All right. I just want don't I don't want to lose control of you guys. Um so not to throw a shot but unlike our colleagues in Washington, we're not trying to defund public access. So appreciate Thank you very much. Thank you. Elizabeth Dion. Good afternoon. I am Elizabeth Dion, member of the Belmont Select Board, which unanimously supports S41 and H91. I'm joined by Jeff Hanzel, executive director of the Belmont Media Center. Belmont's 27,000 residents rely heavily on the Belmont Media Center or BMC to provide access to their local government. Our town meeting has 300 members. We also have numerous town committees with another 300 plus volunteers. BMC is the media and communications hub for our government, schools, civic organizations, businesses, and the public. It is also a town technology hub, managing and maintaining all of the equipment used to broadcast various meetings, most notably town meeting.
BMC is scrappy. Despite the reduction in table cable TV franchise fees, it has expanded services through innovation, fundraising, and community volunteers. Three days ago, my colleagues and I approved an agreement to move BMC operations into our new public library, again, reducing BMC's annual expenses. But we need this bill to ensure BMC's long-term viability. Cable TV companies pay a franchise fee to our towns to rent or use our public rights of way and telecommunications infrastructure, and those fees come back to our towns to sustain community media centers. However, our laws and regulations have not kept pace with the evolving market for content delivery. We hear of people cutting the cord, but that's not really what's happening. Many of us use streaming services such as Netflix, Hulu, or Amazon Prime. These streaming companies are using the same public infrastructure and they are using it for free. That is not fair and it degrades local government's ability to communicate with our constituents.
Belmont's operating budget is tight. Despite despite passing an $ 8.4 million operating override last year, we continue to cut town staff. We don't have the money to cover lost franchise fees. Is this bill a new tax on consumers? In my opinion, it is a usage fee for public rights of way. It is a cost of doing business in our state just as franchise fees are. What about the threats to raise rates on Massachusetts customers? First, streaming services will raise their subscription rates to the level the market will support regardless of this bill, which adds a small fraction to their cost of doing business. Second, this bill is good public policy. It fixes an issue which Congress has yet to address, leveling the playing field between streaming services and cable TV providers, charging them both for use of public telecommunications infrastructure. Finally, it is poor public relations to threaten customers over a small usage fee.
If streaming services provide me with high quality content, I will continue to pay for their services. This bill is an efficient and elegant solution that tackles the pro problem it is intended to solve directly supporting community media centers across the Commonwealth. I strongly encourage you to support this bill. Thank you. Thank you. Window dress are going to talk. [Laughter] You're more than welcome to speak if you like. Jeff Hansel. the executive director of the Belmont Media Center. And I only bring this up because uh it just came up this week in our community. In light of the tragedy in Texas and that we're in hurricane season, we've just started an initiative now just to show you what you can do with this technology to create an additional Belmont public safety information network that's going to address emergency management communications using all the technology we already have.
combining that those resources to provide something that the town needs and at no additional cost and we're doing all that um you know under the current uh regime. Thank you. Thank you for your input. Just a quick comment, Mr. Chairman. Um so thank you for coming um as a select board member uh in particular and because I'm seeing that there's not a lot of you here on this list, I'm going to address this to you. A missing voice in this is support from the MMA. And I guess I would charge you since you're the one that showed up here um with gardenering more support about that because they're pretty wishy-washy about it and I think that would make a difference. I did not know that. That is very useful information. I happen to sit on the board of WEIMO women elected offic M municipal officials of mass of uh and we're a subset of the MMA and I will take that back to uh my colleagues.
Thank you. Any questions? We have one more. I'm gonna uh just take the privilege and this this pains me as a as a Watertown resident to say, but I have to say Belmont Media Center has done great work. Um here and you forgot to say that you were and I didn't realize you're moving to the to the new library, which looks fantastic. Uh as we drive by, it looks like it's going to be fantastic. But um uh a great meeting space, community meeting space and a resource beyond just the the work that you guys do, you know, behind the camera and in front of the camera. Um, but having that space as a as a resource for the community has been uh something that even across the across Belmont Street I I I I have taken note of. So, thank you for the work that you do and I apologize for not asking a question.
