2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 127
Maybe some of the great programs at the library wouldn't be able to happen anymore because we don't have the staff to do those programs and to be in the building as much as they are now. Maybe there's something that has to happen at the schools that if we don't do an override, we have to be clear as to what we may not want to do. So, I just want to have a con. I want the community >> to be giving their input to us about what they support, what they think is important enough to to support an override. >> Isn't that >> I just wanted to can I I want to ask about that because obviously we're just representatives and I'm not elected so I'm just a volunteer. We're just representatives of the community so of course that matters. I'm confused what that would do to our timeline given how imminent this is.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 127
>> That's what I mean. I think we should include Kate on it. >> Kate should be listed as a former board member. >> Um Amanda Hayes as an associate member when it started. Um >> so >> makes sense. Essentially, we're including everyone who was and everyone who is. >> Yes. Is on board. >> So, >> okay. >> I move. >> Sorry. Is it possible to have what you just added put up on the screen? Because does it really say unwanted development on there? >> Yes, >> that's actually what it says because that's how we discussed it because we got a lot of public comment not wanting development in Ashland. Yeah, I'd just like to see the whole thing >> and uh part of the discussion at the comprehensive plan committee was to make that very blatantly direct that we considered it and we found balance or attempted balance.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 128
And I think we're saying we recommend we're we don't put forth the override. We recommend that a override is needed and then we take that time to talk through all of that with the town and the town gets to vote or not vote for it. I think that makes sense. But I feel like one thing we learned is the last time it was a really long process if I'm right. >> Felt it. Felt felt pretty long. >> It was not that long. It seemed long, but it was not that long. >> But I think some of the things we maybe learned or you got the sense that maybe there was so much time that it got confusing and not that we want to rush the process, but >> how it was presented last time was confusing. >> Oh my gosh, it was very complicated. Just the fact that you guys are talking about we didn't make cuts but when it didn't pass folks it was ne that was never the plan.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 128
>> Is that something you can bring up, Austin? >> It's two sentences added to the opening letter. It does not change any of the strategies or any of the goals or >> well I but I don't know there there does seem to be a lot of small town feel small town feel small town feel in there which does >> kind of emphasize that there's not a lot of development in there so like I just wanted to make sure I understood what it >> that's on the screen now >> those are the two extra sentences right >> not the whole the unavoidable earlier. >> I think the problem with the word unwanted development is that it doesn't explain why something's not wanted, right? I think that it's sort of a it's kind of harsh >> but at the same time >> is it is there >> I mean I'll be direct we had public meetings where people said no more so I think it's pretty clear and and we got that a lot >> right I I understand I understand but obviously there are a variety of um opinions and um >> which is why we had a committee balance it out we definitely talked to the committ wasn't wasn't discussed in the last meeting I was at it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 129
Remember the plan we didn't have a deficit the first year. The plan was to go ahead and pay it was a five-year plan passed an override and then you would bank the additional money and use it throughout the four-year period. >> So I'll say >> try explaining that one. >> Yeah. I'll say that someone who is a voter and was not uh elected at that point, I I did find it kind of confusing to make a decision, but I do want to echo Yolanda's sentiment. The last time that we got together when we met, I think in the spring and we talked about this, um we made it very clear, I think we all made it very clear that we needed to make sure that we had some kind of community input >> um on this cycle. And that's why we're we're we're talking now, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 129
>> Yeah, I mean this is the first I'm seeing this final two sentences. >> So it wasn't in front of the committee. It was not discuss but the I mean but this was this I mean a lot of the discussion and not just amongst the committee to Anna's point when you went out into the community and even now right as we're dealing with some of these projects that are coming before us it's not wanted and it's not that it's um you know it's not a not my backyard it's that they are the fear of that it is changing the small town fear feel of the community. I wonder if it can just be softened a bit by putting um and just to to satisfy every um both parties is before unwanted to say sometimes or often um >> how about concerns about developments? concerns about uncontrolled or >> so I want to be clear that the entire plan is quite vigorous in its balance between development, open space, community connection and I do remember the conversation at the comprehensive plan committee about this concept as recognizing one of the biggest challenges we had that we kept arguing about for two years consistently.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 130
Um, you know, I'm looking at the next steps. It's it's important. I think it's important for us to inject some element of community feedback before we make any final decisions on what if if an override happens and what that looks like. So, I think that um you know, I understand the time crunch. I understand that we're running a little late on what we need to do, but I think if we skip that and we need to identify the best way to do this within the time we have, but we need to include that community listening piece, an education piece to determine what our next steps are because we did say that we were going to do that last time and I think we do need to fulfill that that promise. >> I guess I'm wondering why can't they happen in tandem? you know, it's logistically happen at the same time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 130
