2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 124
No, it's a good point and that's it's not in the warrant. >> I understand it's not in the warrant, but part of the discussion here is >> whether we as a group support bringing this to town meeting and >> so he's a individual. >> It's it's you know, you've you've obviously done the work. You've gotten your citizens petition. You've gotten your signatures. It's you're right now you're you're you're planning on bringing it to town meeting. I just >> Right. I would echo what Brandy said. I don't know that town meeting is the place for this discussion. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Where would >> I'm not sure. I I I I would have to really think about that because in regards to the I mean I think it's discussion amongst your the residents, right? Or you as a group deciding that you might decide to write to Middle Sex to the retirement.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 124
You have to be a strong advocate for public education and at the same time you have to and I know all of you are going to be act with honesty certainly respect confidentiality in this business. Things are confidential and at times we cannot just blurt it out into the public. Okay. So, but all of you have all of the means and the talents that I wish I could select all of you, but I can't. So, here are my people. Um, Jamie Coup, Jonathan Mononttoya, Lara Kim, Shana Brewer. Those are my people. Thank you my board my board colleagues. Now I'm going to refer this next step to the superintendent. Thank you, President Boak. And again, thank you to all of our applicants and everything that you shared. I was certainly taking notes on all of your suggestions and ideas. That's always a great part of having our community come forward and being able to hear suggestions and things that we may not have thought about before that we can begin, you know, envisioning and putting forward in the best interest of our students and serving our Beressa community.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 125
I mean if as residents this is something you feel strongly about then maybe you do it as residents rather than >> we can certainly do that but you are the governing body here in Ashland and that oversee town employees we do not >> so that's why you know that's why this directs you or asked you to do that >> so >> I I do think there so you mentioned different elements of your proposal here and I think that the other piece you talked about was the divestment the requested for divestment Have you thought about, you know, maybe separating that out from this particular warrant article and and asking that we generate, you know, I think that's a I'm thinking the reason why I'm thinking about this and again, I'm not an attorney, but like, you know, I'm thinking about when u way back in the day when there were a a a movement to divest in South Africa or businesses that did business with South Africa, you know, there's they didn't target specific companies per se.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 125
So, thank you so much. And again, um there is continued opportunity to partner with us. Each one of these members here have district-wide committees that have seats available. And you know, if you have an expertise or love in, you know, HR, in business, in bonds, in facilities, in instructional programming, we have places for you to give uh that love and passion towards. So, please just be sure to check in with us afterwards and we're happy to share those opportunities with you. So, in um revisiting uh the criteria for moving on to be a finalist, what was established was if a individual's name was uh listed by two or more board members, you would move to the next round. And so as we look at this listing, we see um that every name that's been listed up here from what I can tell has is listed here at least twice, if not more.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 126
it seemed like they had like criteria around certain companies that were doing things XYZ ABC around human rights, right? So, I mean just >> that's a good point. We talked about a general >> but that has its own issues and this is not to say that we won't come back with something like that. That would be you'd have to have a very complex set of evaluations for it to have legal law. So, we're not ruling that out, but we're doing Musk right now because of who he is and his uniqueness. So that's that's how we got to this point. Um so that's >> and just to kind of piggyback on what Makita said, you know, that kind of request can come to us like if we you know that doesn't need to be a town meeting that doesn't need to go on town meeting floor.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 126
So Shana Brewer, Shauna Brewer, Randy Lee, Jonathan Mononttoya, Jamie Coup, Laura Kim, you will move forward to our next round. Okay. Congratulations. And so while we prepare for that next round, we're going to take a brief recess. Um trustees, what would you prefer? 15 minutes. >> How about 10 minutes, my fellow board members? Is that enough? >> Okay. All right. We will take a 10 minute recess, which will allow us time to get organized for the second round of interviews. Thank you again for everyone that joined us thus far. We appreciate everyone's patience that we'll continue with this process. Thank you. The meeting is now called to order. We shall continue with the business at hand. For those applicants identified as finalists, we will be asking each to answer the same four questions to be asked by board members. Finalist will have two minutes to answer each question.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 127
like if if if there's if there's a discussion about us writing a letter to you know about about pensions and things like that that's something that doesn't need to go to town meeting >> but what's the harm of going so we have a whole package here together that includes so >> and >> I take your point but why are we voting against this why are we seeing this is such a big deal >> so I think part of it is >> so much of it is simple >> I think part of it is um you guys have put this together put a lot of thought into it. Got a lot of signatures. >> It's as written in the warrant article. We cannot make any changes once we vote the warrant tonight and close the warrant. We can't make any changes. The only changes can be made on town meeting floor.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 127
