>> I think the part that that um will help the board as well from the staff side is to put the annual target. And so, you did right you it's it's it's in there, but I want to ask the board, what was your what was your annual target for this past school year on the overall goal? cuz you were Yeah. You were going you wanted to go from 73 to 48. Where did you end up this year? >> 79. Okay. So, let me write it up here. >> Good. Yeah. So, the annual goal was 71 because you wanted to this is a decrease goal, right? >> So, if you're a community member, board members, you're saying, "Hey, this is our goal." And then you're going to come, you're going to say, "We're at 79." What are you anticipating? >> Why did it go up? >> Why' it go up?
>> They're going to be Yep. >> What would you say after the conversation you had today with your leadership team and the progress monitoring in June? Not staff board. What would you say? And it's okay if you don't know, but this is the reason I wanted you to walk I wanted to walk you through this because this is what you're really doing at progress monitoring. If you're leaving progress monitoring and you don't know where we're at, how we got there, um we've got we got some we got some gaps to to close. Um and so yeah, they're going to ask you why did it go up >> and you as a board, you don't want superintendent will likely be there, right? >> But you as a board, you're the owners of the system. So you want to be able to articulate to the community, this is what happened.
And guess what? After you tell them how you got there, how this went up, then you're going to tell them the strategy that the superintendent and the leadership team are implementing to get this to go back down. >> What questions, what thoughts, what wonderings do you have about? >> And since you have it right here, I'll give a brief of what that would look like. My response to this would be well based off of all the four progress monitoring reports that we had. One of the biggest things is that we knew that our teachers weren't equipped with the professional development and we did spend a lot of the time through the progress monitoring reports going through mathematical cohorts making sure that our teachers and I know it's a little step back but also what this tells us is that we're being transparent and obviously we have a lot more rigorous work to do.
So we did fail this goal. We backtracked a little bit, but that's I think leads into the new interr will be predictive of all the little things that they were telling us of the inputs, what's working and what's not and what we're going to do this year to make sure that that's moving the needle. That's something that I would just on the top of my head kind of um say this. So that's why it's important for us to know these reports. And one thing I want to add is that this is going to be huge especially when we move into our school board of school because part of us training our community is making sure that if any of them one of these days want to run for office in Kraton that they know that this is the expectation. we're already giving them the tools on how to lead them into these conversations if they want to be making these decisions or continue this monitoring for our students.
So, it's it's important that we have this together. That way, we're not only empowering our community, but we're also empowering the next leaders of Curtain to continue this work and not just be shut down because of somebody that new that comes in. Other thoughts, questions? I hope I hope you're excited about your progress monitoring reports into the new school year. Haven't had a chance to replay the tape of four progress monitoring reports. And I'm I'm excited to see Tuesday's meeting, right, to see what your data what that final um outcome was and how how did it happen. And and I think two things I want to mention. one, when you as a board are going to go and share this with the community here sooner rather than later, um I think staff will hopefully feel some type of pride of that their their board listens to them and is is internalizing the material and now at a point that they're going out and educating the community.
Um and then the other part to this is the the ability to be able to grow as a team and tell the story. There are there are some really good things in these reports. Uh while that's probably going to be a big focus for the everyday person, you also have an opportunity to frame the messaging. And so you want to give a really good balanced report to the community. And so yeah, what we learn, professional development, what we learned, and then these are the strategies that the team is implementing, you're going to elevate the whole district's perspective on what's really happening in your school system. And not only that, but it really solidifies the community feedback that we got when we first did this around, right? We overlywhelmingly heard that they felt teachers weren't certified or they weren't given the need or the things that they needed to teach students.
So, this in a way is saying, "Hey, we heard you. We really honor our teachers and we really do feel that they should have the number one most educated teachers in class." And this reports have told you that we've been taking steps to make sure that teachers are fully equipped in order to teach our students. So we can also tie it back into this is why we do community feedback. It might not look directly how you're saying it, but we are listening and we are changing systems within the district to listen to you guys and pre give you guys outcomes based off of the feedback we got. >> Awesome. I I I find it I find this is a good opportunity for us to practice the importance of distinguishing between technical, tactical, and strategic questions. You have that document in your folder. It is this this one right here.
