>> Anybody else have any questions or comments? >> I was just going to say I appreciate the paired down sort of clear um layout of this. I think it's really easy to see uh where each everything aligns. So, thank you for that. >> All right. Well, then if there's no other comments, uh we'll move on. We don't have any old business. Um, up next is public comment. I I saw you looking for the sheets. There's There's only two members of the public here. I'm just going to sort of ask forward members if anybody wants to make a public comment. Are you guys would you guys be okay with that? >> Yeah. >> Okay. Do does anybody from the public want to speak? >> You're good. All right. Well, then we'll move on to three main points. Yes. So I have the three main points as the superintendent search update, the student achievement report and the school implement improvement plans.
I'm just looking at it when I had a similar reaction, but it was just like, >> well, I don't think it means that everybody's income went up like that. Uh, and I'm concerned with and it's just going to be one data point. I get it. So, I'm we're not going to hang our hat on that, but I just can see how someone can can read when when we say that as in like, hold on a second, my income hasn't gone up 15% in that time frame. >> Well, it's interesting. Actually, the income in Ashland has gone up 51%. But not every individual person not you're always going to find you're always going to find that's what the average is. >> So I would So just to piggyback on what Paul said I think the the underlying message of that says well then you can afford to pay more and we don't want to that's not the message that we're that's not the message that we would deliver.
>> Yeah, I think I think that's it. >> Okay, great. >> All right. So then upcoming events. Okay. Um CLASS ongoing from now until the 24th is the book fair. The 22nd, 23rd, and 24th are parent teacher conferences, and both all of those days are early dismissal for CLES. Uh now through October 31st is the Candlewood craze, which is the PTO fall fundraiser. Um the 31st is the Candlewood craze event if the goals are met. So, uh parents are encouraged to set up a profile for their child and help meet the fundraising goals for the school. Um 10:30 is October 30th is the pause assembly and cubs club meeting and November 3rd is the kindergarten field trip to the Ridgefield Playhouse. For Wiskier, November 3rd through 7th is the Scholastic Bookf Fair. November 5th and 6th are parent teacher conferences and so those are half days for WMS students.
The message that we would deliver is, you know, this is what it's going to cost for us to have level service >> and keep the quality of life in Ashland, >> you know, and then kind of work the numbers if we have, you know, number whatever numbers we but but I but I kind of I kind of have a little bit of the same kind of cringey thing because >> that to me is like, well, Ashlin's dead center, so you guys can afford to pay more and I don't want to message them. >> Yeah. I mean I mean the way people interpret it is the way people interpret it. I think you know I think ultimately like the question is is what kind of quality of life do you want? >> What I take from this >> we should focus on that's >> but this is what I take from this actually is >> to your point I don't think we should be focusing on the growth of income of Ashland.
Um they're also the BHS parent teacher conferences. So they're also half days for BHS. Thursday, November 13th is the student the uh Whiskanir student showcase. 6:00 to 8:00 PM here at the BHS auditorium. And then for Brookfield High School, Sunday, October 26th is uh 3 p.m. is the Booster Club's Harlem Wizards basketball event. Um tickets are on sale now online. Wednesday, November 5th and 6th, parent teacher conferences, half day for students. And November 10th is the NHS blood drive. Districtwide dates to note that are off for students. November 4th, which is also election day. November 27th and 28th, which is Thanksgiving, and the Friday after. Um November 26th, which is the Wednesday, is a half day for all students. Okay. Thank you. All right. Well, um then that is the end of our agenda. So, without objection, we will adjourn at 9:18.
It's our efficiency as a town. >> And so I think you can use these numbers to sell not sell to give that message. It's a different message and it's not about the income. I mean, you need a ratio to look at, but that should be the point of this metric, >> you know, is it our income, you know, the median or, you know, the full average. That's a different conversation. And it does of course mean well, you can pay for it. That's not what we're trying to that's not what this should say. I think it's the efficiency, right? >> Which can only last if we keep up with costs. So, I think you have to like massage these the numbers are great. just the way we message them. >> Yeah. >> Some of these things are hard to communicate to the voter >> because the first thing is you look at is oh just I I just want to say the reason this is in here is because I was asked before when I would put up like the single family tax bill.
Well, what if our income's right and I didn't mean I didn't mean to throw a monkey. You're you're you're I think you're doing exactly what she's talking about is the what you're trying to convey is efficiency and value, right? Um, and when I I'm just I'm just communicating as we look forward to how we communicate these things. And this is just a data point. >> I looked at it and I'm like I I had that moment of like I can see someone who was resistant to the conversation >> looking at that data point and how we might say say things. And I just highlighted as those are the things that we need to be careful of because we can do 99 things really well and the but the person that we need to reach is the one that's going to latch on to the one that resonates poorly with them, >> right?
