And so this ends up happening closer to the um really close to the end of summer. If there is space in all those classes, then student transfer is granted and then a domino effect happens because now a student is vacating six classrooms and so we might have a student who wants to go the other direction and take that set of seats. This year it was 10 students from Appallet High School that were granted a transfer and nine from Granite Hills. And that's almost that part's usually even because at least when we're this full that makes sense. And so after that, the remaining requests are sent a denial letter. And we typically do not continue this process because we do not like having students change school in the middle of the school year um unless there's an unexpected enrollment gap. There have been years when um student enrollment did not materialize after the first week and a half of school and then we were able to go back into the list and continue down by order of submission.
That has not happened in many years. And so that's just a quick overview of the high school transfer process. >> Okay. Is there any any um anything further Pat? No. >> You got questions? everybody. >> Um I do have questions. Thank you for your presentation, Pat. That was a lot of um interesting information. >> Can I interrupt you real quick? So you guys that are here for public comment, I'm going to move it forward because I see a lot of students here that want to speak. It's 9:30, so as soon as we're done with this topic, I'm going to be I'm going to call for the public comment. So just hang tight. Okay. Thank you. Go ahead. I'm sorry. >> No worries. Um so I'm the one that brought this up for discussion. Um it is something that I think um you did a good job um explaining um as far as our practice so far um in the district.
My concern with bringing this forward is our board bylaw um or our board policy 5116.1 which is our intrad district open enrollment um policy and um specifically looking at how students are coming into our schools that as you've noticed uh and noted are um at capacity and limited spaces. Um, I want to make sure that we're taking steps to prioritize the students of our district. Um, and I'm sure as the board considers um the data um and the idea that the money we receive from the uh federal government, from the local government um from the state um is intended to service the students in Apple Valley first um and prioritize them specifically. So when we look at board policies and the admittance of students even in the idea of um our unbiased and random uh process of selection, I I just would like to um ask the board to consider whether the current way is functioning um if we're truly prioritizing the students of Apple Valley.
Um, I was able to kind of look at the numbers a bit and um, and you know, as we like talk about this, it's important to consider there were 241 students denied transfer into Apple Valley High School. These are students within our district being denied transfer to Apple Valley High School. and then 41 students um wanting to access our wonderful art and theater and music programs at Granite Hills High School. Um somehow were not allowing the transition of students from one campus to the next which would then have allowed the uh transition of students from the other campus and back again. So, um, that definitely is not being taken into consideration. Um, and I think it's important we we do consider that because we do have different programs at each of our high schools, different uh skill sets, different talents for our students, and they should have every opportunity to be able to access access those programs first.
Um, and that's even before we consider interd district. And specifically when we talk about um the idea of staff um uh in our schools and they want um their children at the schools, I totally understand as a teacher. I had my kids in my class, you know, at my school. Um I have I definitely think that needs to be prioritized um for our staff. Um, but as far as a sibling of a student outside of our district, well, now they're in our district, so now we're going to let their siblings come. I'm just not sure that should be prioritized like maybe a sibling in our district and they're at this school and so then their sibling can come to the school in the district, right? So, I think we need to think about this in terms of looking at the students of Apple Valley, servicing the students of Apple Valley, and prioritizing them.
Um, and from where it stands right now, I just I'm not sure that's being done. >> Okay. Anybody else have any questions? Thank you, Pat. Okay. Okay. I'm going to move on to public comments here. Um and then we have a couple other items but um Javier Aleandra Roas Javier is still here. >> Okay. Can bl is it can is it >> I got it. >> Yeah. He's here to talk about start times. Yeah. >> Uh before I start, I'd like to say uh thank you to Mrs. Longshore for suggesting public comments being earlier. I 100% uh support that. I feel it's kind of unfair that not only those with us, those of us with comments have to wait so long to speak. But no offense to any of you guys. I'm grateful for you guys being here, but we don't really got much of an audience.
So I'd like to speak to a lot more people. Well, you are online, too. It does get recorded, but >> we have a lot of viewers that watch it online. >> Yeah. >> Anyway, go ahead. I'm sorry. >> Uh, anyways, hi. Hello again. I said I'd keep coming back until changes have been made, and I still have first period in at 7 a.m. Uh, if anything, at least I'm consistent. I want you to imagine something. A student walks into class struggling to keep their eyes open. They aren't lazy. They didn't stay up all night playing video games. They're simply a teenager living with a schedule that works against their biology. First period is hard. Every high school uh first period that I've had reflects that. It does not reflect who I am as a person, though. Research so shows that later high school start time is better for teenage mental health, physical health, emotional health, performance, and safety.
