2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 116
1% annual decrease in enrollment anticipating and projecting a 2% increase in state funding yeartoear. Hopefully we get that from 2026 on circuit breakers based upon historical trends. So we'll see what happens if circuit breaker is impacted by decreasing net assess value increasing tax rates. So we'll have to monitor that going forward. Net assessed value is based upon what we're seeing in SCA1 which is somewhere probably between a 2 to 3% decrease annually net assessed value unless we get really strong growth. Our levy projections are based upon 4% growth in operations fund and a 3% growth in the operating referendum. So those are our revenues from a high level dispersements assuming a 4% increase for salaries and benefits in order to keep competitive in the marketplace beginning in 2026 for all other expenses assuming 3 and a.5% in 2025 3 and a half% in 2026 3.25 2027 2028 and 3% from 2029 to 2033 somewhere close.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 117
Some would argue that's probably high for inflation. Some may argue it's low. Basically on trail of where we've been the past few years in the debt we'll see it's all outstanding plus approved debt that we'll review. So what it looks like is we combine the education fund which is state funding the operating referendum and the property tax fund operations and rain. The blue bars represent our annual revenue yeartoear. So the 2022 through 2024 numbers are actual based upon what was submitted to the department of education by tracing and her team. And the yellow represents the annual expenditures year to year. And you can see this black line which represents the cash balances at the end of every fiscal year. Reminder that schools like all but two school districts in the state of Indiana are on a calendar year budget. So these are the cash balances as of 1231 of every year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 118
So based upon the assumption of you know what let's keep the referendum rate at 31 cents from 2026 through 2028. So you can see this blue line the blue bar year to year is going to keep up with that 31 cents. Let's make the assumption that the referendum is either not sought for renewal or we just let it fall off. You can The change from 2028 to 2029 is that drop in the referendum. So assuming no 31 cents actually zero cents beginning 2029. But if we continue operations as normal, we would peak in 2028 with our cash balance of an illustrative about 36 million. Then through 2033, you can see we'd be back down to about 11.8 million at that point, assuming that we did not realign or right size our budget as a result of the drop in referendum. >> Do do have schools because you've worked with schools with referendum, >> have they ever changed the rate that was voted for?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 119
>> Yeah, good question. So, um, so many different scenarios play out and community by community decision, but there are some I live in a community who is seeking a referendum at a lower rate than what was approved back in 2019. So the other illustration in talking to Dr. Zupa and Tracy is what if scenario? So what if we didn't tax at the full 31 cents over the next three years? What could the impact? Great segue by the way. Okay, >> so looking at 2026 through 2028, if we set the referendum rate to 15 cents, if we essentially cut it in half, what would that look like between these four funds? And you can see that still running a budget surplus in 2027, but in 2028, that's that first year of our LIT revenue going away. At that point, the model from where 2029 we ran a deficit in the 31 model, the 15 cent model, you actually start to see a slight deficit based upon these assumptions in 2028.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 120
And again, we assume that falls off. It's not either soft renewal or is not extended. That's again why you see this drop in blue 2029 through 2033. And rather than having 11 million in the bank, expected at the end of 2033. In this scenario, we don't have about $4.2 million based upon these assumptions. If you don't mind, I want to go back to that. So, what what are schools thinking when they are midway or closer to the end? What what is in their thought process on changing the amount? >> You're saying for when they seek renewal or just >> prior to? >> Yeah. So, if I'm in your shoes, I'm letting my projected cash be my lead. So the board gives direction to Dr. Tracy on what are we comfortable with cash balance wise in the short term. So this is a projection through 203 but as you approved Dr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 121
Zupin Tracy will be presenting the budget here in the coming meetings. So as you set the tax rate you don't have to make decisions tonight. This is just what we're seeing based upon these broad assumptions going forward. So as you determine your budget and approve the budget, you still have another step in the process. So after you adopt your budget, then you'll get the 1782 notice, which I know these gentlemen are familiar with with the county as well. Then if you make any adjustments at that point is when you certify it. So there's what three potentially four more months of this process to play out. At that point you'll know your enrollment, you'll know what your total net assess value is and you'll know what your program services and needs are to determine what is the appropriate tax rate for 2026. So we're just trying to give you a sense of where you could be headed directionally based upon a comparison of 15 cents or three months.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 122
I didn't we last year we we went for the 31 and we didn't get the 31 right >> because of the the cap and what you could receive. >> See, we're not getting I mean we don't we're not 100% in control of that either, >> right? No, you're you're exactly right. That's why we assume% growth. So the state of Indiana did cap the levy growth >> because a lot of communities were growing gosh 5 10 15% depending upon the community. So the state of Indiana capped it at 3% >> for everybody that way. Yeah. >> On the red, green, and and yellow. Uh so for the cash reserves, um us being healthy, is there a rule of thumb? Is there a standard that you know we should aim for? >> Yeah, good question. So the old tradition, I shouldn't say, you know, the traditional model is that you would want nothing below 15%.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 123
