let him address that um our daughter Jessica graduated in 2011 our son Nicholas graduated in 2015 um and I want to focus on Jessica's story because Jessica was a kid who was Raising her hand in kindergarten soccer saying can I have a break now can I have a break and never was interested after that in any ball sport right Sports were not hers she was not an athlete wasn't part of her self-concept when she was I think she was in eth grade and she was watching fencing one night and Scott Von fiser stood in the middle of the gym and chanted her name till she got up to try um and so she she just finally gave up and got up and tried and Jessica went on eventually to be captain of the chesher Fencing Club um and and thought of herself as an athlete in all forms of that word she also went on to be a division 3 NCAA fencer at haford College where she also became captain in her senior year Jessica regularly now engages in sports activities she you know she thinks of herself as somebody who is physically fit and physically competent her self-concept was formed by being able to fence and she never would have played LaCrosse or soccer or anything else she would never have thought of herself as an athlete our son Nick did not fence in college Nick was also a kid who never after I think he stopped playing soccer in second grade didn't think of himself as an athlete um but fenced all through high school after trying fencing he didn't fence in college but he did did go on to play rugby in college and Nick recently finished a 55 uh K Marathon in the mountains of Idaho and regularly scales 12,000 foot mountains and he wouldn't be doing any of that I'm confident if he hadn't thought of himself as an athlete but of course as everyone else has said they were never recognized as athletes as CHS and but I think what I want to speak to is that that population of kids who are never going to Play Ball Sports on a field and yet what it means to them to be able to find a sport and as everyone an Olympic sport where they can feel competent and feel successful and change how they think about themselves thank you thank [Applause] you would Mr oono like to come up next uh as as Kim will tell you I'm I'm Mr polling she kept her main name frankly she's got the Odon name I'd have kept that too uh it's much cooler uh I have the distinction of being uh one of the founding members of the chesher Fencing Club uh serving from 2007 to 2017 I think somewhere around there I was also the head coach during the wonderful run we had in 2011 to 2013 where we were state champs in epe uh 2012 uh second place I have not gotten over this defeat I'm sure that U some remember this um I don't want to repeat what everybody else is repeating because they're telling you all these wonderful stories what I do want to tell you is that the students certainly when I was there and I'm sure it's still the case are an underserved population within the high school there are students that do not participate in other sports either because they're too physical they're too intimidating it's accessible and it's accessible to a certain sort of student um for several years uh when we were at the at the club level I think 90% of the Honor Society was fencers uh I know it's a not a population that probably sees itself as a athletic but there's something about fencing uh the kind of physical chest that fencing is that no other sports brings and it is a gateway and an introduction to a world of Athletics that other students probably wouldn't have so I just want you to keep that in mind as we go forward and you're going to hear lots of other letters there's lots of letters out there uh and stories and everybody's got wonderful stories and it's worthy of your support so thank you Mr much appreciate [Applause] it good evening thanks for taking the time to hear us uh my name is Phil Newton 158 North Brooksville uh Road and uh I'm going to read a letter uh from my daughter uh my daughter Lauren Newton 2018 graduate um and is now in Washington DC uh my experience sorry wrong paragraph she texted it to me of course uh uh when I got wind of the opportunity to speak uh to the Board of Education I was ecstatic to share my experience chesher fencing was part of my livelihood from fifth grade all the way through senior year of high school my aunt and uncle beginning the group may have been part of the reason I began fencing however it was the sport and the people that made me keep with it she was also a lacrosse player so this was a great opportunity we talk about people that aren't you know playing ball sports but she viewed fencing as a huge opportunity to expand her athletic experience and she says my experience began in element Elementary School watching the high school meets in Middle School began to practice with them sometimes compete in Friendly matches once I made it the high school I was on a mission to support and grow the club as much as possible as team captain for two years I saw many students join our club at all levels we made bonds with one another saw personal and athletic growth this all did not come easily the willingness of other programs to put us on their schedules even just as a club and compete with our organization has a tremendous impact on our growth the Connecticut fencing Community respected our organization because they saw the commitment of the athletes and the accomplishments throughout the years additionally myself and many others participated in outside coaching this was necessary because as a club we had limited opportunities for practice due to the time constraints of volunteers and ability to schedule space within the school I'm immensely grateful for all of the volunteers and families that have kept Cheshire fencing alive for the past 20 years and I look forward to seeing the team grow as a Varsity Sport in chesher thank you thank [Applause] you hello my name is Ben Paladino I live at 25 ler Avenue I'm a junior at Chester High School I've been fencing since the second grade my teammates have awarded me the honor and privilege of being named epic Captain this year I've dedicated most of my life to fencing and I truly love the sport most of my peers do not respect the sport of fencing let alone the athletes who fence I've always tried not to let it bother me but at this point I feel that the school Community does not take us seriously beginning my eighth grade year I find myself not bringing up fencing at all and actually hiding my love for this amazing sport I was hoping that high school would be different but then I discovered that fencing was not a Varsity Sport and the disrespectful comments continued again this did not deter me from pursuing my passion nor from bettering myself that athletically and advocating for my sport I realized that despite not being recognized by the town I was born and raised in I was still able to grow my sport I've been competing throughout the New England region and uh recently have earned enough points by placing the top 20% of my tournaments to qualify for Junior Olympics and Summer Nationals I know where I can go with my passion and I will continue to chase down my dream of fencing at a division one program where I can further progress in college it is sad that despite our accomplishments as a team our school Community still does not take us seriously we are a co-ed sport we embody inclusion we train just as hard as any other Sport and we show up and represent Chester in a positive way even when Chester does not acknowledge us I invite all of you to attend a practice League meet or better yet attend the league championship tournament you will witness the Stark difference between a fund ADV Varsity Sport in a club without paid coaches consistent Transportation or funding you'll be surprised at our spirit and tenacity despite our challenges as club status I ask you to please consider making us Varsity Sport the time is now to rectify the Injustice and truly act in the word of quality and not just claim thank you thank [Applause] you all right you hear me great I'm John Pearson 1341 P Lane um been fencing for about three years now this is my senior year in high school and um I've noticed that fencing has brought a lot of joy to a lot of different people here met some great people never thought I'd ever talk to seen people from a lot of people from the marching band who I never thought I'd see again after our Nationals but um seeing them again in a whole different aspect was always a great feeling um after I'd see these people um after seeing like for months of training and practicing being recogn being unrecognized from um not as official sport I could see it weighing down people at our school you know after we went to other tournaments and championships or and even meets with other schools with less equipment having to share equipment taking longer it's pretty embarrassing to have to sit there and um you know swap out a jacket because we can't afford to have extra ones so having people my size even being like um Get Off the Strip take many minutes to swap and have people wait it's kind of embarrassing and chesh high school I know is really big on our presentation outside of school and big on presenting how we look towards other schools across the conference and um for us to have to go and put on the best presentation we can but still be not enough is um really I feel like dwindles how we look to other schools um I feel like with better equipment better transportation and um all that kind of stuff I feel like we could make it a lot better for other schools and how we look because um being unrecognized for being like big tournaments and winning achievements and not being able to present that I feel like it's also a missed opportunity for us because we like to I want to say gloat but we like to we like to show off how good our Sports is and with being not being able to represent and show how good some athletes have done is more of a missed opportunity and I feel like another Miss number on the SEC board I hope everybody considers this and considers funding this because I feel like um because seeing people being upset not being able to show up to competitions that are hours away because of parents being able to work because we're all working and we don't have hours to take off to drive to get our parents to drive us somewhere so I really hope you guys all consider this tonight and give us a chance thank [Applause] you uh I'm Victoria Nichols and I live in 35 cier way I've never been a fan of joining new groups or Sports because I've always been too nervous or too shy to go out there and meet new people and try new things until last year when I was a sophomore one of my senior friends told me I had the right personality to be a fencer and at first I said thank you but the second thing I thought of was fencing and ever since I joined fencing I realized there was a different kind of family at chesher high school that I could be a part of not only did I feel happier but I had so much fun and had so many laughs and I made so many new friends and I met so many different and new people at the other schools not only did I feel hold on that was saying the same thing my bad my friends always told me wow you're in a Fencing Club but like that's so cool but why isn't a sport and I've always had to tell them that I don't know why and everyone always talks in the Halls about whether or not they're going to the football game on Friday or the softball and volleyball games but what about fencing tournaments wouldn't that be fun to watch it would be something new for people to focus focus on and learn more about because as soon as I learned about it and now as a junior even though I'm still a new fencer I fell in love with the sport just like that and I think other kids who are nervous to try new things just as I was could fall in love with it too thank you thank [Applause] you sorry Iman Nui seven career way um hello everyone my name is Iman I am a senior and I'm one of the captains this year at the Chester Fencing Club here at Chester high school I just wanted to take some time up here to talk about my experiences within the treasure Fencing Club so I started fencing my sophomore year of high school and prior to me joining I never fenced before and so joining fencing was one of the first extracurriculars I'd ever joined as we had the p pmic my freshman year I remember feeling so nervous and scared as I never joined a community like this before to myself I still felt like I barely graduated Middle School however walking into that gym Chapman Elementary School gym my sophomore year and uh my sophomore year was one of the best decisions I had ever made through the club I made so many friends and built so many communities and fencing even gave me the conf confidence to Branch out and join other clubs and activities to try new things and meet new people to me fencing was more than just a sport or a club according to CHS it was a community I built I remember always feeling such a deep connection and love after every practice and every competition and yelling out Chester's name at the end of it but learning fencing is difficult it's unlike any other club in the Treasure high school or and it should be regarded as a sport we spend our Tuesdays Wednesdays and Thursdays from 6:30 to 9:00 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Renters Commission Meeting 10/19/23 · passage 2
and I think that's the other scenario in which they're asking them to do some work for them the third thing would be there's a repair person coming and you know if it's for example I can think of last week we had a plumbing issue it was 11 o'clock at night when they call us we can get a plumber out there at 2: in the morning we ask the tenants if they feel okay they say oh yeah nobody has to come over here we'll just meet them we know they're coming and they let them in so I think there's three situations in which landlords sometimes ask people to do the work for them um but agent in term of leasing so I think those are kind of the three scenarios the repair thing um you know that that's kind of usually a joint decision but the leasing the two other leasing concerns are where I hear it most so I'm curious if I see you had it come on the agenda so I'm curious as to if you hearing like other variations of the situation but that's that's my knowledge of kind of what it might look like Julia so those all sounded like perhaps very reasonable times where a tenant might assist the landlord in the business of the property what happened with us is that we or why this is on here is that um through the city clerk's office was it Christian um some rental housing staff let me know that they're getting like the volume is up on this a little bit um other rental housing staff said that occasionally you get stuff like this where a tenant is like working with the city as the agent with inspections and scheduling and stuff like that and that's where it's a little bit tricky it's not my understanding is that it's not super common um but it is either my my guess is either it is more common than it has been in the past or maybe there's been a couple like kind of time consuming ones that step so maybe it seems like it's happening more but really it's maybe one or two cases um that are coming up a lot so I haven't heard of this I haven't experienced this as a renter in an arbor um think of what else for the Julia I don't I don't think anybody should be asking anybody else to show an apartment that that is a job of like I mean I I don't think those kind of things are okay I think that the I just wanted to give the whole Spectrum like I do think if at 2 in the morning the tenant's comfortable there's a house full of seven people and they're like yeah we'll meet Roto rder that we then don't have to pay a maintenance person to go meet them you know I guess I just want to give the whole Spectrum I don't think that anybody should be asking a tenant to show a house or make leasing decisions or unless it's a subase so that's the other situation but it sounds like we're talking about um something entirely different perhaps which is the work of managing the property and unless you're being compensated specifically to do that as a manager of a building or a super or something like that though you don't hear those terms much anymore that that to me doesn't seem all that reasonable unless you're being compensated we have one house that's a big house that the it's the deal that the basement apartment takes the trash cans out or something there's you know and that's they sign it that's in their lease it's just a minor respon you know those kind of things are discussed ahead of time but this this is more work um for everybody if we doing it it it it's not just an issue of the amount of work it's the issue of actually being registered with the city as exactly yeah yeah that too so I have a question about that process I mean if you're just let if the repair person comes for example I know you mentioned that scenario Jordan I mean you don't have to be registered with the city as an agent to accept them right yeah no but I think what you're talking about is like people making I I would consider scheduling an inspection kind of making a decision for a property you're saying it's not the registered owner but to be honest because we own and manage I don't know the process for having Oxford manage the house that I own because as far as the city it should say both maybe Kristen you can clarify because on the when you look at things on on E Track at or stream it does have the owner and the the agent right they're both both on there and if you're uh owner manager it has your name for both but I frequently don't see the current management company correct on those forms for what it's worth I look up a lot of housing records for random U ofm parents but maybe Kristen can kind of clarify what that's supposed to look like because that that I think would help us understand too I don't have a good information on that I think that if they're different it just hasn't been updated um and that's just like a like an administrative process maybe that rental housing is working on um I want to add that rental housing said that um um agents or landlords don't need to be present for an inspection anyone over the age of 18 can open the door for a city inspector um so that's not required um and then the other thing I wanted to share is that I spoke with Attorney John Riser and Chris McFarland in the rent in um rental housing and Chris said that issuing a ticket to a agent who is also a tenant is extremely rare um because we were when I was talking with Riser about it we were kind of like it's kind of the circle of the tenant maybe is responsible for maintenance um because they would be issued the ticket because they're the agent and that's where the issue is but when we spoke to rental housing they were like that's not what we see as much so thanks Kristen Julia I just wanted to say this was this is on the books to have a local agent as a way to protect tenants from absentee landlords um that there was a big problem somebody would own one or two properties but they lived in Arizona and you could never get a hold of them to get anything done so it was a tenant win to get this requiring a local agent yeah I think the purpose is defeated if they make the tenant the agent and they could still be on their vacation in Florida what Arizona wherever it is um but just this is on the city's website U just so everyone is understanding what what agent you know what we're referring to it says the homeowner may represent the property as their own uh agent if they do not live or have an office within 25 miles of the city of an arbor they must choose a local agent an agent can be a friend relative or hired Property Management Service the agent does not have to be a licensed real estate agent um and it says that that you are required to complete and upload the property update and registration form on Stream So these changes may may include phone number email address agent information or other changes so that's how it gets into the system you have to there's a system obviously for that requires that you upload that info but so they're they're not doing that when a tenant is the agent Kristen is that I mean and I guess I have two questions they're they're not updating that agent thing each year I'm sure um but I'm curious to hear if you've seen something different but then the second piece being um you said something about a ticket you're talking about like a ticket for trash cans being out or something is that when you're when you're saying are you talking about something different like a like a like a citation like didn't pass the exection now you have um he said that those it is not common practice to give those to tenants because they understand they he kind of like I understand the tenant doesn't have okay so so the inspectors are nervous to fail an inspection if the tenant is the agent no they would issue to the land they would issue to the owner in that case well sure yeah I mean I don't I wouldn't expect that a tenant would ever get a like you failed the inspection I mean it's I don't know I guess in our experience like have to get a reinspect it's not like you get a fine the the owner gets the owner gets the I know but I don't I don't get a fine if I fail an inspection because something is out of code um which does happen even when you're the best landlord there's something that that you can miss that's small and they come back and do a reinspection like I don't get a big ticket as the owner for having you pay it you get one inspection at least my understanding my husband does most of that but you get you get get an inspection and you get one reinspection for free and then beyond that there would be more fees but those aren't like tickets it's not like a trash your trash cans are still out ticket so I'd be I guess what was I'm curious more a little bit more maybe is what what is rental housing they just wanted us to know what are they looking for help with a part of this like what um or they just wanted us to kind of know what was going on I guess I'm more curious as to like what what spurred it because in our experience these aren't things like and it is complicated with a ticket we had I bring up the trash can thing we just had a tenant that got trash can ticket for having their trash cans out too long um they had a they had a dispute it was a neighbor they had photos um they could act basically you know we we didn't have the evidence so we wouldn't go to court for the ticket they acted as our agent with our permission maybe this is what they're talking about they acted as our agent in court because it was their trash cans their ticket and they took the pictures like I don't know yeah so if you have any more information on what they're what they're asking for help with or why they were telling us maybe maybe that would be helpful we we've asked Ral housing in the past can you let us know if you're seeing anything new or weird kind of like in the rental like in their in their world what are Trends they're seeing and I think this is that was the intent of this communication to say like we're getting incre like we have increased volume of work related to this issue um just wanted to let you know it's kind to me it kind of seemed like um from the information that I have was that some like landlord type responsibilities were falling on the tenant um I think related to inspections and that type of thing that makes sense and I mean if the increased work is like this person doesn't know where anything is in the house I mean if my maintenance guy is there he's showing you where the utility room is he's you're speeding through the house and if somebody who doesn't know those things I mean I guess I'd just be curious as to what specifically was the increased work but thank you that makes sense I think it is um my understanding was that like the the work the tenant was doing was as the agent working with the city to do scheduling and compliance stuff like that thanks that's yucky any questions uh comments on this issue I have one more thing on Monday I am meeting with it to learn how to run the report that shows um registered address agent address so we can see um exactly how R it is great thank you okay well I I would encourage everyone to think about this issue um maybe if you happen to have the time to do some research and see if other cities have similar systems and what they if they allow something like this be interesting to know okay we move on to 7-d which is a draft motion by commissioner good uh Julia do you want to introduce this so this kind of came out of the green Fair we're standing around talking about electricity and so then we start talking about outages and it kind of let us down this uh path of how outages are harder on tenants than they are on homeowners um and so that led to the draft of this um I'm not sure if people have comments it makes more sense to go more into that or I was hoping any comments or question yeah go ahead Bob so I think this is a incredibly good statement about the problems that uh that renters face in uh you know with with the current uh less than reliable uh electric grid that we uh that we face um I wonder if it's the motion would be better suited to say we'd really like this fixed uh however however it it it can it can evolve that uh you know to to give City you know to give city council the message that here are four bullets that are are difficult and we would like them fixed please um because I don't know that we can say with certainty what the solution to this would would be um and I have no opinion on it particularly other than uh I share uh this um uh sort of uh uh dismay with what's going on and would like it fixed as well thanks Bob Ros I agree a lot of with what Bob had to say I think that it's important to relate to council the four bullet points um I don't think that given the phase one report that the city received that we can say with you know 100% certainty that the city having its own public utility is going to solve all of these problems number one number two staff we haven't received anything from was it what happened at the you know from all this was that the OSI staff was supposed to you know really look at everything and then make recommendations for what was to happen moving you know what they think should happen moving forward people who are experts right who have degrees in you know energy and whatever else um and we haven't seen those recommendations yet um they haven't said whether or not they recommend a phase 2 study um that hasn't been presented at a council meeting at this point and so I don't necessarily agree with um the last sentence I I think that it's best to just focus on the four and you know informing Council that we need to see this resulted um and pursue all reasonable Pathways to resolving that that's all thanks ranito um I'll open up by saying I do have quite strong feelings on this issue um and I sounds like there's no dispute no disc you controversy over the problems that are facing tenants and that the fact that this has um um a larger impact on most tenants than those homeowners um and I I could attest to that personally unfortunately um I I think that if people aren't comfortable making a a direct recommendation about the way forward we you know one one of the things one potential um option is to um recommend that there's more investigation and that would one way to do that is to say that we think that the phase two study on this issue should be funded so basically that the study that just came out on this issue and other electri you know energy issues um this is called like the one um energy options analysis um it did it did recommend that this the municipalization should be investigated further and um I know the osi's recommendations which is the office of sustainability and Innovations recommendations won't be out for several months this is my understanding and I think that other commissions are taking up the issue of whether a study a phase two study is um U warranted so if we're you know if we're going to proceed with this I think that no controversy over over the problems and if we are going to talk about a path forward I'll say I'm I'm open to many things but we could just say this warrant more investigation rosanita oh I'll um let council member Rina go first because I saw his hand was raised thank you uh commissioner I I just wanted I I don't want to um to to jump in too much on the actual dialogue here I um obviously got the presentation at the work session on the the report um one thing I did want to say is I don't believe that the next recommendation will be coming just from OSI um so I kind of wanted to OSI OSI is not a like public utility expert necessarily and so um obviously if we were to move forward with with the utility we would need to hire experts outside of OSI to do that work um so I think we will receive a broader staff recommendation on next steps um but I don't want to put all of that burden onto OSI so I just wanted to say that um uh and then you know I I think I I largely agree think with with what's being said I think um Zachariah is correct the the report that we received um from the consultant um did recommend moving forward with a phase 2 study which would be the the valuation of all those assets understanding what the actual cost would be um they acknowledged in that report that that phase two could