>> Well, keep in mind that there may be something that comes up at the board meeting that then somebody says, "Hey, I would like to see us discuss this on the agenda." So everybody still has their right during public during their board comments to request that something be put on the agenda at the meeting or to in advance or you know outside of the meeting to communicate that with the board president andor superintendent. >> That's what I'm I'm I'm I'm referring to. Not not here. Of course here we we have public comment and we have that that um that freedom to go ahead and do that as board members. But I'm saying if the board um if a board member contacts the superintendent, if we could have the superintendent communicate with whoever is here on the das as president so they are also not blindsided.
Um >> yeah, so that's not an issue, right? Or I mean for you to be able to do that. >> So I'm sorry. I'm sorry to interrupt, but I've been having my hand. >> I'm sorry. I didn't I didn't see your little hand. higher. >> There she is again. Okay. So, so what I want to say, I'm not sure if you're on 23 or you're on 24, but on 23 um agenda items, we have a protocol. And again, superintendent does post that. >> Number 23, >> he does post that. >> Number 23 doesn't say agenda items. It says I know I know what you said. Yeah, >> I keep forgetting. So, um that being said, there is a protocol already set. The superintendent does ask us when under our board um on on our weekly board packet, you know, he puts u protocols what we we need more.
I don't know. We all read them and I'm I'm going to say this. I haven't told the superintendent I don't think they the board members read them. I I may be wrong because sometimes they're asking the same questions that he just wrote. I I hear that. And uh the same thing with the community, it says right there in black and white, >> right? >> You need to contact and and that's exactly what we do. And um on the agenda items, if Mr. Ram board member Ramos goes to superintendent and I am sure when you I was board president before when you go over the agenda, I'm sure he's going to tell whoever the president is, you know, board member Ramos has asked for this to be placed on the agenda, you know. So the vice president is gonna know because you're setting the agenda, >> Right.
Exactly. Yeah. But I think that this was this I think that this and superintendent feel free to jump in. I think that this was an offline conversation that took place >> um pri right prior to the board me meeting. I'm not sure how far in advance uh but prior to the board meeting an offline conversation about hey you know I I I'm hearing this in the community and I want to bring this up and you know if somebody's asking to put something on the agenda and I'm the superintendent I'm going to take the request but if it's the night of a board meeting or the day before board meeting I'm also going to tell them you also have the right to you know during your public comments put it on mayor and feel free to jump in at any point. >> Sure. Um I think the distinction here is and again uh I will beg Vice President Benabius to make sure we're on the same page on this.
The request was not Aruro, can you please put this on the agenda? That was not the request. The request was Aruro, how do I request this to be on the board agenda? And just like our protocols that were read right now by by um Miss Miss Angelina Pride, I said there's a section that's called board member comments, reports, and request. And at that time, you can request that this item be placed on an agenda item. So the request to me was not can you please put this on on the agenda. The request was how do I ask or request for this to be on on the agenda? And so I I I I I said per this one way you can do this is during your board member comments reports and request you can request an agenda item be placed uh on the agenda and then it would be up to the president at that point in time to react or say whatever the board president wants to do.
But that would be her that's up to her at that point in time. >> So we're clear. Trustee Gre. Well, yeah. And so that and that I think is the crux of of where where some of this happened because the I will say for example I am I am oftentimes impressed uh board member Rodriguez Fia by your level of preparation when it comes to the your your comments that you make every every uh board meeting. Really you you you take the time to to think it out to write it write it out and have your you've already pre thought out and determined and word for word like and so I'm I'm impressed. Uh, with that being said, if you if you Right. Right. If you took the time if you took the time to do that to write out a request that you had already determined that you wanted to make and let's let's imagine that you weren't because we you are the the the the veteran expert that you are.
But let's imagine for a moment you weren't. And so because of that in the midst of confusion, you were to reach out to board member uh to superintendent Tega on on just hey clarity. If I were to wanting to request, can I do it this way? if he were to confirm and say yes, you can make that request through that through that way. If you had already predetermined to make that request on a particular issue and then if it just so happened that the person who uh came to make a comment that day, just because that person came and made a comment doesn't mean that you can now not make a request. It's it wouldn't be the case that just because this person showed up, if you had already predetermined to to make a particular request, you wouldn't need to say, "Well, now because this person spoke on something, I'm now I now need to cross this item off because otherwise it's a violation of the of the Brown Act." Now, maybe you would say, "Let me wait and not ask because I don't want it to appear as though I'm responding to this person." And that could be discretion and wisdom.
