2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 188
So our membership in ASBA not only helps us, it supports the smaller and rural districts around us because ASBA membership is um according to your budget and number of students. So when we have very small districts, they have a small budget. So they have to pay proportionally. Um but I think the training uh is very very important to me and the networking with other board members. Um Jesse and I both attended the summer leadership institute. Um, I was sitting at a a board t uh table with other board members and on my one hand was a lady who was the um executive director for a senior center in Tuba City and across from me was a gentleman who was serving on the Mingus Union High School board and he is a 30-year veteran of the military and teaches um graduate level courses on conflict resolution.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 189
So I thought that was a a broad diversity of views and um I f I found for myself that even though there was a lot of learning in the classes that I took um the learning from being able to talk to other school board members who also care about public education was incredibly um important to me. Um I just want to share I happen to throw in my uh agenda. So I just want to share some of the classes that were provided. Um and as well there were two wonderful keynote speakers but I just want to mention one Matt Lurman um of social prosperity partners. I had a chance to talk with him individually because I signed up for a focus group and he has been working with the Gilbert Town Council in the last two years to help them facilitate and work better together.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 190
Um and and we got to hear from him and get training from him and I thought it was extremely helpful. I mean, I came home from this conference feeling, okay, we may have differences of opinion, but that's okay. It's okay to have a difference of opinion. It's important to work together and to um work towards helping students do better and helping our public education system function better. Um it there was a lot of talk about building trust and relationships. Some of the other um breakout sessions that we had was um storytelling and the impact of personal leadership. Uh let's see what's been happening at the capital. So we got a summary of what's happening down at the legislature. Um I went to the breakout session of uh a community of possibilities visioning with courage by Matt Lurman. Um there was a breakout session on furpa.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 191
I wasn't able to attend that one. One of the challenges is there's so many good classes to take that I wish they would repeat a couple because I would have liked to attend that class but I went to a different one which was also really good. Um I let me go to on Saturday uh we had some more breakout sessions. I went to one on because I had suggested this one on the book how not to be a terrible school board member by Richard E mayor which I know I've given you each a copy and so that was very helpful it was um the Florence school board they used it for a book study and so they were discussing it um there was another breakout session on from outreach to impact strengthen family involvement through communication Um and then I did attend a breakout session on public speaking.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 192
What you say matters and that was a very effective helpful I mean I did a lot of public speaking in high schools. So I don't know that I learned something new but it was just a good reminder which is what I find all of my ASBA trainings is that it helps me to do better and improve myself as a board member. It helps me to see the big picture of what's happening and it also um helps me to connect and network with other people. But I I did want to share um these are some things that I have brought back from my ASBA training to our district that has been I think beneficial. Um, first was a superintendent search. Um, because of this dysfunctional board, right away we had to do a superintendent search and um, talking to other board members and working through that process was very helpful.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 193
Um, second was Chromebooks. This was something brought up by a previous superintendent. Um, I wasn't all on board with it at first. I was really worried about kids having this technology and access and what would they get into and um but I think it's provided real benefits for our students in that they've learned technology they've learned I mean let's just admit that if you're not technologically proficient you're a real disadvantage in this age and I would say we have a great technology department that's really locked that down so kids don't get to websites that they shouldn't get to. So, a lot of concerns that parents had at the time were addressed and and have not been an issue. Um, but I think what was really important about this was we put those we started to to go down that road of having Chromebooks. So then when I think it was about 6 years before the pandemic when the pandemic happened then we were not scrambling to get Chromebooks for our kids.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 194
We had 7 through 12 everybody had a Chromebook and we had a lot that we had passed down to the elementary schools. So I think that was a huge initi initiative. It wasn't that it was my idea, but it was that because I learned about it through ASBA, I was better able to support what was done and it turned out to be a real advantage for us. Um, another one was uh one conference I went to was probably the annual conference. There was a session by the Daart school district and they were talking about a program that they have to train administrators. Um I I thought that sounded like something that we could use. I brought it back to the the person who was superintendent at the time and I just expressed what I had learned. Um that superintendent called the superintendent of Daart learned about the program and that's our current Aspire program.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 195
