Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
Um, I move that the board of education enter into executive session to discuss a confidential attorney client communication regarding board of ethics requests for records from the board of education. Second. Okay, that was seconded by Aaron, right? Okay. Um, all in favor, please signify by saying I. I.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Yeah. But I got a message that the host would not unmute me or permit video. So I wonder if you would allow me to make a statement or ask a question now. This is for the citizen participation at that time. Yes. Yeah. Sure. We'll allow it. Go ahead. Okay. Thank you. So, um I speak for myself, but I also speak for a lot of people in town. We're very concerned about the number of apartments uh that are going into town, large apartments that will impact services. And in light of the fact that the UN the 40B um prevents towns from adequate negotiation um and that it's an unfunded mandate, meaning the town will be on its own once we have these apartments and we need to provide all the services and traffic issues and whatever else envirment. mental issues. Um I'm wondering Oh, and and when we were, this is going back to the 1980s, I'm dating myself.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Any opposed? Okay, so that passes 6 and Thank you everyone for joining in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um the town was under the gun to put a sludge dump in town and we had success. Everybody in town came together and fought it. But we also had legal support which was very very helpful. And I'm wondering if in light of the um the 40B issue and the fact that it's an unfunded mandate, would would we be able to um do follow the example of a lot of other towns who have been able to use those two issues to more adequately negotiate with developers. Their their goal is to make money. Our goal is to make sure that our town stays the way we want it. And so I'm I'm my question is do we have any legal support? And if we don't, have you considered it? and car kind of kind of confused as to when you when you mean legal support. We have town council that has provided us, you know, information as to they attend the meetings.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
They they attend these meetings. So, they're there. They're they're they're part of the they're part of that process. So I are you looking to increase or have another council come in to work with the town council that we have or somebody just solely for That's a good question because I my take was that the town council was someone that sat in on meetings and made sure that that meetings were run properly. I didn't know that they were attending negotiations. Go ahead, if I may. So, I mean, I I I would say part of the role that town council has is to make sure that the hearings and everything are run appropriately, but that's only a small amount. Um, you know, they are here as representatives for the town to advocate on the town's interests. And I think if you saw uh you know if you watch some of the meetings or a lot of the meetings you know most of them have been attended by town council Lisa me I think the last the last one um and I think the one upcoming is somebody from her firm attorney Brian Wy and I think you know you probably know so I'll give you a good example um I believe there was a discussion a couple meetings ago on the mill site about an increasing of the sighteline distance on some of the traffic pieces and I think the applicant made some kind of statement that oh you know to do that we would have to tear the building down.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Well, it was town council who tear the closest um ranet building down and town council tear them all down. Yeah, tear them all down. And town council, you know, she was the one who said, "Wait, that doesn't make any sense." Um you know, and and push back. Um, I guess I guess what I'm trying to say is that towns are are taking this unfunded mandate as a reason to sue the state to to be the aggressor, not negotiate in a in a select board meeting, but to say, "Hey, we have rights and and we should be able to negotiate and address our needs as well as You know, Connie, the unfunded mandate piece. Now, now I'm I'm connecting dots here. Um, so the unfunded mandate piece is actually a position that the state auditor has taken in regards to the MBTA community's uh law, right, that was being opposed.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
40B is a different completely different animal. I know, but it takes our our ability to negotiate away. Oh, I agree. It's it's an incredibly frustrating process. Um but but that's why I'm saying do we have legal support to help us in the negotiation? Yes. Yes. Um and I think and one question I just want to get some clarification on is the unfunded mandate piece. I'm not I'm not you're are you saying there's no money coming from the state to help us provide the services on the 40 the services that are going to be required for traffic? um schools, police, fire. Um we're on our own. This is we're talking about a a very large percentage increase in population in our town and in all the services that are going to be required. And I so I just am very concerned that I I I think we don't have any any say in the process.