Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
Um, and and I appreciate that there had to be some controls around what that meeting would look like and how much time. And then of course, as we all know, it just kind of fell flat on its face with with not really providing any um substantive uh responses. And so I know that there have been some posted now on the website to the questions that were asked at our meeting, but honestly, and I think I maybe even said that to you, Michael, that it it feels like somebody just took the um the video and had AI try to match up the questions, which because there are sometimes the responses don't seem to match up with the like dust comes up in almost every response, Right. So what I would ask is that we take those questions and um you know I don't have a problem with grouping them according to similar themes you know like there were a lot around the vapor barrier right and then presenting those to um either the folks that were here or other representatives and asking for a written response to those questions that then could be posted on the website.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So I think as a board member that's the model I would set um is really being curious and trying to understand the points of view and where can we come to agreement and where is the compromise in the best interest of the district. >> Thank you. Board member Kanguin has the next question please. >> Good evening. My question is, as a board member, how will you advocate for and support policies that meet the diverse needs of all students, including those who require academic rigor, specialized programming, or additional learning and behavioral supports? >> Yeah, I think um well, I think first and foremost, I would need to learn. I I have the perspective of as a parent and a student of two schools. Um, I've served on different committees and and expanded my awareness of what our other schools offer, but I would say I learned the most being on the school consolidation committee as to what where our schools are differentiated um where are the achievement gaps, what are the needs and so I think the first thing I would do is really actually go and visit the schools and talk to the different um principles and staff to understand the unique qualities and challenges that exist on each campus.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um, you know, I I think it's only fair based on what we were trying to do with that meeting and what we asked um and what were was asked of the citizens, right? I mean, basically, we said to them, you can't talk, but you're going to get your questions answered and and as we well know, that didn't happen. So, I'd really like to follow up with that. Um, you know, additionally, one of the things that has arisen a couple of, well, several times, um, is the height in and of these buildings. Um, and in particular, one of the things I had asked for this week were were the renderings. when they didn't come through with the balloon test, um I had they had offered they would be renderings and so the renderings that they submitted had no setback numbers. They had no height listed on them there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
and really learn that ecosystem so that I can advocate from a stance of neutrality and district mindset versus bringing only what I know today. >> Thank you. Board member J. Shinasan has the next question. >> Excuse me. >> Good evening. Good evening. Brewer. Um, you're serving on the school board when a decision that you supported, such as budget cuts, curriculum changes, or school consolidation, receives strong public criticism at a board meeting and on social media. How would you respond to the criticism while maintaining transparency, professionalism, and the best interests of the school district? Yeah. And the question is like after a decision has been made. Yeah. I think you know at the end of the day um people just want to be heard and valued and I think that the way you respond is think I mean every piece of information you get is a gift.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
There's nothing that would give you any sense of what you're looking at. Um, and so I ask again because I'm not sure where that that was brought up last night, but I'm not sure we still got any place. They're going to go back now and put numbers on them. Okay. Well, how about a rendering that shows how it actually looks in comparison to the existing buildings, right? So, I mean, it shouldn't be too hard to do that. You can either take >> overlay. >> Yeah, you can do an overlay. You can take an existing building and just put it next to it. You can do a you know backup and and do a broader um you know drawing that would include several buildings say the the brick houses across the street um and then all the way down to one to the church and 128 Maine.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I actually think it's worse when people go silent and you don't actually know what people are thinking and what's going on. And it it serves as input for the next set of decisions and policies that we make. I think tonight's a great example. I mean, we heard some themes around technology and AI and new ways to generate revenue and and they're all ideas that have been percolating my brain, but I actually thought I was alone. Um, and so I think when we listen and and look for the nuggets of wisdom in our community, actually all the answers are there for us. So the criticism is just an element of feedback. It's not personal. And so I think you respond with thank you and then you take that into your next set of meetings and decisions. [Music] >> I have the last question. I have the last question, Miss Brewer, and the question is this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Let's look at or or things on across the street the same now up at 61 Waverly. So last night they said they responded to me, "Yeah, there's some numbers on there's already numbers on the architectural drawings." Okay. So I went back and I looked up the architectural drawings. Yes, indeed there are numbers, but all it is is is a it it's not even a picture of the building. It's just sort of shows the levels and it says 12.9 12 feet 12 feet 12.8. You know >> what's what's that supposed to mean to anybody? I mean these that doesn't give you a sense of what the structure is going to look like you know and and the and a couple other things I know that Mrs. confr times about and as have others brought up about water and um and you know I've asked what would it cost if we had to tie into Southboro right we have that ability but what would the cost be and and it doesn't seem to me that we're we have an unlimited amount of water I mean I think there was a time in the world when we felt like we did I think that time hasn't ended I think we all have to be thinking about water supply and you know what what does it mean to to have to tie in for financially and really uh I think Mrs.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
