And so you get your footing there. you don't need to uh especially when it's this flat, you don't need to sand and treat it. And so that was the the the response I had to Tony in our discussion is that you know we do uh designs where we do have the the the uh uh the gravel on top. That's prior that's the gravel and then we pave it that in that application we agree in this case here looking to use the the crushed stone as the drainage system we need that at the surface. If you looked at his approach if you wanted to use the the crush stone beneath the surface during winter conditions that gravel is going to be rock hard like pavement. You're going to get no infiltration. So that's where we were coming from. With the voids and the stones, you're still going to have that ability to infiltrate and to detain.
>> Thank you. >> Any other questions? Okay. Um, policy policy committee minutes, please. Commissioner Suarez. >> Thank you, President Paris. Uh, the policy committee meeting took place on Wednesday, July 16th, 2025, and began at 4:02 p.m. In attendance from administration were Assistant Superintendent Marching Garrow and Michael Doctor. Board of Education members in attendance were Vice President Anthony Santiago, Commissioner Mahia, President Paris. Also in attendance was Miss Maggie Miller, district council. Policy 7510, use of school facilities, was re-examined and discussed. The committee determined that the description and requirements were adequate and that no revisions are needed at this time. Policy 3230, outside activities, was discussed and clarified. No revisions are needed. Bylaw 0152 board officers was discussed to determine if there should be additional requirements to be pres president and vice president of the board of education. Mr. Paris stated he would seek guidance from NJSBA for clarification and information and would report back to the committee.
This is combining both the debt service and the operations fund. So that's why the starting figures are a little higher. Um but really you're looking at foregoing um you know roughly you know two million starting in 2028 to approximately 4 million in 2031 in revenue from the impact of Senate ruled act one. Not even from preenate enrolled act one from post Senate enrolled act one. Right? And we already know that we were giving up roughly a couple of million dollars due to Senate and World Act One. We'd potentially be giving up now another two4 million at the end of the day. And this does not uh account for the LT impact that $630,000 right and that was kind of shown in both slides. So, I mean, I think the challenge is, and this is why I think there are many districts that are going to look at trying to keep their tax rate where it's at because of sustainability.
>> Okay. I mean, I think the questions I have are about um the um the accessible parking spaces. I know when we talked when we went through the review for the dog park, whenever that was, it was one of the questions that came up because they were also looking at doing some kind of a gravel parking lot. >> And the thought about the accessibility was a a problem and the maintenance, the plowing. Now, this isn't town plowing, so it's in in a sense, it's not the town's problem. How do you how you plow the gravel or, you know, the the stone? um how do you keep the the accessible spaces um free? Um I mean that would be something the town would probably look at um as far as maintenance. So that that would that's one of the questions I have. The other question is um is just about the nature.
Policy 1540 administrators code of ethics was discussed to possibly allow administrators to be volunteer athletic coaches. Various concerns were raised regarding oversight, chain of command, and safeguards. These concerns were addressed in the new wording for the policy and reviewed by Miss Miller. The committee agreed on the revision and the policy is up for first reading. The committee received an update on the conversion to NGSBA policies. The process is near completion now that our district's equity plan was approved by the county. Policies are being finalized. The upload to board docs will be set up and board approval will be sought at the next possible board meeting. Once finalized, the meeting adjourned at 5:33 p.m. >> Thank you.
I think the question is for a district is if they were to keep a steady tax rate, where does where does the $2 million you're already losing $2 million, right? So the first piece is you have to as a district um start to adjust for that $2 million impact and that's not going to be easy. I mean be perfectly honest and then uh sat in this seat, you know, school CFO for eight years. Um that's not easy, right? Um you're not talking close to you know 20% of your budget. And so how do you adjust for that first and foremost and then to say we're going to up another $2 million. I think the challenge would be in being able to provide services at the end of the day uh to maintain buildings uh provide transportation to get salary increases. While a noble goal, I think it would be an extreme challenge to give up really at the end of the day, you know, close to anywhere from four to$6 million of revenue and be able to sustain uh the district as is.
I'm not sure this I'm not sure this board can determine unless someone has more experience than I do stone on top or gravel on top which is better. I'm not sure um about being able to determine that determine that argument. Right. That would have to be that would have to be something between GCG and and the applicant to to figure out the the best method to do that. Correct. >> Correct. >> So, um do we have do we have thoughts? I mean um Camila had raised one about the um >> about about keeping it from going on the the street >> and I saw a report that says that there's uh in a previous probably in a previous discussion was already addressed. U I I hope that that it does because stone will be on the road. So I hope that that whatever method is used that it doesn't fall on the town to deal with it.
