Since the IASB's sample policy 2110 says the term of the president is two years, I think that that would be IASB's recommendation. I also recommend a two-year term versus a one-year term. There needs to be stability in board leadership, and holding an election for board president every year could be problematic if a different board member was elected each year. To me, it makes sense to follow the board member election cycle and hold the board officer election every two years when new members join the board. End of statement. So then I guess you would open it up for discussion. >> Okay. Or like >> I will start if you want. >> I I don't mind. I I think that the I hear the 2027 term um part of it. That was a curiosity that I had um if we are, you know, since I don't know what it's not that they took oath, but that we elected them in um for the two-year term.
And so I really appreciate your willingness to to get on this ride with us. >> It's it's been great so far. >> So thank you, Jay. >> Yeah. >> Anybody else would like to say anything or have any comments? >> All right. Perfect. So we will go on to approving this. And I want to say this correctly. All right. I move the governing board approve the superintendent annual evaluation for the school year 2425. May I have a second? >> Thank you, Miss Ays. All those in favor? >> I any naysay? None. This is so great. Motion passes. Thank you, Jay. I appreciate you. >> Thank you. >> All right. And that brings us that basically concludes our student outcomes focused governance portion of our meeting. And that brings us to 5A public comments. Miss Huarees, do we have any public comments today? Thank you. I appreciate it.
I had curiosities around that. Um with Laura's statement, I'll just kind of give my own feedback and my own on it like from my own experience. It's really hard coming in waiting on the terms and coming in being uh sworn in and then immediately going to choosing who's going to be you know president, vice president, secretary when you are just joining you you haven't had any a lot of times no interaction with people. Um you don't know what's going on. they're learning a lot and it just takes to me it takes away that ability. I mean we work as a board as a whole and we all work with Tom. Um so it to me my personal opinion is it makes sense to be able to have that experience for various members. Um potentially someone who's like I'm interested but two years is a long commitment.
Now, approval of consent, which is item six. I move the governing board approve consent agenda items A through H in accordance with policy 1-302. May I have a second? >> Second. >> Thank you, Mr. Jones. So, those in favor? >> I. Any nays?
It opens that door. But mostly I mean it's really hard coming on and literally turning around and having to make that vote that's locked in for two years. It makes more sense to me for someone to be on the board for a year and be able to understand who is working, how they work, and how things are working. Do we want to keep the current roles or do we feel that there's a better ability to maybe mix things up? Um, I think that's where my question of that came. A lot of it was from it was really hard. like I'd never met you guys and I was like, okay, I'm basically being told who I'm going to elect in that case because I have no idea, right? And I'm not going to do it if I'm just getting on the board, but I my interest may be paid along that way.
Hearing none, that moves us to 8A, which is personnel. This is proposed changes and additions to governing board policies 1-203 and 4-45 first reading. Board members, I hope we had the opportunity to look over this equal opportunity and interest base meeting and confer um sections.
And then at that time, you're you're signing four new people on to ask them to do the same thing. It's really it's bizarre in my opinion, but >> can I get a clarification? Are we talking about modifying this such that it's just the president that's going to a two-year term or is it all >> all current two-year officers? >> Okay. Just want to be sure. >> I do understand the because that was a question of mine too was since the current officers were elected under the current policy, would we have to stick with that policy for the two-year cycle? Um, I don't personally find an issue with doing it yearly because it could end up being the same person, right? >> Um, my experience being on a board, it was a different type of board, obviously. It was a nonprofit, but we actually had a one-year limit um because we didn't want anyone to feel ownership over that role.
Do we have any questions, any wonderings, any comments? Miss Ays, >> um I'm I'm really thrilled with this and um I talked with Jay the other day because I haven't had a t chance to talk to anybody from um the local um like Kelly because normally we we chitchat. Um but I'm really excited about um us changing this to IBN. I think it's going to be um a lot more focused um like we have been a lot more focused and I feel like IBN will be a lot more focused um in discussing um you know working conditions um in our district. Uh so I'm I'm really happy that um we have done this. >> Yeah. And thank you so much Miss Eris because I know that since we've started on the board this was something that you've worked really hard on. you sat with our attorney and had back and forth conversations along with the superintendent.
Um, and I think it's good to get new perspectives if someone's willing to step in and take over. If not, then, you know, it continues. I'm good with the two years as is. Um, to me, this is a position. in all three of the positions are you're taking on extra added responsibilities and I commend people for doing that. So there is a little discomfort if you're a new board member and you don't know the people particularly well. Um, but then I tend to trust the existing people and the fact that they're volunteering to do this in the first place to take on this extra responsibility uh once again to me is uh speaks to a little bit about their desires. Um the other point is I think two years is not that much time and especially I'll say board president um it's important to have continuity there.
So, I really appreciate you taking this lead on and and making sure that all portions of our district are working together and this is I think a missing piece that you know we needed to work on. We we initiated it back I think in 2020 when we were first elected. So, it's been a couple of years and we grow and we learn and I I think this is the next best step to getting that process going. So I appreciate all your hard work. >> Would it be okay if I just give a quick shout out?
one year. I don't think if if you happen to be changing people, it it probably takes a good year to learn the facets of being a board president. I know Craig does a lot of extra stuff that um behind the scenes um that's required for that uh that position. So um and then I also believe in if there is an issue with performance that they're given a person is given an opportunity to correct that. And I don't think you can do that in a year. So I think two years to me is the right length of term. Understand totally understand the discomfort it it puts on new board members but um but I tend to trust the existing board members um and the people that are volunteering to take on that additional responsibility. >> I guess I'll speak up. So I'm also for maintaining two years.
