2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 162
I guess I'd share some feedback on it, I guess. Um, well, what what I like about it is having clear timelines about when questions will be submitted and giving sufficient time for preparation. Um, I think that the I think that the assumption that what they are asking about are the are the goings on at school committee meetings is has been in my experience pretty incorrect. like they generally are not that interested in what we're doing. Their questions have generally been yes about budget as um member Martini mentioned at times they've been going over uh really operational level things like what's happening at the high school in terms of the monitoring of the building a HVAC systems and things like that. Um, so I think untying it from our school committee members might meeting our school committee meetings and minutes might make it stronger because I do think it's probably unrealistic for Nan to get us draft minutes and for us to get a chance to at least review them before sending them out to the city council and so on.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 163
And I don't know how much that would really add to the process. Presumably their questions should be high level enough um that they would know about them hopefully farther in in in advance than um than the Monday before this the city council meeting. Um member Charles and then member Martini. Well, what if instead of sending minutes, we sent them the agenda and then the member of the school committee representing is the effective minutes to answer the questions about those discussions because the agenda is done. >> Again, I mean, maybe their maybe their interest in asking questions has to do with our meetings and our agenda items. That hasn't been my experience. But u member Martini, >> I would uh like to suggest instead that a request for questions go out uh to be sent in to the school committee chair at least a week before the school committee meeting so that we can discuss the questions that have been brought up and decide as a group.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 164
uh how we would like to respond or whether we would like the superintendent to track down some uh group of information or what have you. Uh that would that would I think help to keep those questions at that governance level that you were just saying. uh and also uh give the school committee the opportunity to conserve the superintendent's time. Uh I really feel that uh frankly everyone ran our previous superintendent absolutely ragged last year and we cannot do that. We have to establish a more humane um procedure and we as a school committee need to be doing our role um in oversight there. >> Member Childs, >> I really like that idea that member Martini just brought up, but also this is a partnership, so we need to make sure we're not unilaterally telling the city council how it's going to be. I I think to make these guidelines, we probably do need to have some kind of city council side saying, "Oh, yes, this is feasible.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 165
Oh, no, this isn't feasible." Just like how you didn't want the command performance uh orders coming from them. Uh they they definitely don't want us to tell them how they're going to do things. So I think as part of building these guidelines, we need to find a way that we can respectfully collaborate with the city council to come to a plan that both parties are happy with or at least not unhappy with. >> Member Martini and then member Ston. >> I just want to briefly respond. I think the word invite is critical there um that the school committee is inviting questions for a week before our meeting. Mhm. Okay. Vice Chair Ston. >> Um I think that what member Charles was just really getting to is sort of a sort of a key I've been trying to untangle like having a specific you'll get we'll get things to you by this date, you'll get things to us by this time or however many days before such and such.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 166
separating that from the other question which seems to really be the sticking point on the table is what is like actually theirs to ask and what's our job to be asking and what's not their job to ask city councilors anyone as a public a member of the public free to ask any question they want in the public comment section or over email but in their function as a city councelor there are certain things that are just not theirs to to question our our staff member about. Um, so I think that for me like getting that understanding is almost more important than getting the procedure down. And I really would love to see some sort of um conversation being had between us and the city councilors about like what is their understanding of their role visa v the schools um and like can we can we work on that a little bit?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 167
Um, so I'm not sure if that is like an another advisory board situation or if we have a policy for creating a joint committee across two bodies. I don't even know if we have rules for that. I think if there I think I'd like to hear a motion to uh refer these questions to the executive committee to um have a conversation about about plans for achieving the school committee's goals with regard to the city council relations as we've discussed at this meeting. Um >> so moved. >> Is there a second?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 168
