But >> yeah, you really just want to steer clear that kind of effectively for sure. >> Um so now and again I don't wish this on you. So unfortunately the board recently did have an expulsion hearing. Um the board uh first received evidence of the incident triggering the expulsion hearing and during the second part of the hearing the board uh received evidence about the student significant disciplinary history. Um at the conclusion of the hearing the board voted to expel the student. Day after the hearing a board member who was unable to attend the hearing stops you a board member in the grocery store. The board member says, "Rumor has it that that student has been a discipline problem since elementary school. Is that true?" So again, you're the um you're the board member who did sit in on the expulsion hearing, a board member who was not able to attend the expulsion hearing stops in the grocery store and says, "Is it true that that kid that you expelled yesterday has been a discipline problem since kindergarten?" Can't comment.
So we had a a dip of 80 students in the one year. That's why it's so off. So, here's um updated districtwide projections. If we were to continue to trace out the high, medium, and low projection. So, again, if we were to stay on that medium track, we'd be at um you know, about 5,000 students for 25, 35, 10 years from now. Uh you already saw we're at 4,300 roughly um now. So, um, give you a second to digest a little of that. So, um, this is, you know, the information just broken down into grade level changes over the course of the next decade. As you can see, obviously the uh the um K6 continues to grow. Um the middle school would peak out in 23 uh excuse me 20 334 at 880 students. So um almost as big as Highland Scott almost. But um yeah, it's a lot of kids.
Um, good afternoon everyone. I'm a PAR educator at Granite Hills special needs. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. Uh, I want to bring attention to an issue that's affecting many of our staff, the changes to the employee benefits. These changes have had a real and immediate impact. Uh speaking from personal experience, I even as a single employee have had to change my uh insurance provider because it's so expensive. Uh this has disrupted my healthcare and others I know who are dealing with added financial stress and strain from the changes. Uh we recognize the district is facing a financial strain. We appreciate the difficult decisions being made. Uh however, we urge the board members to respect the human cost of these cuts. uh our wages and health and our ability to care for ourselves and our families are being affected. Uh as dedicated employees who support every students every day, we are asking for positive movement on salary and health and welfare.
It doesn't say anything about like a form, but it does say it should be in writing. Um, and then the same like if you're unable to put it in writing, like the district will do it that for you. >> That's fine. >> Um, if the receiving school administrator is included in the allegation, the complaint or grievance shall be transmitted to the next higher administrative supervisor. [Music] And then failure by the um staff member to timely inform a school administrator or the next hire supervisor um shall be may subject the staff member to disciplinary action. >> Yes. Uh the staff member shall preserve the confidentiality of the grievance and only um disclose to the appropriate administrator or next hire administrative supervisor. >> Um the student or parent of the um student may initiate the complaint process by com Oh, let's complete the form again. Um the complaint or grievance may be drawn withdrawn at any time and once withdrawn the process cannot be reopened if the resubmission is longer than 30 calendar days.
And to quantify that scenario one kind of maintaining the debt service levy total borrowing amount of 6.6 6 million and a total interest cost of 2,361,000 2028 bonds uh $30 million project fund $32 million overall borrowing equates to an interest cost of $21,322,000. If we look at scenario two and that's again increase in the levy 4% annually, you save about 280,000 on interest costs in that scenario. But then by the 28 bonds, it's about a million and a half. And that's still keeping the same 20-year footprint with it. Of course, you have the ability then to to shorten that up like we've done in some prior situations uh for prior bond issues, but it gives you a little bit more flexibility. And I'm not necessarily advocating for for 4%. Uh I think just something to think about is if you take care of these projects, how do you set yourself up over the next 5, 10, 15 years?
Um and so because the reservoir level is low, we need to watch how much we take. So that's why we are in a stage two. So um we've had some some good rain throughout the summer, but apparently not enough. Um so that's the thing. And then our sewage actually goes through Framingham out to Deer Island in Boston. Uh so when we were talking on Tuesday about infrastructure, there was discussion about wastewater treatment plant and um things like that. So, these are there's a lot of information behind the strategic plan that a lot, you know, not everyone knows, and that's understandable. Um, it's amazing what you learn when you're sitting in municipal as a as an elected official. Um, but if you ever have questions, don't hesitate to reach out not only to staff, but to anyone on the select board or if you have bylaw issues on planning, reach out to our planning board members.
>> What's that? >> Can't comment. >> Why? And why is that? >> Because it was the person was not there privileged information. >> It's it's confidential student record information. It goes back to the only time a board member has a right of access to that is if they're performing a board responsibility. The board members who sat the expulsion had a right of access. A board member who didn't sit in that area has zero right of access. If if the board member says, "Oh yeah, you should have seen the kid on a sheet going all the way back to you know multiples etc." That's a violation of that information. So can I so if we if we were in the executive session board members couldn't make the executive session we discuss things of policy of some specific nature. We see those board members afterwards. I think can you brief me on executive session?
