2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 138
This shouldn't be a place of like, oh my god, I need to be on my best behavior. It's like no, we need to see what's or they need to see what's going on live in order for them to be able to make solidified decisions on interims and what needs to be changed to be pivoting. So I always always say this and I will always say this is not a good thing. This is not a bad thing. This is figuring out where our gaps have been for years and making sure that we're moving the scale al together so we can see the progress in our outcomes. But thank you for sharing that and I do not want teachers doing that and that has to do with culture. So I'm hoping that all the principles are at the schools are having these conversations with their staff on whether they're coming or not.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 139
Don't be anxious if things are not occurring the way they need to. That's the perfect time so we can pivot. And it is what it is. >> You're right. We do need to change that culture because I mean I know like it spreads like wildfire fire on our campuses when when you know somebody from district comes like it you know everybody's calling each other. So, um I I feel like that does need to be something because I think it's a valuable tool >> going on in the classroom um without knowing. Um I understand the anxiety because of course I've had people in my room before too, but um I do agree with you. I think it's more important that we're getting the the correct data rather than and we don't get names, right? >> No. >> We don't get names principal knows names. >> No.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 140
Yeah. and and and so that's just something that I think for um maybe you know people that are listening um the staff to know that we just want to know if um you know the tools that that they're they're being given is sufficient for them to be effective teachers in the classroom. >> Yeah. >> And all the data has helped us with our inputs like what our teachers need um by doing those learning walks like oh and then also working with their leadership team and having those discussions and learning from each other. So, it's all been very helpful with inputs with professional development and coaching. Um, but yes, we definitely want to change that culture where people are I'm excited. I want someone to come serve me so I can get some feedback or what types of help do I need to be better >> and I I I'm going to I mean this is kind of raw and live so I don't mind being an idiot as you've all over the years.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 141
So, but but I'm going to make a supposition because I I was able to join one of the first learning actually was the first learning walk we did this year, right? So, I was at um Kennedy School for our first learning walk. It this is day four of school. And so my experience there, I know the team's actually done one or two more since then that I I was unfortunately unable to join them for, but my experience at least at that school and and I'm hoping that it's the same experience people have had elsewhere was that going into those classrooms on that day, the level of comfort that both the teachers and the students had with the observers being in their room felt different than when we went into classrooms last year. it felt like there was like a higher comfort level, you know, with having us present in the room.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 142
And I think part of that is us being very intentional about how the feedback is provided. So, I know one of the things that we do is, you know, they have things called glows and grows. You know, you leave these little notes. Some, you know, people have been teachers have probably experienced that. But that, you know, is part of our process. And there was even a lot of intentionality. I really appreciated this. So Martha Hernandez, who's the principal at Kennedy when we were doing our prep before we did our walk, said, "Our school has a lot of windows." So you're going to go in a room, you're going to observe, your team's going to leave, and then you're going to want to have a conversation about what you observed. Please move away from the window because otherwise the teachers are seeing you having the conversation about them outside of the classroom.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 143
So I guess the two things that I'm that I'm trying to point to is there is a lot of intentionality and I appreciate the team. I know um the coaches and and the coordinators and the whole CIA team have been working really hard on this in partnership with the principles and assistant principles um and even with getting feedback from the teachers themselves, but they're really trying to to structure the process and be intentional about what the intention of it is and and not having it be something that's a stressor or, you know, feels punitive or or um >> negative in some way. And then I kind of want to check with the team like I don't know what I didn't get to ask. So this is probably not a stupid thing for me to do in a public meeting but I'm just kind of curious if you had a similar experience at the other schools where you felt like you know first two weeks of school but it it was a better being in the classroom experience than it may have been last year and just answer honestly.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 144
>> Yeah, this is exactly what we're here for. putting them on the spot. And if you didn't have any experience then that should be tilt too like it's okay you know it culture takes longer I feel to heal and to fix than outcomes to be honest academic outcomes seem so far out but there's certain things that we could put in place and shift the needle culture is a little bit different so if that's not the feeling that's okay that just means that we need to do extra love maybe on that site or whatever that looks like >> well and we need the honesty so we know that we can adjust and also as Dr. Ramos has taught us parallel processing is important. So how we have these conversations in here and the tone that we set in our conversations around data trickles through the system as to how that those conversations end up being with the teachers.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 145
