I make a motion to approve the personnel report as discussed and presented. Second. Miss Robinson I Mr. Cerrone I Dr. Pock I Miss C I Miss I. Motion passes 50. I have a motion to adjurnn. I make a motion to adjurnn.
That's not why we do school choice either. We just have to be careful of that. It it's a certainly opportunity to make some some additional funding in here as well too. Um but I I just give you all that data to think about when you're making those decisions. So I mean we're graduating 12 school choice kids next year and we are not kicking in a lot of school choice kids. Like what is what's going to happen? And I know seven people from Berlin alone that have school choice to NOVA. So at one point it's the ratio cliff where we stop allowing kids in and we are paying out extra money. How many school choice funds are we used in the budget? Um we put $850,000 towards it. We did we're we're close to certifying keep saying that but our END. So the in essence, you know, my hope is that that we would in in future years be effectively cost neutral on that 450 is about we take right now 435 450 and we wouldn't spend more than that, right?
We would maintain that balance. You know, the goal is to maintain some sort of savings account. there were um you know a big issue where we had to pay for an expense about a district placement or something like that. We want that money in the bank to do that with um you know and this is choice is is is a challenge that's kind of plagued this uh particularly I mean I come from Western Mass and we've had massive population decline. So, it is in Western Mass, in many places, it is a battle between towns to just steal each other's school choice kids. Um, there are districts that are 50% school choice. Um, I would never in a million years advocate to get close to 50% school choice, but you know, they do it in many ways. They're because of population decline, their chapter 70 is flat.
They're trying to maintain programs, right? So, we're talking about cutting a Spanish program, things like that. If we had a few more school choice kids, could we maintain that Spanish program? We knew we had more money coming in, could we? So, there's there's definitely that side to it. Um, but then at some point, that school choice amount has been fixed forever. And this is the conundrum that Western Mass is facing, right? So, that's never going up. So if your if your costs are consistently going up, operating costs, and you're trying to maintain programs, effectively something's eventually going to give on that 0% increase on that big school choice number. you have this big, you know, call it $500,000 in school choice that while all of your costs are going up, that's staying flat, right, over time, unless you continue to increase numbers and then you end up being that district at 50% school choice, right?
So, so there's some challenges. I think I I I'm so I'm not trying to to pick sides here. I'm just trying to say, you know, there's some there's some pitfalls in the long run on on sort of depending too much on choice, but there's also the how do we maintain programming and you know that AP classes that um I've been in districts where, you know, we've had to um uh eliminate athletic programs and things like that in the past where there just weren't enough numbers there. Um you know, it's an eye openener. have to start thinking about some of that stuff. So I double-edged sword in a lot of ways. Um but a lot of times in western mass became a necessary evil, right? That's why we're back to this is recommendation school pretty let us know where we want. I think to your point Beth, we we need to probably look at this a little bit earlier next year, right?
and have a policy of like this is what we do and that it's predictable and that families can plan and know that maybe my kid's not going to get in next year, but if the numbers change, if it gets below 80, then my child will be prioritized. I would I would want to be careful talking about policy and so people can plan because that type of talk starts to sound like what people do for private school. Like I know when my kids here I'm gonna go to private school at 8th grade or n whatever it is. If we have we've got to be cognizant of taxpayers paying for Berlin Boilson kids. If we're going to start promoting the idea that families in other towns outside of Berlin Boilston can plan that we're going to go to Tahanto and it's not going to cost us anything.
we can stay in a lower tax rate town. We just have to be careful about the language we use for that because that's going to upset some, you know, local town people. Um, I would local taxpayer if I knew that I was spending all this money on the fixed cost of running a school that's like not running anywhere near as really maximize these schools. like we don't want to fill them to the brim, but we we owe it to the taxpayer to have a strong school system that is graduating class that are not 56 kids. But on the other side, that language starts to suggest that Tanto is not a strong school if there's only 60 kids in a class. And that's as damaging as the other way. Um, what about the idea of increasing class sizes, friend groups, and all that? This is not an overnight fix, but what about expanding the region?
