2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 56
But sometimes you have disagreements on something that you're voting on or that's on the agenda or a process. Yes, ma'am. trust. >> I would have to agree that every board, every relationship has conflict, has a disagreement of what you know of any sort, but how conflicts are basically uh handled right uh towards each other and I think 15 kind of goes along with that respecting each other. I I think that has a lot of leverage because we don't have to like each other to be on this board. >> Absolutely. >> We don't have to agree bipartisan. We don't have to agree to be Democrat, Republican, green, whatever it is, right? Patriot, we don't have to agree. But the one thing that we have in common is that we have a goal and a purpose, and that is to lead this district for our students. However, I I have felt that um we internally do have not productively resolved conflict within our board.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 57
I also agree that we do not follow agreements on how we act towards each other when we do not agree when with each other. And I also agree that board members do not treat each other with respect when they are angry because your true character comes out when you are upset when you're angry and how you h how you handle that conflict. And so I've I've been on this board for for some time and I've had to learn a lot of things on how to handle conflict, how to handle things. And I am going to bring up a situation that happened in this last year. >> Okay? >> And um that is um we on the board have agreed that we do not respond to public comments that day. If we have any um any type of comments or suggestions that we um basically speak with each other um before you know and especially because if a person comes and speaks on the dis on public comment um we do not speak on that regardless of um if we've spoken to the superintendent if we have it on our notes to speak on it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 58
We with we refrain refrain and withdraw from those comments. And so recently um this year there was an incident where we had um a gentleman come speak on public comment and on a non-aggenda item and a board member spoke on the public comment and I as the president asked this board member to please you know con stop on this um comment and it had I had to do it three times where this individual um got very angry with me because they were saying that I was being uh disrespectful. But as the board president, it is my duty to keep our meetings in line and to be make making sure that we do not speak on public comment or sway the board on, you know, any type of future agenda items that may be on our agenda items for us to vote because that is breaking the board um the Brown Act because we have not put it on on the agenda.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 59
We have not publicly spoken about it. And so therefore, I I I am the one that said less often. That that is me. I do I do remember that. And after the incident, I asked the board member if it would be okay if we spoke about this after and they refused. Um at first I said okay. And after we went into close session, we came back, did open session, continued. Um, and at the end of our board meeting that day, um, this board member lashed out at me publicly and disrespectful and I am not okay with that. Uh, this board member yelled, uh, belittled me, humiliated me. I All that I asked was if we could have a conversation and we this board member did actually in fact did stay behind and we did speak to our superintendent. And while we were at that meeting, the board member lashed out and said I blindsided them, you know, last minute where they needed to step up where and I I I said, "Wait, hold on.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 60
That's a different topic. That's a different subject. can we speak about tonight? A and if I was disrespectful, I I would like to apologize. I went back and saw the video two or three times and not once did I see that I was disrespectful towards this board member. I was just trying to keep order in the board meeting and the reaction of this board member was uncalled for. It was disrespectful and um I would like to address that at this point. >> Absolutely. And one thing I will say right here is um a couple of weeks ago I was facilitating a student board meeting um student board member training and we had legal there to give the student board members an overview of the Brown Act and one of the things that we did talk about was public comment. When it comes to public comment the rules are very clear and very very brief because it's very simple.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 61
you do not respond to public comment unless, and here's the difference, let's say a parent comes in and they speak um during public comment and they are very angry because their kid got suspended and they feel like nobody's been returning my calls and I need to talk to somebody about this. So, as a last resort, they show up here and they speak as public comment. the board president can say, um, superintendent, can you have a member, um, can you or a member of cabinet, um, take that person outside and get their con their contact information and reach out to them and find out what's going on? You can do that. Um, that is okay. I verified that. What you cannot do is say, "Hey, you know, somebody comes in and they're um they want to uh I don't know, start an AVID program and they're like, "Yeah, you know, I want to start an AVID program at the at the middle school and I think it's great and everybody loves it and everybody wants it and yeah, let's do this." You cannot say, "Yes, I think that's a great idea as well." You know, I think we should also start an AVID program.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 62
You can't do that. That's illegal. That's a violation of the Brown Act >> and I think we violated that that day. >> So yes. So what would you like to say about this so that we can clear the air? H >> how would the board like to handle conflict because this will probably not be the the first or the last. >> I I I think by um I mean you're talking about it now so you're clearing it up. We do have it in writing um before the public participation where the board of education encourages public input. Board members are not permitted to respond to public comments. It's stated right there,000. >> And yes, and yes, I I was present. I do recall the situation and and I did watch the video just to be sure that you know what I heard. But I I as a board member didn't appreciate the conflict between the two board members going back and forth because the board president did ask, you know, we do not talk about and well board member B.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 63