Thank you for your statement. Thank you very much. Um, next we have Peta Padulla, Town of Chelmsford. Oh, virtual. Yeah, virtual. Can you hear me? Okay. Yes, I'm Pete Padulla. I'm the um executive director of Chumsford Teleia. We're the public access center in Chumsford, Mass. You heard from our Senator Barrett, at the head of this meeting. And you also heard from one of our reps, Jim Rciero, who both spoke in support of an act to modernize funding for community media programming, which is no surprise. I am asking a favorable review from you all as well. Um, I'm not going to repeat a lot of you've heard a lot of my colleagues and other people have testified about all the good things that u our centers do around the state and I agree with all of that. I'm just going to single out two two things that um haven't gotten quite as much attention that that in Chsford we can talk about that we do.
One was hit upon by representative Mosschino and also representative Vitomo and um that is that um in Chsford we have what we like to think of as like a vocational training program. We run a afterchool program for at the high school called uh CHS TV. So that that does provide content. It provides all the concerts and and and those types of things that people love. But what's more important about that is that that is staffed by students and uh they learn a ton of skill um a lot of skills in in working together to create these live productions. But what I'd like to um emphasize is that um I just have a short list of students that have come through our program and the jobs that they now hold to today. So I'll just give you their titles. One is senior technical lead in global production at Apple Music.
One is a broadcast engineer at WCBB Channel 5 in Boston. Another is an engineer in charge at Game Creek Video. If you don't know, they make the trucks that go to the Garden, NFL, all these sporting events, the the mobile production units, which we have we have one that they trained on that that that that woman trained on. Head of arena operations at Bentley University. That's all the video boards and stuff for the sporting events. And we also um you know uh these kids work together and they learn all the communication skills. So one of our alumni is also the he the chief of communications and interoperability in the state of New Hampshire emergency services. A lot of that skills that that he got was you know all the communications that go into a live video productions whether it's a sporting event or others. So, um, I just wanted to point that out because I do think it's it's, you know, we've seen in Champsford 22% loss in funding.
And so, you know, if we were to cut out this TV program, it would just it would kind of cut my heart out to have to do that. So, thank you for your support and uh, thanks for listening. I hope you give it a favorful recommendation. Any other questions? Okay. Thank you. So by uh temporary power granted to me today by the the gavl I'm going to create a panel unbeknownst to them. Uh Sean sir who is going to be virtual and we're going to have Sam Pasqual from Pit both of Pittsfield and I'm hoping you are of the same opinion. So if you want to come up and testify and if virtually if if if Sean wants to come on virtually. We're we're actually advocating for two different bills. Oh two. Okay. So I don't know if go for it. Okay. Um so Sean first.
Yep. Okay. Uh good afternoon. Um Chair Farley Bouvier, Chair Moore, and honorable members of the joint committee. My name is Sean S. I'm the executive director of Pittsfield Community Television. Pittsfield, close enough to hit New York State with a rock, and occasionally we like to do that, especially when we have to spend 5 hours and 20 minutes on the turnpike getting to the state house or a Red Sox game. I think you can identify. Uh, thanks for this opportunity to give testimony in favor of House Bill 106, House Bill 91, Senate Bill 41, an act to modernize funding for community media programming. I last testified to this committee two years ago in support of a similar bill. In only two years since that testimony, we have lost 12.4% of our cable revenue due to cable cord cutting. For this, this equal for us, this equals $87,529.
The losses are accelerating and the pain is here now. Because of this, we had to eliminate one full-time employee out of seven on our staff. Uh that's while inflation is increasing our expenses, health insurance costs are going up 12 to 14% per year and employees still need cost of living raises to pay their own bills. We simply can't keep up with this. And I'm hearing from other centers across the state that they are downsizing, closing buildings, selling off equipment. We are not there yet, but at some point soon we will need to evaluate what we will cut next. Will it be our building? Lose more staff? What services will we have to stop providing? Something here is going to have to break. It's important to remember that our current funding model in place for nearly 40 years has allowed us to provide the community with local programming and services without requiring any city funding from Pittsfield.