Yeah, it's this one. So, I I took the liberty of writing three questions that were recently asked at your board meetings that you as board members asked. And I I want us to take a take an opportunity to try to distinguish if if the question that I wrote up here is a technical question, a tactical question or a strategic. But before we go there, we got to disting What are those? Would somebody please um tell us what a technical question is? What does it say in the parenthesis? >> Yeah, trying to understand how something is measured. So you see those examples there based on the goal in the paragraph above as as your sample. So what's the alignment of the portfolio assessment with the SAT or ACT? You're trying to figure out how something is being measured. What is a tactical question? What does it say in parenthesis?
>> Trying to understand how something is done. >> Correct. So to whom is the assessment administered? Which staff have been trained to administer the assessment? How do how do staff feel about the assessment? Those are tactical questions. What is a strategic question? What does it say in the parenthesis? >> Trying to understand how something aligns to priorities. >> That's right. So, this one is a deeper dive. And you'll notice that with the examples that are given there, each one of you submit one strategic question for every progress monitoring report. You've got plenty to monitor because they're going to go take a deep dive. So, this is important for the staff to hear what this is going to look like because um staff, if you're getting like more than 10 questions, you're you're probably spending a heck of a lot of time going and digging up the data and the information.
So, the idea is not to be to to spend a ton of time just to spend a ton of time on progress monitoring. The idea is for you as a board to be clear on are we getting better, are we not? If so, why? And if not, why not? and the the effectiveness is really what we want to see in your board meeting because you're already a pretty disciplined board and I can't wait to share your data with you a little bit. Uh but we're now on the on the course of trying to make you a very effective board. Strategic questions are going to help you get there. So would somebody please read the first paragraph under focus and timing? >> I'll do it. >> Can you put your the mic near you, please? Thank you. >> Thank you. Uh technical questions focus on understanding the details surrounding the assessment and goal details themselves.
Tactical questions focus on understanding the details surrounding implementation of the assessment and goal. Strategic questions focus on understanding relative to the goal what we've learned about system performance and what lessons we've learned from that performance. No questions during an effective monitoring conversation are focused on providing advice to the superintendent board member opinions about system performance or efforts to project to project manage the school system. >> Keep going. >> No, hold on. What are y'all getting from this first paragraph? >> What do you mean? what's coming up for you as you you read that first paragraph as a group >> that it's not about our opinion. >> Yeah, that's part of it for sure. >> I mean, remember right in the training we talked about you have you have you have your educational expert that you've hired your we're going to talk about evaluations a little bit too and that's that's their role, right?
Your role is to ask questions to to to be clear on what's happening. um unless you've been a superintendent and even at that if you've been a superintendent here there's a big gap from where you're sitting to what he's doing on a regular basis as you saw today with the description from the whole team he's responsible for the alignment of everything that you've given him in terms of goals and guard rails that's that's what he that's what his job is. So yeah, and and what I want you to what I really want you to get away from this today, your biggest superpower is asking questions. And the better that question is, the more strategic it is, I think you're going to find how powerful it's going to be for you as a board member. You don't have to worry about telling him what to do.
Even though you might have the urge that you want to tell him what to do, but in asking him a really good strategic question, it's like you're playing defense with him to some degree. Like we're we're backing him up. Like, no, can't let you just show me a shiny penny, superintendent, man. >> Like, I asked you a very specific strategic question with data in it. I'm looking for some answers on this because my job is to trust you and to verify that what we're doing here is moving. Because if you go the whole year again and this number keeps going up, my question to you as a board is how have you been showing up at progress monitoring? Have you zoomed in and asked him the tough questions? And have you have you made sure that before you leave this board meeting that you are convinced that the strategy that they're using is going to turn that data move it down the way you set it out to set the way you wanted it to work.
Does that make sense? >> Yeah. And the other thought that I had, I know that we didn't read the second paragraph. But one of the things that pops up to me is that technical and tactical live within our governing board role, but maybe not when we're conducting business. That I I to me that's a a time for a one-on-one or whatever that looks like because technical and technical are more understanding of the current systems that we have. And in order for us to come up with good strategic questions, we obviously need to have a baseline of what that system looks like. Um it's just that when we're on the board and actually asking these strategic questions, we only get a few hours a month to really get to the bottom of these things and technical and tactical can live in that space. I just don't believe that operating in the few hours that we have on the dis is the appropriate place and this is why it's good for us to start getting used to getting these strategic questions so they live on the board.
