2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 182
Was it that the decision made x number of years ago by the former business manager and spe uh transportation director to bring some of the transportation for sped transportation inhouse? Uh is that is it is that the cons is that model which we're currently doing now uh the best approach to doing it or do we look to see the possibility of going back to a contracted service. So that level of detail uh we have provided when various city councilors have asked questions regarding a transportation what we've been generating for revenue what we've done for transportation the mayor's asked some questions regarding who we transport what towns etc etc um so this would this would be solely looking at the special education to do an analysis of and discussions we've had with the the contractor has been now that we know our special education needs needs for transportation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 183
This firm will go and do the research to see the analysis of the cost for potentially I'm going to say outsourcing that versus what it is that we're currently with our current staff. So that it'll be that deeper level of analysis, but primarily looking at the special education side, not the big yellow bus, especially because of the fact that we're in with the whole Franklin County regional bus collaborative bid that was done. So, >> okay, that changes things. I'm glad that you told me, but I still don't want to spend the money on that. >> Any other discussion, Mayor? >> So, it is one of the things that receives the most questions when we just spent an hour discussing relations. Um, this and I think it's they're very valid points of whether or not this is, you know, how we're spending our money here. Um, and I think that it would be very difficult to look at in-house because I think it's that's about a $990,000 [Music] um that we spend on staff.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 184
It's done in-house. So, to be looking at it ourselves, I think I just think that would be very difficult. So, I'm going to vote in favor of it. >> Member Childs and then Secretary Denive. >> So, my question is both for Andy and Superintendent Joyel. What are your professional opinions on if this is a good use of our limited funds? Like is it something that you personally would do? What what direction are you leaning? Well, I can say that based on the number of questions that we've received, I've already done the internal analysis looking at the total cost, what it is that we've generated for revenue, what it is as far as, you know, I'll say from when this was first engaged, prior to us being here and stuff, my understanding, I'm going to say without speaking of those going before, is that they made I'm going to say either promises that this was going to be a self-supporting operation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 185
I would have never made that promise quite honestly. what it is it's reducing our expenses and the analysis that I have done and it is part of the strategic plan is looking at and using the dart those are the communities that we compare to and and the desi combines both out of district and indistrict transportation yellow bus and sped bus to look at the total transportation costs for green field and I compared it to in addition to I did win and beyond I I did it to the dart communities and I did it to the communities that we are contiguous ous with in the area and the total cost for green field transportation when you take into consideration regular and special education transportation because that was the only way with the data that we had available to us to compare apples to apples. Greenfield fell right in the middle as far as the costwise goes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 186
So, you know, to say that it was not a worthwhile investment, I would say I don't agree with. To say that it was going to be 100% self-supporting, I would have also not agreed with. But to say that it is outlandishly expensive and that we're there's a better way to do it. I don't know that where especially on a special education side of things to have them come in and then because the vendor will go in and be able to then go and look at let's look at Van Pool's rates, let's look at Sweets rate, let's look at all these other rates and just compile all that data for us and then to be able to come back and so that way they're in addition to and I'm not saying it's like my emotions or you know feelings are hurt or anything if they don't trust me then trust somebody else.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 187
>> Um, >> uh, go ahead. >> Yeah, it seems I think you'd asked a little I'll just concur with many of the things that Andy had said and also I I do agree with member Den in the sense of not wanting to throw money away in that sense. Um, we wouldn't I wouldn't have brought this forward. I'm bringing this forward I think at the request of many members saying hey what else can we do because people haven't been you know either satisfied or think there's more answers out there right you hear from the public a lot and as as Andy mentioned right they did they prior to me being here right and other people did present some materials for it and yet we still hear that and you heard that and had us had me look into it so given the fact of maybe hearing from somebody else and that you're still hearing it from the public or other people that this is a topic over and over again.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 188
I'm not saying it would put it to bed in that sense, but it'll get the information and then people can decide whether it's something to keep talking about or okay, now we're we're done and we can go on to other things like student engagement or student achievement, right? In that scenario. So, >> Secretary Deniva, >> if we're talking about that relationship again, the people who have been asking me about this have said to me, city councilors have said, "You need to get your sped transportation under control." And I said, "Well, we're required by law to transport these students. We have to do this." And Andy, you explained to us the federal minimum effort. So we know that we have to spend what was it? $9.268 million per year. Did I get that right? Last year. So I don't see why we have to spend $10,000 just so somebody can feel comfortable about this when they could have just googled special ed transportation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 189
