Um, that that was the way things went down, but I expected having the chair of budget and finance before them representing the school committee would be a very good opportunity for city councilors to ask any questions they might have about the budget.
U, but when I went there, I was not asked any questions about the budget whatsoever. I was peppered with questions about the SRO uh, controversy that had happened uh, just prior to that. And uh it was a very uncomfortable experience because when you go in prepared to represent the uh school committee on certain um things and then you're um asked random questions that you're not prepared for. It does leave you um in a in a very challenging place. uh I did my best to represent a balanced view uh from the whole committee and from our constituents or students and uh and what have you in that but it was it was very difficult and um I would also like to uh underscore Cher Johnson Mousad's comments about the impact of these um insults and evidence-free accusations and uh insinuations about waste, fraud, and abuse um in the school department's budget.
Uh those things need to stop because they are having an impact on our ability to attract highly qualified candidates to do very important things. Um so, uh as people know, we're attempting to attract a staff business manager and uh nobody is going to stake their career on that type of environment. Um and uh of course we are also now attempting to attract a superintendent. So we need to be a city where when the superintendent is at a city council meeting they are not um being insulted and when they are there prepared to answer questions from one counselor who did ask their questions in advance. Uh then they're not being prevented from answering by another counselor who seems unwilling to hear it or perhaps embarrassed about not being prepared with questions in advance or or something like that. Uh I would I would really welcome uh good codification of our mutual um expectations for how we treat each other and how we operate together and that needs to be mutual not just a directive coming from somewhere else.
I'd like to try to summarize um what I think I I'm hearing the committee say and uh please let me know if you think I'm getting something wrong. Um it sounds like the committee is interested in um taking advantage of the opportunity of the platform with the city council in order to share our message with um people who would come to school committee meetings. the committee is interested in having a good relationship with the city council, especially since they're the body that give us the number in terms of our budget. Um, it sounds like people want to ensure that that relationship and that opportunity is one that's respectful and also one where um anyone who's attending has a chance to prepare and uh have the ability to um respond to uh questions and be prepared for to answer those questions. Um, it also sounds like the committee would like more clarification about exactly what is the legal framework in terms of the charter, the rules of procedure, the codes, um, in terms of what are our obligations and um, but separate from all of that, even if there was no obligation to attend, it sounds like the city the committee would like to take advantage of the opportunity.
Um I guess um what I would I guess I well first of all is that have I basically reflected back what the committee is saying? It sounds like the committee's also interested in in caring about my my personal uh burnout and I appreciate that that that's really not necessary. Um, but uh uh was there anything else that I missed that the committee said or did I get anything wrong? >> Yeah, >> nothing wrong. But I think there is an interest when we get to item C. I think there's an interest in that. Item C is the discussion and possible vote whether and how to share school committee reports with the city council and considerations of whether establishing a process for transmitting school committee reports to the city council is advisable and if so what the process should look like. >> That's the one. >> Yeah.
Okay. Great. Uh member childs. So, regarding uh letter B, the motion, >> um it seems like appointing someone when we're about to work on this format, it it doesn't quite go together because it's going to take us time to come up with the format and we don't want to lock into this appointee if the format may require revolving. Um, but that said, I do think it is a courtesy and it's a privilege that other city departments who of course are different because school department is bigger and separate in certain ways. I I don't think we should give up the privilege of having that representation there. I this is my opinion. I think it is important. So, I would like to amend that motion to specify appointing someone uh vice chair section if they agree to represent us at the September meeting while we get our ducks in a row.
>> Okay. So, your motion is to um appoint a school committee representative to the September to represent the school committee at the September meeting. Yes. >> Okay. Is there a second? >> Second from member Deniv. Uh discussion. >> I think that's fine. I think we could alternate, but I would love to have member Ston or Vice President Ston do this on September. I think that's great. >> Good. Thank you. >> Any other discussion? I guess I would say um I I would prefer if we were more specific about what we were asking the representative to do. Um, and I feel like one item would be to direct the representative not to answer questions that aren't provided with sufficient notice from their um, perspective. So that we're not sending someone into the September meeting and expecting them to um, respond to any question the city council might ask.
um especially given that we're having this discussion tonight, I imagine there might be follow-up questions from them. So um but so then we would just need to I I feel like we'd need to kind of really direct the the representative on what we want them to use the platform to do, not just send them. Any other discussion? Member Martini, >> I do think that um piece is important um because this has been a murky area even within the school committee. Um this is something that I learned through training with MASC having participated in the conferences, summer institute trainings um that sometimes is is lost or people don't know or understand when they um begin which is that an individual school committee member may not ask the superintendent to go and track down any little piece of information they We act as a committee. It's a group.
