2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 110
Because of the negative impacts of these intentionally addictive features, S30 and H4229 are essential to enhance online safety for Massachusetts kids and families. These bills protect minors from the harms from addictive features on social media platforms while preserving their ability to use the internet to learn, explore, and find community, which I know is one of the questions from one of the members in your committee today. Specifically, by not allowing social media companies to provide addictive feed that subvert user autonomy and keep kids booed at their devices and by preventing companies from waking kids at all hours of the night with notifications and pings. This act is essential for safeguarding our children. As you said, Madam Chair, we cannot trust these companies to keep our kids safe. The people of Massachusetts are actually depending on this committee to do that. Miss Bernstein from Epic has already eloquently addressed the response to industry claims about the First Amendment and age assurance challenges to this law.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 111
In the interest of time, I adopted her response to this issue. But lastly, I want to mention that if this act becomes law, the Bay State would be in good company. As both New York and has been pointed out, California have taken similar steps in 2024. In the absence of federal action to safeguard children online, it is critical that Massachusetts joins these other states in passing this legislation. We strongly support S30 and H4229 and ask that they be reported out favorably. And I will also be filing written testimony to supplement my testimony provided here today. Thank you for your time. Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 112
Any questions? All right. Great. Thank you very much. All right. Thank you. Next, Haley Hankley. Hingle. Hi there. Good afternoon. Thanks so much. Yeah, my name is Haley Hinkle and I am policy counsel at Fair Play. Thank you to the chairs and the committee for the opportunity to speak today. Uh Fair Play is a Bostonbased national nonprofit dedicated to children's online safety and well-being. Um, in the interest of time, um, I am going to forgo some of my, um, pre-prepared remarks and just sort of respond to some of the conversation, um, that's been going on this afternoon in reference to Bill S30 and H4229, which I'm speaking in favor of today. Um, I, uh, very much support the comments of my colleagues at Common Sense Media, Epic, MAMAS, and others who have spoken about the business model, the issues at play here, and the dire need for action.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 113
Um I just want to respond to some of the um concerns and issues that have been raised by some of the other witnesses, particularly those funded by industry. Um I really want to be clear about where this bill stands in the context of the First Amendment issues and arguments that we've been hearing on uh kids online safety legislation over the past few years. Um, age verification is not um there's no requirement in this bill that you're going to have to give over your personal data. Um, again, Miss Bernstein was um very detailed in sort of what the rulemaking process can look like for the balance between protecting privacy and and providing information. But the other thing I want to point out here is that if an adult does not want to participate in the age assurance processes that are established to be appropriate by the attorney general, the consequence here is that they won't get an algorithmic feed and they won't receive notifications from midnight to 6:00 a.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 114
So, um I really want to be very specific about what the burden and consequences really are here because I think that it is um quite measured in comparison to the enormity of the problem we are facing. The other thing I want to point out as we're talking about what kind of first amendment activity we're really pointing to here and what opportunities are really affected, kids are not automatically receiving affirming posts, um, communities on a silver platter and their feeds. They're receiving what corporate companies have decided is going to keep them online the longest, um, keep their eyeballs there and generate the most revenue. And so these feeds are not in and of themselves some kind of first amendment net positive. Um I just want to be clear about that too in terms of you know someone mentioned finding news engaging in discourse. Nothing about not receiving algorithmically recommended content affects your ability to do that online.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 115
Um you know to the contrary we know from lawsuits like those being litigated by Attorney General Campbell that these companies are choosing profit over what's beneficial to a child in their feed every single time. And so, you know, they've made infinitely clear they're not going to do the right thing on their own. And we urge Massachusetts to uh continue its great work in protecting kids online and joining the ranks of these other states that are um implementing common sense protections. And I'm happy to talk about these issues further and thank you for your time. Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 116
Any questions? Thank you very much. Uh next we have another virtual Zachary Lily. Hi there. Hello. Thanks so much. Uh co-chairs, members of the committee, thanks for the opportunity to testify. My name is Zach Lily and I'm the deputy director of state and federal affairs at Net Choice. We're a trade association dedicated to keeping the internet safe for free enterprise and free expression. I want to share some of the concerns we have about H4229 and its companion S30. While the bill uses language of addiction in order to establish a compelling state interest, at its heart, the bill is about age verification and content moderation, the goal, while well-intentioned, is to impose ownorous requirements in order to shift private content moderation practices of businesses and expression habits of private users. Both of these goals violate the First Amendment. Net Choice is actively litigating these issues at the state level.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 117