>> I was going to share that um I wasn't there for that first week because I was sick. I had I was really sick so I didn't get a chance to my first one's going to be on Monday actually. But I do want to share to go back to your question too is that we've asked teachers what would make you feel more comfortable when we come in. So we set norms and the norms that we set things that they've asked us to do like don't talk while you're in here because we always go in pairs and and I'm guilty of that because sometimes I'll say Tyson what did they say and I can't do that because that comes across as like disrespectful to the teacher. The other thing they ask is like don't go talk where other people are around. We know you're debriefing but try to do that in a more private area.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 146
They've asked to please leave them a note. So, we always leave them a note. We've designed little data wise cards to leave them a note. >> Oh, I love that. >> Um they've asked us to, you know, kind of get they there's just like a list of norms that we go over and that teachers have asked us to do. So, we go over that um before we even do the learning walks as a reminder to everybody. One of them that we've told them that we're going to do is do evidence-based observations only. So instead of saying I'm just giving an example of all the kids were out of control in that class which is a not evidence-based I would say you know 10 out of 20 kids were out of their seats. >> Okay. >> And so you put only evidence-based data on any of our observations so they know there's no judgment.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 147
We're just trying to gather data to understand what's happening in the classroom so we can support better. Um so that's one of the things that we've done to make sure help our teachers feel more comfortable with every people coming in. And I think over time, like you're saying, it's like they're coming in and I'm like, you know, and they're going to give our our school feedback that we've been working on because all the schools also have data wise action plans that they're working on. So they want to know how they did on the learning walk. And last year towards the end, they were starting to say, "Tell me how I did right now." You know, I want to know and so they're getting excited about getting the feedback. So that's what happened over time last year. And then >> Dr. thoughts. >> Okay. Uh the only thing I would add, uh the learning walks were new for me this year being my first year in Kraton.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 148
Um one thing I think to the topic of culture is I think the more we are visible for our teachers, the more they feel more comfortable. Um one example I can give is I was in a classroom, the teacher had the ability to talk with us and I said, "You look so familiar to me." She's like, "I think we were stuffing backpacks together." And so and that was our connection. And so we did recognize each other. So I think the more we are in classrooms, the more people become familiar with us and it's less intimidating because we're in this together and you know we're all looking at it from a different point of view and then I know um every team takes it back to their team to see what can we do to better support our teachers and so for me I found them to be very positive in the first two days of school um or first week of school last two days of the week but um they were valuable.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 149
>> Thank you Dr. Dr. Pombo for um letting us know that there are some kind of norms. So that way teachers that we would now we know that at least there's some kind of norm going in there so they don't feel some type of way. And thank you for sharing that as a new employee because that's always a good sense to feel does this seem right? Does this seem wrong? How are teachers feeling? And for somebody who has a brand new perspective, I'm I'm happy to hear that that was your experience. >> So this is our last one, our guardrail four.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 150
Any questions? Yes. Uh this is a a wondering and I'm just wondering if there is something like an interim measure outside of learning walks that can be adopted or that we could come up with because I just just a wondering and it no that doesn't need to be answered. It's yeah you know because I I I know it's hard. I mean, we we absolutely could. Um what having been part of the conversations around this, we actually leaned further into learning lock data because even though these um guardrails aren't necessarily intended to be related to the goals, one of the things we're finding is that these shifts are what are having a significant impact on the positive results we're seeing. So where we're seeing change happening, we're seeing it correlate to the improvement in those goals. So if you were to look at our two schools that made significant gains last year, that the 10point shift school and the 15point shift school, there were significant increases in learning walk data.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 151
So th that that was sort of a um leading indicator to the lagging indicator of what the result was. So when we when we talk about this one, even though this one is really a guardrail and not a goal, the guardrail is about adult convenience versus progress of students. And so we can give you a different indicator or a different interim measure, but it will not be as highly accurate a predictor, I shouldn't say predictor, correlator um as using the learning walk data based on what we saw last year. So, we used some other things last year and um they you know we measured them and we did okay on them but we really didn't see that they were doing a great job of reflecting are are we focusing on academic progress versus the students needs in order to be able to achieve those student outcomes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 152