Any questions? >> I do. >> Commissioner Bassford. >> Um, I'd like to know what the rationale is or the concern that prompted the proposal uh about bylaw 0152. And do you have any feedback yet from NJSBA? >> Allen? No, I haven't received any feedback yet from uh from Kelly. Um the question was and it was a discussion point was whether or not um we should consider some kind of basic minimum requirement uh before a commissioner is eligible to be an officer. Uh for example right now there's no there's no requirement whatsoever. Um someone could just get elected and be selected by the the board to be an officer. So the question for consideration was should there be some kind of minimum requirement like you must be at least a board member for a year so you at least have this experience under your belt um and have an have a good idea how things work everyone's roles and it's just really part of a learning process and it was simply a discussion at this point there's no policy proposal at this point um but that's where it basically was uh rooted >> are we allowed to change that policy um under the statuto ruling of the state to have a minimum of one year for a person to be on the board through you to the um attorney.
And so, you know, For that reason, I don't know a district that um that we have talked to at this point that uh has talked about trying to maintain the current rate because again they're already facing the impact of Senator Ro which is challenging in itself. Uh and so and I think the other piece is depending on where your taxpayers are at, right? They may or may not a difference in their tax bill. And the example I would give you is if I'm a taxpayer who's already at the property tax cap and my tax bill would say I am supposed to pay $1,400 in property taxes, but I want my 1% says I can only pay a,000. You keep your tax rates where it's at and it gives them a $300 relief off of the original bill. So let's say they're supposed to pay $1,100 instead of 14, but remember they're only paying $1,000 to begin with.
the the setback between the property line and where the parking is is as per the the uh dimensional standards. Correct. >> Between the the parking lot in Yes. >> and the rightway. >> Correct. >> On on the road. >> Correct. >> All right. Thank you. Um, in addition to what Trisha said about the accessible parking, my the more I stare at that site plan, um, I am really curious about all the turning radius, how comfortable it is for an accessible from that accessible parking to get onto also the entry point where it looks like that. Looks pretty difficult. Somebody's reversing their car in that corner spot >> and somebody is driving in and is there are cars in both directions at that entry point that does not look like it feels too tight at that corner. So I don't know if you've done turning radius checks on those on that particular spot.
>> I don't know of any prohibition against it. Um but I don't know that it's allowed either. It's it's your own bylaws. We've had them done in other places and um it wasn't challenged, but um I it's it's a bylaw, so I don't see why you couldn't do it. I don't know that there's anything in the law that prevents you from from doing it. Um I think there was a at least in the discussion I don't think there was a lot of interest in in doing it. Um so I don't know if that makes a difference. >> So just you know I I did some research myself because you know this is my wheelhouse. Um there's no statutory requirement in the state of New Jersey um for board members to serve on either roles as president or vice president. Being a dy elected official. You have to be 18.
So you've lowered your rate, you've created a theoretical savings, but the taxpayer has not seen a difference in their bill. And I think that would be some analysis I would be really looking at as well if it's truly a consideration because you may not be impacting taxpayers in the way you think you might, right? That's the challenge sometimes the property tax system, the property tax caps is we think um by lowering rates we may be having impact on taxpayers and in some cases you might and in other cases you may not. And Again, I probably the bigger piece here I think I would just see and again part of the work we do is with the district is on future cash flow modeling, right? Revenue and expenditure modeling and I know we've been working through that already and and working to adjust and now the goalpost has been moved with Senate Bill Act one that's going to create even further conversations.
>> Yes. So we have um we have provided in fact we provided a um turning template not for just a passenger vehicle. So the inside turning radius this is the fire truck a ladder truck. So your typical vehicle uh ranges you know 16 18 20 ft in length. This is a 40 foot long vehicle. um the ladder truck um that demonstrates it can make the maneuvers in and out of the site. As you can see here, this red is actually the travel path of the tires of the of the vehicle and in green is the body overhang and how that reacts to the movement of the tires. Um so with that said the site is designed um in accordance with the local requirements in uh sound engineering practice where the turn the the width from the edge of parking lot to here is 20 ft.
