So you you are demonstrating that you are reading your packets and that you're submitting questions because you're even putting the questions up on the screen for people to follow along. I will invite you to to watch just a random board meeting around the state or around the country. That is not the norm. So you're modeling parallel processing for a lot of the folks. Would somebody please read past versus future because this is really important as well. >> I'll read it. >> Regardless of whether or not a question is technical, tactical, or strategic in focus, they can just as easily focus on past actions. What have our strategies been? And what have been the impacts on performance as on future actions? What strategies will we deploy given what our performance currently shows? Boards that are monitoring effectively will invest the majority of their time, preferably upwards of third three quarters of the monitoring session focused on understanding the past.
Where are we? How did we get here? What worked? What didn't work? What did we learn? Only once a board is fully conversant in and knowledgeable of what has happened can it meaningfully engage in future focused dialogue. Ineffective >> it's just okay. Ineffective board succumb to the temptation of mostly focusing on tech technical tactical their opinions and statements or what will happen next. These are weaknesses of discipline and vision and should be corrected. Miss Mr. AJ Craig will be being direct right there. >> Yeah. Um I'm hoping that after we do this next piece too that this perspective will be elevated even more the the past and it took me a while to understand why AJ and the council was moving in that direction. I was always more focused on what's the plan? What's the plan? Right? As soon as you say 79, your community is going to be like what's the plan?
What are you going to do? But if you cannot tell them how you got there, >> we got a major issue >> because then you're not how can you really be convinced of what the strategy is if you don't know how you got there? So the questions that that I would have for you after reviewing your four progress monitoring reports is do you know how that happened? And if the answer is no, I'll invite you to visit with the superintendent and let him just give it to you straight up like try to shorten it and sweet like here's what happened. here's how we got here. Here's how this number went up. Because that's what your community is going to need from you. They're going to need you to be short, sweet, and blunt about it. This is what happened. Then you can focus on because we know how this happened.
Now, I can tell you that as a board member, I'm convinced of the current strategy or I'm very very encouraged with the current strategy, but I know how we got here. And so then I can understand how we're going to do better this coming year. Does that make sense? >> Yes. >> Sweet. All right, let's practice. These are actually questions from this board at a random board meeting that I watched uh last night to to prepare. So, here's a question. How many teachers teach targeted and integrated structured English immersion SEI model? I want you to visit at your table. Is that a technical, tactical, or strategic question? No grace. We're going We're going to ask for grace. Everybody got it? What does this table say? >> Tactical. What do y'all say? >> Splits. >> Split how? >> Between >> split between and and these splits can happen by the way.
Technical and tactical. >> What does this table say? >> We said it was tactical. >> Tactical. All right. Who wants to explain why they believe it is the way it is? >> What were you saying, Tristan? >> Oh, well, >> I uh Nicole and Jay said tactical and I held back a little because I didn't know you could mix. So, uh >> you do whatever you want, Nick. >> Yeah, I know. But the measure uh to me when you use how many that l you know I could say well you could make an argument then that that is a measure. Other thoughts from the Sue >> say tactical because how it's done how is it's yeah how is how are those the SEI taught >> how by how many teachers >> why why were we all split >> it was just me. I I just >> um I'm thinking more in like such a basic level of just like a number and thinking about like yeah the data you're going to get the data back but what is it like what is the data really telling you?
I could give you a number but >> I guess you're not diving deeper into anything else other than that question. >> That part you just said a lot right there. That's it. So, you want to have obviously an understanding, right? But the really effective questions, you're going to dive deep. You're going to ask them such a probing question. It's going to be a deep conversation. So, yeah. And then why do y'all say tactical? >> Uh I was just like pretty similar to one of the uh examples under the tactical question. >> Okay. like which staff have been trained or >> Okay, >> here's another question that was asked at at one of your board meetings. >> We don't get the answer. >> No, not till we go through all of them. >> Oh, okay. I'm going to forget about the first question. >> As long as y'all said that it wasn't strategic is the main thing I was looking for.
>> Okay. >> Yeah. What systems are in place to ensure students with the lowest self-management skills, example, sixth grade, male, sped, are receiving differentiated intentional supports throughout the year, not just at survey time. Is that a technical, tactical, or strategic question? >> Strategic. >> Well, it's long. You're like my kids cuz as long as it's >> actually hold on. Can Can you move a little bit please? Yeah. >> Yeah. I would say strategic two or no thanks mostly strategic but it feels like It's missing a key element of a strategic question. >> What's that key element? >> The key element is a tie back to the data. >> I'm talking about the priorities. That's for sure. So I guess then okay I would reward your parenthesis if you want to tell AJ this to say trying to understand how data aligns to the priorities not something because I think that could throw people off but then all your examples talks about the data that's the something >> well and and if I could permutate that a little bit >> I think in this case the something is the differentiated intentional supports.