that was put into place and I am grateful to Dr. McCord for continuing that program. Um, another thing that ASBA has been really helpful to me. Um, we had Gilbert Junior High closed it and I think it was the first meeting I was a board member. Um, that vote was um, we reopened it or I mean we voted not to close it at that first board meeting. I was able to talk to um a board member who had who was in Paradise Valley and they had gone through a successful school closure for two of their elementary schools. And it was helpful to me um because we did have challenges that I think not only impacted our board and our district, but it led I also think to many of the charter schools that now are in Gilbert in our area. But um just talking to someone else and hearing their process and then working towards a better process, which I say it took about 5 years to get a better process to where we actually made a tough and hard decision to close Gilbert Junior High, move GCA onto that campus.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 196
But that decision, as hard as it was, was beneficial for all kids in our district. and find fiscally responsible. Um, just one last one that I picked out was um it was kind of uh Mike Davis was the p the principal of Pioneer Elementary and he shared with me about how he was using data as his school to improve student achievement and um I really appreciate that. But I attended some conferences at ASBA where they really helped me to understand the need for data more and why it was important and how we can use the um standardized testing and look at that data to improve student achievement. So those are just some of the things I've brought home from ASBA and I am very very concerned having served on a dysfunctional board that there if there is not an opportunity for board members to get training that there will be challenges.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 197
There will be challenges that this functional board did we did hire someone who came from Texas and trained us and we did come up with the first um core beliefs and commitments that are in the front of our um policy manual that every can everyone can look at that um it has statements regarding student achievement staff families and community. Um, so I'm proud of that and we did that with some help and some training, but I know that the training of flying someone in from Texas costs a lot more than anything that that ASBA would charge. Um just just so you know um if with the ASBA membership as it currently stands um attending the conferences and pre-conferences comes out to about $2,625 a year. That's what it was for this year. um in with a non-member status attending the pre-conferences and the conferences would cost a board member $7,875.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 198
So that's out of reach possibly for I mean I know it's out of reach for Jesse, but it's probably out of reach for me too because that's that's a lot of money. And I I really I think our membership in ASBA is really important. I think training and learning it's something we're an educational institution. So training and learning should be an important value for us and considering um that that training can be beneficial to all of us and I would love all of us to go to the legal conference together. I know as a teacher that uh you may not be able to be there but um the legal conference is one of the highlights of the year and there's a lot to learn there. Um, so I am very opposed to removing our membership from ASBA and I would like to to make a substitute motion that we table this until we the next board meeting where ASBA could come and present to us because I haven't talked about everything that they offer or do.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 199
that um I think before we remove oursel from membership, we consider um tableabling so that we can study the issue more because again I lived in that dysfunctional board and lived with that for two years. It was an extremely hard time to be a board member and I appreciate how well we have all worked together, but I would like to continue getting training and I I would say I would hope that others would also want to go get training through ASBA. It's I I know um you know there it is a member-driven organization. The people who run that are elected. I mean, I've run for office there. Um, and I think that they're they've been around for 70 years, and it's just like any other association. There may be differences of opinion, but we're coming together to support our values, which is school board service and having great school boards that are effective and capable in making locally controlled decisions for their community.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 200
Thank you, Miss Humphre. Is there Dr. Robinson, do you have any comments? Yeah. So, so there was a motion to table. There's a motion to table. Did I Are we just Are we doing the discussion or are we discussing the motion to not renew right now? So, I I made a motion to not renew and that's what we're discussing. And that's what we're I I'll withdraw my motion to table until we finish discussing. I would like to I withdraw my motion. Okay. Thank you. Um, Dr. Ward, can you do you know how much we spend annually for Well, I think the for the membership it's around $14,600. I checked on that. That's $14,930. Okay. So, just just about $15,000 and then another amount on meetings. Just depends on how many people go to any conference related to that. Uh but um it could be if if you attended all of the conferences and pre-conferences this year, that's $2,625, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 201