We just kept talking and she kept she kept saying, you know, I want I encouraged the board to consider. So I'm telling her and I'm saying you're ask you're asking me to vote. I'm not telling you to vote right now, but I think you should consider. And I like, no, but I'm taking that. You're telling me to say yes to the person that wants whatever they want. Right. And we're all five of us are sitting here, >> so she's telling us to That's what I took from it. That's what I took from it. And I and I did state it at that moment. Um, but I think it kept going further and got worse. and you know I mean can argue I just walked out cuz they they were arguing or I whatever was said was said and then um you know that that's what I know but that's the first time you know that we have had a complex um this school year and I'm talking about last year to this year you know this school year and um yeah it it wasn't it wasn't a good feeling as a board member because you know we're doing great and that that kind of I was kind of saddened by it actually because we We're doing great.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 64
We >> vote how we vote. We go how we go. We don't. That just situation just kind of triggered >> and I'm like I don't want to I just I'm out, you know. >> So for my clarification, let me ask how much of this took place while you were on the deis versus when you left? >> All of it. >> So all of it was when I was sitting here and it was in public so people were hearing and watching it. Yeah, it is. I'm telling all five of you, a violation of the Brown Act to comment on public comment, unless there's a situation like the one I just said where you just ask the superintendent to get information for somebody when they come in and make these big accusations. Trusty Greer, and then I'll come to you, Trusty Ramos. >> Yes. So, I I want to say speaking of absences, this this was a board meeting that I was absent for.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 65
Um, and so I'm so I wasn't I wasn't here personally. Wasn't here personally. Um, but uh but I did but I did uh go back and I and I and I just this was this was a a meeting that I went back and and watched and and then uh saw some of it. I actually perceived that situation differently than it seemed that the rest of the board did. I actually don't think that there was a that there was a a violation of the Brown Act with in this particular situation. I I also don't think that there was anything wrong with how uh board member Benvitas kind of like h handled the the the situation. I understand why we don't why we don't respond, but to your point, Miss Pride, if someone is coming and advocating for something and Yeah. And if I were to say that's a good idea, let's do that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 66
That's a clear violation. what I as I went back and and looked at it, what I saw happening effectively was um they're being advocating for for something to be agendaized and for something to be discussed in a at a future meeting. And I and I and so where I think there was an appeal to the board and I and I also one don't think it's necessary, but I have seen it happen in other instances. I think there was an appeal to say can we agendaize this? Can can can we can we have this added to an agenda? Um and and it's again important to note that maybe for us as individual board members, we couldn't on in and of ourselves have something added on, but there was if there was a majority of us who were saying we wanted something agendaized, then it could happen.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 67
So I personally um did not think that there was anything wrong with how uh board member Benvitas advocated for something to be agendaized and discussed at a future meeting. So, quick question. On your agenda, do you have a place where you ask for future agenda items? >> During board comments, which was when she made the comment, >> that's when you asked for things that you want to see placed on the agenda. >> And just for clarification, I spoke to Mr. Ortega prior to the meeting and he was okay with it. So, >> just >> I was next, but go ahead. >> Yes, she did. I'm sorry. He started talking. I didn't want to go. >> I'm sorry. >> Go ahead. Finish. Fin finish. >> I just wanted to clarify that. Okay. Trusty Ramos. >> Yes. So, I was here. I wasn't absent. But, um, what I recall from that meeting again, and I'm not going to use the excuse that I'm used, so I was I'm still trying to understand the dynamic, but I do recall that when um, board member Benvita started talking and res, you know, responded to that, it dragged on before the president interfered.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 68
And I think that it was with a sign from Superintendent Ortega. So I think that kind of led it to okay well why didn't I why was it nipped in the bud right away? That that's what I recall from that. And so that might have been part of what made it bigger than it should have been. >> I mean the the conflict should have never been there but my feeling was that um you know it's like someone's running all of a sudden stop right. I mean it wasn't like when she started speaking she was trying to it was like after I think superintendent was like making signs like you know and a couple of us were looking at each other like I was like what's going on here but and then it was brought to her attention and yeah then board member Benvitas continued and that's what kind of drew the conflict but from my recollection that's if if it would have been stopped as soon as board member Benvdas would have made a comment about that particular topic then I think it would have um been resolved that would have been more cut and dry if you will >> and quicker and smoother.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 69
