Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
Epic is happy to be a resource to the committee on the issues and I'm happy to answer any questions. Okay. Thank you. Any questions? Representative. Good afternoon. Thank you for your testimony today. Uh I was wondering if you'd be able to speak briefly uh about um you know, we we've heard some testimony today essentially characterizing the legal landscape as saying that this would be uh contrary to the protections of the First Amendment. Could you talk a little bit about that more specifically in relation to these these pieces of legislation? Sure. Thank you for the question. Um, so this uh piece of legislation is content agnostic. It regulates the kind of data that these companies can use to uh input into an algorithm to provide information to order media for miners. So it has nothing to do with the content that is actually shown to the miners.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Instead, it's about data use. It's about the surveillance that of of our clicks and attention online and using that to in and design features that maintain attention regardless of what a minor is being shown. So in that way it's content agnostic. It doesn't regulate content at all. Um and also I I can respond to the to the other comments about the first amendment as it relates to age assurance in this bill. uh if so age assurance in the bill is uh something that uh is directed to the attorney general to do rulemaking to determine this balance between accuracy and privacy protections so that there wouldn't be an unconstitutional burden to access anything. Uh and so the other aspect related to that evaluation is what is the burden to accessing something. So if it's to access a design feature that's not been courts have not considered that to be speech.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um and so the age assurance methods to be determined by the attorney general will be a process with uh notice and and comment and be participatory with industry. And until then, the actual knowledge standard, which is common in the federal level, the Kappa uh bill, the Kappa law, excuse me, uh is something that many, it's a relatively low threshold that many companies already uh employ today. Thank you very much. Okay, coach here, thank you and thank you for being here. Um we appreciate the partnership we have with Epic and many of our of of the bills we have in front of us. um can you talk to me about how these bills compare to what's going on um in Vermont and um you know are there things happening in Vermont that we could apply here better um and how can Vermont learn from us? Sure.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So Vermont uh recently enacted the an age appropriate design code that actually a portion of that law now law is very similar to what is in this bill. So, this bill is more similar to the New York Safe for Kids Act, which narrowly regulates um you know, surveillance-based feeds, which is defined in both of those laws as addictive feeds, as well as regulating overnight push notifications. And so, these this bill in in essence is a part of the Vermont age appropriate design code, but the Vermont age appropriate design code um goes a bit further to to more broadly regulate uh abusive data design practices for for minors in Vermont. So, uh, I think it'll be certainly interesting to see how Vermont, um, enacts this law. And there is rulemaking as well that's been assigned to, uh, by that legislature to the attorney general. Uh, and I think with the rule making in New York and on Vermont about age assurance, uh, as well as the recent Supreme Court decision, um, it'll become even more clear where where the line is in terms of how, uh, what burden is is may be appropriate or inappropriate.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um but the reality as as other uh witnesses have already indicated is that many companies already know the age of their users. Uh and this and what's very important to understand as well is that in each of those bills in Vermont, New York, and in this bill, there are statutory requirements related to the rulemaking to protect the privacy of any data that's used during the age assurance process. Thank you. And then just one more question. We talk about the definition of minor. Can you talk about like um where states are as far as age 16 versus 18? I'm going to just show my bias and say that I really like 18. So, but go ahead. Sure. there's uh there different legislators are are under trying to figure out what's the most developmentally appropriate way to regulate uh some of these uh more harmful uh social media platforms or other companies that many minors are on.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And so some bills will uh distinguish between a child as 13 and under and a minor as 18 between 13 and 18. some bills that uh go further to put bans of 13 to 16 or 16 to 18. Uh and I think it's important that legislators are doing this all at the same time and discussing with one another what might be uh the best uh way forward. I I look to uh you know pediatricians, other researchers doing uh a lot of very important work about what may be developmentally appropriate for minors and then as a privacy lawyer understanding how to best protect the privacy and online safety of of those minors relative to what's developmentally appropriate. Well, that's great. Thank you so much. And you know, you work Epic works, you know, all over the country. So, we appreciate the perspective that you have and and my co-chair and I work with legislators um AC, you know, many many other states on these issues.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, um seeing what's out there in other states is really important when it comes to this. So, thank you and thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're welcome. Uh and now we have two representatives that are going to join us as a panel. So we have Representative Scarsdale and Mr. Representative Machino. Good afternoon chairs Farley Bouvier and more and honorable members of the committee. Would you introduce yourself for the audience? Oh, pardon. Would you introduce yourself for the audience? Yes. Uh I am Margaret Scarsdale. I'm the state representative for the first middle sex district Ashby Dunable Graten Lunberg Pepper and Townsen. Um thank you for taking us out of turn in the spirit of the Daly Lama. I will say I am grateful for that. I am here today testifying on House Bill 91, an act to modernize funding for community media programming filed jointly with Rep.