That way you have two months of reserves on your books and you can maintain. So if the state of Indiana delays a payment, the county taxes are delayed because of new property tax, you got two months of reserves to make sure you make payroll. Well, what the industry standards are now going to is either more of a rangebased system or what's called a riskbased system. So in if I'm in your shoes that smell test like what is a appropriate range somewhere between 8 to 33% depending upon the risk for the district because the reason why I say 30 as much as 33% is because if the county were to delay because of all these new property tax changes they got to do a lot of software but you still have to make your debt payments. What we don't want to do is borrow money to make the debt payments.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 124
We don't want to borrow money pay back our money. So, we want to make maintain a strong balance. So, if we have to make a debt payment, we can make cash on. Do you know has has any or do you know that I guess it's a question any legislation that it's coming out for the windmills because if they're not supplemented, they're not efficient. And I don't know. I mean, that that scares me with we're heavy on the windmills and that can be cut. >> They're not making money. It's a good question. I'm not aware of any legislation coming up. That doesn't mean it won't. >> Yeah, you're right. That's why you would for that case it might be more appropriate to more of a risk based amount because if you look at that portion of your assess value that's relying upon windmills and that goes away how much revenue are they paying for your referendum and want to keep that cash on hand >> 8 to 33% that's a big range >> so it is intended to pretty wide.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 125
I think the the statewide average for all school corporations, I think this number was going back to 2023, but it might be 2024. So, excuse me for not recalling exactly the top of my head, but the the school average was about 33%. So, what question you might be asking is, okay, that gives the school corporation So what does that mean to the average taxpayer though between the 15 cent tax rate and the 31 tax rate? So let's go back to that average tax $153,700. This based upon the 2026 deductions. So 48,000 flat 40% supplemental. So an average taxpayers being $63,000 in net assessed value. So on an annual basis, if you set the rate at 31 cents in 2026, that 31 cent tax rate, we got $197 per year or $16 approximately they pay for extra similar to that because it's roughly half that average taxpayer would have their tax bill for the referendum rate cut in half for that average taxpayer.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 126
5 year for that 15 cent referendum tax rate land $618 per acre. So if somebody owned 100 acres we're paying about $615 per year for that 31 bore roughly half 15 cents of about $298 that does incorporate Mr. melon that does incorporate the 6% deduction for the 2% properties. Then for rental property thou for each $100,000 you're talking with a 6% deduction for rental properties as well $291 for 31 cents about $141 for 15. But for commercial property, no deduction if it's non business personal property. So that for each $100,000 of commercial and industrial property, 31 would be $110 over 15 $150. That's comparison to what it means to average. So to wrap it up, this is the existing debt. I know this board's seen this many, many times. You heard me say that Benton Schools has an accelerated debt payment. So, as of today, we're in budget year 2025, a little over $3 million total in annual payments.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 127
So, you pay twice a year. You pay your debt on June 30th and December 31st. Why? Because it coincides with property tax collections. Pay your property taxes in May. Fit schools gets it first. in June. Okay, you're probably taxed in November, make the debt payment in December. So the gray is the outstanding debt as of today. If nothing changed, debt would mature 2029. prior boards. Part of the strategy is like you knew similar to every other school corporation I think we working with in the state of Indiana, your list of capital needs far exceeds what you can issue in debt. So as a result, we always try to structure to give you the option that if you want to issue new bonds to make capital investments, that's why this board cut out some capacity in 2026 knowing that you They want to issue bonds in 2025 to make those capital investments.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 128
So we talk about it being tax neutral. We can structure these in a way to avoid any type of tax rate increase. So this is an illustration for the proposed $6.6 million bonds paying over 20 years. This is what it could look like. We can we can tailor it to whatever the board's target is from a a tax rate standoint. not slip bonds even. So whenever we do that, we can change around the maturities and push these down, push the first few years down and push the better years up. So again, it's kind of a what you measure on on how you want to target from a tax rate and tax management standoint. >> So when you're talking about all those those list of items that we want to get done, capital projects doesn't cut it. So we use, you know, typically the geo bond is is the way to go, but with this cooling off period, could what does that look like to us?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 129
