Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
>> Oh, please. Thank you guys. Keep holding me accountable. Make sure we're doing our part. >> Okay, >> we'll make sure. >> Thank you. >> Take care. >> Thank you, John. >> Right. >> Okay. Um our 740 uh hearing has been withdrawn at the request of the uh petitioner. Uh there's needed information that they failed to provide us. So they'll get back to us and we'll they'll meet at at uh at our next meeting September or maybe August. Second week in August 16th, I think. No, not the 16th. whenever our second meeting is in August 20th. >> 20th. Okay. All right. So, we can move right along. And with that, we'll open it up for citizens participation because I know Mark's biting at the bit. Good evening. >> Good evening, Mark. Beat you to it. >> Say what? >> I said I beat you to it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Said good evening. >> Okay. Wait, let me start over. >> No. Okay, Dr. Sony 119 Main Street. I coming up with three three things. One was that litigation um presentation. I'm just hoping if it does work for the state and this town, then we can just hope that the federal government doers don't get a hold of it first. So we can be here for this town in one piece. Two would be what you just had on with the clover road. I since I live right behind it and um it's been quiet. No loud music, no nothing like that. Everybody's walking by back and forth and everything. All all is there. Plus I do the u on the Sunday afternoons noon to 1:30 is the u peaceful protest and I and we're there entertainment on the sidewalks once they have their beverages and stuff like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
They said that we we stand out there and they sit out and they sit down and watch us. Three is old story probably hoping for a new beginning and everything else stronger boards committees. I am now very very disappointed that um ZVA and Concom are not on the same page. I'm very disappointed about that because the state. We talked about this before town Mr. Town Manager and now there's a letter out there from the state that Consation was talking about that called mass ready from the state about housing housing and observation points and bylaws and all that stuff. The state I think now is definitely putting small towns under. Just because we are in a housing crisis does not mean that a town can't grow with housing with economics and business without one or two things that's not there anyways. So we have I we we h I we we have the right to our state senator president and all that to say our piece but I I know that we if we do what I do and everything else it's going to get buried and this town's not strong enough to fight back.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
That's why I'm majorly disappointed that it's not happening. 40 B's and the MBTA one too is not going to make this town economically easier to live for. It's just got to make this town more crowded traffic and disappointing to have other people know what Ash is really about. And once the state keeps on bearing in Ashland, Ashland is not going to come out alive. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mark. Yeah, Ashland has a lot of hurdles to go over, that's for sure. As do other cities and towns. We're not the only ones affected by the trickle down effect from the federal government. We're all feeling something at some point in time. All right. Um, next on our agenda is to discuss the town manager's evaluation. And I will turn this over to Yolanda. >> Thank you. Uh thank you Joe. So the process was a little elongated this year due to a couple of different things.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um I don't know if you all remember but last year we had talked about possibly trying to create a new um tool that we were going to use and due to varying things that did not happen. So we used the same tool again this year. Uh everyone filled their their separate evaluations out then they were brought together. Um, I have to admit that Michael helped me use or Michael used chat GPT to >> amazing >> put them all together, but I feel like it it actually created a fuller evaluation based on a lot more information. Uh, based on that, I do have a statement for the public and for all of us uh, regarding his evaluation process. So the select board statement regarding the 202425 board evaluation worked with Michael Herbert and myself as the past chair. Michael's overall score for the past year is 4.4 which relates to meeting and exceeding expectation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
This is based on the average scores of each area in the current evaluation document. There are 10 areas of performance that the board evaluates the town manager in. uh a narrative summary of the strengths that were again this is from everyone's put together the select board collectively recognizes that Michael Herbert brings a powerful set of strengths to his role his passion for the community strategic vision and steadfast integrity set the tone for effective leadership he communicates that vision clearly and builds trust through openness and empathy making him not just an administrator but a true community leader additionally has strong financial management and ability to multitask enables him to turn ambitious plans into reality without losing sight of fiscal responsibility. These strengths have been instrumental in Ashlin's progress and are the foundation of Michael's effectiveness of performance. Narrative uh summary of improvement areas. The select board's constructive feedback for Michael centers on fine-tuning an already strong performance.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
