2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 167
The only authority they have for compelling participation is uh subpoena power. Any other discussion? The only thing that would be good would be maybe we could amend the motion to include who we wanted to uh who we wanted to send. Um member childs, >> I think that sending Vice Chair Ston makes the most sense since Vice Chair Ston is the liaison who has been putting all of this together and therefore is the most knowledgeable. So I would amend it to replace the member with Vice Chair Ston. >> Would you accept that if if requested? Yes. Okay. And Martini, you seconded, so it's okay with you. Okay. All right. So we are voting on assigning uh Vice Chair Ston to present an update on the superintendent search process to the city council at their October meeting and to respond to any related questions on behalf of the committee.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 168
Is there a motion to that effect? >> So moved. >> Motion from Secretary Denive. >> Second from member Martini. Uh discussion. I saw member Goodwin and then Mayor Dorker. >> Um I would just say >> sorry I said I saw member Goodwin and then Mayor Dorger. Go ahead. Member Goodwin. >> Sorry. So inviting to I guess I'm sorry I didn't have it in front of me. So you're in in saying inviting not to the full school committee but just to the executive subcommittee. >> Yeah. So that would be me uh secretary Dene and vice chair >> why that and not the full committee. I think we thought that a smaller meeting would be more productive um in some ways. Uh having less um ju just having a smaller meeting where people could could have a more collaborative discussion and certainly anything that we did we would bring back to the full committee for a vote, but it would give us a chance to have a conversation and come forward to you with a proposal.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 168
Uh, Secretary, will you call the vote? >> Chair Johnson? >> Yes. >> Vice Chair Sexton? >> Yes. >> I'm a yes. Member Martini, >> yes. >> Member Childs, >> yes. >> Member Goodwin, >> yes. >> Mayor, >> unanimous. >> All right. Great. Thank you. Uh, next is looking at medium and long range goals. Um, so we would uh the executive committee would like to hear a motion that the full school committee invite the city council president along with any guests they wish to bring to attend an upcoming executive subcommittee meeting to discuss strengthening the relationship between the school committee and city council and to explore shared expectations for collaboration and communication at city council meetings. Is there a motion to that effect? >> So moved. >> Motion from Secretary Denive. >> Second from member Martini. Uh discussion. I saw member Goodwin and then Mayor Dorcer.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 169
Mayor, >> I think it's probably a very good idea, but I'm just reading that tonight on something that was you talked about today and I I think the the fairness of of anything, you know, I usually read all of my stuff. I actually asked Andy. He sent me something that I like I spend a lot of time reading my stuff and thinking about it a little ahead of time, probably like the rest of you. And so I'm looking at this and I'm I'm trying to read it and you you meet you do a good job. all of you on the executive committee meeting, but it's 10:00 at night and I'm looking at something and trying to figure out what you're talking about. So, I am not I'd move >> a motion for you, mayor, to postpone the motion to the um October meeting, >> please.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 169
>> Um I would just say >> sorry I said I saw member Goodwin and then Mayor Dorger. Go ahead. Member Goodwin. >> Sorry. So inviting to I guess I'm sorry I didn't have it in front of me. So you're in in saying inviting not to the full school committee but just to the executive subcommittee. >> Yep. So that would be me uh secretary and vice chair. >> Why that and not the full committee? I think we thought that a smaller meeting would be more productive um in some ways. Uh having less um ju just having a smaller meeting people could could have a more collaborative discussion and certainly anything that we did we would bring back to the full committee for a vote but it would give us a chance to have a conversation and come forward to you with a proposal. Mayor, >> I think it's probably a very good idea, but I'm just reading that tonight on something that was you talked about today and I I think the the fairness of of anything, you know, I usually read all of my stuff.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 170
>> I mean, no, we're in October now. November. >> Yes, I'm going to move to table that so I can just think about it. >> Is there a second on the motion to postpone? >> Second. >> Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 170
I actually asked Andy, he sent me something that I like I spend a lot of time reading my stuff and thinking about it a little ahead of time, probably like the rest of you. And so I'm looking at this and I'm I'm trying to read it. And you you meet you do a good job all of you on the executive committee meeting, but it's 10 o'clock at night and I'm looking at something and trying to figure out what you're talking about. So I am not I'd move >> a motion for you, mayor, to postpone the motion to the um October meeting, >> please. >> I mean, no, we're in October now. November. >> Yes. I'm going to move to table that so I can just think about it. >> There's a second on the motion to postpone. >> Second. Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 171
