2025-07-10 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 07/09/2025 · passage 51
Any questions? All right, I'll take a motion. I move to approve the adopted of the budget of the FY25 2025 2026 district expenditure budget as presented. I second the motion. All in favor? I I motion carries. Oh, three to zero. At this point, um we don't have anything for information discussion right now. Okay. So, I am going to um let's see. Call for an executive session at 6:17. Uh I need a motion. Well, I'll make a motion to go into executive session at 617. Second. All in favor? I I And if we get signatures on the budget and everything before we go in there, just so that three to zero. Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 51
Uh today we're actively engaged in the development of a proof of concept with the Northfor County Registry of Deeds exploring how we can collaborate to provide storage transparency and resiliency of land records. That project which is led with Blockwise Advisors Groma and the National Association of Realtors mirrors precisely the vision outlined in H87. And we're not theorizing here. We're actually putting uh practicality to test. And so that's why this bill matters. Moving on to 89. an act providing for consumer protection in the digital economy. Uh Massachusetts has been a pioneer uh from the nation's first blockchain municipal bond to exploring these land records that I just talked about. But at every turn, we encounter the same issues and the same questions from residents, community leaders, and local officials. And that's what does this mean for me? H89 answers this question headon. And by tasking the state treasures office with developing educational resources on digital assets, the Commonwealth would empower residents with the tools that they need to make informed decisions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 52
And whether that's understanding the basics of cryptocurrency or recognizing the risks that come with emerging financial products. Critically, this is about inclusion and it's about trust. Without broad-based digital literacy, innovation risks become an insidider game only and it widens the divide that currently already exists. And again, we're very happy to support these efforts. I also want to thank Representative Caitlyn Brigger Beian for shephering these bills in her support for the blockchain industry in Massachusetts. Happy to take questions. Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 53
Uh any questions? Well, you get off easy. Yeah, because people are like, "What's blockchain?" Yeah. So, thank you for your support. Okay. Next, we have Rick Trilling. Rick Trilling. Moving on. Uh, this is virtual Julian Shelfo. Hello, that's me. Can you hear me? Okay. Yes. Okay, great. Um, hello chairs and committee members. Thank you for having me today. My name is Julie Skeleo and I'm a longtime journalist, a mom of three, and the founder of Mothers Against Media Addiction. MAMA is a grassroots movement of parents and allies fighting back against media addiction and creating a world where real life experiences and interactions remain at the heart of a healthy childhood. Kids in Massachusetts and across the country are being harmed by social media platforms that are designed to addict. This addiction has created what the American Academy of Pediatrics calls a national emergency in youth mental health.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 54
I started MAMA after reporting on that and on growing rates of suicide, not just in teens, but in twins. Today, more 10-year-olds die by suicide in the United States than from every form of cancer combined. For more than a decade, we've also seen elevated rates of youth anxiety, depression, self harm, eating disorders, and more. Attention spans are falling while reading and math scores go down. The effects of this on our families, our communities, and future workforce are profound. As social media company's own internal documents show, these problems did not happen by chance. They were the result of intentional algorithm design choices and data practices picked to maximize profit. Meta reports that it removed over 12 million pieces of suicide and self harm content from Facebook and Instagram just between April and June of last year. So a modest estimate is that kids are exposed to 48 million pieces of dangerous, unhealthy content on those two platforms annually.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 55
And that's not even including all the other very engaging but potentially harmful images and videos as you heard the young woman testify about earlier. Is it a is it a surprise our kids are suffering? Of course not. Today you have the power to do something. For too long social media companies have argued that they should be shielded from limits that apply to every other mass media publisher or broadcaster. They want us to believe that implementing standards to ensure their products are safe would somehow stall innovation or violate free speech or put marginalized groups at risk. You have even heard some of these arguments today. Don't fall for it. I'm here to say as a journalist, you won't find anyone who values free speech more. And these companies have the same responsibility as any other company. Children deserve to be safe. That's why there are laws that ensure cribs and car seats are manufactured to certain standard and that vehicles include seat belts.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 56
By law, we don't allow kids to purchase liquor, buy cigarettes, or visit casinos. Why should we allow social media companies to serve addictive products to kids unfettered? Keeping children safe online is something all parents want and something this elected body can do now by voting to enact Senate Bill 30 and House Bill 4229. Please don't wait for more Massachusetts children and families to suffer harm that is preventable. Thank you for this opportunity to testify and for putting our kids safety ahead of tech company profits. Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 57
