2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 298
I'm I'm not going to say if. I'm going to say when we get you there or when you get yourselves there. Uh it's going to be very very evident to anybody and everybody who's anywhere near you. >> What's a district that you know off your head that's in the 90s? >> Yeah, Dotto. and they were all over the news in the Dallas area because they had major gains this year and they have been historically beat up for they were taken over by the state. Uh but my goodness they their two-way communication, their town halls, every board member shares responsibilities. They're all learning how to code their board meetings. Like it is a high performing team. And when you see them arguing, they're arguing about inputs and outputs and outcomes in a good way. Like they're pushing each other. Uh yeah, that's that's one really good example.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 299
All right, last one. And I know we got to push. I didn't think we'd go this long, but hey, again, next time you will all be able to come in already with your own assessment and you'll have the conversation here. Shouldn't take you more than 10 15 minutes because now you all have a baseline, but wanted to make sure that Nicole and Tristan, you had an opportunity to see and hopefully you find value in seeing the the rubric. Yeah. >> Oh, yeah. Go ahead. Sorry. All right. Any other questions or anything on this? If not, I move the governing board approve the Kraton School District's self-eal board self- evaluation of August 16, 2025 with 30 45 points with 45 points as of today's date. >> Is that a one? >> Oh, okay. >> May I have a second? >> Second. Uh, all those in favor?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 300
>> I I >> I Any hearing? None. Motion passes. >> All right, last item. Uh, this is a really important one. So, want to create a space for you to have some real conversation with each other is around how SOFG aligns with um a recommended um superintendent evaluation. in your packets. I believe you all have a document that looks like this. And so, um, I'm actually gonna hand it over to Jay here in a bit so so he can walk you through. You'll notice that it's advantageous to everybody that he have at least three interims per goal and per guard row because you'll see here at the very top it's going to tell you what we consider as meeting and not meeting. And at least twothirds of the goals are met is considered met standard. And at least half of the guardrails are met standard.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 301
And so the more interims he has and the more that he meets uh the better for everyone, but also for the understanding of you and the community. What is unfortunately happening from time to time is what happened here with you. If if 1.2 2 was met and 1.1 was not and this went up instead of going down. Um I want you all to be overprepared and especially superintendent J man that these if these are all green and this is red what do you think that means? If the interims are all green and they meet them but this number doesn't get better what does that mean? He doesn't need it on his >> It's not predictive. >> Are not >> That's right. >> They live out in space somewhere with their actual results. >> Yep. And so your team again based on what they told you this morning, um they they are banking that if these are green, this will be better and this will be green, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 302
So you you want to monitor during the school year so that if these are green, but this isn't if they're telling you the overall goal that it's not getting better, something's off over here. Don't wait till the end of the school year to start asking questions. By halftime, you definitely want to be asking the questions. So, what's going on? If these aren't predictive, these aren't correlating. And so, that's why this is important, too. It is also possible that they don't get these green, but this does, then that means that they're doing some things really, really well with the overall goal, and they're just fine-tuning their interims. But the main one that you want to focus overall throughout the year is going to be the overall goal. Do not take your eye off the overall goal. It has happened in other districts this year that these were all green, these were all red.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 303
What do you think happened to that leadership after two to three years? >> Yeah. So, want to really make sure that you're understanding how the superintendent evaluation was designed. the more metrics he has, the better opportunity for him to be able to learn and grow and measure. But you as a board want to stay focused on that overall one. You want to speak to you? >> Yeah. >> So, um, we took the template, the student outcomes focus governance manual template and plugged in the data. So, um, if we look at Arizona state law, um, typically the superintendent's evaluation is handled in an executive session unless the superintendent requests that it be handled in public. The problem I have with that is if we're if we choose to use this evaluation, there's no reason for it to be in an executive session cuz anyone who's playing the home game and keeping score at home could fill this sheet out themselves, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 304
cuz we're doing progress monitoring four times a year and we're reporting on where we're at with these different measures and so, you know, it's there's no reason to keep it a secret cuz it's public anyway. Um, and Dr. Ramos and I had a a conversation during the break, never done this before, so took a swag at it. And I think we may have assigned the points incorrectly cuz what we were trying to also do if you look at the back there's um sort of a points calculation in order to be able to figure out because um the way we've handled it in the past in Kraton is that the superintendence um pay for performance is receives a percentage of that dollar amount based on u the points scored on the evaluation. So, um, in coming up with a way to do the points, I heavily weighted the goals and put the weight on the guard rails very low.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 305
