It equates to up to um nine hours and they include things like bloodborne pathogens um boundaries u uh uh required reporting of uh to the state with child abuse um suspicion. And uh some of those courses again bloodborne pathogen um that might not be as relevant to the professional development that um was talked about earlier this evening, but there are courses in there that I contend very much do support uh teachers in the classroom. So what is proposed is that um while most teachers are able to get those uh professional development hours uh during the summer and during the PD days during the school year th this past spring we had um some teachers who they were just short of a few hours and so they reached out to uh my office and we want people to get this $800. And so I I did allow that.
I I allowed them to use the vector courses. Now this year, the one thing we would change uh we would limit it to five hours at at the max because we want them to participate in the professional development that again was discussed earlier this evening. But for those who might miss or um just need a few hours to get to the finish line, we want to be there for them and allow that. So on August 25th when I meet with the 301 committee, uh that will be the one recommendation I'll make to them. Now what happens is uh and they represent the different schools. They then go back to their schools and it's it's a teacherbased election as to whether they accept this plan or not. And then um you know I imagine they will as they did last year. I will then bring that to you in the fall for final approval.
Questions on 301. >> I don't have any. Do you guys have any questions? >> All right. um 9.9 discussion information on possible changes to course fees related to the ESAs. >> So what we have uh for those uh this is primarily it could be broader than this but I'm going to narrow it down just for the conversation. Uh you have some cases where uh homeschool students are uh selecting ESAs or vouchers uh empowerment scholarship accounts or vouchers. Uh the question becomes as a homeschool student not accepting a voucher, the laws are very specific that you can go ahead and participate in our sports and you can go ahead and pick up a class. The question that becomes in place if you accept the voucher is are you really a homeschool student? I know most parents may believe them though their kids to be homeschooled. In fact, they would be private school because they've received voucher money to homeschool them so they become a private school.
The issue that seems to be coming up around the state quite a bit, I've had several conversations with with parents uh coming into this year is can we utilize and provide um services for kids that re receive ESAs and charge them for that. And um the answer is yes, you can. It's under the law. It could be extracurricular or could be a coursework. For example, if you have a high school student that's being homeschooled, the parent doesn't know or understand um trigonometry, could the kid sign up for a trigonometry class for us? They would not be our student and we could not pull ADM on them, but you could tuition them in to your school as a student, but then what's the cost? Maces come up, we we uh Dr. Fountain did a substantial amount of work on this and and maces come up with a system of of how much they charge.
Other districts have just started to look at it. Uh Higgley's got a little bit of information on it. Some of the other districts haven't really weighed in, but it's starting to be a bigger issue. Um as we have this discussion, I just want to caution a couple things. How how do you determine how much the ESA should be? I believe Mesa's sports for football anyway, it's $2,000. I could be off on that. Um but I believe that's what it is. For a class, it ranged around 12 or $1,300. Okay. And so now the question becomes now my stance I'll be upfront with everybody. My stance is you took private dollars. Um if it's your choice for school guess it doesn't really matter. That's when you make a choice you live with it good or bad. The flip side of it is we talk about declining enrollment.
Is this a way to get kids in? The thing we need to be cautious about because this is starting to gain steam is somebody sent me a newspaper article. It's more Substack newspaper article uh here in the state where the title I'm paraphrasing because I don't remember it right off the top of my head, but the title was um our public schools abusing the ESA program and char overcharging parents for services and yet at the same time complaining about what the parents are doing with their ESAs because there's been a lot of reports about the amount of money that they've held back or not spending or using for kids going to college and they specifically looked at um no charter schools alone where charter schools do the same thing but they specifically looked at Mesa Agraia Union Talison Union Yuma Union um and I think Daart and called them out based on the amount of money that they were charging.
So it's going to be an issue that's going to gain traction and maybe not as simple as any everybody wants it to be. Let's just say we decide as a board, you say, "Yeah, we're going to go ahead and offer this opportunity to kids and we'll take it out of the sports realm, but we'll take that TRIG issue." And the parent doesn't have the skill set to go ahead and teach Trig. So, can we provide a kid to come in and take TRIG? Um, and so they come and take TRIG and we charge them whatever it is we decide to charge them. That would be the course fee. The problem becomes are they they're not our student. But what happens, and I don't have an answer yet. I know Miss Loit's in the back of the room and she may have an answer. Um, but uh, we've just been busy and I haven't had a chance to ask her, but what does that do for that kid when it comes to state testing?