Any discussion? All those in favor? >> I. >> Any objection? Any opposed? Any abstaining? Motion carries unanimously. Thank you. We'll we'll bring all those questions to the executive committee and try to help uh chart a path forward. Um great. Um on to new business. Composting of food and paper waste discussion. Superintendent. >> Yes. Good evening. I in front of you. Excuse me. I've given you some information. I did have a meeting. I along with many others. I have some notes there. Myself, facilities director, Budro, our past food service director, and Peg Hall, Nancy Hazard, Amy Donovan about composting. We did this in August, and we have some follow-up information for you here about the cost. um this group would gladly offer knowledge about it, come speak to our students about composting and teach people how to do it. Um they do not have any funds to help us with that though.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 169
So what it would cost and we did do we being Greenfield did do composting prior to COVID and then obviously a lot of things changed at that time. But I can give you here's a cost of what it would cost an estimated cost per year to do composting in all of our schools. As you can see with dumpsters being picked up one time a week, a smaller dumpster at five of the schools, a bigger one at the high school, you have to buy uh barrels. Obviously, that would just differentiate. These would yellow versus a traditional barrel. So, students would do that. And then compostable bags. There's quite a bit of an expense on that for there. Um, as mentioned before school, everybody before COVID, I mean, everybody did it. It started Greenfield High has some interest in it last year. food services and Mr. Bostonramm had some students involved to determine it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 170
There is a slight question right now as to the hauling away and where it would go. These are costs from Cassella who is a waste removal firm but many of our things I think all of it in the past and many of our local communities who are doing this participating in composting dump at Martins's farm if I'm correct in saying that the proper way Martins um learning all my geographic and farms around here but it's up for I'm being I'm hearing it's up for sale in the process of being sold and will they continue to accept waste if that doesn't happen they do accept it now so they uh should that change the cost could be considerably higher depending on where waste had to go and that type of scenario in that sense um we've heard a lot of great things as I mentioned to you last month right it's obviously hard to argue with composting right and recycling and saving the environment right it's it's a tough side to say no to some of the cons I've heard about this obviously cost in that sense there is a dollar figure and you had a tight budget last year right and type budget.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 171
You eliminated several jobs, right? Whether it would be a vice principal, individual aids, teachers at various positions. Um, in some way might question, okay, do we spend money on trash or human beings in that sense? And I'm not trying to sway you. Just some of the things that I've heard in that sense. The other would be it's messy. It's a labor intensive job with custodians, cafeteria workers. I mean, yes, the students are dumping it, but the custodians are moving it. Uh we've heard things about pest control, you know, the dumpsters being too close to the building, um maggots, etc., things like that. Obviously, you know, fire, rodents going in there. So, all those have to be considered in doing that. Um definitely a worthy cause, right? There's no doubt about it. Um, if you were to choose to go forward with this, one of the things that facilities director Budro has mentioned, you talked to me with obviously we're kind of midyear right now and these are yearly costs for you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 172
This is what it would cost for an entire year in that sense would be possibly maybe starting just at the high school at that sense for this year and seeing what happens there with the one dumpster, the bags there, the barrels there, how it goes, what happens with the the disposal in terms of the farm in that scenario. and that gives us time to incorporate into a budget if you so choose to do that for the following year as well. So, those are just some of the quick tidbits.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 173
I know I'm trying to keep it moving along, but I'd welcome any questions. Mary. >> Um, so I was talking with um Athena today and if indeed we do go forward with that um she has a she's a grant writer but she's extensive background in composting and um I'm glad if you're thinking about it that it would start in one place. Um, I think it's a great idea and um, the rodent control has really been a that's been my specialty for the past two weeks, like out of control. Um, and you know what we're going to try is every day putting carbon on top of whatever waste is put there. every time, you know, we're we're going to have up in DPW, every time stuff is put in that we put a layer of sawdust on top. It sounds like that should be done daily.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 174
That's actually a problem at the transfer station that I'll be talking about at city council and um but also at um it's it is through the city that it's a big it's a big problem through the city. So, I think we are going to start it starting at one place and if we do indeed, Athena said she would be happy to work with the school if you were interested in in hearing what she had to say. We're we're going to start that up at the transfer station with buckets of sawdust. >> Yeah. No, we'd be absolutely obviously willing to listen to everybody. We we listen to the the commission here and um I did give you the breakdown for all I did do my quick math here. For the high school only, it would be the 2,700 for the dumpster. About 100 I might be off on the bags there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 175
