So, I'm very happy to answer any questions, but I I do want to let the digital navigators do the talking for me. Thank you. Any questions, Vice Chair Hawkins? They they actually met with me before the hearing, which is good because I'm I need a slow description to understand it. We've had briefings and we were happy to talk to you again. Well, no, the things that struck me is I'm thinking of a lot of health care now for elderly people is done electronically. You got to have your vitals checked a couple times a day and of course the other things that the other gentleman from Pittsfield talked about but also this could have been in a couple different couple different committees. It could have been in it could have been in so many but it ended up in the good one. Um but it seems to me compared to some of the other issues we have with licensing uh with being access to third party payment to a lot of things.
This is a much lower bar and to create a committee. I'm not generally in favor of committee. That means it's not going to happen for a while. But to come up with a workable description seems important because you're going to be looking for grant funding. You're going to be looking for funding in a bunch of different places to support what's what we understand is a very important role. But I I think in this case a committee would be good to to get it right. So thank you. Thank you for your work on this and I appreciate the comments. I I think you know the legislature often gets criticized. We put together commissions. But I think that in this case, if you look at the composition of the commission, we've been really thoughtful about who's to be included. And that speaks to putting together a commission to do work, not to just write a report that sits on a shelf.
We want the if the federal government is going to leave this work aside for the moment, the state of Massachusetts can and should step up. And I think there are other states that are similarly interested in doing that as well. So, we should have good partners. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. Next, Alexander Lamach. Who was in person? Can everyone hear me? Guess who went to virtual? I am virtual. My apologies. I could not make it to the state house um this afternoon um due to a couple of uh meetings we to cover today. Okay. But to the honorable matter, members of the joint committee, uh, thank you for taking time to hear my testimony. My name is Alex Martian. I am the director of Hley Media, which is community media center as municip ran by the town of Halley and the 5,000 plus agricultural community.
Uh, today I'm urging you to favorably pass um H106, H91, and S41 and act to modernize funding for community media programming. We currently cover 15 plus municipal force committees, arts and culture programming, news business thought life's hob academy sports and amongst other things. We have just finished drafting a municipal digital equity plan for the Massachusetts Broadway Institute which we will help guide us into bridging the town's digital divide and improve many lives in town. Um because we are municipal department of town, we run a bit differently. Um, just like our nonprofit neighbors, we see franchise fees from the cable company. But when it comes to taking in donations or wanting to monetize our YouTube channel, uh, we simply can't because of legalities and um, mitigating any potential risk that could harm the town legally. U, we are strapped to our, uh, cable franchise fees, which which will dwindle our subscribers to cut the cord.
Next year, I predict our new subscribers to pass 1,000 and our cable subscribers will dip below 1,000. That's half of all dogs in the town of Halfway. Not to mention that our cable provider, Charter Spectrum, is not offering cable to new subscribers or subscribers who want to upgrade. If you go to their website and you click on cable TV, um you'll get more streaming options or actually only streaming options on their website. So, we will not have a chance for new subscribers to help help with our bottom line. We need help to continue the important work that we do and we need it now. We only have enough funding to last us until half of fiscal year 2028 for a small station be robust. The comm the community appreciates our work and I'm sure our community would be devastated to see this local institution go black.
Hadley Hadley is a proud agricultural community. I'm sure we bought produce from time to time now it's grown in Hadley without knowing. Some of our produce is sold to Boston public schools and Springfield public schools which help many lowincome families through generous state and federal programs. Well, more state now. Um, I'm sure many don't worry about knowing where bare produce comes from. However, we have to worry about where our community media how long our community media centers have have to survive and what revenue we're going to get. I urge the joint committee to vote these bills out of committee favorably. Do this for our livelihoods. Do this for our communities. Do this for the greater good.
I want to thank the joint committee for taking time to hear my testimony and feel free to ask any questions about about my operation. Thank you. Any questions? Thank you. Safe. Thank you. Thank you. Um next we have representatives from Westwood Media Center Urban Media Arts and Westford Community Access Television. So please introduce yourselves as you speak. Good afternoon. My name is Sarah Fletcher and I'm the executive director of Westford's Community Access Television Station and it's um a pleasure to be here. Thank you. Thank you for Um, we are facing an economic emergency. The 250 Massachusetts community media stations um are collapsing. This is a $104 million industry employing over a thousand residents. The cable subscriptions have crashed 50% in five years, destroying the funding that sustained 269 community media stations across every district that you represent. We're watching the systematic elimination of businesses averaging over $417,000 in annual expenses and nine about nine employees at each station averaging.