>> Go ahead and read that second paragraph for us then because I want I want to give you some feedback on that. >> Technical and tactical questions are often essential to having a full understanding of current system performance. There is nothing wrong with board members asking tech oh technical and technical question. >> Say that again. Read it again for us. >> There is nothing wrong with board members asking technical and tactical questions. Timing matters. However, the superintendent expected to be the strategic leader over the school systems operations during a monitoring conversation with the superintendent. It is unreasonable to expect them to also have a mastery of every technical or tactical detail. So, if school board members want answers to those questions to be part of the monitoring conversation, they need to ask those questions at least 5 to seven days in advance of the monitoring session.
If that hasn't happened, board members are welcome to still ask new technical and tactical questions during the monitoring session, but the board chair and or superintendent should advise them to that those answers will go out in the next update from the superintendent to the board. So simply said, my friends, he he cannot know every single detail if you throw it on him at the spur of the moment. Um you don't want him to give you false information. You don't want them to make anything up. So you also got to continue to create the space because you have uh to let him say, you know what, we don't have that information in front of us right now, but we will gladly get it to you in x amount of days. And then you're right, you read it in that second line. Please do ask follow-up questions.
The follow-up questions are likely going to be more technical and tactical. So, at the board meeting, it's not just you receiving the info. This is supposed to be a dialogue between you and the superintendent and his team. Make sense? All right. Last piece. Will somebody read past >> Jones? Did you have a question or a thought? >> Sorry. Yeah. >> No, it's okay. >> Oh, no. I was just in the meetings I I've observed when we've been given reports I think your team has done an excellent job of like if they don't know the answer they come back and uh it may not be the next meeting but someone will go oh I remember you asking that so I think if we actually went and looked at all our meetings you would see that you know displayed so that was my thought that's what it's going on in my head >> yeah thank you for sharing that though because they have been which I think this makes it easier in the collaboration we have because it's almost like we're working together without you know we ask a question and I have had that instance with two board meetings they're like oh I remember a board member said this and we finally figure it out so yes that's that's great work in itself already >> I mean to me asking the technical and the tactical like other board members could have the same question but also isn't it being very um transparent for a community who probably does not understand like a lot of you know maybe what we're measuring or things like that.
So to be transparent like asking those questions I think are also important in front of our community um so they get >> 100%. Yeah. And um yes, absolutely. And I think once we do a study session on two-way communication, that's why it's so important for us to be out in the community and giving these conversations to them because when they get to the board level, then they kind of have a minimal understanding. But that to me that fall by back on us. you know, if our community members watching our board meeting and they don't understand, then we've done we were lacking in our two-way communication to make sure they are up to speed. Um, I think historically, yes, our board meetings are open for community because they should know, but our business should be board operating business and we should be out not expecting them to show up and understand everything while we're conducting our business here.
This business time is really this conversation. How are we going to pivot? what are we doing? And then the understanding and having that two-way communication I think is so important because to me this is more engagement not nec or outreach no engagement not outreach and outreach is where all those other things will live in there of this is why we do this this is why we're having this two-way ask your questions here by the time they get here it's a fluid understanding >> please ask questions >> yeah and the as you work through this, you we're going to go to this other document a little bit. I'm going to give you something that can help you guide into designing even more effective questions. The idea is for you to be able to zoom in and allow the superintendent and them to go get you the information and bring it back to you at the board meeting.
You bring up a good point, Heather, because if if you ask the same question as someone else on the board does, someone should probably be monitoring those questions. And it's usually the board president, by the way, or the board officers who will will keep track. And then that way Tristan if you submit a question. Oh, okay. Well, Nicole already asked that question. You know, is there is there something else on the report that you're wondering about um that will be helpful if if as you move through progress monitoring. Now, the other thing is, and I haven't said it, but let me be very very clear. Most board members don't read their packets before the board meeting. So, you have been working to change that behavior and you're preparing for meetings, you're submitting questions. um that that typically is about a five six month journey for most boards.