2025-09-24 Worcester County, MA YouTube / BBRSD Live transcript source: youtube School Committee 9-23-2025 · passage 131
Does anybody have any questions about it? >> No, she's just saying if possible, give preference to Berlin for the question non-eing staff. >> Right. >> I'm just trying to clarify it. >> So, she's saying if possible, give preference to the non for the non to Berlin for the non- teaching or the second student. Okay. Yeah, I'm fine with that. >> All right. All those in favor? I I >> Anyone against it? All right, that motion passes. We're now on to the original motion as amended.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 131
So, that's for that initial lottery. Um, we know that after we do that initial lottery, because we have so many applications, we will end up with a waiting list that we won't get through, but we apparently have to continue to accept applications. um even after we close it for our initial lottery um we just wouldn't take any action on those applications unless we exhausted our initial weight list which is very unlikely. So I don't love that it seems a little bit misleading to let somebody submit an application knowing that you're probably never going to get to it but that's what DESI is recommending. So again I linked in some resources here at the end of the slide. So, the first one is the regulations um that were put out in August that were um emailed to everyone. Uh it's the model policy template that we'll be um working on to update our own policy.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 132
And Tom, I would say your team might be able to provide feedback on maybe this one's lowhanging fruit, this one's going to be more challenging or it's going to need more engagement from our partners like the BEA to get where they stand on it. And then we move forward like that. I think in terms of the cell phone stuff, I I feel like there's almost no obstacle and no cost um to tightening up cell phone regulations or policies. Um I feel like that could be something easier. I I don't know about like public buy in on it. I I just know from personal experience just not talking as a board member but just parentto parents are frustrated by the amount of time their kids spend on devices at home. Um and I think I don't know I think the six or so hours of school a day is a good opportunity to easily get them off of that and say we're not going to do that in this environment.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Worcester County, MA YouTube / BBRSD Live transcript source: youtube School Committee 9-23-2025 · passage 132
Any questions on that? All right, all those in favor of that. >> I >> Anyone against it? All right, that motion passes as well. Tracy, I think you have our uh instructions. >> I do. I do have one additional question because you chose to put school members on the script search committee. Do you wish to appoint a chair of the search committee or do you want them to elect their own chair? >> Uh, let them elect their own. >> Great. >> Do we need to vote on that? >> No, that's fine. I if you were going to appoint a chair, I would ask you to and because sometimes when there are school committee members on, they have they elect they the school committee says, "Hey, this is your chair." If you want them to elect their own chair, you're taking no action means that they won't.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 132
Uh a link to to DESI's website, the Office of College, Career, and Technical Education. So, if you want to go there, look at other information. Um there's a lot of um a lot of information on their website. um the CTE regulations, that's more like the overall chapter 74 regulations for Massachusetts. That gets a lot more um I guess technical, if you will. And then the last link is our enrollment data. Brenda, did we send this slide to them? >> No, I can email it to them. >> Yeah. Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 133
Um, but maybe it's more complicated than that. I don't know. >> I think um the thing is is it's the teacher discretion. So if I teach art and I like to always have Rob teaches math, right? Because he is engineer, >> super smart math. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> So he might have a lesson might that hey, you know what? get out your phones and you're gonna go to this website and do this. Well, like so my kid goes to his class, hey, we got to use our cell phones because this come to my class. I'm like, hey, cell phones away. >> You know, isn't that's the thing? It's like t, you know, so the kids coming home and you know, maybe Aeron's kid is saying like, well, why did you get to use your cell phone and I didn't? You know, like I'm in math and I didn't get to use it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Worcester County, MA YouTube / BBRSD Live transcript source: youtube School Committee 9-23-2025 · passage 133
>> Yeah. >> And just for one point, I'm glad Matthew died. He's a school choice. Oh, all over the >> place. [Music] Great. >> Uh, Tracy, anything else you need? >> No, that's everything. Um, I will work with the administration to make sure that those who do self- selection are doing self- selection and um, work over the next couple of days to get an application up and as soon as your uh, invitation to apply with the application for the superintendency goes up. >> All right, thank you. Motion to return, please. >> So move second. >> All right, Megan and Lori, all those in favor. >> Anyone against it? >> Okay, return. Thank you. Thanks for >> Thank you. >> Whoever gave me the contract. Thank you. Look where they came from. It was magic.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 133