We will go in reverse alphabetical order by last name. Finalists who are not answering the questions will be asked to wait in the ED services conference room to ensure that they do not hear the questions before it is their turn. I would add I think there are some goodies over there for you. With that, with that, I would ask Jonathan Mantoya to come forward and for Miss Strickland to accompany the other finalist to the ed services conference room so that we can have the next finalist as soon as it is their term. Thank you. Yeah, we have to wait. Okay, wait till they're over there. You tell me one more minute. Okay, we're good. >> Thank you very much for waiting. I think we can begin. Board member Jeriah Hog has the first question. Trustee Hog, please. >> Hi, Dr. Mononttoya. >> Oh. Oh, that's right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 128
>> That's right. >> Right. >> So, you know, we're already talking about how the procurement is not applicable. That's going to be something that is talked about on town meeting floor that it cannot be it it cannot be um implemented the way that it's written like it just >> well we actually don't know that because I've asked for well I've asked for legal I haven't heard it >> so Bob you you sat in this chair for a long time you you know you know what procurement law >> yes and I I know that that we're just delivering um the sense to the agents of the town that they should have this in mind as they do procurement. It's up to them to decide how that works or if they can use it at all. We're not dictating that to them. >> So, so this is a conversation that we're having tonight and I think >> this is the appropriate place to have those discussions >> but I'm not an expert in procurement law.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 128
Okay. Timer. Thank you, Miss Gomez. >> Thank you. So, you have two minutes to respond. My question to you is how would you work with other board members, labor partners, and administrators when perspectives differ on important decisions? >> Uh, thank you for this question. U, I experience these types of situations often as a director of programs and dealing with community partners. Um, I think different perspectives are what we kind of look for, right? like that's that's what what we thrive on to be able to to learn from one another. In terms of of when we have those disagreements, I'll just I'll say that I think being able to to lean on our love of students and our service is really really what brings that forward because it's not about this person or that person. We're here to serve the students and also I would say you know leaning on our mission statement right regardless of what we what we believe um which is valued we need to be true to the mission statement but also just leading in service to students with love that that's it and if you can fall on that if someone's passionate and disagrees it's because they care they deeply care about the students and I would never fault anyone for that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 129
Well, I don't think town meeting is the appropriate. >> I think that's beside the point because town me is making a statement of the sense of the citizens of Ashland for you to carry out to the best of your ability within the law. That's basically all it is >> and that's what we do. That's what we do every every day. That is what >> you don't have statement behind you as to what what our what the citizens uh wishes are >> and that's why we have town meeting resolutions. I I mean I I firmly believe in freedom of speech and I firmly believe that people have the right to speak and bring bring issues to us, bring issues to town meeting. We have that that's what the mechanism for citizens petitions are all about. Um, I think that if we would have had this discussion two months ago, it would have been a much more productive use of everyone's time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 129
Thank you. >> Thank you very much. >> Um, board member, please. The next question. Mark. Um, my question is, as a board member, how would you advocate for and support policies that meet the diverse needs of all students, including those who require academic rigor, specialized programming, or additional learning and behavioral supports? >> Thank you. I think this is a really good question. Um, I think about my time as a classroom teacher and differentiated instruction. you know, I've taught students that are heart surgeons and and um you know, all like all all walks of students and I just think about we don't really have to recreate the wheel so much. A lot of of what we what we need to do to serve our students is dare. It's in there. There's laws that's that are already on the books from the 80s, from the 70s that support all students, multilingual students, neurodyiverse students, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 130
And and I hear that you want to have a you want to have a discussion about making a statement of what the town of Ashland stands for. And I hear that. I think that that's that is absolutely something we should do. I I'm not sure a resolution against Elon Musk on town meeting floor is going to get us there. And maybe and maybe that's part of the discussion that we have of like what that mechanism looks like. Maybe there is a maybe we have a public forum not town meeting but a public forum where we discuss what we can do as a community and how we protect our I mean we're very concerned >> always about protecting and the safety of our community and >> you know I don't want I don't want anyone in Ashlin to feel like they're targeted. I don't want anyone to feel that they're unsafe.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 130
