2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 104
Uh so this excites me. This is something that I would find enjoyable, but more importantly refreshing. But even more importantly, I think I could be very helpful to you. Not only everything that I've done and the experiences I have, but also all the relationships I can bring to bear around resources and supports uh and do it with trust and honor that you could trust me in the in the um in the duties that you would hold me accountable for. So with that, I thank you for your time. I've enjoyed this opportunity to speak with you and hope we can talk again. Thank you. Thank you. Good night. This is the latest interview I've ever had. It is an unusual time on a Saturday night. I appreciate your flexibility. I know you didn't. I I understand these people in Greenfield, they don't play around. We are serious.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 105
We are serious here. All right. I'm leaving now. All right. Good night. See you later. You're enjoying. Thank you guys. It's definitely enjoyable. Thank you. All right. Um, let's see. I think first I want to fix the agenda just by making it official having some entertain a motion to move public comment on the agenda to before the vote on candidate selection. So moved. Second. Motion from member Ston and a second from member Martini.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 106
Any discussion? Quick question. Will public comment be before or after deliberation? Um uh the vote includes the deliberation. So yes. Okay. Just checking because of the wording on the agenda. Yeah, good good question. Yes. So um the vote on candidate selection will include the committee deliberating about the vote. Um and that will happen if this vote passes after the public comment period. Okay. Uh any other discussion of the motion to move uh public comment on up to before the vote on candidate selection. Okay. All those in favor? I. Motion carries. And I personally would like a fivem minute break before public comment. Is there any objection to that from the public? All right, let's take five minutes. [Music] Welcome back. Uh we are now at public comment. We will start with public comment in the room. If there's anybody on Zoom who would like to make a public comment, please notify me by chat or raising your virtual hand or getting my attention some other way.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 107
Any public comment from the room? There's no sign up tonight. to be the public. No, we have some other members of the public. These two would fight you on that. They also have members of the public, too. Also, all raised their hand at once. So, uh let's see if someone Yeah, just can decide amongst yourselves. Come up front, please. Yep.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 108
You have uh three minutes. Just say your name and where you live. My name is Ann Valentine and I live in Hatfield. Um I just wanted to bring up two kind of generic concerns that I had. Two of the candidates expressed um experience with closing schools, which I know is something that people are interested in learning about. Um I I'm hoping that you heard that it was to move children into a new school. That was something that I heard. Yes, understanding how to close a school, but it's different when you move them into a new school that's waiting for them. Just a comment because that was said by two different candidates. Um, some of the candidates, uh, one of the candidates has some positive comments that I had the opportunity to talk to staff at the middle school and the high school. Um, Mr. Joyel, that's how you pronounce his name.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 109
Um, people have approached me with comments such as he was approachable, he was calm, he was knowledgeable. They um I'm also thinking that it would be nice if we had somebody that was stable, not really into some big changes right now, and somebody who we know and trust. Thank you, Tara. Hello, Tara Clutier. I live in Greenfield. Um I kind of want to echo what an said about Roland Joy. Um, when I heard member child's comments about um looking for calm and uh stability, it just made me think of Roland Joy. I worked with him at the high school last year when he was there as an intern and it felt calm. It felt like we could talk to him. We would see him in the hallways. He was talking to students. he was talking to adults. Um it feels like at such an unstable time here that that is a good match.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 110
Thank you. Any uh public comment from people on Zoom? Okay, not seeing any. Um we'll move on to the vote on candidate selection. Um I I I guess uh well I'll talk a little bit about process. Um I had been thinking just come in and have people start making motions because um when time is short sometimes we have to rely on Robert's rules of order and just um uh you know voting and majority wins. But maybe we can do a bit of a hybrid um a full kind of a a full consensus process may take more time than we have, but we could do a partial process of at least starting to narrow the the list of choices that we're voting from among. Um so I wondered if uh maybe we could take a a motion to suspend the rules of order and have a more informal conversation to try to narrow our list of candidates before moving to uh vote.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 111