Any discussion? Secretary Den, will you call the vote? Do we have to have a friendly amendment because we didn't >> No, we the original one. >> No, we we're postponing the the motion to the November meeting so we don't have to vote on it. We can continue our discussion then. >> Thank you. Um who made this? Who is the second? >> I'm moving to table. >> Um Mayor D. It's to postpone technically. I've been reading up on my Robert's roles a little bit about Thank you. Thank you, chair. Uh, and so is a motion by Mayor and second by uh, Goodwin. >> Okay. Uh, Secretary Den, will you call the vote? >> Uhhuh. Chair, >> yes. >> Vice Chair, >> yes. >> I'm a yes. Member Martini, >> yes. >> Member Childs, >> yes. >> Member Goodwin, >> yes. >> Mayor, >> yes. >> Okay, unanimous to postpone to November.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 171
Any discussion? Secretary Den, will you call the vote? >> Do we have to have a friendly amendment because we didn't the original one? >> No, we we're postponing the the motion to the November meeting so we don't have to vote on it. We can continue our discussion then. >> Thank you. Um who made this? Who is the second? >> I'm moving to table. >> Um Mayor D. It's to postpone technically. I've been reading up on my Robert's roles a little bit. Thank you. Thank you, chair. >> Uh and so is a motion by mayor and second by uh Goodwin. >> Okay. Uh Secretary Den, will you call the vote? >> Uhu. Chair. >> Yes. >> Vice Chair. >> Yes. >> I'm a yes. Member Martini. >> Yes. >> Member Childs. >> Yes. >> Member Goodwin? >> Yes. >> Mayor? >> Yes. >> Unanimous to postpone to November.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 172
>> Excellent. Great. Okay, we're moving up to item 9B, review and analysis of the current regular and special education transportation operations and discussion of consultant work. Uh, is that you, Superintendent or Andy? >> Uh, yeah. >> I would just like to clarify that it's not regular red. It's just special education transportation. >> Okay. >> Do we have a typo in there, Andy? >> It says regular and special ed. It's just special ed. >> Okay. Thank you. Um, yes. So then I'll jump in and I know that we we talked about this last month. So you had the packet last month and you still have the packet here and that was we had heard in the past about you know I think this happened years ago obviously before some of our time here where the city took over special education transportation in terms of vans which we call 7D drivers and then some small buses small and medium range mediumsiz buses that require CDL for that um and there's question on did it fulfill its duty as is Is it profitable?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 172
>> Excellent. Great. Okay, we're moving up to item 9B, review and analysis of the current regular and special education transportation operations in discussion of consultant work. Uh, is that you, Superintendent or Andy? >> Uh, yeah. >> I would just like to clarify that it's not regular red. It's just special education transportation. >> Okay. >> Do we have a typo in there, Andy? >> It says regular and special ed. It's just special ed. >> Okay. Thank you. Um yes. So then I'll jump in and I know that we we talked about this last month. So you had the packet last month and you still have the packet here and that was we'd heard in the past about you know I think this happened years ago obviously before some of our time here where the city took over special education transportation in terms of vans which we call 7D drivers and then some small buses small and medium range mediumsiz buses that require CDL for that um and there's question on did it fulfill its duty as is profitable?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 173
Maybe that's not even the word profitable. Is it cheaper than out bidding out that type of scenario? So, I know that you've had information in the past presented to you and from what I've heard, right? What I've heard, um, maybe people still question that. So, if you're questioning it, we did put together, we didn't put it together, but we contacted Andy has contacts out there and this gentleman in a company who could do this, you know, study. you've seen all everything that would be done and it was presented last month and you voted to postpone to this month.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 173
Maybe that's not even the word profitable. Is it cheaper than out bidding out that type of scenario so I know that you've had information in the past presented to you and from what I've heard right what I've heard um maybe people still question that. So if you're questioning it, we did put together, we didn't put it together, but we contacted Andy has contacts out there and this gentleman in a company who could do this, you know, study. You've seen all everything that would be done and it was presented last month and you voted to postpone to this month.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 174
So there's nothing new I don't believe from our side Andy to present but we obviously would answer any questions that you have. >> Any questions secretary? >> Did the seeking of the study come from the administration? >> I would say yes. the former superintendent based on feedback and the the seemingly constant discussion regarding special education transportation and the the questions that had come up from presentations made to city council discussions about the overall transportation the whole concept of owning our vans etc. And then I provided information regarding and admittedly my analysis was cost basis only and comparing the cost of special education transportation and regular education transportation honestly of Greenfield with the dart communities other districts that Desi compares us to and I did the geographically contiguous communities as well that was presented didn't seem to you know change the concerns regarding special education transportation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 174