Any questions from the committee? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. and thank you for your testimony and your work on this. There's nothing like mamas to get things done, right? I completely share your goal. I I completely share the end product of why we're trying to grow here. I do have some concerns on how we're going to get there and central to that is age verification. So, I just didn't know if you wanted to talk a little bit about age verification and how you think this is going to work and work in a way that actually is not harmful on the other end of this in what is often referred to as the dark web. Absolutely. So, you know, big tech unfortunately has been operating a lot like big tobacco and they will make any argument they can about why any safeguards at all um could potentially be harmful.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 58
But what they don't talk about is the fact that they are already collecting that data on our children. And we know that because of their own internal documents and the multiple whistleblowers that have come forward to say that, for example, Instagram was collecting data on the number of 10, 11, and 12 year olds who were staying up at 12, midnight, 1:00 a.m., 2 a.m. on school nights because these products were so addictive they couldn't get off. So even though these companies like to distract us by warning us that age verification might create new problems, they're not really being honest about the fact that they are already have so much detail in our children. They can tell not only how old they are, but their most intimate and detailed preferences even beyond what children themselves or we adults ourselves could identify. Yeah. So I'm going to agree with you on that that that they're already collecting that data.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 59
quite frankly, they are selling that data. Um, and so I I guess I'll point you to our data privacy bills that that um are being very actively uh discussed now and worked on. Um, and us treating both children as defined as under 13 and minors as defined as 18. Um, as that is sensitive data that cannot be bought and sold. They know who is under 18. They just do. Um, and so I'm curious if um, a known or should have known standard would be something that you think would be workable. I think that we've seen um, success in these approaches. For example, in New York that was mentioned earlier where last year we passed the safe for kids act or the stop addictive feeds along with child data privacy protections. And so I think that approach chair is really smart to make sure that both are enacted at the same time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 60
And again, you know, we're differentiating between um minors and adults. While certainly we would like all of these products to be as safe as possible for everyone, we recognize there are differences between minors and adults and we don't allow our children to go into casinos or buy alcohol um because we recognize that they're addictive. So, I think when companies say that there are too many burdens in making their products safer, you know, we don't buy that argument from any other type of company. We don't allow baby formula companies to put wood chips in baby formula because they can make more profit. And similarly, I don't think we should allow these companies to profit off of our children using absolutely any technique um possible. And that's why these bills make so much sense. So again, you know, we're open to a variety of solutions. Um, but we have seen in New York that those bills that were passed in a bipartisan way and in conjunction with input from the attorneys the attorney general's office that there are enforcement mechanisms for families.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 61
Too many families are experiencing um just catastrophic harms to their children's well-being when these products, these companies are amplifying content designed only to for engagement and nothing else. and they are receiving um kids are receiving challenges that are resulting in deaths. Um on Snapchat uh there are record rates of fentinel sales and we now have record rates of fentinyl overdoses. So there's just too many harms and it's time it's time to correct things and protect our kids. Well, again, I thank you for your advocacy and I would welcome further conversations with you and the uh bill sponsors on this. Thank you so much and thank you. Happy to help. Thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions? Thank you. Uh, next we have in person I Arie Cohen, [Music] chairs Moore and Farley Bouvier, members of the committee. Uh, my name is Ari Conn. I have been a first amendment lawyer for more than a decade and I am currently lead counsel for the foundation lead council for tech policy at the foundation for individual rights and expression or fire a nonpartisan nonprofit organization that defends the free speech rights of all Americans.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 62
Hold on a minute. Okay. Uh, I'm testifying today in opposition to Senate Bill 30 and House Bill 4229, which while doubtless well-intentioned, would violate the First Amendment rights of all users, regardless of their age, and impose government control on how speech is published and distributed online. These concerns have led courts around the country to enjoin similar legislation in other states. Uh, and today I'll briefly focus on two primary concerns. First, as you've heard, this bill would effectively require all social media platforms, which are almost universally built around curated content recommendations uh to verify the age of every user. This necessarily requires users to hand over personally identifying information, eroding the anonymity that allows Americans to read and share information on sensitive or controversial topics, including political disscent and criticism of powerful figures, safely and candidly without the risk of reprisal. And this is true in practice regardless of whether the bill directly mandates collection of government ID.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 63
