And so the the $10,000 in my opinion, if it's going to will it 100% put to rest the concerns about the fact that x number of years ago it was agreed that we would buy vans and and run our own transportation operations. I've said it before, I'm very surprised at the amount of revenue that this generates. You know, I I am surprised by that. Um I will say when you look back at when Mr. number, you know, he was the one that the former former transportation director put forward this proposal. We fully we didn't meet what it is that they said that we are going to do. What they put together as far as their plan for the proposal of what you know, I'm not saying that they said it would be 100% self-supporting, but I'm saying that what it is that they put forward was not, you know, we didn't hit those targets, but we're getting there, you know.
So, if this $10,000 is going to put to rest the fact that when you look at the options that are out there for special education transportation, what our current configuration is, is a viable option, then I would say that's money well spent. So, I think we're looking for a a motion to approve the uh consultant work on the special education transportation operations. Is that right? I'd like to hear a motion to that. Motion from Mayor, second from member Goodwin. discussion. Okay. Second, >> mayor. >> So, um in that and I know in that will it be looking also at um some of will it factor in like like the cost of the actual buses and insurance costs? Okay. >> Yes. >> Any other discussion? Uh, vice chair, >> I just want to be really clear. I know I heard Andy verbally say that even though in our agenda and in the um proposal materials it says both regular and specialized transportation that the $9,995 figure is specifically just for our special education transportation and that that will be stricken from whatever contracts are actually signed where where it says anything other than that.
So, if this $10,000 is going to put to rest the fact that when you look at the options that are out there for special education transportation, what our current configuration is, is a viable option, then I would say that's money well spent. So, I think we're looking for a a motion to approve the uh consultant work on the special education transportation operations. Is that right? I'd like to hear a motion to that. Motion from Mayor, second from member Goodwin. discussion. Okay. Second >> mayor, >> so um in that and I know in that will it be looking also at um some of will it factor in like like the cost of the actual buses and insurance costs? Okay. >> Yes. >> Any other discussion? Uh, vice chair, >> I just want to be really clear. I know I heard Andy verbally say that even though in our agenda and in the um proposal materials it says both regular and specialized transportation that the $9,995 figure is specifically just for our special education transportation and that that will be stricken from whatever contracts are actually signed where where it says anything other than that.
Um, and by the buy, how much extra would it cost if it was our full transportation program? >> That's correct. It is just special education transportation. And I've had discussions subsequent after the last month's meeting with Mr. Libri, and he agrees uh that that regular ed was, you know, he does boilerplate analysis work regarding that. So, um, he he, you know, he he will take out the regular ed. As far as the regular transportation goes, I'm going to say that the due diligence is done by the Franklin County District as a whole because we join all the Franklin County school districts to go out collectively for that sole purpose of getting more bang for your buck by having all the districts join under one collective bid. >> Great. Thank you, >> Member Goodwin. Okay. So, that takes big buses out of the picture. So, the staffing for all of the special ed transportation would be part of the analysis as well.
Um, and by the buy, how much extra would it cost if it was our full transportation program? >> That's correct. It is just special education transportation. And I've had discussions subsequent after the last month's meeting with Mr. Libri, and he agrees uh that that regular ed was, you know, he does boilerplate analysis work regarding that. So, um, he he, you know, he he will take out the regular ed. As far as the regular transportation goes, I'm going to say that the due diligence is done by the Franklin County District as a whole because we join all the Franklin County school districts to go out collectively for that sole purpose of getting more bang for your buck by having all the districts join under one collective bid. >> Great. >> Thank you, >> Member Goodwin. Okay. So, that takes big buses out of the picture. So, the staffing for all of the special ed transportation would be part of the analysis as well.
And that would include their health insurance, everything that >> Yes. >> Okay. Great. >> Any other discussion? Secretary Den, will you call the vote? Chair Johnson Massad, >> yes. >> Vice Chair Ston, >> yes. >> I will abstain. Member Martini, >> no. >> Member Childs, >> can you come back to me? >> Yes. Uh, member Goodwin, >> yes. >> Mayor, >> yes. >> Member Childs. >> Well, I'll just go ahead and abstain because >> Yeah. >> Okay. Okay. >> All right. Passes. >> Passes with four yeses and three abstains. >> Uh, one no. >> One no and two abstains. Okay. Thank you. Um, moving on to school committee self-evaluation review and discussion. What are next steps? Does anyone have any um next steps to propose from our uh self evaluation? Not seeing any, we can move on to the next item, strategic plan review. Any uh questions or comments related to the strategic plan?