>> And so we just need to be really really almost more mindful of those pitfalls to not step in as few of those as we can. And that's a good point. And I think I think Paul, you also kind of unearthed a little bit of something else there, which is if you want to find a reason to not vote for something or to vote for something, you're going to find it. >> You can take any of these numbers and kind of come up with an argument against it. >> But I think to Paul's point, I think in in terms of the it's the messaging of it, not the numbers itself. But I think we also have to be very mindful of how, you know, if we're moving forward and asking the community for an override, a huge chunk of this conversation is going to happen by people who have small snippets of information on social media.
>> Exactly. >> And this, I think, is something that can be taken very much out of context and remesaged if we're not very careful in terms of how the data is shared. And so I think that I to your point in terms of the message of it, I think we need to be super mindful of how we share the numbers, what they mean, how it's how these things are explained in a way that people can understand because this is really confusing, frankly, like a reading through some of this. >> So I'm not doing a great job. >> No, you're you're doing a great job. >> I'm not clarifying, >> but you're talking to a room full of people who have a baseline of understanding of what these are and it's still confusing, right? So, kind of thinking through ways to really simplify the message of what do these numbers mean?
Um, and and why are they important to understand as part of the conversation because I think >> that's fair. >> All of this is going to be taken wildly out of context in snippets on social media because that's just what happens now. >> No, Tina. >> And it it can really muddy the waters. Yeah, >> you're you're right. and actually you know hold that thought the simplicity of the message and and I'll come back to that because I think we can learn a lot from some of our previous attempts but uh Shantel again we did not communicate beforehand but this your efficiency comment leads us right to the best overall metric that we can use for overall efficiency which is the um expenditures per capita. So just like you know the per pupil expenditure you know you look at how much money a school district spends on its school system and you divide that by the number of students that it serves.
You basically take the municipal or not just the general fund but the entire budget and divide it by the capita per cap or the number of people and you get a per capita expenditure number. So very similar to the uh per pupil expenditure. And then I also added on the enterprise funds that you see there in orange just because I know you know some of our fees are higher than than the average like our sewer fee. Water fee is is is reasonable uh very reasonable but our sewer is extremely high. And so I wanted to you know try to get as much of a big picture here as we could. And so that combined expenditure per capita again we always rank towards the bottom if not the bottom. We're we're here second from the bottom. You know, when you look at the 18 communities, um Upton, Upton is a unique community going through a lot of changes right now.
Um but, um you know, this just shows there has been minimal investment in the community in terms of general operations. Um >> okay, so this this has not that does not have the debt exclusion numbers. Um no enterprise fund extend. >> I believe it does because I believe this takes our whole budget and and divides it by the number of people and so that would include the debt the um debt service numbers. So Yolanda just take the expenses line on that on the budget the total budget and divide it by the by the uh people. >> Okay. So you're saying these this what we're seeing here for Ashton and all these other communities includes debt service for all these communities as well as for us. >> Correct. >> Yeah. And and this is just a general comment I was going to have for everyone but you and Jim as we present these things.
I would always encourage us to be putting the data sources and links to the data sources at the bottom of these things. So it's not just trust us. Here's the thing. Or if somebody wants to look at it, um, somebody has that question, right? We can't >> we can't spell it out in every single with every single lens. So, uh, you know, Jim and you and and anybody that's going to be putting out something, let's just be really super transparent and have a link to the cherry sheet or whatever it is and maybe a little snippet of we pulled this and you know, just how we how we because we're trying to make it simple, but you want people to be able to say, "Hey, I have more questions about it or I'm not just going to trust you, Michael. What is it? How does how do I do this?" And yeah, so just for whenever we're putting these things together, let's let's start to try to do that because that'll be part of our messaging and part of our transparency and trust, right?