Uh as you've heard uh before the only really uh alternate meth method of age assurance is facial age estimation which still requires handing over biometric information. But beyond that facial age estimation can't reliably distinguish between a 17-year-old and a 19year-old. All systems have a buffer zone between two to five years within which a user will be rejected and forced to hand over actual identifying information including identity documents. And these systems also oftentimes falsely reject users for minority groups, particularly transgender individuals who might not have identity documents depending on where they are um and their uh personal situations and those with darker skin requiring them to show additional identification. courts. The first amendment protects the rights of minors to access constitutionally protected speech on social media. The Supreme Court has held that it similar similarly prohibits the government from regulating who may speak to minors and on what constitutionally protected topics.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 64
Content recommendations are themselves speech protected by the First Amendment and calling them addictive simply does not change that legal reality. At its core, this is a contentbased restriction on what speech may be conveyed to minors and how, and it will therefore be subject to strict constitutional scrutiny, which has been described as strict in theory, but fatal in fact. The bill compounds this problem, furthermore, by simultaneously prohibiting platforms from withholding or lowering the quality of their services to any user to whom it's prohibited from providing these recommendations, effectively requiring platforms to display content in a way that does not align with their own wishes. It adds compelled speech to compelled silence by requiring platforms to speak and distribute information to users, but only in the way the government approves of. And this is prot precisely the type of government entanglement with speech that the First Amendment prohibits.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 65
I would urge this committee to vote no on both of these bills. Thank you. Any questions? All right. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Um, we still have roughly 25 people have testified.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 66
I've been a little given a little leeway going beyond the three minutes. Um I apologize if I am going to try to strictly enforce the three minute to make sure that we move along and everyone gets a chance to testify. Okay? So please don't take it as being rude or trying to interrupt you. We just need to make sure that the hearing proceeds. Um next we have Suzanne Bernstein from Electronic Privacy Information Center. It's virtually. Hello. Good afternoon. My name is Suzanne Bernstein. I'm council at the Electronic Privacy Oh, can you hear me? Yes. Okay. Sorry. I'm counsel at the Electronic Privacy Information Center. Thank you for the opportunity to testify in support of S30 and H4229, an act protecting children from addictive social media feeds. EPIC is an independent nonprofit research organization focused on protecting privacy, freedom of expression, and democratic values in the information age.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 67
Existing protections for the privacy and safety of minors online are deeply inadequate. Many companies employ design features that use minor data to figure out the best way to manipulate each minor into staying on the platform as long as possible. This is regardless of content. These design choices lead to overuse and compulsive use of social media and harm minors by interfering with poor life activities such as sleeping, exercising, or socializing. All the while, evidence shows that company's behavioral engineering tactics are ruthlessly effective, preventing minors from controlling the amount of time they actually want to spend on social media. These design practices deprive minors of their autonomy, taking control of their online experiences out of their hands and subjecting them to heightened physical safety and data security risks. This bill will mitigate these harms in two ways. regulating addictive feeds, as they're called in the bill, and overnight notifications.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 68
The addictive feeds provision limits the personal data that a social media platform can use to curate feeds for minors. It addresses the current design practices of ordering feeds based on the passive surveillance of users, tracking clicks, time spent watching, or even spent hovering over certain media. And borrowing techniques from the casino industry, this induces overuse, and companies use this data to predict and design what arrangement of media is likely to keep a user on the platform longer, invading minor's privacy and contributing to this compulsive use. And while S30 regulates specific data management design practices that lead to overuse, it leaves open many channels for personalized delivery of the same media based on a user's express preferences, not passive surveillance. For example, subscribing to, liking, disliking, or otherwise explicitly interacting with a piece of media or media in a certain category. S30 also prohibits push notifications between 6:00 am between midnight and 6 a.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 69
These notifications are an important design feature encouraging compulsive use by incessantly reminding users of the app even when it's inactive. This is an intentional move. Uh, in Massachusetts ongoing lawsuit, for example, against Tik Tok, the company admitted that push notifications are key to drawing users attention back to the app, and they have sometimes sent thousands of not notifications to a day to minor. S30 protects miners privacy, enhances minor autonomy, and significantly improves their online safety by prohibiting abusive data and design practices. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above