But the thought of not doing anything and and and the the the request that we do more, I'm I'm in I'm in favor of of of doing more. So, I'm not saying that I'm uncomfortable with raising it. You're you're bringing up good points around we need to understand the ramifications of of the decisions that that that we make. And so, I'm I'm I'm for it there. So, to be clear, I'm saying I'm good to to move forward with all the things that we've already committed to. I, as of right now, am not a fan of transferring $2.5 million from from this fund over into uh fund 14. We said it is. >> Um, I think that's a a broader conversation. I am though in favor of looking at some of the areas in gray and asking where do we are are there some projects that we have not yet given authority to that we begin the process of green lighting.
Following a recent public records request where a parent was initially informed that these reports didn't even exist, the superintendent acting on the advice of legal counsel removed school and grade from the reports without board approval. That action leaves us unable to perform meaningful oversight. This might not be viewed by all board members closely, but for me, I I've reviewed these reports um since I became a board member, and oversight is is not optional, and oversight without sight is no oversight at all. I have repeatedly requested this information be restored. Yet the reports continue to arrive without it. Without access to the underlying data, we cannot verify whether suspensions are being applied fairly and equitably. Evidence already presented to us suggests that it may not be. For example, if a student brings a weapon to school, it is essential for a board member to know which school.
>> We have an idea of when we're going to start this project. um they uh had a 2% design contingency which is included in the amounts I gave you and they feel comfortable that their construction contingency should only be 6%. However, I know how the board feels about contingencies. So, I continue to keep a 10% contingency in the presentation and I plan for a 10% because I know that's, you know, that makes everyone in this room feel comfortable and I makes me feel comfortable not to rely solely on contractors just to give us that little bit of a buffer. So, I continue to put the 10% contingency in short-term facility plan and plan for that financial year. >> Right. I it was in the it was in the when he presented that. >> Okay. I I just want to be tight with our numbers, but let me make sure I understand.
I am in I would be in favor of of that member Greer can ask for clarification um just because you didn't say even though you're not in favor of the right now of the 2.5 you still would be in favor to greenlight the 2526 knowing that there's $2.2 million that's the cost of 2.2 2 million. Let's continue with a deferred maintenance plan. >> Absolutely. Okay. Just wanted to clarify that point. >> I had another It's basically on on the same question I asked earlier, but maybe I'll ask it different because I wasn't clear. So, as we sit right now for the deferment uh plan, we have enough funds to carry us through 2025 to 2026. >> Yes, sir. >> Okay. So then I guess what would be the purpose of adding that of taking from the general fund or uh from the project funds to add to the deferment plan because is or is that for for future years?
And if one student at Williamsfield High School is suspended for nine days for bringing a weapon, while another student at Higgley High receives only fiveday suspension for the same violation, the mo the board must be able to see the discrepancy and understand why the consequences are not consistent. We can't do that without knowing what school it is. The attorney claims the change is necessary to prevent potential violations of FURPA, but FURPA protects personally identifi identifiable information, not broad deidentified data such as school and grade. These reports never contained names, student IDs, or other identifying details. They were already deidentified. Nothing in them indicates any attempt to identify individual students. By definition, they were not they were compliant with FURPA and board members by law have the legitimate educational interest in reviewing this information. Even more troubling, the fact that we use taxpayer dollars to fund attorneys who advise administration in a way that actively prevents the board from fulfilling its responsibilities is troubling.
And Bear Construction is our general contractor. >> Yeah. >> Bear Construction is a is a construction company that's, you know, registered with the TIPS cooperative that allows us to work with them directly. >> Okay. Tips cooperative cooperative. They are the ones that's on our behalf representing us, right? Uh the t the cooperative is you know basically you put in a region where you're looking to get the rates what kind of rate you're doing when you're doing it and then it's all pre-negotiated contracts that the contractor can work with in their subs. >> Okay. All right. And you there representing you are there for our over to make sure we got checks and balances and so on and so forth. Right. >> Yes sir. I I uh I plan to follow the same process that we work with the sports flex. Mr. McClean was very instrumental in that.
The the the purpose of doing that is to continue with the understanding that the 10-year deferred maintenance plan would take on average an additional $2.5 million a year because some of the years is not going to be $2.2 million. It's going to be more than 2.2. So if on on average we would need a $2.5 million additional deposit to ensure that for the next 10 years we we well right now the next seven years or six years that that those would that those would get done. So you so 100% we don't need that for 2526 >> but we do need it if we're thinking long-term we we do need an average of that deposit to ensure that 26 27 27 and and beyond get done as well. But then do we have to do we have to kind of decide on that now or can we?