You know, you know the the the what you need to run for the board of education. You can't have a criminal record. You have to be a resident in the city. You you're able to read and write English or appointed member of the board or and there are there's a big push going on in this in some cities. I know Jersey City that was changed though, but there's a big push about going back to appointed board. So stay tuned to that fellow uh colleagues. Um and uh you need to receive the handy five, right? five affirmative votes and then you become president. Um so there's no legal mandate for prior course cons uh completion specific training and other credentials as prerequisite for the leadership positions. We've never had a policy like that. I've been on the board forif 14 years 15 years going into while I strongly urge um ongoing professional development and recognize the value it brings to effective governance.
This would be even more difficult to to to pull off that. So, I just think u appreciate the look. I think it's an interesting piece. Um the other just want to take a look at here real quickly uh is what does this look like in terms of taxpayers. Uh and we just took I think a couple of uh situations here. They're a little bit illustrative. Uh so this is North Burn City Taxing District. Uh this is again what they would pay in property taxes. In this case, all of the homesteads are at the cap. They're paying their max 1%. You see the bill go down from 25 to 26. Uh that is the result of that 10% credit. U my worry, and this is probably just Barry Gardner, but a lot of people hear $300 and think I'm getting a $300 deduction on my tax bill, and it's not $300, it's 10%.
Typical vehicle width is about six feet from and in some in some cases um you're talking uh I have a Tacoma. My width from outside mirror to outside mirror is 6 1/2 ft. So with that, if you have two vehicles going two ways, that's 13 ft. You still have seven uh 7 ft to play. >> It's not that point. I'm uh it's at the entry. So the truck that you firetruck path that you show that truck is literally in the middle of that entryway. That's how that's drawn and that's not how we are assuming the traffic flow will be. Right. >> So, and I appreciate that, but again, I think you need to look at the truck which is more than twice the length of a passenger car. So, with a passenger car, the the turning radius is much tighter than that um and will stay in its own travel lane.
It is crucial not to um conflate best practices with statutory requirements. Um suggesting otherwise risks misleading members and undermining democratic nature of our board's internal leadership decisions. Um I will not support anything like that because we've always made a sound decision on who we're putting in place. But um I'm just understand uh why all of a sudden now this comes up. I'm just curious. >> President Paris, may I? >> Yes. Yes. So, um >> we know the statutory regs and we know that whether it's bylaw or policy, we can create a policy that we want, right? Um just because there isn't a statutory rag doesn't mean we can't create a policy. We tweak policies every single meeting. We make a policy ours. We change it, right? Just because it's not it doesn't have to be 100% the rag, right? It's about what's the need of our district and the need of our children.
So in this case, it's roughly start as $130. Um but I think what people are also going to find their assessed value goes up in the home. It's not going to be the full $130, right? It's going to eat into that. Um, but potentially they would see, you know, some impact there, but then it obviously returns back to, I think, kind of status quo of what we've seen in terms of property tax, uh, bills with gross assessed value. I think the bigger concern is this one. Uh, so this is Geneva Township taxing district. Um you can see from 25 to 26 there is a slight decline in the tax bill for that 937 to just under 894. But then as the mechanics of the bill start to happen because they're not at the cap they have sensitivity in their tax bill. And so when the business personal property goes away it shifts the tax burden as we call it away from the business personal property to the other units including homeowners.
So the typical in in any design for parking lots, the maneuvering aisle uh is 24 feet and that's in your town bylaws and other lanes that are not maneuvering aisles are 20 ft wide. And so those are the standards to which we designed. >> Yeah. But you're you're making the assumption that people are parking in the in the right spots. And I know you mentioned that possibly spray painting the stone, but stone gets moved and kicked and I mean, right, it's not like it's there's no adhesive to the ground for it, right? So these are moving items and I we've all I mean when you have the overflow parking for church, how how close are people on staying in those lines? I guess what I would ask. I I we know what parking lots look like when they're when they're not when there's no lines.
So that's just one. Whether it's a statutory or not doesn't mean we can't create our own policy for our district. >> Am I correct? >> As long as it doesn't violate >> long as it doesn't violate the law, right? As long as it doesn't violate the law. So um so that that's that's that's one. So, where this really came out from was, you know, um I know when I was first elected, um more than one person told me it's an unwritten rule that now I was not looking to nor did I want to be the president nor the vice president, but I heard from more than one person person that it's kind of like an unwritten rule that you're the new person. You really don't know much. You should get to know the position. And I 100% agreed with it then and I still agree with it now.