2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 90
Maybe because those messages erase after three minutes. Maybe not. I don't know. He doesn't have it yet. My daughter uh sat in the rain, stood in the rain for an hour today waiting for a bus that to summer camp that never came because she doesn't have a cell phone. I think she's too young for it. Um, nevertheless, where I'm struggling is this. You and others have compared um the addictive nature to alcohol and tobacco and pointed out that we as society have come up with a solution to that. And that is not that they can't have delicious alcohol or that they can't have just the tastiest cigarettes. It's that they can't have it at all. And that's not what this bill is proposing. Right? This bill isn't proposing you have to be 16 to use social media. It's saying we're not going to use the algorithms that figure out what you actually like the best and give it to you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 91
We're just going to have to do it sort of an oldfashioned way. And I guess where I'm stuck is, you know, there's a reason that my son doesn't have access to Instagram and my daughter doesn't have a phone at all. I get it. I'm really frustrated by it as a parent. But where I'm struggling is the comparison to other things where we don't take half measures. We just say you can't have it at all. The reason my son wants Instagram is because everyone else has it. If nobody could have it until they were 16, this would not be a problem for me as a parent because none of his friends would be using it, right? And so I'm struggling with whether or not this half measure of controlling or thinking we're controlling, I don't actually think we as a state legislature have much influence on what Google is really going to do in the back end.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 92
We're never going to look at their code. um if that's really the right approach or if in fact we should be thinking about pushing further and saying social media is bad for kids there's no half measure. Shouldn't we just say if you're not x years old no for you? What do you think? I mean it's you know it's a very good question. Um I guess I hadn't even uh considered it yet. Um, you know, I I think um, you know, it's certainly worth worth looking at. I I don't know if it's something where if we did attempt these uh kind of smaller half measure half measures, you know, just to see the the impacts, if we're seeing um, you know, any changes in um, you know, uh, the effects that it's having on uh, on kids, you know, if it if it seems to be helping.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 93
um that way they still have access to certain content as opposed to, you know, having algorithms designed to bombard them with with um all these different things. Um as opposed to just outright banning it altogether. Um but yeah, I mean it's a very it's a good question. I'm not I'm not too sure. Thank you very much. Thank you. Next virtually is Kyle Se good afternoon. Afternoon. Uh good afternoon, Chair Farley Bouvier, Chair Moore, and members of the committee. My name is Kyle Sepi. I'm the state policy manager for the Northeast at the Computer and Communications Industry Association or CCIA. And CCIA is an international trade association representing communications and technology firms. Um, and today I'm speaking to respectfully oppose H4229 and Senate Bill uh 30. CCIA believes that children are entitled to greater security and privacy online and our members have designed and developed settings or parental tools to individually tailor younger users online use to their needs.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 94
And while we understand the intent of this bill, there are some concerns around the overall impact of uh free expression and access to information and the potential impact on marginalized communities in Massachusetts. So, here's what's going on in other states. Multiple federal and lower courts have held that recent state legislation that requires age verification violates the First Amendment's guarantee of free speech. Um there's been some uh preliminary injunctions issued in some states, temporary stays as well. And this is because uh requiring users to produce let's say state approved documentation to prove their age imposes significant burdens on access to constitutionally protected speech. Um it can also be susceptible to data breaches. Courts have uh also held that statemandated age verification requirements were not only an additional hassle, but they also require website visitors to forego anonymity otherwise available on the internet. Also, age verification imposes a sweeping burden on access to speech by requiring verification mechanisms for all users.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 95
And uh this is the opposite of the bill's intended effect. The bill also carries compliance concerns. Um, for example, it doesn't specify which technologies the state would consider commercially reasonable as mentioned in the bill. Um, which would leave businesses unable to know when they're violating the law. Its verification requirements would also disadvantage smaller businesses as these tools are costly. Um, I did link a study in my testimony that addresses uh the impacts of cost for your efforts. Uh so if enacted, this bill will uh lead online services potentially to stop even serving users under 18 altogether, restricting their access to information and supportive communities. So what is the solution here? So CCIA believes that an alternative to solving these complex issues is to work with businesses to continue their ongoing efforts to implement mechanisms such as daily time limits or child safe searching so that parents can have control over their child's social media use.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 96
Um but also implementing digital citizenship curriculum in schools and I can share some of those uh state bills as well for your reference. Um, I know I'm out of time, but thank you for considering uh the comments and I look forward to uh working with you throughout this process. Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 97