So if there's something that you would like to know or that you think is important for the committee to know the the procedure that conserves our administrators time and therefore our ability to attract and retain highly qualified people. Um in part is to ask for an item to be on an agenda. If the chair agrees it will be on an agenda the member can discuss with the committee whether this is information that we wish to ask the superintendent to coalate for us u or not and even if the chair doesn't agree then it still goes on an agenda so that the committee can decide whether or not to take that topic up. It's very democratic. Um we have had this situation, however, uh with city council where um not only do we have have we had individual um school committee members wanting lots of various random bits of information, but then we have an entire city council u full of folks who also have uh lots and lots of uh various questions which the commit the school committee may or may not want our um school administrator taking their time up should to should to should to should to should to should to should to should to should to should to should to do.
We have to decide whether it's valuable, whether that is something that um this individual that we are supervising should be should be doing. Uh I think that is part of uh the problem that occurred last year. I think the school committee has really bent over backwards trying to be as transparent as possible and answer any question that came up and I know that our uh previous superintendent did as well this past year. Um, as part of this guidance that we may be developing here, um, I would like to ask that there be specifically guidance for budget and finance. Um, because I was asked to uh, spearhead some cooperation uh, collaboration with ways and means and was happy to do that. I reached out to the chair of ways and means, invited him to our next meeting as a subcommittee as well as a a second city council member, gave them the floor as our first item to say anything that they wanted.
they were uh generally treated as members of the subcommittee which uh probably was not really within our policy or necessarily appropriate but uh we really wanted to give them the opportunity to ask any question you know whereas if they were just a member of the public they wouldn't have been able to do that now I know I came prepared to that meeting with a long list of questions for the superintendent um and I don't uh neither city councelor uh questions prepared in advance for that meeting. So clearly that did not result in any uh improvement in the relations between school committee and city council and I apologize to everyone. Obviously, that was a flop. Uh, and I wish it had been more successful, but uh I would I would really appreciate it if um this guidance can cover specifically um the roles and responsibilities and what um the this particular subcommittee with regard to budget and finance should and should not do.
Um, so that because I think that's probably going to be the main point, the main issue of communication between the two bodies realistically, if that makes sense. I'm I that probably digressed a fair bit. I'm sorry. >> No, I appreciate it. Um, any other Oh, uh, Secretary Denive, >> I guess I just want to say that the community engagement subcommittee is on the cusp of having a joint meeting with the city council community relations subcommittee, which sounds like a tongue twister. Um, exactly tongue twister. So, the community engagement subcommittee of the school committee is about to have a joint meeting with the city council community relations subcommittee next Monday. And this was a baby step to try some of this just really meet and greet kind of vibe to create a relationship. But that came about because of this general feeling that we're not all getting along.
But just bringing up the concept of it brought people to complain that we shouldn't do it. So people want it and they don't want it. So, I can't make a anyone happy, which is fine, but I'd like to have something really set in stone about how we do this so that we can do this work and have everybody understand what their lanes are and what is allowed and not allowed so that good things can happen and there's some guardrails in place so that it doesn't go strange. Well, I mean, speaking of guard rails and guidance, our one of our policies really says that subcommittees are to do work that's directed by the committee as a as a full committee. And so I don't think it makes sense for the community engagement subcommittee to be initiating a joint meeting with the city council uh subcommittee without bringing it to us first and getting our getting us to to vote on whether we're directing the the subcommittee to do that or not.
