2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Board Study Session · passage 4
So, one of the things I'm very excited about in our work today is that it is still August and we'll be looking at um proposed interim measures not only for our goals but also for all of our guardrails today um in addition to the data sets that drove the recommendation of those particular interim measures. And um the hope is that we'll get feedback from the board today. we'll make any adjustments and then we'll bring those interim measures back to Tuesday's meeting and we'll actually be able to um start only 3 weeks into the school year, you know, and we'll we'll already know what those measures are cuz we we met with our principles last Thursday. They were all very agitated like when are we going to know if these are the final goals or not, right? like um cuz they're they're rocking their roll and and we make sure that we're setting ourselves up for success by being able to create clarity around what we're all working on this year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 5
it is not a predictor or it's not a cause and effect relationship. So, um I was trying to figure out what's the best way to describe it. So, if you think about size of your foot and a shoe, okay, shoes have lots of different shapes, sizes, qualities. Some run long, some run short, some run wide. I have a very skinny, narrow foot and I can't fit into anything. So, I have to have one type of shoe that fits my little foot. A correlation coefficient is the relationship between the two. So if I have an 11 and a half foot and I find a shoe, these are on running shoes and that 11 and 1/2 fits my foot, I have a very high correlation. If however I go to a Nike shoe and I have a 11 and a half and I buy 11 and a half shoe and it's too long, I would have a lower correlation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Board Study Session · passage 5
So that's for me that's the most important thing is I want to make sure that we're designing the system so that way we are allowing everyone in the system to be able to achieve success because we're giving them clarity around what we're doing, why we're doing it, and how we're doing it. So, um, so that's kind of my intro. Um, and with that, I'm going to turn over to Dr. Ramos for the facilitation because he's really the expert on how this process will work. We in your packets today, um, there are sets of data and also the interim measures and our progress monitoring reports um, from throughout last year for goal one that we'll use later in the day um, as we talk about improving our question process. Thank you, Mr. Man. And before we turn it over to Dr. Romos, I do want to set some ground rules that this is going to be an open conversation, but also we should not be looking at the data as a good or a bad thing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 6
Okay. So, it's how closely the two things are um related or how they're alike. So, the closer to one we get, the higher the correlation. We can go the other way, too. And you can go to zero to negative, which means there's no correlation. And so, what we're doing is we're trying to correlate AASA, which is a very robust assessment that students take over three days. Um for for math, there's two parts to it. Um, it's well over a hundred and something questions. There's multiple parts to it. Obviously, we're not going to put our kids through that. So, we have from our vendor uh a mimic or a not a sample, but it's a smaller version. That's 30 35 questions. We're trying to figure out what's the likelihood of a kid scoring something on one versus the likelihood of kids scoring the same on the other.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Board Study Session · passage 6
Literally, this work is for us to see where our students are, what we need to do to make sure we're moving the needle for them, and have these candid conversations, but also not use this data as something of, oh, people haven't been doing their job or whatever the case is. That's not the space for this. This is really for us to collaborate, come together, and really focus on the data to make sure that our students are going to have the tools they need to start moving the needle on their outcomes. So, I just wanted to ground that. And with that, I'll turn it over to Dr. Ramos. >> Yeah, that's fine. I I believe it is on. Yes. >> And and before Dr. Ramos starts, I just want to thank you, Madam President, because you know me, I always have to sneak in the phrase vertical articulation, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 7
So, the higher the number, the closer the closer that we get. You want me to explain the reason the three? I'll go. >> You're good. Okay. >> And then I'll I'll ask No, no. I'll ask you. >> Get out of the way. >> No, we're a team. We're a team. Okay. So then I after we Vanessa and I went to that cohort training. I said, Tyson, we need to have 6 or higher. How do we do that? So So you're like, I don't know. So um he went to our uh testing company, which is Renaissance, and asked them to do a study for us, for our students. So this right here in the orange is our students. Um, and so that's why it says CSDR Kraton School District analysis. And we asked them to do look at our 500 eighth graders in math um, and look to see what would be the closest relationship to how they're doing throughout the year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Board Study Session · passage 7
