Um, we did check with the village. the village of Kerry uses uh the YouTube platform and they gave us information about the type of equipment that they have and uh essentially what we would need. What's unclear is and I listed the type of equipment there. We have to do more research into what whether or not any of our current equipment would be compatible as well as what are the different features that the YouTube platform and the way that we want to record the meetings requires before we can figure out what the SMP 351 device needs as far as add-ons, encoders, software, things like that. Um the the you know the b real benefit here not only the the cost but the uh live closed captioning is actually available and it's available in multiple languages which is helpful. Um this the staff time is still on average seven hours per month.
It would also add some more time to Mrs. Dorflur's uh doing the minutes because there would not be audio transcripts available at the minutes. Um and we need the time to research the equipment needs. Um, one thing I put about this is this is just an unfortunate time of year to try to be looking at a new technology. It isn't that we can't do it, but the summer is the absolute busiest time for our tech team. every single member of the tech team is engaged every single day getting uh more than 2,000 iPads prepared, updating uh the 400 or so um uh computers that we have, laptops we have, um updating software, updating curricular information and materials that are needed on the iPads, the testing that's going to be new for this year. We also have big projects going on with building renovations as well as the audio enhancement, which is huge and involves a lot of tech.
So our our tech team, which is normally kind of straight out in July, is sort of doubled up right now with all of the kind of big projects that we have going on, too. So I'm not sure that between now and uh when we would need to put this in place, which would be by August, since this is going to expire August 11th, that we would be ready and have all the information and or all the equipment purchased that we would need to go with uh YouTube starting as soon as next month. Um, we did look at live streaming with Google Meet and Google Meet does not because that's free, but that doesn't support the uh the platform of doing this type of a meeting. We also talked about last month and brought forward um the possibility of not live streaming. So, if we did not live stream, it certainly saves money.
There is no cost to doing that and it does save the impact on the staff in terms of the time it takes in the meetings. Um, so there's a savings to that. No equipment would need to be placed. Interested community members of course can always still come to a live meeting. I know we don't have a lot of people here um but there would be in the future no ability to watch the live stream and no ability to watch the meetings that are um posted online. On the other hand, we talked about this last month too. There are fewer than five audience members on average viewing live and the people who go back and view it later on live stream view for an average of less than four minutes at a time. So it's it's relatively low use. And then another option we did that again would be without live stream would be um no live stream but add an email bulletin.
So what there were two ways that we talked about doing that um one that I think would take the least staff time would be to have the uh the minutes that Mrs. Dorfler already takes and uh take those make bullet points and then distribute that information through an email list, post it online on our website um so that we could have direct communication going from the school to the staff which we don't have that right now. People can go and access it um but right now they're not actually accessing it very often, but we could then even have community members if they're interested get added to an email list that we could send that out. We also talked about the potential of having um Jessica Neil, who does all of our social media stuff, actually come to the meetings and she could take the notes.
Um but in talking about that, that would then add back in the staff time that it's taking right now, as well as it would be one more step. We'd have one person doing minutes and a different person doing notes and there'd be a little more confusion around what information is it that we're taking from the meeting and putting out there publicly instead of just doing a summary of each of the things. Um, the email bulletin again would be created using the minutes and could be sent out directly and I I do think it would increase at least the number of people getting the information. Whether or not they read it, we don't know, but at least it would be out there for people to see. So, these are the different options that we have. Um, what I would say is if if we do want to continue with the live streaming, we may want to really seriously consider whether we want to up Zoom for one more year or at least for another two months.
So, we have some time for our tech team to really be able to dive in, make sure we know exactly what type of equipment and what the real costs will be associated with um going with YouTube. If we um decide to go with to no live stream, then we would need to in a future board meeting update policy 2220, which now right now requires us to um record and post, which is not a big deal, but just so that we remember that.