Any questions? Mr. Chair, uh the gentleman referred to multiple states that uh have issues with the bill. Could he name some of the states just for our research, please, that he referred to? Absolutely. So, for example, in March of 2025, an in Arkansas federal court invalidated a state age verification law um which required users to produce state approved um IDs. There's also been um a preliminary injunction in the Georgia federal court and some of the states um that have been paused. I think um other uh witnesses have mentioned California, Utah. those bills very similar to Massachusetts um require age verification for social media and the issue of free speech has um or the first amendment has been raised as a serious uh concern that's po causing the pause for these uh measures thank you very much Mr. Chairman, you have such patience with me today.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 98
Um, thank you for your testimony today. I do have a few maybe comments more than questions. One, just noting that though I disagree um with the Supreme Court. Um, there was an age verification ruling, you know, just a few weeks ago. Um, so I'm concerned about that testimony. And the other is, you know, I'm I'm being very frank here. When I look at your membership, it is these these companies themselves that have worked very hard and very determinately to addict our children to addict all of us to social media. And so as a general rule, I do not see how we can trust these companies to work to make sure that children are kept safe. So I think with that, uh, Mr. Chairman, I'll yield my time. Thank you. Any other questions or statements? All right. Thank you very much. And next we have David McGary, Taxpayers Protection Alliance of Virtual Testimony.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 99
And I believe we are trying to quiet the the crowd down outside. Good job. No fun of any kind. So now you know what we sounded like before. Uh is David. Hello. Okay, David. Thank you very much. Go ahead. Thank you so having me here today. My name is David McGary. I'm the research director at the taxpayers protection alliance, a nonprofit that works to inform legisl legislators and the general public about the effects of regulation. Um I should begin by stating unequivocally that protecting children in every context is a fundamental duty of the government. Um on the other hand I urge you to remember that with good intentions but without proper execution we often produce quite flawed policies with quite dangerous consequences. I think this is the fault of Senate Bill 30 and House Bill 4229. the mismatch of intentions and executions. By instituting a deacto age verification mandate, these bills would require users of all ages to offer up substantial amounts of sensitive personal data to tech platforms and thirdparty verification services, which are both vulnerable to hacks and data breaches.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 100
And this would simply be as a precondition to accessing the basic conduits of free speech online. Now, you will likely hear advocates of online age verification argue that there's an analog to offline ID checks at, say, a bar or a tobacco shop. However, uploading and memorializing a photo of government documents or scanning one's face creates far greater threats to privacy than merely flashing an ID at a brickandmortar location. It should also be noted um that the kind of data that tech companies currently collect on their users with which they sometimes estimate those users ages is far less invasive than the kind of data needed to comply with these bills. If we complain that tech companies collect too much data currently on children, we surely shouldn't advance legislation to mandate affirmatively that those same tech companies collect far more personal and far more invasive data to conduct age verification.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 101
Now, obviously endangering the privacy and data security of children and adults in Massachusetts and thereby making those data more vulnerable to identity thieves and other criminals cuts directly against the intent of these bills supporters. But these new dangers, although would be utterly foreseeable effects of these bills becoming law. Um, quickly uh to address the constitutional connections, purportedly content agnostic or contentneutral bills are not immune to first amendment scrut first amendment scrutiny. Even such bills can heavily burden the first amendment rights of both children and adults. And to by way of conclusion, um the fate that these bills would not run a foul of the first amendment is entirely unearned in my view. Vermont's recent age appropriate design code enacted last last month was referenced as a partial blueprint for the bills in question here. But just in March, California's age appropriate design code, a very similar law, was blocked by a federal court in that state.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 102
And moreover, many other age verification bills have been uh halted over the years with federal just this year. Thank you very much and I appreciate your time. Thank you. Any questions? I guess your opinion on this may be a stupid question, but as a parent, it's your responsibility to control or to provide for your child. You provide them food, clothing, the right to other access to other types of material. Why wouldn't this be part of the parental your parental obligations? Yes, sir. In fact, I think I and I agree with you entirely and that um that premise is exactly what leads to my conclusion here. I think that parents, not the government, will be far more effective in both monitoring their children's online lives and parenting their children online and keeping their children safe online um than than any standard um than than any any bill like like the one um proposed today.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 103
There are numerous um safety tools that are available for parents. Um and this goes for all levels of the technology stack. This goes from um from the network level such as on Wi-Fi networks. This goes to to the device level um the the app store level to the app and platform level. Um and we've actually seen states um we've actually seen states education programs for parents, children's and children and families to educate them better both about what tools are available and how to use them. Um, in fact, I was just recently talking to um a parent in Florida about this and Florida has had a very good experience because it turns out that the problem with many of these tools is not that they don't work, but that parents don't know how to implement them or are unaware of their existence in the first place.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 104