And that would include their health insurance, everything that >> Yes. >> Okay. Great. >> Any other discussion? Secretary Den, will you call the vote? >> Chair Johnson Assad, >> yes. >> Vice Chair Ston, >> yes. >> I will abstain. Member Martini, >> no. >> Member Childs. >> Can you come back to me? Can I? >> Yes. Uh, member Goodwin? >> Yes. >> Mayor? >> Yes. >> Member Childs? >> Well, I'll just go ahead and abstain because Yeah. >> Okay. >> All right. Passes. >> Passes with four yeses and three abstains. >> One no and two abstains. Okay. Thank you. Um moving on to school committee self-evaluation review and discussion. What are next steps? Does anyone have any um next steps to propose from our uh self-evaluation? Not seeing any, we can move on to the next item, strategic plan review. Any uh questions or comments related to the strategic plan?
Okay. Uh let's see. Discuss capital requests. We did that. >> We did >> procedures for adherence to open meeting law. Um, I guess I'd like to just discuss why I put this on the agenda tonight, but then I'm going to suggest that we postpone um further discussion and any votes to to next month. But, um, uh, I'm going to try as much as possible to frame this in terms of the future. Um, how would this school committee like to address if in the future um school committee members uh try to point it towards me? Um, how would the school committee in the future like to address uh I if a school committee member uh sends an email to a quorum or more of the of the school committee. Um, you know, we all have been to open meeting law training. Many of us at this point are very experienced public officials.
Okay. Uh let's see. Discuss capital requests. We did that. >> We did. >> Procedures for adherence to open meeting law. Um, I guess I'd like to just discuss why I put this on the agenda tonight, but then I'm going to suggest that we postpone um further discussion and any votes to to next month. But, um, uh, I'm going to try as much as possible to frame this in terms of the future. Um, how would this school committee like to address if in the future um school committee members uh >> try to point it towards me? Um, how would the school committee in the future like to address uh I if a school committee member uh sends an email to a quorum or more of the of the school committee. Um, you know, we all have been to open meeting law training. Many of us at this point are very experienced public officials.
There have been reminders sent out over the email. So, that's talking about the past, but in the future. Um, how would you see it seems to me there's some of the options that we have available to us are not great. It's not wonderful to file an open mating law complaint on a fellow committee member essentially reporting your own committee. At the same time, by its nature, email the public doesn't know what's happening over email. So, they wouldn't know whether an open meeting law violation was taking place. There, I think two um two things we want to address. One is to try to deter uh violations of open meeting law by email. Also, we want the public to in my mind I we want the public to be informed about what what if any errors are made what is being discussed by email. So, um that's why I I put this on the agenda.
There have been reminders sent out over the email. So, that's talking about the past, but in the future. Um, how would you see it seems to me there's some of the options that we have available to us are not great. It's not wonderful to file an open mating law complaint on a fellow committee member essentially reporting your own committee. At the same time, by its nature, email the public doesn't know what's happening over email. So, they wouldn't know whether an open meeting law violation was taking place. There, I think two um two things we want to address. One is to try to deter uh violations of open meeting law by email. Also, we want the public to in my mind I we want the public to be informed about what what if any errors are made what is being discussed by email. So, um that's why I I put this on the agenda.
I'm I wonder if between now and next month that the committee can can think about those issues and if we can have a discussion about how we might direct the policy committee to work on creating something to address those kinds of questions.
I'm I wonder if between now and next month if the committee can can think about those issues and if we can have a discussion about how we might direct the policy committee to work on creating something to address those kinds of questions.