My own research is proving that a majority of students, adults, and educators pled a later start time. The reasons given all state better health and clarity. I can submit these results to you guys if you'd like. Uh yet here we are in Apple Valley Unified School District, a group of students now growing in uh strength and number and support pleading for you to listen. Past personal experiences make me think that if I were asking for a large sum of money for a field trip, perhaps you would be more attentive. But the more I come here, the more it seems you simply just don't care for us students. I know change is hard to make. I know this isn't something that can just happen overnight, you know, but this was a law passed six years ago. You even had an entire COVID shutdown to, you know, figure something out about this.
And I know there was a lot of stuff going on and there was a lot of stuff to deal with. A lot. I mean, it was a miserable time to be a student. But here I am asking you tonight, are you listening? Are you making plans to make changes? When should high school students expect to feel relieved? Thank you. [Applause] Um, I'm going to give you, if you can come up here real quick, I'm going to give you my cell number and I want you to call me when you get a chance when you get out of school tomorrow. I want to talk to you about this. Just me and you. Okay, hang on. It's late. So, uh, but I will I will I know you got to get up. So, call me tomorrow. All right. >> Thank you so much. >> Okay. Thanks. >> All right.
We have another one. Is it Silus? Felus. Did I say it right? >> Okay. Silus. >> Uh, hello. My name is Silus. I'm here to speak on the same issues as my friend Kian. Um we're both Granite Hills High School students and uh we recently been promoting a campaign to convince you guys to change our school start times and part of that camp a major part of that campaign has been running a poll just to get the general public opinion about it. Um we had a rate of about 80% yeses and 80 and 20% nos. every single yes or um every single parent that responded to ours responded with a yes and about 810en of every single uh faculty member responded with uh in support of our cause. Um and almost all of these answers in support of our cause have long well-ritten paragraph long arguments supporting us.
And on the other side of that, those against our cause submitted like one sentence saying, "Oh, I don't want to get out later." We There are mountains of data and evidence backing us up. And the only excuse for the other side of this argument is just convenience. There is no there's no uh sorry, there's no uh there's no positive outcome that comes from keeping our school start times that early in the morning. We acknowledge that this is not an easy change for you guys for you guys to make, but we beckon you to realize that it is a necessary one. If you deem the health of thousands of students important, this is a necessary change. If you if you think that facts and data are more compelling than just simple convenience, this will be necessary. If you truly and wholeheartedly care for these students of this school district, this is necessary.
The final question I have to share with you guys, are you just hearing us or are you listening? Thank you for your time. [Applause] >> Terry, you're Terry. It's Terry Peak and after Terry will be Steven Cobbs and then Santiago Padilla. First, I'd like to say thank you for getting my name correct. Sorry, I gave my kids different names. >> They got some tough ones. >> We're Celtic, so my kids reflect that. And I also want to say thank you for moving the public comment section up. I seem to remember eons ago that public comment section was earlier in the agenda. Um, >> but thank you for getting it going. >> Good evening. Hello again. Isn't it amazing seeing students actively engaging, doing research, and advocating for themselves and for what's right? I am beyond impressed with not just my son, but the rally he's gathering.
And it is larger than just the two. They have quite a few at at Granite. Research from the American Academy of Pediatrics shows that teenagers natural sleep cycles during shift during adolescence. Their brains don't release melatonin, the sleep hormone, until later at night. That means even if they try, most teens can't fall asleep early. When school starts at 7:00 a.m., you're asking them to function on six or fewer hours of rest when they actually need 8 to 10 or more, depending on the kid. The consequences are serious. These stats are on repeat here. Studies reveal that students who start school later experience better grades, higher test scores, and sharper focus in class. Even more importantly, well-rested teens have lower rates of depression and anxiety. The CDC has also linked later start times to safer driving, reducing car accidents among young drivers. And believe me, this is a concern as every morning when he leaves, I'm watching him on my app, making sure he gets there.
Okay. This isn't just about comfort. It's about health and learning. California already recognized this by passing a law requiring most high schools to start no earlier than 8:30. Other states are even beginning to follow. By aligning school schedules with how teenagers bodies and brains actually work, we give them the chance to succeed both academically and emotionally. And I know there's a lot going on with contract negotiations, union requests, and everything else that the board deals with on the daily. But if we want our students alert, motivated, and safe, the solution is simple. Let's follow the law and let them start school later. Giving teens the rest they need isn't a luxury. It's an investment in their future. Please help make the change. As I said last month, all of my boys are stellar people. They are, at least to me. My youngest is a game changer, a revolutionary.