So that's that's my simple answer. We ab if the board desires something that is not learning walk related we can absolutely make a change and deliver that. I just don't think it will be as functionally useful as these three measures would be >> and uh Mr. Man excuse me for a second miss um can you just let us know where the walking rubrics are pulled from? Is that a data waist thing? Is that a Danielson's framework or where is that walking rubric um specifically from? >> It's from the Danielson framework and then parts of it are from a learning target success criteria book to like get more detailed with learning targets and success criteria but most of it's from Danielson and Danielson is a pretty long rubric. So it's just pieces that we're working on from Danielson. >> And Danielson is the one that we just updated SWAP not too long ago because they even expanded more of their framework to align to the things that we're doing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 153
So, that was interesting. Um, that's all I had to say. >> I'm just going to say I can honestly say like with the way that you've the >> Can you speak a little bit closer to the mic, please? >> Sorry, it sounds like it's not very loud at all. Um maybe >> I'm just saying like um the way that you've explained the learning um walk rubrics and the way that you're doing them and the way that it sounds like um the feedback from teachers and things like that um as a teacher myself like we crave we crave that feedback, right? Um just like our kids crave that feedback. And so having these learning walk rubrics um I think are a good telltale sign especially with the principles being on board because they're probably doing their own learning walks as well, right? And so um you're just capturing that small like moment in time when you guys go through but principles know, other teachers know, and you guys know if adult convenience is getting in the way because you can see it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 154
You can almost immediately see it. um even another teacher going into to see somebody else teach, you can see it immediately. So, um that was just my two cents with, you know, being an educator and being in education. >> Yeah, thank you for sharing that. And one last thing I'll share about the guardrails is that it says in in the book, right, guardrails create the non-negotiables that must be honored while moving through the goals on the way to the vision for improved student outcomes. So, our walkthroughs literally are one of the biggest indicators to see if there is going to be improved student outcomes because if we're at a lower letter level of three, that's a direct indicator of maybe something's going off in the classroom, not necessarily to the teacher's fault, but PD, whatever it may be. And if we're not getting the grasp of the basics, it's almost like we even though we've been operating since the 1800s, there's a lot of system changes that we barely are kicking in in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 155
And we do have to work from zero. Um I remember some of our last year's guard rails, we had a lot of zero pretend to something because it was something new that we were doing. Even though it existed in the realm of the things that we were doing, it wasn't as direct. It wasn't as specific. And these guard rails, although they can be changed, I think it's more for them and their expertise to tell us this is going to be the way that we're going to get our goals while protecting the vision of the community. And one of the biggest things that we did here is how are we supporting our teachers? Why are they not equipped? Then return to speak to our students and help them move the needle. And these walkthroughs have literally been I think one of the magic sauce that have been able to get us to that level.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 156
And it inherently has I in my view um supported our culture too because now teachers feel supported. They have that two-way communication with their administrators, their coaches, and now they're feeling heard. So in return, I believe that that psychologically gives them empowerment to then empower their students and be like, "Hey, now that I feel supported, I feel equipped enough to support you in your journey of learning." >> Well, that this is the last part, so I don't know if Mr. Man or turn over to Dr. Ramos. >> Um Dr. Ramos, it's almost going to be 12:00. We're going to start lunch. So, I don't know if you want to close us off with some reflective moments and then let us know what we're going to be getting into after lunch as well. Thank you. >> Yeah. So, the board as the staff has told you your responsibility is to to u your role is to vote up or down on the interims.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 157
And the reason that is it's the role that you get to play. It's you you don't get to pick the interims, but you get to ask questions and you get to vet them. And if you're not in agreement that these are actually going to get you to where you want to be, then I would first have a conversation with superintendent um and and share your perspective, your feedback. And it's I know it's going to be really difficult to not give advice and tell him what to do if you have a strong push back on a certain interim, but at least have a dialogue with him so that he can get a better understanding of what your expectations are because at the end of the day, remember, you represent the vision and the values. The guard rails are the values of the community and these are pretty important to folks in your community especially based on the feedback that you got.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above