So moved. Oh, okay. I'm going to go with a motion from member Ston and a second from member Goodwin. Um, motion from member Ston. Okay. Second. Good one. Okay. Thank you. Sure. Okay. So, I guess what I would uh propose as a a process would be on that. Oh, we have to vote on it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 112
Any discussion? Okay. Uh, all those in favor? Hi. Hi. Um, did I start the recording? Yeah, I think I did. Yes. Okay, it's recording. Um, okay. So, we suspended the rules of order so we can have a more informal conversation. I I think what I would suggest is that we just go around and people say, "Who are the candidates that you're choosing among?" Um, so we can kind of get a picture and I I'll do a little bit of a tally. Um, it the tally isn't a vote, but just to kind of see where the energy is in the room around different candidates. Um, who would feel ready to begin? Member Goodwin. Um, Roland Joy would be my first. My second would be Mark Goslin. And my third would be Moren. I'm not sure how to say her last name. Ben Bonita. Benenda. Okay. All right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 113
Member Childs, who are you thinking about? I'm still thinking and wanting to listen more. Okay, fair enough. Member Den. My first choice is Annie Azeroa, followed by Roland Joy. And my third choice would be Mark Mclofflin. Member Sexton. Can I come back? Yep. Member Martini, Mark Goslin, Annie Azaroa, and Roland Joy. Mayor [Music] Roland Joy would be my first choice. Um, Maren Biana would be my second choice. Mark Goslin would be my third choice. Okay. Um, so any members who haven't had a chance to share your your thoughts that you're ready to share yet? Member Ston. I think for me my first choice candidate would be Annie Azerloza. Um it's a little trickier with the with the other candidates, but I might go um Moren Vinienda followed by Roland Joy because upon hearing the recommendations of our educators. Thank you. Member Childs, I think the list of names that has been brought forward is a list that I am comfortable with.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 114
Okay, great. Um let's see. Uh I don't know if I have a ranking. Um exactly, but I would say uh Joy and Ben and uh stand out to me. Um so the list of names that have been mentioned are Joyel Goslin Biana and Azar Loza and Mclofflin. the most kind of heat or energy is around Joy uh and um then Bian and Nunda tie with Goslin and Annie and then Mlofflin and that wasn't it was too complicated to factor in people's first second and third choices but just the names the number of times the name was mentioned I suppose um so Um, I guess I would open open the floor if uh folks would like to um speak to one of those candidates and why they are um your choice. Member Goodwin, I think um it was hard. I mean, Mark Goslin was I started off my day with he was my first choice.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 115
But the more I I actually went home and reread Roland's stuff um before tonight's interview. And I think one of the things that he brings that none of the other candidates bring is a healing component because he's worked in our district and teachers already know him. And I think that's an important thing right now in this space of time for our district to bring that that comfort which he brings to the high school teachers and the middle school teachers. Others member Ston. Yeah, I um not to discount that, but I do think that there was the uh another candidate who specifically mentioned healing and was able to even just glean that from being around us. So that was um Annie Azerloza who like specifically called that out. So I just want to to name that there might that she might be another candidate who could accomplish that without any without baggage from already having been here to experience some of it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 116
bringing a bit of more of an outsers's perspective. I'm not necessarily arguing with you, but I just wanted to name if that is a factor that there are more than one way there's more than one way to think about or approach that. Um, I think the other things that really made that candidate attractive to me. Um, was that I I just appreciated the sort of energy and the specificity and the conciseness with which she approached her answers. to us. Um, uh, it felt like that was a candidate who actually had more time for some Q&A back and forth and left more time open to have questions from from other folks. And I think that that's an important like that's that's a reflection even in the interview space of being able to to be have to dedicate the time to listen to others and bring them in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 117
I really also appreciated what she spoke about in terms of student empowerment and student engagement and involvement. Um, you know, that's a a big goal and a factor of mine. So, I just wanted to to give a a a fair or a plea for this particular person even though I understand based on the numbers that they're unlikely to be the candidate. Okay. Any other um mayor? So, I appreciate that. I thought um she was going to be my fourth if I had to go through and she did do those things that um you spoke about um taking the time. You know, people interview in different styles. She took the time to, you know, be listening and I I saw what you're seeing. Um but I kept going I was going back to my list of what Liz Lefond had said and what I heard people saying about the you know the comm.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 118