Viva revolution. Thank you. Steve, welcome. I know this is my second time uh today speaking. I just want to remind you uh earlier uh we took a poll and the ones that were responding to the poll, 98% wanted us to keep going um to keep fighting. I'm passionate about that as a chief negotiator, lead negotiator on our side. Um, Tim, I apologize. No offense intended, but when the statement was made just a little bit ago, it sounded a little tonedeaf. When we asked teachers to wait, thinking maybe there might have been an announcement. It was kind of on the par when we were sitting in our negotiation last time and we waited 30 extra minutes to come back for nothing. And there was no extra. The reason I'm passionate about it, I got two things written to me today sent to me and it said, uh, ASV AVUSD community alert.
Our schools are sinking our property values. The crisis isn't just in the classroom. I'm not sure who wrote this. It's hitting your wallet. Low teacher pay in Apple Valley Unified School District is driving away talented educators leading to high turnover and ultimately hurting your students education, the value of your home. The facts are stark. impact on education. Competitive teacher salaries are directly linked to attracting and retaining highquality teachers which in turn is shown to improve student academic achievement and lower dropout rates. When ABUSD loses high uh you lose experienced teachers to higher paying districts, our students suffer. Said impact on property values. Quality schools are a cornerstone of property values. Home buyers consistently pay a premium to live in districts with strong strong reputations. When a school district struggles to retain experienced staff due to non-competitive pay, its reputation declines, acting as a drag on local real estate prices.
ABUSD teachers deserve a livable wage and our students deserve the best. It's time to demand better from our school board. What can you do? Share this post to raise awareness. contact the school board and demand competitive pay. Attend the next schoolboard meeting and make your voice heard. And that was one of the things that was said. The second thing was sent to me was another statement of please don't settle without accountability. And so our teachers are feeling this. We're there. We're asking you. I started the night saying please do the right thing. And I again end that tonight. Please do the right thing. We want to move forward. Thank you. Santiago, Padilla, Santiago, do you recognize me? >> I'm your neighbor. You You >> You take care of my house. >> Oh, >> you never see me in a suit and not a hat on.
Probably >> see you in a suit. You look good, man. >> I see you every day. >> Anyway, I'm here presenting an idea for a change on earbud law. I believe that as students, we deserve not so much of a right, but more of a voice on what laws are enforced against us. And I've interviewed many students across Apple Valley, the Apple Valley High School, and we've come to an understanding that if you have a B+ and 85% in the class, you're doing pretty good. Correct. You should be able to have one earbud in so long as you listen and complete your work, given that the music you're listening to is somewhat school appropriate. A failure to do so or lying about your grade percentage will result in one demerit and the week off, regardless of your grade percentage.
Any questions? No. >> All right. >> I'm gonna You got a couple minutes. I'm going to tell a story about this young man here. So, he lives across the street from me and one day I'm out getting my mail. It's kind of funny story actually. I'm going out and get my mail and he goes, "Hey, there's a crow in your yard with a broken wing. Can I go over there and get it?" I said, "Yeah, yeah, I'll help you round it up." Long story short, he doesn't find it. Next day, I see it again. I text him and he comes running out. He catches it and he's like, "I want to take care of it." And he's sending me pictures of this crow in his room, this big giant crow. And then finally I said, "Well, what happened?" He says, "Well, my grandma made me get rid of it because it was living on my ceiling fan in my bedroom." So, but this guy has such a heart to try to take care of the the this wounded crow and it's still running around the neighborhood now, but it's been what a couple of months now.
So, >> but anyway, I appreciate your comments and we'll talk later. >> Santiago, your principal is at the back. Make sure that um Mr. Goodro finds you and has a conversation with you. >> Okay. >> All right. Good job. Thank you. >> That's so that's all we have for public comments. So, uh, we're going to move on to other business here we have, but I appreciate all the comments. And, um, >> do we just want to confirm really fast for the record that there's no public comments at the teleconference location? >> Oh, I'm sorry. Anybody online there in your uh, in Austin, Texas that wants to speak? Uh, Maria, >> well, I have to say it's 11:41 p.m. now, and if anybody wants to speak, I haven't seen them. >> Okay. Okay, thanks. All right, >> we're at E1 Footsteps to Freedom 2026 tour dates and that will be Tren Nelson >> as I did last year in order to get direction from the board.