Um, but in talking with Dr. Ramos, the the the intent of the instrument is for all of the goals and guard rails to be weighted equally. So, if so, it's it's up to what the board wants. I mean ultimately this is your evaluation for me and there is time for us to adjust that you know prior to an upcoming meeting. Um so if you if if you give me guidance to go ahead and make that shift that to be balanced then we can shift it to be balanced. So the piece I forgot to ask Dr. Ramos is my understanding was also that the points are based on the interims not on the goals themselves. Um, and I thought we had a conversation last year and that's what I understood, but you may need to correct me on that. Perhaps the goals do factor in. >> Yep.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 306
I'm looking for it on here because the one in Texas will explicitly say if you met the goal, then the interims are not as important because the main focus is the goal. >> Gotcha. >> Is it on here? Otherwise the board was about oh >> a goal or guardrails performance is met if the actual ending point the desired ending point uh which which would be the goal. >> Yeah. >> Or at least twothirds of the interim goals or guard rails are actual ending points their respective >> desired ending point. So yeah there it is right there. >> Okay. So, so we did it correctly then because if you look at um if you look at goal one, it's marked as did not meet standard because um >> is your >> because the goal the goal did was not met. And in addition to that, if you were to look at the interim measures, one was met and one wasn't met, which is 50% were met.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 307
And the measure the measure mark is 66% or greater. So that one did not reach 66% or greater. So it was marked as did not meet standard. If we look at goal two in this case we met the annual target and we met both of the interim measures. So this one is marked as met standard. >> That one I would be I would be sharing this story if you're not already. >> I know that's what I told um Mr. Man. And I'm like, where's our comms and marketing all over this? >> This is huge, y'all. What what what he just shared with y'all. This is huge. >> Not everyone has been able to do this. Sorry. >> Look at goal three. >> You're just talking about doing that, meeting the goal. >> Yeah. >> Okay. Sorry. >> It's not it you meet the if you meet the annual target, that's a big W for everybody.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 308
>> Yeah. >> And the interims don't become as relevant. But if you didn't meet it, as you're learning here, your interims have got to mean something. >> Yeah. >> Meeting all three, you're saying is the big deal. >> And well, yeah, but even just meeting the annual target that there was positive shift in the numbers that this that's huge. Not everyone saw gains y this year. >> So if we look at goal three, similar place with that. We met we met the annual target. We also met both of the interim measures. So that one is also marked as met standard. if we go to so this is where it gets weird and ugly and this is where Dr. Ramos was talking to us about the importance of the alignment and I um I struggle with guilt as many of you know um with with this one according to the way the system works we did not meet the annual target but we met all three of the interim measures so it's marked as met standard even though the annual target was not met but as the reason I have guilt over it as Dr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 309
Pombo shared with you um you know when we looked at this it was one of the things that triggered us to go back and check our correlations right so but to the best of our skill set and knowledge for last year we recommended these interim measures and those are the interim measures we worked on >> that part is huge my friends the the year that they spent in really digging deep into this the learning that they have that they they brought brought you updated and changed interims for that very reason right there. So, I've said this to the board and I I'll keep saying it. First several years, you want to have grace with the leadership team because they're learning a new system. They're adjusting. They're pivoting as are you. You just saw yourself eval, right? Like if you let up off the gas, put on yourselves, you'll also go that way.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 310
So, you're modeling what you're expecting them to do. So, this year, I'm I have no doubt. And I heard you say at the board meeting several times, the flywheel effect is coming. Y >> that's what they're anticipating. >> Y um for guard So shifting into the guard rails for guardrail one. The um there were two interim measures. Again, this is a why you don't have two interim measures, but we weren't as aware of that last year and we and we did adopt two. And so we've we missed one of the interim measures by an entire point and then we um uh were successful in the other interim measure. And so in this case, this one also did not meet standard um for for apparently I can't flip pages and talk at the same time. For guardrail 2, we met both of the interim measures and so that one met standard.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 311