How do you define equity in education? And what specific steps would you take to promote and support equity in Beressa schools? >> I think equity it means ensuring that everyone has the opportunity to achieve success. It doesn't necessarily mean everybody has the same thing, but that we remove barriers for those that really need it so that they can be successful. I think about um my cousin, she's a little person and she's my age, and watching her grow up and really like learning like, oh, your counters are way too high for you to do dishes or you need a special tool in your car to drive. that doesn't make her any less likely to be successful, but I don't need those things. She needs them. And so, we need to look for those um opportunities and where the barriers are and then what do they need for that step.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
on Friday too had some numbers in terms of what we actually have for capacity currently right before we would have to >> and the other thing is the MWR uh not MWR but um the the sewer right the gallonage there okay so we figure that if this project or these projects go forward then Framingham will will let us buy some more gallonage right or the governor would basically say yeah you've got to give them more gallonage that we pay for, >> right? >> And so, >> and the cost >> that too is at a cost, >> right? >> Um, and you know, I I just kind of feel like we're we talk about these things, but we never get any answers. We just talk about them. And I feel like so often through this whole process, questions have been raised by many people regarding this pro these projects.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um and so, how I would do that is I mean those that are closest to the work have the solution. So, that's a true foundational belief of mine. So, it's again looking at our data, looking at our schools, looking at our students, looking at our staff and our teachers and asking them what's needed and finding ways to provide it. >> Thank you for your answers. You may sit down and um remain until we're done, I guess. >> Okay. Again, I want to thank all of the finalists for their responses to the board's questions. As I mentioned at the opening, at this time I would like to ask my fellow board members to again focus on what they are looking for in an applicant to fill the vacancy and ask that they identify their top three unless you only have one. Top three preferred applicants in order based on which applicants be best meets those criteria.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And you know, if you're lucky, you get to say what your concern is, but you I don't think you rarely do you walk away feeling like you have a response. And it that it's there's just such an emptiness to this whole process that it's astounding to me. Claudia, can I can I jump in for a second because I do want to I do want to add and thank you for your comments that I've I've been reached out by few of my constituents as well, especially uh about the meeting with the EPA and the whole question piece. And I actually want to say that your your remedy around getting those questions answers makes a lot of sense to me if we can just get it in a way on the website that I mean the groupings are fine but we need to be able to display the questions that our residents have been asking and make sure that there are clear answers to them so folks know that you know they they they did abide by the process that we asked them to to abide by but they did not get the answers uh that they were looking for and that was a huge disappointment.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Yes, we can rank order this time. >> Do we have to rank order or we have to rank order? I see. I I >> Are we ready >> this time? I'm ready. I mean, I think so. So I mean imagine the amount of pressure that you have to I hope you're all ready for this kind of pressure when you join the board. But >> oh dear >> uh but I mean since I'm since we have to rank choice u so my top uh person to be appointed will be uh Miss Brewer Sha Brewer uh followed by um Mr. Lee and uh Miss Coup. >> As for me, I stand by what I said earlier. I I'd be fine with any of the the candidates to be appointed. Um I think everyone brings a unique uh quality and experience to the board. Uh but the one thing that that I'm looking for uh as a board member is um that missing voice on this board.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I don't think we've had a meeting since that that and then so thank you for bringing it up and that's I got a lot of negative feedback about that and I would like to address that. It's not just because we got negative feedback but you know again we we asked people to follow a process and folks felt like they their voices were not heard and that that's that's not I think what our desired result for that was. No. And I think >> so that's the first piece. But >> go ahead, Michael. >> No, I was going to say I mean I I was disappointed just as disappointed if not more so than than everybody else just because I knew what the expectations were. I knew what our expectations were in terms of what we wanted coming out of that meeting and what we felt going into that meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And that missing voice on this board for as long as I've been on on this board is someone with a unique experience that has actually served in this school district as an employee. Uh particularly if there's a classroom uh uh someone with classroom experience. Uh we've never had that in this school board as far as as long as I've been on this board. Um so I so that's the reason why I uh uh selected uh Mr. Lee and uh Miss Coup and those who are my uh rank orders as well. This is very difficult because everyone did very well. So, I'm just scrolling through my notes. Um, I with everybody's responses, I think I would actually rate my top three in order of in order. I think number one, Bisha. I think her answer on equity was excellent and I really enjoyed her definition. Um, number two, I would say Randy.