I think that's going to slow you down too much. I think that this is something we should >> de delegate to the chair of the steering committee to work with the administration to come to a proposal for the full committee just to expedite things. >> I I can do and for like next week, two weeks. >> Yeah, I would run probably next week. Yeah, I mean we need to post so so probably be late next week. >> Perfect. Okay, >> we can we can have something together very I imagine pretty swiftly about that. Thank you. >> Okay, great. Does that work, Judy? >> That will work for sure. >> Okay, great. Thank you. All righty. What's next? >> What is next? So, um advertisements. These are um sort of what's included already as well as optional. This is essentially the decision point of do we want additional advertising?
Any discussion? Secretary Den, will you call the vote? And >> Chair Johnson Assad, >> yes. >> Vice Chair Ston, >> yes. >> I'm a yes. Member Martini, >> yes. Member Child, >> yes. >> Member Goodwin, yes. Mayor, >> yes. >> Unanimous. >> Okay. What's next? >> Okay. So, this is where I might also um have Judy step in and share some of some of her prior experience with how this has gone down in other um other searches before. But in general, this uh is where we're going to talk about the different roles of the big school committee, us altogether, us seven. um the role of like what Judy is actually supporting and helping us do. Um and then we'll get into the screening committee and towards the end the decision point is actually thinking about the broad brushstrokes makeup of the screening committee. This is not specific people at this point but this is thinking about oh we might want two parents or do we want three parents or do we you know like and thinking about the types of people we want represented in the screening committee.
Um as described to me, not really, but we have to say so. >> What do you mean you have to say you have to give us the option as a school committee to decide? >> Exactly. >> Okay. >> Correct. >> But your recommendation can you say why? Why? I mean I have reason but tell me why you don't think >> because with the fee we're already paying we're getting everything that's underincluded which is most of the online sphere of different networks and platforms and outreach strategies. The only thing that we would get if we paid more is being in print versions of things which as described to me is just not where a lot of the candidates are learning about positions. And so it does not seem to me that that is worth the cost in the same way that a student focus group is worth the cost.
Um, any questions about that before we actually say the spiel? >> Any questions on that? Not seeing any. Go ahead. >> Perfect. >> Um, Judy, can I ask you this? >> Sure. um in your packet there's some um more detailed discussion of kind of the roles of um the consultant versus the screening committee versus the school committee but I'll try to make it brief. Ultimately it's the school committee that chooses the next superintendent. And so the school committee's role in this gets much more intense at the second interview stage. um and and that ultimately is your responsibility. It's one of the major responsibilities of a school committee. The screening committee um is the group that actually screens the applicant applications that come in, decides who should get a first interview, interviews uh that group and then decides who will they forward to the school committee as finalists for the second interview.
>> Okay. So you need a uh it sounds like it would be good for us to make a motion to approve the list of advertisements that is listed under included and that we are not selecting the optional at cost options. >> So moved. >> Second. >> All right. So, we have a motion for member child and a second for member Goodwin. Is that the motion that you needed from us? Vice Chair Son, >> I believe so. >> Okay, great.
The screening committee is made up of a wide range of people to get the input from different perspectives of the community. Um and and often we recommend there to be uh you know uh possibly nine uh to 11 or so folks on on the screening committee. uh it's sometimes hard to narrow it down to to that few. But on the other hand, if you have a wider group, each individual of the screening committee doesn't have as big of a voice. So, you want to kind of um kind of balance uh that idea that people who are putting in that much time to the interviews, you want them to have have a voice. And if they're just a a one member of 30 people, they have a much smaller voice than if they're one in nine people or 10 or 11 people. So the number is important, but it's also important to make sure that you have and every community is a little different, you have the right balance of people on that committee.