And if you're required to take the state testing, does that automatically change the notion of you as a homeschool, private school parent and whether you want them to take the state testing? if they're not required to st take the state testing or they are required, what does that do to our percent tested? And so if you have kids in the classroom um that does the test count or not test because they're not our ADM so they might not count but they have a test result and so now does that mean they don't count on our data so yet we taught them and that could be a positive or negative but if it's a trig kid there's probably a brighter kid. Um but likewise if if all of a sudden now we have enough of those kids you're now below the 95% tested that then penalizes us.
So when we have these conversations I just want you to to be to be just a caution that we haven't even thought of all the different unintended consequence good or bad um that that this brings in. It's in in a simplistic world it's like well why should every kid have an opportunity to participate? Well let me ask you the question. Let's change it back to sports. Last time I checked, I'm an old coach. There's only one starting quarterback. So, when the kid comes in and takes away the starting quarterback, well, how do our parents feel about that? especially if the kid has never been in the system and you have a kid that's grown up in the system or what if you only have 10 kids or 11 kids on a basketball team and three of them come in and now they take away the opportunity of three kids in our high school to play even though they're technically not in our school.
So you start to have these conversations of saying well just let the kids play or just let the kids take the class. It may get a little bit more complicated then when you start to figure out how much does it really cost you and say 2,000 for football. Does 2,000 really cover the cost of what it takes and what's the liability if the kid gets hurt when they're now but they're not our our kid because they're not on ADM and so what's the trust say about that? So, so I bring this for a for a discussion, but just note that what on surface may seem simplistic and a quick yes or no, we need to have and the reason it's a discussion item and not a action item is there has to be some conversation because it creates a potential set of issues that may be reflected.
Now, if if everybody's doing it and we're the ones left out, then who's being stupid here? But I'm not in some cases where people think through all of these issues. We just had a short conversation within I can't remember his cabinet or leadership and all of a sudden what starts out as this size went to this size very very quickly and now trying to think it all the way through and figure out what does it mean um is an issue. So, I'm I'm open for a general discussion or questions. Um, but but I know Mr. Horn had asked about this and and so this is where it came from as we had a conversation, but it's it's much more convoluted than initially thought and and has some tentacles in there that that may make this thing uh into a 12 or 15legged octopus instead of just eight.
>> Does anybody else want to go first? I don't want to hog the microphone. I feel like Okay. So, I actually have a lot of answers to some of the questions that you brought up. Um, conversely, I also uh met with several policy advisors um and elected officials down at the state capital a couple of weeks ago. Um, in the spirit of being transparent and authentic, um, I am a proponent of school choice. I am a homeschool educator of over a decade. Um, I have never accepted any ESA funds. Um, I went to go meet with them because I had uh issue with the way that the ESA funds are being utilized. Um, I feel like they are uh not being utilized properly. And so, as someone that also deeply cares about the public school system, I wanted to see if there was something that I could do about that.
Um, in in my research, um, I've come to find out, as Dr. Wyman alluded to, that there's probably a much uh better way to say this, but it's a big hot mess. One big old hot mess, and the deeper that you get into it, the messier that it gets. um to answer some of your questions. So um there are students like mine that have never taken any ESA funds, not one penny of ESA funding. Um in I can speak to Navajo County. I can also speak to Panell County because we have resided in both of those and temporarily in Maricopa County for a little bit as a homeschooler. Um but I know more so about panel and Navajo. Um, in Panal County, you and Navajo County and Maropa County, you have to file a affidavit to um of intent to homeschool. If you're doing uh Prima Vera online or one of those other online schools, that does not count as a true blue homeschooler where um you are a true educator.
You are purchasing your own curriculum. You are educating your own students. Um, and that is what I did when I came to Combmes. Um, when my oldest was a freshman, they did ask me, "Are you a a real homeschooler?" And and the question can be kind of it can catch you off guard because, you know, if you don't really know where the background is to that. Um, and so by Arizona state law, if you are a true homeschooler and you have an affidavit from the county, which I do because we've never accepted ESA funds, um, then your homeschool student is allowed to not only try out for all sports and clubs and athletics, they still have to make the team. They have to be good enough. They can't you can't require that they be allowed to be the starting quarterback. Um but they can try out for sports and beyond sports and they are allowed to take up to two electives.
