Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
Um I tell this story because engaging with these families was probably the most rewarding thing I've done in 40 years of television. remote participation, live um translations, they're all here to stay. Um the AI advancements in technology is absolutely amazing, but it's not cheap. In 2014, our annual budget was $1.2 million. We're down to about 550,000 now. I'm not asking you to vote in favor of this bill for me or for Focus Springfield. Um and really for for all of us, a way to look at it is um good government engagement in cities. uh towns like Springfield have to continue. We don't know what the future holds or how we need to communicate with our residents. And 10 more seconds, I promise. Whether covering legislation, following a basketball team to state championships, um or battling a pandemic, it's all important work, especially while uh local news is just waning.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, I'm asking you to support it, not because it's nice, but I think it's necessary. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, good afternoon, co-chairs Farley Bouvier, uh, Moore, and joint committee members. Uh, my name is Nathan Glenny, executive director of Fitchburg Access Television, which took 90 minutes. I'm sorry, uh, to get here today in Boston. Um, I am here to support H106, H91, and S41. Since 1987, FATV provides our 42,000 residents with a direct media connection uh, to our community. In 2020, we tripled the hours of hyperlocal community programming and featured nearly 700 hours of media content in 2024. But since 2016, Fitchburg has seen a 40% linear decrease of cable franchise fees to what is now a quarter of a million dollars less than what we had a decade ago. Um, FATV does not receive general funds from the city of Fitchburg. uh nor would that even be feasible.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Our gateway city is already faced with inflation and growing needs, including all those lovely potholes. Um in FY27, the city will likely will have to have tough talks of budget cuts. They're not going to add a another line item for PEG services uh to their general fund. We urgently need your advocacy to support this bill. Otherwise vital PEG services will be facing cuts and will provide less information to the communities that we all proudly serve. Peg services should be viewed as a public necessity as well as a foundational right towards democracy. We broadcast over 300 annual hours from 20 different legislative bodies. Uh FATV secures facilitates a secure remote participation option for Fitsburg constituents. We also provide real-time closed captioning in English and Spanish to foster an inclusive yet informative community. This is a true testament on how transparent municipal governments should operate for greater civic participation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
FATV has now become the only reliable and trusted source for local municipal meetings, debates, elections that are coming up this fall, and its results that we produce in 75 minutes from polls closing. These connections to our residents is an integral part of an informed and democratic election process. If a funding solution isn't realized soon, community media stations will close and that's a fact. And oh, by the way, the local newspapers who watch us to report upon it, it's going to be even more of news deserts. Um, in closing, I urgently request this committee's swift and favorable recommendation of these bills. We should assure the residents of the Commonwealth that we want you to be informed, connected, and included in a civic in civic pride and participation. This bill makes sense for Massachusetts residents and why we need to get this bill across the finish line.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Thank you for your time today and I would be happy to answer any questions. Thank you. Uh Sandra Harris, Massachusetts Coalition to Build Community and End Loneliness. Very nice to see you again, Chair Moore, Chair Arvier, and members of the joint committee. My name is Sandre Harris and I am the co-founder and co-leader of the Massachusetts Coalition to Build Community and End Loneliness, a statewide network working to ensure that all residents of the Commonwealth feel connected to their community and enjoy a strong sense of social health. I am also host to connect a monthly community media program which is soon to enter its fourth year and I am here to urge you to favorably pass bill number Senate bill number 41 and house bill number 91 and act to modernize funding for community media programming. Connect was created to tackle the isolation and lack of lack of accessible information we observed during the early days of CO 19 especially among older adults, people living in rural areas and those who just cannot afford community or cable television.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We were especially worried about the poor digital outreach such as online only access to vaccine appointments that excluded many individuals without internet access devices or digital literacy. In a society rapidly becoming digital, we must ensure that no one is left behind. Community television helps to bridge that gap. It connects with people who are often unseen by mainstream media, those who are relying um on community television for trustworthy local information. Former US surgeon general Dr. Vbec Murthy described us as a lonely nation. And just last month, the World Health Organization Commissioned on Social Health issued a landmark report identifying loneliness as a global public health priority and calling on all of us to take action now to help build a more connected world. Members of the joint committee, I am proud to say that Massachusetts is already responding to that call. Community media programming has been a vital partner of the Massachusetts Coalition to build community and loneliness and making this happen.