I think we've built up a lot of trust over over the last decade or so. Um and I think that would just help in the conversations going forward. >> Yeah, that's that's a good point. And um I'll just say, you know, the comparative the comparative data comes from the Massachusetts Department of Revenue. Um so yeah, we should include that uh moving forward. Um, I can tell you if you just look at our tax, you know, if you took a $100, right, and you said, "Okay, let's break it down and figure out, you know, how much of a $100 goes to, you know, our departments." You know, nothing here is really out of the ordinary, folks. Um, you know, $55 going to education that includes Keith Tech and the Ashlin Public Schools. That's generally that's generally normal. um you know where we really really get hurt I think sometimes is that benefits and insurance number um and I'll I'll get a little bit more into that um uh one of so what what's driving a lot of this deficit is our fixed costs I think Marcy you mentioned fixed costs earlier health insurance you know when we joined the GIC uh back in like 2015 2014 14 2015 we saved a lot of money at the beginning.
So we saw an immediate savings and then you know we started seeing less of an increase than our uh our previous health insurance group the west suburban health group and so the GIC became very very attractive to other communities and guess what happens then they start joining them joining the GIC and so that starts pushing up costs and pushing up costs and so I think our the in FY26 we saw an increase of it was over 10% I believe and that's combined with I believe it was about a 10% increase the previous year. Uh there's several different reasons. Believe it or not, the one of the biggest drivers are the GL GP1 drugs. You know, those are driving up a lot of the cost. And so the GIC is looking at ways to kind of limit that moving forward, but we're still planning on um we're still planning on um you know, the the projections you know that that we have with it with it going up a continued 10%.
um pension obligations are expected to increase and that could actually go up higher uh than than what we have anticipated. We're basing it on previous uh you know previous years and the growth over previous years. But there's two factors that go into the pension assessment. Number one, it's who are our pensioners and people are living longer and people's salaries have have naturally grown over time and so that number is higher, right? And then there's a catchup provision. So we're required to be fully our pension system, the Middle Sex County retirement system is required to be fully funded, I believe, by 2042. Middle Sex County has decided they would be fully funded by 2038. So there's a catchup amount included in our regular assessment. So those are the big drivers because, you know, if you look at a health insurance budget of 7 million, you know, you start looking at 10% on top of that.
Well, I mean that's 700K just right there. Um, so it can be pretty pretty significant. >> So, and Michael, just for transparency on your previous slide when you had the dollar that $55 did not include the health uh the health and stuff like that. That's that's part the biggest part of that uh component are the school employees. So, just to be clear on on that proportion, it's not like, hey, that $55 is not all-encompassing of that cost. And the other one is it's I I know no one in this room is saying municipal and school, but just as as that lays out, it's not 55 isn't all in encompassing. The the overwhelming majority of the health care is uh we have the obviously the most employees. So, >> right, it's a good point. Um, I won't go through all of this just in the interest of time, but um, I can tell you I met with our fire department today.
You know, we have grown their staff over the years, but it really hasn't grown in the last five or six. And they're looking at some of these building projects and they're like, "Wait, you're looking at population increasing more, you know, more calls, same amount of people. Now you're also talking about big buildings. We've got, you know, we've got six firefighters that are scheduled to be on a shift. Sometimes they drop down to five. not a not a good not a good ratio when you see you know some some buildings you know go up in flames and and you know you know you've only got that many people kind of running in now granted we have mutual aid coming in but it takes a little while for them to get here and you know public safety DPW those are kind of easy to point out right you know those are easy to kind of make the case for you know we need to look at our administrative staff which hasn't grown like we need more in our finance Um, you know, there's a lot more requests for information.
There's a lot more information desired to help make decisions. Um, that's important. Transparency is important. Um, so we need that. We need, if we want to look at long-term planning, we need to hire additional planning staff. You know, we need to look at pro if you want to look at more projects, etc. We need to hire more administrative staff as well. So that's kind of the whole situation. And so what are we, you know, what how do we get out of this mess, right? H how do we how do we make a change? How do we change the trajectory? Um we could cut or freeze, right? I already have our department's looking at a 5% reduction for 2027. They're doing two budgets right now. As Claudia can tell you, I got a fire chief who's panicked. He's he's going around squeezing squeezy toys, telling he wants to cut my budget 5%.
You know, it's it's you I talked to Douggee Small today, you know, at DPW. 5% that cuts out virtually everything out of salaries and a bit of salaries as well, you know, but that's the number that we would have to hit to basically shave off our portion of that deficit. Um or we can increase funding for services, look at a levy increase um and invest in new projects potentially, you know, depending on on the amount of that increase. Again, it all comes to but there's no magic bullets, folks. We've moved to the I'll get into this a little bit more, but you know, we have made some really really strong reductions in costs. Um as I've shown you previously, we've looked at other sources of revenue. We use other sources of revenue significantly. Like I said, 20% 20% of our general general government budget comes out of grants, revolving funds, and other resources.