I for one think these sentences really capture the most difficult issue that we had to confront for two years and softening it is going to soften all of those difficult conversations to something that never happened and it did. This is exactly what happened. This is what we had to confront. >> So Austin, I'm When did you get these sentences? And I'm surprised we didn't get anything like I'm looking for my email to see >> cuz this wasn't what we voted on. >> This is right. That's the other thing is we didn't vote these. >> Yes. Yeah. Um to >> I think Michael told you to write it, right? >> Yeah. I believe I recall the committee discussing um so um Roberta had volunteered to do some >> word smithing. Yeah. So, Yolanda suggested some of the language um to work with Michael on a revision to this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 131
>> Like I said, I I think we sure, but I'm just saying that like we just have to include that and we can figure out what's going right now and then at the end of the year we come back together then we're starting again. We do at the same time. >> Here's why. Well, or I mean, you know, again, I'm only one person. There's a lot of us sitting at this table because my fear is that if we here go, you know what, we think an override is what is needed based on what we've heard from Michael and Jim. >> Yeah. >> We're going to start going to the community and they're going to go, >> you guys have already decided. >> You guys have already determined. >> Well, it doesn't have to be presented that way. That's part of the messaging >> and that's part of >> that's not the sentiment at all.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 131
Um I believe that conversation was held before the vote that the committee took on the plan itself. >> Suggested it because I wasn't there before the vote. >> So, I I just could just want to explain what what happened. We had many many many conversations um about this balance and the need to balance small town town feel and we heard it many many many times in the survey in the meetings in a box in the public forums and everything and when we were talking at our last meeting um I brought it up again because we had talked about it in September. I think the meeting you were at, Trisha, it had come up then and we had had a big discussion about it and I just said that I felt like we would be doing a disservice to the public and the public input when they felt so strongly about this for us to just not even mention it and that we had to at least put it out there that we heard them, that we understood their concern, and that we did our best to balance it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 132
And I think I just want to I I think the clarifying part here is tonight whatever we decide to do, you know, it says here that we're looking at override options. If we if we do a straw poll tonight and say we're looking at options and one of those options is not to have an override, I'm comfortable with that. To say that we're proceeding, we're going to proceed and look at these options, include community input and such, that's fine. But to say tonight that like, yep, we're definitely going to need an override and, you know, we got to figure out how we're going to structure it. I don't think I'd feel comfortable taking a straw poll on that tonight. Just for clarification. And I think that's maybe that's the differentiation here that we need to to to from a communication standpoint and from a procedural standpoint that we need to make um and and and maybe go forward like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 132
So, it was Michael's letter, you know, the the dedication letter. And at the last meeting, he asked me if I would be willing to give a a go at writing something that would capture what I had said at the meeting. And I said that I would. And I wrote something and I sent it to him and I sent it to Jen and I think I sent it to Austin. And the part that says um the words that participated in the process were added by Michael. He edited that and he added that piece and he was fine with it um for his letter and we were not meeting again and so I couldn't circulate. It would be a violation of open meeting law for me to be sending something like that out and we weren't meeting again. We had our final meeting. So, um, it seemed like the committee gave Michael permission to give me permission to draft something and send it to him and he okayed it, made a couple of edits and that's why it is not in the version that you guys have seen because it happened after the fact >> and I think I thank you for for drafting it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 133
>> My understanding was that we were going to take a vote on exploring options. >> Yeah. not not saying to the community that we have to do this. >> So I think that we're kind of on the same page with regard to that because I think part of our fiduciary responsibility >> forward with exploring an override for 2027, >> right? And exploring could agenda don't do it. Yeah. >> We just need to be clear about >> for sure. Clarity and transparency is key here. >> Yeah. And I think we need to commit to that community involvement. >> 100% agree. I communicate that. >> Yeah. If I can just and just to clarify maybe so ultimately a decision is not made to put it on the ballot until the select board make that decision. >> Um and I want to clarify there's two bites at the apple here essentially.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 133
I remember the conversation we had. Um, I think the issue that that we're all feeling or I'm sure, let me put it this way, what I'm feeling is the unwanted development is a little I I think it's I it you know, and I and I can I'm I'm fine with the rest of that sentence and if we can just soften unwanted development to say concerns around development >> or unplanned development maybe Uh I would just say concerns because it's because we say while dealing with unavoidable and as many residents that participated in the process strongly stated concerns about development that's people are concerned. >> Would that become too generic if you put that way? Because we are very specifically >> indirectly addressing or attempting to address one particular development in the community. Right. So I don't know if say concerns of development it becomes like overall >> I I I genuinely think people came in and there were lots of people saying they don't want it and what we as a committee did is we recognized and we discussed it and we found we basically discussed that some of some development is unavoidable.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 134
