2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 97
>> Yeah. How I mean the way people interpret it is the way people interpret it. I think you know I think ultimately like the question is is what kind of quality of life do you want? >> What I take from this we should focus on that's what I take from this actually is >> to your point I don't think we should be focusing on the growth of income of Ashland. It's our efficiency as a town. >> And so I think you can use these numbers to sell not sell to give that message. It's a different message and it's not about the income. I mean, you need a ratio to look at, but that should be the point of this metric. >> You know, it's a our income, you know, the median or, you know, the full average. That's a different conversation. And it does, of course, mean well, you can pay for it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 97
Thank you. Hi, I'm David Ivancho. I was the representative for the third precinct. And when I started this, I was pretty new in town. I was maybe two years and now two years more, four four years in town. It was a great way to learn a lot about the town, all the various committees, all the people. um big committee but um I think for me the most interesting thing was sitting down with all the subject matter experts that we got to talk to during the middle of the process when we're talking about all the various strategies and getting feedback on them and one of the things I would hope that when we get into the implementation of this is that those people live here in town those are our experts that we bring them in and that you know they can be part of those successful strategies that we go forward with.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 98
That's not what we're trying to that's not what this should say. I think it's the efficiency, right? >> Which can only last if we keep up with costs. So, I think you have to like massage these. The numbers are great. just the way we message them. >> Yeah. >> Some of these things are hard to communicate to the voter >> because the first thing is you look at, oh, we just I I just want to say the reason this is in here is because I was asked before when I would put up like the single family tax bill. Well, what if our income's right? >> I didn't mean to I didn't mean to throw a monkey. You're you're you're I think you're doing exactly what she's talking about is the what you're trying to convey is efficiency and value, right? Um, and when I'm just I'm just communicating as we look forward to how we communicate these things.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 98
So just making sure that you know we have the expertise here in town to get this to get this done. >> Thank you. >> Anyone else in the room or online? >> That is optional. >> Rajri Kosh um 11 Edward Drive. Um I echo everybody's sentiments especially members of uh the comprehensive plan. It was a large committee and um I just remember how we began with such a lot of contentious uh arguments and threats to resign and um lots of drama. It could be a well a well-written novella um and someday that has to be documented and made into a film because it'll make a good one. Um but um each and every member brought in so much talent and so much expertise um that that is reflected in the document that has been made. Um each one of us um deals with different constituents.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 99
And this is just data point. >> I looked at it and I'm like I I had that moment of like oh I can see someone who is resistant to the conversation >> looking at that data point and how we might say say things. And I just highlighted as those are the things that we need to be careful of because we can do 99 things really well and the but the person that we need to reach is the one that's going to latch on to the one that resonates poorly with them, >> right? >> And so we just need to be really really almost more mindful of those pitfalls to not step in as few of those as we can. And that's a good point. And I think I think Paul, you also kind of unearthed a little bit of something else there, which is if you want to find a reason >> to not vote for something or to vote for something, you're going to find it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 99
Um we do meet people in in the community. We build community. But it was through the expertise of our consultant that we got these tools like a meeting in a box which I never knew something like that existed because I've been in programs, I've been in research um institutes. What we do is focus group discussions but this is called MIAB and we got to learn about it. Um so some of those tools are very useful and we will take them forward. I know we will give you the thanks. You have the patent rights to it, Jen and Austin. But um those are very useful key um tools to uh engage with the public. some of the strategy discussions or even the technical working sessions um we had expertise from within the community and I think some of them don't get um get named often but I hope that in some ways they are recognized and acknowledged because everybody's contributions came into what the document is um there are lots of photographs and there are no names of it I can mention a few of them but um each one of them contributed to um our engagement uh the massive engagement that we had.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 100
>> You can take any of these numbers and kind of come up with an argument against it. >> But I think to Paul's point, I think in in terms of the it's the messaging of it, not the numbers itself. But I think we also have to be very mindful of how, you know, if we're moving forward and asking the community for an override, a huge chunk of this conversation is going to happen by people who have small snippets of information on social media. >> Exactly. >> And this, I think, is something that can be taken very much out of context and remesaged if we're not very careful in terms of how the data is shared. And so I think that it to your point in terms of the message of it, I think we need to be super mindful of how we share the numbers, what they mean, how it's how these things are explained in a way that people can understand because this is really confusing, frankly, like a reading through some of this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 100