Like that bothers me because if we're talking about staying in our lane and having a good relationship, that's part of it. cornering a school committee member and being really insulting to them and saying they need to figure out transportation when they could have just learned what this was bothers me. I don't like that. I don't like that part of the relationship and that kind of stuff needs to stop. So, I don't see why we should spend $10,000 to satisfy somebody's question when this is already answered. Um, I could see spending it if we really thought that we could improve it. If we really felt like there were other avenues that would save us a tremendous amount of money, then yes. But this is just to just to jump through someone else's hoop. And that that speaks to all of the things that you were talking about earlier.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 190
[Music] member Martini. So the long and the short of this situation is that based on the available data from our surrounding area as well as school districts that are similar to Greenfield that we're not likely to save much money or might spend more uh to farm out these services than to keep them in house. And the real reason why we would be spending this money would be to allay hopefully allay um questions or concerns from folks who haven't followed school committee meetings very closely or who uh don't have much faith in what they hear from the representatives of the school committee who go to them. uh is that am I off base in any way in summarizing it that way? I'm going to say quite honestly that I don't know because you know the the analysis that I did admittedly was straight cost >> you know so when when we're talking about the level of detail that they would be looking at they could potentially be looking to things that go I'm going to say much deeper into that where I'm looking at you know a combination of things I'm looking at self-reported data that is reported from these other districts you to to Desi through the various you know the end of the year report in particular that they have to report to I'm looking at you know uh and mainly also because it's only it's already a year be year old in a sense you know as far as the data that is reported and and posted on a desi website these this organization and would would be able to look more specifically at Greenfield is transporting five students from here to a private school in Springfield.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 191
They're using this type of van and then you know Vanpool does a similar run for that from here to there and you know what are their rates versus what it is that our costs are associated with they can get to that granular level. We could get to that granular level, but that would call require Teresa and transportation, myself, calling vendors to ask them to get us their information, calling corresponding school districts just to verify indeed that what you know because I know, for example, Vampool, even though they have, you know, they they charge different schools, different rates because if you've been a long-standing client of theirs, they they will end up maybe increasing their rates only 2% where if you're a newer client, you might get a 3% increase or what have you, you know? So there's all several variables where the the hiring of a firm would would be able to get down deeper where the analysis that I did again repeating myself was straight total cost reported to Desi for all the contiguous and dark communities combining both regular and sped because that was the only way you can do apples to apples because when you look at the reporting at Desi it is they classified as out of district transport.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 192
transportation. So some districts between whether it's the charter schools that they might transport, some districts have agreements where they will allow for transportation through school choice, vogue transportation. So it's things like that where this being focused solely on sped transportation would be the focus of what this organization would do. superintendent. >> And just to uh kind of say that if you look at their scope of op scope of work operations starting on page two going to page three, some of it would probably mimic some of the information that they had done in the past. But I do think there are some new things on there such as reviewing the current and future district requirements, looking at different things, assistance in implementation of recommendations and or contract negotiations, assessment of the transportation department, communications with contractors as needed, technical assistance and mentoring throughout the year. So I do think they would bring some newer information that wasn't there and that may or may not be of some value.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 193
>> Thank you, Vice Chair Ston. It was just seeming to me like there's two different questions on the table that I'm hearing. One is, is this even a worthwhile set of questions to ask? And the second is if yes, how do we want to do that in-house or outsourcing? Um, and so I'm I'm curious if we could actually just before we get bogged down into this folk or have them do it in house, can we have a quick like do we even think that this is worthwhile to ask because it seems like that is there's a disagreement there. Yeah, I think that's what we're discussing. But just to go back to the ind district thing, I think what u Mr. Pette is saying is that has been done and presented. So the the the extent of the in-house work that is going to be done has been done and the school committee and the city council have received that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 194
