2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 157
The eyes of your employees and students are upon you. The eyes of your community are upon you. The question is not whether you have the ability to act. The question is whether you have the will to do so and what's best for all of us and our future. Will you rise to this challenge or you continue to let the ship sink while those who depend on you struggle to stay afloat. We can't answer this question for for you only you can. And I pray that you an that your answer is that you are willing to do what is necessary to move us forward together. With both lead negotiators for CSEA and AVDA being ministers of Christ, yes, we're pastors. I know our prayers and our hearts are for this district and our people we serve. It isn't a coincidence that it happened this way. I promise you, Steve and I are both really nice guys.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 158
So, let's get to know each other and let's move together to work onward in solidarity. Mr. JC Scott, President, CSEA, Apple Valley 828. [Applause] >> Okay, up next is Ava Karen. First of all, October 21st is our exec board meeting. Is there any way to um start the board meeting an hour later at 6 instead of >> Okay. Yeah. Because that would impede in our we're having training that day as well. Okay. And thank you for the board members who graciously allowed us to continue on. And sorry for inconveniencing those who were upset. Okay. Good evening, Superintendent Nelson, board members, cabinet, President Scott, Ava members, CSEA, and other union members, and overflow. We had a good many over over there tonight, too. We appreciate the support tonight. I'm going to keep this kind of short because I know others want to speak as well and it's already late.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 159
These are difficult times for our district employees and it is during these times like this like these that we must band together even more as we move forward. We stand stronger when we stand united. And tonight I want to finish presenting some of the figures that I shared earlier. Just going to briefly go over I briefly went over the insurance with you and just wanted to point out again that we received 124,000 towards our healthcare. That is all that we received the last time. Um and as you know we're at the bottom of the salary. Even Atlanta, a district who has faced serious challenges and in now an impass is ahead of us and that's unacceptable. I've also provided you with scatoggrams and as you can see from the scatoggrams um last year we had 742.5 full-time equivalents and this year the numbers dropped to 695.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 160
That drop directly lowers the cost of the 1% increase to salaries, making it more affordable for the districts to pro for the district to provide relief to educators. In addition, I have shared salary schedules from um his with you and as you can see, we mark the 5, 10, 15, and 20 year mark. And that data data is staggering. At those key career points, Hisparia educators earn anywhere from 12 to 23% more than what we do here in Apple Valley. That is not only unfair but demoralizing to the teachers who have dedicated their lives to this district and our students. I've also provided you with several unodudited actuals. If you want to go to sleep tonight, you can read them. But I did um highlight them and you can see that the um budget corresponds with the same color as the unodudited actual. And as I'm not going to go through those cuz Steve went through those earlier, but the one thing that really stands out to us is whenever you look at the um 24 25 unudited actuals, the last page and the 2526 budget that um our certificated staff um has decreased by 7.5.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 161
5 million and our certificated pupil support salaries have decreased by 2.4 million while certificated supervisors and administrative have gone up by 2.4 million. So we're just kind of wondering why that is. Um we know it's not they're getting extra money on your paychecks but is that because of increase in positions? We would just like to know why that increase is in the budget there. Um then we are not here to make unreasonable demands. We are here because we know the district has choices and those choices should reflect the values of this district and this community. Students deserve strong schools and strong schools are built by supporting the teachers and the staff who dedicate themselves to our kids. Abuda is committed to working with the district, but we need to see real commitment in return. Tonight, I call on you to put resources where they belong in classrooms, in students, and in the educators and staff who serve the community with heart, skill, and dedication.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 162
On a lighter note, I'm excited to share that Abuda has entered a float into the Happy Trails Parade on September 13th. We will be handing out drawstring backpacks to children along the parade route. Any certificated employee who would like to walk with us and re will receive an email with a form to sign up. This is a wonderful opportunity for our students to see us out there in the community. Whether you are a counselor, teacher, SLP, this is a first for us and I know it will be a proud moment for the Apple Valley educators. Before I close, I want to thank everyone again from all the unions for coming out tonight and showing solidarity. It means a great deal and is deeply appreciated. Have a good evening. In solidarity, Karen [Applause] Okay, I had a request for a five minute uh restroom break. So, we'll be back in five minutes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 163