I think it would be um how something aligns to the priorities in relation to the data. >> Okay. Yeah. I was like it's missing from the example too is what I was going to say because it's not really what's in the example. >> Everyone in agreement. No. What do you think? >> I mean yes I do. Can I just have an example of what what do you mean by that including data? >> Go ahead. >> Oh, sorry. Um, and I didn't mean to jump over you because you know given the results of interim measure 1.2. >> Okay, got it. >> How will we how how are we providing these supports to make certain that they're not just >> Got it. >> reflecting at the end. >> And the that this this gray page I think is grayish, right? This one is going to we're going to go through it here after this last one and you'll see that this is this gives you the how-to how to compose a a strategic question.
All right, last one. How is the district ensuring that restorative practices are not just documented but implemented with fidelity, reflection and relevance to students lived experiences, technical, tactical, or strategic? >> I need time. Sure. >> I just tell my kids that, but I do. Yeah, >> I'll start over here this time. Um, well, we we just we just discussed I said there was a little bit of both and then my lovely partner said she believed it was more tactical and I'm going to switch my answer um because the um in technical we're not really measuring anything. So, I think it's more a tactical question or we both agreed it was tactical. She persuaded me the public defender did. >> So, technical or tactical? >> Tactical. Anybody got anything different? >> What' y'all get? >> I'm going to ask if there's trick questions included here. >> Well, the reason I ask that is practices aren't in any of our measures.
So for me, this one felt more like um the temptation to create a question that's trying to guide the superintendent as to priority. So, and I don't know if that's true or not, but if if everything is supposed to tie back to the progress monitoring report and this, you know, what are our interim measures and then what are the inputs? You know, we're supposed to stay focused on inputs, outputs, and outcomes, right? Um I have you know it's hasn't been a common thing but I have noticed that some questions and it may not even be intentional sometimes are like driving towards well I would like to see this and so the question is structured in such a way like don't forget about restorative practices even though that may not be related to the progress monitoring report itself. That's why I asked if it was a trick question.
No >> for the brave space convo on that one. I I could see where you're coming from with this and I think it's very difficult given how the interim measures are written especially for guard row one to like ask super strategic questions about like a panorama survey especially since we've never taken the survey ourselves right so I think this is something that could be an element of whether or not kids are responding favorably to whether they have indicators of self-management right if you don't have indicators of selfmanage management, you're probably getting a lot you're probably participating in a lot of restorative practices is what I'm going to assume. So, I I could see how this could be related to a guard rail. I think it's just harder with the guard rails because the data isn't so tied to um it's not so tied to like a finite thing.
Like these things are so fluid and can be influenced by so many things that it's hard to understand or pinpoint exactly. And I don't even think y'all would know the answer exactly of, you know, where how these kids are getting to changing answers in their indicators of self-management either. But I think that's why we have to ask these kind of questions maybe. I don't know, not exactly this one, but I could see other questions where you might have an issue with them that are similar to this. >> Yeah. And I and I was working from just to be clear because I think what you said is absolutely true. I was working from the assumption that this question was related to a goal, not a guard rail. So if this is a question that was related to a guardrail, I agree with you 100%. So I I was working from the assumption that it was a goal question, >> but you're bringing the reason why we're going to go to this next page on why it is important for you all to move more towards strategic questions, at least for the ones you're going to submit ahead of time.
Um, and so anybody got anything different than tactical? This one's more tactical. Do you want the answers? >> Yes, please. >> Tactical almost strategic the by by you'll you'll know that actually we may be able to make this one more strategic here in a bit. But yeah, definitely more strategic. And then this one, this one's definitely more tactical for sure. So y'all y'all are assessing right on point. And then again, just use that piece of paper as your guide. And your this one is going to be even more helpful. the one that says effective question asking. So, for example, here's what I want you to do. I want you to take the fourth and final report of your progress monitoring. And I want to invite you to to to replay the tape of how you would if you could go back to June. What is a strategic question that you may have asked to get clarity around this right here.
