Or can we put in like an asterisk on there saying if you swing very far out of the scope of that design then we can come back somehow. >> The most you could do would be to say things like no corrugated steel siding or no but also massing of windows bigger than this. >> You're also approving the drawings that are submitted with a package. Yeah. And if that rendering is submitted as part of a package, you are saying once you're giving your approval, you are saying that that piece of paper that is attached is approved. >> Got it. If it doesn't come out that way, what is our recourse? >> You can go back. I mean, >> can the town sue them? Like because you guys are >> we have stopped work. We have stopped work on projects. >> You given an example of of something that came out wildly different than what you expected it to look like.
You stopped working to hide >> and did they change it and make it? >> Yeah. >> So, it did come back into what it was supposed to look like >> for design, not for design. >> Okay. >> For design. Yes. >> So, I'm confused by this. Did a building get put up that we did that you approved that didn't come out the way you thought it was going to come out >> and they changed it and they came back and we we said what needed to be changed and it got changed. Yes. >> Okay. So, so it did come back in the scope of what you wanted. >> We brought it back. Let's say that >> but it's not an ideal situation. >> No, no, I again I'm just trying to understand >> in the perfect world the money will appear. Everything will be perfect.
>> Scott just doesn't understand the process. He's just speaking in generality. So if this happened again, what's the process that you would bring them back? >> So but it seems like sometimes you maybe your experience is different than ours. Like we have had hap this happen where we did bring we stopped the work. We it brought it back and >> it didn't sound like that when you first told the story. It sounded like that building was still up and existing in the in the wrong design. No, it changed. We It got changed. >> So, I'm going to I'm going to reel this in. We're completely like I don't know what this relates to at this point in our agenda. >> I'm trying to understand the process of what we're doing. >> Yeah. Yeah. But we can't have open meeting like >> in theory. This could relate to >> I thought I heard one about >> new projects.
I suppose >> looked at it, >> right? But it got >> But I think we need to >> Sure. But I think we should drop the topic and if we want to have a conversation about this, we should put it on the agenda for the next time. >> Yeah, it is a big it is a big topic and we're trying to talk about it in a philosophical way, you know, but um >> there's no agenda item to cover it. So >> I hear you. I hear you. >> You already started down that road. I just kept saying it. >> Maybe it would be since we do have new members though, maybe it would be good just to have like >> a general session kind of. >> But not on the 23rd, >> right? Not on the 23rd and probably not on the 13th either, but >> okay.
>> So, planning board tasks, I owe Jasmine a >> item of language to reddraft the design review bylaw and I never sent it to her. >> Lisa, I did talk to Lisa, town council, and we can do a revolving >> design review committee >> roster, but don't we need to go through town meeting to edit it? >> You would. We would have to go through town. I send you that language. >> Yes. >> Today. >> Okay. >> Behind schedule. So, obviously, we're not going to put it on the November >> thing, but we could for >> spring. Yeah. Great. >> Awesome. >> Um, that covers that topic unless someone wants to discuss some other task list item. >> Nope. >> Comprehensive plan. Trish and I are going to go to the next meeting and hopefully vote on the draft. >> That's that update. Design review committee.
I assume we still don't have one. >> Nope. And and Did they respond to She never responded to my email. >> She never responded to anybody that I that I noticed. >> We have official resignation letters. >> We do. The clerk actually signed it that day. Didn't hear about it or something like that. >> Actually, yeah. The next day, I think. >> Are we at a point of posting for filling? >> I don't think we want to do that until we know what this other path might be, >> you know? >> So then no design review committee until spring potentially. >> Potentially. I think this is a time where we need to reformulate. >> I mean, I I will say I have some mixed feelings about that because it's a lot of extra work on us that we could in theory designate and I think this board, this particular new board would benefit from having a design review committee we can go to.
>> Well, the other option potentially is that we get an outside thirdparty reviewer for design, which is what happens sometimes in other communities. So, that's an option. or we can have a longer discussion about it in a month, say, when we get through some of these other. >> Yeah, I say we have a longer discussion, which >> which is fine. >> Yep. >> But um >> I actually like the idea of a third party review, especially for this project that's coming up because even if you have a new committee, they're going to be new and they're going to >> this one, the YMCA. >> Yeah. Because the town doesn't want to charge the YMCA for a third party design. >> That's the problem. That is that's going to be the problem. We're going to have the town saying no. So again, let's have a deeper conversation about this because I don't think it's going to be easy for us to authorize or require applicants to pay for anything if the town is good.
