2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 76
So, I said no at first and then we went into then I said okay after we reconvened after close session and then we went back in there and we spoke about it and I thought it was resolved. I don't have any bad feelings about it. I know that um with respect to public you know to comment right to get something agendaized I had spoken to Mr. Ortega and he gave me the green light now if there is something where I should talk to the board president I believe there is right I thought that Mr. Ortega would be communicating that and I think from what I recall we spoke about that among all three of us in that meeting. So as far as I know this has been resolved. I don't harbor any feelings about it. I do I do want to point something out for clarification is that and I respect the board president whether it it's this board, city council, any board.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 77
Um but I also feel that as a board president or just as a board member, right, or a professional that um we have to make sure that how we react and how we talk to people, we have to look at our body language and we have to make sure because one of the things that happens is body language says a lot and I don't appreciate when I'm being told versus I'm requesting, can you please, you know, let's let's talk about this. That's not I I don't need a mother on this board. And I made that very clear that night. And I I just don't I'm here because I'm here to do a job. I'm here to honor the board policies. And the minute somebody what happened that day is when we started close session and I'm going to bring this up since we're you know full disclosure here when we had when we were >> be careful you can't close session I'm not disclosing information I'm disclosing body language I saw towards another board member and I thought it's this kind of thing stop right there don't you know I I'm I just thought we have a new board member and it really bothered me that when I saw that being displayed, I thought we need to respect each other and board member Ramos is new and it it just it it just it just bothered me that day.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 78
I don't know if you recall because that's not recorded, but I was like, "Wow." You know, just because of the body language there. And then we come back to our our board meeting in public session and I'm thinking I thought I had cleared it with Mr. Ortega. And so I was confused during the comment when when President um Ariana was making the comments about um stop right there. And I was looking at Mr. Ortega for direction and he had like that what do they call that? the dead the >> dear and sites during that >> and and if I'm wrong please correct me but you know I I was waiting for him because typically and most often people refer to Mr. Ortega for clarification. Right? So that's what I was doing and I didn't I wasn't getting anything in response. So it just kind of continued.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 79
I thought, okay, so what do I do here? But I was requesting it to be agendaized. Board member Gear is correct. >> Okay. Thank you. Um, I want to make sure that we hear from everybody who wants to speak on this without like just hash rehashing this over and over again, but trying to find a resolution to move forward. So, board president really um you had another comment than trustee Rodriguez. >> Go ahead. No, I was just going to say shortly also that um again, I think the situation was out of control because the length of time, but I think that it was maybe misunderstanding. I'm not sure board president board um member Benvitas, you know, because it stopped when I said you're asking for a you that she goes, "Yeah, yeah, that's what I'm asking for." And I Okay, so remember I told her I said that to her.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 80
Um and that's when it stopped. So you're asking for and you she said, "Yes, that's what I I'm asking for." And and that's how we we cleared it, you know, because I maybe maybe I think maybe she wasn't sure how to ask it for for what, right? to be agenda. >> And I think it could have been a misunderstanding, right? He just got out of control. And I think because the the tone, and I'm talking about both of them, okay, I'm going to say this. The tone, the body language, >> I think that kind of got out of control >> on both sides. >> Yeah. Yeah. And and it just kind of just got like that, you know, because I just walked out. I just hear a marving, but I just like and and again, um we never had a situation like that before. And you we usually are very stuck with each other and so forth.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 81
And um I um not just surprised her because that was the only time really and I'm not sure. I know she she had um talked about Mr. Ortega. I'm not sure what their discussion was either. So I'm not sure if she understood what he wanted to say. I don't know. >> Okay. U board president. >> Yeah. I just just to ask for clarification. Um basically uh not once was I rude. if you go back in the video and when we went to close session, I just said, "Hey, would it be okay if we spoke after?" And her response was, "No, I don't have time. I'm leaving right after." Okay. You know, um I I said, "Okay." All I said is, "Okay." Okay. And if I put my hand, it was to say, "Okay." It it was not to shut you up. I just said, "Okay." I I really wanted to handle this in a situation where we are both adults and we're both respectfully speaking to each other.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 82
Um not once was I disrespectful. Okay. I don't know what you saw. I'm I I both >> I I was if you see when when she started when she got up at the end and she was like I'm not you know she started yelling at me. I stayed quiet. Not once did I respond to her. Not once did I say anything to her. I just said, "Okay." And she walked, she was yelling, walking across. Cabinet was here. Everybody was here. And I said, "Oh, sorry. One one absent board member was not here. >> Yes. Um but but just ju and it's not that I want to defend myself. I I take responsibility in what I've done and what I do. I I think I've proven that to the board. But the thing that I'm not okay with and I want to be able to to to say publicly right now is that, you know, um, when board member Benvidita said, "Well, I thought we hashed it out.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 83