Uh, I've been sort of doing back flips for the past hour because all of the cases that have been discussed are Net Choice's own cases. Uh, just a month ago, uh, Arkansas and Ohio and and Ohio had their social media age verification bills permanently struck down by the US District Courts as unconstitutional. Uh those judges found the age verification is violative of users first amendment rights to access lawful speech and attempted content restrictions are violative as well. They represent the government deputizing private platforms to become sensors of the state. Algorithms are the way platforms can express their protected editorial discretion. Ironically, creating burdensome regulation around when algorithms could be used would be disastrous for children's online safety. Without an algorithm, you're left with a randomized feed, which would be which would greatly increase the likelihood of young people seeing developmentally inappropriate content. This bill would also prevent the promotion of new content that a user is not already familiar with.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 118
Um, you know, right, it's not always necessarily the most nefarious content. Um, so that would particularly harm the small creators and businesses and benefit the largest incumbents who are already on the platforms. We appreciate it. We're appreciative of the sponsor's intentions and agree more needs to be done to keep kids safe online, but violating platform and citizens first amendment rights isn't the way to go about it. We respectfully oppose. Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 119
Any questions? Thank you. And now the long awaited testimony from Mass Access. Come on, David. I wonder what bill you're testifying on. Take your time. Good afternoon, chairpersons and members of the committee. Just announce who you are, please. Yes. My name is Rob Chapman. I am the executive director of Bevcam and Beverly, and I also serve on the board of directors and as clerk of Mass Access. I'm here to voice a strong support for H106, H91, and S41. Bills that aren't just about funding media. They're about preserving public trust, access, and civic inclusion. Across Massachusetts, community media centers are on the front lines of democracy. We don't just film meetings. We connect residents to their schools, town halls, zoning boards, and elections. We make government visible and participation possible. But our foundation is cracking. In the past two years, WCCA TV in Worcester has lost $287,000 in cable revenue.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 120
Focus Springfield has lost over $143,000. HC Media and Haveril is down more than $116,000. And it's not just dollars, it's impact. As one director put it bluntly, we are expected to do more with less. Another added, "The continuing drop in our cable television revenue has caused us to cut staffing." Fair Haven TV said, "We've seen a steady decrease due to customers switching from cable to streaming." That's the shift that this legislation directly addresses. H106, H91, and S41 do what common sense and fairness demand. They ask streaming companies using our public's rights of way to contribute to the civic infrastructure that keeps our communities informed. These aren't taxes. They're compensation for using public assets. Just like cable companies have paid for decades. And unlike vague state level funding, these bills direct funds to peg centers where they belong. They also restore fairness over time. Winchester's media center notes that their best year with was 2017 over 438,000 in support.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 121
Today it's significantly low. H106, H91, and S41 would help restore centers like these to peak funding through a datadriven assessment set by an independent board. We are not asking for charity. We are asking for continuity for the ability to provide or to continue providing accessible nonpartisan hyperlocal coverage of government and community life. When a parent can't attend can't attend a school committee meeting, they watch it on our channel. When a senior can't leave home, we bring the town to their living room. When elections happen, we're the only place to find unbiased local information. This is what's at stake. Not just programming, but public connection. On behalf of community media centers across Massachusetts, I urge you support 1 H106, H91, and S41. Help us to keep democracy visible. Thank you for your time. I'm gonna go with the short version. David, president of Mass Access, uh, here to speak, as you probably predicted, in support of H106, H91, and S41.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 122
You may have heard the argument that this legislation, if passed, would result in a windfall for community media, more than we could possibly need. The reality though is that a recent informal study by the Department of Revenue shows that funds collected through this bill would merely make up for what we've already lost from declining cable franchise fees and would hopefully sustain funding as these fees continue to decline. This isn't about excess, it's about survival. Another perception is that this bill would burden your constituents financially. Excuse me. There is no law that I know of requiring companies to pass this cost down to consumers. And more importantly, if community media does not force change to its funding structure, the cost will shift to municipalities, placing that burden on all Massachusetts residents, not just those who utilize streaming services. Like many municipal services, community media works in the background and receives very little fanfare or notice until it's not there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 123
The entertainment industry has certainly evolved over the years. Yet, the perception that community media has never experienced growth persists. It's unfair and it's ill-informed. We're not asking to reinvent the wheel. The system exists. The work is necessary. The impact is real. This is a simple change to the law to reflect changes in technology. So, I respectfully urge you to support the passage of this act for the benefit of the people and the communities that we all serve. Thank you. Thank you, Representative. Good afternoon. Thank you for your testimony today and for the for the work that you do. um you know as as the uh as you said the cable subscribership and viewership is going down which is having an impact on your bottom line but I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of your members including uh you know a lot of our relative community u community stations have actually seen an uptick in some of their uh subscribership viewership in the various platforms because you know I can speak to at least found with Martha's Vineyard Nucket community TVs have been really innovative in the way that they reach people not just on cable but on the internet on social media and basically an all of the above approach.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 124