The board does not have our own attorney that represents us and the taxpayers. The attorneys work for the administration. This creates an imbalance that undermines transparency and accountability. And let's not forget that I myself have had issues with my child's FURPA laws being violated three times in this district since I've been on the board, including one incident where where it included a staff's attorney. If the district cannot protect sensitive identifiable information when it comes to my child, it is inconsistent and disingenuous to claim that providing deidentifiable school and grade data to the board creates a legal risk. Arizona law requires us to receive suspension reports while the statute does not dictate every detail including school and grade is common sense and essential for oversight. Suggesting that the board should wait for for a study session if we suspect or desire more information is backwards. We cannot suspect or desire more information if we are denied the information that would reveal a problem in the first place.
Um, and I honestly think, you know, what I'm what I'm seeing from this, I know, you know, we previously we went out to bid with a lot of SummerSlam projects. As you can see from the agenda right now, we're still just finishing up a payment to read construction from almost 14 months ago. Um, Keith, we've had what, three walkthroughs um on the stadium building since this week. Uh, just to verify the work. It's been a much smoother process. um very little in terms of change orders and it's it's been a much pleasant experience. Uh and that you know through them working with us directly through the tips cooperative what I see is a vendor that's very committed to the district where I can't say I always got that with whoever won the bid because they're getting the bid you know for 3 months and then they're moving on from the project some of the delays we've seen when we went out to bid and working with those contractors.
>> No. No need to decide on that right now >> because it to me if if we we feel like we have the funds right now to as we start the school year to move on with the different plan which we all with the different plan which we all >> see like we have a consensus we want to move forward with that then um right now to not stir things up so to speak and because there's a lot of movement that that that we expect with with the with the sale of properties deposits etc. Um I would just say that we kind of table that for another um you know I don't know for another couple months see how things um play out so that we don't necessarily have to you know make a decision. >> Well so my question to that is so how are you planning to replace that funds if you took it out of the general fund with the sale of the funding the properties or how are we going to replace it?
Transparency and accountability are not optional and I request that this information be added back into the report. As board members, our job is not to take administrative administration's word because we must verify that discipline is being applied fairly and equitably. That is our duty and I would like that information back so that I can uphold that duty. Thank you. >> Board member Van Hook, can you clarify something for me? With the old way with which that we received it, can you explain to me how you're capable? And to be clear, and I should have said this first, so I apologize. One, in no way, shape, or form should your child's information have done, and that is terrible to be clear. Secondly, I also agree with you in that when it comes to discipline that we should do equitable practices. Full stop. I agree with that wholeheartedly.
So, I think it's a very good relationship we have and everyone's pleased with the work and the time frame and the cost. >> Okay. And again, uh let's continue to provide the oversight. the limiting factor that we had, we was looking to get $5 million from our TIF, which we are getting, but the 1.5 million that we're not getting in evidencebased funding kind of take a million and a half out of the five million that we're getting from UP to pay. We was looking to pay $2 million out of that $5 million on a yearly basis to pay for the sports complex as well as the middle school, right? two million a year. That's what we're looking to do. >> 2.25 million. >> So, so we just have to, you know, and and it sounds like we're doing it. So, forgive me if I'm diving in a little deeper than what I should, but I just saw some things that I thought >> and that's why I kind of wanted to say something is that I wanted to make sure that all of us that are voting on what we're voting that they have all the information.
Um board clerk, are you speaking of if we use if we took from the general funds and put it in >> So no ma'am. Right now what we're saying is that we will utilize and max out the funds that are in fund 14. So right now we have $1.2 million, we'll be transferring another million dollars, which is our schedule. Every year we transfer a million dollars. Um if all the projects come to fruition, that would mean fund 14 will be at zero come June 30th. So come July 1, we will be transferring another million dollars, but that's all that will be in fund 14. So nothing beyond the million-dollar commitment that's already been in place that we do year-over-year will be coming out of um general fund. >> Okay. >> And and for the for the record as I by my calculations the only reason why we would have enough in the fund this year to do that is because there was funds deposited before.
