then we can actually see what happened. >> Um so when I look at the budget for 2223 um we thought our revenues would be 246.1 million but our revenues ended up being 263.9 million. >> Mhm. >> So which put us higher 17.7 million. In we had a projected revenue of 231.3 million. We ended up having a 253.1 million which put us up 21.8 million. >> And in that year 2324 well actually I'll go to 2223. 2223 the total revenue as you me as you just mentioned we projected at 246 actually came in at 263 just a little shy of 264 expenditures in 2223 were 246. So yes in 2223 revenue over expenditures we had approximately what is that about a $17.4 million surplus that year. Mhm. >> Um not 21 million, not 17.7, but 17.4 as its revenues minus expenditures. The following year, 2324 in budget, we were expecting about $231 million in revenue.
We got 253. We spent 261.8. We deficit spent that year. >> Yes. >> So we spent more than we got. Yes. >> And then again in 2425 we were expecting $228 million. We got $252.9 but we spent 265.1. >> Yes. Mhm. >> So then our end game is 2425 where we projected we would get the revenues of 228.5 million and we ended up getting a revenue of 252.9 million um for um a difference of positive 24.3 million um which works out to be uh total expenditures versus revenues as of this unodudited actual being 14 million.2 in the green. >> I'm I'm not familiar with how you arrived at that calculation. >> So, it would be just like you looked up at our spending for 2425 being minus 10 million and then as I just pointed out our income, our total revenue being 24 million. I took the 24 million minus the deficit spending of 10 million and arrived at um in the green 14.2 million.
>> Okay. Um so >> it's not an accurate calculation if you're looking at the actual financial activity in the 2420. >> I'm gonna interrupt here. I don't think Renee we're going to get anywhere. We have a lot to cover still tonight. >> Okay. Sure. >> And I'm not trying to cut you off, believe me. Um, but I don't I think uh what you provided is is what you provided, but I don't think that it's fair to just ask Matt all these numbers up there to to describe this. So, >> Oh, I wasn't asking I was just presenting. >> Okay. >> Yeah. So, I wasn't actually asking him to answer. Um, but I did want to present the data that I found and organized here. And and of course, I also have the budget for this year. uh the 2526 in the pink. Um we have the total budgeted expenditures and I also have the total budgeted revenues.
Um the budget we passed in May as a board changed uh to the budget that was released in unudited actuals. Just wanted to point out in three months time our projected spending uh decreased 723,000 and our projected um money that we will have our revenues went up 11.4 million. So I thought that was great news and um I have this available for anybody who would like it. Um you're welcome to it. I have three of these Mr. Rowley, any more questions from the board I can respond to? >> Um, well, I don't have any. >> No, I think you're good. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Okay, Kylie, send me the cards.
Okay, remind everyone uh three minutes, please. And the first one I can't read. It's What does that say? Test. Test. >> Cyan Pierce. >> Okay, there you go. Cyan, did you still here? >> Was that close? >> Here. I remember you from last time. Yeah. Okay. [Applause] Get my speech up here real quick. Sorry about that. >> Thanks for waiting. >> Of course. Yeah. All right. Um, good evening. Remember me. I said I will continue to return until we meet change and as we know I still start school at 700 a.m. Uh honestly I didn't expect change after just 3 weeks. However, I feel it's necessary to continue to make my presence and requests known. I speak to you this evening concerning the well-being of most teens enrolled in AVUSD, specifically high school. Um, according to the American Academy of Sleep Medicine in an article published to their website aasm.org on August 16th, 2016, they say a natural shift in the timing of the body's internal circadian clock occurs during puberty, causing most teens to have a biological preference for a late night bedtime.
Returning to an early morning school schedule can shock can be a shock to the system for teens. It is also important that parents and local school boards work together to implement high school start times that allow teens to get healthy sleep, the healthy sleep they need, and to meet their full potential. Teens require about 8 to 10 hours of sleep. Let me show you some of my personal experiences over the last 3 weeks trying to force myself to uh to sleep by taking melatonin at 9:00. So, I go to bed about 10:30 and wake up at about 6. That's only seven and a half hours of sleep, but I wake up groggy because of the melatonin. Melatonin. On a normal night, I finally feel tired enough to sleep at around 12:30 to 1:00 a.m. That leaves maybe 5 hours of sleep max. I'm no longer groggy, but still so tired.