So I'm wondering if mass access has any uh specific numbers related to uh increase in uh access and viewership of community uh content. It's hard to say because we don't have access to any numbers on cable. We can certainly measure views uh online u but it's hard to make a comparison when you don't have data from one side of that. So um we do understand we're you know we've moved to that online presence because we're trying to meet the people where they are and make things accessible to people where they are. So, um, you know, I think all of us at this point or, you know, most of the community media centers across the Commonwealth do have some sort of online presence and offering, uh, both on demand and and social media type of video. Thank you. Sure. And just if you don't mind clar I want to just clarify that there isn't revenue on the streaming streaming side.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 125
So even though people are accessing it through streaming, they are not um there's no revenue attached to it. Sorry, Mr. I'll let it go this time. Yeah. Won't be the last. Representative. Yes. So uh a couple things. First, I want to acknowledge that I have a program on my local community access. I've had it for geez since the beginning of COVID. Um I've got a friend smiling in the background. She's the one who put me up to it in the first place all those years ago. And um and I want to say that community media is more than just filling the holes left by the gap in local media. And it's more than just ex adding transparency and accessibility for the public with respect to local government. It's also a whole bunch of other really important programming that is nothing to do with either one of those things, but still adds values to the community.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 126
And I want to say that out loud because I know the advocates are trying to find the strongest arguments, but there are other arguments that they ought to be making as well. In my opinion, uh we've got great programming that is just fun. We have great programming that's artistic. We have great programming where people of all ages are learning the technical skills on putting together the programming, right? All of that's also important. I want to say that out loud because um that hasn't been said yet. Maybe I've taken somebody else's thunder. apologize, but I feel like everybody's really been stuck on these these two facts. Um, well, I wanted to say it louder. Um, and I I also think it's the case uh I don't want to speak for anyone but myself, but my hunch is everyone on this committee values community media and recognizes the decline in revenue and wants to find a replacement.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 127
I say all of that because the question uh at least in my mind I think and some others is whether or not that revenue should come from streaming services or from some other place, right? And I say that because um you know the focus has been on why this is important and and keep saying it until everybody agrees. But I think the people on this side of the room do agree, right? I think we need to think carefully about what the right source of that revenue is. For example, instead of streaming, what if we tax the ISPs themselves, right? If I don't have any streaming services because I watch it all on YouTube for free and I watch my Brookline Interactive Group programs on YouTube for free, I'm not generating any of that revenue even though I am actually consuming those services because I'm using the internet, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 128
whereas someone else might have six streaming services because you know they got to have the Disney Plus and they got to have the Max now called HBO Max again as of today I think right and they got to have the Hulu and they got to have Right. Um, so, so my point is simply that I think it would be healthy for us to talk about different opportunities for revenue rather than be stuck on streaming because I think there are there's an interesting conversation to be had about different sourc and my guess is most of the folks here if we told them we're just going to write you a check from the legislature every year y'all would be like thanks and go home you it's not that you want to tax streaming you want the money right so let's have a conversation about where the money should come from.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-07-10 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube An Act to modernize funding for community media programming · passage 129
It doesn't need to come from streaming. It could come from somewhere else. And I think that would be a conversation that I would like to have. Um it to to a to actually ask a question. Am I correct in saying that if you guys were just getting a check with the money on it, you'd be perfectly happy like do you need to tax streaming? That's a difficult question to to answer frankly because you know we are looking for something that's sustainable and not fight for every single year and you know it is very much appreciated that go into alter any any revenue but um what we're trying to do is really to create that future and it's not just the streaming services now it's what happens after that you know what becomes the next so the big flaw with the federal funding is that they wrote all of this legislation under the cable and from day one those cable companies have been trying to sh and municipalities have been keeping some of the money for themselves instead of passing it along like mine for example not to name names well that's that's that is their uh that is their right to do so yeah thank you questions or statements I have a question Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above