It's built on the fair principle that a company using the public's right of way should compensate the public for this use. And now that streaming has overtaken cable as the mo the way that most people get their information and entertainment, something that we've also participated in as well, I ask that you take this step now to modernize the way these local services are provided and funded. It must be done at the state level. Going forward, without modernizing the funding, cities and towns will be faced with a hard choice. Either pay for it with taxpayer funds or lose the services entirely. And this will lead to what I believe is a very uneven and inequitable distribution of local information where wealthy communities will be able to afford to pay for it and poorer and rural communities will be without it. We've been creative with our own fundraising efforts trying to make up for these cable losses.
Uh but we can't bake sail our way out of this. At some point there needs to be a predictable and reliable method to fund our local programming, the impact of which is felt right here in Pittsfield. And doing some quick math, it's obvious to me that the revenue generated from streaming won't fully replace the cable revenue. Not even close really, but it will be one tool uh that we can use to stay in business and be true to our mission. But I ask for your support on behalf of our organization and our Pittsfield community. And thank you. Okay. Thank you.
And stand by until after the next testimony in case there's any questions. Robert, my name is Samuel Pasqual. I'm the digital navigator at Pittsfield Community Television and um thank you so much uh Representative Provier and I'm sorry for the five hour ride. Um we're I'm actually here on a different bill for uh H100 for uh digital navigator uh digital navigator credentiing. Um, but I am housed at Pensfield Community Television and again highlighting the great amount of resources that media centers can provide. Um but I I'm here to speak about credentiing because uh as as I have worked in the past five years as a digital navigator in my community, I have a lot of trust um in being able to uh provide all kinds of services to my community where technology is confusing. Um, I worked in my comm in my church to be able to help anyone who needs help with their technology.
And now I'm at Pittsville Community Television doing the same. Um, offering digital skills classes, uh, providing people with devices, uh, helping people navigate what are affordable internet connection um, uh, options, whether it's cellular or home internet. Um, but I come I'm lucky enough to come from a uh place of trust. I came from my church and I also have a background as a certified ethical hacker. I worked in government um pentesting government uh you know companies and I have a lot of trust within banks having worked uh to provide the security training for staff. Um, but there isn't currently a lot of credentiing for people doing the digital equity work that has been widespread all over the country. And I think that it's really important that we have more uh people that are um credentialed for this and and this commission that is going to be created under um H100 would help create that um that framework for creating uh credentiing for digital navigators.
And um I think that uh the work that we do with being able to dispel a lot of misinformation um that can be you know a lot of the bills that we that you guys are um currently reviewing regard a lot of uh safety online and a lot of that involves things with misinformation with AI and I currently work a lot with the sheriff's department with um the district attorneys retail retail crimes department to help uh spread information about how to limit um scams. But overall, you know, the the information, the importance of this work is that we are able to um provide uh a career path for more people to do my work because I'm uh one person in the county, but I've often heard that I wish there was more of you helping out my grandma or or and this is a very timely and important bill.
um tomorrow could be your grandma that gets scammed for $10,000. It it it's not something that is a theoretical threat. It's something that needs to be done now and there needs to be more of a a career path for people interested in going into digital navigation. Thank you.
Any questions? Okay, thank you both. Thank you both. Really appreciate it. Uh next Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Sabadosa. Thank you so much, Chair Moore, Chair Farley Bouvier, particularly for taking me out of turn. I can be very brief because it sounds like you've heard excellent testimony already uh about the bill that I wanted to talk about today, which is um H100, an act establishing a commission to study a statewide credentiing program for digital navigators. Um, I know that you have amazing teams and they've already told you what the bill does in full. Um, but I just I I want to to stress a few things. I mean, first of all, we are at a moment where the federal government has pulled away a tremendous amount of funding for digital equity. The creation of this commission does not restore that funding. Um, but it does look for ways that the state can try to step up to to figure out how we continue to implement our digital digital equity uh roadmap that I think we we want to do that the digital navigators who've spoken today have underlined the importance of um and it um will help us figure out both how how do we fund people?
How do we work on getting a credentiing roadmap? What does that need to look like? And it feels like I I think at this point a very small lift with again just a commission of people together talking about how we move forward. Um I've come to this work because I have seen firsthand in my district the need for people to have someone to give them a little bit of help in figuring out how to navigate technology. And I hope that this committee, which is really a very lovely, friendly committee, um will see that same importance to this issue and and help move this bill forward for us.