They said to me, "Hey, just FYI, I think it was a superintendent at the time." So, FYI, you're going to be doing this and it's weird, so you should reach through. So I think there's a maybe a mechanism that we could also work on a procedure effectively with incoming board members to help glide that in a little better than it has been in the past. So so for those reasons I'm not in partic as well as I'm not reiterating things that others have said as well. So I agree with all of those from this policy committee. Um there's basically three things we can do right now. One, we can vote to try to change on it. Two, we can leave it until a year from now because even if we nothing's going to change till 2027. So, we can table it in one year, we can come back to it and say, "All right, do we want to change this for a year or three?
One of the things that, you know, we've really I know um the board brought up concerns related to cell phone use in the schools last year. And so, one of the things that that we've been taking some time to pay attention to as we've been out in the schools is like, is this something that's problematic or a disruption? Like, are students following the policy and and the requirements that currently exist? And as far as we've been able to see with, you know, notable exception exceptions that sometimes lead to, you know, student discipline conversations, um, we're really not seeing this as a as a my voice went out. Sorry. As a widespread challenge, um, in our schools right now, but it is certainly something um that we we could have that team look into more deeply. Um, and we can also have conversations, you know, at the school site level to see, you know, if people are starting to experience some of those disruptions.
We'll leave it the same." That's kind of the three things that we have because no matter nothing's going to change now until 2027 for those that want to change it. So I mean it's up to us what you guys want to do. But I have a question that I think is relevant. Does so the board workshop that we have does that happen every year or just when there's >> we try to do it every year. We've done it every year as long as well. No, >> there's an opportunity every year to at least have discussions about >> how well somebody's doing their particular job or just adjusting roles. Absolutely. Yes. >> Yeah. It also gives an opportunity for those that are in those particular roles are like, I don't think this is working out or I need I need more help to bring that up as well.
>> Um, another question that I had quickly, I'm sorry, is, you know, I noticed, for example, there is a policy 5-401 police interview notification. That wasn't really a policy that was standalone before and it's something we've addressed within other policies in the student conduct committee. And so I guess my question is is um twofold like one like making sure that we're kind of trying to see how all of this still melds with this the work that we're doing on the committee. Um >> and then you know double-checking like you know is this written in a way that we also still want to adopt? Is it the least restrictive? You know like the things we do on the committee basically. And so maybe what I can do and I'll just put this out there is take a look through this since these are the changes from the last legislative session and um given that it's still within the purview of the committee's bounds which I would assume then I could have us maybe take a look at some of these in the committee moving forward as well.
So, anyone in favor of waiting some time and voting on it prior to the 2027 date? >> I don't think anything's going to change. For me personally, I don't think anything's going to change from now in the year. I don't know that we need to I don't know that I need to revisit it. I don't think anyone's going to change sorry any input that they have on this. like I'm ready now. I don't And we can always if if anyone changes their minds, we could always revisit in a year and change it again, couldn't we? I mean, if it really like came down to it, if there was something like we're like, "Oh my gosh, like we made a mistake." I I don't >> Yeah. Then we change this policy and then there's another policy that we would change >> 2.2. >> Yeah. It it because it touches like um there's another policy that would specifically speak to that when >> Yeah.
>> Absolutely. I mean my recommendation would be um so uh not to get too geeky but um unless something passes with a twothirds majority um usually 90 days from sin die the end of the session is when they take effect. So for us that's September 26th. So my recommendation would be if we we can't review it in time you know to make changes for a second read perhaps we adopt it as is and then take a look at it in committee and make adjustments after the fact. >> Totally. and you have far more expertise than I, so I would love to have your eye on it. But from to my level of expertise, what I've noticed about these trust policies and even the updates, they are very tight to statute. So there's typically not a lot of wandering outside of what specifically we require. >> I mean, I can already tell it's a lot less fluffy than whatever we had before, >> which, you know, the upside to that for us on our SOFG journey is that, you know, we're we're supposed to be on a policy diet.
Right now, it's all tethered to uh board elections cycles. >> I'm going to be honest. I think I'd rather just table this for a year. That's my That's my opinion. So, >> I'd like to just vote as keep it or I want it as is. I don't think we need to wait or re-evaluate unless someone brings it up like you're saying. If someone wants to bring it up in a year, fine. I don't think we need to make a formal statement say we're going to revisit it in the year. I'd like to keep it as is. >> But if if I guess the question is if we either vote now and it's and and the vote goes the way it goes for whatever people choose to do at that time, right? And then it and that's it. Or we leave it as is right now and vote in a year so that people have had in theory have had time to think about it, consider it.