And the more that parents have access to these sorts of things, the more that they are actually succeeding in um monitoring their their kids online activity and in um shaping their kids online worlds in a very effective way. Okay. But since we have the issue with parental education of the parents, government does regulate that a minor can't have um alcohol. That's you have to be 21 to drink. You have to be 21 to smoke. you have to be 18 to be considered an adult. Why can't we regulate this access to this? Yes, sir. Um the there there are with respect to free speech, there are um there are first amendment limits on how far the government not the parents but the government can intrude upon um especially older older minors such as 16 17 year olds access to um to speech. But I I think the I think the other issue I would point you to here which may be more significant is the ancillary effect of the of um age verification and burdens on speech on adult speech.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 105
Um the the fact is that age verifi places burdens on everybody to verify ages. You must verify the ages of all users. Obviously you can't know who is what age until you've carried out the process. Um, and so bills such as these would require adult users to submit uh very sensitive personal information simply as a um as a precondition to getting online and engaging in basic first amendment protected activities such as finding finding news, engaging in online discourse, and um all of the other sorts of things that um that we consider to be core first amendment protected speech. Okay. Thank you. Oh, actually, we do have another question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh, I'm sorry I missed it at the beginning. Could you repeat who uh what organization you're with? I work for the Taxpayers Protection Alliance. We're a small think tank out of the DC area.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 106
Okay. And do you do you work with some of the the industry folks that are uh involved in some of these internet uh companies as well? Um I've I've had conversations with some industry folks about this about some of these issues if that's your question. Yes. Yes. So I mean I was just thinking because your first argument was related to you know the risk that's posed by uh having some of the sensitive data. Uh you know the risk that's posed related to identity theft you know to uh cyber crime that kind of thing that you mentioned. uh and you know I know it's not it's not you but sounds like you've had some of these conversations with people who who are in the know uh related to just the lack of confidence in not only their own uh internal security measures but also the third party users uh third party verification companies that they use considering not only with potential for uh measures like these but the sensitive data that those companies already have and the total lack of confidence that there seems to be in maintaining that security as is if that's a main concern going forward.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 107
Well, I I would say I I I agree generally with the with your factual with your factual portrayal. I I would say I didn't get I didn't get those I I didn't base my comments on any opinions of of of any of the industry or any of the tech companies. It's just been I mean it's been widely and publicly reported that everyone from big tech companies to third party agent ident identity verifiers um even I mean even to state state and local governments and the f and federal agencies routinely experience hacks and data breaches. Yeah. I mean that I think that just goes to show why why we need some action in this area considering all the sensitive data that's out there. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Uh next, Holly Gross hands. Yes. Hello. I'm here. Hopefully I said that right. Uh Gross hands.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 108
Yes. Thank you. We're all yours. Thank you. Good afternoon. I'm here today in support of S30 and H4229. My name is Holly Gross and I am senior counsel for tech policy at Common Sense Media. We are a nonprofit that is dedicated to improving the lives of kids and families by providing the trustworthy information, education, and independent voice that they need to thrive in the digital era. In Massachusetts alone, more than 18,000 teachers teach Common Senses materials in over,900 schools. We are known in Massachusetts for our dig digital literacy programs. Today I come to speak to you on behalf of Common Sense Media and also as the mother of school-aged children my own of my own and I care deeply about the mental health and well-being of not only my own kids but also all kids and teens like them who depend on this committee and this legislature to establish deeply needed protections for their online safety, privacy, and overall well-being.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 109
You have already heard testimony today about how teens are reporting being on social media almost constantly. Additionally, our research at Common Sense Media reveals that kids and teens are struggling to set their own boundaries when it comes to fielding the barrage of notifications they're receiving from apps on their own smartphones. The successive usage and business model meant to increase our engagement is and should be raising concerns. As you have heard, kids and teens are struggling to manage their online habits, often feeling compelled to return to addictive social media platforms due to the features specifically designed by these platforms to maximize engagement, such as these addictive feeds and notifications, which are the focus of this these bills. You have already heard through testimony today about the increasingly devastating effect on children and teens these addictive features have led to. The bottom line is that for these companies, time online equals more money, regardless of the impact on our kids.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above