So we should have a deeper conversation as to how realistic that is. It's a great idea in theory, but then no one wants to pay for it. >> We look like badasses for >> How expensive are things like that? >> 11,000 was the last one I got for design review. >> All right. Well, let's >> Well, let's revisit that in the next >> Let's leave that for another time. CPC, I think you already Is there anything else you wanted to add? You >> Yeah, they're bringing there's a bunch of warrants coming to the to the uh town. >> Yeah. Purchasing of couple plots of land for the town forest. um a survey for a possible road that well it's a it is an old road that is behind like part of a forest and part of like the back of people's houses and they're trying to figure out where exactly it is.
Um the YMCA and I think a softball field improvement thing those are all got approved from us and are coming to the the thing. All right, cool. Metro West Regional, have you done anything with them, people? >> Um, there's a meeting coming up on 23rd. Um, I realized all the emails were going to the Ashlin Mass email ID, which I don't have access to. So, Yolanda just connected with me day before yesterday. So, I'm going to sign up so that I can make it in person or not. I need to figure out my schedule on Wednesday. But, >> so the 23rd will be a double duty for you morning and night. Do you need me to do something so you can access your Ashlin? >> So, um, Peter tried, uh, again, I don't know. So, my Ashland mass ID is blocked and I'm not able to open it.
>> And, uh, Peter tried couple of times. It wasn't successful. >> We create a new one for you. >> I think we can pop >> if that's helpful. Yeah, because it's probably going into a black hole and I'm not able to access. So Yolanda seems to have sent all the Metro West to that ID and till day before yesterday she didn't realize I was seeing them. >> Oh, >> what is it? >> Oh yes. Would you like >> All right. So um >> pass it around. We're not going to talk about this right now, but um there is uh when we pass the ADU, this is just a heads up about what's coming on the 13th, right? >> Yes. November 13th. >> Discuss on the 13th. When we pass the ADU bylaw, I believe in the spring, right? Um Doug um Doug Scott I was going to say Doug Small.
Doug Scott um noted an an issue with it and not Yeah. noted an issue with it that he has taken upon himself to work um to have a bylaw that that that negates that situation. Basically, it's putting in I think in the most part it's kind of putting back in the old bylaw, but only for in-law apartments only for where it is a family member. It's not for rent. It's not a stranger. And so, um, and I need to talk to them about that more specifically because I wasn't aware that he was going through this process. >> Doug Scott is the building inspector. >> He's the building inspector. Yes. >> So, his confused. So his concern at the at the time um was that okay there's the there's a regulations for an ADU but if someone comes with for looking for a building permit and and this is my explanation without having talked to him so give me a little leeway on it but if someone comes that they're looking to put in an in-law apartment say say within their existing house and it has a bedroom and a kitchenette and a little bathroom and and a door to say hey this is grandma's department.
He would not be able to allow that to happen because it's neither in ADU nor is it allowed in in the um >> Did we take it out? Was it there before and we removed it or he's adding a brand new section? >> We did. It was in there and it was in-laws were in there and was removed from what I understood. >> Yeah, the in-law apartment was removed and we put in ADU. Right. Because >> because we thought they were one and the same >> because they seem to be one and the same but from his perspective they're not. So for instance, an in-law >> building code differentiates inlaws and AD. >> That's interesting though because I don't Is that his interpretation of that? Because my interpretation of when I was told this in real estate that the ADU did include the in-law. >> I need I need to get to the bottom of this because an an ADU and especially the way we have written it, it's it's a housing unit, right?
Housing units need two means of egress, right? Any housing unit has two means of egress unless they're sprinklered, I think. Um, but u an in-law apartment could be so in in an ADU has a lockable door that the two people in the two houses can't go into each other's units, right? But they have two means of egress out if there's a fire in their unit, right? An in-law apartment in in what Doug thinks I think he sees is that you portion off a a portion of your house for for grandma, right? >> With her own entrance, >> right? With her own entrance. But for her to but but she's still a part of the house. So it only has one means of egress. So there's no lockable door like >> and you wouldn't see this because this isn't there's no mass general laws on in-laws.
There's only mass general laws on ADUs. >> Isn't it just another room? >> Building code is where the difference is. Building code differentiates between ADUs and in-laws. But without including the in-law, there's no way for our building commissioner to allow you an in-law because we can't grant use variances. >> Yes, it's a little it's a little tricky because to to get a sense of it about but anyway, I just wanted to tell you that it was coming and um I didn't I wasn't aware of it either. So, it's a little bit, you know, coming on us all of a sudden, but we we we're just going to need to look at it and address it as do some research and address it as a board. Um, unfortunately at this point I don't think it's changeable. Um, but so let's get to an understanding of of the issue before we, you know, um, go too far down that.