We exceeded our limits and I could never uh imagine that we would do that. So that's something I'm still dancing about um and and celebrating. Um so I'm looking forward to this plan moving forward and the implementation committee or coordination implementation coordination committee taking this forward um to the best and you know following through to the best of their abilities. I know several factors come into the being but then you know we're using this as um a flexible um living document and I think that's the best part um in how we're approaching this plan. Thank you. >> Thank you and thank you for your leadership on this. >> Oh sorry um Hassini. >> Hi Hassini ready. Um, I'm the high school representative and I just want to say that I really like like how the committee allowed for members to participate in like various and distinct ways like I was able to reach some uh residents and kids my age through social media.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 101
>> So I'm not doing a great job. >> No, you're you're doing a great job. >> I'm not clarifying, >> but you're talking to a room full of people who have a baseline of understanding of what these are and it's still confusing, right? So kind of thinking through ways to really simplify the message of what do these numbers mean? Um and and why are they important to understand as part of the conversation because I think >> that's fair >> all of this is going to be taken wildly out of context in snippets on social media because that's just what happens now. >> No, you know >> and it it can really muddy the waters. Yeah, >> you're you're right. and actually you know hold that thought the simplicity of the message and and I'll come back to that because I think we can learn a lot from some of our previous attempts but uh Shantel again we did not communicate beforehand but this your efficiency comment leads us right to the best overall metric that we can use for overall efficiency which is the um expenditures per capita.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 101
Um, and also I'm just really thankful that I got to see students participating in some of our like public outre outreach tactics like the surveys at Ashlin Day and the farmers market. Um, and essentially I'm just excited that I got to be a change maker in the future of this town that I'm gonna grow up in and educate students my age about how their future is going to look like 10 years. >> Thank you. >> Great. >> Trisha, could I just say something? >> Hassini designed our logo, the Envision Ashland logo, um, and was great with our social media. And so it was so good to have and she and honestly she um she was very vocal in our meetings which isn't the easiest thing to do in a group of 29 um 28 adults. Um and I'm and Hassini I just got to tell you um you're going to go far my friend.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 102
So just like you know the per pupil expenditure you know you look at how much money a school district spends on its school system and you divide that by the number of students that it serves. You basically take the municipal or not just the general fund but the entire budget and divide it by the capita per cap or the number of people and you get a per capita expenditure number. So very similar to the uh per pupil expenditure. And then I also added on the enterprise funds that you see there in orange just because I know, you know, some of our fees are higher than than the average like our sewer fee, water fee is is is reasonable, uh very reasonable, but our sewer is extremely high. And so I wanted to, you know, try to get as much of a big picture here as we could.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 102
She's a graduating senior this year and I'm so proud of her and I'm so glad that she was a part of this and I'm so glad we got this done before you graduated. Thank you so much. >> Thanks, Hassini. >> Trisha, I think there there was Are we missing anybody? >> Carl, did you want to >> Looks like he has his hand up. Um, >> okay. >> And I was say Carl in this room also was a member. I don't know if he wants to say something. >> All right. Mark Done. >> Thank you. Mark Don 19 Main Street. I've been watching this at home where I am. And I I was debating do I want to come on or let everybody else speak or do I just want to sit down listen here I am. I would like to thank everybody on the board that is the comprehended plan steering committee.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 103
And so that combined expenditure per capita, again, we always rank towards the bottom, if not the bottom. We're we're here second from the bottom. You know, when you look at the 18 communities, um Upton Upton is a unique community going through a lot of changes right now. Um but um you know, this just shows there has been minimal investment in the community in terms of general operations. Um >> okay, so this this has not that does not have the debt exclusion numbers. general enterprise fund extend. >> I believe it does because I believe this takes our whole budget and and divides it by the number of people and so that would include the debt the um debt service numbers. So Yolanda just take the expenses line on that on the budget the total budget and divide it by the by the uh people. >> Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 103
But I also want to give a special compliments and gratitude to Miss Jan Gman. We learn we have known we got to know each other and without without her I probably would have never stepped into the ring of the tech the tech strategies and the steering committee meetings and stuff like that. or come up in between different boards to say what I thought of this comp plan and what they're going to be doing to the town itself. Jen gave me that inner confidence to get up there and we we know each other. So, I'm saying thank you to to Jen. Now, I'm going to go and thank another person that's in with the select board with the who did the forums, Yolanda Greaves, who I I did use the forums to get my ideas across and get opinions. and she left me have the time of that most people would want to give me and was listening and and learning me to be a two-way street um person to understand what each of the goals were.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 104