>> What I heard is that they could do more in depth, but it would take roughly $10,000 worth of their time to do it, which they could be doing other things while this guy spends $10,000 of his time doing it. Well, >> okay. I guess I'll share a personal view, which is if we're going to spend $10,000 of someone, it's time to do this. I think it might be useful to have it be an outside person, there's an advantage of that since there, as we've mentioned, has been some a lack of trust, shall we say, between certain members of the community and the financial information that's being shared with them. So maybe having a outside consult would be an advantage in that regard and also allow Mr. advocate to focus on other more strategic initiatives of the school system. Mayor. So, I'm just going to say I got this the material yesterday and I read up to about here, but not thoroughly all of this this whole proposal, but the the questions that I have I I don't feel like we've asked and sufficiently and you know to to respond to what member Den said we transport during using our own system We transport like 19 children and we from our community and 12 children say from a different municipality and some children we are paying services for.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 195
So, these are the questions that I would have. If we had all of those slots filled, you know, all of the busing slots filled, were we able to transport everyone ourselves? Because right now, what we're doing is some of each. We transport we we pay our own drivers, which is wonderful, and but we still need things like van poolool services. So, we're not able to do the whole thing. And I also think that looked into it should be the the included in it should be the long-term cost because that is something that is part of the whole city budget. Um, you know, full-time employees plus benefits and and I've also heard from diff, you know, I actually was contacted by a union member after one of these meetings and I think you know the service that we provide is a very good service. So, are we able to do the whole job?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 196
Are we able to do the whole job if we had every slot filled? Um, what we're charging other municipalities, has that number changed? Um, so those are things that I would think that we would need to look at. And the cost of the buses and continuing, you know, buying the buses, it might be the best thing. Everybody needs to get where they get. they have to have a good safe ride with somebody with them if they need somebody with them, which many times that's the case. Um, so anyways, even as a member of this body, I, you know, when we're talking about it for somebody else, my questions weren't answered, so I still have more questions about it. Other discussion, member childs, then member Vice Chair Ston, >> would it make sense to table this for the next meetings so that we're not making a snap judgment about $10,000?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 197
>> You uh certainly could make a motion to postpone the motion to the uh uh October meeting. >> I move we postpone this to the October meeting. >> Is there a second? >> Second. Uh we'll say a second for mayor disorgans. Uh and uh all in favor >> I Okay, motions. I guess we should maybe we should any negative consequences for delaying this for a month? >> Yeah. Okay. Thank you. All right. Um, so the next item was um came out of a request from member Goodwin and um uh our attorney had some concerns and guidance for us with regards to this. So I guess in light of both of those things, I would move uh that we um pass over uh the overview of the process for addressing IIA compensation and future contracts. >> So are we moving to skip it or to table it for next month when Goodw member Goodwin will be here?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 198
Well, I guess I was I was saying to pass over. I don't know if that's a Robert's roles thing, but I I feel like between the attorney's concerns and the ability of member Goodwin to have a discussion with the superintendent between now and next month, I'm not sure if we'll necessarily need it on the agenda. I'll certainly respect her request if she would like it um to remain on the agenda. So, I guess my request at this point is just to pass over it. So, is there a second for my motion? Second. >> Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 199
Any discussion? Okay. All in favor? I. Any abstensions? Any um nays? The motion carries with the mayor as standing. Um the next item was the school committee self-evaluation review and discussion and next steps. Um, I think that we covered this earlier in our discussion of the year-long agenda. Any other items on that, Vice Chair Son? >> Just as a reminder, since it was a while and, you know, several brain cells ago, don't forget to come to October with your goals for our for our committee. >> Excellent. Um, yes, Secretary Deniv, >> I have an item of new business, but it is in no way urgent. Can I email it to you? >> Of course. >> Okay, great. >> Certainly. Um, okay. Uh, moving on. I'd like to hear a motion to enter into executive session pursuant to Mass General Law Chapter 3A subsection 21A. Item three to discuss strategy with respect to collective bargaining or litigation if an open meeting may have a detrimental effect on the bargaining or litigating position of the public body.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 200
And the chair so declares the committee will not return to open session. >> So moved. >> Motion from member child, second from vice chair ston. Um any discussion? All in favor? I. Any abstensions? Any um naysay the motion carries unanimously. So with that I would hear a motion to >> point of order. I think we have to do a roll call vote for that. >> Oh that's right. Thank you so much.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - September 10, 2025 · passage 201
Secretary Den, will you call the roll call for that one? >> Chair Johnson Assad? >> Yes. >> I'm a yes. Vice Son, >> yes. >> Mayor Member Martini, >> yes. >> Member Child, >> yes. >> Mayor Disorger, >> yes. >> Okay, we're all unanimous. >> Excellent. And the motion carries unanimously by roll call vote. Um I'd like to hear a motion to adjourn. >> So second >> motion from member Den and a second from member Martini.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above