One of the first things you're supposed to try to do is pair as much of your policy manual down as you can to specifically statutory issues. So, you know, we kind of I don't know, hate to use this description, but it's almost like we went on like a quick weight loss program, right? And um but now obviously sometimes you go a little bit too far. I've never managed to make it too far in my weight loss journey, unfortunately. But um >> but um you know there are probably some things where we may want to add some more meat onto the bones because there are things that are specific and important to our community that we want to make sure are captured in there. >> I agree with that for sure. All right. Thank you so much. >> All right. Any other questions or comments regarding these first reads?
Maybe at our next board workshop there's more discussion about it. Whatever else I'm just throwing that out there. Is that am I interpreting that right? Option one is to vote now. That's it. It changes the policy as a second read or first read or whatever it is. Or B we table this for a year. Those are two effectively the binary kind of votes. >> Yeah. I guess you're not as is. No, nothing's required. Right. >> Right. We wouldn't do a second reading, >> right? We would end at the right touch. >> Right. We might need to later if we're going to do that official change. >> I think I'd rather vote now like right now about where we stand on it. >> What? >> Nothing. >> I guess now I have my own thoughts. All right. >> Isn't it? >> Any everyone in favor of voting now?
>> All right. Perfect. Looks like that brings us to our LB. This is part of our legislative political report. I do not have anything. I don't know if any other members have, but this is something that will be in addition to so our community and our members can be informed of civic engagement and that how that will particularly impact Crane as a whole. >> I mean, there's one update since our last meeting that doesn't have to do with the legislature, but it's still kind of political, which is um the ruling in the capital um funding court case. Um, and I have I haven't had time. I got to page 30 of 114 of the ruling. Um, and it's a judge I've done trials before in front of and so it's very interesting seeing a different side of things. But um, it's very thorough is what I'll say and is like so in-depth and um, it will be very interesting to see how um, the Court of Appeals addresses it and obviously the Supreme Court because they're not going to quit.
Thumbs up. >> Voting now. >> Okay. We have enough to vote. How many? That's four vote nows. Okay. We have enough to vote now. >> So, is that a is that a formal action? >> That's it. >> No, it's just consens all your This is first reading. So, you you have consensus to now make a decision. Do you want this policy revised? so that we can bring it back to second reading next month and stipulate that it's a one-year term. >> So now is effectively >> if you there isn't consensus to do that then we're leaving the policy as it is. >> So right so here's my question is then next month let's say we change it then we have to bring 2.2 up for first read. >> Yeah. Um I >> organization >> which is the reorganization >> that's the reorganizational meeting even if we bring it up as one as a first reading that's fine from a timeline perspective because this isn't this isn't going to run into December you know what I mean so you'll be fine because as some of you have already pointed out it would impact to 2027 and then moving forward 2028 2029 that >> so is this just kind of a thumbs up all in favor and all just just you know if you >> thumbs up is to change the thumbs up >> however you want to word it.
Um, but you know, um, there are, just to get real nerdy on the law side, there are justices who just like really love the Arizona Constitution and that's like their whole shtick. They're kind of like local Scalas, right? And so like what that what that means for us though in the education world is that um, a lot of Judge Fox's decision is based in the the guarantees that are made within the Arizona Constitution. And so a lot of times when you're making arguments as a lawyer, if you can base your argument in the Arizona Constitution, even more so than the US Constitution, you got a better shot of of winning things. And so I'm hoping that this decision is the vehicle that's going to get us there. But it will be a long road to see when that actually pans out. >> Well, since you have been so open and honest, I will share that I have not made it through all the pages myself either.
Yeah thumbs up >> I think you got to be careful about this. >> All right let let me let me be the moderator. Hang on. Let let me play the moderator here. I will >> uh so as a board please provide a thumbs up if you would like the policy to be changed to a one-year um one-year term for all officer positions on the board. Okay, >> that would be a thumbs up. >> Oh, >> I can't see it. >> That was >> one, two, three, four. Okay. So, there's consensus to bring it back as a second reading. >> Okay. >> To a one-year term with it written. >> Do you have that noted, please? >> Yeah. I want to make sure we have this button language being changed to a one-year term of office >> for all offices >> and then we'll have to um address the second policy that talks about the reorganization meeting.