I'm open to any discussion people want to have about it now or we can um postpone to November. Any discussion now? secretary. >> Um, I have been present during an open meeting law complaint. I don't know if you were there. I think you were there. Um, and this was an open meeting law complaint about the mayor, past mayor, and it was about email. And I thought that we came together really well as a committee and we made the decision for ourselves to engage in professional development about open meeting law. Um and then that was not supported by our chair at the time and it never occurred. So we never did the work that we were that we voted to do. Uh which I thought was kind of sad because I think that it would have really helped all of us. And I know that when people come on the committee, I I also have to like everybody has messed it up at least once and then they get a nice email from someone saying, "Don't mess it up." And then you learn.
I'm open to any discussion people want to have about it now or we can um postpone to November. Any discussion now? secretary. >> Um, I have been present during an open meeting law complaint. I don't know if you were there. I think you were there. Um, and this was an open meeting law complaint about the mayor, past mayor, and it was about email. And I thought that we came together really well as a committee and we made the decision for ourselves to engage in professional development about open meeting law. Um and then that was not supported by our chair at the time and it never occurred. So we never did the work that we were that we voted to do. Uh which I thought was kind of sad because I think that it would have really helped all of us. And I know that when people come on the committee, I I also have done like everybody has messed it up at least once and then they get a nice email from someone saying don't mess it up and then you learn.
So I think that when you first come on and you make this mistake, um now we have the handbook to follow. Uh that's acceptable and understood, but it's repeated violations after you've been told that I would like to discuss in November. And so thank you for putting that on the uh agenda and I will do my very best to think of solutions. >> Okay. Thank you. Any other questions or comments on the topic to think about now? Uh member childs. >> So this is really weird and it feels sort of rules lawyery but I just can't get it out of my head. It's sort of like how we're all members of the committee but also members of the public. So, what would happen? We don't have to answer this now. This could just be me being silly. What would happen if one of us were to use our personal email and send the email to the full committee email as a member of community or parent?
So I think that when you first come on and you make this mistake, um now we have the handbook to follow. Uh that's acceptable and understood, but it's repeated violations after you've been told that I would like to discuss in November. And so thank you for putting that on the uh agenda and I will do my very best to think of solutions. >> Okay. Thank you. Any other questions or comments on the topic to think about now? Uh member childs. >> So this is really weird and it feels sort of rules lawyery but I just can't get it out of my head. It's sort of like how we're all members of the committee but also members of the public. So, what would happen? We don't have to answer this now. This could just be me being silly. What would happen if one of us were to use our personal email and send the email to the full committee email as a member of community or parent?
I'm pretty sure that'd be an open meeting violation. >> But I I don't know. It's just I I think there are some and and then also when we have people like the mayor who is a mayor and as a member of the school committee, does it count as separate hats? >> So the I think those are basic questions about open meeting law. There certainly are resources available to us to answer that. We could certainly at the the attorney general's offices is more than happy to come and do a training specifically for us. Um my experience with the training um one time we I don't we did have an open meeting law placed against us. We agreed to have uh them come and do a training for us. They they presented the information but there was no real opportunity for I mean there was opportunity for people to ask questions.
I'm pretty sure that'd be an open meeting violation. >> But I I don't know. It's just I I think there are some and and then also when we have people like the mayor who is a mayor and as a member of the school committee, does it count as separate hats? >> So the I think those are basic questions about open meeting law. There certainly are resources available to us to answer that. We could certainly at the the attorney general's offices is more than happy to come and do a training specifically for us. Um my experience with the training um one time we I don't we did have an open meeting law placed against us. We agreed to have uh them come and do a training for us. They they presented the information but there was no real opportunity for I mean there was opportunity for people to ask questions.
basically they made their presentation and no one said anything or asked anything because the because something about the the format was not conducive to that. Uh so anyway, just a thought. Uh member Martini, >> uh my recollection is pretty spot-on with member Den's. Our former mayor made comments very publicly in the newspaper about the discussions held in an executive session prior to those minutes being published. And uh it's true that members and that resulted in the committee making an open meeting allow complaint about itself which I agree is preferable if we have a violation particularly something that's repeated. I think it's much better if it comes from us than coming from from someone else. Uh the committee should have responsibility for that. Um, and it's true that we do get this online training and it's required of people and and what have you. However, it's also true that there are often um particularities that are not really covered in that training that um leave people wondering.