ultimately determine that moving forward beyond that would make that this could be financially infeasible um but they weren't ready to make that that decision yet because we don't have those numbers um but I do want to acknowledge that one of the things we learned during that work session was the priorities for the community and the the top three things that came out of that were reliability resilience and cost um and and obviously the the problems here are directly related to some of the reliability and resilience problems of the network um I will acknowledge you know I'm I've talked to Zachariah about this I've talked to others that are engaged with Anor for Public Power that at this stage kind of reading through that report waiting to hear back from staff I'm I'm kind of leaning in favor of going forward with phase two um but I will also acknowledge that one of the biggest challenges for me is simply that if DTE were not to fight us and were to say here take over um and the storm came through tomorrow all of the same houses that are without power would be without power again so just taking over the utility um is not going to solve for reliability or resilience it requires kind of a different different approach to how um we handle uh maintaining the network and making sure that we have a reliable grid um I do think DTE is failing um in that respect um but I I also want to just be to acknowledge that being publicly owned doesn't solve that problem it's the flexibility I think that I think zachari would agree with this the flexibility of of being able to make those decisions locally um and and being able to invest differently into how we maintain the grid that would create those Solutions longer term um I do think DT has been failing us on this front thanks um ranita um I it I believe in a phase two study because I I am very much a nerd and so I did read through the the the original report um and I there was a lot that they left out because what is it it costs money to pursue the other avenues to know what's you know I guess the legal aspects of it as well as trying to figure out you know really the true cost of what it would be um and trying to figure out more about the actual conditions and bringing in others who can try to figure that out for the the infrastructure as well as the Staffing that it would that it would entail um I I think that so I agree with this uh fa you know it endorsing a phase two study if you will um but I do think that this we still should be advocating that Council pursue um other you know all ways of resolving those four bullet points because it it would take a while to you know start the phase to study and complete it and so I think that it those four should still be worked on thanks was juliia um we can go through a formal motion process where we do this and then do a friendly Amendment or we can wait and do this next month and I can try to rewrite it um but I I just wanted to make a comment maybe this is something we need to do as a commission I feel I'm kind of frustrated with the OS I um that I was on their um green rental housing task force and we made recommendations for changing um some of the code around weatherization um you know all within things that you know are allowed by state law and it it felt like a hot cake like it never went forward and we couldn't even get OSI to make a statement saying they supported the existing weatherization law um you know inspectors don't routinely go up into addicts to look for whether the installation meets the required amount um and Os I wasn't willing to support that so I'm a little um think maybe this commission needs to reach out to them to see if they could do a little bit more on rental stuff and and then I'm open to the commission how we want to handle this um motion I'll just point out I I did contact OSI about the green rental housing task Force's recommendations um and I asked them how quickly they they you know if they're still pursuing them how quickly this would be cre drafted into an ordinance and it seems like they're still working on it so I think that they probably would be open to um hearing our perspective on any of the issues related to that issue I I can't say more than that but I sounds like they are working hard on it um and um I will you know I I'll pass this off to D rosanita in a second but it seems like since there's some discussion back and forth about what this motion should look like it might might make sense to table this until the next meeting in the meantime anybody who has feelings on this can reach out to to Julia and maybe we can have a collaborative writing process of editing uh this motion uh rosanita I was just going to say that maybe yeah we could I don't know talk about it and is it something that we could Workshop in is it next month's tenant Education meeting so that way it's it's ready for the um the regular interest commission meeting um it's a good question I think that I'm not sure if the tenant Education meeting is the correct place for that um would you would we be willing to to send out a win to meet to meet just on this topic specifically for you know 30 minutes or so how long it takes yeah I'm willing is that so then it's just creating like a little ad hoc committee yeah I just don't want to eat into the tenant education committee if they have things that they want to discuss it's not this you know okay okay Julia what would you like to do with this motion uh table it until the next meeting okay um does that require a second and all that or does that just is automatically Ted yeah we hadn't moved it yet so I don't think so okay thank you um okay we can continue here thank you for the discussion um I appreciated everyone's perspectives and I'm glad there's consensus that with the way things are it's not okay because I lost a lot of soup a lot of soup that way I'm very upset about that I'm afraid to make a new homemade soup because I know I'm gonna lose power again okay s-e write to council uh we had discussed this before um um but I'll open the floor real quick and you know we can have a short discussion about it again um does anyone have thoughts about about the proposed right to counsil program I know previously I said I'm interested in exploring right to counsil and an eviction diversion program since they are similar in the their goals um uh and I think that it might make sense to engage other parts of the city government hhsb the housing and Human Services Advisory Board Human Rights Commission um and probably some outside groups rosanita um is it well I'm not diametrically opposed to right to council if things get to the point of an eviction Court I do think that um as the renters commission we should be looking at ways to avoid helping tenants avoid get getting to the point that it ends up in um in court or filed with court not like as you know us taking taking things on but there are other cities do have other programs like tenant landlord mediation programs um as well and those have also been found to have been rather successful um and so I think that to me that's also a path that I'd like to explore or for to see about the city possibly exploring thanks ranita Julia um I really support that and that uh that kind of mediation before going before a judge is what Philadelphia is doing um and that's worked really well there um I also want to push the point that uh Michigan is a little unique in the United States in that you are allowed to withhold rent legally here um if you don't pay all your rent in Illinois Indiana Ohio you're just evicted here you can say you know go in the court and say look at I tried to get repairs from the landlord here's a notice that I sent them they didn't respond the apartment's not worth full amount if I don't have heat all I can do is you know I had to buy a space heater so the landlord should pay for those space heaters they should pay for the electricity those kinds of things and then the eviction judge certainly in the past I don't know if they've changed considerably but then the response was always yes you should pay rent but there's a diminished value to the apartment because of these lack of repairs so you have to pay this amount and then you don't get evicted um and that's the only way that they're really was viable for tenants to fight for repairs because you can't sue your landlord who can afford to hire an attorney to go sue their landlord to force them to do repairs it it's not really a route that's feasible by any means um so I think uh a a diversion mediation typee process would still allow for this but I think it's important to recognize that the eviction Court judges were the only judges that were helping uh tenants in in their poor conditions in their units thanks Julian any thoughts or questions okay well I will go ahead um I agree with everything that's been said um I think that if you were to just do an EV um um a right to counsel program that it would be somewhat reactive and you might waste a lot of resources that way when you could just prevent people from going getting to that point in the first place um I think there's a number of measures from eviction diversion programs to just increasing the cost to file an eviction um which there's some research on the the correlation between the cost of an eviction to file an eviction and the number of evictions which is very interesting out there um but uh I'm going to go ahead and talk with Jeff our leaz on to the hhsb since um he's our U he's our intermediary uh um to that body I will send an email to Human Rights Commission and I think from initial discussions with those groups we can um start contacting other organizations and do some research contact with other organizations so if anyone is anyone here interested in participating in that process of exploring ways to reduce evictions Gail Jordan Julia Patrick rosanita I should write this okay uh and Patrick okay okay rosanita Gail Jordan Julia and Patrick right good everybody great wonderful all right then um well I think we can move on to our next U discussion Point 7-f uh which is discussion on oh inspection fines yeah I think if I remember correctly last time we um had asked Kristen to um try to do some fact finding on how frequently uh inspection fines you know how can we Access Data regarding inspection fines I was hoping to have an update for you today I'm meeting with rental housing staff tomorrow afternoon I was hoping to squeeze that in before the meeting um are you wondering specifically like just like Annual fees collected about inspections or did you have anything else specific I I I think it it's both the fees for having the inspection and actual fines for violations and if there's any historical data on that too and for me this is coming from it's seeming like the building department is a little overwhelmed with the number of inspections they have to carry out in a year and if there's any way we could look at this data to try to come up with ideas on how that department could have more money for more inspectors thank you I'm also uh wondering on the specific issue of the tenant handbook um they said that they usually give a warning if they figure out that a landlord has not beg giving out the the booklet but I'm wondering do they keep a record on that because how would they know if there was a repeat offender if they didn't keep records on it um because last time I check I don't think there had been really any finds issued for that I can ask that too okay um I actually also have other questions regarding short-term rentals um um and I guess just a broad question is like is there anywh that we can find their short-term rental enforcement policy because I think I've been really curious to know how they go about that process if they if they identif first of all how do they identify short-term illegal short-term rentals and what's the process they go through once they do sorry to load you up with lots of questions I know that there is a web page about short-term rentals I will um take a look look at that tomorrow before I talk with Leisa um but I will add that to the list okay thank you if they're actually Gathering fines on short-term rentals that aren't legally registered it seems like that could be a big way to make money in a way that tenants and homeowners would be happy to help because a lot of those buildings are pain in the neck if you the neighbor anything else on the issue of an inspection fines related to rental Housing Services okay great well then we can move on to um 7-g a plan for our November 16th meeting so we are set to review our bylaws review and draft a work plan for 2023 and review our meeting date at our next meeting that's just automatic right Kristen yeah those are good um November housekeeping items definitely take a look at the CTN schedule that's attached there it shows um where the conflicts are for recording and broadcasting evening meetings if the group is interested in um changing from this um like third Thursday at 7:30 time there's not a ton of other options but uh I think it'd be good to start a discussion on short-term rentals we might get to the meeting and realize we don't have time for that I at which point we could just take it off the agenda but I think it's good to start that conversation any other points of disc discussion for our next meeting Julie um I I was feeling a little uh unsure of myself when I was writing the motion about electricity um because I just read like the report on junk fees so part of that was leading to me wondering exactly like what the city council was expecting from us as a commission um should we just randomly be throwing out stuff like Electric outages are hard on tenants or do would they rather see a booklet of here's 25 tenant laws that would really improve things in an arbor um you know like it I I think a better feeling for what that expectation is would make it easier for me to work on the work plan I apiz go ahead Travis um I can try to answer that for you uh I would say there's generally a range of things that we will get from the commissions um I think for something like a statement being made about um the impacts of the outages coming to us in a resolution as a statement from the body kind of adding to an already existing conversation that's taking place I think is more than enough to just kind of weigh in from this body as well um I know that on junk fees in particular um that's something that we're ultimately going to you know work to develop into an ordinance it's probably not something that other bodies are going to be weighing in on to the extent that you guys are so I think it really does vary um issue to isue um I would say like we do not need a report for every single thing um that's that's kind of above and beyond um right so part of part of our role Cynthia and I our role is um is to take some of these recommendations back to council and then Council ultimately decides if we want to move forward with with taking some sort of action on them or or not that's you know those are sometimes we do get recommendations from from commissions that we don't take action on um because the council feels differently about it um but um but you know you don't have to go through a report is absolutely not necessary um because that council is going to do that work also right like you're ultimately making a recommendation um that can gener come in a resolution um and then we're going to work with staff on on next steps anyway um to the extent that you know there's on on some of these rental ordinances that we're working on obviously we are looking to have renters informing these discussions which is why this body is so important and so that's where we have seen kind of this body go a little bit of a step further in making some of those actual policy recommendations that they'd like to see implemented because we do we do acknowledge that we don't have that voice on Council right now I don't know if that fully answers your question because it's it was really an either or um but I would say I don't think you have don't ever feel like you have to put together a full like white paper um in order to come back yeah you know a a a resolution making a statement to council is is generally the standard yeah thank you Travis um okay I think that answered your question Julia think we're good to move on to item eight reports uh we can go to 8- a report from city council would either of our council members like to give us a report it sounds like and I apologize that I was late uh sorry I just went without raising my hand um uh I was late it sounds like uh council member Harrison has already given a bit of an update on the junk fees ordinance that we're working on um so I will skip over that um the other thing that um I participated in and I know council member Harrison um was was going to join us this morning but but couldn't make it um and said that it would be helpful for me to give an update on is that we had a tour this morning of um some of the can uh locations in the community um and so we were able to go to um the Bryant Center Green backer Court Brick and high cone um to view the community centers and kind of see some of those Supportive Services that are available for some of the um some of the communities are subsidized housing Bryant neighborhood is a a community center for for a neighborhood um that has traditionally been more affordable although I will acknowledge is is starting to see that upward trajectory as we are seeing this affordability crisis um there is a we we heard today on the tour that in 2008 and granted there was the you know the bubble head burst at that point um in 2008 the houses in the Bryant neighborhood were going for about $46,000 um one of those same houses is currently listed at about $260,000 um so the prices are astronomical um but we have um Bryant Community Center particularly this is obvious it's my neighborhood it's the one I'm most familiar with um also uh so they're serving the residents there about half of the the residents are homeowners about half our renters um and so it is still a heavily Rental Community um and in that neighborhood in particular that's where Bryant and OSI have a really strong partnership right now and are working on sustainability issues um helping to cut some of those electric costs helping to in one case literally save lives because as they were doing one of their inspections of the house and going through to find out what um upgrades could be made they found out that gas was leaking from the stove into the house and was actually creating health issues for the tenant or for the the tenants there um and so um that's some of the work that's happening there um I will acknowledge that one of the biggest things that we heard on the tour was um there are simply resource challenges for for these um these really important services in the community um Can used to be a beneficiary of kofu funding U the coordinated funding kofu um when kofu fell apart um that was replaced by the city and the county uh creating the new Human Services partnership uh funding that uh can just found out that they did not receive funding in their Grant application this year um and so they're they're going to have to find some additional sources through other grants or funding available um but one of their biggest needs is actually um their food pantries are are seeing increased increased need um and the reality is that food gatherers which is their partner um does not have the resources available to provide them um so there is definitely a food shortage that is impacting residents throughout the community those in need um and so it is absolutely something again where that partnership with that HHS liaison um might be valuable to have some of those discussions as well because a lot of the families that are being served by these centers that are um that are currently struggling a little bit are renters as well and so yeah thank you very much any questions comments wasita um with the um with for was in the past K had um some like a couple of americore me members uh connected with them correct are they going do you know if they're going to be getting an increased number of americore members who can perhaps help with development AKA you know AKA searching out uh grants and helping them to you know write those Grant applications um yeah um I don't know if they're going to get more americore members um I know that I think we met one today I know that there's still a partnership with the program um but I do know we did hear today that they do have a staff person who write they have a a grant writer on staff now um and so that is a person's job um because that's they've had to ultimately find and replace those funds um and so it sounds like they've had some success obviously on the sustainability front they just announced a pretty substantial Grant that's doing help here in the Bryant neighborhood um but but obviously some of that you know food delivery those types of things those are that's still an area of need thank you Cynthia yeah I just wanted to um mention that we um on Monday we passed a resolution to ask our city administrator to complete a visibility study using building inspectors to complete the home energy score assessments as a voluntary service during the renovation process so um doing during the um the ORD you know we passed ordinance a couple meetings ago to uh bring the home energy inspections into the um real estate process and um you know in a year in the city of Van Arbor we may there may be about at most roughly about 1500 real estate transactions and roughly a third of those are actually um condos condominium so um by putting the this in the um building and inspection process like basically when anytime you know someone goes to pull a permit for a Rena or you know there an addition or you know some something they're doing on their home this provides an opportunity to get the score and we do roughly about I mean upwards of anywhere 10,000 to 14,000 of these in a year so um this is was in my opinion a better way to do it but we passed the ordinance so we are asking our city administrator to do a feasibility study a six-month study and come back to council um to let us know what and and that would increase um inspectors or well I shouldn't I won't speak too much on it but anyway I just wanted to share with you and both Travis and I were on um that uh res we were sponsors on that resolution so that's good thing I appreciate that shout out but credit goes to Cynthia on that um speaking of of white papers I think what what was the research document we put together 86 Pages uh so so Cynthia Cynthia did her did her homework and put together a really good proposal um to to move that forward so now I'm gonna I'm gonna give some credit then also so since we're giving credit I'm gonna give some credit to rosan because she uh she called herself a nerd so um uh but she you know much credit to rosanita for for helping with that research so yes thank you thank you Travis thank you rosanita very nice nice well thank you for your work on these issues um I uh let's I know we don't have a report from HHS Le is on Jeff night here said he's going to email us his report um and I think um I guess yeah go ahead Kristen I have um kind of a brief report I can give if we're ready to move this report I'll share my screen also this out also um um you had asked about the rights and duties of tenant booklet to get some information on how those are getting handed out and I have um one of the admin assistants in our office put together a Spong sheet that I was really really pleased with so I attached it I'll show it next um but we are the clerk's office is working to update the city written section of the booklet on the white section we're looking to include um updates on the resource pages to kind of reflect the same as what's on the renters commission web page and then we're also trying to um if there's enough space and it works out to include um like an infographic kind of like this or this one for ELO to reflect some of the new changes in code um what else oh we're also handing these out when we hand out um the booklists these kind of print outs of like at a glance right to R do an ELO um rental housing gave that information on um the agent tenant issue we also the clerk's office also sent rental housing all of the text and graphics on the rental housing laws in an arbor page because we got a a couple of questions to our office about um where they're kind of like hey what's right to R you I've never never heard of it do you have information on that so uh we gave that information on rental housing and then we also gave them um just the text that's on the renters commission page so they don't have to uh duplicate work um the rent control motion that you all passed last time was included on the 1016 city council meeting agenda what else oh I was surprised to see that email subscriptions are up to 538 so it's up about 200 Since I checked last um so that's pretty interesting and I send out emails um before every regular meeting um if you'd like me to send out more um like for committee meetings I'm happy to um also this is kind of news for renters commission you have visible tab now on the clerk's boards and commissions page so it's no longer um a web page that you can only find by typing in a2gov.org commmission um that's exciting um also the clerk's office posted on their Instagram that there's a vacancy for the attorney with experience representing landlord's position um we didn't receive any applications unfortunately but many people saw it so um if anybody has any ideas or contacts for how to reach somebody um who fits that um criteria um let me know and we can work on it oh and then this is thank you so much Kristen yeah thank you great yeah lately it's been busy because it's kind of um well what was like move in time um yeah yeah let me know if you have any questions okay um Jordan that is super awesome I have little muffin that is expiring very quickly so I have to go but I wanted to make one announcement um I was at the capital on Tuesday for um Senate Bill HB 4878 which is fair chance access to housing um right now it's kind of stuck and we really need uh representative Coleman to get it out of the house so if anybody or any listeners have it in them to um send representative Coleman an email and tell him that you support fair chance uh access to housing that would be great essentially this bill would make it so that landlords could not look at criminal backgrounds um to prevent them from housing there are some carve outs uh for example if the conviction was a year ago um arson and human trafficking as well as somebody on the lifetime sex offender list those could still all be something to um preclude you but essentially this is is trying to get it just so that these folks are looked at for the type of tenant they will be the type of neighbor they will be um we know statistically that most people do not reoffend a second time and the portion of the of our population here in Michigan that this affects is huge it's almost onethird of michiganders have a conviction so um we really do um need to look at some of these things uh we also know that this um essentially gives landlords a way to racially discriminate if we're going to acknowledge that the criminal justice system is is unfair and bias and dis proportionately impacts um black and brown citizens and then we know that if we are using criminal records to allow them to not have housing um you know that just kind of feeds into that discrimination so um if you do support it please um you can follow one group that has been doing a lot of advocacy as Nation outside um so you can follow them on Facebook uh to get some email writing tips um they've been really um vocal and helpful in getting the bill uh written and getting things going um and if you have any questions also you can email the renters commission and Kristen can get those to me and I can try to help too so um that was my last announcement thank you guys all for being here and sorry to to duck out early but it's not GNA be pretty here in a few more minutes so thank you all thank you for that thank you I'm sorry I didn't raise my hand thank you Jordan for your advocacy absolutely no no worries at all um okay yeah uh so are there Christen I I think I would love to discuss the I am so happy to hear about all those developments I think we should maybe discuss those at our next meeting if if possible because I I have lots of questions and um very uh grateful for work and the work of other staff members on this um but let's keep going with reports from Commissioners are there any other reports okay go once and twice all right um we can go on to item nine second general public comment all right um public comment can be made by phone by calling 877 853 5247 or 888 78899 and entering meeting ID 935 8814 or 1 941 um or by Zoom um by joining the zoom Link at a2gov.org renters commission meeting and if you are in the zoom meeting you can press star n to raise your or you can press the raise hand feature to raise your hand if you're calling you can press star9 to raise your hand um and you can address the renters commission about any topic for up to three minutes so if there is anyone who would like to address the renters commission go ahead and raise your hand now and we'll call on you all right oh we do have someone perect go ahead I'm wondering if the tenant education Community has any plans on educating future potential renters to stop shopping so early I think demand is driving a lot of this the the chair of the uh education committee isn't here so I'm going to jump in for um we have been talking about having some public type sessions uh where we give education about the law um we did talk earlier in this meeting about um considering some changes or whether it would take a a legal suit to um get some more protections to make it a little bit easier to enforce the um early leasing ordinance so there's I don't have any date to give you right now but it is on kind of our agenda thank you all right and there are no other attendees thank you Kristen okay we can move on to item 10 which is communication we have three emails um all related to Courthouse Square I have read through these I don't think there's anything for us that is actionable personally but I'm willing to if anyone has any points or questions or you know disagrees with that point of view I'll open the floor I'm sorry I didn't read them is anybody still complaining that the elevator isn't working they're different complaints regarding I think like HUD rules uh and rent increases I think it's just sort of impossible for it's not our place to really get super involved in this besides just trying to connect them to to resources which I think has been attempted um and it's I don't think we can really get a full picture of what's Happening um the I did try to reach out to the attorney who's at legal services of South Central Michigan who has been working at the courthouse Square Apartment complex and I haven't received a response but I did get another name for someone to reach out to so I haven't yet done that I got to say green fair and um I will do that uh tomorrow morning just to check in and make sure that they have they're connected with this the res the lawyers connected with the resources that they need okay um last chance for any questions or comments on this okay we can move to um item 11 which is adjournment do we have a motion to adjourn motion I'll second Patrick do seconded by rosanita thank you all those in favor of ruring yay yay yay also post a name that we are adjourned thank you everybody thank you thank you very much have a great night you good night bye