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I think an unfunded mandate argument might be a little bit tough just because they they would pay taxes. Um so you know the building the property owner would pay taxes and so you know theoretically those taxes pay for the additional services. Now we can certainly debate I think whether or not you know the tax revenue actually offsets you know the increase in service. I I think towns like um Middbor and Felmouth were able to I guess it's the h I I don't know I don't completely understand the process but it's the housing authority or something in the state that that towns have gone to and and fought the the process or tried to negotiate and and some have been successful because they had legal support. They so at the housing appeals committee I think that's what you're referring to right so but do we have we done anything like that have we gone to the housing appeals with with attorneys to help represent us?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So you don't go to the housing appeals committee until um a decision is actually rendered by the zoning board of appeals. So that's the process that has to play out. So, so the zoning board of appeals would issue a decision. Um, I'm not sure if the if the town can actually take it take the case to the housing appeals committee. What usually happens is that the ZBA would render a decision or deni that would be a denial or they would render a a decision that was an approval with stringent conditions that the developer then would say you know what that makes it uneconomical or that's not right and then they would appeal it actually to the housing appeals committee. So that's where it's heard and then generally you know I have to say towns have a very very very bad track record in terms of coming out on top and winning in those situations.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
That's what gets so frustrating, I think, when we get letters from Mass Housing that say, "Oh, you know, you can control things through the zoning board of appeals process. You have the ability to do this." and they completely and I would say disingenuously ignore the fact that a developer if they don't agree with the decision can appeal it to the housing appeals committee who almost 99% of the time finds in favor of the developer. It it is it is extremely frustrating. I'm pointing to examples where we they've been able to fight it and that's that's my question and it it could be Ashland approved the apartments right because um I guess there it was it was at the not this past town meeting but the one before that it was on the um the MBTA communities law again separate very separate from the 40B Right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Well, I know, but the 40B is what ties our hands and the unfunded mandate is the door that you can squeak through to um that's what towns have used to fight it. And anyway, I Yeah, maybe we should talk because I'm I'm trying to understand kind of like the where your your strategy here. I I'm kind of getting bits and pieces. So, um I'd love you know. Yeah, I just need to tie it all together. That's I just need to So I think if I understand, you know, what Conniey's talking about is um so the MBTA is is separate law, right? And that's relatively relatively new, very new. And towns have fought that. Um I'm not sure if anybody's fought fought that successfully at this point, but they have fought it. Um and then what that does is it made us change zoning in certain parts of the town, right, to increase um the concentration.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So um the 40B has been on the books since 1969 and its purpose is to increase affordable housing generally throughout this the state. Um and that's the history that Michael's talking about in terms of nobody ever wins. It's it's um Michael basically led a uh the select board and the rest of the town committees to create a letter to mass housing last year in May, late May, outlining significant reasons why this project in particular at that time 10 to 60 main shouldn't necessarily go forward and mass housing said nyx we don't care. So you well know that this state is desperately trying to create affordable housing. I think that the issue that we all have is that affordable housing. Yes. Does this actually create affordable housing? I mean that's one question. And um another thing question is does it does anybody want to live in apartments?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Is that what they is that what people want? Some people absolutely that's what they want. But is that the way that they make it into living in a condominium or a single family unit, something they own? Right. And um so the next step now where we are right now is the ZBA process. And um so the the ZBA is receiving input from the town's attorney. I hope sometimes there's stuff being said behind the scenes that because sometimes there isn't much input in public um and in ter in terms of how we can move forward. We can't just say that we don't want it at this point. we have to have they have to be really pretty good solid reasons and as Michael said. Um you know we that's historically hasn't really worked out very well for communities. Um I think there's some things about the the timing with this for us and and that particular the 10 to 60 main site that make it a little bit more unusual.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I mean, some of those pieces were raised in the letter that Michael sent to Mass Housing on the town's behalf. Um, but I still think that uh, you know, the fact that some of the we would have been in what they call safe harbor where we wouldn't have they wouldn't have been able to come in and do this um, if some of the other units had been built. But, you know, one unit during COVID and because of co COVID, I would argue ended up um, became became less affordable. So the developer pulled back. Um another group of units ended up in the courts. Um I don't know that you can blame that on COVID, but we could try. But so I mean I think that we are going to push for um our attorney and the ZBA to to come up with some definitely um you know some things to make this a little bit more attenable to us.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