So, um I think that that as a board member, I hope I can innovate, but I I have a feeling that a lot of it is just going to be referring to the things that already exist and maybe having to remind not none of you, but like maybe remind myself of okay, like I learned about this. This is um you know, all students are entitled to learn in their home language or or all students are entitled to to equitable access to to learning. like these are things that are already on the books. Like it's if I can just rely on that. Um I'll end with that. >> Thank you. Board member Sharin Basan has the next question. >> Thank you, President Bai. Um Mr. Mononttoya, uh, you're serving on the school board when a decision you supported, such as budget, budget cuts, curriculum changes, or school consolidation, receives strong public criticism at a board meeting and on social media.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 131
And and I worry about our our residents. I worry about people in the community not feeling like they can be in public for fear of whatever retribution may be coming. And >> and that's that that feeling of helplessness is is what that that that's hard. That's really hard. And this is why I think the purest form of democracy is town meeting and that's why this resolution is going there. So people talk about >> town meeting is a legislative our legislative session. That's that's where that is that is our Congress. That is our that's our >> and that's where we make the big decisions and the final approvals. That's what it's about. It's individual democracy. So that's why this is going there. I >> I think at this point, you know, it's in the warrant. we're about to close it. >> You know, it's, you know, as a group, you have to determine what you're going to do if if you're going to still bring this to town meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 131
How would you respond to the criticism while maintaining transparency, professionalism, and the best interests of the district? Yeah, I think thank you for that question. I think this one really hits at the heart of what I see my role as a trustee would be making really tough decisions and and and living with the consequences of that. Like I don't take I'm not going to take any decision lightly and any decision that matters there's not going to be disagreement. I'm never going to to get everyone to agree with what what it is that that that I I decide. And I'm okay with that. I'm willing to live with that. And um in terms of responding to it, I think if I can just lean on my, like I said earlier, the mission of of the of the um school district, my love of the students, and then also the easy ones, the der like the law stuff like, okay, well, I'm sorry that you disagree with that, but it's just what it is.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 132
I think you've heard >> from all of us. Um, >> thank you. >> You know, I I think we need to close the conversation. And >> I'll just repeat if you have specific wording or if you come up with something that we could use, I'm sure we'd be happy to look at it. >> Well, that would be wording that would have to go to town meeting floor, >> right? They could they could write an amendment and say we're amending the language and that's that I mean it happens all the time. >> It absolutely happens. Well, >> thank you for your time. >> You're welcome, >> Rob. Appreciate that and we appreciate the efforts that you try. >> I mean, I wonder if you could take this and write it to say if we could, but we, you know, say we can't do these things, but this is what we wish we could do.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 132
We have to to do this um in in service to our students. Thank you. I have the last question. My question is, how do you define equity in education and what specific steps would you take to promote and support equity in Beressa schools? you know, um, the board probably hasn't had a chance, nor would I want you to read through my dissertation or any of my research. It could be pretty boring, but it's all equity. Like, that's what I do. That's why I get up in the morning. That's why I left the students that I loved, that I taught for 10 years to go back to graduate school and to try to make an impact and study this stuff. It's why I teach teachers at St. St. Mary's College so that hopefully I can impact more than just those few. I had what like 140 students but so I I get to impact more I hope um with through equity you know we're blessed in this area some it fluctuates but I think we're the second most linguistically diverse place in the country behind Jersey City somehow.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Selectboard Meeting (October 15th, 2025) · passage 133
Something like that even would get it all in there. There is the phrase of non-binding resolutions, you know, that they didn't quite use here, but it's almost >> But that I was just Rob, that's not a bad idea. Non-binding resolution. >> Well, it says extent allowable by law. >> Right. And so >> and that connects >> Makita what you just said is is >> to the extent that it's allowable by law, but it's not allowable by law. >> Right. Well, you don't know in all cases and all details. for some of the >> my point is you don't know in all cases and all details. Don't make the decision for them. Pass the resolution and let people carry it out. You know, that's that's my I guess closing point. >> Okay, >> that that makes sense. >> Yep. >> That makes sense. >> And and the other the other point that we may want to just consider with that, Rob, is that at some point in time your committee uh decides to withdraw that the only time that can be withdrawn is on town meeting floor.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-16 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube October 15, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 133
Um but that goes back and forth. So like we're in this beautiful place with such diverse perspectives and and and that is an asset and I think um the equitable the equitable part of any of any institution or any education is the most important part. Our students need to be able to access education no matter what. And I'm I'm passionate. I I direct the the bilingual um authorization at St. Mary's College. So, I'm passionate about multilingual education. As a uh an English learner, as a child that was forced to forget my language, then relearn it in college. These were things that that that that are close to my heart. You know, going I went to a funeral the other day where I was able to speak Spanish with my family. When I was a kid, I wasn't able to talk to them because I wasn't fluent in Spanish.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above