Two grades that building. Um, I'm sure that's something our community will ultimately take up again. But, uh, you can kind of get a sense of where our enrollment goes. And it's exciting to me. Um, when I was at the Cheshire High School principal, we had 1,600 kids. It's it's a lot is great to have that many kids in the building. Um, and that's the projection for 25 uh or 35. I can't even wrap my head around 35 36. These projections, by the way, uh take into account development. They take into land for development. Um Mike the the demographer has spent a lot of time meeting with our town planners, our officials, reviewing um plans and proposals. Uh and so they do take these things into account. Um, and he's still reviewing those things. Um, but you know, the numbers you see before you should generally uh reflect the future projections.
Uh when staff are supported, students benefit as well. Thank you. [Applause] Okay, that brings our um close session comments to close. We do have um we need to go into close session. So, I'm going to read what we're going to go into. Um, just to give everybody a heads up because everybody's here, we will be back at 700 p.m. if even if we don't finish or not, but we'll probably end up going back into close session at some point to finish. So, I'm going to read what we're going to go into now, but we will be back at 7 p.m. We have the presentations from the schools and some other presentations to do as well before we go back. So close session item one superintendent evaluation two people personnel of expulsion cases STIP 52425 and STIP 724 conference on litigation government code section 54956.9 subsection 8 current litigation 10 cases CIVB 222303 23221 17124112359 CIVVS2400289 Government code section 549 54.5 subsection C and 54956.9 subsection D2 two an E1 anticipated litigation one case 20242501.
Were you shaking your head? Did you see it? Uh, James, >> Sorry. I thought you shook your head like, "Yep, I see it." >> No, no, no. >> Okay. I don't know that I see that part. >> You want me to open it up and help scan? eight. I know that one's much longer >> arrangements. Sure. >> I don't know that I see anything about the ability to take it to like remove the complaint. >> Okay. I'm just going to put then red not included in the new material. Uh retaliatory or imit intimidating acts against the student who's made the grievance. um or a student who assisted, testified, or participated in on any manner of the investigation uh are specifically prohibited and constitute grounds for a separate complaint. >> You see it? >> Yeah. >> Um to asssure that students and staff are aware of its content and intent.
Can you do it with maintaining your current debt service levy? Does it need to increase by 2%, 4%, 5%? Uh what does that ultimately look like? And I I think you could even, you know, potentially set out on something and then change that going forward, but trying to come up with some plan. We know the general assembly is going to continue to make changes with this. So, how how do we fund what you need to fund while staying flexible to still be able to pivot if we need to? There are additional changes that that come up. Uh so you're not put in a bad spot and feel like your back's against the wall. >> Can we go back one slide? >> Maybe do this again. Go to the bottom left corner circle over there. Over there. >> That's painful. >> It is tough. >> Okay.
Just like if you are parents, you've reached out to your school committee if you have questions about school curriculum or issues that are going on in your schools. Okay, we're going to go back to uh 2 C and 2 D. 2C is promote preservation and planting throughout Ashlin to expand the tree canopy and promote carbon carbon sequestration and goal 2D is become a model for sustainable land use, waste reduction and green infrastructure. And I would say that Ashlin has done a lot of this already. Like I said, becoming one of the first green communities back in 12 or maybe 13, 14, I forget which. And then looking at our last two big major building projects, we did geothermal at both our both our public safety building and our Mendes school and the new Mindzes. So we are we are talking we're not only talking about this as a community, but we are doing it as a community.
Is that okay? >> So yeah. So the distinction here is is for so >> okay. So yes suppose in executive session uh you discuss you know how about attorney >> sure you discussed attorney about some issue. I couldn't you know I couldn't attend the session. you know lying what the discussion was in that example yes that is proper because you're a board member you have a right to even though you miss the you have a right to know session now I guess question you know how the board I guess the question is um should that briefing be done you know board member A goes to board member B not the chair to say hey someone after the executive session or should that go to chair to the chair for it's probably best keep it that way just so that it's the same everyone's getting the same message but no that this example really is because that that's where it's and also again so I'm a board member who was I turned all the documents back like I was supposed to hear I should erase from my anything I learned in that it's false hearing because again I've got to preserve that as confidential.
He's very well aware of the north end. So, um, this next slide uh speaks to the capacity in each building. So obviously it's really important that when we redistrict in 25 26 this year for next year's school year, we don't want to get ourselves in a position where we have to then redistrict three years later. So we're looking to fill buildings in a place where there is room for growth. You know, the north end there's there is more space there for development that may occur. you know, you don't want to fill that at 98% capacity in year one and then have to redistrict three years later. So, really cognizant about the loads in each building. You can't underfill it either because this has to go to the state and you know they're fitting a pretty significant amount of money on this. So, you know, they they're going to need to approve this.