I'm 108 units of bags. So few thousand on the bags. Probably around 5,000ish in that sense. 300 for the barrel. So somewhere in the range of about five if we were to do it for the high school. Does someone wish to make a motion to either direct the superintendent not to pursue this to pursue one school or to pursue all five schools? >> Sure. Yeah. Vice Chair Son, >> I was just curious if if this is a practice that we've already done, presumably we had some of these equipment pieces before. Where did they go? >> Did we dump? Yes. Sorry, I'm interrupting you. The dumpsters we do not have. Those are special dumpsters. So, those were here and then they the company is taking them back because you're not paying for them anymore. So, those dumpsters are gone. The bags are gone. They're not being used.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 176
And there are a few yellow barrels still floating around, but not enough >> for every like if every school needed two or something. >> Okay, great. I move to direct the superintendent to uh work with the mayor's office. Is who is it in the mayor's office? >> Athena is in economic development. But >> oh well, how about I'll just put like this. I move to direct the superintendent to uh proceed with a plan to reinstate composting starting at the high school. So that's starting with that one school second. >> Is there any change you'd need from the motion or whatever? Is it clear enough or does it work? >> I mean I think from the motion I'm thinking starting to work. We're pretty close to having a lot of information obviously unless the new information from the city hall side of it would be are you committing I'm making this up $5,000 to this to then say go for it if there are no grants in that sense and I'm not trying to put you in a bind right but I can come back next month and just give you a little more information but that doesn't have a starting it >> so maybe the motion would be to direct the superintendent to come to the school committee with a proposal for um what it would look like to do composting in one school for this fiscal year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 177
>> We can do that. >> Sounds good. >> Okay. So, you made that motion. And who seconded? >> I did. And yeah, I accept that shift. >> Okay. Any discussion? All in favor say I. >> I.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 178
Any opposed? Any abstensions? Motion carries unanimously. Thank you very much for that research. >> Thank you. >> Uh The next item is review and analysis of the current regular and special ed transportation operations and discussion of consultant work. Superintendent. >> Yes. You have a packet in front of you that is a bid from a consultant to do some work. I've heard from many members about transportation. As you know, we bid out our large school buses, large yellow buses to Kazcus. they have won the bid and we transport in minivans and a few small smaller yellow school buses in that sense and we hear a lot about and we do some work for other cities towns around us transporting some of their students so that we can receive some money back and cut down on our operating expenses in that scenario over and over again similar to what uh business director Pockquette mentioned earlier today and I think member Den mentioned you know you hear a lot of questions from people about whether or not are we making money, are we losing money doing our own thing?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 179
Was it good to bring it in house? Was it not good to bring it in house? Some of that would be really tough to do because there's different scenarios here. This is a educ not an educational it's a transportation consultant and uh hopefully you had time to read prior to this a bid and what they would do is if you so choose to do this would be for the services costing $9,995 do a scope of work that you'd see on the back of page two there and give you a review and analysis and it take approximately two months seems like at the most and you might have some information for you by December at that point if that was somewhat what I'm hearing if you wanted something inhouse we'll get some definitely can get some basic information to you but probably not as extensive obviously as this could be this money tell me if I speak wrong would come from the transportation operating expense yes revolving revolving account thank you that's why I went to Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 180
So, I guess the question before the committee is whether we um would like just basic information that could be gathered um from within the district or whether we would like to uh spend about $10,000 um to have a consultant give us a more thorough analysis. And if I may just jump in and correct me if I'm wrong, but this is not something that I just um I don't say dreamed of or worked on. This had been something that had been going on since the late spring with the former superintendent as well and the business director for reaching out to this company. >> I think that's a great idea. So, I'd hear a motion to approve the um proposal put forward by Alliance for Education Associates in the amount of $9,995 um as presented. >> So, that's the motion from the mayor. >> Second, >> and there's a second from member Martini.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 181
Any discussion? Uh, Secretary Denive, >> having been slightly involved with transportation in this area, being the driver of the big yellow bus, I know that there are not many options. So, I do not think that spending $10,000 to find out that we could save like $500 maybe, I don't know, is not a good use of our money. That's that's what I think. I think that uh we know who our our vendors are, what's possible. There is a vendor that we haven't talked about that I have some questions about that I'd like to bring up in the future meeting. Um, but I just don't see this being a a worthy expense. And Andy is like his fingers going crazy. >> Oh, >> if I just for clarification, uh, this is only the special education. I know the title says regular and special education. This is specifically this the discussion had been are we making money?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above