So, with that, I'll open it up any discussion that the board has or questions that you have. >> I want I something has been killing me since they said it. Um, during the superintendent search presentation, they use Zoom. >> Did everyone else hear that? >> Yes, but I heard it's like a placeholder for any sort of virtual meeting space, not necessarily like Zoom specific. >> Y It's sorry >> that people don't want to show up for interviews. They want to do them at home or people want to be able to ask their questions at home on their time. They don't want to come sit here for 45 minutes. But >> I was like, "Oh man." >> Right. >> I hope but if they're reaching out to like the community and stuff, is the community still on Zoom? Are other people >> That's a good question.
>> are just using that. That's what I'm I'm just wondering about that. >> I can answer that question. So, we don't have if we got rid of Zoom, we wouldn't have a Zoom account to host to invite someone to come to. If someone else has a Zoom account, you can attend that. You don't need to have a Zoom account to attend their meeting. So, for them, if they were doing Zoom interviews, that's not through our Zoom account. Anybody, >> you wouldn't even need to have like I could never have had Zoom but still attend their Zoom meeting because they're the ones paying for it. Okay. >> If that makes sense. >> No, that makes sense. And I like it. Um Okay. I just wanted to be sure that we weren't going to like >> Right. Exactly. Um I'll just listen to what you guys have to say.
I have a feeling. So, um my position and I feel like the board, we've had a lot of conversations about transparency. So, I don't feel good about taking away recording meetings in general. I don't have a problem with the idea of recording the meeting and then hosting it on YouTube. So, it's not a live stream. It's come to the meeting if you want to see it live. If you want to see it recorded, then it's there the next day, but then we actually have the transparency and the recorded history of what happened at a board meeting. Is there ever a question about it? I don't know. I don't know that anyone's going back and looking at the archives or looking at it for more than 4 minutes, but it is there. meaning we are not attempting to hide something. There's going to be a lifelong record of it.
And I think so my vote falls in the I don't care as much about the live streaming as I do about the fidelity of recording it. >> Yeah, I think transparency is an issue. Um and it's important uh especially given the gravity of the search that we're about to to undertake again. um and having that opportunity for the community members not necessarily to sit at home with their bowl of popcorn and watch financial reports for Mr. Shepard, but uh but be able to review that on their own time. Um and being able to do that. So, I don't know if that's Mr. Mr. Fitz Simmons, I don't know if that's just getting a camera out here and hitting record and having one of your crew upload it the next morning or what that looks like um combin versus like what we're doing now. But I would agree with Miss Herman that we the live stream isn't as important as the recording.
So, it's not quite as simple as just putting a camera in front of um because we have to capture the audio from all 15 or so microphones that we have around the room right now. And just having it come through the speakers and picked up by the camera is not going to work. Uh we have a hard enough time picking up when the kids do the presentations, we have a hard enough time picking up their audio and we have a microphone sitting right in front of them. Uh, so it's a little bit more complicated than just putting a camera in front of you guys and hitting record. >> Again, I know I'm like on a different page, but I've thought about this for like the past month, and like my 5-year-old has more hits on his YouTube than some of our board meetings. Uh, Dr.
White's videos had triple what we have on our board meetings. And I don't think that it's a lack of transparency, especially if we're putting out a bulletin. Um, we have been transparent and during like I I know during the referendum process that was like a huge process and never once did I have someone come up to me and say, "Oh, you're not being transparent." Like I don't hear that. maybe four years ago when things were all crazy with co there was a push for like something like this but I don't hear that in the community that we are not transparent and you talk about like the gravity of being on a superintendent search we're not talking about that in every board meeting what we're discussing in close session about a superintendent search so I don't see how the community is getting information about that from this and I still see it as like a burden on you on Laura on our staff for 4 minutes.