So there's nothing new, I don't believe, from our side, Andy, to present, but we obviously would answer any questions that you have. Any questions? Secretary, >> did the seeking of the study come from the administration? >> I would say yes. the former superintendent based on feedback and the the seemingly constant discussion regarding special education transportation and the the questions that had come up from presentations made to city council discussions about the overall transportation the whole concept of owning our vans etc. And then I provided information regarding and admittedly my analysis was cost basis only and comparing the cost of special education transportation and regular education transportation honestly of Greenfield with the dart communities other districts that Desi compares us to and I did the geographically contiguous communities as well that was presented didn't seem to you know change the concerns regarding special education transportation. So, I knew of and as does Superintendent Joyel know of the individual Rich Lee from this company uh who does this for a living.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 175
So, I knew of and as does Superintendent Joyel know of the individual Rich Lee from this company who does this for a living. Uh, and so I reached out to him asking him about coming in to do all the oversimplified review that we were asking him to do is compare self-operating special education transportation and our current sped transportation services to contracting out and do that. That's, you know, that's the comparison, the comparative analysis that we were asking him to do. look at current operations and our current configuration versus the what it would look like if we were to contract out and where I did strictly admittedly financial what data reported to the department of ed and going on to school districts budgets um he would actually go root by root you know and start to map out and do some comparative analysis of what is out there for the special education providers and what it is that we are currently paying our own for those own roots and see if it you know what that who knows what that analysis would entail.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 175
Uh, and so I reached out to him asking him about coming in to do all the oversimplified review that we were asking him to do is compare self-operating special education transportation and our current sped transportation services to contracting out and do that. That's, you know, that's the comparison, the comparative analysis that we were asking him to do. look at current operations and our current configuration versus the what it would look like if we were to contract out and where I did strictly admittedly financial data reported to the department of ed and going on to school districts budgets um he would actually go root by root you know and start to map out and do some comparative analysis of what is out there for the special education providers and what it is that we are currently paying our own for those own roots and see if it you know what that who knows what that analysis would entail.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 176
So that's the the genesis of that. >> I appreciate it. And when you say who knows what that analysis would entail, are you able to give us an idea from your own professional opinion if spending $10,000 on a study like this would yield us a savings of considerably more than that? >> I'm not It goes to the question of it's going to c speed transportation is going to cost us money one way or the other. And the thing about it is there are so many variables involved in I mean there's so I mean when we're talking down to the level of some students on a van would require a monitor. Some students on a van require being harnessed, they require being in in car seats, etc. and stuff. So there's that level of detail where you know to look at where it is. some students can't ride with other students and so on and so forth.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - October 8, 2025 · passage 176
So that's the the genesis of that. >> I appreciate it. And when you say who knows what that analysis would entail, are you able to give us an idea from your own professional opinion if spending $10,000 on a study like this would yield us a savings of considerably more than that? >> I'm not It goes to the question of it's going to c speed transportation is going to cost us money one way or the other. And the thing about it is there are so many variables involved in I mean there's so I mean when we're talking down to the level of some students on a van would require a monitor, some students on a van require being harnessed, they require being in in car seats, etc. and stuff. So there's that level of detail where you know to look at where it is. some students can't ride with other students and so on and so forth.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-09 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee October 8 2025 · passage 177
And so the the $10,000 in my opinion, if it's going to will it 100% put to rest the concerns about the fact that x number of years ago it was agreed that we would buy vans and and run our own transportation operations. I've said it before, I'm very surprised at the amount of revenue that this generates. You know, I I am surprised by that. Um I will say when you look back at when Mr. number, you know, he was the one that the former former transportation director put forward this proposal. We fully we didn't meet what it is that they said that we are going to do. What they put together as far as their plan for the proposal of what, you know, I'm not saying that they said it would be 100% self-supporting, but I'm saying that what it is that they put forward was not, you know, we didn't hit those targets, but we're getting there, you know.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above