The record shows that she has not only met students needs, but exceeded them. Building systems and supports that did not exist before she arrived back at Granite Hills. Only this time, not just as a staff member, but as a Granite Hills alumni who truly embodies our motto, Maroon and Gray, lead the way. At the heart of all of this, Angela has sat one-on-one with students in therapy, check-ins, classroom presentations, and crisis assessments, always with an open door policy for students and staff alike. On behalf of Granite Hills community, I urge you to recognize the tremendous value that Angela brings to our school. Keeping her at Granite Hills is not only the best choice, but the ethical one. To remove her now would dismantle the vital programs she has built and take away the stability, care, and advocacy our students and staff both need and deserve.
Any discussion? All those in favor? Seven. The resolution. >> Yes. This is a standard resolution when there's more than two weeks between meetings. This is authorizing resolution authorizing the treasur deputy treasur of James County Schools to make payments of claims without board prior approval to October 23rd and allow the treasure deputy treasur to make transfers of appropriation within education debt service operation funds in order to balance major account classifications. >> Entertain a motion to approve motion by Pat. Do I have a second? Second by Cheryl.
Thank you. [Applause] Okay, is Karen Post and then after Karen Post will be Karen Sabers. [Applause] Good evening, Superintendent Nelson, board members, fellow colleagues, [Applause] parents, and students. My name is Karen Post. I am a teacher at Sandia Academy. I have worked there for the past 21 years. I currently teach TK. I'm not sure why. Um, 20 of my years have been in kindergarten. I went to seventh and eighth grade right here when it was Apple Middle. I had my first kiss at a seventh grade dance right here. That boy did not call me for 20 years. Whatever. I'm over it. I went I went to Apple Valley High School and was proud to be a Sunundevil. I was on the girls basketball and softball teams. Three out of five of my children graduated from Apple Valley High School. So needless to say, ABUSD has been a consistent part of my life.
Any discussion? No, I'm just making sure. You good? Okay. All those in favor? Seven. Next, we go down to property. We have another resolution. >> Yes. This is a standard resolution on surplus items that I'd like the board to approve. >> So again, this is to dispose of >> dispose of surplus. >> That's good. No, that's all right. Entertain a motion to approve. I have a motion by Chelsea, second by Travis.
I'd like to express my thoughts to you the only way I know how, which is through a poem because I like to rhyme. Must be all those years in kindergarten. My poem is through the eyes of a teacher written by me. I've been here at AVUSD for so so long. Maybe I'm doing something right or something totally wrong. Whatever the case, this is my home. I've never had an inkling to leave or to Rome. So many friends I've made along the way. Some have moved on while others like me stayed. Some we have lost. They'll remain in our hearts. We'll never forget them. In our lives they played a part. It's been 21 years since I stepped on ABUSD ground. A lost and broken soul who needed to be found. As the years went by, a tight it was formed. I grew and developed. A teacher was born.
Any discussion? >> All those in favor? 70. >> And then permission to advertise. >> In conjunction to that, I'm asking the board permission to advertise the sale of surplus items. >> A motion to approve. Motion by Pat. Do I have a second? >> Second by Kurt.
It hasn't been easy. There's been tears that I've cried. It seemed an uphill battle, but ABUSD was by my side. Going home exhausted, covered in paint and snot. It's true. Is this my chosen profession? I'll just give it all I got. Now here I am, and I'm so proud to say if I had to do it all over, I'd do it all the same way. This isn't a job or work or a chore. It's a place I feel proud to walk through the door. So when you walk in, no need to have game. It's a place you can go where everyone knows your name. But it's not about the money. Or maybe it should be. We are the ones who make the difference in the children that you see. It's getting harder to make ends meet. It's getting harder to get a good night's sleep.
Any discussion? All those in favor? Seven. Sure you come and buy all of the surplus items. Next we're down to relations. We have anou. Yes. Asking for approval for anou with true trust outside therapy with Jennings County School Corporation for parentally placed therapy in the school. Okay. I'll entertain a motion to approve that. I have a motion by Marilyn. Do I have a second? >> Second by Pat.