But um I don't know that that um how successful we'll be, but I am certainly one that thinks that we should fight it with all our heart and soul. I I don't think that it um is good for the community. I think it's would be very destructive and and and even beyond that. And I'm certainly in favor of affordable housing, but you know what? Build some let's build some condos. Let's build some workforce housing in in the town that people who work here and uh can where they can live, where our teachers and police officers and firefighters can live, right? Yeah. The the the gambit of affordable housing or the the stigma of of a unit being called affordable. It's actually not affordable. That's right. So that's what Joan Gony's argument was. Right. and and and I we understand that. We all we all get that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We understand that. So, like Michael said, the law hasn't done anything for affordable housing. It's been on the books since 1969. Correct. we haven't made any progress in affordable housing and and that and that aspect of it is something that I want to you know we'll I'm sure we'll have future discussions on this but something to deal with the uh uh leaders in the legislative and and and the Senate as to you know change the legislation and and the wording that governs 40B that at some point some of these developers are going to have to abide by the the bylaws of all the municipalities that they're coming into. Right. If if not, then why the heck? Excuse I'm starting to get my Sorry, kick me when you when you see me. No, you're good. I haven't done this yet. But um when that happens, be ready.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um all I can tell you is that it just we need to make those changes and those changes need to be done, but it's not going to be a quick process. It's going to be a slow drawn out process as legislative actions are usually done that way. So, but this is the time to start it because it's on everybody's mind. It's on everybody's, you know, table in front of us and this is what we need to do now, Connie. So, yeah, I mean I audience knows and I think you know that I'm I'm I'm not supportive of the of these of these specific projects. Um, and you know, the ZBA right now has They have some power to put certain restrictions on and they need to be supportive. They need to get the support from all of us as a whole, but make sure that what they do and what they present to the developer is done in a way that helps the town and not circumvent the bylaws as they already are.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
That's right. Presented. So, we just need to make sure that the zoning board chair and the members hear us and realize that, you know, we're here to support them and and and help them through this process as long as they're willing to accept the help that that's being that's being suggested, right? And zoning boards were created to protect towns, right? But if the legislation if the legislature makes sets up legislative laws that defeats that then then why have them to begin with? And the one thing I would just add because you know you were talking about unfunded mandate and I think I think rather than sort of an unfunded mandate because to Michael's point they will pay taxes. Um, I think because all of this is happening all at once, it is really tough for us to be able to pro project what the needs of the community are going to be and and and be proactive at all.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Exactly. So, so um you know when we talk about infrastructure, we need to we need to to deal with water, sewer, we need to figure out the traffic and the public safety personnel and the rest of the the staffing needs of the community plus just how we're going to be able to manage the additional children in the schools and all that stuff. It's all at once. So I think I think that adds to the to the um frustration to the frustration. So so you know and and we completely agree with that you know and that is one of the things that as where we were reviewing the um the third 40b application that is co you know that is in front of mass housing right now. Um, that was my that was my feedback as to what I wanted to include in that letter because the cumulative effect of what's happening with these projects because the other part about 40B is once once these get permitted once um at least by the second 40b I'm sure probably even by the first 40B we might end up in safe harbor.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We definitely end up in safe harbor. Yeah. So when that happens, we're able to shut the faucet off to not to not be able to um to be able to say no. That could you could you repeat that? So So what happens is So what happens is um what happens is is when when a town hits 10% of affordable housing of their subsidized housing inventory, the SHI that we talk about, um you can get into safe harbor. You can also get into safe harbor by adding a certain amount of affordable units per year. So what will happen is once we hit that safe harbor, once we hit 10%, once we hit a certain percentage, if if a developer comes to town and wants to do a 40B, we can be like, "Nope, we're closed. We're not going to allow that anymore." But what has happened is when the first 40b application came through for mass housing, these other followed very quickly because they didn't want us to get into safe harbor.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above