Um, so I guess that's a whole other kettle of fish, but um, uh, so anyway, that's where my mind went when you when you said that. Um, >> it was in last month's report. So I guess that sort of also speaks to we should have it like really >> known and decided so that we don't you know I mean that's why we made such an effort to make sure that it was in the report and we spoke about it as early as possible you know to like give space for those comments and thoughts because this is like we're waiting into new territory >> but it's territory territory we must explore. >> Yeah, I I personally missed that. So, I really apologize for um not noting that last month. Um great. So, where we are at discussion of An's motion that we appoint someone to represent the school committee at the September meeting.
Um I guess um I could see two options. Um I don't know if we we can vote on your motion clearly, but um I wonder if given the discussion if we might want to just wait another month and go in October or what direction if you would be open to amending your motion and giving the representative some specific direction about what to talk about and how to handle uh questions from the city council. I could easily amend it to being just a recap of the highest points of this meeting with the direction being if asked an inappropriate question to say that I do not have that in front of me right now. >> Okay. So, you're um amending your motion to say um a motion to appoint an individual to represent the school committee at the uh September city council meeting with the direction to share a summary of what took place at this meeting and to not respond to questions that are outside of the scope of that person's comfort or knowledge.
Okay. And who seconded the motion? Do you accept that? >> Yes. >> Okay. Um, and did your motion include a particular person or or was it open at that point? >> Well, I moved for Ston because Ston seemed like they have the resources and are willing and I'm not going to step in between someone else and city council if they're willing to take that. Do you want do you would you accept the nomination from the committee to do that in September? >> Sure. >> Okay. All right. Um any other discussion? Okay. Uh let's um let's vote. Secretary Dene, can we do it as a roll call vote? >> Chair Johnson Msad. >> Abstain. >> I'm a yes. Vice Chair Son, >> I think I have to abstain. >> Okay. Member Martini, >> yes. Member Childs, >> yes. >> Mayor Disorger, >> yes. >> Motion carries with two abstensions.
>> Okay. And thank you for the motion and thank you member Ston for being willing to represent. Um, I guess before we move into item C, I feel like there is an item hovering. Um, or maybe it doesn't have to be a formal motion, but I think it would be good to ask the superintendent to work with council to have a presentation at the October meeting just giving us a picture of the legal framework of all of this with regards to the charter, the um rules of order, and the uh code that the ma mayor referenced. Mayor, >> I I think I just emailed that to everybody with Ian's help from the code. I just emailed that. >> Thank you for providing that resource. So, what do people think? Would that be um an okay would that be helpful to the committee to have a presentation on that?
Any objection to having that happen? Okay, great. All right. Um so, we'll move on to this item. And there's um a handout from member Deniv on your um proposal. So do you want to speak to this? >> Hey, no. >> Okay, maybe it didn't make it into the packet somehow. >> I can I can speak to it though. >> I can pull it up. It's pretty short. Um see if I can grab it. But if you want to if you want to start speaking to the intent of it, I can. >> Um, I made this very rough and loose because I wanted and hoped that we would have discussion about it because I think that this is something that we have to start and I know it's uncomfortable and we haven't done it before, but baby steps. So, I apologize if it's not polished in any way, shape, or form.
But the idea that I had was that we find a way to get our reports to the city council in a really mindful way that is the same every time. And in my mind, I had well their meeting is a week after hours. So after our meeting, say like this evening when we're done tomorrow, the when the minutes are ready from NAN, we send those off to the city council with the concept that they have the entire weekend really and Monday to think about their questions and send them in. And then that would give the whoever's attending the meeting and the superintendent 24 to potentially 48 hours to get answers to things. And then to know that those are the questions that they're answering. And if there are further questions, those will have to wait until the next meeting or a future date when the superintendent has time to answer them if they are appropriate.
And then the idea with that is that that also gives the city council president a little bit of leeway so that they know that there isn't going to be space for gotcha questions or ways to um cause anyone in discomfort um so that the lane is really clear so they can get their questions answered in a timely fashion. You have time to think of answers ahead of time. Everyone comes gets their report and it's done. And no one should expect our superintendent or a chair to stay for an endless long meeting and it's not in bad form for them to leave after they make their reports. Same as any other department ahead. So that was in my mind and I tried to write something down about it hoping that you would all bring your excellent minds to it and craft it into something that we could really adhere to so that everyone's experience is smoother.