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We felt like everybody was all set to to deliver, you know, the product that we were all talking about. So, um, and, um, I can certainly take, uh, ownership of that. You know, it's a fine line. You, you know, you didn't necessarily want to prep, you know, D and EPA, but at the same time, you want to, you know, make sure and follow up and make sure that, okay, this is what the expectation is. Do you feel like you're going to be able to to meet that? Um, and I think that's the message that that we had received. So, we were surprised. Um, and I certainly agree if if everybody is comfortable with us summarizing the questions and kind of grouping them by topic, I'm happy to send it to D and EPA and and ask them to, you know, take some time and and and respond and respond thoughtfully.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I really loved his in the classroom experience and bringing that to the question and he has that understanding of how to you know support our students with disabilities. And I would also say three Jamie Coup I al also really enjoyed her responses and her education on education is very evident in her responses. Yes, it's my turn. I have um I know that we need someone here who can represent all of us, all of our students. And so I do have I do have a couple here. My um first one is um Shana, the next one is Lara Kim and the other one is Jonathan Montoya. Those are my three and thank you all of you. You did an excellent job in responding to our questions. >> At this at this point, I'll I'll assist you for this part. And we also have Mr. Tunic, our legal counsel here in the audience, also to assist if any of the trustees have questions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I >> I would say that it's very important as we're grouping those questions, we want to make sure that we have a list of the original questions and then like you know what that summary is. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> So that people can see that their questions that they submitted >> were addressed under a particular topic area or rollup area. >> Wonder if we'd do like a matrix where you have like you know one column is all the individual questions and next to us like a block. >> That's what I'm sort of envisioning something like that. >> We think in spreadsheets Makita >> I know. >> So >> it's an affliction. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> It you know just one last comment. I think it's my last comment, but you know, one of the things that we're doing as a board and and you're doing um with your department heads in that is looking at what are our highest priorities in the community.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um, but now that you've done your rank order, you can review what you see there. Um, at this point in time, the board has some options. You may choose to, um, continue discussion amongst your top candidate if there needs to be more discussion there. You also if anyone feels inclined want to make a motion for an appointee you may also do that. If we are torn between one or two individuals we can do a closing question and bring them forward. So you've got some choices. So um so you know I I didn't provide any comments when I made my selection but uh so we looked at the entire application process right including the um the initial screening plus the screening questions as well as the uh final questions and uh and what what I was looking for and uh and the reason I I uh went with that with that order is um how well you uh you understand uh our complicated questions and how we how you u formulate your thoughts.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And it it has struck me because I I brought this up even I think at at our uh July 12th um retreat is that to me whether or not you are okay with this or you're not okay with it, >> it's one of the highest priorities in this community. What it's going to look like and how you know what the community is going to look like based on whether or not like I say you're for or against it. It's really important. And >> Claudia, I spent 10 hours working with them to figure out the the the design and and and to work with them on that. I I understand it's important. >> Yeah. I I just feel as though we haven't it doesn't hasn't felt to me that I feel like and I think I've expressed it, you know, that I feel as though I've had to really struggle to um to even have some conversations sometimes around this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
You know it's not easy standing out there as throwing uh questions at you and you know you have to uh really understand what we are trying to trying to achieve and respond based on that. It's not it's not the easiest thing to do. And the the reason I I uh had um and again this is not it's not an easy process like you can see. The reason why why I had this brewer up there is because uh I I felt that her u uh comments were you know very uh on point on several issues uh especially with equity as well as u uh how to how to uh be a empathetic listener and things like that. uh which is why I had um Miss Puiter u as my as my top choice. Again, I don't think we can go wrong with any of uh any of the candidates.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above