There have been some sections that I've just skimmed, but I mean in addition to what you described, which I think is really powerful, there's some amazing sort of alignment of how the prior Roosevelt v Bishop case like comes into play in relation to the constitutional ruling and what's happened since Roosevelt v. Bishop and um students first and all of those types of things. So, it is like a history lesson in school capital funding, a very scary one, and a history lesson in state constitution around these issues. And I just like like you, I was blown away by what I've gotten through so far and and the accomplishments that the judge has has made in trying to really sort of lay the groundwork for what's the reality here and what should the decisions be even if it were appealed. So, I'm hoping because this acts like a powerful tool set of why we're in the right that um the courts upstream will uphold the same decision-making.
>> Okay. >> And then that's where you guys will take formal action on that. Okay. All right. Next item is dashboard. Tom, it's item 6.3. >> Yeah. Sorry, I'm just making a note to myself real quick. Okay. Um, so, uh, as promised, based on the July board vote on the power metrics that kind of completed and shaped out everything then we've been working on for the last couple of years. So, um, I'm not going to speak too much to it. I'm going to let my team take over the presentation of the actual dashboard. Um, but I think this is meeting some of the dynamics that mirrors exactly what our strategic plan is focused on while also giving the ability for the community members to dig a little deeper where on certain parts of the strategic plan and empower metrics that people would want to look at.
And while it does it it isn't a solution for us today, hopefully it's it'll help improve capital funding for public education in the future. Um, the judge also weighed in on one of my favorite arguments that I just love to talk about, which is, you know, there's been this argument in the state for years and years about why is charter school capital funding indexed to inflation, but public education funding is not indexed to inflation. and and the judge even took that on and you know basically made the statement that the public school education um capital funding should be indexed to inflation in order to meet the standards of the constitutional protections. So that's good reading. >> Tens of this judge reviewed tens of thousands of pages of exhibits and did a trial, bench trial himself. And just to put it, the people that are going to be judging him at the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court have staff attorneys and law clerks who are paid to do all their work for them.
And then just as a quick reminder, our website will still hold all district uh report cards and school building report cards published by ISBY. So it's all still part of that that program. So, I'm gonna go ahead and turn it over at this point. So, our objective was to there supposed to be a drum roll or something like that. Do you have sound? >> Sure. >> Uh to make a interactive dashboard that helped the community get to the heart of the strategic plan and see where we were in terms of progress. And we used as inspiration the DMG model. The colors are a little different, but it's essentially what you'd find in the DMG model. You can click on the mission and vision and see it. You can click on the theory of action or you can collapse it, but you can essentially dig into any one aspect of this without being overloaded cognitively with too much information.
Basically, this man has no one working with him. You know, you've worked at the judge before. They don't got nobody doing any work for them. He wrote that 114 pages himself. >> So he put a lot of work and effort into this. I've got I mean there's times when you get things that are just like denied no explanation or no. So it's pretty wild. If you have a chance and that's your thing, you can get into it. >> Awesome. Thank you for those updates. Do we have any other legislative or political updates? >> Just a question for you, Madam President. Do we intend to do these uh reports as part of the meeting agenda going forward? >> Correct. Okay. >> Until never. it it's always going to be there, especially given our climate. I'm sure there's always going to be something to be talking about.
You want to just simply short circuit to the goals and the priorities. the priorities and their their respective goals themselves, they're there. Um, this particular graph when you mouse over various data points, you'll be able to see the the data that's behind it. So, you can see that. So, that's for 2024 at 2023 at 57. I can't read that far. Um, or you can also remove some of the elements at the bottom. So if you click on math growth target that'll go away and you can focus on for example just the reading targets and that's the case for any of these graphs. No, I'm just for clarity. We don't have the 20 24 20 because that are in that we don't have it the data yet, right? >> We just Yeah, we will have it. I think we have it. We just we can put it into the graph.
So, yes, it will stay on the agenda. Thank you for that question, Mr. Jones. Um, all right. Hearing no other legislative political reports. That brings us to 12A, future agenda items. Do we have any future agenda items? All right. And I think the board self eval Oh, no, never mind. All right. Perfect.