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Connect offers more than just background entertainment. It foster fosters real connection. We highlight resources, share strategies to combat loneliness, offer tips for healthier and happier living, and provide information and resources for living with Alzheimer's and related dementia. We encourage neighbors to check on one another. We offer strategic um methods or roles for managing the holiday and winter blues. But most importantly, we offer hope from caregivers to young people. We promote the power of intergener relationships. This partnership doesn't just inform, it uplifts. It includes, it heals, and it connects. Please modernize funding for media programming. In doing so, you help to invest in public health and equity and in the kind of the Commonwealth where everyone is seen, valued, and recognized. Let's answer the call. Let's show the world what Massachusetts can do to ensure that no resident feels invisible or alone in the neighborhood they call home.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Thank you for your time, for your service, and your support, and thank you for taking positive action to modernize funding for community programming. Thank you. Any questions? Mr. Chair, I just really want to thank Sandra for your work. I think your work is incredibly important and it brings a new and different voice um to this issue and it's very valuable. So, thank you for being here. Thank you. Okay. Um our next is a virtual Nell Forax, League of Women Voters. Good afternoon. I'm Nell Forgus, legislative specialist for the League of Women Voters of Massachusetts. I'm also a resident of Sudbury and a big fan of Sudbury TV. I would like to thank Chair Moore, Chair Fi Bouvier, and the honorable members of this committee for the opportunity to speak today on behalf of the league and our 44 local leagues serving over 100 communities from Cape Cod to the Birkers in support of H91S41, an act to modernize community media funding.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
The league believes it is of the highest priority that we secure the funding future. Emphasis on secure of our local community access stations. Many speakers today including representatives Machino and Scarsdale, members of this committee and officers from Mass Access have noted the positive impact of these stations in our communities. The league concurs with the many important points that previous speakers have made. The League of Women Voters believes that democratic government and a healthy democracy depends upon the informed and active participation of its citizens at all levels of government and that governmental bodies must protect the citizens right to know. Your constituents rely on their local community access stations to stay informed and to participate in their local government. No one, not even those who work in local government, can attend every meeting in person, especially given that many meetings are scheduled at the same time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Massachusetts municipalities rely on community access stations to broadcast, stream, record, and preserve town meetings, town forums, public hearings, and innumerable board, committee, subcommittee, commission, and council meetings for the public. Your constituents also rely on the leagues of women voters around the state and their partnerships with their local community access stations. Together, we produce and make widely available programs that support an active and informed electorate. Lead programs consistently rank among community media stations highest watched video ondemand programming. Community media programming is integral to informed and active participation in local government, but will not survive unless the way in which we fund it is updated. We all heard the emotion of the previous speakers whose stations are collapsing. The league believes that passage of this bill is an urgent and intelligent investment in the future of our democracy. As Representative Machino asserted, funding has hit a critical tipping point, and this bill is timely, relevant, and ready.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Demand for services are up, but funding is down. We urge you to pass this bill swiftly and favorably before it is too late and stations begin to not just downsize, but to close.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I'd be happy to answer any questions. Thank you so much. Now, any questions from the members of the committee? Thank you. And thank you to the league for your strong partnership on data privacy and all things good government. We really appreciate it. Thank you. Terrific. Um, we now go to Stephanie Sarah from NCTV and I don't know if Bobby is part of that panel also. Stephanie, hello everyone. Hello Stephanie. Hi there. My name is Steph Sarah and I'm the director of programming and grant writer at Nantucket Community Television. Um I am testifying in support of House Bill 106, House Bill 91, and Senate Bill 41 from home today with my three-year-old nearby. So if you hear a growing voice offcreen, that's just part of the reality. So many of us are living. Um Nantucket Community Television serves as one of the most um we serve one of the most remote communities in the Commonwealth.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
um on Nantucket, an island 30 miles out to sea, community connection is not just a convenience. Um public media access is essential to our well-being, our democracy, and our sense of belonging. I imagine that being on the receiving end of our individual testimonies and support of these bills, um you know, it might begin to blend together. Um but that's the power of independent voices. When layered, they form something greater, a multifaceted perspective that becomes a unified call for what our communities need. At NCTV, our mission is to empower Nantucket Voices. We create original programming that supports mental health, intergenerational connection, civic participation, and community identity. Our programs champion the power of creative expression, especially in today's climate. We are the Nantucket platform for teenagers finding their voice. We preserve elder wisdom through oral history traditions and children's programming. We bring meetings, celebrations, workshops, high school sports broadcasting filmed by and featuring students to those who can't always be in the room.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um, NCTV is a small but mighty team and what makes us essential is the trust we have earned from our community to serve them in these ways. I believe in the power of community-led storytelling as a healing art. That is why I chose to testify in support of these bills. We also have the unanimous support of our town and county select board. These bills are not abstract to us. They're personal. They're about making sure local voices don't get drowned out in the distance by disconnection or by profit margins. These bills are about empowering public access media to continue showing up again and again for the people who count on us. So, thank you not just for your time, but for your presence in hearing and reading each of our testimonies. My community is watching and just as I hold space for them, you are holding space for all of us by listening.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