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Passaic County, NJ YouTube / CPS TV transcript source: youtube October 19, 2023 - Clifton Board of Education Meeting · passage 2
to 1: p.m. at wee bake fresh Bakery which is formally Gourmet desserts bakery located at 851 vanav which is confused because it's across the street from the Walgreens on Mount Prospect Avenue it's an opportunity for us to connect I'm going to have coffee Donuts cookies waiting thank you for your valuable time and your consideration once again I am Joseph sieno number four on the ballot for a seat on the Clifton Board of Education this November 7th and I look forward to seeing you at the polls thank you all very much okay good evening ladies and gentlemen I don't know if you guys remember me from last time uh but I was was talking about the transgender issue um section the district policy 5756 C if you could just please state your name your name is oh Anthony dvo I live in Clifton thank you been here for 17 years have a 10-year-old son in the district everybody's doing great um I was here about 5756 before I start I want everybody to know I have nothing against the LGBT Q Community this is not what my problem is my problem is in this poorly drafted document it states that there is no affirmative huh it states that there is no affirmative Duty for any School District staff member to notify a student's parent of the student's gender identity or expression the rest of this isn't worth even talking about once again my point is the state is now attempting to co-parent with a parent as I said before if my kids's got a snotty nose I want to know I'm quite sure that if Little Johnny goes and breaks a window he's going to the parents are going to get a call I'm pretty sure that if he scrapes his knee somebody's going to get a call but if Little Johnny wants to walk around and pretend he's a unicorn and change his name in school then I'm not supposed to know that is the most ridiculous thing that I have ever heard in my life trying to remove a fundamental right from a parent I'm not here to sit there and say or be told hug your child at night that was a pathetic response the reality that everybody says this is not a mandate and it's only guidance that is another fallacy the reason why is because the AG that was arguing that case CU I pulled up the brief I pulled up everything I pulled up the minutes I pulled it all up he was at a point where he was going to lose and what does he do he picks up this thing and it says School transgender student guidance for schools and everybody stopped but it's not guidance because guidance if you look in the dictionary says to help to guide somebody to do something to get them to an end point for the state to spend all this money suing these districts that don't agree with it that's not that's not guidance that's called a forced mandate anybody that can read knows what that is number one number two looking at how this works and how this is written I would be ashamed to put my name on this ashamed and I write and I do things for a living whoever threw this together doesn't know what they're doing and I don't care what anybody says or what anybody does the reality is if you're trying to take away a fundamental right from a parent you're going to have problems you you have to do what's right forget about being scared about litigation costs forget about all that do what is right we we we destroyed our kids during coid we really messed them up because everybody had their own special interest with regards to it and now we're going to do this I've got a 10-year-old son and only 57 seconds left I'm not going to put him through it and as I said before and angry parent I am willing to fight a bear with a toothpick and let me tell you if you see that pray for the bear don't pray for me because the bear will lose and that's all I have to say thank you good evening Elias Rago president of the Clifton Student Union um I come today with two um issues um so as we all know you can look at the news you've heard it at board meetings there is a national teacher shortage um and first let me say that I'm not knocking administration because I understand that Administration is doing the best they can with the present situation but um maybe some aren't aware of how badly this is affecting students currently multip there's at least two um classes are quite literally learning virtually as they walk into a classroom and are expected to sit down open their Chromebook log into some kind of Zoom or Google meet and learn from a teacher that likely doesn't know their name maybe doesn't even live in New Jersey and I think we can all say that that simply does not make sense and it's not beneficial to the student um once again I understand Administration saw this as a simple fix and everything um and I'm happy they did that because the Alternatives could be worse um but the reason why this really you know hit a nerve is because so many of Board of Education members and it's more than one that's either sitting up there today or running now run on the promise of teacher retention that they're going to bring teachers into the district and I question how can you think that you're going to run on a campaign promise that is is an issue for Nationwide um it really doesn't make sense to me and it really just doesn't make sense because students are quite literally not learning as in I've heard them say to me personally I've I've been told personally and I've heard them say to other people we can't learn how are we expected to actually sit in the classroom with over 20 students you know it's bad enough people complain that in a classroom with 30 students they can't learn one teacher now they're in a classroom with almost 30 students and their teachers on the computer it doesn't make sense um and once again I acknowledge this is a national issue you know I saw on the agenda today I believe at least if I understand it correctly four more PA professionals are resigning um it really is affecting our schools um I had a friend that couldn't start a club because there aren't enough pair professionals um I acknowledge the district's you know once again they're quick fixes I see that we're going to raise the salaries of substitutes but that that's not how you fix this um and if your argument of why you should be voted for is because you can raise people's um wages and you think that that's really going to fix this because last time I checked we did that last year too and we're still struggling with this you know it's not the right quick fix and you're on here because somebody trusted you to fix issues somebody trusted that you can think critically and that you can face these issues that face the district and affect students parents whatever it may be um so first of all I don't think that's the right quick fix it's something and I once again I acknowledge that but more has to be done because it's truly affecting students thank you all very much for um good evening my name is Anna man and I am here to speak up for my daughter's asthma action plan um that was denied by a Dr Basista and Mr Rober toy um The Asthma action plan came straight from tonfly Pediatrics our doctor um with the alal dose that she's been prescribed since she was a baby and this doctor Basista denied our asthma action plan because he says he's concerned about the dose and I'm here to ask for help um cooperation I'm willing to sign a hippo release form so that the doctors can speak to each other um because I don't want to delay this any further it's a life-threatening um matter and I'm afraid that when she's in school and she's having an asthma attack and the pump doesn't work for her I I'm afraid that I won't get to the school on time um we were given a handwritten note it was a handwritten denial note and I was honestly a little surprised by the handwritten note um that I that I emailed Mr Rober toy um and he confirmed the denial and I even sent um a document from hackin sack University Medical Center showing that the dosage that she's getting is correct none of the um um the prescri uh the pharmacies none of the pharmacists have ever expressed any any concern on the dose so I'm really not sure why I'm being um denied or prolonging what she needs um at school and all I'm asking is that they give her a nebulizer treatment because the pump doesn't her it does it's not effective for her she's 6 years old um that's all thank you um silence pleas please sure good evening everyone uh Joe Kenova 21 Hudson Street I'm running for border of Ed number 7 on the ballot uh I'm not here tonight to be repetitive this is the final meeting before the election and as candidates we could tell you what we know what we have experience in but the truth is that it doesn't matter because you can learn that as you go and as long as you dedicate time to being a board member you could be an effective one so we could be good public speakers but that's really only necessary if the board is members of president or someone like Dr Roberto who represents our interests as a district we could tell you our position on issues but that's only a glimpse into time on certain known issues in the moment we could show up to every event in town but it does that re does that really mean we care more what skills are really needed listening skills to represent the students in public on issues and items that come up coming up with policies that meet the needs of the district and respect students and parents providing a value ad for subcommittees and issues facing our district not just taking up a seat being a springboard for the super if needed to understand if what he's thinking makes sense most of all the values and morals of a board member are important issues change from day to day but knowing the moral character of a person knowing how they evaluate situations gives you a great idea as to how they will represent the community if they are on the board regardless of the monster of the week that we need to tackle or the issues that occur most of the job is being a level-headed person that can reason with others to understand the issues and vote their conscious on what's best for both the school and the community My overall thoughts for students is that we need to provide them with with what is needed to have a shot at success and it's our job to show them all the areas they can go so they could choose the profession that they love because it resonates with them and not because they think it might be a fit for their future I have three girls and they attend Clifton schools I hear firsthand items that come up and would love to continue making things better and move along for Clifton if what anything I have said that resonates with you tonight as a voter I would appreciate your vote for me this November thank you anyone anyone else wish to address the board hey right here oh I'm sorry I didn't see him hi I'm Cameron Hebron I'm number three on the ballot and like the other candidates before me I'm not here to speak too too much about my Board of Ed race but I am running on a platform of advocacy accessibility and accountability um am I even speaking into the right mic um so first things first I wanted to talk about teacher retention as well as school crowding since I heard that stated earlier school crowding and teacher retention were huge issues even before Co and now that now that CO's over they still remain that way either thankfully or unth thankfully Co shifted a lot of priorities and allowed the state to expend more of the budget on the grounds on the premise that it helps Public Health however they didn't do any work on the back end to actually ensure schools continue to get budget the this budget while schools were already previously under budgeted prior to coid um data showed that short-term fixes like teacher trainings bonuses help but don't actually solve the root of the issue or the long-term issue however there is data that shows quality of life cost of living and other resources outside of bordered would help solve these issues like a parent stated earlier asthma inhalers as well as other health care is a huge it's a huge need for a lot of communities let alone our community schools are expected to be a not by the taxpayer but schools are expected to be a source of free child care as well as health behavioral modeling as well as a source of nutrition for students however we do pay out of pocket for lunches here um other states other counties and other districts don't necessarily have to do the same um that's more tax stuff on the back end next thing I wanted to talk about at first I was confused as to why the health standards were even controversial I hear a lot of people bringing them up I got asked a couple questions about that anyway and just by reading the policy it seemed pretty standard for most developed nations with and like within the last decade it's really on par with most developed Nations um when we talk about transgender people that's only half a percentage less than .5% of the population but in short it's important to have state legislation that doesn't make performative gestures towards a group and actually helps these minority groups going back how this Segways into the pharmacy The Asthma thing and other health care needs when someone is transgender they have the frontal lobe of their brains the white matter in the frontal loes of their brains more accurately aligns to the gender they identify with as Oppo as opposed to the gender they were born with AKA The frontal loes of your brain don't have that much differentiation between the gender your body was assigned and the gender you perceive yourself as that comes from hormone washes in the womb and there's a lot of research behind that let me just get through this taking things a little further I see the same curriculum making linguistic mistakes it's a little bit sloppy and honestly revamping the anti-discrimination policy would do a lot more for families and students and honestly the state at large um to take things even further the health curriculum is the same base with the past decade with a the same base we had over the past decade with wider ranges of implementation but it's statistically proven by many studies to reduce the prevalence of communicable diseases and not non-communicable diseases when we have thorough legislation we when we have thorough planning around health education and health literacy it reduces communicable diseases like coid and non-communicable diseases like HIV and STI um next New Jersey has some of the lowest STI incidents in the country I think it's around 47 and that's all a result of good policy put forward not only by the Board of Ed but by the state um emotionally changing policy would put us in League with States who have amended their health aded standards and have gotten higher incidences of HIV as well as other STI okay um there was one more okay some of my notes from the last session just rapid fire who decided to name the the thing A literacy Green Card why are we measuring English literacy through something called a green card a punch card was right there um Bravo to you guys for the data are the therapists and TR County behavioral changed in gender dysphoria and is it accurate adequate all right thank you vote number three hello everyone good evening my name is Dr lanade uh I'm an Iranian American and I live here in Clifton uh firstly I don't think uh Middle East or any politics should be discussed here at the Clifton Board of Education meetings we have so much to focus on when it comes to education I think we should make a rule to only discuss matters that directly have to do with our children's education but since some of the members of this board have brought up the situation with Israel and Palestine on multiple occasions in the past I'd like to address it today let me start by saying that I want peace for all innocent civilians let's make that our goal and reach out to other community leaders to wish condolences for their tragic losses and to see how we can help to achieve peace rather than Stoke flames of anger and hatred I'm really worried about something tragic Happening Here in Clifton and if we don't reach out in dialogue and find ways to encourage our community members to calm things down I believe we're headed to a dark place my uh my question that I'm here for tonight is I need to know specifically from Mr abdrabo who has spoken many times in the past about the Palestinian cause I'd like to know where you stand because I won't feel safe sending my children to school with a board member who thinks what Hamas did is Justified for the cause so my question is do you believe what Hamas did was immoral you condemned the horrific act committed by Hamas to innocent civilians and children please stop this is you're not going to be directing questions to specific board members we are not going to be answering politically charged um issues with you it has nothing to do with the business at hand of this board of education great so then hopefully you guys can establish a rule that matters like this should not be discussed in these meetings that would be even better I'm going to ask you respectfully to move on with whatever comments you wish to make but not direct them at any particular board member and please try to address questions that our relevant to board operations and the education of the students of Clifton okay great so I would like to request from the board to establish this rule that I'm requesting we'll take it under advisement sir I'll be watching online after to go put my kids to bed thank you for everything you guys do thank you good evening my name is Lor L I'm the president of the Clifton Education Association I would like to remind the candidates that the Board of Ed education Commissioners are responsible for overseeing and regulating The District's Public educational system their primary roles include setting education policies they establish policies and regulations for our district to ensure the high standards that we are accustomed to curriculum standards working with Janina kusevic the board plays a crucial role in developing and updating curriculum standards to enhance the quality of our great education school funding they allocate funds to ensure equitable distribution of resources the accreditation of our school district the board makes sure that the district receives its accreditation ensuring the district meets specific quality standards in addition the job of the Clifton Board of Education commiss Commissioners is essential for several reasons quality education our education here is phenomenal we have to work to improve this quality in Clifton which is vital for the future success of our students the equity help ensure that all students have an access to fa fair and Equitable education regardless of their location or background our accountability the board holds schools accountable for their performance driving improvements in the educational system policy development they create and update policies that adapt to changing educational needs technology and societal Trends funding allocation the board's decisions on school funding impact the avail ability of resources for schools which affects the learning environment and opportunities for our children in summary Clifton Board of Education Comm Commissioners plays a pivotal role in shaping and regulating the district's educational system with a direct impact on quality equity and future of our education here in Clifton now I know that many of you will be going to the convention for the school board just like I always go to the Jaa convention and I haven't missed that in 25 years the only time was Sandy that was it but I saw that you guys have some great sessions 364 exhibitors you're going to learn a whole lot of great stuff there for our district and I'm really happy to hear that now I just want to um piggy back on the teacher shortage and I want Elias to know that the cea and the district were working together on that so we're looking for opportunity to get more teachers here into the district and as everybody knows it's a national shortage and the problem is so many years especially here in New Jersey with one of our previous Governors that the idea of being a teacher and being treated very unfairly in the news and um being torn apart uh has stopped many people wanting to go into education and it's usually the first five years and that's the key time when people make up their mind are we going to stay or are we going to go so I just want to reassure that we're working together with the district to find solutions to this National problem thank you very [Applause] much anyone else wish to address the board seeing none motion to close motion by m Mr robero second by Mr Mahia okay we're now going to move uh I'm going to do uh number eight first Dr roboy please thank you Mr President it gives me uh great pleasure to have one of our uh exceptional students here tonight with mom um and our special education technology integration coach Miss fante and speech and language pathologist from school 17 Miss Heather pulk to do a brief presentation on augmentative alternative communication AAC and recognition of AAC month uh Commissioners you'll remember last month uh Mr brunak read a a resolution where the board uh confirmed and and recognized uh AAC month after their brief presentation Henry one of our exceptional students will show us how he uses his AAC device Mr fron good evening my name is Amy Franti I'm a special education technology integration coach for the district well first let's start happy AAC Awareness Month AAC Awareness Month happens every October AAC Awareness Month began in 2007 initiated by AAC organizations it's a time where people and organizations shine a light on AAC to help more people understand what is AAC celebrate people who use AAC to communicate and share the latest tools and Technologies in AAC the ultimate goal for the month is to make people aware of AAC and to create supportive communities for our AAC users so what is AAC AAC is short for augmentative and alternative communication augmentative means to supplement so it includes things that make communication easier such as text messaging or pointing alternative means instead of as it includes the things that completely replace V verbal communication such as a communication book or a speech generated device so who uses AAC AAC is all of the tools we use to communicate in addition to or instead of verbal speech so most of us are using AAC every day some individuals who cannot communicate verbally or have trouble being understood will rely on an AAC device to assist them they may have a developmental disability which has affected the development of their speech or have acquired a a disorder that has affected the individual's ability to speak such as a stroke what can AAC look like here are eight pictures of different AAA AAC systems that you may find across our district in the leand corner is a flip book so students can flip through the pages to communicate their wants and needs to the right the green go talk that is 20 images that stay in a one location and then students could select their message and it will spee uh it will generate speech next is a switch so if a student um has a message we put an icon on the top we select it help and it communicates what the student needs to the right is an eye gaze tracking system and here if a student is unable to point um to an icon they can use their eyes to select the different icons to communicate their wants and needs needs and then in the left hand corner that's an igas system that's just paper that we can create uh we have Apex it's called a picture exchange communication system and here a student would take an icon provide it to a communication partner to let them know their wants and needs next we have an iPad which is a high-tech device that would have um different applications to communicate and in the rightand corner is a communication coreboard there are two types of AAC we have our uned AAC and this is AAC that doesn't require a physical Aid or tool so it's our facial expressions body Gest body language gestures or the use of sign language and then we have our aided AAC and that is AAC that uses tools and materials such as a symbol board a communication board a switch or a speech generating device just some information about our Clifton AAC users all students in our district who cannot communicate verbally or have trouble being a being understood are provided with a type of AAC system by a district speech language specialist we currently have 63 students who are using a high-tech AAC device which is the iPad um and we currently use two different applications so we the S the SL SLP will select which application would work best with the student we would upload it to a device and then provide that to our students and then I myself um do parent and staff trainings throughout the school year so that they um are using the systems effectively so I'd like to thank you all for supporting all our AAC users and now i' would like to introduce one of our AA AAC AAC users to the [Applause] podium okay is Henry my name is Henry [Applause] okay and we have a few um questions from the commissioner so if you'd like to ask a question Henry will answer some of the questions okay Henry you ready what is your favorite color [Music] favorite hey color is orange my color is great okay who's next anyone over here hi Henry good evening buddy no baseball for Frankie on Sunday so we might not see you and Bobby and Gabriella right uh what do you like to eat Henry [Music] didn't say you chicken nuggets a I love chicken [Applause] nuggets anyone else on this side Judy hi Henry hi Mom hi who is your teacher M teacher is m h my teacher is m h strawber d Henry who's in your family mommy daddy Rosalie [Music] Daisy two cats cats mommy daddy Ros Daisy two cats all [Applause] right over here cats cats one more one more one more hi Henry I'm Tony what do you like to watch on [Music] TV pop [Applause] patrol Henry thank you so much you did such a wonderful job we're so proud of you y and Henry and his teachers and his par would like to come up for a presentation it's not about me Henry just leave them I'll take them okay the certificate reads certificate of achievement we recognize that Henry D Simone of school number 17 on behalf of the CL Board of Education Administration for your outstanding AAC demonstration tonight October 19 2023 with sincere congratulations on your achievement with recognition by resolution of the Board of Education the desire to excel is the formula to a lifetime of success efforts have been have brought distinction to you your family your teachers and your [Applause] cats in there three two one some these phones got Laura's phone no this one's locked don't worry about it got I gotot this I'll text it [Music] to [Applause] good I just don't know where my phone is where my notes are mommy's just GNA say something G to go to 7 right all right good evening um I would like to thank everyone for having me and Henry here uh tonight I would like to thank commissioner brunak for adding the resolution um two weeks ago as well um I I have like a very foral speech but I feel like I don't want to use