We all work so hard. We all care so much. But that won't even pay our bills or barely cover lunch. This is your chance to make our world right. Put the shine back in our eyes and do what you know is right. Thank you. Okay. Karen Sabers is up and then after Sabers is Steve Cops. Um, >> go ahead, Karen. We'll call the next one. Okay. >> All right. >> I'm sorry. You're right. >> Okay. >> Good evening, Superintendent Nelson, board members, cabinet, President Scott, Avuda members, CSCA members, and audience. My name is Karen Sabers and I stand before you as the proud president of Apple Valley Unified Teachers Association. First, I want to be clear this is not about coming against CSEA. We are we fully support our classified colleagues and sincerely congratulate them on their settlement. Our fight tonight is not with them.
Any discussion? All those in favor? 7. I believe for a couple of people here specifically about thatou. I just want to thank you all for coming. I know this is going to be a short meeting and um so we appreciate the support that you're showing um and if there's anything that we can do for you all just let us know. >> Absolutely. Um so now we're down to other Nikki just want to thank our parents. The elementary conferences are finishing up tonight. We've had a great turnout across the corporation. So we appreciate that partnership. Hearing nothing else to come before the board, we'll entertain a motion to adjurnn. Have a motion by Chelsea. Do I have a second? >> Second by Pat. All those in favor? Seven. Meeting journ.
It is about advocating for our certificated staff. We appreciate CSEA's support and remain united. We are extremely disappointed that the district and the board has chosen to offer CSEA more than what they offered the certificated staff and likely less than what management will be offered if they receive the same as settlement as CSEA. In Superintendent Nelson's recent email, it was stated that CSEA's offer was made equitable to Ava's 2425 settlement. But this is not equality. Let's be clear about the facts. Last year, Avuda settled for $2,750 per cell increase on the salary schedule only because the district refused to provide the 3% ongoing raise we requested. We were told that the district needed help with recruitment. In good faith, we agreed to that and also agreed to support a $5,000 sign on bonus for new hires over a three-year period. But the 2750 per cell increase does not equate to 3% across the board.
Once a teacher reaches year 9, that raise dropped below 3%. Falling into the 2% range. It begins at 2.99% and falls to just 2.06%. Meanwhile, CSEA was given a 3% off schedule payment for last year. certificated staff was not offered that. This year we were both offered 3%. We declined and filed for impass because that would not even take us close to Hisperia and other surrounding districts salaries. When it comes to health and welfare benefits, the inequality is even clearer. CSEA and probably management were offered the same insurance caps as AVDA which were originally based on AVDA's $20,000 cap. CSA CSEA's previous cap was $16,375. So this settlement would provide them with an additional $3600 per person. Management's previous cap was 15,000 giving them 5,000 more per person. certificated staff received nothing additional. We have always placed some of our increases on the salary schedule and some on the insurance cap.
The other units have chosen more often than not to just place increases on their salary schedule. Where's the equity in that? When we are going when are we going to break this pattern that has gone on for years where every time we come to the table to negotiate compensation suddenly there is no money. Yet the board continues to approve budgets that reflect different priorities. We've been told directly in negotiations that the budget is the board's responsibility that you are presented with the numbers and you vote to accept them. This means you carry the fidiciary responsibility not just to AVUSD staff but also to the community that elected you. So I ask, when are you going to start taking that responsibility seriously? When will you begin asking the hard questions? When are you going to begin listening to those who do provide information to help you become more knowledgeable?
And when are you going to start working together to make this district become more transparent and bring morale back? At the last board meeting, we raised serious concern. We asked why certificated salaries were reported as decreasing by 9.9 million while management salaries were reported as increasing by 2.4. 4 million. The answers we were given during negotiations is that the BCBAS and nurses were being moved out of certificated pupil services and into certificated supervisors and administration administrators to create more transparency. But after researching and contacting other districts, we've learned that since these positions are not are on the management schedule, not on certificated salary, they should never have been included under the certificate of pupil category to begin with. If they were hidden under pupil services in the past, perhaps to make certificated salary percentages look higher and managements look lower, then we must ask what else is being hidden and where.