So you're saying these this what we're seeing here for Ashland and all these other communities includes debt service for all these communities as well as for us. >> Correct. >> Yeah. And and this is just a general comment I was going to have for everyone but you and Jim as we present these things. I would always encourage us to be putting the data sources and links to the data sources at the bottom of these things. So it's not just trust us. Here's the thing or if somebody wants to look at it, um, somebody has that question, right? We can't >> we can't spell it out in every single with every single lens. So, uh, you know, Jim and you and and anybody that's going to be putting out something, let's just be really super transparent and have a link to the Cherry Sheet or whatever it is and maybe a little snippet of we pulled this and you know, just how we how we because we're trying to make it simple, but you want people to be able to say, "Hey, I have more questions about it or I'm not just going to trust you, Michael.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 104
So, I'm thanking her for letting me do that. And when every time I I did speak, I didn't have to give my name and address, which was an uncomfortable way of saying yes, Mark. Go ahead >> to the board itself as I sat in the steering committee meetings as a citizens participation. I still was drawn. I still was I I fell back a little bit when at one meeting they made a plaque for me as a citizen participator with my name on it. And that that show me that I I felt like they were comfortable with me being at home and understanding what everybody means. I'm I'm not a member, but as a citizen that's been going all these meetings and got a placard It made me speechless for a couple minutes, for a couple seconds until I got my breath and said, "Mark, just keep going." And then so I'm just thinking that and everything and um yeah um I'm looking at the the man down the uh with the wool hat on and and the little beard and the glasses.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 105
What is it? How does how do I do this?" And yeah, so just for whenever we're putting these things together, let's let's start to try to do that because that'll be part of our messaging and part of our transparency and trust, right? I think we've built up a lot of trust over over the last decade or so. Um and I think that would just help in the conversations going forward. >> Yeah, that's that's a good point. And um I'll just say, you know, the comparative the comparative data comes from the Massachusetts Department of Revenue. Um so yeah, we should include that uh moving forward. Um, I can tell you if you just look at our tax, you know, if you took a $100, right, and you said, "Okay, let's break it down and figure out, you know, how much of a $100 goes to, you know, our departments." You know, nothing here is really out of the ordinary, folks.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 105
He had taken all my notes and all my personalities when I was sitting right behind her one meeting and we got along real well. So all this after two and a half years along with the committee Jen and you and all the people that were involved two years didn't seem it went that fast. It was very informal understanding and I felt I felt as as a citizen I can speak for the town but I'm hopeful that the town will understand what the work behind what they don't see will be good for the future of the people coming in. So I thank you for letting me speak and I'm just gonna stay on Zoom here just to listen. Thank you. >> Thanks Mark. >> I I wanted to briefly comment uh as a planning board member, as a committee member. Uh the other day I took a walk in Ashlin State Park and reflected with my mom about 1993 when we moved to Ashlin the first time and then I came back to Ashlin later after leaving.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 106
Um, you know, $55 going to education that includes Keith Tech and the Ashlin public schools. That's generally that's generally normal. um you know where we really really get hurt I think sometimes is that benefits and insurance number um and I'll I'll get a little bit more into that um uh one of so what what's driving a lot of this deficit is our fixed costs I think Marcy you mentioned fixed costs earlier health insurance you know when we joined the GIC uh back in like 2015 2014 14 2015 we saved a lot of money at the beginning. So we saw an immediate savings and then you know we started seeing less of an increase than our uh our previous health insurance group the west suburban health group and so the GIC became very very attractive to other communities and guess what happens then they start joining them joining the GIC and so that starts pushing up costs and pushing up costs and so I think our the in FY26 we saw an increase of it was over 10% I believe and that's combined with I believe it was about a 10% increase the previous year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 106
Um but we reflected on how much Ashlin looks a lot some things look just like they were when I moved here my uh for my junior year of high school in 1993. Um Ashlin State Park looks a lot the same, although it's harder to swim in it because of the water pollution, but looks very much the same. Um the town has certainly changed. Um it, you know, we commented on those things and I realized as I was walking around Ashlin State Park, um that as a child, I certainly would have never imagined that I would find myself here at this meeting about to vote for this thing together with the select board. and how special that is to be able to move to a town and then see it grow and be part of its vision. Um, so that's really thrilling for me and I feel a lot of love for the town of Ashland tonight.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above