it um but what I really did want to say um is you know it became clear to me when Henry was very little that he wasn't developing the same as his older sister and you know we didn't know what the future held for Henry and when he was like a little baby like how old his baby brother that he didn't want to talk about cuz he was too worried about the cats uh when he was around his age you know we didn't know if he would walk we didn't know if he would talk we didn't know what type of life he would lead and literally there would be nights that like my husband and I both like dreamt of him walking and like dreamt of him talking one day and he walks now you know you saw him walking all over you know he wanted to go up all these stairs in this building um you know and I feel like when that became a reality I you know we stopped having those dreams you know and and I realized recently even though he doesn't talk verbally I haven't had a dream in a really long time of him speaking because I I have heard his voice you know it doesn't sound the way you your kids voices sound but I know it's you know his mind and his heart and I just wanted to thank the Board of Ed and the special services department and Miss Gorski and miss pulk and everyone that you know works with him tirelessly every day his teacher Miss Huston is wonderful with him all his power professionals everyone is wonderful with him um because you know I I have heard his voice you know and sounds different and that's okay so thank you for having us here [Applause] tonight coming up having another picture all these board members want to have a picture with your picture is famous everyone toct okay I think I could see all right three two one great job [Music] bud we're not going to do a tumble uh so I I speak for myself but I'm sure the rest of the board um would agree folks this is what education is all about this is what Clifton education is all about right here thank [Applause] you Henry already asked to come again oh he's welcome anytime thank you to to Mom the the entire staff the teachers that work with uh Henry and children like Henry every single day we are so appreciative of all that you do and so grateful thank you okay we're going to okay gotta find it here is this somebody's device where is the uh teacher Employee of the Month where the heck is it that's cuz I'm on the wrong one keeps going back to the fifth yeah it switched back to the the meeting of the fifth that's why I can't find it yeah thank you okay uh do we have certificate somewhere oh they're down there okay um yeah um Mr uh AIT trobo would you take one what do we have for right you just distribute them out that's fine I didn't know okay so um these are um these are our recognition and um I'm sorry these are the uh October students of the month so we'll start uh whoever has freshman please is Sophie here all right uh SEC of achievement this recognition is certified to Sophia zel on behalf of the CL board education Administration for CHS freshman due to the month October 2023 with sincere congratulations on your meritorious achievement with recognition by resolution of the Board of Education the desire to excel is the formula to a lifetime success your efforts have brought distinction to you your family and the Clifton public students schools excuse me Dad expanation oh my God you don't even know that many words it's an auto fil hey Jim [Applause] Jim good think we're good think he signed in but he's good no he go no my bad you're in business all right cooking with oil now ohic good evening everybody is Judah here Judah Judah Portillo delali Judah is a sophomore at Clifton High School who enjoys history class and shows his creativity by making animated videos he was most influenced by his sixth and eighth grade teachers who made him feel valued and encourage him to pursue his dreams his parents have been the most inspiring people in his life as they push him and encourage him to do his best he looks forward to having continued success here at Clifton High School certificate of achievement this is recognition is certified to Judah Portilla de Valley on behalf of the Clifton Board of Education Administration for CHS sophomore student of the month October 2023 congratulations [Applause] Judah e thank you president Smith is Juna Crawford here come on up junah junah is a junior here at Clifton High School junah is a junior here at Clifton High School when she's not in the dance room her favorite academic subjects are math and English Jun also plays varsity volleyball and is a part of the advanced dance classes and dance Ensemble program her most influential teacher has been her dance teacher Miss barrows who has resurfaced her love and passion for The Art of Dance junah plans on continuing her dance career through and after College as well as majoring in sports journalism and broadcasting Communications congratulations to junor Crawford our Junior student of the [Applause] month hi uh is Nico Valencia here okay no worries he's here oh Nico come on up senior student of the month Nico Valencia Nico is our senior student of the month he was recommended by Mr White for his tremendous Improvement and growth in English Nico's favorite subject is Tech draft mainly because of the projects and assignments are very entertaining Nico plans to go to college and study architecture Nico is currently a member of the CHS nutrition club and also works as a swim instructor at the YMCA so the certificate of achievement this recognition is certified to certify nicoo Valencia on behalf of the Clifton Board of Education for October e with uh with so many uh talented students in our high school is truly an honor to be recognized as student of the month so we congratulate everybody for your Great [Applause] accomplishments okay we're going to um we have uh number 10 okay um a new uh recognition program uh that's been started this year Dr roosi wanted to highlight uh employees of the month and while it's such a we have such dedicated and talented people in our district um we wouldn't fit everybody in this room to be uh employees of the month but we we surely would like to recognize uh one employee uh this this um month of October for recognition so um so we have um actually we have a few here so we'll start with um we'll start with Joseph Joseph Schmidt [Applause] for now start on this side please yeah we'll read it but start on this side they already gave things out that's all right you're there go ahead go ahead uh Joe SMI Schmidt is a floating head custodian who works quickly and diligently responds to all staff's requests regardless of how many tasks he already has to do Joe makes sure that he says hello or good morning to every staff member or employee comes across Joe always has a smile on his face he makes staff members feel seen and valued Joe makes sure everything he has to do is done and then some he is a kind he is kind and helps without hesitation he knows every aspect of every school with which in and of itself is very quite impressive Joe also sets a great example of hard work to our students which is admirable we recognize H our U Employee of the Month Joseph Schmidt floating head custodian congratulations oh oh theme that's it right yeah that's it yeah present the should I read it or no oh yeah we read the black uh just want to read this so really before I read this actually Joe and I just reg graduated class 2003 together we just celebrated our 20-y year um High School reunion last Saturday um so not that I asked to read this but it was handed to me I thought it was just fate um so it's actually an honor for Joe for me to read this for Joe Clifton Public Schools district distinguished Employee of the Month October 2023 presented to Joe Jo excuse me Joseph Schmidt for outstanding service dedication commitment to the Clifton Public Schools Learning Community congrats [Applause] buddy [Applause] thank you president Smith this next uh Employee of the Month War goes to William Terrell hey [Applause] Mr B Mr B that's a way to do it bring your own audience so William Terrell mostly known as Bill head custodian Bill Terrell is a remarkable head custodian for school 12 who is all [Applause] here he works with a smile on his face every day and gives his colleagues staff and students his utmost dedication to keep the building clean organized and up to code Bill quick fills in for his colleagues with no complaint and answers all calls after hours even though he is not qu required to he is a true team player Bill not only works tirelessly to keep the school building clean and spotless but he makes sure all teachers are happy and comfortable in their classrooms he is present and visible at all times and when given the opportunity he participates in school events to connect with students and staff he takes pride and joy in his work and keeps schol school 12 welcoming safe and [Applause] [Music] [Applause] presentable Clifton Public Schools Elementary School distinguished Employee of the Month October 2023 presented to Bill Terrell for outstanding service dedication and commitment to the Clifton Public Schools learning congratulations [Applause] bill school 12 be only F if you come up and get this come let's go [Applause] you [Applause] thank we got more to go we got more to go who's reading Brooks I have horn I have horn horn who's reading Brooks uh Middle School distinguished Employee of the Month John Brooks School security specialist John Brooks has been an amazing addition to wwms Mr Brooks welcomes our students every morning with a smile a fist bump and his wonderful playlist of music to pump everyone up and Infuse our day with positivity he is a positive force to be reckoned with often with some brief words of wisdom or encouragement both students and staff all equally recognize the beauty of what Mr Brooks does for our school every day District security Specialists look to him as a mentor and leader staff members feel safer with him there students feel protected and looked at after Mr Brooks always goes out of his way to get to know students make them feel seen appreciated valued and safe congratulations to John [Applause] Brooks Commissioners we're not the only ones who love uh Mr Brooks he is being honored tonight at his university he's being inducted to their hall of fame um so we'll recognize him in the future but that's the type of uh person we're talking about here congratulations Mr [Applause] Brooks High School distinguished Employee of the Month Jeffrey horn Network [Applause] [Music] [Applause] coordinator Mr horn is a dedicated patient compassionate and understanding Network coordinator Web Master does not see his position in CHS as a job but as a service to his co-workers he is always ready to resolve any technology issue swiftly and efficiently it does not matter how busy he is he will always make time to answer your questions with a big smile Mr horn is highly proficient in his knowledge and technology and brings talent to clipton high school he makes his priority to address all user complaints by ensuring functionality and efficiency of sites and web services Clifton public schools high school extinguish Appy point of the month October 2028 2023 my bad presented to to Jeffrey horn for outstanding service dedication and commitment to the Clifton Public Schools learning [Applause] community con [Applause] Mr M Mr Smith also Mr horn made the mistake of telling me he wasn't sure how formal this was so he wrote down a few words so um after your picture maybe we'll let Mr horn say a few words [Applause] un right all right guys uh duh I didn't know how formal this was so I wrote a couple things down um good evening ladies and gentlemen colleagues administrators board commission Commissioners I would like to take this opportunity to express my gratitude and appreciation for to be nominated for this honor uh when people explain what I do for the district they seem to like describing it as that I wear many hats uh I suppose that is true in some respects um I am a network coordinator for the technology department I manage all Auditorium productions for CHS I dabble in live streaming I am a media specialist uh and I am a teacher although I not in the classroom uh that is the hat that is most important to me um to explain uh technology as we all know can be very frustrating um so I approach resolving issues uh with a teachers's perspective in mind uh I dedicate myself every day to tackle each and every Tech issue with urgency efficiency and with a smile on my face as someone mentioned me earlier uh I do talk through Tech problems with our administrators teachers and students uh from a teachers perspective as I said so they can understand the problem at hand and that tends to help alleviate some of the frustrations uh if technology is hampering our administrators well they are not productive in guiding our district if technology is not functioning in our classrooms the direct result is the loss of incredibly valuable instructional time and in the end it's about maximizing instructional time uh for our teachers to instruct our students of this District so um for me that's why I'm here uh I approach my job with great pride and enthusiasm to make sure we do maximize the instructional time for our students um and so I guess people had seen this taken notice of that regarding me and I'm extremely grateful for that uh I would like to thank everyone involved with this recognition I would like to mention a few special thank yous my colleagues and Friends Mr mccy Mr lesler Mr Rose Miss kenning miss sagorski Mr Mecca my supervisor Eric mountain and my technology department colleagues and of course I would be remiss without mentioning my amazing family and their support that I receive at home um we don't live in Clifton but my family likes to call me Mr Clifton so because I'm here quite often but thank you all so much thank you uh Dr robit toi thank you Mr Smith Mr horn thank you for those words folks I just want you to understand the um significance of this this is the first time we're recognizing an employee of the month we have almost 1,800 employees so to be recognized uh at your particular level Elementary Middle High School or district is truly um truly an honor you there were hundreds of nominations this month alone and you were chosen having said that I want to give credit where credit is due um this idea was not mine although I loved it and it was last spring near the end of the year one of our assistant principles Miss Jennifer Ray uh sent me an email and said it was just so nice how we honor the students of the month why don't we consider honoring an employee of the month and I said I love that idea guess who's going to run run it and uh not only did Miss Ray run it she took it over she handled everything um so miss Ray I wanted to acknowledge you tonight and thank you for all you did did we have [Applause] um how many nominations did we get was I accurate 101 nominations so so folks the the November nomination will come out um next week very shortly uh nominate your colleagues and I I love the fact that uh Representatives came out to support their uh their their colleague and I hope that we see more of that in the future thank you very [Applause] much okay next we have our um our wonderful student uh representative Jada yep Buton there you got it sorry okay good evening um Commissioners and Dr Robert toy um I'm going to start with just some um Sports announcements so our girls tennis team girls volleyball team and boys soccer team had their senior night this week so um please continue to come out and support the rest of our other sports as we wrap up the fall season and um our football team is having its second to last game of the season tomorrow at our Stadium tickets are $12 if anyone wants to come out um okay so Club updates Key Club is once again having its NJ EA pridefest Pride fast Grant um continuing to host their free Zoom series of workshops with the Garden State equality for the whole clipon Community um they have upcoming workshops January 24th um March 20th April 17th and May 22nd if anyone um any residents of Clifton are interested please contact Miss Turk at jurk Clifton schools onet um next we have some updates with our mock Tri team so a couple weeks ago the CHS mock trial team attended the Yale bulldog in Invitational which is an elite trial tournament in the US um our Clifton mock trial team dominated the field and beat their opponents by 118 points they face teams from Texas North Carolina and Massachusetts Massachusetts one of my sophomores um Jenna altner won the best attorney of the competition competition by 20 ranks um Omar Ari one of our seniors won a dual best witness Award with 17 rinks for prosecution um yes thank you our steadfast dedication over the summer summer break was rewarded this is what um the adviser Mr vand said their steadfast dedication over the summer was rewarded with a clean sleep of all four rounds um next they will be attending the Harvard mock tral senior competition they will learn techniques from Harvard's University Mo team with Jess Jessica Alexander a CHS alumni that will be teaching them strategies and techniques from the number one ranked college level mock trial team in the country so that's exciting um and their victory at the yellow bulldog in Invitational Garner garnered an invitation to be the bubster team for the mock trial um Interstellar virtual mock child competition they gained an honorable mention from Empire at their closing ceremony um they said an an astonishing feat was performed by the clipon high school they will be competing next November at the mck Tri World Championships in Chicago Illinois and we can expect an update on their performance um from the Hindu student Hindu Student Association they will be having a cultural dance known as the Garba on Friday October 27th starting at 7:30 in the lower gym of the CHS and they would love to invite everyone to come out and support them which will be next Friday um so our senior class we actually just celebrated a successful homecoming weekend starting with the senior Sunrise Breakfast um and a big congratulations to our homecoming king queen Bianca gardano and Omar Ali near nearly 400 CHS students had a wonderful time out of dance this past weekend um and spirit will spirit wear is now being sold by the senior class through October 30th with options for General designs by anyone in the community who would like to support our class of 2024 um so we have our fall play coming up um it is called I hate Shakespeare they're hosting what they hope to be their biggest and Main fundraiser of this season with a flapjack fundraisers at the Applebee's in Garfield New Jersey on Saturday October 18th between 8 and 10 a.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Monroe County, IL YouTube / KCHS transcript source: youtube Columbia CUSD4 Board of Education October Regular Meeting · passage 2
and we need to check do another roll call make sure nobody stuck out here here here here here here all right we're still here that's good didn't lose anybody in three minutes all right we don't have any visitors again in public or in person welcome everyone online a correspondence any correspondence no correspondence this time all right move right on to our consent agenda SC if you'd like to walk us through that this being October there is very little um you've got of course your financial statements and your uh minutes of previous meetings um we we have two individuals to hire Michael Gum shimer as a custodian and Fred Wagner as a bus driver we are always looking for more custodians and bus drivers and subs of those non-certified um but with that that's really it so Administration recommends the board approve the consent agenda as presented perfect any questions concerns comments is that an entertain any motion to approve the consent agenda as presented I'll make the motion thank you do I your second second leis the seconds roll call please H yes Andre Cory yes Kelly Moyer Greg Meyer yes Lisa Schumacher yes Tyson search yes perfect pass it unanimously we'll go into our communication reports and presentations the enrollment report is in your packet think there's anything significant on that and we'll go right into our ad our building administrative reports starting with the building hi that's me so I'm Mrs Bard I'm the assistant principal here at CHS um so if you look up I have some slides for you guys um at the end of September beginning of October we basically have our biggest event of the year which is homecoming um if you see the on the picture over there of the band drum line last year we started a tradition where at the end of our games the drum line kind of walks everyone out and plays and everything um it actually is now our second year that we've done it so we're trying to make it a tradition to include the band there during homecoming games the kids thought it was great and even busted out their electric slide that they do typically at the end of basketball games before they walked out of the school um if you see in the middle picture we have our staff members there so one of our games that we always end with is the tug of war game um and our seniors won this year so they beat out freshman's uh all the way through Juniors and everything but then we surprised them with a staff tug a war and the staff luckily won just barely but they won um and then one of our biggest Traditions during homecoming had that we always start off with is our hallway decorations so our theme this year was Hollywood um all the H all the hallways looked fantastic the seniors did Mama Mia it was very beautiful um but I wanted to highlight the Juniors they uh did Top Gun one of my favorite movies so um but they had a nice Runway they had airplanes and everything so that's a nice little tradition that we always do and then they spend nice time cleaning that up at the end of the week too so thank you for all those students who came out um at the very bottom we have our fight for Like an Eagle this was our breast cancer awareness month is October so our volleyball team and our student council raised over $1,000 that we ended up Don donating to the bre breast cancer awareness Society so we thank volleyball insute Council for doing that um in the middle picture we have Miss McGinty and our choir they ended up going to the St Louis Cardinal Stadium where they sang the national anthem or God Bless America one of the two but they had a nice little field trip out there they did a wonderful job um and Miss McGinty and the choir team as well as ban um just recently went ahead and had their tryouts for jazz festival and everything like that and I believe we have several students anywhere from four to five that actually qualified for the festival so we're really excited for them um and then at the end we just have some shoutouts with our uh sports teams uh Jacob Hall and Avery Allen they a sorry Arendelle um made it to golf State this year so that was really excited for both of them um in soccer right now actually it happened tonight it was supposed to happen last night was their Regional Championship and darkness kind of went out and so we played overtime today out at father mcy and they won in penalty kicks so our boys are Regional Champions this year and they will be starting sectionals in Murphy's Boro on Saturday at 1:00 um our volleyball team I just got text updates from our athletic director who's out in freeberg he said freshman just currently won against freeberg in three sets our JV has won the first set they're still playing JV right now um and so they were winning 1514 against freeberg varsity of course hasn't started but their Regional play starts in so our playoff series uh for the state Series starts October 22nd and then cost country this Saturday is also going to be in Highland um we have very good hopes for Mr Ethan Hogan he just won his um conference for us uh we have some lovely ladies that are also doing very well in that Series so we have high hopes for crost country as well and then I just wanted to give another shout out to Ethan who um currently I think about two weeks ago signed with the University of North Carolina to continue his running career out there so we're very proud of that young man um if you go to the next slide I have more of the educational going on here um if you look into that corner we have four of our students and miss Germain that are proudly uh displayed out here every um month we do staff and student of the month um our character trait was purposed so those young um students over there won because of their purpose and their goals in life and where they're going and then Mr Jermaine we did a shout out because of all the help he's one staff member that truly bleeds blue and so he got the staff Spotlight as well for that month um um if you look at that lovely display of Miss Bard in Eastern Illinois University our College um it was college application month this month and so our counselors have put fantastic videos out there and to support going to college we put every teacher every counselor every Aid out there on uh displayed what college they're going to so every day they walked into c a classroom they were seeing the different colleges that we've all G on to um and then lastly yesterday was October 18th we had a very large group um it's probably our largest group that we've had recently that took the PSAT and the nmsqt which is basically um the National Merit Scholarship program test so um we had 39 sophomores and 64 Juniors take it so um sometimes we've just closed down a classroom room our study hall room for it and this year we actually had to bring everyone into the gym because we had such a large good T A large group taking it um and we also just got some notice about the group that took it last year we have Mr Noah Boyer Edwards who um is now a semii finalist he's competing for actually one of these scholarships so we're very proud of him and then we have Lane elers who um got her scores back and she's recognized for a commendable um score as and which is known as a commendable student so congratulations to those two students of ours and that's all I have unless you have any questions for me awesome perfect well appreciate the building update and sports update too so perfect all right we move on to our assistant superintendent reports so I'm going to pay you back off of Amanda real quick so when they took the test yesterday it was um the first time that we've given this on online um the College Board is pushing to take sat PSAT all of that will be on an online test now much like the elementary students take the Illinois assessment of Readiness um and so it was there was some learning curves to go along with it but um the councelors the administrators um but es especially the students that took that test did a fantastic job with switching up a format on them all of a sudden with that so just give them an extra shout out um this month kind of my my highlights are um Kelly search at Eagle View and Erica Kane at uh Park viiew are two of the teachers that are piloting our Orton Gillingham um reading program this year um like I said we have several teachers that win over the summer to get trained they are two of them Kelly is really taking the lead with first grade and doing a lot of the planning getting it organized for the team so that all of the first grade teachers that are piling in it are on the same page um and have everything that they need Erica Kan is doing it in second grade um and she has been great with coming and being um communicating with me a lot about what's going well what she's struggling with what do they still need um so that we can keep tweaking it um we are working with um Jen Hall at waterl and we are actually sending four teachers on Monday and eight teachers uh in November to go do some observations at um in water that they've been implementing for a while and so now that our teachers have been trained they can kind of go see it in action um at the middle school I want to give a shout out to Rachel Matthews um she is in the PE department and does an exceptional job teaching but we've been spending our last couple sip days in the PE departments looking at the updated mandated units that the state has set forth and all of the requirements um and while you know science social studies had a one page or a two page the PE Department actually had 14 pages of updates to their state mandated units um and so they've been doing a great job um and Rachel has done a great job at Middle School kind of uh keeping that department together coming up with ideas and sharing them with Administration on how we can get those to work um and then at the high school Scott gerine again um did not realize that he was the high school Spotlight person until Amanda and I had just talked um earlier this week but um Amanda was kind of that spearhead person at the high school in the PE Department um when she left there was obviously a big void to fill and um Scott not only has stepped up and kind of taken that lead but like Amanda said he is willing to do anything for anyone I went over to see High School um the homecoming games and he was right in the middle leading it all on the mic getting things set up ready to go moved it around um anytime anybody asks or needs anything he's always right there to help do that so um really appreciate that and then as far as what else is going on um the state has I guess not temporarily but hesitantly released the school designations