So um what you just described you know so I've learned a lot about data wise from Dr. Pombo and our team. And so what you just described is also the data wise approach that we use with the staff because rather than looking to seek blame and shame, we look to determine what our problems of practice are because if we truly want to focus on improving student outcomes, we don't do that by pointing fingers at people because I am the genesis. We do that by um determining what can we improve, what can we do better, and what inputs are ultimately going to provide us the outcomes we're looking for as measured by the outputs that we're that we're watching, which is why our work with our interim guard rails is going to be so important today. So, sorry to kind of jump on that, but I just I was kind of touched by like the alignment that exists there and that, you know, we're really trying to create that alignment throughout the system.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 8
Because when they take the assessment, if I'm an eighth grader, it has all the standards I need to learn by the end of eighth grade year. So if I take it in the beginning of year, I probably don't know any of those standards. So most of our kids are going to score low and that's why it looks red all year long. Um and so this is showing uh the cut scores what how our students did um for each assessment and then how they ended up at the end kind of like the um relationship at the end. So you can see before our cut score for like uh minimally proficient was they had to get 0 to 39 would be mentally proficient. Now it's 0 to 19. And then to be partially proficient, it's 20 to 27. And to be um proficient is 28 to 39.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Board Study Session · passage 8
And I'm so happy that we have an actual data framework or set or program that already has that. So it's really aligned to the work that we're doing here on the board. So thank you for sharing that, Mr. Man. Dr. Ramos. >> Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 9
And then 40 is actually highly proficient if they got a 40. 40 to 100. And that's at the very beginning of the year before they've been taught anything on the eighth grade standards. So that's where they're um those are our cut score. So they did our 500 students. So based on this for the just for the pre-est we have a 6 almost.7 correlation. Did you have a question? >> Yeah, I just wanted to to make sure I've got it clear. So what on that first line math pretest? So then those are the the cut scores based on what they would have learned or sorry I want to make sure I'm >> they might become late. So since they haven't learned everything, if they score that then if they score 40, even though you would think, oh 40 is low, but since it's beginning of the year and they haven't learned everything, it's actually is highly proficient.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Board Study Session · passage 9
Well, good morning everyone. Um it's good to see you all. This is an opportunity to try to break this down into like the simplest of terms, meaning um as you've got your board goals posted. question that I'd love to ask you is, are you on track or not on track to meet each goal? And that's a question I'm asking. Do you know if you're on track or not on track to meet goal number one, which is eighth grade students that score minimally proficient on ASA math will decrease from 73% on August 2023 to 48% by August 2028? Do you know the answer to that question? >> I do. You do. What is the answer? >> No. And do you know why not? >> Um, yes. There's a couple reasons why. And I think one of the biggest ones was I think the assessment that we had and the coaching that was being involved with our own teachers in math needed to expand, but it it had a lot to do with the curriculum and the professional development that we were doing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 10
>> Yes. And so it's saying that they have some type of foundational preparedness for um eighth grade. And then go ahead J. >> I just wanted to add because this came up in our leadership council meeting last week. So, and and I am not correcting what you said, but I just want to create clarity around this because I think it's important that all of us help parents with this. If they score 42, let's say, it does not mean the child is highly proficient. It means they are on track to be highly proficient. They still need to grow. And so, one of the problems that we have sometimes is a kid goes home and says, "Hey, look, mom, I'm highly proficient." And mom's like, "This is amazing. My child's arrived." But if that child doesn't have any learning over the course of the year, they are not going to end the year highly proficient.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Board Study Session · passage 10
>> Got it. Okay. And that and that's really the way I'd love for you to enter these progress monitoring sessions when you're at the board meetings. It's for you to for you to walk out of here knowing are we on track, not on track. And if we are, why? And if we're not, why not? And then of course, if you're not, you're likely going to be asking the questions, well, what's what's the plan?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 11
>> This is where they have to be between 63 and 100 at the end of the year to be highly proficient. >> Right. >> Rather than 40. >> Exactly. But what but what the statistic is telling us is if they start the year at 42 and all other things being equal that you know as far as that they're getting what we would expect from them as far as their growth over the course of the year. So, it's not like they're absent 60 days that year. They're not, you know, they're not skipping all their homework, you know, um they're not in a situation where they don't have a teacher in the classroom for some reason. Assuming everything goes the way it should go over the course of the year, then that 42 tells us that they should be able to grow those additional 21 points they need to grow in order for that score to exist on that post test.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 12