So we I believe when I came on, we were uh issued a geo bond for the technology and safety. So what And it's typically a threeyear, two or threeyear payout. So what does that look like? This cooling off. >> I'm not an attorney. >> Okay. So I I want to any bond council to confirm. So but my understanding is from a geo bond perspective it's kind of like a three-prong test. The first question you ask yourself is the last time we issue geobs did it have a twoyear or fewer repayment. If the answer to that question is yes okay then what's the next question? Does your proposed bonds have a fiveyear or fewer repayment? The answer to that question is yes. Then you go down to the third question is well then when do the prior bonds that have a two-year less maturity, when do they mature?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 130
There has to be a cooling off. So let's say you make your final payment. Let's say you have two-year repayment or excuse me a two-year maturity. you issue bonds for example in February 2024 in the final payment. It's not when you make not when Bon schools makes a payment but actually when the bonds bond payment is made in January 15 of 2026 since that would have a what a 23month repayment you could not issue geo bonds again from February for when you initially sold the initial box. So it's a one year cooling off when the bonds mature, not when you make your last. >> And uh do you know what the premise was behind that? >> Yeah. My understanding just based upon listening to the testimony is a lot of school corporations because of a lot of schools schools have a laundry list of capital needs.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 131
So a lot of schools were issuing geo bonds once they got their net assessed value in August or September issuing a small geo bond just to keep the tax net assessed value was going up. That means so too was the tax free. So that tax was going up to homeowners. So it was a way methodology for the general assembly to basically say no you can't do that any longer. If you do, we have to have more than a five year repayment. None of this one or two repayment. Good question. So, this is not final. I want to be clear about this. This is not final. Whatever the board determines from a target target tax rate standpoint, knowing that if netis value goes down, we might not be able to even absorb that payment that we're estimating here in 2026. So just by the sheer fact part of that total assess value goes down we may have to push down the capacity anyway.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 132
So we'll continue to work Dr. Z and Tracy and ultimately get your direction on how we may want to approach that. That's all I've got. I know that was probably pretty lengthy. >> I do want to ask about the refunding because I think John you had mentioned that my dealings here and at my previous school, we never refunded. It was a you pay off and then you go to a next one. So the refunding is that common? H do you know if B's done that before? >> Yeah, because you would only refund if you can save dollars. There's a specific state statute that says you can only refund if you save on interest. So the point being that what a lot of schools do and I would recommend the same to J schools is pass a resolution give yourself a minimum savings threshold that way you got all target exactly what the parameters would be for us to even consider refunding and if we didn't generate savings still move forward so you've given Dr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 133
and Tracy the authorization but not required. We would only do it if we can save on interest. I made that same recommendation to school board last week and CFO the other day. So there's no harm in passing the resolution because ultimately if you can't refund because interest rates are not where they should be, it means you got a good deal when you first sold the bonds and that's great. Got to go home mortgage. refunded back when interest rates are low and you can't refund now. It's okay. That means you got a great interest rate. So just again it puts you all in the driver's seat to make decisions that are best for you and your taxpayers. >> So when we had our retreat um it was talked about quite a bit with um when it comes time for renewal, you know, will we need the whole 31 cents?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 134
Should we reduce it? Should we have none? And so a lot of that discussion was about the renewal, but you and I, you know, I've talked to you here in the last week or so. You you have brought up other options. I I did not know that schools did that. It and I'm not implying that we should. I'm just saying that that was a surprise to me that that after a voted referendum amount that that could be changed. And so, um, that's something that during the the retreat we did not talk about. And I don't know. I guess I'd like to talk to other schools with referendums and and wonder why they might do that, what the strategy might be. >> Yeah, >> they did it here, right? They reduced they voted. very the very first one we we did the I was not on that board but they did >> the board prior >> and when we came on >> it threw off the whole >> projection but then what we did is we we stayed conservative then the next two years trying to get a better >> they voted 15 cents on the referendum which got us in a hole essentially because it could have been 20 cents or whatever.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-08-19 Benton County, IN YouTube / School Board transcript source: youtube August 18, 2025 BCSC School Board Meeting · passage 135
How you calculated that kind of gives you a visual what you actually on your, you know, to stay a balanced budget essentially. Like why why ask for a referendum and take 31 cents if you only need 20 cents. But it got us the and I wasn't on that board either, but they voted 15 cents. So when the new board kind of came in because everybody was upset about that. We had that vote right away 31 cents which also upset upset the taxpayers. So now like that's that's what I when I was on the board I was like let's just stay balanced. Let's not take more than we need. But that's that's kind of what we're all trying to get on where we were already in a hole. So, we need to work on that and even vote on I think we we vote on it every year, don't we?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above