um they are under embargo until October 30th and not only have they they were released then they were all redacted because they were wrong then they were released again Chris and I have both heard from multiple people that they are changing so don't get too set in it um I will say though that we have already started diving very deep into the data that there is um with some hopes that the state has some errors in some places to our favor um but at least just getting it and seeing where we at with this data that they're right now giving us um and start setting some goals and some some growth expectations um which is then also leading into some professional development we've been spending a lot of time already this year um I said the elementary teachers are working on that Orton Gillingham uh reading instruction that we've been looking at mandated units we've been looking at our power and priority standards again really making sure that we're focused in on what is essential to be taught um I don't know if you realize but our state standards if you broke them all apart and taught them there's 15,000 hours worth of instruction that needs to happen to cover all of the standards and in a typical school year if you don't take out the days for homecoming games or Christmas parties or anything like that we only have 9,000 hours of instruction um so there's a lot to figure out what's the priority and what's the utmost importance to get taught with our students so we've been doing that we also though have started um Chris and I had a conversation about we've been building up our PD for our teachers um but it's also time to build up the PD for our administrators and so we're slow slowly getting into that um because we uh want strong teachers and strong administrators for the benefit of our students in this District so we're we're starting to work on that as well then parent teacher conferences are going on right now Tuesday night next Friday morning um just thrilled with as many people that we've had signed up um very glad to see the number of teachers that reached out to parents before we even set it up live so um it's been great and hopefully they are going well right now and that's all I have unless you have questions thank you right now we'll move on to our super um I'm going to be short we're we've got projects and we're going to be talking about a lot of the stuff that I've been doing tonight I am getting the tax uh Levy ready for you all to do the initial approval next month um but our tax rate is looking good I believe it's just under 4% right now the eav keeps moving into nice directions that helps us keep that rate down um I'm going to Echo what Alyssa's been saying about all the PD uh we consider ourselves lifelong Learners and we are always getting better and um it's really this last half day I uh was trying to find my sanity and so I went into one of the rooms while they were while they were uh working and I I watched a bunch of the teachers here in Parkview there's no other way to say it they were just absolutely nerding out about early literacy and the rules with the consonant vow consonant and what sound comes from the I mean just the science of reading and I was just sitting there in awe and it was really just very cool so um I am glad that that OG training is coming we've got that resource in Miss Hall at water that's a national trainer and and so it's just it's a really good program and I'm I'm looking forward to seeing where it's going to pay P off but that's the teachers PDS the the administrative PD because we're all learning every time is is also of importance and so it's good stuff that's it that's pretty much it all right perfect we'll take it all right go right into our items for Action uh first one is the approval of the 2023 annual financial report yeah and this kind of goes along with that lifelong learning uh a good audit is like a uh going to the doctor you know you get a check up and they tell you what to do right uh our FY 23 had no um no issues no problems with the financials however during that year while we transitioned over our financial software we realized that there are some weaknesses in our controls and so um last month we had our our presentation of the financials uh Miss Cory and I sat down with Mr schals and went into great detail on how we could could improve and ensure that some things that had happened in the past can't happen again um you've got a copy of the summary of the auditor's results and again these are recommendations that are really for [Music] um just to ensure that we're all reminded that we can always be better we can always do more and uh find your Solutions but with this last little part about the findings you'll see that the criteria the conditions the cost lause um there was really just this one finding and again it was not from something that happened this year but from something that we found this year that we wanted to make sure we took very very seriously um with that said I would recommend that the dis that the board approve the annual financial report Mrs Corey do you have anything you want to add to that no I think you've summed it up I agree okay any questions comments concerns would anybody like to make a motion to approve approve the 2023 annual financial report I'll make that motion thank you Andrew do a second I'll second thank you Tyson roll call pleasey yes Kelly Moyer yes Craig Meyer yes this is Sher yes Tyson search yes Adam hkin yes all right unanimous approval and we go on to Item B which is approval of the bid for the parking lot project and you've got this letter here from FGM you'll see that we had two biders uh krb Excavating and DMS Contracting and this is for the parking lot that would be up at the um city park and uh the recommendation is to go with the base bid we did do an alternate that would add a little extra um sidewalk and the city was looking at whether or not they would want to um tag on that alternate but I I talked with Mr brim today and and they will be doing doing that at a later date and so the recommendation is for us to do the base bid and that would be awarded to krb Excavating and the base bid would be awarded at $47,476 they were the lowest and the most responsive or they are a responsive bidder So Perfect Adam anything you want to add uh nothing to add the only uh I guess question I have is in the recommendation letter from fgma it says that um they had krb I guess had noted that flooring in some light fixtures are concerns for lead times I don't I don't understand why there there's no flooring in this project right and what light fixtures because am isn't amarind providing the elect maybe lighting for the stairs we get some clarity on what light fixtures and why flooring is a concern when there is no flooring in the scope of this contract for this effort okay I will look into that get clarification back to you but I would still recommend the base bid yeah we with that I'll make a motion to approve the base that approve them as the the how about contractor how how about let me make a suggestion on the motion you're about to propose How about if if you make a motion to accept a base bid as long as it doesn't include overages for lighting or flooring since we have well it was only for schedule is was was the only concern that's why I wasn't really okay just the only concern they had for their schedule was with flooring and lighting okay I didn't know if that was part of the contingent or not so no okay all right sorry didn't mean to interrupt so your saying oh I was just saying I would make a motion to to approve approve them as the as the recommended offer or to select krb as our contractor Perfect all right we have a motion do I have a second I'll second all right got it there a roll call please Kelly Moyer yes Greg Meyer yes Lua schacher yes Tyson search yes Adam hkin yes Andre cour yes yes perfect we have a new parking lot congratulations everyone involved know when that's going to start I would ask for that schedule to be shared with the board though okay I think uh it's pretty much ready to go isn't it yeah it's it's just a matter of temperatures and and time so um I will notify FGM tomorrow get clarification on the flooring in the lights but ultimately look for the schedule and see when we can get that so they will um will pending the vote yeah get it started tomorrow yeah I mean they didn't have any like because I when they came to for the bid opening they didn't express any concerns with the the desired completion date so that's why I'm not so concerned with what with the details of the schedule because the completion date we wanted was by April I believe yeah and so they you know obviously their schedule includes a completion date of that but when they're starting when they plan on doing you know ripping up the existing Road stuff like that is I I think it just be good for us to know so that we can start coordinating with the city and anyone using the park Etc so yeah absolutely that Park in lot full tonight with people with the foot the the youngsters playing football so yeah is it's going to be a good addition all right perfect we'll move on to our discussion items we'll start off with the facility study we met today with uh Peter and FGM regarding the high school project we are going to be meeting every other Thursday so our next meeting is November 2nd um we do have a homework assignment uh Mr hemin Mr Myers and I along with Kim poock from uh Cobalt are going to be meeting with Brian Reeves and Amanda Bard um next week Tuesday I believe to put the the the base plans and start making that every teacher's got a room and how many rooms do we have what do we need getting some of that granular details uh this process of adding on and um this kind of project is rather new to me and the idea of getting the big picture and then going down to the details to then go back to make sure the big picture to then go back to the it's it's um it's interesting but um we will be moving ahead and every two weeks we'll be having homework workk assignments and start moving forward do you have anything to add Mr hin from the meeting today uh no I think right now um basically where the meeting we had today was like Chris said it was just a preliminary here's here's a swag of here's everything you wanted and here's some you know a little bit more detail as far as a design and some options so we discussed them giving us different options for the auditorium for the gym for the classroom spaces as far as okay if you did a full build out of everything you know like the auditorium for example all lighting all curtains all sound materials you know sound deadening materials whatever um give us everything outfitted give us the base shell or you know they some of it they called White boxing and give us an option in between so that we can make some cost trade-offs um you know along the way to make sure that we're budget conscious and responsible so that's part of the proc process of where we'll be going over the next couple of meetings is working through okay here's three different pricing options for each of these spaces um what are we going to get or you know maybe not three options maybe five maybe two whatever um but here are some Al alternate options or decision points um based on how how how much you want to outfit now what we can do for later um you know all the classrooms won't be immediately used we recognize that um so us just having those discussions and then looking at what we can do later um as far as Renovations that are have the most impact and which ones would have little impact so a lot of that trade-off discussion um that's kind of we started setting the groundwork for it we haven't actually started the trade-off decisions but setting the groundwork to get the information so that we can make informed trade-off decisions because I mean that's the name of the game with this it's not hey here's everything we want we're going to get everything we want it's how do we make trade-offs along the way that are the right decisions so and still leave opportunities for future projects as money's become available to be able to get some of those things that we had to not get this time right so so it's been a very uh a good process you know and with every step they they start refining their numbers and so but by the next meeting we will have more details perfect any questions all right all right going on to our Item B is the iasb resolutions first reading unfortunately this is not as many as we had in the past so very fortunately yeah and so what we do here is is typically um just bring it to your attention next month we will actually go through each item and um please come with any questions email me any questions you have on them or concerns you have on them and and uh because Mr search will be taking diligent notes next month because he'll be going to the IAS the The Joint conference they call it now um and casting your votes for the [Music] board Perfect all right on to when will the meeting are we moving it up next month yeah it'll be Wednesday so we're just moving in a day we're not going up a whole week yeah no just the day so when we uh set the agendas or the the board meetings that was one of them that we moved and so we did it the Wednesday then we'll travel up the next day those resolutions are also available the publics are available on our new website if you haven't checked it out yet but they are there in case anybody wants to look at excellent point perfect thank you good plug and our new website is hopefully uh more user friendly I think it I like it but good all right any other questions on the resolutions go on to individual board member comments anybody have anything they'd like to share this evening I just wanted to give a shout out thank you to the high school volleyball team and the coaches um last month they participated in my suicide walk that I do every year on the song for soldiers weekend and and um they kind of did it as their little warmup before practice and they also did a collection of some funds um at one of their games and donated that to the suicide Foundation nice anyone else that's hard to follow Lisa all right board M prerogative I don't have anything this evening and we did have a spot for an executive session but I don't think there a necessity for one so we will forego that therefore there will be no action items following the non-existent executive session the only thing left to do is adjourn would anybody like to make a motion to adjourn I'll make a motion thank you Kelly are a second I'll second Lisa all in favor any opposed perfect that concludes our meeting time is 7:32 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2023-10-20 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 10-19-23 · passage 2
practicing our form technique and learning new skills and that doesn't even include competitions on the weekends with hours of practice and competition each week fencing is more than a club on top of that competition days are more than just competing for us treasure treasure fencers it means we have to get up and drive ourselves to places like Gilford or Madison which can take over an hour to get to um the students and especially our director Heather Von Fischer can't always get a bus available for competitions due to a lack of funding which if we were classified as a sport at cheser High School then we would not have to worry about driving ourselves for hours to get to a competition the treasure Fencing Club also participates in tournaments the novice JV and varsity tournament and we usually place in these tournaments meaning that and get medals meaning that most years we have fencers who are ranked in the state for all the skill and commitment it takes to be ranked in the state we should absolutely be recognized by the school for a dedication to the sport as someone who has been fencing for three years now my life has truly changed for the better through the the Fencing Club even more so that I'm considering fencing in college we deserve to be recognized as a Varsity Sport and I hope the Board of Education will support us thank you thank you good evening my name is Jim lebre uh 1289 Deer Run Circle and I have yet another letter from a former fencer my name is Barrett Le and I'm a 2011 graduate of chesher high school I started fencing through the chesher program in January of 2015 when I was in sixth grade I was terrible at it and I wanted to quit after two classes thank goodness my parents encouraged me to keep trying if not if not for fencing I never would have found my place fencing was my main extracurricular before and during high school and it provided me with lifelong friends who I view as family two former Chester fencers got married to each other I recently attended the wedding of another it also allowed me opportunities I wouldn't have gotten any other way I fenced on the Collegiate varsity team for four years at Boston College against Olympians and national champions and I'm very proud of my Varsity letter beyond that my teammates again friends turned family saved my life and not for the first time I know I have a Network because of this sport I'm sure many people will rise to talk about what the team is now the incredible sacrifices of the Von fisers and the hugely generous Gifts of time and expertise from all the volunteer coaches like John minardi and Jim poine over the years that family aspect is what makes this program so special but I want to talk a little bit about the early days in all that time we practiced and eventually competed wherever we could find Space usually Elementary schools sometimes having practice cancelled or moved last minute to accommodate other groups my freshman year of high school I talked about fencing so much that my history teacher who was also the softball coach hi Mrs dorbo I'm a history teacher now too convinced some members of the softball team to support us in our first ever home meet but we weren't a part of the high school yet so it was at Norton the other team was confused and thought they had shown up to the wrong place so we kept working at it fencing was on my high school class ring but I never got a real Varsity letter just the one Scott Von Fisher bought for all of us with his own money when we graduated I have fond memories of many meetings with longtime chesher High Athletic Director Steve trone working on a proposal to let the fencing team use the school in any capacity at all I thanked him for it when I asked him to sign my yearbook he was as always gracious I still remember the unrestrained joy when after many back and forth discussions on our proposal I could call the team and tell them we were a competitive Club the same as the mathletes who knew that was a thing it wasn't a big move on the school's part but it meant the world to us moving the team to the high school meant we finally had a stable place to practice and compete it meant we belonged at least a little we not the high school chartered and paid for a yellow school bus to drive us to the state championship the next year the first time we had ever traveled anywhere together as a real team instead of car polling and then we won and it wasn't our last when I checked a few years ago at least a couple of the trophies were still in the case I really only started fencing because there was a a demo one day at Chapman things would be immeasurably different now if I had even just been sick that day instead I got lucky and my whole life changed imagine how many generations of fencers won't need that kind of luck to get started because they'll see and hear about it at the I School while I no longer live in Connecticut I dearly wish I could attend this meeting in person and urge everyone in attendance to support the feny team in the culmination of their dare I say our decade plus quest to obtain official recognition as a Varsity Sport at chesher high thank you for your time and go Rams thank you thank you so [Applause] much good evening good evening uh I'm John minardi uh I was assistant coach of the fencing team with Jim polling and Scott Bon Fisher and and Heather and uh they were terrific uh and I'm grateful for all the work they did and I'm grateful to see that the tradition continues and Mike Michi and Blake are here they were both on the first championship team that uh that uh and Mike made actually decisive victory at the end but I'm actually here to read Scott bomb Fisher's letter he could not be here tonight he is in Houston and uh so I'm gonna read as if I'm Scott bomb Fisher because he wrote it in the first person even though I'm John monardi I live at 244 Crescent Circle in chesher Connecticut uh and my son also uh could not be here tonight uh he's with his daughter uh he's married now and but he was also a chesher fencer uh so here's the letter from Scott I am Scott Bon Fisher the founder of chesher Fencing Club and I'm excited to learn that the chesher board of education is considering recognizing the club as a sport it is significant that the words of support have come from the students in alumni and is their passion for the sport that gave birth and has kept the sport alive at chesher high school the club began humbly by a handful of young students requesting that I bring the sport to chesher in a few short years it was a completely different set of students that petitioned and gained Club status at the high school through that time the club was supported by an amazing set of volunteers that seemed to come from nowhere and everywhere within our town fencers who were Olympians olyp University competitors chesher Sports alumni doctors Professor First Responders and of course with the uh Team of Cheshire Educators ultimately even the alumni of the program began to give back to the community and helped the club continue to thrive today over 20 years later yet another group of students has come before for you looking for a venue and the recognition to represent this town competing in the sport they love so dearly this means in which the club has grown is commendable but is not sustainable as a sport has grown within the state maintaining a level of competitiveness of which this town is known is difficult to achieve while being completely self- sustaining thank you for your considerations Scott I want to thank you for taking the time to listen to us tonight to everybody here who's spoken to you thank you thank you I just curious just quick show a hands how many more folks want to speak four of mine to go a little while longer do you good please yeah please um hi my name is Cadence Le France I live at 184 toath Lane um I will be speaking on behalf of sucha who couldn't be here tonight and myself um this will be both of our second Seasons fencing with the high school um treasure fencing is a community of people who enjoy the sport however with the restrictions that come with not being identified as a sport for example no busing becomes very hard for students to partake in the activity in the situation of No Buses students may not be able to get rides from parents which may cause them to not be able to participate at all by definition fencing is a sport that develops skills such as speed strength and reflexes it's even considered an Olympic sport um by officially making chure fencing a sport and offering the amenities that come with it our fencing group can grow and get even better in the future and um I'd like to add my own thoughts or speech um I am immensely proud of what myself and my teammates have accomplished throughout my past year in this sport um placing second at the novice tournament this past spring against schools with much better funding than I is something I'm incredibly proud of and while the difference in funding makes my achievement worth more in my heart I can only imagine how much um I'm sorry how well our team could compete if we were equals in the first place um I also believe that the current members of this club work so incredibly hard to improve our camaraderie with among our team and with other schools and just work so hard to make it a positive environment and if any like if anything I believe that our current members deserve to see the full potential of this club thank you thank you so [Applause] much hello everyone my name is Grace bian I live at 264 Higgins Road cheser Connecticut I am a junior at chesher high school and I'm captain of and a captain of the ch fencing team I first joined fencing my sophomore year because a few of my friends were members and I wanted to try something new however it wasn't long before I began to love the people the practices and the sport and going to practices became a highlight of my week fencing is a place where everyone can feel like they belong and after only a few weeks I had already come to think of myself as a CHS fencer and a part of the treasure High School fencing family I love every aspect of the sport both the mental and physical stimulation getting to learn something completely new is challenging but very rewarding these challenges have both made me a better fencer and an overall more confident and adaptive person I never could have imagined that I would be voted Tri captain my second year of fencing but I love the team and I'm so grateful for all the opportunities this club has given me opportunities to make friends be a part of an amazing community and deel develop leadership skills that while competing against other varsity teams another thing I appreciate about the team is that like me many students join as beginners and are able to advance their skills from there treasure fencing offers to fully fully teach new fencers the sport and prepare them for meets and state tournaments in order to continue doing this we need coaches throughout the years our coaches have been made up of CHS graduate volunteers and although we love these volunteers and I'm so grateful for them um they are no longer in the program and as a sport that includes blades fencing requires protective equipment as well as definite safety regulations this creates the need for experienced coaches and for this we need funding the fenon club already acts as a sport and is home to almost 30 members and has been established for over 20 years however as an active sport up-to-date protective equipment is essential to create reliability and decrease the risk of injury to students our director Heather Von Fischer who fully volunteers her time and resources has been amazing at providing most of our current equipment and although still usable it's not the safest um I would actually like to add a tiny story that I didn't write but last year I heard from a few of the older fencers that um uh first I would like to clarify that I am so proud to be a CHS fencer but I heard from them that the other schools would specifically put their senior nights on the nights that they had meets with chesher so that they would make sure that they would win and they would be a happy senior night right and although I'm not sure if that story is true the concept and the idea is is there and that's just disrespectful right okay uh continuing fencing is a sport that develops reflexes physical strength and strategic skills it's community that supports you throughout the winter season and Beyond and I'm so grateful for everything that this team has given me and all the opportunities it has provided I can't imagine the rest of my high school experience without this team and I hope you'll help us continue to success of this program and support us so that CHS fencing can reach its full potential full potential as a sport thank you for your time thank you hi uh Carol wonderlick 1257 Maran Road um I've been involved with the uh high school team for many years my daughter started when she was a sophomore and um as with many people in this room several of us parents decided to take lessons once our children graduated um I can it was a lot of fun too and as I can say today I still fence I train l i compete locally and nationally um for several years I was a coach for the team it was an experience that I found to be enjoyable challenging and rewarding the students who joined the team were diverse many had never participated participated in a high school sport fencing gave them an opportunity to have to have otherwise oh fencing gave them um the opportunity they wouldn't have otherwise it didn't matter how athletic they were how quickly they mastered the basic skills or how they performed on the fencing strip they were a member of the team they were on a squad and they all competed regardless of their ability I can't think of many other high school sports that can say the same fencing is a sport that requires both intellect and physical ability it is often referred to as physical chess you have to be disciplined and have self-control you must be able to plan ahead react to an opponent think on the spot adapt to a situation and change your strategy it is constant problem solving you are mentally organizing yourself as you prepare for different possibilities all while all the while you are being Physically Active on the Strip these skills techniques and thought processes help shape who you are and how you navigate Life After High School when you fence you a member of a very supportive community that Community includes all ages backgrounds and ability levels this is from personal experience a 12-year-old male can fence me and we and it is on an equal playing field it is a complicated game oh I also wanted to mention that it's an also a