Okay, so we have trusty Rodriguez Pena and then board president. >> So and and again um I I felt as a board member that she's asking me to reconsider, you know, take into consider taking into consideration to you know give the gentleman what he what he was asking for and so forth. So it's like she's asking me to vote yes on and that's another thing. See, again, we never vote. We never voted yet. That was not even in the agenda. Was not agenda, so we should not have anyways. But um I'm feeling that she's telling me to agree with the person to vote. But again, it we talked about it's the way because right when the president said, you know, we do not disc, she kept talking and talking and talking it just stopped right there and then it would went further. That's what happened.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 70
It went further and it went fur and then it went even after the meeting when we left the it kept going. I could hear them arguing but it just kept going. See if they would have snipped it at the butt and then um stopped it immediately because we do not um it says right here that you know respond um that may have just let it go but it just kept going. So one thing before um I let you comment for president, one thing that all of you have to understand because three of you have said in that chair, you have to respect the gavvel. >> Yeah. >> No matter what if if that gavel is hit and is cut off, you cut it off. >> All of you are going to be those of you who haven't been in that chair will be in that chair one day and you will understand why and the importance of it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 71
>> So that's one thing. You have to respect the gavvel board president. >> Um, just as you're saying, respect the gavvel. I I I did not want to be rude to board member Benvitas. I had asked her once. I asked her twice. I asked her three times. I shouldn't have to as a president have to ask one of my board members to reconsider what they're saying at that time. If she wanted to agendaize this in a future meeting, there is there is an email where she can email she can let me know where I can go ahead and put this on the agenda. Absolutely. >> or she can ask during her board conference. >> Absolutely. But that was not the case. one thing is an ask and say you know I would board you know board president um I would like to agend you know I would like to put this on the agenda to discuss this further.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 72
I even said in my comments board member Benvitas can we talk about this at another time. I even suggested to her. Can we please basically like can we talk? We cannot talk about this right now. And one of the things that you just said right now when the gavl I did not want to be disrespectful to her cuz and that's why I I I kind of let her go for a little bit cuz I thought you know what she's going to catch on. She's been here for for three years. She She's not a new board member. She should know this. Apparently, she didn't. And apparently, she took offense when I tried to bring back and redirect the board meeting, which is my job as a board president. Anybody who sits here, if anybody starts going off topic, starts going off in a different way, we have to set the board back into direction.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 73
And at that moment when I had to sit there and ask her three times, I was not trying to be rude. I was trying to bring her back. And I think what really just, you know, broke just everything was at the end where she just stood up, badmouththed me, and stormed out. And I was like, whoa, what just happened? And I looked around and I was like, I that was uncalled for. We're adults here. One of our things that, you know, in our board meeting norms is, right, we disagree agreeably. She may not have agreed with me that the way that I stopped her, I I didn't know how else to stop her other than to hit the gravel and tell her stop. Stop talking. I I I didn't know how else not to be disrespectful, and I wasn't trying to be disrespectful. So with that being said, I I I I think it's important that training does happen, you know, to individuals who are not here on the president's um role prior to coming to be president on this dis because if you don't understand what the president there's so much going on as president, so much you're following this, you're doing this, you're doing this and and we as presidents when we sit here it's important that our board has our back and at that night I did not feel that board member Benvitas had my back on the other hand she did not know that behind story behind that agenda item that she want wanted to to pro you know to to bring forth if she would have had a conversation with me prior to the I could have we could have had a discussion.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 74
We could have said, you know what, let's go ahead, not this meeting, but maybe we can agendaize this next meeting. Absolutely. But because of the lack of communication, another thing that I wanted to bring up was that when we went to go speak at board at at superintendent's um uh office, she said that I blindsided her. You called me right before the meeting and you asked me to be president and you blindsided me. That's the role of a vice president when the president is asking. >> Is this a different topic? >> It it is. But yeah, >> but it happened the same day. But it happened the same day where in the heat of the moment she brings this up where I had no clue that she felt this way where she's telling me that I blindsided her because of the the impact of my job at times um does require that you know it's a life or death where now you know to your answer to the other questions I I've actually I I I work from home now on Tuesdays is to make sure that I am here and because it does become a problem if I'm in the office.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 75
So that that >> can I ask a question? >> Sure. >> Uh number one, have the two of you resolved this? Have you had a conversation about a calm conversation about the policy or the protocol? >> No. No, we haven't after that meeting. >> Okay. So then there's probably I'm making an assumption here. Forgive me if it's wrong, but there's probably still a little tension. >> Absolutely. Yes. >> Which isn't a positive thing for a working environment? >> Absolutely not. My second question would be um has the um has the protocol been explained the Brown Act been explained of the the reason why did anybody explain to you why you couldn't make that statement or that request? First of all, I thought it was I thought it was resolved that night because we went into Superintendent Ortega's office to talk about it. She asked me to talk.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above