2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 96
increase deduction more deductions changing in 2027 going from 48,000 to 40,000 then increasing the supplemental homestead deductions and that same apples to apples comparison you can see ultimately until 2031 when we quote bottom out that average homeowner will pay the least amount if their market value doesn't increase will pay the least amount of AV in 31. What you're seeing is a 4% 3% 3% 3% 5% 6% decrease in debt assess value. So over this time horizon this average homeowner your market value would have to increase 4.3% per year just to keep the net assess value flat. I'll say it again just for dramatic effect. average homeowner would have to see a 4.3% increase in gross assessed value to keep this on average flat of around $66,000. So we've seen more than 4% past few years, but we've not seen that over the past 10 15 years.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 97
So your guess is as good as mine what's going to happen over the next couple years. But again, this credit is Not part of net value is supplemental homestead credit first restaurant I thought Arby's like Arby's coupon and getting that cost taken off the bottom line just means you keep it in your pocket which means school district library county are not collecting that revenue so the DGF department finance estimates this credit in 2026 to be about $89,000 to community schools. So, it's great for homeowners, but there is a revenue impact to the operations for schools. Sorry, I feel like I'm blind people with this reflection on my watch. So, now it's transitioning to the 2% properties. So, what are the 2% properties again? Residential rental properties. of home rentals, a land, and long-term care. So, this group on a holistic standpoint never received a deduction before.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 98
So, you can see in 2025, no deduction. beginning in 2026 transitioning a six% deduction all the way until 2031 for ad rental property home rentals in long-term care approximately onethird of the market value now will be tax deducted. So you got homeowners getting increased deductions 2% bucket getting deduct deductions which is leading that way to a decrease in net assess value. What happens when net assessed value goes down? Tax rate probably goes up. So this is a 20-year snapshot of a land throughout the state of Indiana. There is a formula that is that's been designed by the Indiana General Assembly that determines the base rate per acre throughout the state of Indiana. So it's not like Benton County has one special base rate per acre. Monroe County has a different one to county has a different one throughout the state of Indiana. There is one base rate per acre.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 99
So the gray represents the numbers that have been certified by the state of Indiana, the department of local government finance. In 2025, the base rate value per acre is $2,120. Excuse me. No, that was 2390, right? >> That was the original. Thank you. So they changed it in 2026, I'm sorry, pay 2026. They had certified 2390. So we were expecting about a 67% bump per acre. The general assembly changed the methodology on the capitalization rate. So went from 2390 now to 2,120. So this does not count the 6% deduction as well. This is just a straight base rate calculation. So farmland farmers will see a drop in excess value in pay 2026. LSA legislative services agency is projecting that here in the blue. This has not been certified. This is a projection. But LSA is projecting a 6% increase in base rate. But if you compare 2027 to 2025, you can see 2027 is projected to be lower than 2025.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 100
And again, that does not include the 12% deduction that they'll be eligible for in 2027. So now transitioning to the 3% bucket. So who's a 3% bucket? Commercial and industrial or business personal property? business personal property changing what is called the dimminimous amount. So for those of you who may own business personal property, you complete what's called a form 103 is your aggregate amount of business personal property. So when that aggregate amount is less than 80,000 in your 2025 taxes or 2026 taxes, you're not paying any property taxes on it because it's considered to be dimminimous. That dimminimous threshold is increasing to 2 million in 2027. So it's great for businesses, great for farmers who own combines and tractors potentially if that aggregate is less than 2 million. But there is it is going to potentially impact because that dimminimous amount of increases that assess value could go down which means tax rate could go up.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 101
So dimminimous that takes effect to pay 2027 taxes. Additionally, there's this 30% floor. So any new equipment put into place purchased in this calendar year right now. This is personal property is after you depreciate it, there's a floor of 30%. If you purchase new equipment this calendar year, that new equipment is no longer subject to that 30% floor. So, a lot of CFOs, a lot of farmers will probably be doing this. I would do the exact same thing if I were their shoes. Well, is now the time to replace equipment in order to not be subject to that 30% floor. Since that is such a business and individual based scenario, it's really hard to predict what could happen with this property type. So, we'll have to monitor that and as net assess values roll out, try to measure what what the impact is. So 1% deduction, 2% deduction, now 3% deduction with business personal property.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 102
>> What do you mean by a property floor? >> So what do you mean by when you say floor? >> I say a floor. So think in terms I'm going to use a high dollar figure. So let's say there's a manufacturing company. They have $10 million of manufacturing equipment as business personal property. Typically accountants will depreciate that over maybe five or 10 years or whatever the useful life of that equipment is. So let's use $10 million as an example and let's say it has a 10ear useful life. So after seven years right now that $10 million equipment still has a $3 million value. So they'll continue to pay $3 million of assessment on that business personal property. If they replace that equip to purchase new in 2025, there no longer there's no longer a floor for that $3 million. So as it depreciates, there's no limitation for that $3 million or 30% goes away where ultimately it may not pay any property taxes potentially.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 103