>> So, happy to take any questions. So basically what we're looking at, you know, we're not ready to present a policy and ask for a vote tonight. Um potentially would like to um have something together and and vote on it in October if possible. But I think it's um it's going to be really helpful for the committee to kind of know where this committee stands on that because you can't really complete the whole admissions policy unless you know which way you're going because a lot of those logistical pieces about the application process and all of those things. They're really contingent upon whether or not you're doing the the weighted lottery or the unweed lottery. Um so we're looking for kind of feedback on on where the committee stands right now. Um well, first you know how I feel about this. Um and I think my first question is is before this policy was changed, did the Department of Education or anybody from the state gather information from the districts or ask for input before making this change?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 134
Why do you get to use it? And that's the thing. >> That's different examples because it's a different class. >> And that's the thing. So, I'm not saying like I don't think we should I you know I think Tom needs to actually go to the committees and go to like the polls and say hey teachers okay elementary teachers what are you doing off all of them say nope okay middle school teachers do you use them that's what it is it's the teacher discretion so and the thing is is the teacher says no that teacher just has to be supported in that decision >> and you know whether this is well the community is coming to me. It's like okay, you know what? Did you address this with the teacher? Did you address this at the school level? Like I I'm not going to know what's going on like you said in like the high school freshman.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 134
Yeah, I mean I think this conversation has been going on for several years. Um especially I would say probably um the fall of last year and in the spring. They were sending out a lot of information. They put out their initial um guidance. They they opened it up for public comment and feedback. There were a lot of uh work was done on, you know, the legislative level. So yeah, I think um you know went to the the board of education multiple times. There were a lot of changes. So, >> and engaging ev everything that folks were saying at the public comment sessions and how vocational administrators and vocational schools stand on it. Do you think they would have been in favor of a lottery admission system? Well, the uh NAVA, the Massificational Association of Administrators has been working on this for years and then this last year has been a much more heated conversation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 135
I don't know what's going on with that. Like we shouldn't know what's going on with that. So I think that's the big thing is I think Tom needs to just poll for this issue and say what's the percentage of people using cell phones as hard as lessons or whatever and what's the percentage not? And that way we can say, hey, it's the teachers discretion. We support the teachers in their decisions if they're using it as part of a lesson. And if they say, nope, that's I think that's just what we really need just to capture that data. And then I think we can decide, do we want to be restrictive because if teachers are actually going to use this as a lesson, it's kind of like AI, right? We refer like, hey, AI, but now we have a policy about AIDS. you know, where it's under the discretion of teachers and so forth.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 135
Done a lot of u work with all our legislators, board of education, we've been to every meeting for the last two years fighting this. Um some of our the House uh added a bill to the uh the budget this year that passed to eliminate the lottery, but the Senate it didn't pass. The Senate didn't pass it. So then consequently it's now it's gone through, but uh uh Representative Moran has put a bill in they're working on now to try to uh stop the lottery. Um when I talked to him last week, he estimates a two at least a two-month uh battle in order to try to get this through. He feels like he's got the votes in the House. Not sure if he's got the votes in the Senate yet. Uh but they're still working on it. They're hoping that uh so um I mean we've sent several letters.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 136
So, if it's a tool that the teachers can use, I'm for it. But this tool where the teacher says, I don't want this in my class, then we need to support that teacher. >> And I'm also curious about how the teachers may feel if it is something they are not able to manage in their classroom for some reason and what tools they may recommend that firming up the language or whatever may help, right? like if there's a like teachers will know firsthand whether they're actually having an educational impact in their classroom, you know, and what would they be able to do or not do, you know, I my kids came through school primarily at a time when this was a beginning to be a problem, let's say, you know, and one of my kids actually had a education like a 504 that was supposed to allow them to use their phone because it was the only way >> they could keep track of their schedule and their homework and everything else because they didn't have a laptop at the time, you know.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 136
we've sent um to uh both the department of education to the board of education to all our sen uh representatives and senators and I've spoken before them at our last uh meeting we had with them last spring uh so it's been a but there's so much push to pass it the governor has been the one that really has helped to push it through cuz she's in favor of it and governor Baker was not and since this governor has got in place, she's been able to, you know, work with people to get it through. >> So essentially, you're answering my question is vocational schools are not in favor of lottery admissions. >> No, none of the vocational schools. >> This was a two-body decision. This was the board of education and the governor, >> right? This was not a decision that was made with vocational schools, with vocational teachers, with families.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 137