Um I I guess where I am struggling as a fellow board member who has had access to that information. I would argue that doesn't give me any information to know what is equitably done in that. For example, let's pretend one of the reasons that somebody was suspended is for fighting. And I taught high school and middle school. So fighting was a part of the job at various times which is you know never fun. And there are circumstances in which this fight that you watch and you see and you see the the the happenings of those involved and you understand why the 7 days or 10 days or whatever it was is given. And then there are other situations in which they are a fight and it's still categorized as the same and it is a very different situation in terms of severity what happens everything else but at the end of the day the categorization is still a fight and so if I see student A fighting and student B fighting and there is disproportionate days while I agree with you they should be equitable how is it that we are capable of seeing those equitable practices from that information.
>> Yeah. So, you've been on the ground level and thank you. We really appreciate you having understanding of this and bringing it to us. So, >> and as I did in June, I will be sure to reach out to Bill when we get closer to seeing those page back plans for the entire school. So, >> just the whole project. I want to make sure that the middle school, you know, like I said, it's been a a good they've done a good job out here. So, I want to make sure we continue that over there and they get a great job at the middle school. >> So, are we at a standstill right now at the middle school with work or we still work in the evenings or whatever? We did a lot of work during the summer, right? >> Yeah. I mean, at this point, we are I am pushing for them to, you know, based upon the outcome of this meeting.
>> Correct. So due to the fact that as as you as you noted before us there was >> um a different an earlier iteration of us had the boldness to say let's put a million dollars aside for for uh into fund 14 and because that happened there is now um compounded you know two deposits or so of of that that are left in that fund and that's the only reason why we were able to do it. So it is and that makes sense to me because that is a regular ongoing expense and we're paying paying that out of our regular ongoing revenue. Um and and so yeah may maybe there's we can have this conversation. We can continue to have this conversation to determine what what we do you know post June of this of this year but but I'm just generally uneasy with the idea of using onetime funds for ongoing um expenses.
I argue before you still had no idea of the context and the reasonings that was done. You just had the aftermath. >> Well, I I think the the violation varies, right? So, but then there are violations where where let's say somebody is caught vaping or smoking or there is a weapon um where so I since I got on the board when we would receive those reports I would take that information and dump it into Excel and then you can actually sort by violation and you can sort by school, you can sort by, you know, different things you could fill filter and then be able to filter, let's say, just on the violation and then you can see the difference in the number of days they're being suspended. So that provides the information where you've you've got a year's worth of data in a Excel spreadsheet and be able to filter on these things.
Um, I would like to break ground, weather permitted, if they could secure stuff and get started just a little bit, maybe pour the foundation, some of the exterior work, >> doing the work in the weekends or something like that or not doing the school days, they're not going to be working, right? >> Well, I'm saying the exterior work, you know, how they got started on bridges a little early with some of that stuff. >> Are they going to be doing that during school hours? some of the exterior work could be done if it doesn't uh disrupt the educational environment. That's >> that's what I'm alluding to. Yes. >> Okay. Whatever they can do without being disruptive to the learning. >> Yes, sir. And then also stay on um also stay on schedule because we know how important it is to finish that project on time.
Natasha, can you clarify for me uh when the board uh gave authority for 10-year deferred maintenance plan, did that come with a $2.5 million deposit? >> No. >> Okay. Thank you. >> I would excuse me. I'm going to have to interrupt. I I'm I'm in a f I agree with board member Greer. Um, since it did not come with it, I think this is a lengthy conversation and we're way past the board meeting. Um, at this point it's 5:00. Uh, no, not 5:00. It's your guys's 8:00 now. Um, we're half hour over. So, I think that we we can go ahead and continue speaking about this. At this point right now, um, there's no direction uh since I feel that we still need to speak on this matter. or president, just for clarity, uh just so that I'm understanding correctly, um does that mean there's no direction for the $2.5 million, but there is direction that we continue with the project be authorized and that we continue with the 2526 deferred maintenance plan knowing that there is sufficient funds there right now without having to transfer any monies.
It it creates a pretty good picture on the variance between the schools, the grades, and you know, so right now the way that the report is now happening, if we let's say it says weapon brought to school, we have no idea what school, what grade, was it elementary school, was it in high school, we lose visibility into all that information. And so we lose our ability to have oversight, which is part of our job. So we can't just say, "Oh, you know, this could be a potential FURPA violation." When there's no identifiable data, and if they're thinking that somebody might request the information, then okay, fine. Redact. If if you think that somebody who does a public records request could potentially be able to tell who it was at that school on that day that was suspended, then you can redact it for a public records request, but it shouldn't be redacted from board members when it's our job to do the oversight.