Okay. And and without the membership, you said it was $7,000. $7,875 per board member. Um so somewhere in excess of of $20,000. Um so I I agree. I I feel that training and collaboration is super important for for board members. So, it's it's really important that I re receive uh training. Um it's important to to me and I've sought out a lot of training, a lot of opportunities with a lot of different organizations both through Zoom calls as well as in person. So, I think there is an abundance of opportunities that are out there. I do think with that funding as well, we could even bring someone in for like retreats and things like that for our district and do do training. So, I I feel like I value training just as much. I feel like there's there's other ways to get that for collaboration.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 202
I think we're fortunate that uh we we have several opportunities throughout the year to collaborate with other school districts um through the meetings that we have with them and and so I've appreciated those opportunities and I I agree. I think that those are important opportunities um that that we have outside of the ASBA to do and I mean I really do appreciate everything that with Miss Humphre. I know it's heartfelt. I know this isn't really important to you. Um and and I respect that and I'm sensitive to that. Um, I did ask several other board members, um, recent board members, um, who I I think were part of a very functional board who who didn't feel that way and didn't get that benefit from it. And so I I I think that I think that your experience would be in the minority of of Gilbert Public School board members.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 203
Um and and so in talking with them and and even talking with district leaders, um it it seems like the reason we were still members of ASBA was for for policy. And now that we get that through the trust that there's there's not that need. And so for me, I I'm basing it solely just off physical fiscal responsibility that we have and and not to other districts um but to our GPS district to our GPS taxpayers and to our GPS students. And and for that reason, I think it's it's always so hard to to get emails from parents or have students that like spoke to us at the previous meeting about programs that we're having to cut at schools. And those are super hard choices. And so we're making hard choices. And so for me, this is this is one of those choices that I think the value is not there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 204
And so for that reason, I I do support not renewing. I have a question. What board members have attended ASBA events to see what it's all about and see the value of the training? I attended one training my first month as a board member. I haven't attended ASBA, but after the list that I was just presented, I've attended countless trainings at this point as a teacher and as an administrative assistant for my internship. Um, so I do I understand the value of it because I have sat in rooms with people for those trainings many times. I think also we should, you know, maybe there are some foreign board members who didn't like ASBA, but I think one thing is we've been in it since it originated except two years. We did have board member involvement, especially during the early 2000s. In 2000, MNA Shepard, our board president, was the president of the Arizona School Board Association.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 205
During that time, we're having issues getting state dollars um to improve, you know, to build more school campuses. And so what ASBA and her advocacy was to get more funding umh for our school as a growing district. And so I think there's a lot of parts of ASBA. And I think I think it'd be beneficial especially, you know, for myself since, you know, you're hearing just my perspective of going to trainings to have someone from ASBA speak to us to explain what do we get as members. And I think, you know, I think maybe we could utilize that. I'm not sure what other trainings are out there that kind of provide that variety as well as the member, you know, how many other schoolboard members are there. When we left in 2012, uh we were one of two districts who weren't in ASBA. I'm not sure what that status would be now, but it's part of our history.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 206
Um especially with our former board members, and I really think it, you know, I oppose leaving the membership Okay. So, there's a motion on the floor to not renew our membership with the Arizona School Board Association. Is there a second? No, he he seconded it previously. Oh, he did? Okay. Yes. So, right, I was offering the I was amending to the motion to table it so we could have a presentation from ASBA. That has not been seconded at this point because I withdrew my motion and now I'm putting it back on the table. Okay. So, we've got Thank you, Mr. Briner, for seconding that. Um, so I I guess procedural vote on the submotion. Yes. and then go back to the original motion. Okay. Depending depending on what if the submotion passes then we're done. If it fails, then we go back to the original motion.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-11 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Gilbert Public Schools transcript source: youtube Gilbert Public Schools Board Meeting 6/10/2025 · passage 207
Okay. So, all those in favor, can we speak to the submotion? Yeah, absolutely. Go ahead. We can discuss this. I just and and I and I mean this sincerely, Jill, I I don't think that anyone could deliver a more passion and sincere plea than you did. I I don't need to hear from the ASBA. Um, I I think you did a very good job. I know how passionate you are. You did a great job representing what ASBA can do. With that said, I I I still support not renewing and and I I don't feel the need to table to hear from the SBA. You know, I I appreciate the motion. I think, you know, it's important for our public to know as well what ASBA um provides. And making sure that we have someone from ASBA talk to not only us, but to our constituents to know what ASBA is all about from that professional standpoint, I think would be beneficial to us to make the right decision uh for our taxpayers and and our our students.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above