>> Okay, thank you. >> That answer your question? >> It's a good question. So with that mindset and thinking in terms of what these deductions are, you always want to be mindful of who are the largest taxpayers. So Bon schools an obligation you have is having debt outstanding and as you heard Mr. Bars talk about investors. You have to update them on an annual basis of who your largest 10 taxpayers are. So here is what we reported this past summer for the largest 10 taxpayers as a percent of your net assessed value. So the smell test we always do on this type of report is look at this total number. That means it's 20% of your total net assessed value is with these these 10 taxpayers for your rating. schools has a rating just like your own personal credit score. So the school district's credit score, one of the metrics they monitor is 20%.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 104
Typically rating agencies like to see that being somewhere between 12 to 15% to be considered a diverse tax base. It just means that you're higher risk because if one of these were no longer used if or the farming operation went out of business, you're at risk because it could impact your overall medicine value. Your takeaway is just know that your top 10 taxpayers are about 20% of your total medicine. So let's start looking at some of the metrics. So this is a stoplight feature. So the state of Indiana requires you every January, you all probably remember every January you get these fiscal indicator report. So the state of Indiana requires you to review eight indicators ADM which is your average daily membership or enrollment. What your fund balances are whether you're running a surplus or deficit your fund balance as a percent of expenditures. revenue by type, referendum revenue as a percent of total revenue, net assessed value, tax rate.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 105
We added these two additional ones because we think they are equal in importance even though the state of Indiana does not require you to approve this. But this these are the indicators as of 1231 2024. This is a preview. You'll see this report come January as well for your uh review. average daily membership. You'll hear me talk a little bit more about this in the coming slides and Dr. Zup and I welcome her her insights as well. This one probably puts us at the biggest risk. You heard the gentleman back talk about enrollment and the way we're trending. The stoplight feature means that anything that's not green really means that caution. We need to investigate, understand why it's occurring or what's occurring, why it's occurring. Fortunately, as of 1231 2024, there's not currently a concern. But if this enrollment trend continues that we'll see in the coming slides, that could turn into a red at some point, but at this point, we'll consider that a yellow fund balances.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 106
You'll hear one of the greatest strengths of it schools is the strong cash balances. We have a really strong balance statement. That's kudos to this board for being pragmatic, having a plan in place. 2024 we ran a balanced budget. So we're yellow, not accumulating too much in the way of of additional um because the education fund ran a deficit. However, the operations fund ran a surplus. So we put it in yellow at this point 2024. You heard me say number two fund balances fund balances at percent expenditures really strong. It's a great place to be. gives you a lot of flexibility in addressing the challenges that are coming ahead with SBA1 revenue by type. There is really only shouldn't say really there's only one mechanism or le you can pull from revenue for schools property taxes. So revenue by type you've done it but you can so call it a green referendum as a percent of total revenue.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 107
This just means that you're relying upon referendum revenue and your total budget is not good or bad. It's just a fact. You're fortunate to have a referendum, but as we look ahead, we'll see what would happen if we don't have a referendum. Net assess value. You all saw firsthand and experience the changes with BP and what what happened with their assessment. So, we had a couple of drops in that assess value. So, we'll call it yellow, but we'll continue to monitor as two of the three counties have come out. We dropped. So, we'll have to uh continue to monitor that tax rate. You'll see me say later on the bitten schools has about a 86 cent tax rate in 2025. The state average is dollar2. So you're well below the state average. Circuit breaker losses as of right now from a percentage standpoint you're lesser than some of your peers and percent of your total budget being less than 1%.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 108
So sort of greater losses have been manageable, easy for me to say. The debt rating, we'll we'll show that in the coming slides as well. You got a really strong credit. So two charts separate but both related to enrollment. This is your legal settlement in residential enrollment from 2017 to 2020. These are all data available from Indiana Department of Education. The blue bars represent the number of kids K12 living within business schools. And this is one that piqued our interest in looking at these data. In 2017, we have 1,935 bitten schools kids K12 living within your borders. So that residential enrollment, excuse me, that legal settlement, if you look at the line, try to best fit line is going down, but 2024 1,783. >> It almost tracks the same for the ones that are. >> You're right. >> Is that county or district? >> District.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 109