But just because you are saying something that someone else said doesn't necessarily mean that there was some plan or or or coordination. That was how I perceived this the situation was that there was count and there and uh Mr. P you even said during the thing at some point you can look to the superintendent and it was a while ago that I watched but I do believe at some point in the meeting um board member Benvitz did say Mr. Ortega can you please help and clarify here and and then you said yes you can make you know make make a request. So that's where I'm saying I think that there was some where there was confusion is I perce as an outsider I perceived a board member requesting that an item be um placed on a future agenda and there and there is no problem with doing that um at a that not only is there no problem with doing that that is the appropriate place and the appropriate one of there are there are a few appropriate places and and and channels and so for you what I would be nervous about with agreeing and using this as president to the position that puts you in is then as soon as someone asks you a question about how do I hypothetically add something is there now pressure on you that to say to whoever's in the board presidency hey I think that board member Rodriguez Pñena might be thinking about adding a particular item and then she does or doesn't we have the ability uh when she made a request where it's the board president or the uh superintendent that happened during during the meeting in real time where both it was an and where both were were were formally asked about adding something to to the agenda >> for for clarification for what you're saying.
You're saying that if they ask it ask bring up something during public comments, then when you do board comments, you can request that it's on the agenda. >> What I'm what I'm saying is if I came in today and I wanted to I wanted to discuss uh what are we doing with surplus with with um uh bond funds. If I have already predetermined coming in that I want to make a request about bond funds and then someone else not no court if someone else comes up and decides to make a comment and says >> I think that there I'm I'm curious what's going on with in the in our community and why are our schools not this or that >> it I I if if now moving forward I am already predetermined that I'm going to make a board request about bond funds that I'm not responding to this person >> but you're still going to follow protocol and do it at the appropriate time >> which is during board meeting comments and requests dur in in public meeting.
>> It says here during your >> Where was it? I just read it to you guys. >> Questions, comments, and requests. >> Yeah. I said a board member should approvise and board members should request something beyond future request by making request to board president or at the board meeting. Actually, it's not specific. The item will be placed for discussion at the subsequent board. It just says board members I thought it said during public during the board comments, but it says board members may request that an issue be agendaized by making a request to the board president or superintendent prior to a board meeting and or at a board meeting. It does not say during public com um during board comments. >> I think everyone interprets it. >> Yeah. That it should be done during board comments. That's what I just want to make sure is that it's done during board comments.
I think we need to add that into here >> and that's what happened at the meeting. >> Yes, I agree with you. Yes, absolutely. Trustee Rder. >> Yes. I'm trying to defend myself against board member Greer. Um what I would like to say is very true. I mean yes you do. Um that is a time I think it was for board member Benabutus was the way she asked. She didn't say I would like to place it. You can see the video on the board agenda AB or C. She said I'd like you to consider or reconsider board that we should A B or C. you know, so she's asking not to agendaize it. She didn't ever say use the word agenda in the conversation. >> So, it was more like >> Yeah, I kind of like to tell me telling me, right? And then I kind of said, I think what you're asking and then I said, you know, um, you want to and then she said, yeah, that that's what I'm asking.
Okay. So, we cleared it. But I think it was just the way it was again. And and you know, I mean, we're all learning. I mean, I'm not That's what I was getting ready to say. >> I I am a veteran. True. But I was new once and I'm sure I probably did the same thing. I sat my first meeting like >> what am I doing here? I I don't know what about you learn as you go on. It's it's not >> right >> a bad thing. >> So, we've talked about this a lot. So, you understand the protocol now for putting something on the agenda. And I know that you did talk to Superintendent Ortega in advance of the meeting, which is one of the ways to put something on the agenda. He told you to bring it up and then some like Trusty Gre said somebody happened to come in and talk about it so you brought it up.
So we're all understanding that it that you can only place something on the board request that something be placed on a future agenda during your board comments. We're clear on that. >> Yeah. I want to make sure we're clear because I want I don't want anybody to leave this meeting and then come back next month and try to put something on on the agenda. So is there but is you say there's not clarity. >> I I'll I'll wait. There's another >> Okay. Yeah. I I think there is clarity that we can go to the board uh to the board president or the superintendent prior to a board meeting. Right. I think there's clarity that we hear during our board comments can actually say superintendent I would like to request the such and such to be agendaized >> absolutely >> but but there's a but you know what so and so saying you know so and so saying is absolutely true number one we're addressing the commenter >> right you can't do that >> you cannot do that >> right Second, I would like to encourage all my colleagues, >> you can't do that.