So first of all, I want to thank Miss Ays because she was invaluable in this part. She has so much experience with this. So um but the other thing is I want to give a shout out to our CA partners and President Kelly Blakesley. Um you know, they've just been incredible to work with. And one of the changes that's in here that I'm that I know she and I talked about and we were kind of excited about is that the you know in the past we've surveyed subsets of staff for part of our IBM process and under the new policy and we'll be working together to make sure that the entirety of the staff has an opportunity to participate in the survey which I think is very powerful. It certainly ties into CEA's values and Miss Blakesley's values and so just working with them as as a partner team has been very much appreciated.
My three reasons are again I think stability and continuity is important. There's issues that overlap over years. There could be contracts, capital projects that are pretty complex that you have to have knowledge on. Uh I will acknowledge it's I think for everybody when you get elected the first thing you do is basically seat a new board of of people you don't know. But uh even with one year every other year we'll be doing that basically. So that will still exist. Uh, I also think having a two-year term for the majority of time keeps the board focused on governance. We're not really talking about elections. Now, to Rob's point, if someone's not performing, if they can't perform, there are provisions where we could do that, but that way the board is not always in transition or we're not talking about this except for every two years.
>> I just had a question. I guess it was hard to go and look cuz given what's going on with our website right now. So it was I mean with the policy stuff it was hard to go and look and I know that some things have been adopted and amended over the past few years um with regards to this. So I guess I was just confused on exactly what was changing other than the IBN like name. >> Yeah. So it's it's a the reason it's a little more difficult is when we moved to the new model policy there there was in the base policy manual there was no uh meet and confer or IBM policy. So it just kind of >> not intentionally but by virtue of the shift was deleted. Um but the old one actually was ours anyway because it wasn't in the old policy grouping either.
Um, and then I do take the recommendation from IASB to heart. they've got well have experience in this with best practices and uh they've seen a lot of boards and so when they make a recommendation unless we have a very compelling reason internally to go against that I think that uh we should take their recommendations to heart >> I'm I am I'm in favor of leaving the policy as it is. I'm always a little bit of a um concerned about unintended consequences particularly when we aligned like IASB or others. There's just things I don't know out and and be kind of impacted as things move forward. Um, one I will echo and say I appreciate you, Rob, for saying, you know, that the the extra work that all the officers put in and yeah, there's a little bit um from a board president kind of like the relationship that you need to build over time with the superintendent and the other staff's kind of critical um to be able to understand because in a lot of ways, yes, while um Tom is our only employee, we I work with the most with him right now and whomever the superendent it might be.
And so um this one I know u Mr. Castillo when he was working on helping to put together the initial draft that Missys and myself and and uh big shout out to Dr. Lauren who also gave us some amazing feedback that was integrated um looked at was really heavily based on what was there before. So the biggest changes that I'm aware of are the shift that Miss helped us with to use more interest based uh negotiation language. Um and then and that's really more of like a uh systemic shift, right? Um and then the other piece would be that change in the survey process to in include um the availability of that survey to all staff members. >> Thank you so much. Any other questions or comments? And this is just a first read. It will come up if for some reason we need to relook at these and have any other questions.
So I I kind of feel like I'm kind of like the HR department that kind of has to help make sure that their goals and objectives and what they're trying to do and are they aligning to what we are and then coaching the board into a a a not coaching working with the board on figuring out the right way of getting to where we are in a way that fits within the the work and and the uh responsibilities that they all have. That takes a lot to learn. So, if we have an opportunity where this turns into a one-year term, that could take time. So, between the glide up of learning to learn the job, being on the job, and then if there's a point where the board is somewhat contentious at any point in time, and people need to kind of campaign and work through it and make big choices and that sort of stuff, that could take a month or two.
We still have time from this board meeting to the next one to adopt. Okay. Hearing no other questions or comments, we will move on to 11 general. Um >> yes. >> Do we need to do anything with the just read? Sorry, my my apologies. It's been a while. So, thank you. >> It's okay. um 11A which is governing board um the trust model policy program update first reading. These are I'm assuming a lot of different changes and that have been happening assuming from the last legislative session and these are the updates to stay in coordinates to state statute.
So by the time you're at that point, you're really only effective and inefficient for about four months at a time, which is a challenge for me to be able to kind of I could see sitting in the seat. That could be a challenge for someone doing that. Um I do understand that this is an option that someone could maintain the same seat, but I've seen plenty of boards where that becomes a bit of a hot potato over time, you know. Um and that that that be can become a challenge as they move forward and where there's continual an adjustment. I appreciate entirely, Danielle, what you're talking about because all of us were in that boat where they sit down at the chair like, "Wait, what? I I need to pick these people and it's a challenge." And and um I I at my time I came in and I reached out to the existing board members and I talked to them.
Um do we have any questions or comments regarding these? Yes, Miss Gibson McClean. Um, I just know that there was that new law with regard to phones and I know sometimes people have questions about it. So I was just curious for like a very brief update about what you might be thinking about there. >> So So the brief update is the law really just requires us to have a policy that addresses it and um that is not heavily addressed in this update because the district already has a policy that addresses it. um we certainly could look at um amending or modifying that policy, but we don't we don't necessarily need to make changes to be in compliance. Um and where that would seem to live from my perspective is with the um student conduct policy group because that would probably be really the best place to have any determinations about um shifts and changes.