I And I know we brought like something was brought up last time about great conversation. Yeah. But nobody's watching it. So like I'm busy. I have I I've helped coach sports. I'm a Girl Scout leader and I still show up. When I want to go to the village ones, I show up and like I ask questions and I'm insanely busy, but I also have a desire to like learn. So I feel like there's got to be held accountability on both sides, too. Um like we have Nancy who comes all the time. She's and of course we know um Michelle comes all the time. Like these people want to be involved. We've given four years of this with nobody taking biting it. Nobody taking it. So I just don't know if it's as valid anymore, especially if we have an option to send out the minutes of what is happening because I think someone's more likely to read an email than come sit on YouTube.
I've missed meetings and I've sat on YouTube and it's not that exciting to watch the playback like and I'm a board member and I don't think I've been on for more than four minutes. So I skim through and get the gist. So I just think it's a burden that's not giving much back. And I think so I'm just I don't think it's not being transparent. I think we should look at other options than continuing to be a burden on I guess time on time. Like you sit there and watch us for hours on end, but nobody else is watching us. So I just it doesn't make sense to me anymore. >> So are you advocating for no live streaming or no recording or both? I think it's like if we can give someone a bulletin of minutes, I think someone's more likely to open up their email and read the minutes, read what these bulletins have to say.
Um, than sit and watch a video. I don't because if you don't have time to come here, then you don't have time to go sit and watch a video. And it's clearly not >> a burden more on Laura if she's got to do the minutes and send out the emails and all that. Isn't that more of a burden that you were saying you're trying to >> but it's still saying it's a burden then it's still saying it's a burden on staff impact if we're live streaming and posting it to YouTube too. >> I sort of agree with Mindy where the live streaming isn't as much of an issue for me as making sure it's posted but posted in a timely manner. Not months or weeks later but like 24 48 hours. That would be like my thought on it. Like I get the live streaming that makes sense.
Um but I do I do agree with we should record it. Um my question too though is who is researching the different platforms? You're saying you haven't they haven't del delved into that yet? Um so it's actually all of us have been had a piece of that. Uh Mr. Rivera, Mr. Shepard, uh Mr. Fitzim, we've all actually done pieces of this. Um and the so these were the ones that were the most obvious that were uh platforms either we already had access to or knew how to use or um like with the YouTube we use it in part we do use it for the posting part. >> Um the other thing I just also want to say so that the board knows in terms of transparency prior to us live streaming or recording meetings at all we are required to do audio recordings of meetings.
So, we have audio recordings of board and committee meetings going back since before I was here probably. Um, so there is even if we didn't record uh visually, we do have to do audio recordings. And so that's what we would do if we weren't going to be uh live streaming or not is kind of it it almost doesn't matter if we're going to video record. It's as easy to live stream is not in a way because we still have to have staff here to do all the equipment and microphones and all those kinds of things. Um, but there's if we didn't do any video recording, we are still required to audio record and those tapes have to be kept on file. Again, we didn't have anybody ever knocking our doors down to try to get the audio recordings, but they are there and they are of the entire conversation that happens.
Your comment, I I'm going to ask a question off the fly and Mr. Fitz Simmons, if you can't answer it right now, that's totally okay. Um, is there a difference in time or effort if we if we turned the camera off and we were just doing the mic setup and the audio recording? Does that change the burden dramatically or substantially even? >> We would have to find a new solution to record the audio. Uh, right now Zoom is handling both the video and the audio transcripts of the meetings. Um, so we'd have to find a new means to do the audio recording uh if we just turned off the camera and kept everything else. >> And Dr. Thomas, was the audio recording is that like the dictaphone for all of us or was there something more robust that was doing the audio recording once upon a time?
I don't remember it. >> It was a digital recorder that just like sat right out here in front of um either the superintendent or the board president and it it was sensitive enough to pick everybody up. sort of like you use in close session. So I guess kind of getting an idea of what board members are in favor of keeping live streaming and ones that are not. And this way we know how to move forward and to consider continuing to look for other alternate programs or whatever. Um just a general consensus. >> I sorry I was just going to say I think we should extend it for two months Zoom and research and then you know have more that's fine. >> I feel like we should I I think that what I'm hearing is the majority of us feel like some kind of recording should be available.