Remember I said if you don't know how you got here, this is an opportunity for you to practice to write a strategic question with your with your with your teammates at the table. Write a strategic question. And here's your descriptors. You're going to want it to be in a smart question format. I think you'll see the power of it if you if you if you really look to implement it. First one, it says it's strategic. So we know what that is between strategy strategic versus technical and tactical. Now you're going to take it from just being a regular strategic question. You're going to make it a smart strategic one. The second part is you're going to want it to have a measure focused. The third part is you're going to want it askoriented. Sophia, would you read ask oriented for us please? >> Is the question open-ended or is it a yes no multiplechoice question?
Also consider the tone of the question. If the question is asked in a confrontational or accusatory manner, it automatically fails to be taskoriented since a respectful and professional approach is more likely to yield valuable information than a confrontational or accusatorial approach. >> You can watch just about any random board meeting and you'll see that a number of boards are going to fell in that arena. >> And then surprise surprise, why the staff don't give you all the information? because they haven't modeled the behavior of a of a safe space for staff. Like I said, kudos to you here. Y'all are setting the bar really high for a lot of folks. I don't know if you know this, but a lot of folks are watching your board meetings and this they're actually they're they're pretty impressed at how how great of a culture you've been creating and continue to create as a team because you're modeling that.
You're allowing the space for the staff to be honest with you. And when they've got some data that's not looking good, they're not hiding it from you. >> They're giving it to you. >> Were you going to say something? >> I was just going to say that's not how it's always been. So, it's good to to think about that, especially for the newcomers. >> Yeah. All right. Results focus. Somebody please that one. Read that one for us so we're all on the same page. >> Results focus. Does the question focus on understanding data rather than sharing opinions? Also consider the tone and approach of the question. Is the question being asked with the purpose of authentically learning about the data? Or is the question really just advice giving or recommendation making in disguise? Is the question directly related to understanding data about board work, the goals, the guardrails, and our legally required items?
If the question is not directly related to board work, it should likely be avoided. >> Yeah. during progress monitoring and then time bounds. >> Does the question focus on current performance, past actions, or future performance, future actions? Additionally, consider the timing of the question. Is the question being asked at an appropriate time in the decision-making process? If a question is being asked too late in the process, that's a governance failure, not a management failure, and should not be allowed to harm the process. Preparation is key. >> Yeah. So there you have an an effective example and you have an ineffective example. So I'd like you to use this part of the document to compose one question with your table. Everyone doesn't have to create their own, but everyone work at creating one strategic question in smart format. Again, you have the effective example in front of you.
It's what you were talking about Jay just a minute ago to be able to take to connect this to a specific goal or guardrail is going to be instrumental in the way that you they're going to give you the information at the board meeting as well. So have fun. I'll give you about 10 minutes to come up with a strategic question based on that fourth and final progress monitoring report you got here in June. So again, >> you get to replay the tape. What's a question you may have asked that could have helped you get better understanding of how that 79% came about? This projected data is what you're saying. This was projected data. This is actually the end data. That's so that's the actual end data. It was the other one that was projected. Okay. >> Okay. Okay. I mean, I'm almost tempted to ask about like >> like looking at the data like we actually did decrease.
So it's not like um It's easier to pull up a tactical technical tactical Yeah. Is that what that's saying? Sorry. trying to develop. How would that come? [Music] seems to >> not have adequately across >> which in the hood place. more efficient. So, how are you going to do this? I guess you [Music] You can ask it. Just ask it in a strategic format. Smart. Even if you know the answer already >> some of that still seems technical to me rather You're asking about which inputs didn't work. >> So you're struggling with just trying to find something more strategic and less tactical like these inputs of >> I think that's well strategic you're trying to understand how something align >> and I'm not saying it's right. Yeah. >> My thought was >> on misalignment of theut >> well that's the like in these presentations >> it's almost like the input >> you're telling us the inputs and then here's the results but how are those two really like I mean I can make assumptions but I don't know what's going on in the classroom.
I mean the teachers are getting trained >> but what happens after that? >> Yeah. >> So that's intention >> better. But the question is what is better? >> Yeah. Because for me strategic say >> we're seeing I'm looking at these results and I know the overall strategy is five years. Are there other are there better interm like when we looked at the current met versus the term measure >> is the current measure in or lined up with the strategy something like that answer >> I think yeah like we're addressing the student engagement because Does that make sense? >> Well, how a lot of us questions say based on based on% of the elementary basically tie back to Yeah. >> Measure was the one >> I'm looking at September. Uh >> that's okay. Yeah. Intern measure we hit 72 >> current measure >> was the one we did.