I'm sure it is. And I don't mean to make it sound like it's just one thing, but like I know if I was a developer and I was walking in and out of meetings for a year, I would it would be frustrating. Frustrating also. And so I know you're raising your hand. So one of the let me just say one thing. One of the things that I really appreciate about K, a former planning board member, she was obsessed with this idea that it's not fair to the developer or the planning board because what happens is when the developer comes with a plan and we keep, well, you didn't do this, you didn't do that, you didn't do this, you didn't do that, you start a blame game where the developer is like, well, the planning board kept this on forever. And the planning board is like, well, you weren't prepared.
Quick overview of the project. Uh as you all know, it's located on the site next to the Renaissance at Matson uh school. The scope that we are um looking at includes 78 units in three buildings, two to three four uh stories. Uh the project budget at the conceptual level has been estimated at around 50 million uh with an anticipated construction timeline of starting the second quarter of 2027 uh and completing uh construction towards the end of 2028. Um the project delivery method that was stipulated for this project was a sign build. Uh basically the owner hires a single entity that's responsible uh for both the design and the construction of the project. Um some of the advantages of this delivery method is having a single point of accountability which hopefully results later in uh less fingerpointing during the construction. Um also better collaboration and constructability during the design.
And it's a blame game and it doesn't it that's what happens. And so Kate's obsession with a checklist was precisely to address your where the idea was they provide an application. The planning department has a clear checklist. If nothing if all the checklists don't match, she's not even going to bring it to us. She's going to work with them behind the scenes to work through all of the stuff they're supposed to have before they even come. That way when they come, they're ready and we're not risking. Yeah, I think there's more to it even than that. I think there can be a whole checklist, but in the planning board and particularly say with that project, there were things that just as a board did not work for us that we, you know, did not work for the public, didn't work for the steering radius to make sure that the fire truck has the ability to get into the site and make it safely around the building.
Uh given that designers and contractors are part of the same team uh which ideally results in fewer change orders during construction process and also streamlining the schedule uh since uh there's sometimes a bit of an overlap between the design and the construction and getting that input uh from the very beginning the constructability input from the very beginning on the team. So uh we have here a kind of a summary of this selection uh process going from the RFQ to the selection of the design builder. Uh so for the RFQ phase uh which we are reaching the the final stages of it uh issued we issued the RFQ get responses did the evaluation review of those responses um and with the outcome of having a short list of respondents that will be moving on to the next phase which is the request for proposals the RFP uh in which in a similar manner we'll release the package.
You're looking at um egress on the building. You're looking at where the parking is located. Where are they putting snow removal during the winter time? Are you blocking those parking spaces? Are your drainage on site? What are you using to take care of the snow removal? Are you using sand or salt? And where is where does that drainage base out? Because that determines what you can use on the Those things all sound really good to me. Yeah, that isn't what I read when I read the first five or six. No, those things minimize the use of wetlands, steep slopes, flood planes, and hilltops, obstruction of scenic views. Yeah, those things like you said are really more you have to use like preserve unique natural or historical features like historical but what's a unique natural you have a 500y old willow tree on your property and somebody's like we want to chop this down to put a gazebo there you might say can you maybe consider it years old what if it's 80 like what like well this is why you have the five of us right it out um it's also important to remember that those larger projects also tend to be a special permit and a a site plan review simultaneously.
We'll be getting responses from the three uh respondents and go through a process of evaluation, interviews, uh presentations on uh what they are proposing for the project and ultimately selecting the design uh builder for the project. Uh culminating with the contract for them to proceed and finally fully engaged Uh the purpose of this uh RFQ is as mentioned to evaluate and prepare a short list of the most qualified uh design build teams that uh submitted responses um on a best value uh basis. uh some of the focus areas uh for this evaluation more import most importantly I would say their their experience on similar projects and with design build uh the project delivery methods uh also taking a look at their financial capacity uh their history when it comes to legal issues or other claims safety and very relevant to our project their proposed or uh forecast of what the budget would be to complete the project and the timeline.
Which is why just at the last town meeting, we changed our site plan review to match special permit. So those calendars go in line. Yes. Because a lot of times they you're get they're getting both. They're separate approvals, but you have to have both to to do your project. And so sometimes it's not the site plan review that's holding you up. It's the special permit which is you're asking you know the special per you're asking for something special. Yes. That's the whole thing is a special permit. You're asking for something special and so there is more there is more of a push and pull with that. So I will say a good developer with experience will come in with an attorney who will essentially write all of this out in the initial applications is non-issue. I would love to see more of that. You have a she keeps raising her hand.