Item four public employee discipline dismissal release reassignment transfer leave title certificated and classified employees. Item five public employee appointment resignation retirement reduction title certificated and classified employees. Item six conference with labor negotiator agency negotiator Jeremiah Harrison. B. Employee organization, Alpha Valley Unified Teachers Association. Conf or item seven, conference with labor negotiator. Agency negotiator Christian Dupri, employee organization, California School employees association. Eight, conference with labor negotiator, agency negotiator, Treine Nelson, employee organization unrepresentative. And finally, item nine, security matters, government code section 54957, consultation with Apple, consultation with Apple Valley Unified School District Chief of Police. Okay. So, um I can only speak for myself as the president. We are going to go into close session and I know there's items six and seven are on here. I'm going to push very hard that we come up with something to push forward. We have negotiations tomorrow and on the 12th.
A notice of this policy and pro procedure shall be posted conspicuously in each school building and shall be made part of the rights and responsibilities section of the student handbook. >> I don't see anything like that. >> Okay. Um and the forms um are readily available for submitting these complaints or concerns. Anything about that? >> Okay. Um the disposition of all complaints or grievances shall be reported to the superintendent and the compliance officer um for discrimination if other than the superintendent. And the superintendent will determine if the policies of the district have been appropriately implemented and will make such reports and or referrals to the board um as may be necessary. I don't know that that's in there either. >> Okay. Um the st the the superintendent uh shall develop procedures for the maintenance and confidentiality of documentation related to the receipt of the students complaint or grievance findings of the investigation and disposition of the um ma matter.
So for everybody, can you explain why the debt services increases from 2025 to 2029 and then just drops off and then levelizes again? >> Yeah. So that was just the way I kind of set that up for a structure just to kind of illustrate what that 4% annual increase would be going back to to what uh you've kind of done historically and keeping up with inflation eventually. My thought was in 2029 you're going to have additional needs. So how do we fill in within that current uh that current footprint? So I I set up the stair step eventually. I didn't want to set up the stairst step where you pay it off in 12 years and it's just increasing forever. So that's why it stops in 2029. Again, completely illustrative. If you wanted to see at 28 or 30 or 27, that that would certainly be an option.
And then that's it. So it's about five of eight. Um I have I'm not seeing any more hands or any comments. Do you have any general comments about what we talked about tonight? Please feel free to raise your hand and comment. Um, again, it's I'm seeing some names that I'm not as familiar with and I'm seeing uh I really appreciate that participation. I know thanks to Mike Kaira and Jim Adams at our Ashlin public schools, they shared information about these forums to our the families that have kids in our school system. So, it's great that that is out there. Mark, you have uh one last one last comment. >> Yes, I do. And it's basically saying what I what I do and everybody at all committees inside town hall and out around the town is that I put myself out there for all the things I've been doing because if I don't say anything it doesn't the citizens doesn't hear but what I'm saying now is that there's got to be more in the citizens that know what's going on out there and people talking to me back and forth and I tell them what's going on as much as I know but I'm but I know that down the road the future families coming in but I'm I'm afraid they might not get any of this understanding and what this town is actually about and what the grow and what the growth going to be.
So if my neighbor says oh my god what did that actually do? You can't talk about that's confidential student information. The only thing that would be public is the actual expulsion motion which won't have a lot of detail to it and it will not identify we never identify because we can't identify a student in it'll say student or something like that. So bottom line is even if you're forever >> confidential child like who that child is there as well. >> Yes. their number in >> what's that >> it would be reported in the minutes that student [Music] >> which is not >> no one can figure that out so um yes you may know that it was you know five words um you would know that but if someone's reading said hey you know I heard kidney just I don't know who that was I don't want my you know that I thought my in some way your answer has to be I can't that is strictly confidential can't talk about it so okay so another um so yesterday the local newspaper published a front rate story again this never happened to my knowledge um about a teacher employee of the district who was arrested for selling narcotics in the community article identifies the teacher by name and school parents come uh parents from that school come to the next board meeting and during public comment several of them expressed concern that the teacher must be fired immediately unable to resist it must be Penny board member again um responds by saying rest assured this teacher is history is board member statement appropriate a yes board member had every right to make comments under the first amendment no board member's comments created legal exposure to the And why?
They're going to need to look at those numbers. So, um this slide just really speaks to the fact that we're looking at capacities. There's a scenario A that was created many years ago. This is not the scenario that we are going with. I tell you with 99% probability. This was a scenario to basically um take a look at locations and things like that. And obviously since this was created in 2022, that was before the north end development and you know things have changed significantly. But this gives you a sense of the sort of maps that we would be looking at and where people in different communities would be moving. So, please don't quote us on this. People will freak out like this. Oh, this is this and this is a lot of um angst over nothing here to be honest with you. But it gives us a model of like what would projections look like, what would enrollments look like?