They are not allowed to take any core classes um now since the advent of ESA and how that's kind of changed into I don't know how the law has changed regarding the core classes but I believe it has changed um because now schools are um accepting other other districts are accepting ESA funds. Um, I spoke with uh the gal that kind of spearheaded she was um appointed to be the director of ESA funding. Um, and I was picking her brain and kind of finding out from a business perspective, how would this benefit us? Because if you go through McDonald's, Wendy's, Burger King, your favorite place that has fries, they always will ask you if you want fries with that. and I think they make a pretty good amount of money off of their fries. Um, it's something to consider this as an added income source and look at it in a business perspective in that manner.
Um, she said that when I asked her about the other schools that were doing this, um, I actually heard a dollar figure for 2500 to play football. >> Um, there is another, she wouldn't tell me what school, but there is a school that is charging 2500 to play football. Um, so they can use their ESA funds for that. She said the most popular ones um, if you were looking at it as a um, supply and demand. And so if you want to make offerings, and not saying that we would, but just so that you have the knowledge um, of what homeschoolers with ESA funds are looking for, it is typically math classes, science classes, band, choir, and other electives such as languages. Um those were the big ones. Um let me see if there were some other questions that we had here. >> And then for clarification and I think it becomes extremely critical.
I think we need to differentiate between homeschool and people that take ESAs. I I would not call them homeschoolers that take ESAs. If you accept an ESA, you are a private school student. And the law is very clear on homeschoolers. So you're right. Homeschool has been going on that's been going on for two decades about what you can do and what you can't do as a homeschooler. But this differentiation is a little bit different. And so when you accept that ESA, what do you what do you do with it? The law is clear. You can they can do something that's sports or courses. What's not clear because it hasn't really been discussed on a higher level is so what's the real cost and how do you determine the real cost? So, is it 2,000? Is it 2500? You're in small rural communities I'm aware of that they had this discussion.
They went back to the same price as the rest of the kids in the school because the pressure would have been too great to charge that much for someone in in a small smaller rural school that cost. So, I I just differentiate because the homeschool is very very clear. You you have a lot of rights in homeschool. Uh, again, if you take ESA, I wouldn't call them homeschoolers taking ESA because I think back to your point, I think sometimes when people come in and they say, "What are you?" and they say, "Homes school." If you don't know to ask the rest of the question, then you're assuming they're a homeschooler and you're assuming a set of rules apply to them. And in fact, they may be receiving an ESA, and that creates an issue. So, I I think we really want to separate that. You could take it a step further because um somebody that is a homeschooler that's not this is where it gets remember we just or I just said it's a big hot mess and the deeper that you get the messier that it gets.
So here's where it gets messier. You could use the exact same curriculum that I I purchase all of my own curriculum. I teach all of my own curriculum. I do not outsource um with the exception of originally I did allow my children to come and take electives here and now I have two full-time enrolled students at Combmes High School. And I'll get to that point in a second. Um, some another homeschooler, I'll just we'll use air quotes on this one. Another homeschooler, I don't take any ESA funds. I never have. another homeschooler that's using my ex mirroring me to a tea can take the ESA funds not go to Prima Vera or wherever online use my exact same curriculum and they can be reimbursed for or have ESA paid direct through class wallet as a vendor for their curriculum and so then technically they're they are the same as me but they're using the ESA funds so then going back to our policy that we reviewed and approved recently regarding starting if we would really like those kids that are taking an online school, we would like to convert them over to comb center for success.
Should we decide to entertain this further? That would be where we could say, okay, you're taking ESA funds, do you use an online school? And this is where we have to start. If we're going to compete against the likes of the I there's like six or seven high schools that we're competing with that siphon kids out of the out of the area. If we're going to compete with them, we have to start looking at it as a business. And so that's when we would ask them just like um Mr. Fountain was uh Dr. Fountain was speaking to cars earlier and you kind of ask them a little bit more as the salesperson, right? And so we would say, okay, you're taking ESA funds, you're going to an online school. That might be one of our stipulations. I'm just throwing ideas out there. And that stipulation for you is a little bit different than the kid that's pure true blue homeschooler.