Like adding another town to the district. Yeah, I think that's might be the direction that we I mean I don't know how we maintain we're I mean we're talking about buildings getting near capacity. We're going to need help there. The problem is that like like I crunched all the numbers for the the middle school. This is off topic, but we have three grades in the middle school. It's 50% of our school like those and then it goes So we like we put the middle school like in the corner. We treat them like high school kids. Like we never re really I feel like we should have really taken a hard look at what we were doing when we moved the sixth grade up to the high school and really found a way to like I think we never recalibrated from that. And I think a lot of the decline after middle schools might have something to do with the fact that like we need to maybe take a hard look at how we explored something like that um a couple years ago with Carol remember um rearranging the buildings and y things like that.
It was like a year and a half ago. Didn't go anywhere but so it was an idea. So just so% building a middle school. Yep. where we we're looking at the schedule for middle school, right? And we're making some changes at that middle school level, right? And for the amount of time and we really uh spent some time, Lisa and her team um looking at it. It's a it's a project. I appreciate like that's it's been my complaint since my daughter was in sixth grade that like we that's sixth graders or we just threw talking freely the middle school into the high school and said here you go, right? We we really did. will give you a little bit of wing instead of creating a separate schedule that should be for the middle school that's operating in the high school and the high school operate.
So that's something you're changing this year. That's some that's why two years ago we started talking about culture changes, why we fought for the additional assistant principal. That's why we're not getting rid of them. That's why I asked that question. It's not a perfect fix. Just one example, we talked about this, right? So, our sixth graders that come here are following the same schedule timewise as our as our high school kids. If you're a sixth grader in any other public school in the state of Massachusetts, you're elementary school, you're getting 90 minutes of ELA, 90 minutes of math, 90 minutes of all your core subjects if you need to have that 90 minutes. That's what they're getting at Burlington and Bolston. When they come up here to the high school, they're now at a 47 minute schedule. It's a big change every day. So, we're we're looking at that and that's a big shift to take place as well.
But you need some staffing for that as well too, right? And I think I think the um the biggest staffing thing that we have to look at is our elected teachers. We share elective teachers and that's it's it's funny that you would think that that was the driving force. I like you know between you know February and now I breathe the schedule and the driving force behind the entire schedule are the elective blocks right it is elective blocks not for high school it's the elective blocks for middle school and making sure the middle schools have their elective blocks that's the driving force around the whole schedule and we our elected teachers teach mostly middle school students and so if we want to have and then kind of what's left over is are the opportunities for the high school and so if we want that separation which I think is developmentally appropriate to h it would be appropriate to have them run on a different schedule.
We have to have different elective teachers. Yeah. The staff can afford it. Yeah. That's this is always conversation, right? We we hear that people are not happy at this or happy not happy this we're sort of hearing stuff out there underneath back to being strategic plan when we're having those SWAT analysis, right? And saying what are you? So, if we're hearing that people want that to look differently, and that's what we're hearing, then we're going to come to you in the budget wise and say, "Okay, we need to hire more staffing because that middle school's got to operate by itself even though it's in the building. It can't be working on the same schedule at the high school." And that's truly what we should be doing for our middle school kids. And maybe if we're doing that, which we should be doing, that will entice those kids not to want to leave here when they're going because it will be a different experience in middle school than it is in high school.
Right now, it's the same experience. So, I'm graduating up. like they well I already in sixth through eight I don't need to it's not a different environment so now they're looking for something different so maybe that's the reason why they're going to St. are or they're going somewhere else. But we need to work on what we have here before we're we're branching out. It should look different for our kids. 90 minutes in most sixth grade classes in the state of Massachusetts for ELA and math. They come here, they have 47 minutes every day. Yeah. I also I while I completely hear what you're saying and I agree um with the the small class size and you know the opportunities like the year we made budget cuts we cut how many heads from this building um I just I have a hard time adding more in than the recommended number.