So incorporates kids live in all three counties. So the correlary to that is you can see the gap between the blue and the yellow. So that's essentially what this is. So the purple are those kids who live outside of B schools who are attending B schools. What is that pink color my color? So pink are the ones who live within schools but transfer out. So then you can see what that net transfer impact is. But the one that has my radar because Dr. Zupin and I have talked about this one is this is not just a bitten schools challenge. Heard me say I know you've heard Dr. Zupin say it as well. In the state of Indiana this is a common challenge for rural schools. I think what 60ome counties of 92 are decreasing in population. So kind of being your lifeblood of your school district on that blue line you all are keenly familiar with.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 110
So now looking at everybody's favorite topic we look at some of the expenditures. So if you combine the education fund which is supported by state revenue and the referendum fund which is a property tax revenue it supports teaching and learning. So we talk about what are we paying for out of education fund and referendum. The 100 object code are salaries. The 200 are benefits. Salaries and benefits. You can see over the past three years, purple being 2022, blue 2023 and yellow 2024. Pretty much everything we do out of these two funds are for PG. So this is very common. throughout the state of Indiana. Teaching or education is a people based industry. So right within what other schools throughout the state of Indiana and nationally are doing. Similar to the operations fund, majority of the cost are salaries and benefits when you combine the two.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 111
So compensation for staff operations fund. Remember that it's not just teaching and learning, it's how you operate your school district. So 500, 600s are transporting kids and your supplies. 400s are let me take a quick step back. 100 100s to 200s are staff compensation. 300s are some some contracted services. 400s are building maintenance type of items. 500 and 600 are some contracted services and supplies. Then the 700s are your capital investments. So learning more you all recall during co there were some delays in shipping. So my school was delaying some of the time was not as clean as we would have hoped. you can see some of the impact year to year with uh delayed delivery of school buses. So that's how we spent our dollars over the past three years. Bon schools has a A+ credit that is considered to have very high grade credit.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 112
That is a very strong credit rating by standard of course. Standard Core is not doesn't just rate the state of Indiana, but it rates school districts throughout the country. So having a A+ rating is great because anytime you sell bonds, you're going to improve by about three to five basis points every time you're a notch higher. So how that compares to the rest of the state of Indiana, you're in this yellow. So you're in good company with a lot of your peers throughout the state of Indiana. So we did a SWAT analysis and working with Dr. Zupen and Tracy. So SWAT is like what are our strengths? What are our weaknesses? What are our opportunities? What are strengths are got a strong credit rating? We've got really strong cash balances and we have a comparable low total tax rate compared to our peer statement. And that's not by accident.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 113
These are things that you have strategically targeted to put yourselves in good position. Some of the weaknesses though as we look ahead is residential enrollment is decreasing. We talked about that blue bar transferred out of the district are also increased let revenue loss about 134,000 in 2028 that expenditures projected to outpace revenue beginning in 2029 that we'll look at then concentrated amount of excess value compared to large tax. Those are opportunities though You got some flexibility with how you may want to plan for the referendum. With those strong cash balances, some of the challenges presented by SEA1, those strong cash balances that buys you some time to make some informed decisions going forward. We'll talk about the debt schedule later on about how your debt schedule at this point all debt matures in 2029. You position yourself to consider capital investments in 2025 as a result of that work and we're monitoring possible refunding of the 2016 bonds.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 114
You heard Mr. Bars talk about how bonds are are mortgages. Yes, in some ways. Um but what I would say here is you can't refund a municipal bond anytime you want to like your own mortgage. They have call dates. So to keep that tax exempt status you heard talk about there's a provision that we can only refund bonds within a 90-day window before the call date keep the tax exempt. Your takeaway there is these 2016 bonds having July call date. So if interest rates are low enough we'll seek an opportunity to fund. We'll see the threats as I see it is legislative actions one prison's challenges no doubt about it especially with net medicine value economic uncertainty what could happen with inflation seems to have subsided here in in recent months so the federal government is passing more costs on Medicaid down to the state right Now, Medicaid is the second largest expenditure in the state budget.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 115
If they pass more cost on to the state, K12 and higher ed are the largest portion of the state budget, about 47%. Medicaid's about 26%. So, if Medicaid eats up more of that pie, that could present challenges to schools and higher ed being compressed. We'll see what the Medicaid impact is in the coming months, which means they could open up the budget again, which is not something they would do during a short session typically unfunded mandates, new standardized tests, and high school diploma requirements, then the wind. So, those are the threats posed. So, let's get into all of those factors being together. These are schedule assumptions. I'm not going to read each and every one of these unless you want me to bore you to death. Point being that working with Dr. Zupin and Tracy trying to use some of historical trends to help project out where we're going.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above