I have to rush to school because traffic is horrendous at Granite. leaving at about 6:25 in the morning and still have to drive through the dirt field just to make it to the parking lot and make it to class on time. I often wake up not feeling well because I live with a stomach issue I've had since birth. And sometimes if I haven't had enough sleep, my stomach is so upset I end up throwing up. Most of the time this doesn't happen until the middle of first period. I always feel better after throwing up and resting a minute and by 9 I'm in tiptop. But what happens when you puke at school? you get sent home and you accure an absence for the rest of the day. Something that can personally for me can be avoided with just a later start time. Now the last time I was here, Miss Tucker, you said you heard me.
And I want to ask you and everyone else on the board, did you hear did you just hear me or are you also listening? And while you're at that, I implore you to also listen to what Mr. Javier has to say. Thank you and good night. [Applause] Thank you, sir. And we have Terry. You're up next. Yep. After Terry will be Veronica. Yeah, I'm kind of littleer. Thank you. I am Terry Peak. I am mom to five Peak boys. My job has been to support my kids teachers and their daily routine. Let's not go into the countless hours of spent in the classroom and the thousands of dollars I've donated and spent to help make classrooms and programs a success. If you ask just about any teacher that has had one of my boys, most are retired or have moved on, they'll tell you it was a special year in their class when they had a peak kid.
They became an extension of our family. I have been my boy's rally supporter at sporting events, theater programs, ceremonies, and awards. I am my kid's mom. I've had one graduate with honors and go to college. One graduated high school and went straight to a career. He's now a secondstep manager making a considerable amount of money. One graduated with high honors. Too many sports awards to list. By literacy, works for BNSF as a conductor. One graduated class of 2025 with honors, multiple certifications, and a dual career pathway and is currently in college. And well, you've met Kian. So, yeah, I think I'm doing a pretty good job as being my kid's mom. So, I'm here for two issues. Ken is not a rebellious teen. He doesn't fight against my rules or family obligations or our morals or ethics. He is a revolutionary, always challenging the status quo and trying to bring change and make things better.
He is fighting for later start times and I support that. Read the studies. Obviously, Governor Nuome did in 2019, six years ago, he created a law. I ask you to follow it. It's for their benefit. My other issue is regarding transparency, parental support, possible violations in board policy at a district level and all of the above, plus student advocacy at Granite. In recent years, there seems to be some huge lack of accountability and communication at this once great for my family, high school, and district. I have been a 23-year parent supporter of AVUSD. I've been on multiple committees instrumental in passing Measure S, the founding member of several parent support groups on various campuses, parent advisory council. I've been awarded and recognized by the county, the district, many teachers and organizations and schools as an elite volunteer, volunteer in action, or simply for being the everything and showing up.
I've been a substitute employee. Everything AVUSD has done for the last 23 consecutive years has directly impacted my family in many ways. Some good, some amazing, and some in very recent history detrimentally. My family has been hurt recently by things allowed by the board. I've really put myself out there for this district and have rarely if ever heard or been supported in return. This time I ask you, hear me. Hear my son. listen wholeheartedly and act. I am open and willing to talk about any and all of the above mentioned in depth. I have an idetic memory and an abundance of experiences. And if you need help or a volunteer trying to figure anything out, I know where you can find one. Thank you. Good. >> Thank you, Curry. I see where your son gets his >> speaking ability. Yes. Yes. Very well. Very good.
Veronica. >> All right. >> And after Veronica is keep go ahead. >> I think everyone needs a quick laugh. By the way, dogs do eat homework. >> If you get a Belgian Malininoa, oh, good luck. All right. So, I want everyone to take a moment. Why did you enter education? No one in this room, the board, the staff, no one said money. We need to make enough money, but none of us entered for educ for money. We thought about the impact we'd have on kids. We thought about that one teacher that we had back in the day that impacted us. For me, I did not go into education. I had a successful career in healthcare. I worked with cardiac patients and I did that for a number of years. um and due to life circumstances thought that I wanted a change. So um I decided to enter teaching.
So I asked people because I'm not from the desert to add to it. Where should I go? Apple Valley. Apple Valley is great. That's where you want to go. Really good staff, really good community. They're great. And I do believe that. But the version that I'm seeing now that I'm hired and I'm here is different than what I was told. So, what I was told was this version that we all knew used to exist and it's not the same. So, I entered teaching during COVID because I'm super intelligent. I took a $50,000 pay cut. I can show you the double W TWS to back it up. And so, I entered and I'm not expecting to get that $50,000 back. Don't get me wrong. I mean, if but I have seen that the glowing recommendation is not quite what it was used to be. The pay is significantly decreased compared to the neighboring districts and that is getting worse as they keep getting raises and we are not.