Um and you know it's one of those things where you can't have you can't have your cake and eat it too, right? If we and I'm saying we like as a school committee, as a community, if we want to cut heads from Tahanto because we want to keep our budget lean because we want to run lean because we don't want our taxes to go up, then we're just going to have a small school. If we want to expand and grow and flourish and keep our, you know, try work harder to keep our kids, there's a cost just like anything else. There's a cost associated with that and we can't be cutting heads if we're adding if we're adding kids. Yeah. So the idea you're talking about the idea of if there's extra space in a classroom fill it but not just take it in and then need to hire so that money is not helping anyway.
We don't have the money and and like again we we decided and and you know not to pick open scabs about the budget but we had very strict from both towns this is all we can do. So we did what we could. We made I feel like we made some pretty equitable cuts. I mean, Tonto did bear the brunt of it because of the the two towns sharing in a cost, but you know, this is where we landed. So, even though we have more physical space in this building, we might not have enough resources to educate these these students. I think that's what you were trying to say with the like we can't do this. We don't have the resources. We make the we would never make the cuts at the elementary level, right? Because we're looking at those numbers, right? Even adding this person, well, it's 13 and 13 or whatever, right?
We don't want to be above X number for elementary schools. People don't really understand that secondary schedule, right? They really don't. I'm sorry. I'll get that. Um, so when you're making cuts at the high school, you're thinking, "Oh, we're just making a cut." They don't really realize the impact that it's having across that entire school, right? We cut positions this year at the high school. We cut an athletic director position. Now we have a segment. Julie's got yman's work to do with this right now. Incorporating the middle school and the high school, right? not on a full-time position, right? So, I want to be careful about opening up and saying, "Bring more athletes in when I don't have a full-time athletic director at this point because that was a budget cut we decide to make as a whole." Will that come back next year? Absolutely.
Possibly. But just got to remember that as well, too. She's a stipen position. Uh I think Jess something to say. I just I just wanted to make a um almost like a point of clarification just because I feel like what I know what people said and I know what their intent was and I just want to make sure the perception is is clear. Um when you go from middle school to high school here you don't change buildings. So it so a lot I think a lot of kids think oh it's just the same but there is a distinct difference between the middle school and the high school school. And I often wish those middle school kids would try the high school because, you know, I can't think of a school that I could have sent my daughter to or she would have gotten a better education.
And my son is not in a school, but it's due to COVID and simply educational loss during that time. And so we had to retain him and regrade him. We couldn't do it here. He would have been here as well. I believe firmly in the school. It offers a fabulous education, middle school and high school. But I think sometimes kids in middle school think it's going to be more the same and it's it's completely different. So um very high standards and I've been really h So I just wanted to say that because I know we talk about like to your point like they think I've already done I know what the art room is. I know where the gym is. It's not a new um but I do think we have a lot of work to do with with retaining our kids and making connections and making sure that they value those connections and want to stay because those connections are so important.
are just I'm curious how like in the past few years how many classes have not been able to be run because of enrollment in those classes? I don't know. I know it's it's put you on the spot and I apologize, but um just no like um there's there's been very few classes that had um that didn't run. I don't know of any. I I think it might be because it a weird elective slot. There might be a chorus. So like a so a chorus section couldn't run or a band section couldn't run. Art sections and that. So it's mostly elective se sections that couldn't run because we're surfacing the middle school, you know, and then and then they're blocked in. they're like very blocked in to where they're offered. Um, so would you say that's staffing? Sorry to interrupt. Like that's more about we need more resources issue.
We we definitely need more resources issue. So, it's not So, we're not offering um AP bio this year because we cut a science teacher and that science teacher has to do a anatomy and we are going back to a model of perhaps we do a flip-flop AP Chem, AP bio, AP Chem. That was it for a long time. And not only that, but hiring. So you staff you staff the middle school with full-time art and music and those electives. Then you really don't need a full-time person possibly in that high school depending on their schedule. So you got halftime arts and elective people. It it's it's doing schedules is is absolutely incredible. And just one last thing what Lori said. I've spent probably a lot of time here at the high school as as Lisa knows the kids are really happy here. You need to know that that I've never been in a high school and I've been in a lot of high schools in my district.