The overarching themes are communication, delegation, and maintaining objectivity. By keeping all the board members uniformly informed and providing robust analysis for decisions, he will strengthen trust and efficiency at the governance level. By delegating more and guarding against personal overload, he will sustain his effectiveness and be able to engage even more with the community and big picture issues. And by approaching sensitive personnel or public situations with a touch more detachment and a steady fact-based demeanor, he will navigate controversies without compromising his integrity or focus. The board is confident that addressing these areas will not only improve Michael's performance, but also make his job more manageable and rewarding in the future. In summary, upon the uh the final the annual evaluation, the select board's message is one of confidence and appreciation. Michael Herbert is performing at a high level, demonstrating effective leadership, strategic vision, and dedication that have positively impacted the town.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
The board's overall rating reflects the view that he is meeting or exceeding expectations in most areas. We acknowledge a few areas for continued growth, largely around communication and personal workload management, but these are seen as refinements to an otherwise strong performance. Collectively, the board is grateful for Michael's hard work and passion. We look forward to continuing to partner with him as Ashlin navigates its upcoming challenges and builds on the successes of the past year. >> Thank you, Lana. Thank you for all the work and effort to get that done. And um and I'm sorry you had to go through those those those matters to get this to get this done because it wasn't it wasn't easy and um we appreciate all all your effort and sacrifice to get this completed. >> Not a sacrifice. Thank you. Well, you had some issues that you had to deal with and and you did it you did it >> very professionally, very very grateful.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Any comments or anything you want to add to let you land on what we basically collectively have said? I'll open it up to the board. >> No, I think that was a good summary. um you know and and I too appreciate your efforts, Michael. And uh and I think that the areas that we suggested you refine um are indeed the I think it was outlined as it would improve your life as well. And so I look forward to that. Um you know, I think we you've had a couple of new board members now for a year or two. And so I think that um puts different eyes on on things and people who aren't as familiar with things. And so sometimes that's a good opportunity really to see how we need to um adjust a little bit. So I appreciate that. And um and that's that's all I have.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Thank you very much. >> Randy Nikita. So the only thing I would add is just that you know all of us had an opportunity to also sit with Michael and go through like our personal evaluations and discussions and I think that's also really important part of the process because we um it's it's it's also it's also talking to you on how we can do a better job of you know working collectively together. So I think that that was you know it's a good part of the process. Um, and you know, I appreciate the work that you do that, um, you know, I mean, none of us are wall flowers. We're pretty we're pretty strong personalities here. So, you know, to balance all of us. Um, you know, that that takes some finessing, too, I'm sure. Um, but just thank you and glad that uh that chat GPT, you know, could come through.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I still need to use I still I have never used it. I've been scared to death of the thing. So I need to now I need to >> well now we can sit down with Michael now he knows that he's proficient in it will say >> oh my god >> be careful folks you know I I will say that you know somebody who goes across the country and trades people on how to do prompt uh engineering and such I think it's good that we're able to utilize these tools but I think we also do uh need to be careful about how they're utilized um they are not perfect >> uh it is not perfect and is uh unfortunately you know those of us in it We say garbage in and garbage out, but sometimes you put good stuff into chat GPT and you do get garbage out.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> So, um, so just just a just a caveat before we start doing free advertising for >> that. This was definitely not free advertising, but I think this was a tool that helped. >> Sure. because I know in the past for myself when I've done the accumulation of the the different evaluations I did not have as detailed a final report and evaluation. >> Um what I would say is similar to your caution of >> none of this is proprietary information that was put in here. >> Right. We we don't want to go put anything proprietary into chat GPT because once you put it in there it becomes the public domain. >> Um So if you want and you know there are ways to do it with that with AI but you then are buying something so that it can stay proprietary. >> Correct. >> Way to do it is is ask Makita before you >> exactly >> or people even more skilled than I >> or ask chat GPC to develop a very neutral >> neutral.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I I just had one more thing to add that I'm sorry I forgot to say. I just wanted to mention that I think you you're restructuring um you know with the loss of of Jen Ball and your restructuring. Hopefully that will help um with everything you have on your plate going forward. And I also just wanted to make mention that that was actually we we saved a little bit of money, not a huge amount of money, but it was actually um cheaper than than continuing the way we were going. So, um, just wanted to add that. Thank you. >> And it made and it made it made some of the, uh, the workload a little easier, you know, not a whole heck of a lot, but a little bit easier. You know, that's one of the things that you and I had discussed during our time together was, uh, you know, allowing other people to take more work off your shoulders.