Um so the process started with a release of the RFQ package uh back in December of last year. Uh part of that included an outreach where um the district worked with a few of the news outlets in the area. uh it was posted on the district's website. Uh we also reached out to the different builder exchange programs uh in the region. Um I'm also reaching out to parties that uh the group that was the team working on this thought would be a good fit for for this opportunity. Uh we after that had anformational meeting and a site visit uh in January uh where there was a good attendance. We had about 24 entities that were represented during that site visit. Um the next step was getting the responses. Uh the deadline was February 14th of this year and since then we've been reviewing those response packages.
I'm sorry. No, it's fine. So, I just wanted to add in like also to that like the wetland steep slopes and everything. First of all, anything that goes to your site plan review is also going to go to conservation because one of our triggers for the storm water bylaw is the second it hits your site plan review. So, it will always go to conservation and we'll be looking at that as well. Mhm. And um a lot of that first one is honestly the wetlands protection act is going to be covering wetlands and flood planes. The storm water handbook especially with the new revisions that they're working on are going to strongly regulate what you can put on steep slopes. Um and working on steep slopes also affects your storm water. Um so that's where that part comes in. And then unique natural features can also I mean in in my scope of conservation we're normally talking vernal pools right and and and other rare habitats and things like that and those are also protected in their own way but they're not so protected by the state as they are by the local bylaws.
Uh going through the evaluation and ranking procedure to tonight where we are ready to present the recommendation. So the valuation was based on criteria stipulated in the RFQ package. Um as you can see uh there were about 10 or so different categories. Uh some items were based on a past fail uh um basis. For example, was a team licensed and and registered all the participants like the architect, the the contractor engineers. Um, and as you can see here, what was the distribution of scoring for the different categories, uh, highlighting the project experience and the reference, uh, which we thought would be very, uh, important and key to the selection of the the team. uh part of the committee. Uh there were three different parties. Uh two were staff members. Uh ARUSD staff members and one was an ARUSD consultant. Uh we EHP were not part of this evaluation committee.
Um, so that that's something that maybe the intent at some point also was to include that. And then the same thing with the tree and vegetation, soil removal, grain changes. That also goes back to storm water. It goes back to your air quality and water quality and all of that because once you start touching those things, you affect all of that. It's all one big system. Um, so it's all important in its own way. when you get into the technical details, you cut a certain number of trees, now you have to provide even more storm water because trees provide better water retention than a lawn and things like that. So, that's where that's all coming through and that's what you get peer reviews to help you with and what I'm sure Jasmine will will give you details on as well. Um, but hopefully that helps clarify why those might be on there as well too.
Our role was basically to uh facilitate the process but we were not uh part of the scoring. Can you provide me the names of the staff members? Oh um sorry DJ Sakai with Dennis Oliver Kelly with regard to that we're in the middle of the procurement process and in during the procurement process there's certain information that's kept confidential including the names of the people who are um who are providing who did the scoring on this. So my question is since we don't I don't know maybe I'm going to make it a little bit more convoluted but um I would like to know as well. So that type of information we can be provided in close session. Um it's not really a close session item but it's not something that we would disclose during a board meeting. Yeah of course. Yeah. Go ahead. Is it something that can be uh disclosed to us individually in our one-on- ones that we ask or we can provide it in a confidential manner?
And you'll see from develop from project to project too how you know you might say something like you want to minimize you know the obstruction of the scenic views. You might have a site somebody has a house right there and you're putting up a condo. They're putting up directly in front of a house. They've got 10 acres. Can you just right 30 ft maybe so you can preserve half of their view? And they say yeah sure we can do that. Or they say actually there's wetlands right there and we can't do that. And that's why we put it here. And then you go, "Oh, okay." And you've tried your best, but sometimes it is just sometimes you just have to eat the sour grape. You know, you try your best to do what's best for the community, but also at the same time the developer wants to site and they do have certain rights with certain things.