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Machino and Senator Lewis. So simply put, this bill is about protecting a lifeline. One that keeps people connected, informed, engaged, and even entertained. Our community media centers, like the one in my district and your districts, are there to broadcast local government meetings, um, high school sports, concerts, and even cooking shows. and they are especially important to our seniors and residents who aren't always able to be in person. For them, our local access channels are a trusted and accessible way to stay connected. And even more as our local newspapers um go under or are gobbled up by other entities, it's really the only way for many of us to to to be a part of something and to stay connected. But funding has fallen sharply with the majority of viewership shifting from traditional cable streaming to um um the the uh streaming providers from traditional cable companies.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, it puts this lifeline at risk. And that's because unlike traditional cable companies, streaming providers do not pay anything for using local infrastructure to distribute their media to customers. By modernizing the law and having streaming services pay the same cost that cable providers pay for the use of local infrastructure, we can restore a vital revenue source to our municipalities that our local media centers absolutely rely on. Now, some will argue that the cost to keep community media centers running will somehow fall unfairly on communities. But in reality, what is unfair is allowing big streaming companies like Netflix and Hulu and HBO to profit while local media stations are forced to close their doors. Massachusetts has one of the strongest media center networks in the country and we would not be the first to enact such a law. Florida, Iowa, Nebraska, North Carolina, South Dakota has such a law and I respectfully ask for a favorable report for H91.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Thank you. Oh, thank you so much, Representative. And thank you to the chairs for me to come um around and testify today in support of our bill. I'm Joan Mosschino representing the third Plymouth District um the communities of Hingham Hall and Cohassid and I have fabulous um community media centers and um I've been engaging with Mass Access um and you're going to hear testimony from Mass Access. You're going to hear testimony from a lot of the um uh the community media centers here in person today. And I know you've already gotten a lot of written testimony and it's going to keep coming um because to uplift my um colleagues remarks um we are now at the point um where we've really hit um that that critical tipping point. I think the heyday of um the cable franchise subscriptions was probably 2013 2014 and we've started to see um a decline in those cable subscriptions which is why everybody else's um uh cable costs have gone up right to try to equalize that out and over that time over those 10 plus years um we've been seeing that decline in revenues um but what's come of it initially was innovations um a lot of efficiencies and and in fact it's a vibrant ecosystem that's out there um that is doing tremendous content as you've heard um from my colleague from Senator Barrett from Rep.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
earlier. Uh but we've now hit that point where um they're not going to be able to keep pace and it is at the same point interestingly enough when the demand for this public programming has really become um a premiere and in fact there are bills out there about you know requiring this kind of programming. So, I I just I think we're at an influx moment where um we really need to think about how we replace that revenue. And so, we made choices in this legislation to update the existing law. It worked really well. You're going to hear it and see it. You've already got the testimony and writing to to prove it. uh and it's at the point now where where we really need to start um keeping pace with the technology and the way that consumers are are consuming their entertainment media. Um, so that's all we're doing is we're following these new companies um to that innovation and we're replacing that revenue because that's the goal of this whole bill is to have a stable, steady, reliable source of income um for all of this important work um for transparency in government for fantastic programming um for the innovation and in fact um I'll just use my own community as an example um they are now starting to stretch into uh training and and creating uh career paths for students.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And they're bringing people in for both content and for production. Um and they are meeting all of the demands of the traditional PEG and uh we just I don't want to get us to a point where we find out what happens if we lose this funding. So I feel that this is uh this is not this is a refile. We've worked with the committee in the past um and I' hope to work with the committee um to advance these. And I do just want to also give a shout out to um Senator Lewis um is uh Senate 41 and Representative Vieira also filed a bill on this um House 106. So um it's timely, it's relevant, and I think it's ready. So we look forward to working with you and uh you're going to hear some we're happy to answer questions, but you're going to hear some really great testimony um shortly.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Any questions? repres. Thank you. You know, have asked questions from the first couple people that testified on this and it's important to my district, but do you have if you if you can, can you comment? One of the one of the issues we have now is can we believe what we're hearing or is what we're hearing on the news filtered? And I'm thinking that it would be better coming from a local source. It certainly is in my community. Do you have any comments on that? So we have seen um in in addition to this um one of the other confluences is is these media news deserts. Um the local we I we always used to have um so I had four um local um weekly papers and they were the ones that were sitting in those select board meetings. They were the ones at the high school, you know, hockey team.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