This isn't just about media. It's about economic devastation rippling through every community. The economic domino domino effect when stations close is that skilled workers lose their jobs. Local equipment vendors lose hundreds of thousands in sales. Professional service providers, the CPAs, contractors, maintenance workers, they lose steady clients. Property owners lose reliable tenants and communities lose their economic anchors. The reality is we're losing everything. Right now, camera operators in Springfield are job hunting. Producers in Actton are looking out of state. Equipment suppliers in Worcester are watching their customer base evaporate. And these are your constituents. And they're losing their livelihoods. They're disappearing. Massachusetts built the nation's largest community media network. 269 stations that were economic success stories. Now we're systematically destroying this achievement through inaction. H91 and S41 are our last chance. These bills aren't about new revenue. They're about preventing economic catastrophe. They represent the only viable path to restore stable revenue streams before we lose this industry forever.
Without this legislation, over a thousand jobs disappear permanently. $104 million uh economic activity vanishes. Decades of workforce development gets destroyed. Local economies lose critical anchors. The choice is binary. We can act now to save a thousand jobs and over 104 million dollars in economic activity, or we can watch it all disappear forever. The businesses that use our public infrastructure to reach Massachusetts consumers must pay their fair share, not as a windfall, but as the economic lifeline determining whether this industry survives or dies. Every day without action brings us closer to permanent loss. Please vote yes on H91 S41. Don't let Massachusetts throw away $104 million in economic activity because we failed to modernize outdated funding models. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, chairs and thank you chairs and members of the committee. My name is Tina Lagard. I'm the executive director of urban media arts in Malden.
Uma is Malden's community media center with vital civic resource offering access to technology, creative tools, and educational opportunities for community members of all ages and backgrounds. And we've been proudly serving our community for over 30 years. But today, I'm here to tell you our model is breaking. Uma's cable franchise revenue dropped 23% in just the last three years alone. The impact of cord cutting isn't hypothetical. It's a financial crisis that's already here and it's dismantling the infrastructure of community media. Just last month, I was forced to make one of the hardest decisions of my career. I eliminated three full-time staff members at my facility. We lost our associate director, a 34-year veteran who helped build Ruma from the ground up, launched our art gallery, creating a decadel long citizen journalism program and partnership, excuse me, with our community and local colleges and trained hundreds in community storytellers and served as our accessibility coordinator.
We lost our director of operations, who served for 25 years, maintaining our equipment and facilities, producing thousands of hours of civic coverage, launching our podcast services, and building a bridge with our gaming community. And we also lost our director of marketing, who led our digital presence, built a citywide event calendar initiative, and created inclusive pathways to engagement for communities often left out of traditional media media narratives. Together, these cuts saved us $230,000 annually. But at what cost? Their responsibilities now fall on just three remaining f full-time staff and one part-timer. We kept the lights on this year, but without structural funding reform, we might not be able to continue doing it. Despite aggressive fundraising and development efforts, grants, sponsorships, donor campaigns, it's simply not enough to close the growing deficit caused by declining cable revenue. That's why we need your support on bills H106, H91, and S41.
They aren't just policy ideas. They're a lifeline. These bills would modernize funding for community media in the streaming era, recognizing that local access, civic transparency, and digital inclusion must not be lost to outdated funding models. Uma's story is not unique, but we want to be part of a better future. We want to continue being Malden's hub for creativity, dialogue, and democracy. Please pass these bills favorably and help us ensure that community media doesn't disappear with a cable cord. Thank you, chairpersons, members of the community. My name is Melinda Garfield and I serve as the executive director of Westwood Media Center for the past 10 years. I'm also a member of Mass Access Board. I submit this testimony in strong support of H106, H91, and S41. Westwood Media Center is a nonprofit PEG organization that serves the town of Westwood since 2007. While we may be a younger organization that uh some of than some of our counterparts shortly that had uh established shortly after the cable act of 84, we became an essential provider of local government meeting coverage, high school sports, community events, and educational training in video and digital media production.
Despite efforts to diversify revenue through production services, facility rental, sponsorships, and donations, our funding continues to decline at an alarming rate due to the drop of cable subscriptions. Over the past 5 years, Westwood has lost 1,277 cable subscribers. In fact, our current subscriber count is now lower than it was when Comcast and Verizon first entered the town in 2007. This decline has translated into nearly $60,000 reduction in our operating budget. As of July 1, just a few days ago, Westwood Media Center can no longer afford to maintain our studio and our office space due to this budget shortfall. We are currently without a permanent facility. Our live meeting, municipal meetings are now being produced from a 300 square foot former jail cell in the basement of town hall and our reduced staff is operating remotely. As we approach the busy fall season, I am deeply concerned about our ability to continue delivering the highquality services our community relies on and deserves.