sport where an able-bodied person fences someone in a wheelchair it is a complicated game we are always learning the only limits to the sport is the one you impose upon yourself I'd like you to please consider strongly making this of our city sport thank you thank you hello I'm Javin Zang and I just want to share my thoughts on what I think and feel about defensing team uh five Bluefield Court hello everyone my name is Javin Zang and I'm a junior at CHS to be completely honest I'm pretty nervous speaking in front of everyone I'm obligated to support my team because as meant so much to me in my freshman year I didn't really participate much I didn't go to many practices and I didn't go to a sing s Le match in the whole season I almost quit this quickly changed in 10th Grade I went to the first game in my life and I was super nervous when it was my turn to fence this fear quickly dissipated after I heard the encouragement of my fellow fencers I didn't realize how fun fencing was before I started participating more I started going to every match I could I started to get be excited for practice to start most importantly I started to uncover the community that was def fening team if someone wanted to go to McDonald's it was the team that was going if Alexa mcpadden wanted to host a party at her house where we ate cake and watched movies and looked at all the stupid and funny pictures we took over the season the team would go if Ben Paladino wanted to host the best senior night ever you would expect patas confetti launchers and a parade of Bloons to welcome the graduating seniors this fencing Community pause for emphasis has truly been the highlight of my high school career so far thank you for listening to my thoughts and to another successful season of [Applause] fencing thank you so much well [Applause] done hi I'm gr Loa from Cher high school and I'm uh representing a speech from Eric a warts dear treasure Board of Education I hope this letter finds you well even though I am unable to attend tonight's meeting I hope that my input might still be able to Aid the decision to make chure High School Fencing Club into a official Varsity Sport I'm a CHS alumni from class of 2022 and was a member of the fency club for all four years of high school I also returned to coach last year but I was regrettably unable to continue this year due to scheduling conflicts I can however say with utter certainty that one of the best parts of my high school experience was fencing I was is I as in is the case with many students came to treasure High hardly knowing anyone and it was through the amazing community of the Fencing Club I was able to develop lasting friendships and make meaningful connections with other students the welcoming environment of the team still holds strong to this day with a focus on both improving the existing skills of experienced fencers and intr and introducing new students to the sport sport the fencing community of Connecticut includes many high schools both public and private with dedicated fencing teams recognized as Varsity Sports by their respective administrative bodies one of the persistent challenges of the cheser high school fency club is transportation in the past students have relied upon their parents or carpooling with friends in order to attend fening meets and tournaments it is through these tournaments that fencers not only improve their skills but also form friendships with students from other schools with whom they compete due to due to the nature of the sport as is the case with many others there is a certain number of fencers needed in order to compete and even being one team member short can in many cases lead to immediate forfeit if students were provided with transportation in the form of a bus as is the case with to my knowledge every other school with the varsity fencing team it would lead to better attendance as well as make it EAS easier to know if the team is going to be able to fully compete at any given event now I know there's only so much time I so much time with which I have to speak and trust me I could go on and on about the benefits of the sport to students mental and phys physical health but I will wrap it up here so that you can hear from whomever will be speaking after me I implore you to consider the cheser high school Fencing Club of Varsity Sport AS it will give the team the resources it needs to live up to its fullest potential thank you Eric a warts thank you thank you so [Applause] much hey my name is Blake Wetmore uh eight pwns side place I was a student here back 10 years ago now I'm part of the group that kind of started this whole uh Club off I if the group started in 200 three I must have started in 2005 I think I watched on the sidelines at Norton playing in the cafeteria with some of my friends for the first couple years uh but I've been part of this group for almost my whole life and after fencing through my high through my whole High School career it was some of my favorite experiences of my life I still think back on the first year that we won but even more fondly coming back the year after we lost in the finals and and to reclaim our title probably my favorite memory all of high school but after uh going off to college and coming back I knew that the club was looking for coaches so for the past six years I've been I guess the head skills coach as we call it Heather was certainly the head head coach but I was the one teaching all the classes and uh teaching all the skills and as you've heard from everybody all the current and past students the passion for this sport is clearly there and the dedication is there um the hardest part has really been the on our side making the program continue whether from Transportation or really vitally having coaches there who know the sport and can teach them I like to think I did a decent job with the program um but I'm certainly not a Olympic level fencer um and if we could find a way to get professional coaches in people who have been trained for this or have fenced all through college would be amazing and right now the landscape for fencing coaches is so difficult where uh I've been a volunteer for the past six years and even this past year there have been coaches from other groups who have been trying to poach me to their Club offering me money to go there and pay me and just to be dedicated to this group I've been staying but if we're trying to go out and get coaches with no money and no funding I'm just worried that the club might not be able to continue for a long time as much as Heather wants to push forward um her being there alone isn't enough to run the program so if we could get money to go out and hire a coach we'd be able to consistently uh progress this club forward and really see amazing things happen and I just want to lastly say so proud of all you students coming out um it's been amazing to see over the past few years the growth in all of you and to see some of you standing up here after seeing who came to their first practice it's uh unbelievable to see you up in front of a group and talking so uh thank you all for your time it's been wonderful thank you so [Applause] much hello Michael micii from 1135 sper Road I started fencing in 2008 tagging along with uh my sister who my mom forced to go there to uh yeah she forced her to go fencing starting at Norton Elementary School which is kind of where uh a lot of the practices were taking place I tagged along in fifth grade uh fell in love with it picked up the the blade in the hand and never really stopped was competing against treasure Academy in fifth and sixth grade beating those kids and uh often through middle school and into high school um I played you know like I played football uh fencing track baseball all four years never stopped and fencing is the sole sport I wish I could keep doing and I coached for a few years with some of these athletes and unfortunately I cannot continue um but being able to get funding for this this sport would greatly greatly enhance uh uh the sport to come thank you very much thank [Applause] you Hello friends bear with me I just wrote this in a parking lot alen Nichols 35 C away so I'm here today to thank the opportunity to advocate for our kids chance to make you proud fencing has helped many high school students in chesher for the last years and last year our our daughter was invited by a good friend Ben to join in the fencing team and we are so happy she did um she really Blossom and she really improve in every area in school and sports um before she used to play softball and now with fencing the softball coach noticed that she improved in many aspects of the game as a catcher and then vice versa and when she came to practice fencing the fence the the coach noticed that the softball practices did help her with the fencing so in her first year um it's amazing where the quality of the training she received here because uh she placed third place in a state along with a good friend to place second place and that says a lot about the commitment uh and Ben plays amazingly out state so I'm I hope that you guys um give this kids a chance to make your proud because mark my words keep their names is going to be not only local State national and some probably International recognition um our coach Heather Miss Heather from Fisher has been a wonderful coach and has given so much of her time and dedication she and her assistant coaches have thought the kids discipline needed to learn this amazing Sport and good techniques that allowed many of them to succeed in state competitions joser High School fencers have qualify above many private and public schools and those schools with bigger and stronger support um some of our kids like you said qualifi I beat some of the ches Academy kids that have been practicing for four or five years um in other schools as well um this program has been growing year after year and we hope that this unique and elegant sport can receive the board of aded and superintendent um support So allowing our students to increase their presence in local State national and perhaps International um we do have many athletes and our cheser high fencing team with determination and refined skills enough to place cheser Public Schools names higher in the leaderboard we appreciate your consideration in supporting our fencers in making this official School Varsity Sport giving them the opportunity to make your proud thank you thank you El we uh we have time for one or two more so uh thank you please welcome to come up hi I'm Shan Le in 264 Higgins um thank you for all the Board of Education members um for giving us the opportunity to speak here on behalf of the cheser fencing team my daughter Grace joined the cheser high school fencing team last year she really likes it she has been very diligent in participating in the practice sessions several times a week asking me to purchase equipments a metal helmet other things which I did they also have regular meets and games with other fencing teams all across Connecticut he even won a medal in one of the matches of I'm very proud of her for me the fencing team is very much a regular school sports team surprisingly I found out that the fening team does not have a sports status in chure high unlike other sports they don't have a budget support from the school they don't have paid coach they don't have bus transportation to and from games out of town and they are really a second class sports team in cheser high school because it is not recognized um it is painfully unfair to the many def fing students you can see they should be treated the same way as all other sports teams I know other parents feel the same way please support our chair here fencing team with regular budgets bus transportation other benefits enjoyed by all the student Sports in in spite of all this second class status the team has been striving to be their best the captains the seniors put others in practice in providing Transportation with some parents and uh the volunteering coaches help the fers whatever way they they can this great team atmosphere does give me some comfort but it should not be an excuse for us not to support them let's treat the chur High fencing team just as other sports teams let's give our students the support they need and they deserve by making them a vasage sports thank you thank [Applause] you good evening um I'm not from chesher I'm from Prospect but I'm a local girl lived there my whole life um I'm here because I know some of these athletes students parents I've worked with them for years um I teach fencing I'm a coach I also teach at Quinnipiac University I've had been since he was this tall I've known Mike for a long time um my titles are state champion National Champion North American Cup champion Canadian American CH Cup champion world champion I work with athletes in high school I work with eight-year-olds I work with Olympians I have two going to Paris I had no idea ch wasn't didn't have fencing as a Varsity Sport I thought it was do you know there's 23 other schools in Connecticut that have fencing and it is a Varsity Sport um Madison Fairfield Greenwich uh greens Farms Guilford Simsbury those are a few I'm paid a lot of money to coach at some of the other schools Green Farm I can tell you these kids deserve this they deserve a place where they fit in they deserve a place that has opportunity and growth they deserve it chesher high is a fantastic school you have everything here these kids deserve this sport quite honestly I don't know what else to say I was shocked to find out you didn't have it they really do deserve it honest and truly and these guys work so hard some of them are at my I can't get rid of them they're with me five days a week they're working out they're eating right they're training hard they're not just looking at school competition which is where they start they're looking beyond that with their leadership skills that's what this teaches them confidence so I just uh that i' give my two cents thank you no thank you thank you for coming [Applause] out so we went we went way over our public comment period but it it's it's it's it's worth it again I know uh the speaker some of you thanked us for listening that's why we're here you elected us and you know we we hear concerns and the feedback and ideas um before I say anything else I just want to say thank you so much uh outstanding speeches tonight uh very professional with our students that are currently here you you shined uh you're making is very proud up here uh it's great to see the confidence the enthusiasm the well thought out arguments you're making I I think that's reflective not only our school system but the value of this club it helps build those skill sets so very well done I'm even even happy that we have former students writing in in some cases texting Dad to read the the uh which is awesome is that just you know explains the value of this and I so I I couldn't be more proud of hearing everybody tonight um I I know our board members probably feel the same way we normally don't do this I just want to spend a few minutes I'm sure we all have questions um but before before I get into that there's nothing on our agenda tonight that we're going to discuss this and vote on it uh this is the first I've seen and have people come out uh to raise this and I'll talk about process was that might help um move this forward um so me talk about that and I'll just turn quickly the board members for a few minutes if they have any questions since we have everybody here tonight I have one or two um but what normally happens is the superintendent prepares his budget and somewhere in that budget are additions and and you know it's usually teaching positions or not I I haven't seen any I'm not putting you on the spot I haven't seen anything yet for fencing to become Varsity Sport as many of you pointed out it's usually around Transportation coaching salaries certification that kind of thing so I uh I'm just wondering if you've had any discussions with and I I want to put you on a spot I'm not sure he's talk to Mr parisino or like in the past but have you taught anyone besides us tonight about moving this forward and who should they talk to uh to as far as I'm concerned this is an official request but uh I would expect to see something in our upcoming budget process which starts in January uh for this so the board can actually vet it ask questions and we went through this a few years ago with girls ice hockey and that I think at that meeting and if not mistake even prior to that there might have been a couple finance committee meetings where the group showed up and gave the committee some details such a number of students typical cost out of pocket for parents and and during the budget process that year they showed up and we actually went a lot of detail about it um before I turn over to the board what um sure I mean I can I can hit on some of those I assume some discussions have happened yeah absolutely you know I know that uh Mr Paladino spoke to Mr parisino he had sent um us after the open Forum board meeting two weeks ago kind of a a budget uh overview and to be clear I mean fencing hasn't been put forward nothing's been put forward yet like we haven't even started our budget process yet uh that'll as Mr paragini said take place in January for the 245 school year and at that point I would present this and I said to Mr Paladino that that would be part of that budget presentation so um you know right now is things stand we're in the process of pulling all of that information together and it would be shared through the budget process for the board to decide upon for you know the future yeah thank you again I didn't mean to to put you in the spot I don't want to assume anything before I turn over to the board really quick is there a even at this me we're gonna ask some questions and I uh is there a point to contact besides Heather is that you that we can send our inquiries to and collect them because uh you we don't want to wait till January to to ask some obvious questions but okay so thank and by the way thank you and to all the coaches all the volunteers for all your time and effort past present and future coaches I hope that continue to move this forward uh it's not lost on us that you do this uh not for the money because there isn't any but you know for love our kids and you know trying to get them to to be better so I appreciate that um any questions from the board before Samantha I do I have some questions a lot of questions actually and um couple comments I'm a little same as you Mr perini a little discouraged and saddened by the fact that I'm hearing this for the first time given that the program has started in 2003 um you know I my only knowledge of fencing is through friends and I am well aware that number one it's an eloquent sport it's very prestigious and I just said to my colleague over here it's chess but real fast chess as the lady back there had said so I'm I'm disappointed because we are reacting to a large comment public comment right now where and it's a process question you're absolutely correct what are we doing do we need to re-evaluate the process to catch this early because then my question extends beyond what are other clubs that are not being acknowledged in advance of you know we're reacting what is the proactive process to ensure that all of our kids are seen and heard before we have a not that we I listen I'm proud of all of you trust me but we're reacting to a large crowd right now so I'm a little sad I'm I'm very emotional it's it's way too long for us not to have recognize these guys and gals for a while so I I'm I'm hoping that Dr could answer some of these questions um I did get a little education today because I also didn't know that there were 23 other towns as well too so thank you for that um so I I myself need some clarification on the process I myself need to um also understand what is also the St sustainability of the program um given that I do not have knowledge of what the feeder system looks like because if we do eventually vote on this I'd like to see this continue as well so those are some of those mix the motion questions if we can answer them prior to taking any votes yeah thank you I just want to remind the board that this is not a discussion topic uh it's really the questions or any questions for the public we can get into the details other committees but understand uh while we have the audience here any any information the Board needs tonight from our folks yeah please AB um so back at the open form Mr Paladino came we sat right over here and I just want to say um um a huge thank you to you because you know we were kind of you were going through you were asking some questions about process and how things were happening and then finally we looked at you said like what is it that you want and you said you know then you went through the whole thing with fencing and these kids and so you know we sit in these seats up here and I've been on this in this role for four years and I honestly had no idea just like when the girls ice hockey I had no idea about that either and so we can't know everything that goes on in the district so when a room of people like you guys all come out I know you've had busy days a lot of you guys have been up since 5:30 this morning I have a daughter who's a junior at T High School I get it um and you speak before us it's not easy to stand at that Podium but if we don't hear people come we obious we don't know some of these things are even going on in the district so huge thank you to all of you for coming out and I won't be here because I'm not running again but I hope you guys vote in favor of this uh next year thanks you'll be here in spirit yes Tim thanks Tony yeah just two comments um first of all with to a feeder system um I actually I don't know that I really would look for something like that from a sport I actually think that as well as the the individual nature of it in my mind is a really good thing because so my kids are in elementary school but I can already kind of see like you know my son's in second grade but he's not in he's not in flag football yet and there's there's the feeder system and I could see a freshman in high school feeling I haven't done that for years so I can't do that so in my mind this could kind of be an opportunity for uh maybe I'm just thinking generally more introverted more uh kids who haven't participated in team sports to feel this is an opportunity for me to do something so I actually really that that sits well with me like a feeder system can be good but I think also the lack of one is totally totally fine I think there's a benefit to that uh as well as the individual nature more like a golf because I think most of our sports are probably team sports and that's a good thing but I could see a kid who hasn't played getting a freshman year and feeling they just they can't do it they can't jump into a team sport because everyone's experienced so just my thoughts thank you and thank you for everyone who spoke tonight thank you yes Ian yeah I just want to say thank you all for coming out tonight um this is what it takes to get this process started and um it was delightful to hear from all of you I did know that there was fencing going on um and I knew that it was going on for a long time because my kids way back when I'm looking at uh Mr Wetmore and and thinking I think you were just a year behind my son in high school so anyway um I did know it was going on um I'm glad to see that it's risen to this level of involvement and um I you know I'm interested in this go moving forward with this this uh topic and um I'm excited about it I it's going to get my support so um yeah we're going to be talking about it so thank you for coming out because this is how the process does start thank you thank you an so I I want to but I want to say thank you to to all you I know uh even our students who are here you probably have some homework to do and appreciate you being here at nine o'clock in a board of ed meeting but your voices are heard and you know for the record this is on the record it's going to be on our YouTube school it's yeah you're on camera it's a good thing it'll be on our school tube so I I think uh especially for our students you know please watch you look back on on your comments I think be very proud of yourselves for this evening and we are looking forward to reviewing this during the budget process as Dr s and committed we're expecting to see a proposal and you know and we'll definitely talk about how this can hopefully be made into the budget so uh Heather we're probably gonna reach out to you I don't know if we'll just CLI some questions some in your way uh I'll find your email somehow I'm sure um but I expect between now and January please expect some questions from us and to anyone else out there as well on the community if you're watching this please feel free to email us your thoughts on this our our email contacts are on the treasure Public Schools website um again so I I can't thank you enough on behalf of the board being tonight and uh you've been heard and clearly we have some things to work on again like people said here uh while we try to you know watch and see everything going on in the school district we can't see all the details uh but but we appreciate your feedback and I I do remember fencing being in place if not mistaken I believe might have been 2011 or 2012 way back then I believe there was a small group that showed up uh to move this and I don't recall there being that big participation clearly it's grown over the years and that's commendable to all your hard work and dedication even for those um who moved on from suppor this program so we'll definitely take the seriously and we'll let you know when we'll be talking about this but expect the January time frame um if it comes up sooner we let you know but thank you you don't have to stay but you're welcome to we we had a boring business thank you [Applause] we good to go you guys want a break or just keep going let's go okay so up next there's reports of our standing committees I give a second to clear out last okay yeah all right so a curriculum committee we do have a report as well as possible action tonight so I'm going to ask uh faith cannot be here this evening I'm gonna ask Anna Marlene to take us through the last meeting and fortunately I couldn't be there but I have to speed on the whole topic so I I we're gonna bring you up to speed Tony I am well aware but we actually talked about this in finance so I'm kind of curious to see what's coming out so Ann do you want to start sure uh so curriculum committee met met on uh Monday evening this past Monday October 16th and we really spoke about two things that Miss Solano is going to go into uh detail on she'll report on uh the agenda item first regarding legislation that changes the starting age of kindergarten from turning five years old by December 31st of a school year and that's going to be backtracked to uh the child being five years old by September 1st of the school year um so with with that I think I'll just I'll leave it to Marlene to um explain to us what this proposal is all about so in your packets each of you has um packet that looks like this talks about the public act 23159 that raises the kindergarten starting age and beginning July 1st of next school year that in order to enroll your child in kindergarten they must turn 5 years old honor before September 1st of the school year in the past that date has been January 1st so there's two couple of things that are that are happening there um the first one is that districts are charged with coming up with a process and making sure they inform families that um this is the new law and that they would need to make a written request if they wanted their child to start kindergarten um they would have to make a written request for early admission upon request then the principal and a team would need to determine um an assessment that would determine whether or not kindergarten would be appropriate developmentally appropriate for a child that age so what we really looked at was how many children are we are we thinking this will impact and so we ran the data of how old children are typically when they come into the district and so we looked at our historical data we're saying on average there's about 60 children who fall within that September 1st to December 31st time frame who would be four and could not start so we're thinking about the impact that would have to these 60 families and wanting to sort of meet them halfway because they may or may not have know about the law number one they may or may not have planned for an extra year of daycare or preschool Etc so we're thinking about starting a one-year transition program that would be for these children only those who fall within the this birth date range we would reallocate a kindergarten teacher and a par educator per enrollment we could we could put a cap on that um that would be housed at Darcy school and Kim desert is here with us tonight in case we have some questions for her we're estimating that to break even that the tuition that would need to be charged would be roughly $5,500 that would cover the cost of any any teacher and a par educator like roughly we're looking at that and saying that in to follow with our other Kinder other preschool programs parents would provide transportation those students who would be in that program would