Okay. So that's that. Um, do we need to do any updates on 40? Do you have any on tonight? Unless you have an update. >> Well, if assuming that 10 to 60 Maine, 61 Waverly, and 55 West Union all are approved and counting the Arbella, which was already approved but is in litigation. If we count all of those, if they are approved, the housing the subsidized housing inventory goes up to 18%. So even once our 20 um 30 census data comes back, the likelihood that we're above 10% SHI is still very good. Now the issue is our housing production plan is set to expire this May. If your housing production plan expires, you lose your um safe harbor. So we are contracting a service right now to update our housing production plan to get it approved before it expires in May. And part of that housing production plan needs to be smart plans to keep us in that 10 over 10% affordable compliance so that way we don't become reactive to 40bs again.
And then we can plan for them intelligently as builders come in. We can say no, we need this many units to be affordable to re to maintain our compliance. And then it's also within our purview if we want it to be 80% AMI, 40% AMI, we're no longer at the mercy of the state and the developer. all within the town as long as we stay above 10% and that law doesn't change. >> All right. Well, thank you. That was a good update. I appreciate it. >> The Arbella also, by the way, is still still lower. >> Yeah. So, we don't know where that 18% >> it could get dropped on us at any point. So, >> yeah. So, um Okay. >> Did they are they I don't know if I can ask this. Is that part of the traffic plan? Dearbella, >> I think >> they are taking it and we did ask them to take into consideration Sirrus.
So for YMCA and 55 West Union, we said please take into consideration 55 West Union and YMCA for both projects, the Sirrus apartment, the Arbella, um the MBTA station and the Dunkin Donuts and the dog park. >> Is aren't they also changing the MBTA? Like >> the train schedules are going to update to be every half hour in 2027 is the plan. And speaking of MBTA, our uh bylaw, yes, got approved. So, >> what are the next steps? >> Yes, we're all set with it. It's that's it. It's approved and it just gets incorporated into the E code. >> So, there's no zoning changes that happens. >> They'll update the zoning map to incorporate where the overlay is, but >> all right. >> But I haven't heard of a single I've only heard of one community so far where developer took advantage of the MBTA.
I haven't heard of any other >> developers. We basically already >> Yeah. >> Um, September 11th minutes look good to me. >> I have a few things. Um, line 43 and 44. Um, I'm sure Miss Ms. Kinsman did not make a motion and also second the motion herself. >> So, I don't know who seconded the motion, but um, >> yeah. 4344. Brandy is making a motion and also seconding the motion. So I don't know what the answer is. >> Um >> how do we fix that? >> You can look at the >> I have to listen to the minute. Yeah, listen to the recording. >> Um or just say and someone seconded. I don't know. >> Motion was made and seconded. Yeah. On line 89, um, it says, "Miss Kendall stated there was an email received regarding appointing a member to the I think there were multiple emails.
I remember them being multiple emails." So, put that. And then, um, there was one more. Oh, um, on line 246, there's just, um, the very end of that paragraph on 246, must be used within three years and are I don't know what that's supposed to be. I would just take off the end and R and then I'm good. >> Okay. So, I'll make a motion to approve the September 11th minutes with the changes Trisha noted. >> Everyone else good with that? >> Yep. >> Okay. And a roll call vote. >> Wank. >> Anna Tesmani. >> I pilot I. >> I. >> And Trisha Kendall I. So, um, next meeting obviously is on the 23rd with the select board and with the YMCA. We'll try to keep everything else out of it if at all humanly possible. Um, otherwise, if there's nothing else, >> I'll make a motion to close.
>> Wait a minute. He has >> just I just want to know like how long is that select board piece going to be like going over this comprehensive plan? I'm just imagining it not being a short >> I don't think it will be very short >> because there's going to be discussion about the implementation committee voting hard to could be 45 minutes an hour could be long >> still starting at the same time. >> Yes. >> Yeah. >> Do you want to try and see if we can start it an hour earlier? >> I don't know. >> No. Yeah. >> I'm I'm already running late. >> Yeah. I think it's I mean I would not start changing meetings unless we start changing all of them. Bigger conversation. >> I think just we hold out um plan to hold out an hour for the YMCA. Um though they might be starting quite late.