Any discussion? Secretary Den, will you call the vote? And >> Chair Johnson? >> Yes. >> Vice Chair Ston? >> Yes. >> I'm a yes. Member Martini, yes. Member Child, yes. Member Goodwin, yes. Mayor, >> yes. >> Unanimous. >> Okay. What's next? Okay. So, this is where I might also um have Judy step in and share some of some of her prior experience with how this has gone down in other um other searches before. But in general, this uh is where we're going to talk about the different roles of the big school committee, us altogether, us seven. um the role of like what Judy is actually supporting and helping us do. Um and then we'll get into the screening committee and towards the end the decision point is actually thinking about the broad brushstrokes makeup of the screening committee. This is not specific people at this point but this is thinking about oh we might want two parents or do we want three parents or do we you know like and thinking about the types of people we want represented in the screening committee.
And so that's why in your packet there's um some different uh ideas for uh who might be on the screening committee. And for tonight, we want to have you decide who are those roles. So you might say like two parents, one teacher, one, however you want to decide uh on the list, but not individual names. And so, um, then then we'll get to work on, um, getting the the the word out to people on this opportunity and making sure that people understand what the time commitment is and then eventually um, matching a name with each of those roles that will then come back to you for you to officially appoint those people to that group. So that's the uh screening committee's role. Um so my role is really to facilitate this whole process. Um and and you know because we've we've done this uh a good number of times.
Um, any questions about that before we actually say the spiel? >> Any questions on that? Not seeing any. Go ahead. >> Perfect. >> Um, Judy, can I ask you to >> Sure. um in your packet there's some um more detailed discussion of kind of the roles of um the consultant versus the screening committee versus the school committee, but I'll try to make it brief. Ultimately, it's the school committee that chooses the next superintendent. And so the school committee's role in this gets much more intense at the second interview stage. um and and that ultimately is your responsibility. It's one of the major responsibilities of a school committee. The screening committee um is the group that actually screens the applicant applications that come in, decides who should get a first interview, interviews uh that group and then decides who will they forward to the school committee as finalists for the second interview.
We have some good tools out there for soliciting people for these roles, for getting the news out um and for helping you through that that process. And then now that you have a steering committee, the steering committee really helps me to steer the process um and do the logistics um get the I don't have access for example to your um email system to get the news out to all parents and so on. So that screening committee helps to get those steps done in the process. That's the roles. What we're hoping tonight is to have you um decide on your screening committee um who what roles will be um on that on that committee? Who who do you want to see on that committee in terms of roles? Um so that we can then get to work to um solicit people for those uh for that job.
The screening committee is made up of a wide range of people to get the input from different perspectives of the community. Um and and often we recommend there to be uh you know uh possibly nine uh to 11 or so folks on on the screening committee. uh it's sometimes hard to narrow it down to to that few. But on the other hand, if you have a wider group, each individual of the screening committee doesn't have as big of a voice. So, you want to kind of um kind of balance uh that idea that people who are putting in that much time to the interviews, you want them to have have a voice. And if they're just a a one member of 30 people, they have a much smaller voice than if they're one in nine people or 10 or 11 people. So the number is important, but it's also important to make sure that you have and every community is a little different.
>> Okay. Um then I thought as a starting point oh were you going to say something vice chair? >> I well I was going to launch into my my spiel specifically about the screening committee but if you have a question or comment now I'd be happy to hear it. >> Nope. Go ahead. >> Great. And so, um, in thinking about the screening committee and its makeup, I do, pardon me, have a proposal, um, keeping in mind that we're looking for a group size of about 9 to 11 people and that three of those people will already be taken up by myself, member child's member disorder. And so that leaves us, you know, with >> six to six to eight additional people. And so my thoughts were having um three parents, one for every elementary, middle, and and high school. Um as well as three members of staff, someone to represent educators, uh represent administrators, and then also represent like support staff folks.
You have the right balance of people on that committee. And so that's why in your packet there's um some different uh ideas for uh who might be on the screening committee. And for tonight we want to have you decide who are those roles. So you might say like two parents, one teacher, one however you want to decide uh on the list but not individual names. And so, um, then then we'll get to work on, um, getting the the the word out to people on this opportunity and making sure that people understand what the time commitment is and then eventually um, matching a name with each of those roles that will then come back to you for you to officially appoint those people to that group. So that's the uh screening committee's role. Um so my role is really to facilitate this whole process. Um and and you know because we've we've done this uh a good number of times.