They were the ones that were at the plate. They were the ones doing the mans on the street at every event. And they're gone. They have there's only one left. It's the Hull Times and they're struggling. Um, we used to have the Patriot Ledger, Ganet Media. They're they're they're nowhere to be found. There is no local content in there whatsoever. WATD is our sort of regional radio. They try. There's only so much they can do. And the online papers that are starting to appear um are very they're lo they're they are local, but they're very focused on their own interests. It's not um it's not the journalism that we're used to when you know you know so the the the standard reporter was in that select board meeting staring you down and god forbid you said something and and they had all the history and and they and they would follow it and they would ask those penetrating questions and and I think from you know right now transparency is such a huge piece of of what the legislature is thinking about and these are all conf conflating here this is the last bastion of trusted news sources.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And I just I think it's I think we're all at a crisis point and um I don't know how to save the the the weekly papers, but I know how to save this. Uh thank you. Great question, Mr. uh vice chair. I I just want to uplift my own communities. Um so I serve uh six small communities. Four of them do not even have a traffic light. And the newspaper that now services us, as Rep. Machino said for us you used to be you know at the select board and that reporter was there and they would ask you questions during the meeting or after like they were following it. Now the Lel Sun has bought up those newspapers and they cover 16 towns. So, you know, you get a fourpage newspaper and maybe something's mentioned, but there's not the detail about, you know, issues of importance to the community and um uh you know, just an attempt to educate.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, it it really is it's become a desert in my my area. And I'll just uh briefly comment, thank you for your uh long-standing work on on this issue. um you know in Pittsfield um and you know the center of the Bergkshire is Pittsfield Community Television without them I don't know they are they are literally set up in city hall they cover every single public meeting that we have they are very much a part of virtual testimony during during um COVID um they they're really a center of what we do and um and we are lucky enough to have a local daily um locallyowned local daily and um but we you know I very much think that this is a ve an important thing to do. How to get there is is uh is is the problem ahead of us. So anyway, thank you for your great work and I'm looking forward to further testimony today.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So, um like everyone else, thank you. This is a great cause and thank you for working with us last at the end of last session on the language which we now have before us and hopefully you'll have a very short positive stay in this committee. We're going to hold you to that, Mr. Chairman. Thank you so much. Thank you. Uh we now have Timothy Mcuade virtual. Yes. Uh hi there. Um first of all, uh thank you to all the members on the committee for letting me speak with you all today. Um, I'm speaking in support of S30 and H4229, uh, bills that aim to protect kids from the harmful effects of addictive social media feeds. Um, this is a serious problem that I don't believe can be ignored anymore. Uh, social media platforms are designed to pull people in, especially kids.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Their algorithms are not neutral. They're built and designed to keep users hooked. And that is especially risky for younger minds that are still developing. These feeds can increase anxiety. They can fuel harmful comparisons and they keep kids stuck in endless scrolling. This bill is not about cutting kids off from technology. It's about making sure that social media platforms act responsibly when there are kids involved by requiring parental consent for algorithm-driven feeds targeting minors. We're creating a basic safety net. We already accept that kids need protection from addictive substances and addictive activities. We see this need in the form of age restrictions that have long been in place on things like the sale of alcohol and tobacco or age restrictions on activities like gambling. Numerous studies have shown that social media use uh use activates the brain's dopamine reward system and when combined with targeted algorithms, this can create a dopamine loop that leads to compulsive use.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Therefore, it makes sense to offer the same kind of protection when it comes to digital products uh that we already have in place on other products and activities which have similar impacts on the mind. Uh some people are understandably worried about free speech and innovation and those are valid concerns. But this bill doesn't restrict what anyone can say. It just sets some limits on how content is delivered to kids. It's about protecting young users without getting in the way of creativity or business. Massachusetts has always led the way when it comes to smart digital policies and this bill is another step in the right direction. I urge you to move forward with it and help make the online world a safer and more transparent place for our kids. Thank you again for your time. Great. Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
U any questions from the committee? Representative. So this may be a bit of a rambler, but there is a question at the end, I promise. Uh, I have a 14-year-old and a 10-year-old. My 14-year-old has a cell phone and desperately wants, I don't know, one of the one of those apps, um, Instagram, because all the kids like to text each other on Instagram.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above