>> You cannot do that. >> But that's not a request to put something on the board. That's that's just saying, "Hey, everybody." >> Correct. And that's a violation of the Brown Act. I don't think that we're negating that any one of us >> can ask and request some, you know, to put something on the agenda. Absolutely. >> Absolutely doable. Right. I think we're all in agreeance in that. Correct. and we now know how to it's the it's the little things where we add more to it and more to it and more to it that it becomes a problem. >> So in line with this conversation, can I take us to number 25 where the board agrees on the role of the board president and managing the board meetings? >> Oh prior to get this one based on the prior one, this one should be blue.
>> Okay. And again, my apologies. I know I keep saying it, but we had to do this one by hand. So, um, so your board bylaw 9121 outlines the responsibilities for the board president. Um, and again, and I'm not saying this just because I'm a representative of CSBA, but anybody who's sitting in that board seat for the very that board president seat for the very first time, you strongly are incly encouraged to take training prior to >> it. Is not just as easy as it seems when you're watching somebody else do it. And maybe even then it doesn't seem easy, but you'll hear other people bring up questions, comments, things that will help it help you and guide you. Um, for the when it's your turn to sit in that seat. So to the two new trustees who have never sat in that seat, I would recommend that you take board president training and don't just assume that, hey, I got this.
Um, your superintendent will definitely be there to guide you. your seasoned trustees will be there to support you, but it's also very good to have hear the whole spill and the whole perspective and to learn the ins and outs and how to handle certain situations. So, again, strongly encouraged. >> I I have a question on that. Um Yes, ma'am. >> Are the board president workshops ju uh just at CSBA? No, we Well, that's the first one. Um because that's usually when most board pro um boards are transitioning. So, we do one definitely then. I don't I haven't looked at the schedule yet in a while, but you might want to pull it up while we're talking about the other things, but they usually do try to do one in January as well. Um, I know they try to do one or two dependent upon interest after AEC.
So, M A, you know, is our annual education conference. I'm just assuming everybody knows what that means. So, it's the CSBA annual education conference. That's when they have it. That one is just I like that one a lot just because there's so many people from up and down the state that are in that one where you get to hear a lot of insight about things that could happen and you know situations. So >> are they doing one in Sacramento in December? >> Is that there's one at AC but I don't know if it's sold out or not. >> February 4. >> Okay. So, if you missed that, if you can't get into that one in Sacramento, then February 4th would be the next one. But by then, you've already had to chair two meetings, and I just encourage you to get it as quickly as possible.
So, okay. Can we move on? >> Yes. >> Trusty Ramos, you're becoming one of my favorite. Okay. Um, well, this page is looking pretty good, so this one should go pretty fast. Um, board members come to meetings prepared. Do you agree that all of you are prepared when you arrive at the board meeting? Is there anyone who feels like one of their colleagues or themselves is not prepared when they come to the board meeting? >> I I may have been the the less often. See, the only because I just make that last comment because sometimes I'll hear some of my colleagues ask a question that's already I've seen or I've read. So, I'm not sure. I mean, maybe they didn't read it or you did they read it? Did they have time to read it? So, I may have wrote that um thinking that what I just mentioned that I I I hear a a lot people asking the same thing that's already here, >> right?
That's already been >> been uh Yes. So I do and I'm like didn't didn't they just read that? I thought he put that on there, you know, and I I do hear that >> quite often. >> Yeah. And that would that would be a red flag. But also remember there's people like me who are old and then we may for have forgotten. >> So you may want to give a little bit of grace. >> I get it. and board president. >> Um I I would like to also say perhaps sometimes not that the board member is not prepared. Um maybe perhaps the board member wants the community to know, you know, u and that's why they ask the question that >> that's encouraged. Absolutely. And thank you for bringing that up that we're board members are encouraged to ask questions so that the public hears it whether you've asked the question in advance or not.
There were still things that I always asked at the meeting so the public could hear that response as well. Yes. >> But you know when I'm going to ask a question I tell I I I speak to superintendent so he is prepared or if this goes to our CBO or curriculum. So you know I don't say I don't know or let me look into it. So I do let him know I'm going to ask about this or I'm going to pull this >> so he knows prior and they were also prepared. You know it's not none of these surprise. No surprise. >> And that's what I always tell people, a surprise. And there's still questions that come up that you didn't think to ask in advance. That's But if you know you're going to ask something in advance, it's nice to give the superintendent a heads up because if somebody in the community asked you that question and you only get the answer and you don't see them for another three months, they don't get that answer to that question.