Okay. Any more questions? You want to continue? Anything else? Okay. Thank you. Um so we got nine teams uh submitting responses as you can see here the the list of the all the teams um all of them with um regional experience um housing experience to certain degrees housing experience experience with um working with prevailing wage projects skilled and trained labor um some of them have worked collaboratively in the uh so they have that um experience that they bring to the project. Um and as a result of that uh we are ready to um present the outcome of of the evaluation with the short list. I just wanted to make a comment that as an RFQ we're not saying that the people who aren't on the short list aren't qualified. It's we're giving you the three top in in in terms of the qualifications and um understand also like you know we do a lot of other projects and it's when we're normally used to doing people who are um experienced with school construction.
So, you always try to make the best decision, but you're not you're not always going to get your way every time, but you just have to use your best judgment. Gotcha. And I'll butt into also at the beginning of each of those bylaws, you also have your purpose section, which I have on the screen now. And that is really your guiding document of what each of those criteria are really deriving from. And so if you're ever like, what does this mean? You can always refer back to your purpose line and it might provide that clarification to of what were they actually trying to do. Now that said, in all this discussion, it doesn't mean that the bylaws the bylaws we have now are ones we have to adhere to, right? That's our job. But u but that doesn't mean they can't be changed. Absolutely. They get changed through town meeting.
This is workforce con workforce housing construction. So there's a different focus from what we've done perhaps in other projects that we do for the school district. And then again, so it's the top three that's in the statute that we do the top three as opposed to just, you know, a random number in the education code. They call out for three. So I guess I pose a question to Superintendent Serda that um I was surprised that number four wasn't on the top three. Um and so I just wanted to, you know, I guess we can't go into it open session. So that's okay. So to come up with a short list um we went through a process of receiving the uh response packages and EHP we took the first um step at reviewing everything and basically coming up with a a summary tool where we were uh tabulating all the responses submitted by the different uh respondents and also reaching out to the difference uh different references that were listed by the respondents.
And um I think there's a number of things that as we have gone through the years that that things seem like they need to be tweaked, if not at least discussed to to see if you would like to tweak them, right? But they you you kind of come um at times where we're just up against something that seems like it's strange to be up against, right? It doesn't really make sense, but yet these are the bylaws. So um so that's why again like part of what I want to do especially with the new tone planner who seems enthusiastic about the idea as well is to help go through these bylaws and and you know I mean Becca was involved with the the storm water one recently that went through planning board but she's the only one who probably truly understood it right so so an example might be instead of minimized use of wetlands you might change that to must conform to the storm water bylaw and refer to that section instead And now that it's the same intent, but now it's specific and it's more tangible.
Uh we had two meetings with the evaluation committee uh where they were um scoring using the once again the criteria that was stipulated in the RFP package. Um how those meetings uh occurred where we EHP would present the information. We go through the the criteria, show them the question and then show them where in the package the respondents submitted their how how they responded. It was basically a presentation for them and then the uh committee would just u make an assessment and at that time assign scoring to each one of the categories. Um once we were uh the evaluation committee uh was done with the scoring we tabulated the all the information uh all the scoring to complete uh the come up sorry with the short list um which we are presenting here. So these are the top three scores. Uh the scoring here it's uh average scores and given that should the board concur with the short list that's being presented.
And that might be some things you see as you go through the bylaw that I now that you've worked with, you see the intent, but you feel it could be written better to be understood better by either the applicant or a resident. I mean, these were last updated in 2010, I think, but not all of them. Not all parts. So, some of these could have been written 20 years ago, and just development changes. Everything changes. So sometimes the intent was clear when it was written and we just need to change it to how it meets our needs today. I will add that your point about how long these things take is is an important um because it's a loss for everyone when it takes a long time. Nobody's happy about that. I would say most developers I would say probably walk in expecting at least probably eight months to 8 to 12 months for a special permit depending on the project.
Uh so the next step would be then to proceed with the RFP phase. the uh request for proposals where we would release the package to the shortlisted respondents. Um some of the key items related to the RFP will be their design approach uh the pricing and fee proposals, the proposed schedule and how they perform uh during the interviews that will take place and their presentations. And the goal will be to have a final uh complete the final selection of the design builder towards the end of of the year. And as a refresher, we wanted to go over the um pre-construction process uh from the selection of the design builder to start of construction. Uh so once the design builder is uh confirmed the next step will be to go through the application for planning uh with the goal of uh obtaining entitlements for the project.