On behalf of the staff, board, and residents of Westwood, I respectfully urge this committee to report these bills favorably. And Westwood Media Center is not alone. Peg centers across the Commonwealth are facing similar financial challenges and the time to modernize the funding structure is now. Thank you. Questions. Thank you. Your testimony is really compelling. Thank you for being here. Uh next is virtual Seth Albomb. All right. Uh, good afternoon honorable members of the joint committee. Uh, thank you for your time. I'm Seth Albam, executive director of the awardwinning Lynn Community Television. Lynn is a diverse gateway city of over a 100,000 people, many of whom cannot afford cable. And like Pittsfield, we're at a precedence. there's been a very sharp decline in cable subscriptions in our city and therefore franchise agreement funds that are allocated to us. Um so our mission at LCTV however remains to connect residents with city government, nonprofits and the arts and to offer digital equity in an economically diverse city.
But with the steep revenue decline and a very lean budget, we can no longer afford rent. We're currently located in a very accessible storefront in a downtown shopping plaza. The rent has gone up too. It's way too high. So, we're searching for a new space in a city where accessible and suitable locations are scarce. At the same time, we're digging into limited reserves to keep going. Reserves we also need to pay for the move. We're cutting back. One full-time staffer moved away, so that made things a little easier. We didn't refill the role. Another has gone part-time. Weekday hours at the studio are reduced so that we can still cover essential community events. And the deadline to find a new location is fast approaching. We could very much um we could I don't know what we'd operate out of. Um we haven't been offered a space by anyone.
If we find a space, we'll likely cut our square footage in half and end up in a less successful part of Glenn as well. Still, I want to say in 2024, our members produced 323 shows and episodes in Spanish and English. Staff covered 141 community events for LCTV News, award-winning LCTV News, I should say, and we covered 28 municipal meetings. And that was while we operated at a $63,000 deficit. F FY25 no better. FY26 looks worse. The rain is outlasting the rainy day fund and it's raining harder. We've kept up with our audiences. Twothirds of our viewers watch on their phones. They're streaming city council streaming school committee on YouTube, Facebook, andv.org. There are three ways to watch us online simultaneously. Our website translates content into 12 languages and carries programming in Spanish, English, Haitian, Creole, and Kami. Our LCTV News local election coverage is already underway for the September preliminary and November election.
And it's there there's no no other. We have a daily newspaper, but it's getting thinner and thinner. That is how people find out their information. We host candidate forums ourselves. Our technology has outpaced the cell phone. Our cameras record in 4K. Our studio hosts podcasts, film screenings, and events. And we have a computer lab with robust broadband. And with a limited use grant, we launched the bilingual digital literacy program that teaches computer skills and loans out Chromebooks. But that grant doesn't fund our rent, government meeting coverage or access to the audiovisisual production tools that create modern digital equity. Municipalities haven't closed the funding gap and they can't. Foundations aren't supporting community media and I don't know why. Sponsorships are trickle despite our best efforts. Now we need support that reflects today's media reality. and we've modernized here at LCTV. Seth, I'm going to have to ask you to hurry up.
Sorry. Thank you. Um, we ask for your support on H91, H106, and S41 so that we may continue. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions? No. Thank you very much. Um and next we have a panel um from Pittsburgh Access Television and Focus Springfield. So just like just announce who you are when you speak. Thank you. Thank you for having us. Uh, I'm Stephen Carrie from Focus Springfield TV in support of H106, 91, and S41. I feel like I'm on Sesame Street when I say I'm here for the letter G. In PEG, it stands for government. Uh, we don't have a long history. Focus Springfield has been around for 10 years. Uh, but we made up for lost time. Initially, we were known for our coverage of sports, uh, especially basketball. a little plug for the invention in Springfield. Um, since March of 2020, however, we're known for municipal meeting coverage back when Zoom was new.
Uh, they were scary days in 2020. We quickly realized that our city couldn't function if commissions, councils, and other open meeting laws waited it out. Uh, Focus Springfield worked with elected officials to meet or exceed OML requirements. In the past year, we've aired over 1,600 hours of government meetings. When we began in uh 2014, I looked around and noticed most of the equipment was the same as when I was an intern in the 80s. Uh the locks were to keep the uh museum curators out. Um we started visiting established peg stations and that convinced us that we needed to invest heavily in technology. We're all geeks. I could talk to you all day about the equipment. I promise I won't. Um, in December 2020, uh, we realized how lucky we were that we invested. Um, Springfield Public Schools wanted us to air a town hall and people are concerned about learning loss.
Um, fears are returning to the classrooms. There's a lot of bad information and rumors around the city. The school department provided experts to share vetted information and have real Q&A um time for real time Q&A to address additional concerns from families. We're a diverse city. Uh we've got about 40,000 students. Um the effort was uh to broadcast in eight languages and frankly we were scared to death. We didn't know how to do it. Uh we pulled it off and um it started something really big. Schools established support groups. They had interpreters work with families. Homework health tips were delivered to homes. By the end of that school year, over a million meals were served to homes. The engagement continues today. In the five years since those interpreters are able to be replaced by this great kind of system of subtitles, shout out to State House News.