which means that there is a nearly 77% likelihood that when they take the AASA test, they will score on the AASA test as highly proficient. So, I just I just and I apologize. I'm probably overexplaining. >> No, no, no. I think that's good because if they stayed at 42, if you look at the post test, they would be partly partially proficient. So, and and when we're looking at these cut scores, we're noticing no matter what category the students start in, they have to grow around 20 by the end of the year. 20 percentage points. Um, which is not We were We're kind of guessing like probably like four questions or something like that. They have to get right four more questions to get right to move um a level. I know. Isn't that pretty crazy? So, this is just an example of eighth grade. So, the other thing to show, so if I was a a student and I scored 19 on the pretest, like we're just we just finished taking the pretest, then I know to move a level just for the next test, I would have to get a 25.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 13
Do you see how the next test is 25? Um, and then you could see, but by the end of the year to stay in that section, they have to get between 34 and 47 to move that level. So, if they started out at 19, um, that student would only have to move like 15 points, right? or 16 points. They're all around 20 point move a level. Some are more, some are less depending where they start in the actual area. >> Now, are these cut scores drivers of what our interim measures will be? Okay. >> So, what we um and then the other one and we'll just tell you why we didn't pick this. So, this was done on our Kraton students, our eighth graders, and it was done for all of our grade levels for both reading and math. So, we have that one document you have has all the cut scores for all the grade levels.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 14
I'll go over that in a minute. Um now this is the other one where they did a study on five districts um right five districts or all the districts just five districts to come up with cut scores and you can see that one has a higher correlation but we did not go with this one because this was done in November 2024 and these are based off our May 2025 test scores um and so when they do a new study we could consider changing to those cut scores but right now we wanted to do off of our students So when we Yeah. Our kids >> I agree. >> Sorry. >> does it is Renaissance like doing all this with for not extra money? I guess I'm just asking. Okay, >> cool. >> Their research department. Yes. Thank you. So that that's the um rationale behind the cut scores why we are switching cut scores.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 15
And the reason why that's important is if we adopt these interim measures that we're going to go over in a little bit, it will show that we're doing better because we won't have all the kids in red all year. It'll show kids going from red to yellow. There'll be more yellow, green, and blue. And so we'll show you an example of that. And I'll have Tyson show that go do this part. You want to show the example? >> So here's um eighth grade math from uh under the old 40 60 80. So if we look at uh last year's pretest, eighth grade kids came in second week of school, we take the pre-EST. This is 40 60 80. And you can see we call this the sea of red. So we're seeing a lot of kids that are mentally proficient because the cut scores are so high at that 40 60s passing 80 is above.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 16
And so and that was the the lower if you remember if you look at the the correlation coefficient the correlation coefficient for this is very low at 0.5. So pretty much 6 and above is a strong relationship. So that red is not giving is not a strong relationship of how they're going to be at the end of the year. >> Right? >> So when we take and apply the new set of cut scores, if you look at the pie chart here, we notice that now we've got a more representative indicator of where our kids are at. So no longer am I at the 78 or 79, it's dropped down to 72. I also start to see a little bit of blue. So, those are our highly proficient kids as well as some proficient, partially proficient. So, it's more representative and we have a higher correlation of how they're going to be um at the end of the year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 17
>> Questions? >> Can I just throw two notes out there? One is there's there's two ways this benefits us. The first way that it benefits us is when we come and we do um progress monitoring reports with the board, you're going to see a more accurate reflection of of sort of what's predicted to be the outcome. Like Dr. Ramos uses the example of the game. It's a more accurate reflection of what the score might be at the end of the game, right? Um because if you think about it like odds in Vegas of a basketball team winning a game 0.51 it's just slightly better than a coin flip right so we're saying oh we're going to make determinations about what's happening with our students on you know pretty close to a 50/50 shot of being right which is I think why SOFG uses that 6 or above.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above