So there are reasons to do things sometimes and I and then in even that case we talked to the teacher when the teacher said he couldn't bring his phone out or whatever else we went and talked to the teacher understand why you know and then sometimes we agreed sometimes we didn't but most of the time we did so I guess my point is like I'd like to hear a bit as a part of that polling if it's what everybody thinks is you know is there an adverse educational impact in their classroom that this language could assist on So that sounds a lot like dig a little deeper, find some information, bring it back to us to see what the extent of the current challenges are around this because our policy effectively says no phones except for teacher discretion. >> I just want to go back to what Tom was talking to though.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 137
And now we're just using students as numbers in a lottery like we're a charter school and throwing them into a bowl and pick up a number and if you win, you win. You don't win, you don't, >> right? >> Um, which to me is a racist practice and is is it it does not help. I mean, it doesn't help districts like us because we already have a majority of students from communities like Lawrence and Mthuan. >> Um, this would apply in a district where they need a lot more of that diversity. Uh, versus a school like us where we already have a good system in place. It has worked. Um and and the issue at stake is creating more seats for students and bringing down that damn weight list that we have that's way too long. So I'm just going to put it out there that this system that was put in place by the state is is a total shame to and a smack in the face to all of the vocational schools that now have to shift to this policy and go back to the families and explain to them how this new process is going to work.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 138
So I don't think you guys that we found a solution because I we're asking him to look and get back to us on a lot of things and timewise are we asking him to pri ask are we trying to prioritize which things he's coming back to us with or >> well if we can do that now yes otherwise I think part of me would say ask Tom to say okay of the things I heard these are the things I think I can tackle in what order I think I can tackle them in >> and or as he asked us to do can you establish a priority of what's most important. >> Can can we just do a separate email and tell say hey here's your three you tell me what's one two and three and then if the majority wins. So if people think that cell phone should be number one that wins.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 138
Um, so I'm I'm curious to hear at the next meeting what the admissions committee stands on. >> Um, and and whatever happens in the legislature. >> Um, >> cuz I want to make sure that, you know, we're putting the best interest of the kids first. >> Um, and also strengthening the system that has been broken instead of creating new ones that make absolutely no sense and have not been proven to work. >> Yeah. >> So, >> yeah. Yeah. absolutely right on every count. So, the uh we'll bring it we'll have to uh bring it to you for a vote at the next meeting. We're going to move the meeting. We're going to have you vote on moving the meeting up so that we can get this completed and get it to Department of Ed time for November 1st. So, I think we have it on the agenda to move the meeting up.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 139
If we think that the gun um curriculum safety is number one that one wins. That's what I think that would just be the send us an email with the three. We send them back how we feel is one, two, and three. Majority wins. >> Does that work? And then you have an idea. >> Is everyone okay with that? >> Yeah, that's fine. >> Are you okay with that? Can I just say that with the cell phone policy, we do have a policy and I think in the very least we could try to make efforts to make sure that students and parents understand what the policy is because it seems like some people maybe don't understand that there is a policy. >> Yeah. >> Okay. It's a fair point. All right. So, I'll send an email out. Katie will help you make sure that I do that says these are the three and then you guys respond back to me because there's I'm the only person that can effectively do that with your prioritization.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-09-24 Essex County, MA YouTube / Greater Lawrence Technical School transcript source: youtube District Committee Meeting (09/23/2025) · passage 139
>> Yeah, change the date. There's a date on there >> to the second to the uh I think it's the 16th. >> And what does it mean over here about the selection? Something about >> we have so many students. Next Tuesday, >> chair, >> it'll be October 14th. >> October 14th. >> That's the next Tuesday. >> It's two weeks from today. >> Sorry. Yeah, that's the model template. And sorry, what was what was the question? Three weeks. Three weeks from today. Yeah. >> 14th of October. >> She can come to the meeting. aviation. >> Sorry, Miss Ferris had a question about the template. >> All right. Again, not a biggie here. I just want to reference when it says when and the students interested in applying whatever and you have too many applicants, you have to take in district before out of district. Does that make sense to you?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above