So um we actually the strong financial management skill expertise in te technology and school law and advocating for public education. I think all of them did that. the communication we we heard from those that knew Roland that he communicated well with um in the two schools that he worked in. And I guess my overarching thing is would be um the known and what our um what what those who know him and and worked with him had to say. um comfortable, secure and a communicator. So I think that was a known entity. So I I would advocate for that for him. Thank you. Is there anyone who would like to advocate for Mclofflin to be one of the contenders? I know there was one person who had them on their list but wanting to know if you wanted to speak to them didn't seem there was broad interest I guess.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 119
Member Goodwin can I add one more thing for Roland? Yep. He's the one who lives the closest which is a consideration. Okay. Member Denife. Um I'm fine with Roland Joy. Um, and really all of the candidates seemed like they could perform the job adequately and had all of the experience necessary to do it. But I think that um, finding somebody who really exhibits a care and interest in Greenfield and in Western Massachusetts and in the particular nature of our community is especially important. And the only person who did that in their cover letter was Annie Azerloza, who specifically said that she was excited to be moving to Greenfield if we chose her and that she wanted to embrace uh Massachusetts and Western Massachusetts in the future. So, um I think that that's really nice. I the cover letters are easily more important to me than even the interview style.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 120
and she was one of the few that had the power of brevity and awareness of the space and um the listening skills. Uh the other candidates, you know, really knew how to steamroll their points. So, I think that that's something that will would really lend itself well to our district. And Roland Joy also possessed a little bit of that. So, those are the two that I'm really set on. Thank you. Anyone else wish to speak? Member Martini. Uh I really that's I appreciate you sharing that perspective u member Geneive because I am not a cover letter gal. I wouldn't have um uh seen it that same way. But I really appreciate that view. Um I am thinking uh greatly in terms of their interviews today. I think that uh Goslin and Azer Loza certainly had the strongest interviews. I appreciated Dr. Goslin's uh values when it comes to serving students with disabilities.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 121
uh as you all know that's always forefront in my mind uh and I think he gave the um strongest answers in relation to that uh particular group of students and and Greenfield needs to serve them well. Um and uh I also listed Roland Joy because of the needs that everyone has um already noted for um creating some stability and uh calm in the district right now, especially for our staff. And as you heard me say earlier today, what I really would like to see in a year uh as an answer to one of our candidates questions uh is that our staff felt supported this year. So uh perhaps he is the best candidate as an interim. Um if so, however, I would uh really hope that perhaps Dr. Goslin would revisit us as a superintendent candidate. Um, I guess since we're in our informal suspended rules of order, maybe I'll I'll take a uh shot at kind of summarizing what I think I'm hearing the group uh saying.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 122
Um I think what I'm hearing is that there are number of people who would strongly advocate for Joy and a number of people who could really live with Joy and respect and appreciate some of the comments that were made during public comment about him. Um, I'm also hearing some passion and interest about um I have her first name here. Oh, M. Ms. Azer Loza. um and her ability to um show passion for the city, engage with us in a very personal way and a way that left time for kind of engagement back and forth um between the commun the the members and herself. Um I also appreciated those characteristics of her. Um, I wonder if that seems like a fair summary of kind of where we are. Um, is this does anyone have anything else they would like to say or do before we enter into a motion making Robert's rules of order kind of process for um for making our decision.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-06-23 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Special Meeting June 14th 2025 · passage 123
Uh, we'll go with member Charles and then member Goodwin. Well, I I just want to take a moment to reflect on this being a very much emergency rushed process that we really didn't get the chance to get to know people as well as we would want to. Um, and in that case, uh, Mr. does have the edge of being a known quantity, but at the same time, Azerosa impressed me a lot and but it it I just wish we had more time with the candidates. I wish we could do more before having to make a decision. Thank you, member Goodwin. Totally agree with that. Um, and I would like some of these candidates to hear that we would like to see them apply a year from now or or when we start the process for even a permanent superintendent because I think it's a different job.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above