You know you got a town meeting vote and you have to have a ballot vote as well. As noble as Yolanda you and Makita you know your intentions are I've never known that to happen in any other community. In most other communities, the the leadership decides based on the information they have, okay, we know it's it it is going to be a community discussion. The leadership decides, okay, we need to look at making this decision. Okay, we're going going ahead and making a decision to put it before the voters to have that conversation. What you're talking about, I don't think there's necessarily the time to do anything anything well in that structure. And also, you know, I I don't I like I said, I think it's it's very noble and admirable. Um, but I I don't I guess I don't really see much of a difference.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 134
We wanted to plan better for it. We wanted to create livable communities that and if development happens we wanted to work better. And that second sentence se tells that story. That first sentence and the words unwanted don't somehow get rid of all of our balancing all of our equitable work. It's just a recognition that for whatever reason the people of Ashland gave us a lot of that feedback and we can't just ignore it. We listened. We heard it and we attempted to create a community where development happens in a thoughtful livable way. What if out of what if we just remove the word unwanted right to that in that sentence because if you take away because if you think about it small town field while dealing with unavoidable if you take out and as many residents are part you know if you take out that middle section unavoidable development right the second part of that sentence >> is It has a term it's been a while since I've done my right but just take out if you if you keep you know to just take out the word unwanted it still talks to the word development and brings in that information >> the message >> and I think it's still I and and I and I guess that the thing you know it's sort of good we're we're hearing this conversation now now at town meeting will people pick up on that word on that sent in that in that letter on that sentence.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 135
I guess I'm kind of thinking like the way Shantel does. I mean, that's the conversation. This is what we're putting forward. This is what and I think we've heard continually about what's important to this community. I'm seeing a lot of headshake, nod. I think some of it's semantics which is really important versus we're saying we need an override versus we're saying we think we need to talk as community about our options >> several of which are types of overrides and one of their options is not to vote for an override. So part of it is messaging and semantics but I think to miss the opportunity to start now would be a big mistake. >> And I I agree. I I think like we should if we decide that we're going to kind of explore these options that all of us here, not Michael but all of us here are tasked with the community engagement over the next two months so that when when we do have options in front of us, we have some >> right so they're informing the next steps very much informing >> and I would say that that's all incumbent on us to have these conversations and maybe >> as different boards, we figure out the ways best to do that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 135
I don't know. But if we have some members of the board that are sitting here who were not part of the particip not part of the full comprehensive plan process are feeling a little prickly about that then it might be something to >> I can't I can't uh see the screen and who's uh here right now but um Michael Herbert was letting me know that he he should probably say a word about this. So he's out there somewhere in cyerspace. I don't know. Uh, Michael. Uh, there you are. Okay. >> Good thing we have various forms of technology. Go ahead, Michael. >> Thanks, Trisha. And, uh, we thought we were going to get through this one with without me coming in, but uh, no, just I was watching from afar and Ashley was just typing a note to the committee, but, you know, given the the subject of the discussion, I I figured I should probably chime in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting October 22, 2025 · passage 136
>> I I think that's fair. And I don't want I think when we we say semantics, sometimes people think that's dismissive. That's not. I want to make sure. I know that's not what you meant. I wanted to clarify that as well, but because again, you know, I think we have to be very specific and intentional with our communication. Even during our discussion this evening, I think clarifying the point tonight about our path forward was a worthy discussion to make sure that we understood that we are going to go forward and we're going to explore options, one of which might be not pursuing an overlight override, but we're exploring options at this point. And if that's what we're doing tonight and we're saying that we're going to commit to doing that, I don't have any any problems with that. But I just want to make sure that if that's what we're doing, we're communicating that clearly.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-24 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (October 23rd, 2025) · passage 136
I I think there's two key points that led to me feeling comfortable having this in here. Um and uh the first one is that u I do feel is extremely accurate that the people that we heard from through this process did say um you know that they did not want development. Now I think there's various reasons for that. Um I'm not sure everybody you know knows exactly you know kind of some of the technical aspects of what goes into that etc etc but this is how they feel and I think that is that was that is accurate. Second u and the reason I felt comfortable putting this in here is I do believe that we discussed this at the last meeting um including specifically that word unwanted. I remember feeling a little prickly about it. Um, you know, maybe everybody did not hear the same thing that I did.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above