then attend kindergarten the following year they would not go to first grade they would go to kindergarten and the curriculum is something that would be based on the Connecticut early learning and developmental standards what we call CTS and the curriculum could be developed through um through our office in Miss desert this year and then those teachers who would be we would be reallocating would be given time during the curriculum writing Institute looking at the students who are coming in and tailoring it to their needs so we feel that this is um worthwhile because it addresses the immediate issue of these families we're meeting them halfway this would certainly be much much cheaper than daycare um it would be commensurate with a preschool program Miss dessert has met with other preschool programs and they're also reeling from the law because they may or may not have the space to provide for an extra room in their in their daycare facilities whereas we are able to with some of the reallocation that we've done with our um one of our special ed programs we we would be able to to house this temporarily for one year at Darcy I would also just include you know the space is available because the students are not enrolling in kindergarten because they're not age five yet right the other piece that I think is relevant here is that um over the course of the last several weeks uh the Connecticut Department of Education and office of CH Early Childhood have been kind of collaborating around guidance for school systems um that has been I would say significantly delayed uh the hope is that we would see it this week um but obviously don't have it as of today in that guidance though uh we were told that a substantial part would be dedicated to the rationale the rationale for moving the start date uh age five from January 1 to September one and I would be uh remiss if I didn't indicate that most Educators and the research pretty strongly speaks to the benefit of that um so knowing that it research Bears out that it's beneficial for students to wait I think this is our uh compassionate and reasoned response to provide access to Quality uh programming that through no fault of the community may not necessarily be available due to space uh at a cost that is incredibly uh competitive if you've had to put children through daycare lately um and so it also sustains uh importantly for us if we had 60 kids not show up um and we would therefore be looking at reducing staff more than likely so we would be letting go good people um who you know we may not be able to hire back the following year when the demand recalls and so um they would have recall rights uh if there is a reduction in force but they may have another job find go some place we have to try and find somebody else who may or may not be as good so I think you know this threads the needle this proposal in a lot of places and uh all it does thankfully is provide us another option to pursue at no C cost to the taxpayer but great benefit to many as I think I've just articulated so just a little more context from where I said yes question Sam I just want to go back to the numbers so I'm getting this right little linear for me right now so we have 60 kids for next year hypothesize that's our our average over the last five yearsin thatth doesn't this impact the ratio of pre required pre because they're technically considered preschool but now it looks like you have 60 kids in one classroom with this 1K teacher and Par educator proposal no we're saying that it could be up to 60 children approximately and that we would look at um one one one par educator and one kindergarten teacher per enrollment so if we had 18 kids it would be one in one if we had you know 40 kids we'd have two kindergarten teachers and two Paras we're not anticipating needing to Al move any more than three but I don't know that all those families are going to want to do this program they may say no we want to stay with daycare they may choose another option so we're we're just ballparking okay I'm just going back to because I believe the prek ratio is a 10 to one correct me if I'm wrong so yeah class size is question I guess we we would have two adults in the classroom so you have 20 kids to two adults okay because that's the ratio based on my knowledge of prechool requirements so again probably probably be less than 20 students I mean currently we have about 18 students in a prek classroom y it would be closer to that with the two adults with the two adults thank you thank you for this I'm not sure that I'm not sure that I uh agree at this point with the idea of uh the sort of loss of teachers because you have a loss of students and I'm saying that because the projections we've had for the whole school modernization from what I recall from maybe six months ago was we probably should be adding three teachers per year if we're kind of falling in line with enrollment growth anyway and that's at the elementary level so I'm just thinking if we don't have those students those teachers could Pro probably be moving to well expanded K first grade second grade third grade I'm not sure what the qualifications are requirements but that's I'm just putting that out there that that that didn't really resonate with me with that that one particular point because I'm thinking we're gonna have to keep all those teachers anyway do what we can to try to keep them potentially um our our our uh enrollment data is generally based off October one enrollment when we work with uh NASDAQ uh and so we don't have updated enrollments yet yeah it changes on a day-to-day basis somebody moves out of town I get that yeah but um I don't know that you know the the 60 I mean if it is indeed 60 students that's our historical average you know that that's a pretty big drop off um and I don't know that we're going to make that up in enrollment in other places usually is K12 enrollment that that has been growing um but yeah I mean that's certainly a consideration Tim Fair okay okay um yeah so being one of those relatively recent uh prek parents what are the hours you're thinking about because the hours for my perspective as a parent or key it would in school huh full day you say full day full day to me is 9 three or 8 to2 whatever it is but as a parent it's like seven to five for prek versus so no but this is a really serious question because in the other if they're at Darcy it's one thing do we have does does the why offer before care and after care at Darcy they do okay so this is something that you've had a quick chat with them and they'd be agreeable to trying to absorb that we currently have pre uh before and after care at from the YMCA at Darcy they sign they're just got a different label same number of kids in essence okay but just a different label on them now they're transitional kindergarten kids well they're also but those pre those that's kids from around town that are getting focused over there as compared to what they'd be losing if it's just ditt they'd really be losing five and picking up like 30 to 60 kids so I'm just saying just have that conversation hopefully with the Y sooner rather than later if we're going down this path um just to make sure they could do that okay um I think that uh and and so the idea here is this is fully self-supported that's the plan you know tuition that charging offsets cost of and you know we could build the first room we can and we can build a second room if we can and continue to open it and close it based on sure you know making sure that we can offset yeah yeah okay I get it because you want to hit 18 or 20 kids per classroom and you're not going to be opening up a class with 25 kids in it is what we would hit that's what we're budgeting off of yeah okay um and so you uh Adam have you talked about this in finance I don't want to spend you have I'm gonna comment after you're done okay I just saw it coming from curriculum so I wasn't okay all right um yeah I mean is uh I guess the last or at least another point I'm thinking is what is the prek we we do offer prek right now and there's an enrollment cost that I thought was like n or $10,000 oh we are going to talk about that in Finance as well it's not close to that but okay we have multiple prek programs one is a Smart Start program yeah that's a um sliding scale State program our our prek program that is uh really it's an integrated pre prek program where uh typical peers join students who are receiving special education services half days and we have three four and five day options uh for those programs those are uh incredibly manageable price-wise as a matter of fact for the five-day program we're um seeking a a change in the tuition to $200 a year so that up or down up to 20 from 2700 it hasn't been adjusted in about at least 15 years is that is that is that funded with like Federal Smart Start funds no uh Smart Start is a completely different okay uh full day preschool program we have two of those classrooms uh and that is subsidized through a grant the the we received grant funding to pay for both of those programs okay I I I just want to say uh based on what we hear because I'm looking at this coming from curriculum and honestly I was like wait I think I just want to know a little bit about the money so based on what Adam says it's entirely possible I support this alternatively I might just want to get a better understanding of the numbers now they play out because do we have like you know you know one program is called prek and it's three grand another program is called prek and it's it's six grand I'm not really sure I just want to understand that a little bit better and maybe we've got all that but right now I'm hesitating in supporting it just to understand it before I vote on it and and with that I'll be done I can I can I just add something aren't we talking about different times though we're talking about two and a half hours for the well the time is different for the integrated prek program versus the Smart Start and this transitional prek program so tonight we're talking about the transition correct question I did thank you sir I don't think I've said a word since 7:45 so all right to see that my voice still works that's nice um so uh yeah we discussed this a little bit in finance not to this detail because I don't think we had it yet because it was before the curriculum meeting uh was a few days before um so was our understanding when we discussed it that this was going to be uh what's what's the term like a net zero uh cost to the district um so I I just wanted to have clarification on because where the the plan is to use current existing uh teachers and staff who teach kindergarten to teach prek normally the stand at least my understanding is that the certifications go k up not K down so how does that certification work is there going to be some sort of um waiver from the state to allow kindergarten teachers to teach prek or how is that work so that we can use our existing staff to allow for this plan to work we've checked with our folks over at the state certification office and our kindergart or current certified kindergarten teachers would be able to teach this transition program great um trying to think uh is there a question about being all day I think we covered that right day yes full day right uh I think that's it for now we would follow the chesher public schools calendar CH I I I thought they in finance uh so student would be there full day I thought there were sections or warning and PM so am I confusing that's for the so foret I'm good thank you y Andrew yes just you might not know the exact reason for this but why are they doing this is there I mean I looked through all of this I don't see anything as to like is this been thought about for years I mean why why are they changing the age here yeah I think there's been a push and talk about it for many many years we're one of um there's the majority of states have a earlier um require that five-year-old date before you could start kindergarten uh so this has sort of been in the works we've had uh even some folks from our staff over the years who worked at Darcy or part of the early intervention Center have been part of supporting the fact that children should be older before they start kindergarten not that we're not we are also supportive of you know preschool programming and making sure that everyone has access to education but having them be five before they started is something I think we would certainly be behind and it's it's been talked about but finally the legislation came out um first off I I appreciate this I just want to say kudos to you Marlin because um you know trying to capture these 60 kids and not putting the um the burden on families to now have to consider the cost of daycare like Dr Solen stated um is my opinion just a really thoughtful genius idea to do so um I just want to make sure that we're not absorb we're not absorbing any more costs now that we're talking about Finance because we did discuss it in finance the distinguish distinguish the difference of the programs and so forth so this is just a one-year plan we want to support the 60 students um and it looks like you considered the break even cost so I'm fully in support of this in this this has been years in the making Andrew as an educator I feel as though finally the state has done something that's developmentally appropriate for children um oh jeez I just had it uh the two our break caught up with you yeah it did oh geez what was I going to ask oh so the assumption that we're going on is that private daycares cannot absorb these kits that's a year from now so is it that they refuse to hire additional staff to cover the bump or they they can't they're not allowed to what what reason did private daycare give us as to why they couldn't absorb it a couple things I think I think some is just limitations on Space you know not having another classroom available for children that's not to say that some of our community preschools might not be adding that um in I think the other wrinkle to this is the cost for any family that was thinking oh maybe this parent is going to go back to work because the child will be in full day kindergarten and now that cost becomes prohibitive because of the cost of private daycare we're coming in to say okay what if we can offer something at very lowcost Break Even again for for one year this would not be a permanent thing and only for the children who fell into this age bracket but yeah I guess I asked that question because I guess I was one of those parents where my son went to two years of preschool before he went to kid so he was an older kid going to kindergarten like we had made that decision already so yeah so I'm just wondering yeah if it was not so it's it's a combination of an ability of attempting preserve staff because you continue to say it's might be 60 right could be 18 could be 20 whatever um and sort of helping private because I would think the daycare would welcome more businesses it really depends on the the provid I don't know what their tuition is anymore obviously my son's older so we haven't had to pay for preschool uh I know Tim maybe you can speak to it a little more but a few years years ago I left at $116,000 16,000 for year yeah so it's probably at least 18 or 20 at this point for one and that was that was a mid-range that was that's the other conflict right so we have that pre if you are uh three was it three going to four or we have a lottery system for a full day pre and for now one year basically anyone who wants it can now get it for 5,500 for if you're in that one age I want be clear that yeah right it's only those kids for one year but it's like you hit the you kind of hit the lottery for one year because normally you would be paying 16,000 or maybe well we are the one we went to is a little more expensive but you know the saying you know whichever one you go to um you know it's probably a lot more than 5,500 a year yeah okay sorry um yeah so I really I don't want to belabor this I do have one question that I'm just trying to understand in my head the tuition is estimated $5,500 to break even so the break even is key that makes it relatively I'm close to a yes on it because of that but I'm still wondering $5,500 what do we spend on the average student1 155,000 17,000 that's that's I'm just you know when you calculate a per pupil expenditure about 18,000 the difference here is that we're not covering all of the district overhead with this all we're really talking about I mean this isn't including keeping the lights on and stuff like that uh what this does is cover the cost of the teacher and Par educator okay and we wanted to make it uh financially accessible because it's $118,000 a year to go to to you know a private provider let's say not all but let's just throw that number out that's also the 365 days it's also 6:30 a.m to 6:30 p.m perhaps this price uh is not necessarily hitting the lottery I would call it super competitive because if you do want um you know after care that's going to be an additional cost uh it's not free but I think it makes it very accessible and it makes it very attractive to also entice people to do what we believe is developmentally in the best interest of kids which is if you're not five yet we think it's you know the research says that it's it's not just our gut that it's your best it's in your best interest to maintain a Trad a traditional a transitional program as opposed to jumping into K so I think all those things considered collectively that's why I say threading the needle to try and capture uh the benefit of many uh I think you know we work through this and find a real hard time finding a flaw um with with regard to the uh four-year-olds who enter kindergarten that had do we have any impact on that decision that was state is how I understood it they made the decision and we're just living by it we're just trying to figure how to work around to make people's lives easier based on what their expectations have been for probably several years right and I think that's why we did a one-year program yeah because this is in effect more or less the 11th hour for parents that had been planning go to kindergarten and you know to be able to yeah to be able to accommodate the one-year transition I think it's uh We've we've tried to design a a win-win yeah no and these are kids would have been in the school system anyway so I mean I get it I I can support this it's frustrating that the state did this and um I understand why but not having communicated better with parents but support how what what they did but not how they did perhaps is yeah transitions are difficult and you had a had a question earlier I want to forget about you sure yeah I understand I know you do so uh just I've been looking at a yeah no and I appreciate I think this is very clever I appreciate the pracon this I I um I guess it's a mix of blessings was thankly I don't have to I don't have this problem my kids are hopefully out of college soon off the pen payroll so um uh but if I were a parent today and I was impacted by this I think this is a really a kind gesture I I I don't see the the negative of this especially self- sustaining and and and this is not to compete with our daycares um because there might parents that want to use a daycare and get in there and but I think for um those families where even today even the lowest cost daycare is out of their range this may likely put them in a in in a Range that they can work with so I I support this but we don't have a motion on the table yet we just got the backdrop so if someone would like to make a motion would you like a motion yes please we can get into it I moved at the Board of Education approve a one-year transition program to accommodate Public Act number 23-15 n raising the kindergarten starting age great is there a second Sam seconds any discussion on the motion yes Mr gripple I would like to I would like to make an amendment to the motion to add a Sunset date just to sort of make it crystal clear to Sun um uh so it' be um end let's see onee transition program uh so at the end to sunset on I guess would be June 30 2024 would that be correct or you can specify for specifically 24 25 school school year oh yeah I wasn't sure yeah what would be correct there to so it be to to not my pen doesn't work no to Sunset the at the end of the 242 school year so the proposed amendment to the motion is to move to the Board of Education approve a one-year transition program to accommodate Public Act number 23-1 159 raised the kindergarten age starting age for the for the 24 20 25 school year yeah I guess that achieves the same thing sense yeah that's fine just in case school year goes later snow days on a specific date right sure right yeah yes okay is there a second to Amendment okay now the discussion is about the amendment on the table all right yes Sam can you just read the amendment for clarification so move at the Board of Education approve a one-year transition program to accommodate Public Act number 23159 raising the kindergarten starting age for 2024 for 2025 school year I might be word smithing a little bit it just it seems pretty redundant one year is one year if you want to just replace one year with the school year 24 25 and that outlines it a a little more spe spe you know what I'm talking about yeah I the reason I made the amendment because I was concerned that the one year isn't you don't know what it's spe specific to is it a one-year transition program or is it a one-year in duration program so if I can make a motion to yes modify that we moved at the Board of Education approve a transition program to accommodate the Public Act number 23- um 159 raising the kindergarten starting age in the 2425 school year with that for the 24 25 school year excuse me it's late help out Carol please oh on the linked motion oh okay so that's pretty high tech I know she's too fast for me right now do you mind Carol just reading it out please yes that's what my modification would be perfect is there a second if it's a friendly Mo Mr gripple Seconds thank you discussion is on the L Amendment motion is there any more discussion on motion awesome thank you this is great uh by the way um so let's vote on that well I don't have the motion vot on the amendment first then vote on the motion no this this is this is the amendment yeah so move that the Board of Education approves a transition a transition program to accommodate Public Act number 23159 raising the kindergarten starting age for the 20 2024 2025 school year all those in favor please raise your hands thank you as unanimous the motion passes I haven't seen that many amendments since budget like 2021 or something yeah it's been a while that's this is great record for this decade maybe team thank you that was uh that was good discussion all right moving on to finance committee yeah we gotta vote on right that's it nope that's it vote on the amend we just did we just did but but we have more curriculum but but wait there's more yes exactly um there's one more informational item that we um discussed in some detail at curriculum committee meeting last Monday and I will turn it over to miss Solano once again to talk to us about an overview of the smarter ballast assessment growth data thanks an and before we move on to that can I just let you know that in your packet there is also a letter about the kindergarten start age I wanted you all to know that um Jeff has on our website just if folks are curious about the law and if anybody's asking you know what's happening we try to put it up there to clarify thank you okay so um this was a followup on additional data uh referencing growth specifically growth for our high needs students so if you take a look at the first sheet that has two um data sets on it and chesher is highlighted in green this is a comparison of durg B districts very similarly to um the data that was shared the last time on achievement it looks like this if you're looking for it yeah this is the one and so on the left hand side are the smarter ground is the smarter balance growth report and that is for English language arts and this particular report looks at the average percent of Target achieved and I'll explain to you what that is that means that every student has a particular Benchmark score that they got the previous year on the smarter balanced assessment and there's a Target that they need to reach or that we're hoping and and we're working towards them reaching let's say it's um 100 points just as an example so if a student reaches 99 of those 100 points they're not making 100% growth but they're they're obviously very close so this report tells you on average how many of our the amount the percent increase or the the percent of growth on average that our students are making on both Ela on the leand side and math on the right so when you look at that this is the our ranking you could see Woodbridge who tests about students and orange that's probably in total but this is only grades four through five in Woodbridge right and only four and five in Orange as well because those kids matriculate up to Amity Middle School just underscoring our our ranking there and then on the on the right hand side is the same information for Math and that's the durby comparison so that's all students so if you skip to the next page you could see a bar chart that gives you the breakdown because there was um a question um at our curriculum meeting can we see the breakdown of Elementary in middle school so we start in fourth grade because that's the first grade that we have growth data for and that goes up to 8th so you can see the the information for fourth fifth 6th and seventh grade math in blue Ela in red and on the next page it just gives you the the percentages the same information just in a in a different format and I will add that to give you some context about this that in the state of Connecticut it we see a trend with students in the Middle School dropping their their growth their achievement dropping from elementary to Middle school so while you do see that here it is a state Trend not to say that we aren't focused on improving that number or improving that percentage of kids who are meeting their growth Target but it is something that is is not um different than what we're seeing in the state as a whole the last slide here or the last sheet talks about high need students and this is Statewide performance this is something that Jeff may have shared with us before but I wanted to make sure that you were able to take a look at it if we look at our high need students which includes our multilingual Learners our students who qualify for free and reduced lunch and our students who um receive special education services this is our ranking for our high needs performance so you can see the blue blue arrow is our math ranking which puts us at about 11 in the state and our Ela on is about 12th again you can see new Canan has about is first some of those other Gold Coast towns and Cheshire when it says total number that's that's the number of students served those are the number okay yes so well there's total number and there's count which what is um the total the total number give me a second 1869 is the total number of kids right and 1354 is now that were [Music] tested have to pull that up okay good question how many kidss are in the district four 4,000 above who was tested in four through eight um be it'd be about that 89 or 186 1800 yeah 1868 you know that that would be the total number of students tested do you have that spreadsheet Jeff still I don't know if it would speak to that I think that's the number of nonin students to be honest with you 1869 the 1354 and then the differences the high needs but it doesn't show that that makes sense so so high high needs is not the student High needs is the study area no and I said say that just because I'm looking at two different numbers here just if these counts are 1354 and 1405 it just seems odd to me 1869 versus 1868 I'll just ignore one difference that means nothing to me a kid was absent or something but 1354 changes by 50 kids between math and Ela so I'm just maybe get some we'll get you on that yeah thank you yeah every district has like kind jump like that yes um so this G be Mr Obvious here huge drop off in grades seven and eight um is that because the targets set in elementary school are too easy or is it it gets a lot harder in middle school I'm I'm guessing it's the second but again though is there is it because of the class sizes are different where the you know the kids were maybe used to more one-on-one attention in the elementary school and they don't they're more have to become more self-sufficient in middle school so that's why these drop or is there any sort of thought process as to why there's such a difference I think your questions are all all good ones when we look at the state we we obviously see this happening not just in chesher but across the state um there could be a couple of reasons for it adolescence big change in in school switching classes there's a lot of changes going on in the Adolescent the other thing that um we have looked at is our math program our math curriculum and wanting to make a change there so you'll remember last year we um went through the approval of a new textbook after a year of research and so we were really thinking that the rigor in the resource that we were using wasn't up to standard and so it is our hope that