I thought we it with the superintendent. I I I have asked her plenty of times, hey, I've text you, hey, you're my vice president. I I can I rely on you?" I can't rely on her. Meaning that at this me this year for myself has been a very very hard year not only in my career but in with my mother. I lost my mother. >> Yes I recall. many times. I did not mean to, you know, however you said that I was, you know, that I came to blindside you. Not once would I ever think about blindsiding any of my colleagues ever. If I ask for help last minute is because I'm drowning and I need help. I need help leading this board. And as vice president, I asked with full humility. And if you couldn't do it, it would be okay cuz guess what?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 84
We have a clerk. And if the clerk couldn't do it, guess what? We have somebody else. But that statement of me blindsiding you, I you know I we have no communication. The the the role of the president and the vice president is to have full com communication. Hey, you know what? Many times I tech you did not text me back. Hey, I'm going to be out. Hey, she superintendent, she's not responding. What do I do? It's been an hour. I'm in a crisis right here at work. I need help. And I I'm I I let her know, you know, the the thing is right here I think is so important is there's a lack of communication and trust. >> So then my question to both of you is how do you repair that? I know board rotations are coming up. um you still have to get through the November meeting and then the beginning of the December meeting as board president.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 85
You have to take that gavl um at the December meeting if you use a rotation process. You use a rotation process. Um so you're going to have to rely on her to tell you, hey, this is you. the two of you are going to have to work together for that December meeting and you should be working together for the November meeting so that you know what your role is and how to take that gavvel come December. Um, so how are the two of you going to get past this in order to be able to work effectively together for the next two meetings? I I would like a public apology since publicly she disrespected me in front of cabinet and in front of the board. >> That's a question you have to pose to her. I cannot make anyone apologize. >> I I would like a public apology.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 86
>> I'm not sure what I did wrong, but my apologies and I hope that makes you feel better. I'm sorry that apology was not accountable. The I'm sorry. Hold on. Let me finish. The fact that you yelled at me after the meeting and the fact that it you're not taking responsibility for that. I'm sorry. >> Are you finished? >> No. >> Okay. I did take responsibility that night with in the meeting with Mr. Ortega. I apologized that night as well. Now, I apologize again. I'm making it public here. >> What are you? >> I don't harbor any ill feelings about this. I thought we had moved on. Uh I I'm kind of at a loss here. So, that's how I feel. I don't I don't harbor any bad feelings. I thought we were working together. Um I already spoke to Mr. Ortega about taking the gavl.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 87
we met. Uh, now I didn't even know until now if there's a if Mr. Ortega would have told me, Sander, you need to speak with Gabby, then I would have done that sooner. If that's the case, if that's the policy and procedure, then I I don't have a problem doing that. As far as I know, I thought I apologized at night when we met after close session. Um, I I I'm just trying I'm at a loss here. I'm trying to figure out how to make it better. I I feel okay. >> Honestly, I think the two of you need to have a conversation offline. I really do. Um board president, you know, I've worked with this board for quite some time and that's always been my advice when the board has had any kind of conflict or turmoil that the best way to resolve it is to have a conversation just between the two individuals or three individuals or whoever was involved to resolve it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 88
And that is the point where I think the two of you are at because understand you do have to work together for the next two meetings to make the transition and you need to be prepared for that and you need to be able to do so effectively and efficiently and you need to do that while respecting one another. So, the two of you need to sit down and have a conversation about how to move forward. If you're not comfortable having that conversation on the own on your own, I would suggest that you talk to Superintendent Ortega to maybe sit in on that conversation um while it happens. But it has to happen because remember um as we move forward like I said you guys have to transition. Um you have to make sure that everything flows well. You're going to need you know guidance on you know what's on the agenda be at the agenda building all of that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 89
So the two of you are going to see each other a lot over these next two months. So it has to be addressed and then apologies have to be accepted and move forward. And I would say that on both sides. I don't know. I will now go back and watch the video so I can see it for myself. Not that it matters, but just to see it for myself. But from what I'm hearing from everyone, um it sounds like there was some misunderstandings and there was some um some work being done to prevent a Brown Act violation and that's important. So, and one of the other things just as a side note is that I would strongly encourage that you participate in one of the board president's workshops because it is a lot. I know that you filled in before. Um, but you're going to be doing it for a year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 90
So, you need to have some work on, you know, these types of situations so you know what can and cannot be done. you want to make sure that you have a clear understanding of the role and not somebody just giving you a gavvel and saying okay leave the meeting. So I would strongly encourage training um as well. But for that did you still want to say something? >> Just real real quick I think like uh what board member Gri mentioned regarding like when is the right time. I think um just a suggestion to the superintendent to highlight because he does put it on there if there's any disagreement you know see me or see the board president so it's not boiling up for a whole year that's what it seems like you it's been a whole year and they thought you know board member Benvita thought it was taken care of and board member Ariana says in fail and you know what I'm saying so it would have cleared the air from this whole year and here we are today you know wasting I'm not wasting >> page page eight your board handbook.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 91