Um, and then here's where I would love some more support in thinking through is I would really love to have student representation here. And I know that that comes with a lot of difficulties and constraints of working around student schedules. Um, and asking them to sort of speak for their speak for their people in sort of ways. um and balancing wanting to have representation from the broader community as well that has a vested interest in education but finding it hard to think about having only one person in that role and how could they possibly represent the community, you know. Um, and so I know that I am advocating for having the three of us who are already on the steering committee plus three parents and three members of the Greenfield Public Schools staff um, as I described earlier. And then yes, would love would love your support in thinking through who these other couple of folks might be.
We have some good tools out there for soliciting people for these roles, for getting the news out um and for helping you through that that process. And then now that you have a steering committee, the steering committee really helps me to steer the process um and do the logistics um get the I don't have access for example to your um email system to get the news out to all parents and so on. So that screening committee helps to get those steps done in the process. That's the roles. What we're hoping tonight is to have you um decide on your screening committee um who what roles will be um on that on that committee? Who who do you want to see on that committee in terms of roles? Um so that we can then get to work to um solicit people for those uh for that job.
Um I I'd like to share um I really value students and and their participation and in involvement, but I do think to both because of logistical challenges like you're discussing, but the idea of having one student and then all of these adults and thinking that they're going to go into that environment and it's going to work very well for them. I just I just think it it isn't actually going to solicit the kind of feedback from students that we'd really want and that we have the um the focus group um we have our student council representatives so we could be seeking their input in in other ways but I would I would argue I guess against um having a student on the um on the committee not because I don't believe in engagement But because I think if you are going to engage, you need to do so in a in a way that's realistic in terms of allowing people to to fully engage.
>> Okay. Um then I as a starting point oh were you going to say something vice chair? >> I well I was going to launch into my my spiel specifically about the screening committee but if you have a question or comment now I'd have be happy to hear it. >> Nope. Go ahead. >> Great. And so, um, in thinking about the screening committee and its makeup, I do, pardon me, have a proposal, um, keeping in mind that we're looking for a group size of about 9 to 11 people and that three of those people will already be taken up by myself, member child's member disorder. And so that leaves us, you know, with >> six to six to eight additional people. And so my thoughts were having um three parents, one for every elementary, middle, and and high school. Um as well as three members of staff, someone to represent educators, uh represent administrators, and then also represent like support staff folks.
And I just think one student in a on a group with 11 adults is not realistic in terms of getting the best out of them and them having a good experience of it. Remember childs? >> I'll argue against that. I'll argue that we have some students at Greenfield High School who are already getting advocacy awards for their work. We have some very active, confident students and we also will have some high school seniors who have already turned 18 by the time these meetings are happening. So I would say that for the right student, the kind of student that we want Greenfield to produce, they would be able to be an effective member of this committee. more good one. >> I totally believe in student involvement. But one of the things about the candidates that you need to understand is at this level at the screening procedure, there may be people who want their information kept confidential.
Um, and then here's where I would love some more support in thinking through is I would really love to have student representation here. And I know that that comes with a lot of difficulties and constraints of working around student schedules. Um, and asking them to sort of speak for their speak for their people in sort of ways. um and balancing wanting to have representation from the broader community as well that has a vested interest in education but finding it hard to think about having only one person in that role and how could they possibly represent the community, you know. Um, and so I know that I am advocating for having the three of us who are already on the steering committee plus three parents and three members of the Greenfield Public Schools staff um, as I described earlier. And then yes, would love would love your support in thinking through who these other couple of folks might be.
They don't want people know they're looking for another job. At that level, it's really important. And I know some other districts that had some problems where information got out and it backfired on them. Um, so I would just say there's no reason why you couldn't look for somebody who is maybe a graduate of Greenfield High School, an alumni of Greenfield High School. That could also be a parent who's an alumni. Um, I'm just I think it's with teenagers right now in social media to protect your candidates is really important in this process. Um, and I've sat on a committee with 40 people. I've sat on committees with eight people and even when you talk to adults sometimes that gets violated. So I think it it's harder for younger people. Secretary Denive, >> I think based on the interactions I've had with the students at the Yellow conference, they are very civically minded at the high school and I think that they'd be a great addition.