For guardrail three, we met both of the interim measures and so that one met standard. And for guardrail 4, we met both of the interim measures and so that one met standard. Now, one of the things I recognized, you'll notice the way I assign points was not accurate. Um, because of the 66% system, these need to be adjusted. So, that way for each of those groupings, it's either an all or nothing. Like I was doing um based on the number of guard rails that were that were met. And so, I I can correct that now that it's understood better. And then the really the two questions for the governing board if you look at the back sheet are that the goal and guardrail interim measures currently are weighted towards the goals but that can be recalculated for it to be equally weighted across all um and then the other question is the way that we did the percentages we really literally connected it to percentages.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 312
So like if you look the only way to get 100% is to get 100%. Um for 90 to 99 it's 90%, 80 to 89 it's 80%. And if you look if it's below 50% I figure I'm packing my desk anyway at that point. So why bother to give me any pay for performance? >> To the first part of all that um when you're saying the all or nothing. So, for example, if we were going on page three. >> Mhm. >> Uh the guardrail one, you're saying that you shouldn't have given yourself three and a half there. >> That is correct. Yeah, it should be zero. >> Zero. And so the same for the >> same thing for goal one. >> For goal one. Okay. >> That should be zero instead of nine. >> Correct. and and and the numbers, the three and a half and the nine numbers won't persist like they'll be recalculated if the board chooses if if the board is comfortable with everything being equally weighted.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 313
So, so fundamentally each category if they were equally weighted because there's there's four goals, four guard rails, there's a total of eight. We would divide the 100 points by 8. I think that becomes 12.5, but I too tired at this point in the day to do the actual math. So that's just a guess. It might be right. Sometimes I guess right. And so then each of the categories would get 12.5 points. And it and it would either be a you met it and you get 12 and a half points or you didn't meet it and you get zero points. So if the So the I guess the three questions are is the instrument acceptable? Yes. >> Should it be should the points be equalized across goals and guard rails? >> You mentioned something about Dr. Ramos telling you that that it should be or it usually is or what?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 314
>> I I won't speak for him. I'll let him tell you. >> Yeah, because we want him obviously the goals matter a great deal and do the guard rails because that's what your community is talking to you about as well. So, yeah, both should be equally weighted. Okay. >> And they have made the adjustments. Again, I'll say it again because it's really important. That's the reason that they've gone to three inter rooms per goal and per guard rule. Once we saw the math, it made a lot more sense to us. So, you can't get 66% out of two interim measures. So if the board is comfortable with it, we'll make the adjustment to the to equally weight. We'll make the adjustment that it's all or nothing. We'll update the instrument and then if the board's comfortable with it, we could bring it back to our um we could we do it during our student outcomes governance section on Tuesday if we add it Monday.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 315
>> Yeah. Okay. What is everybody's thoughts? >> So, here are my thoughts. There is always a level of um leeway in evaluations and I equate it to like staff evaluations like other staff members like certified. So, like for example, I'll go back to teachers. It's not 100% you get 100% your money. There's like a leeway, right? Um, so I'm having a little bit of a hard time like with their like like I feel like Jay is always hard on himself and so >> you noticed >> like with the all or nothing thing and then looking at this and saying he has to have 100 points. Um, like I don't I don't want to like dumb down the expectation. That's not what I'm I'm saying. But like in every situation there should be given some leeway. Um, and so that's my only two cents on this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 316
>> Yeah, my input is that I think that we should equally wait at the two different sections and that we should find some way to make the scale a little bit different as far as the percentages go. Well, and I I could offer what we could. The probably the simplest way to do that would be to change it to 90 to 100 is 100. 80 to 89 is 90. I wouldn't personally I don't want to go too far off of that because I really want to be held accountable on this. >> And by the way, this is not SOG, so this is really neat for me to witness and listen to because the point systems that's Yeah. that you all hear. >> Yeah. Yeah, >> you just give me 100% all the time, too. But that's not what I'm asking for. >> I definitely think the goals and the guardrails should be equally weighted.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-16 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube August 16, 2025, Governing Board Meeting · passage 317
Um, that that makes sense to me. Um, on the whole and then what else were we discussing is cuz I'm reading specifically from the book the area where it talks about superintendent emails. So, as I'm listening to you guys, I'm trying to see if I can find answers within the book. >> What was the next one? >> Well, the next one, like Dr. just said really isn't going to be in the book because this is our like state statute required thing. >> No, I know. But there's >> So the other question is how should we adjust this percentage with the points because as um Heather was just talking about and as he alluded to in terms of like some leeway. The only way right now in this system for him to get the 100% payout of pay for performance is if he got a 100 points, a perfect score.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above