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Well, it allows um I think you know one of the things the restructuring has allowed me to do is actually focus on some other things that needed to be done, you know, and like we talked at the retreat, some of that more proactive stuff and some of the more day-to-day um stuff that are more on the strategic level, I guess you could say, as opposed to more the tactical level. But um yeah, it definitely um you know it it's it's um refreshing to get uh feedback where both you know the strengths and the areas of improvement are consistent across the board members. Um as you can imagine it would be very very difficult if I have five different sets of you know things to work on or five different things and trying to um trying to put that uh you know put a plan together into doing that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And um yeah, I mean it's a it's it's been a year so far. 2025 has been a year full of challenges, but also opportunity. And you know, I really really you know, first of all, I want to thank the board for all their support and guidance, direction, partnership that we have. um really you know how much I really feel strongly about a team and team uh working together to accomplish common goals and I think that's what we have been able to do over the last decade um and I'm really you know despite the loss of some real key personnel um I'm really excited about who we have um and our team in place right now as that starts filling out and starting to put in some of the final pieces. Um, you know, we've got a nice mix of familiar faces um that are continuing in the same roles, but familiar faces that are in new roles and also new faces.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And um you know so far it's been really energizing and I can't um I just really can't thank enough um you know the four um four ladies in in the office um you know Katherine, Beth, Diane, Susan and uh just the work that they do, the dedication that they show to the town um but also the support that they show me personally um has just and um you know the difference sometimes between some very good days and some very bad days. So I consider myself very very fortunate to be surrounded by talented people. Um and uh I was talking with a former manager um the other day and we talk about the fact that you know when when you have you know predominantly positive reviews that talk about accomplishments you just feel like oh my gosh I really didn't do any of these things. It's all been really the staff that have done this and And so it's been um um very very grateful uh for like I said the talent and the dedication that so thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Well I I'll let I'll just like to segue into something you just it's it's the leadership provided from your office that allows that to set the table. You set the table. So, we thank you for doing what you do. Um, it's a team, it's a team effort, not one individual. It's a group of collective people that have a a vision and a goal and they're all on the same page with respect to. And it's okay to have differences of opinion uh that go along with a day-to-day workload. And because if you don't, then there's definitely something that's that's a dictatorship. That's not that's not collective minds working together. So with respect to that, so um I appreciate all the work that you guys have done and appreciate everything that all the new hirees and their new positions are doing. So it's working out well. I believe it's working out well.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Likewise. So all right. Um next one on our agenda is to open the special town meeting warrant special town meeting scheduled for November 19th, 2025. And um I have a motion to read unless you somebody else would like to read it. Okay, you're all set. There a second. Thank you. All those in favor? I one absence. You just walked out the hall. Um okay. So that's passed and we don't have to do anything else with that. We now do we need to uh sign something? We don't need to sign something right now. I don't know if you, you know, want Catherine just to kind of go through the outline of the absolutely process. >> Yeah, I think it would be helpful just to either outline the process or just to direct folks to where they can they can see an outline of the process so they know what's what what this what we just did and what this means.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> What what did we just did we just do? Um so what we just did is we opened the warrant um for a special town meeting which will take place on November 19th, 2025. And um listed in the backup is exactly the timetable. Um so September 27th, excuse me, will be the deadline for notice of intent to submit proposed foreign articles. Um those proposed articles are filed with the select board's office and I believe my contact info is actually listed. Yes, it's down below. Um and then uh September 27th through October 15th. That's when there will be um discussions, presentations, public hearings. Um October 16th is when the select board will vote to close and post the warrant. November 5th we will um well that's the the state um to go ahead and post the warrant and then November 19th is the actual special time meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So >> 7 o'clock at the Ash High School. >> Unless we change the news, but >> No, no, it's at >> Okay. >> Thank you for that. I appreciate that. Matter of fact, >> any any sense on what I mean? I believe we're going to look at doing the comprehensive plan. Any sense on what other articles might be brought forward? I mean, obviously funding and things like that, but anything else big? Looks like as of right now, we have um just about 10 articles, obviously free cash. Um, and then we have the, let's see, we have the in-law bylaw. So, when we voted in the ADU bylaw, we just need to, um, I think redo the the in. And then CPC funding for the Y. We have capital, the senior tax exemption, uh the KEFET budget adjustment article, the regional agreement, >> and these are just this is actually just a future tracker so you can keep track of like everything that's come in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above