Thank you for showing me. >> Okay, everybody's back. So, we're going to move on here. We have a next one is item two on discussion items. So, just to let everybody know that's still here. So, we have one, two, and then we have public comments coming up. So, just hang tight. I know there's like nine cards, so let's get through this here. So, uh, item two, board bylaw 9323, meeting conduct, and I see that trustee Okara brought this forward. So, did you want to start off with it, Maria? >> Oh god, I wish I had it in my hand. Um this board uh policy that I was looking at was the meeting conduct. Uh I was interested in making sure that we start our meeting and end it on time so that the personnel that are present will have the opportunity to u get home and get some rest because the board meeting is on a Thursday.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 164
It's not on a Friday which means that you still have to get up and go to work the next day. So I wanted to make sure that we hold ourselves responsible for making sure we are done on time so that the staff can go home. Um teachers are here. Um but in some instances we don't have teachers. Um we just have the personnel sitting on these days with us. Uh so I wanted us to make sure that um moving forward that we if we have to we have to rearrange our board agenda so that our agenda will address things that uh relate to our kids our school do it out of the way and then we can do the things that the housekeeping portion of the board meeting uh after that. So that was why I wanted it and because we we tend to go on and on on board meeting on things that um will bug us down.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 165
So we need to find ways to um um to figure out how to work our border agenda so that we can get out here on time. Not to say that I don't want to be here. I live by myself so this is my day to have people around. But um so um when we were talking about this, I wanted I don't know if everybody was aware of it. So I thought perhaps we should um I should go over the bylaws of this um board policy 9323. It says, "All board of trustee me meetings shall begin on time and shall be guided by an agenda prepared in accordance with board of board board bylaws and posted and distributed in accordance by Ralph Brown Act and other applicable law laws. The board president shall conduct board meetings in accordance with board bylaws and procedures that enable the board to efficiently con consider issues and carry out the will of the majority.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 166
So we are a board of five. So there has to be a majority for that will. The board believes that late night meetings deter public participation and can affect the board's decision making ability and can be a burden to staff. Regular board meetings shall be adjourned at 10:30 p.m. Unless extended to a specific time determined by a majority of the board. The meeting shall be extended no more than once and subsequently may be adjourned to a later date. So we only have one time to extend it and after that we just have to follow finish whatever that time said and we'll call it a day. Um that is the the big part of it. And then the other big part of it was the members of the public are encouraged to attend board meetings and to address the board concerning any items on the agenda or within the board's jurisdiction so as not to inhibit public participation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 167
Persons attending board meetings shall not be requested to sign in, complete a questionnaire, or otherwise provide their name or other information as a condition of attending the meeting. Uh, in order to conduct a district business in an orderly and efficient manner, the board requires that public presentations to the board comply with the following procedure. Uh, give members of the public an opportunity to address the board on any item of interest. uh to the public that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board either before or during the board's consideration at a time so designated on the agenda at a regular meeting. Members of the public may bring before the board matters that are not even listed on the agenda. The board shall take no action or discussion on any item not appearing on the posted agenda except as authorized by law. Um, so you know, I'm I'll be more than glad to have this posted so everybody can see it and know how we are supposed to conduct ourselves.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 168
But the one thing that is that is key to me is to make sure that we close board meetings on time so that staff can go back and get ready for the next day. >> Well, one thing that we may do is start some of it earlier. I know some of you guys have jobs that take you away from starting earlier. Uh but it seems like we get bogged down with the closed session stuff is what drags this on because we can't seem to finish it within the two hour we provide. We used to start at four or um we used to even do this one hour of close session and now we're at two and we're we need more time >> and that was one of the reasons why we wanted to do the close session again is because if we're trying to do close session at midnight then everybody's like out of it and things can get overlooked and stuff but that's here nor there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 169
We'll we'll deal with it tonight. But I think if we begin the starting the meetings maybe uh at 4:00 for close session and if if we we did talk about having like an open calendar where we could it's like a moving target where we could change times without noticing as far as yeah well we can notice within 24 hours. >> So for a normal board meeting it's a 72-hour posting. Um, what our current board policy indicates is that we will be at approximately begin at approximately 5:00 PM, but we have posted as being at 5:00 p.m. So, you have a little bit of flexibility in order to move it to 4. I don't think my opinion, and we'd have to um ask others, is that um starting at four with it setting approximately five probably is not um within the policy. We would probably want to change the policy if you wanted to to look at the close session agenda and identify that we might need a half hour.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 170