Page eight, item number three. How does a board member request that an item be agendaized on a board meeting? >> Board members should submit a request to the board president and or superintendent to be added to the next feasible board meeting. When can a board member request that something be on a future agenda? Board members may request that an issue be agendaized by making a request to the board president or superintendent prior to a board meeting and or at a board meeting. The item will be placed for discussion at a subsequent um board meeting and staff will prepare an appropriate background. >> And that's exactly what I was doing. Well, and then it's funny because number five says, "What should I do in the event of conflict among governance team members?" >> If at any time there is a concern, you should contact the board president andor superintendent to work on resolving the issue prior to the next board meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 92
>> Right. See, so that I think that should have been done. I mean, this has been five months ago that this situation happened in May. So, so then my recommendation, this is your board handbook, your governance handbook. You need to do number five. >> And one of the things I did when after the meeting, I think it was the next day or I I don't recall, I got to look back at my text message, but I have a text message of that particular policy that board uh policy you just read and I sent it to Mr. Ortega. >> Okay. because it did say or during during a board uh during the meeting during the comment. >> Okay. Um I don't know if board president was okay. Trusty Gr >> I'm recognizing well it well it may not may not be done but but recognizing that we we we have spent a lot of time talking about like what what had happened and there's there's need for offline conversation whether it's the the two or the the three and uh I for I think it was Yolanda who said like from your pers again having not been there from my perspective I saw some intensity on both sides that that that seemed a bit um height heightened and and more so than it than it should have been and then on on from just what I saw and I wasn't here so so just from >> but but being here seeing standing up and so forth which you couldn't see from I'm just saying that so that's what I see >> sure >> so so it's a different view you heard what I seen I heard >> but what I'm and what I'm speaking is is from the perspective of outsiders who are looking in so being somebody who was on the outside looking looking in even without the other details I even saw like what I heard you say is being here you saw some intensity on both sides.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 93
And I'm simply saying having not been here and just looked at what was what was broadcasted, I saw some intensity on on both sides. Uh as as we though look to go forward here, here's I think there's there's two things that I that I that I see. One, um want to just reiterate based off of the policy that you just read or the board protocol that that that you just read. Just because someone comes and and says something from that from from the microphone, it does not mean that no that um once someone says something then no word can be spoken about that thing whatsoever in a meeting otherwise it's it's a violation. If there have been situations where people have come and complained, there's no air conditioner. There's no what's up with the AC's not not working and we've had a line of folks coming and saying things and we have said, "Superintendent, can we can we get an update and or can we add can we have a meeting or can we discuss or can we see what's going on with the air conditioners?" It would be inappropriate for us to weigh in on and and take action.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 94
That would be highly inappropriate. But to but to direct things in such a way where where it's an appeal or a request to to take things uh for for a future board meeting I whether it was in the past or into the future I see absolutely nothing nothing wrong with that where I think there is issue and this is the second piece is when the the person who's chairing the meeting is chairing the meeting and it and and there could have been some mis misunderstanding or miscommunication I would say that in that moment it's best to for for it's best to yield um to the to the board president un unless I mean I don't know something is happening that is so wildly egregious and I don't think that it it it was raised to that point maybe a bit intense but it wasn't raised to the point I I think that that an appropriate response would be to to yield and then to take take this up after the fact or or to bring clarity and so where I do think that there there was some things became became unnecessarily heightened was at the point when the board president asked for it to stop.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-22 Los Angeles County, CA YouTube / Azusa Unified School District transcript source: youtube 10/21/2025 - Azusa Unified School District Board Governance … · passage 95
I think that there was some might have been some misunderstanding of what was going on, but to then belabor that and kind of take take that out back and forth, it it it makes it larger than it needs to as opposed to saying I don't think you understand me or I think there's another side of this that you're not seeing, but I'm not going to hash this out right here publicly in front of everyone. So, I'm so I'm therefore going to going to yield and then and we need to have a a larger conversation about this in the future. Thank you and thank you for the perspective of somebody who wasn't present that watched and saw what was happening. That's much appreciated. Um, so to move forward, trustee, every time someone says something, if something triggers me, I'm sorry, but you know, but I think there's a difference.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above