This is your responsibility as a board. It is your duty to ask these questions and hold the district accountable. Our staff and our community deserve transparency and they deserve leadership that will step up and ensure fairness, not just excuses. Our students all also deserve better. They deserve quality teachers, counselors, and SLPs. The only way to ensure this is to provide certificated staff with comparable salaries to those of the surrounding districts. Thank you. In solidarity, Karen. [Applause] Adrien Forbes and then and she's not here. >> Oh, okay. Now, Mr. Cop. [Applause] Well, good evening uh board members uh cabinet and uh fellow Avuda CSEA. Uh thanks for coming out tonight. Uh I started a couple years ago with negotiations and one of my first things I said when I went in the room is just uh we want to do the right thing and I continue with that.
I'll end with that tonight. But book ends of that in between um we look at these things of where we're at. I was told to uh find money to look for some things. Uh I did that. We were looking at books and supplies. books and supplies. Uh the last year was uh started out at $27 million. It ended up the year uh on the actuals last time was $12 million and change difference of about $25 million. Um as we looked at that, we were trying to find where some money was. Um by the time it was done, all that money was gone somewhere else and we not quite sure where it's at. It was now budgeted this year. Instead of it being kind of where we ended last year, it went up to 18 million again. And so I'm wondering why that number jumped up again that much.
So as we're trying to find money, uh that's just kind of where I'm at in looking at it. And I want to continue to say do the right thing. We had a meeting the other night and uh I was kind of worried that I might be getting out ahead of some things as I'm trying to lead negotiations. And so I wanted to report back to you tonight when we uh pulled our group. 96.7% of our group that responded said 3% was not acceptable. We want to congratulate CSEA on their well-deserved raise and uh I stood and talked about significance versus symbolic um last time and I felt like that was significant. Ours I think was symbolic when we walked into the room and I got that. So the second poll question was would you like to continue to fight for more and that was even more.
Uh 98.3% of you said uh yeah let's keep fighting for more and uh [Applause] So, as we go forward and we I'll keep looking and uh I'll keep digging through these things. I noticed uh that CSEA's uh raise was reported in the budget uh or not in the budget but in the the minutes of tonight the board docs and so I found that down in item number four and I saw it was about 9 something% out of this year's budget that's going to them. I could not find anything for management. ours is not in there because we didn't settle. Um I can only assume I don't know where management goes, but when we're told we have no money. Um that kind of makes me nervous about where things might be. So um again, I just want to end up with just saying we want you to do the right thing.
We have teachers that are uh needy and wanting and not to be the top, but to be fair, respected, and kind of put in the place where we were years ago. So thank you for your time. [Applause] Sandra Waller. Sandra and then after Sandra will be Ann Gordon. I believe it's Yeah. Gordon. >> Okay. [Applause] Hello, my name is Sandra Waller. I currently teach TK at Sandia Academy. I'm speaking today concerned to the certificated salary pay scale. This is my 20th year with Apple Valley Unified. And again, I must say when I chose AVUSD, the district was viewed upon as the best, most prestigious education as well as salary benefits in the high desert. First, I'd like to say thank you for the offer of increased health and welfare benefits. However, I'm quite disappointed in the salary increase of 3% that has been offered to us.
As a 20-year teacher approaching retirement, I find myself very unsettling. I find it very unsettling this 3%. I will admit I am living comfortably as of now on my salary. However, I am a twoinome household. I know my fellow colleagues are not all in the same position as myself. It is my hope to retire in the next few years and my retirement pension will be based on the last three years of my service. I have worked hard my whole year my whole 20 years to move across the pay scale so I would be in the right place to position myself for a comfortable retirement and I was pretty happy with that until I realized that the other districts in the high desert are paying their teachers a considerable amount more than myself. And what is concerning to me with the subpar offer of 3% my retirement will be considerably less than teachers in those said districts.