I think we could probably pull a 4:30 and we'd have to just indicate that it is based on we'd have to bring the calendar back. >> It's on here. Yeah, it's on and it's here for that change to say to match our board policy of approximately 5:00. Then whatever it's posted as would be the start time that the public would see. Mhm. Okay. And too is it's um we can move things around during the the meeting. We can you know as the pre as the president whoever sits in the president's seat can move items around like I'm going to take something out of order with just proper notice to the rest of the board to agree with that. So um we can we can try that. Maria just maybe start putting it in there that's approximate. we could start earlier if it's going to be a heavy close session day that's getting bogged down.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 171
I think it will work. Uh but I think uh what we need to look at what exactly do we move forward to you know so if we are going to um move it and say we're starting at about 4 4:30 uh what agenda items can we have as a close session discussion before the public actually comes because when we're doing a a public facing issues uh there are issues that come on an agenda that does not require the public to be part of >> most likely simple litigation. >> It could be litigation. >> Every single thing that's on close session they can comment on. So that's why we post it the way we do and we do have to we are required to have a public comment session prior for the items on close session. So sorry. >> I get it. >> Okay. Well um >> anybody else >> are we going to discuss it right now?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 172
We can talk till 10:30 on it. >> That sounds like so much fun. >> I know. >> Um I would just request um 4:30 would be amazing. I could probably swing 415, but I am a teacher and I have a parking lot to fight to get out of to get here. So, >> what about you, Anita? You do teach. Like >> she's retired. She can make time. >> You're flexible. 4 4:30, 4:15. Okay. >> Yeah. Yeah, I mean it's better for staff if we start earlier too because they they're here anyway. So, and most of the teachers can get here by 4:30. So, >> five. >> Let's try that. Brun. Oh, I'm sorry. >> Yes. So, I'm a little concerned about starting early. I hear your concern, uh, Trusty Apara, about um making sure we don't go past the 10:30 mark. And I think that's so important um as well um to consider our agenda items and really um make astute decisions as far as how it's built and how much time it might take.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 173
Um my concern with starting early is not having a good time for our staff to be able to join us. Um I'm speaking on behalf of teachers who have later exit times. Um, I'm speaking on behalf of classified maybe who have evening schedules set. Um, I want to make sure that they all have time, including our general community who have work schedules and may want to attend. U, these are the concerns I have with starting any earlier than 5:00 p.m. >> It's pleasure of the board. It doesn't matter to me. I can be here anytime. So, >> I think we should pl we should practice the the 4 and a 4 >> 4:30. Why did I say 4 and 1/2 p.m. >> Well, let's practice that and see how it works and then we can pull back. >> So, during this item, you're having the discussion.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 174
The calendar is in the consent agenda for you to then make a decision about the matching what our policy currently says, which is approximately 5 pm instead of just 5:00 p.m. >> and then you go from there. >> Sounds good, sir. >> Everybody good? >> Okay. All right. We'll move on to item three, board policy 5116.1, intra district open enrollment. And that was brought by trustee Longshore Renee. >> Um, yes. Thank you for allowing continued discussion on equitable access in regards to board policy 5116.1 intra district transfers. Um, California law says it's up to us as a board to decide. Ed code 35160.56 quote permits parents to indicate a preference irrespective of child's place of residence within the district and requires a district to honor parental preference if school has sufficient capacity without displacing currently enrolled students. As previously noted, AVUSD has denied requests of access to our high schools.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 175
Granite Hills High School over the past three years has four years has denied 241 transfers to AVHS and AVHS requested transfers. 41 wanted to access Granite Hills High School. Um and those were also denied. Um when those were denied, we also as a district permitted 82 in district transfers. The board policy specifies that priority should be given to students who one reside within an attendance area so that they're not displaced or that they meet criteria meaning student safety considering both physical and emotional or if they have a sibling or parent who is a staff at that site. So when applications are submitted, it specifies there must be a random unbiased selection process when requests to attend that campus outnumber capacity. This is according to ED code 35160.5. So my question is, what is our current random unbiased selection process to determine who should be admitted whenever the school receives admission requests that are in excess of the school's capacity?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-05 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Sep 4, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 176
Superintendent Nelson, do we have one? >> I can describe the process. >> Would you like me to describe it or would you like me to provide it at an update in a board um presentation? um at in in a board presentation. I think that would be great. I think that would give you time to also uh detail it and be able to present it to us. Um as far as it being a random and unbiased selection, if more students were trying to get to a school than um there were spots for um then I'm looking for the random and unbiased selection process to determine which of those students were allowed in. >> Absolutely. Um, I believe that because we are denying students um, intrad district transfers to Granite Hills High School and Apple Valley High School while allowing 82 interd district transfers to come in to our district.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above