They were playing catch where Apple Valley used to be and now they're leaving us behind. Um as a new teacher the trainings that the district provided the US Department of Education says that 50% of teachers quit within the first five years. We just cut all of those extra trainings. Where is the support for those teachers? 53% of teachers are burnt out according to the National Education Association. We need to be giving people support. That means emotionally and financially. Um I'm single rather the correct word would be widowed. And last year as a new teacher I was teaching after school and a second job. I shouldn't have to do that. Plus we know that teacher hours are not actually the correct hours. Um, I like to think that I am the person that we want to have an education. Yes, I came roundabout. I'm not the young brand new grad, but I am the had a very successful previous career, very well educated.
I got my masters in education as I came. I would like to think that these are the people we want to have in the district. And if I'm pondering, is it worth it? That's scary. Um, I didn't come into this for the money, but I should get a professional wage and receive the support so that I don't become one of the statistics and wash out because I have another career I could go back to. I could call my boss and their answer would be tomorrow. Don't get me I don't want to do that. Don't make me do that. Um, and I have seen the impact that high turnover has on my school already. I've only been there five years, but the constant turnaround of teachers changes everything for the kids and the culture of the school. And so I think everyone in here wants to do the right thing and have the right things happen.
But that includes supporting us emotionally and financially for all of the certificated and classified staff in the district. Cheyenne Johnson. And after Cheyenne will be Kimberly Wilcox. Is Cheyenne here? Okay. Is Kimberly here? Wilcox. Kimberly Wilcox. No, >> I don't think there's anybody back there now. So, um Melissa here. [Applause] [Music] All right. Hello, listening colleagues, fellow Ava and members. Um, Superintendent Nelson, Mr. Conrad, who was my principal when I started at Apple Valley many years ago and the board members. Um, I am an adult transition um, PAR educator at Apple Valley High School working along um, Priscilla Longrigo, who had a leave to go do an IEP, by the way. So um but I asked that the board consider um SB88 which is a state law that prohibits school staff to drive students in district um vans except for bus drivers. So um this is detrimental to our program.
Our students are not able to go to off-campus jobs. they are and these jobs are important because some this is some of the this is one of the reasons why some of our students even show up to school. They want to work and they want to make money. Um and then our students are are gaining our job skills in order to become productive members of society. I work with kids who are moderate to severe special needs. So by them even learning wanting to learn how to work is a is a big step forward for our students. But not only in this, we also are developing um relationships with our community members um in Apple Valley and our and our school and our um school district. So some of these um community relationships are Miss Maria from RVs where our students go twice a week to work.
Also Mr. Arsenio from um um um metal recovery recycling where our students go to work. Not only that, but our students also have built relationships with our school district, including Marina um Torres and Mr. Andrew from Equity Access. Our students are the students that will fill 200 bags in our food pantry to feed 200 people of Alpha Valley community. Not only that, but we have had the pleasure of coming and working our food pantry job dressed in our Halloween costumes and and Superintendent Nelson giving us our um a a um sorry um tour of the school district and you know and that is beyond learning in a classroom. Our students thrive on on becoming our students thrive on becoming community members and building these relationships with our with not only not only myself, the teachers that I work with, but also the the the community of Apple Valley and also the school board.
We our students love being able to walk into the school district and handing out presents to you guys. They love it. But we cannot do that because we cannot drive a van because the state of California has said only bus drivers are allowed to drive and that is hurting our students who enjoy coming coming to our program. And of course I'm here supporting our fellow members since we do need we do need an increase in salaries. I am working three jobs. I c I brought my nephew today um to the board meeting because I am watching him for my brother. I am getting paid to watch my nephew and everything and that is unacceptable. My my fellow CSA members cannot come to board meetings because they're working at their jobs. So, I just wanted to bring that to your attention. >> Thank you, Melissa. I think uh while we normally don't comment on um public comment time, I do want to make sure the board understands that we are working diligently on SB88.
It's one of the bills that has passed, flew under the radar. It was passed in order to stop um Uber andyft from being used for school districts. The there is a list of things that I will take to um uh Sandabs as a way to maybe move forward and change that law. Um if one of our staff members, if Melissa got into the van and was going to drive students over 200 miles, she could do it, but she can't drive locally. And that is an incredible ridiculous thing that has happened. Um it has created a detriment to our students and we realize it. So I appreciate that you said something Melissa because it is on our we're working on it. Um we are trying to come up with solutions so that we can take care of this and get our kids back out where they need to be.