In that spirit, I invite the committee to publicly affirm your support for these bills today or in the days ahead so that communities like mine know that we are not standing alone with peace and progress. Thank you. Thank you so much. Uh we're going to now move on um to Bobby Planser also virtually. Thank you very much. Oh, should I go now? Yes, please. Awesome. Uh thank you very much. Uh Bobby Clanszer, I am also here on behalf of NCTV. Uh good afternoon chairs Farley Bier and more and members of the committee. My name is Bobby Planser and I'm a talk show host with Nucket Community Television where I proudly host my show Bob and Around Town for the past 10 years. I started the show in 2015 with my late uncle Warren. When he passed away in 2018, I made it my mission to continue the show in his memory.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
NCTV has made it possible. Every episode, they help me with filming, editing, and making sure my show reaches the community. through MCTV's support, including a small but meaningful $100 an episode that I earn through MCTV's budget, I've been able to share local stories, connect with the people of Nucket, and continue to our island's creative voice. Without this legislation, I honestly don't know if I'll be able to continue. I would hate to lose the platform that I love. Bill S41 and 8, House Bill 91, is crucial to protecting community media across Massachusetts. With more people streaming instead of using cable, our funding is dying, is drying up, and stations like MCTV can't survive on hope alone. Please give this bill a favorable report so that people like me and so many others on Nucket and across the Commonwealth can keep doing what we love. Sharing V stories, perspectives that truly reflect our community.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Thank you for your time, for your consideration to this important legislation, and I look forward to answering your questions. Thank you. Thank you, Bobby and uh Stephanie from Nantucket TV. Senators here and I had the pleasure of joining one of your uh high school uh hosts just uh just a few weeks ago to appear on one of your programs. Uh so not only for your programming uh and the creativity related there too, but also uh for your advocacy on this. It was actually through NCTV that I first heard about this bill. So, uh, thank you for being here. Thank you. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. Right. Next, we have uh Glenn Williams, Boston Neighborhood Network. Good afternoon. Do you hear me? Yes. Okay. Thank you. I want to thank you uh for for having us on. I also want to thank all of my my uh comrades in in arms here.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Not really in arms, but you know what I mean. Uh of the peg axles. My name my name's Glenn Williams. I'm the general manager of Boston Neighborhood Network. And one of the things that I want to do is I want to talk just a couple of seconds about the impact we have. We've heard a lot about what we need and what's going to happen and we need the this that and the other thing. But I want to talk about what happens to our community. The news four, five, and seven. Everybody sees it. The first 25 minutes of it is this kid got killed. This building burnt down. This country is trying to ruin this other country. Then the last five minutes they talk about a cow they found that has a picture of Elvis on its side. We've decided we've decided not to do that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
What we do is we make sure that we get every city councelor in the studio here and we have them talk about what's great about being a Bostononian. What's so important about being one of being from one of the 22 different sections of the city and how fun it is to be a Bostononian. The other thing is we all cover football games and all of that. Well, few years back, couple of seasons back, we had a football game and was coming to the end of the game and I'm sorry, no. Okay. Uh was coming to the end of the game and everyone gets to play. They put the little kid in there and he miraculously puts his hand up in the air, pulls the ball down, and goes back for a touchdown. Right out of Rudy, right? I one of our cameramen rushes down, sticks a camera in his face, and interviews him.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Didn't get a lot out of him. A week later, I got an email from his grandfather telling me that this kid is mostly nonverbal. And the fact that we put him on TV and we made a big fuss out of him, he now walks around talking about what a great experience it was for him. We also get emails from grandparents from all over the country that come and tell us about how great it was for them to see their grandchildren graduate from high school. How important it was for for Senator Nick Collins to have his St. Patrick's Day breakfast. We made sure we put it live on TV so that everybody can see our politicians, regardless of the side, regardless of the issues, spend time with each other and be human and have a good time. It's so important. I'm sure I'm almost done. I'm sure on the way in today or if you looked out your window, you saw our truck parked outside Boston neighborhood network.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above