we see that number rise in direct response to teachers learning how to use the new resource and the rigor of the math program being increasing so we're hoping to see that change so then that leads to this qu so if the if you've determined that the rigor wasn't up to standard for seven or let say even grade eight so should we expect to see a rip now through high school as kids may be still a little behind than they should have been or is that something that we're going to see or are we starting to see or will we see yeah you know I'm not entirely sure if that will happen I I it's part of a hypothesis that we have that if they're exposed to more rigorous content and more complex thinking that that will they will be able to rise to higher and higher levels there's work happening at the high school level very specific and targeted to things happening at the high school and we're targeting this resource at the middle school so our our hope is that we're we're targeting those right things and that we'll see that change but yeah I think the high school folks are also um of the mindset that students having a higher level of rigor at the middle school again when I talk about the rigor I'm really talking about like some of the questionings some of the way the questions were posed just when you're using one resource and you have to constantly be retooling it to make it a little harder that's a lot of work on the teachers so this should level things out a little bit thank you Mar what's the um support then because obviously glaringly obviously we need more support in the middle school so what is the multi-tier systems of support middle school going into high school you know we take care of a lot of our little kiddos K to 6 we have systems built in there what what's the system in the secondary yeah that's a couple of different things um we were look we had a universal screener that we were using um we changed that Universal screener it's changed again now with our new resource so that's one thing that's one way that we're identifying those students the other is over the last year and a half or so we've gotten a little more targeted and teachers have gotten more support with identifying students who need support in math and looking at the interventions that we're providing them the third thing is that we have now looked at the roles of some of our Math teachers and we have moved one of our teachers into a role where he has additional time to help with coaching and he's also helping to coach for the new I ready program in addition addtion to that with that bounce forward money we sort of retooled some things and we have a teacher who's dedicated to providing intervention at the middle school so those along with some structural things where we've structured some um regular meetings and regular look fors from through data team meetings and through identification of students I think that pronged approach is going to help us catch those kids before you know on time rather and then later so I mean there intervention adjustments there are curricular adjustments with the math resource and then there have been instructional adjustments as well around you know teaching for Visible learning you know that the Math teachers have really embraced that so uh this really I want to say full scale change but there have been a lot of changes in terms of how we tackle math in particular at the middle school thank you and is there anything else in the curcum report that wraps up curriculum excellent thank you and uh I think we're sending out uh committee agendas to all board members but certainly be on the lookout for curcum committee agendas because I we do talk about this routinely there so we'll make sure everybody's lopped in uh finance committee Mr gripple back to you asking you shall receive I suppose Mr chair um okay since Mr massana isn't here I I get to give the uh uh Finance report this evening so I'll I'll just uh read the summary that he prepared um as reflected in the above summary above uh or the the above summary through September 30th our budget for the 2023 24 fiscal year is 84 m993 429 We have expended and or encumbered 60 million uh $718,000 during the first three months of our new fiscal year which includes most of our payroll incumbrances for the year but not all our transportation incumbrances which should be entered in October at this time there are no variance concerns to report but do note the following items related to the 2324 budget um Connecticut minimum wage increases or qu Connecticut minimum wage increase um which went from or will go let's see yes will go on January one on jary one uh from $15 per hour to $15.69 uh per hour uh as a result as a result of the state's first ever economic indicator adjustment um let's see in line with this we will need to adjust salary of approximately 40 employees who are in positions that pay at or above the current minimum wage uh but are below the new uh the new wage on January 1 um the impact will be minimal uh energy price locks energy markets continue to be volatile as we have been monitoring prices and working with our consultant on best course of action we were able to lock prices on below energy Commodities uh for uh heating oil at uh $258 a gallon propane at $22.29 cents a gallon uh Transportation diesel uh at $269 and electricity at 11 almost 12 cents a kilowatt hour um and that is the end of our summary uh are any questions on that summary report okay I'll move on to Medical benefit trust Mr massian will be very proud [Laughter] um medical benefits looks like it was uh below the uh 1.1 million uh budgeted for the month um we claims came in at $97,900 051 leaving us with a a claim reserve of 1.78 months not like the good old days of three to five months but you know it's better than going down um so that's what I have for that I have no knowledge of claims history or any of the other stuff that been with um but any questions or comments there okay um let's see we will move on to the approval of prek tuition rate which is unrelated to the previous discussion just so we can clarify that um so I would like to uh make a motion uh that the finance uh a motion that furthers the motion that we made in the finance committee um moved that the chure Board of Education approved tuition increase for the part-time preschool program as follows three days per week current tuition $1,635 annually to a proposed increase to $1,735 annually um four days per week uh from $2,190 to $2,350 uh five days per week uh $2,700 to $2,900 and these are all annual figures um is there a second for the motion Sam seconds um discussion on the motion yes an I have a quick question um so I'm assuming some percentage increase was decided upon what what would that have been based on um it wasn't a straight percentage increase um and what the increase was based upon was a review of other preschool integrated preschool programs and it varied I mean I think Sam and Adam could tell you I mean we looked at a variety of different programs um in the area and we intentionally kept these low to continue to entice families to participate but um they do reflect a slight increase as you can see it's it's a $100 for the year I mean in percentage wise I appreciate that it's larger than that but um you know we try to be competitive and again we haven't addressed these in more than 15 years sure any other questions or comments on this seeing none I'll uh call for a vote all in favor it is unanimous of those present thank you and that concludes the finance committee report thank you Mr gripple but don't go anywhere because policy is next thank you Mr chair um for uh policy committee uh that I pull up the minutes here um we had a uh discussion on um a policy uh policy 2134 uh for to change the um the title of assist superintendent for instructional services so this um we it was um a different title I forgot what it would say what does it say here it was in assistant superintendent for instructional services changeed to assistant superintendent yes thank you Dr s um and so we um we uh pass that for let's see what's that is that for a first reading or second because it's a regulation require notifying the the board yes so it's a regulation so it does not need to proceed any further it was just for um uh for us to review and for the board to be notified uh that we uh concurred with the uh change in title um I don't think we needed to I don't think there's any further action that needs to be taken unless there's opposition to that of course um um seeing n will move on um and then uh finally uh we move for a third reading the uh survey uh surveys of students policy number 61625 uh all of the changes are on our website uh for public review um and let's see I would uh like to make a motion that the uh chesher Board of Education give a third and final reading to policy 6162 51 surveys of students student privacy and direct the superintendent to put said policies into immediate effect is there a second Tim seconds is there any discussion seeing none all in favor I it is Ann are you in favor are we talking about the 61625 yes um I'm going tostain okay so uh all right so all in favor we have uh five against abstain okay one abstain all right the motion passes and that concludes the policy uh well actually no not yet I have one question um so that that motion passes um so so not to be a I guess I'll be a wet blanket so uh going back to the public discussion we had here before for emphasis yeah pause pause for emphasis um so while they're talking I'm thinking about procedure right I'm thinking about um do we have a policy in effect how this board and or Administration considers how a club sport becomes a Varsity Sport it's a great question we do not but I pulled one okay because all I can think about is great testimony this evening but I'm thinking there's probably maybe five or 10 other sports that would like to become varsity as well how do we cons how do we weigh all of that and how do we consider that so that I just wanted to know if there was a framework that we had in place already um that we could consider it analytically or unemotionally perhaps uh to to know whether or not you know was it do you have to be a club sport for 20 years is that enough but what is enough to become a Varsity Sport great question we asked the same question uh that hasn't happened in my memory I mean even the hockey thing was it's not necessarily making it a CHS vars City sport we they were a co-op and we just paid the co-op fees now right that's a distinct difference I never became a Varsity Sport at least not you know I mean it's a Varsity Sport but it was just a much different scenario um so I did pull a model policy on that and we'll review that with your blessing at the next Meek I I I do bless that and know we should definitely yes uh that concludes the policy report uh okay I would also ask the policy committee I'll send a formal email but to uh we do have a policy in our Board of at 9000 bylaws I don't remember the number but it's around self evaluation um we can actually do a self- evaluation of the board we haven't done one in some time uh we'll take it up this this year nothing urgent but you know if we're valuing the superintendent and students we might as well valuate ourselves so it's that that don't think was touched since 2014 and C has a model policy I think it's pretty close to it anyway it's a nice positive thing so you know per your committee's or the committee's perview let's talk about it this year correspondence Dr hergan do we have have any correspondence we do awesome uh we have a nice email from marinaa soel of who is co-chair of the chesher food drive dear an and members of the chesher board of education on behalf of the chesher food drive board of directors I want to publicly thank Chester public schools for its upcoming participation in the 50th and ual townwide chesher food drive we are especially thankful that each of the chesher public schools will participate by running schoolwide food drives starting next week through Friday November 3D we are fortunate that our kids have many opportunities to help others the 50th annual chesher food drive will be held on November 4th and 5th from 9: to 3 on the First Congregational Church green we invite all community members to join us at any time during those hours we will also be accepting food and monetary donations in front of Stop and Shop that weekend all food donations will stock the shelves of area food pantries as the student um reps mentioned and monetary donations will fund the town's food voucher program so for more information you can always go to cheser Food drive.org many thanks marlina thank you up next is superintendent report Dr Solen thank you very much Mr perini point of order Mr chair uh approval of minutes oh s Tak so in our packets we do have minutes uh for last two meetings so I'll make a motion that the Board of Education approve the minutes from meetings held on September 21st 20 23 and October 20 October 5th 2023 is there a second Adam seconds any discussion or changes on the minutes see as there are none uh ask for those on favor of the motion to raise your hand I'm sorry yes Sam um I would like to abstain on the October 5th so the fact that it's clumped together how do we we have to modify again Carol yeah so can you separate those two make I guess you need to do two motions then for two different dates yes Mr grippo I'd like to make an amendment to the motion go ah you were Smith this um I moveed that the Chester Board of Education approved the minutes from meetings from the meeting held on September 21st 2023 I second the amendment okay all those in favor of the amended motion it is unanimous Mr chair I'd like to make a motion yes sir uh move that the Cher Board of Education approve the minutes from meeting October 5th second t uh 10 seconds any discussion changes there are none uh all those in favor there are one two five in favor and asens extensions there one exstension motion passes thank you thank you for catching that uh all right Dr Solen on you all right thank you very much uh we'll start with the school modernization update uh really exciting that we've uh had many meetings over the course of the last several weeks uh many with the community uh in addition to our standard meetings that we hold as a Next Generation School building committee and uh the the tekon architect team has worked pretty diligently to take in community feedback uh that process has been ongoing and you if you've been following closely in the community have seen adjustments to some of the designs the North End uh was pretty dramatically adjusted after a lot of feedback the committee um really worked through a lot of uh constr around the the new Norton school design and I know that tekon is is currently trying to update update that design and taking a lot of feedback into account I know I think Adam pointed out the fact that the field the soccer field and the initial design was up near brooksvale and is there any way to modify that some other folks pointed that out I know they're uh actively working on that so I would say stay tuned if uh you haven't checked the chesher Public Schools website I would encourage you to go there on the bottom left hand side there's a link that says big link that says school modernization and it's got all of the recent presentations and all the information you can see some of the designs and things unfolding uh throughout the process so um just a a shout out to our committee on the amount of time and energy they they've been putting into it is really commendable and and appreciated from where I said um just a a quick update you know as we were talking about some of the growth scores and some of that distinction between um you know the the middle school and the uh elementary school performance a district Who Shall Not Be Named because I don't want to do that but uh super high achieving durge Fairfield County school system that we generally remain competitive with um their grade for ELA per growth Target achieved 79.6 grade 8 was 60 uh math grade four 89.3 grade 8 69.6 so as Marlene was saying it is really a a trend that we see Statewide um doesn't mean that as you heard we made substantial adjustments anyway but um it is really something that you see across the state that middle Elementary to Middle School transition um at the request of the board uh recently we have uh solicited our local Representatives uh in Hartford for uh some dates to meet and uh we'd love to collaborate with them and give uh each other the opportunity to to hear um concerns and and goals as we enter this next legislative session so uh I have shared with the board some potential dates at that we we' shared with the legislators and uh hopefully maybe after the meeting if if you could check your calendars real quick we might be able to square away some dates and hopefully put this on the agenda sooner rather than later uh in advance of the I believe it's February 7th that the legislative session begins but once we get into January we're pretty inundated with with uh the budget so we're shooting for December um I want to notify the board that uh if you recall last year you put a lot of time and energy into reviewing and approving a survey for our students the pass survey that is designed to uh provide Insight on how our school system is growing in respect to our social emotional goals and um we're excited that that survey will kick in uh starting uh probably late next week and I'll be sending home a letter to all of our parents again that's the survey that you reviewed and approved last year uh so we're excited to try and get some data around that and we'll look forward to sharing it with the curriculum committee so that's it for me any questions for Dr Solen on his report the comment um that is great to see PA in all the meetings i i attended several I was able to hop on the uh virtual one was a couple nights ago you got like 24 people not all of them were staff they were actually there's citizens there which is great um but I also encourage um people to if they want to get a real deep dive into what's going on is to watch the Next Generation meetings because just the one that I watched um on the uh geothermal presentation and how it was sort of discovered in mid meeting how it would would have been a good it's or I think it has become a good idea to have both schools go hybrid um geothermal electral and the heat pump comination allows us to save significant amount of money to I'm guessing probably direct somewhere else not actually probably not actually save but to direct somewhere come on budget right yeah make sure we come in on budget right so yeah there's a lot of those details a lot of minutia if you if you like that sort of thing that sometimes when I'm in the mood I do like to watch that stuff um that uh there's a lot of detail there so if you want to get caught up on what's going on watch those meetings available on the town of Cheshire YouTube awes put the link make sure the Link's on our website too great yes Sam yeah please I mean this is not an an item that the superintendent spoke about but I do want to just take a personal point of privilege to um thank the superintendent for his immediate resp response to the crisis that's happening overseas in the Middle East um I thought your messaging was very thoughtful um and just very compassionate to our community and providing those resources to help um our families navigate through this so thank you very much thank you likewise I I did share your parent School uh not out to one of the forums only because you know there's uh for for uh citizens that don't have students of school system you know unless you're really plugged in you don't know how um you know that's being um communicated but I thought it went over very well you should know so write Sam comments it's crazy world we live in um yeah Tim thanks thank you um yeah so as as Adam had alluded to uh there's been some the school building meetings go on a few weeks ago there was a discussion um regarding labor agreements that I don't think we've really touched upon here so I just wanted to acknowledge that there's trade-offs with any decisions that any body makes um the body being the building committee Board of Ed whoever um but there were a couple of votes taken that likely from my understanding of the discussion likely led to saving several million dollars within the project budgets so I just wanted to thank chairman perini as well as Council chairman Tim slokum for the leadership that they've shown on this throughout um then getting the right people involved to to do things like that so thank you for that Tony uh Tim thank you very much I I appreciate that but uh you know let's so but the this the school building construction committee is doing some phenomenal work too and yeah we were involved in the selection process quite a few folks were and I think there were over 30 people that volunteered honestly I think we could have selected them all so I uh uh appreciate that um but also want to thank that committee for doing a lot there's a lot of people involved this whole you know this whole project from start to finish start it takes a village and it's awesome to see treasure throughout these years step up and get to this point so uh yeah I'm feeling really good about it but but thank you much appreciate it um yeah you're absolutely welcome I I mean it um and also uh going back to the building um there again as Adam was alluding to there was some great discussion about Net Zero Energy buildings um it looks like that is likely to happen as we move forward I think that's great and I also want to thank the board specifically for I don't know Jee do you happen to know when he voted on it sometime a year and a year ago or something the board voted to support the idea of serious consideration of Net Zero Energy buildings I think that consideration has happened and it basically has demonstrated that looking at life cycle costs when you take life cycle costs into account for the energy consumption of buildings it makes a lot of sense to do this it costs a little bit more up front and you save a little bit on the back end so anyway thank you to the board for uh supporting that idea because that was part of the discussion when they were talking about life cycle costs of the building thank you it's awesome good work all around thank you Tim for you know being a strong opponent and constantly keeping every educated on that it does said does take a village so good things happening can't wait for the show to hit the ground that project when is that going to happen again it will start breaking ground next winter okay so there's no old business uh chairperson's update very briefly uh I attended a School Board Association weekend conference a couple weeks ago it's basically scuba associations from New York uh Connecticut Massachusetts on up hey long story short uh it was great to get insights from other school board members that you know the good news is uh we share a lot of the same problems and challenges folks are working through the fiscal cliff with the SR funding running out uh in other school districts um you know everyone's talking about shes of teachers uh and Educators leaving districts and states for other states uh Connecticut was pointed out as one of the states that's actually learning teachers away recently this one reoc reciprocity that's been the place that uh Dr Russell Tucker has been to other states the point being is uh we're not alone in of of our challenges the the one humbling moment for me was uh I think I shared was Dr Solen as we're going around talking about some of the challenges in the district that um I know we look at our rankings and I know those don't tell the whole story uh but you know I uh I came back with just a renewed humbling that uh as far as I'm concerned treasure has it pretty good compared to some other um school districts and so we count our blessings uh because the town put emphasis on education but I was humbled on a discussion only in the state but there's one state that has some very rural school districts um and some uh you know High poy level so a school district in a very Lal location can have 45 total students that you know need to get back in school that don't have uh you know food for lunch you know there's not a great deal of funding that's said happening in New Hampshire are struggling to get um funding so it's in you know treasure I really had nothing to complain about that kind of joke that you know most recent issue was a moldy grape in one of the cafeterias you know so uh the point being is I I you know sometimes we get caught up in a lot of the uh the negativity but there's a lot of good happening in in Connecticut school system so uh felt pretty pile that at least in chure you know I think we're heading the right path but anyway uh it great to meet other folks and we're not alone uh I've been asked by cab to represent uh represent cab at the National School Board election in Washington in January and I'm going to be representing cab at Congress and some public testimony January so just just they asked me I didn't ask them so if I go to Washington and break it I uh but it's it's all good so I'll talk more about that yeah I it's it's it's kind of funny I say you sure you want me to go to Washington because I'll probably make it worse I can't I can't stand politics uh but anyway it's all it's it's it's all good just just know that a lot of boards in Connecticut are you know I'm not sure yet they won't be open for business yet in January well it's the end of January so there's there's some session happening yeah I know yeah okay uh and that's really it so uh that being said I know it's been a long evening and thank you for sticking around this evening you've been you've been great as well Christ Bruno my can I well actually can I just make one quick comment before weour um you the your your comments on on teacher short just just sort of clicked in my mind we had a Town Council Forum a couple nights ago right where there were at least three or four Board of educations asked to Town Council um incumbents and Challengers and all I thought was that our to our Board of Education candidates our incumbents and Challengers do not have their own for to be able to answer those questions accurately because a lot of the answers that were given were not correct and there were some of us in the audience that could have given the correct answer ERS and they don't have the opport opportunity to and that the candidates are going to have to find different ways of getting their uh information and message out so that the people know what's actually happening so I just wanted to comment that if anyone's listening that there should be a townwide forum for our Board of Education candidates and if not for the next time around so that uh somehow that we're we're treated less than uh even though we control 69% of the budget so just say and thank you for that I know uh you talked about it I there was a couple candidates to reach out to me um some of the new ones is great but um thinking that this Board of Ed was responsible form we're not um in the past it was a town white PTA and I did reach out and uh was told there's no plans to have one that's s was me mistaken so I reached out as well yeah and I I'm not sure what why or or how but yeah it is um I I hope all the candidates particularly the board of candidates uh find a way to get their message out and if there are listen if there are questions uh all candidates should know that they you can reach out to Dr Solen uh to get some ideas you can reach out to Board of Ed you know we're not shy with anybody we're helpful all of us are really good to get information out there but if there are yeah if you heard some weird responses the other night please feel free to email us we'll we'll help you get some answers but I don't know if you have more to add Sam um I'm asking about um yeah caves caps conference coming up and are we leveling up this year Dr Solen we didn't meet all the criteria to get to the next level thankfully we met the uh at least in our estimation the criteria to be recognized and I can't remember what committee meeting I was in where we discussed this but um we did submit everything a few weeks ago Carol and hopefully we get acknowledged again in November when we go did I put in for an RSVP I don't know even remember if I did yes so thank you for that I remind board members uh as we're all welcome attend the conference uh please do if you can it's it's it's Friday and half a Saturday I know it's tough on a on a work day um and you should have in your emails from C uh the delegate assembly packet which is all the legislation that we think uh the next session is going to dis discuss and cabes Collective stance being from all boards so if he's I will take take a look through it out one yeah I'm trying to get electronic copy of that I just have a paper one so I'll get it out but um uh there's going to be that Thursday night um yeah I represent treasure so we have one vote on this but we can certainly amend this and make changes but I know it's a little wordy but um and yeah that's anything else on the conference yeah okay so to not continue this meeting I add I call for a motion to adjourn I motion to adjourn you second all those in favor it is unanimous thank you team it's thank you for speaking out
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above