>> Yeah. The other the other component is I don't think it's binary. I don't think you can have the discussion with the community without doing the work because >> it's going to be a not it's going to be a very productive conversation if you don't come with any answers to the obvious questions and and those things. So, >> uh and quite frankly, we we can't do anything binding because our agenda just says discuss budget. So, we can't take a vote of any substance even if we wanted to. Uh, so just be clear on on on that. >> Uh, but but I think it's committing to the work and I I agree with you. I think we talked a lot about the committing to doing the work before and I think some work has been done but that's going to be key because you can't have the conversations without it's the it's the catch 22 and you got to fi find that right balance of when are you ready to go have that conversation and you're always going to have people saying you've already decided because you've done all this work but we have to do the work >> to understand whether >> to have a good conversation because you can't just say hey what do you value okay thank you I'll come back and get It's not you're not going to get that many iterative conversations, right?
Uh, that's certainly possible in a large group of 29. Um, I also was on on Zoom. Uh, but I do feel like that that was stated and there were if there was not an official vote, there was some significant head nodding um, which then led to me asking if Robera would go ahead and craft it. Robera gave a pretty accurate uh summary of, you know, basically the sequence of that of those events. So, um I I just thought it was important to kind of add kind of why I felt it was comfortable in including it in this letter. >> And I'll say Michael and I agree rarely and I 100% agree with him, which is an important way to maybe end my last comment for the night before we vote. Do you I'm just asking for the people who think this this is important to be in there.
So, so you got to strike that right balance of when you engage during a process of discovery, right? You need you need the information to have a productive conversation. >> I I don't disagree with you, Paul. I think that the information needs to come first. I think one of the ways of discussing this with everybody in and around town, giving everybody the opportunity. Uh we've had public forums for a lot of different things and I think this is really important. It's important for every resident in town. So why not have a public forum on this topic have all the question have all the answers to the questions we know are going to be asked like like you've already mentioned and then you're not missing people. You're giving them an opportunity to come to a public forum. Whether they come or not, that's up to them.
What was the feeling of it before those two sentences and what like why was it so important? The end the end point of the whole document is the vision, right? What what's the importance? Did you just want to make sure you acknowledge that people felt that way? >> Yes. >> Are there other points in there that you acknowledge the way people felt about different things? So it was such a repeated theme in our conversations. Like if you had to sort of pick a theme for two years that we kept coming back to over and over again, this was one of them in my mind. So and I think that was the feeling Robera had expressed at the meeting. Whether you agree with the policy or the politics of it, the great majority of the Ashlin community who participated in our meetings kept coming back to this in different ways.
I mean you can lead a host to water, but that's as far as it goes. So you bring people in, you provide them a location, community center maybe here. We have other, you know, options. Zoom and WACA has all these different uh technical advances that we could utilize to reach as many people as possible to sit and go talk to people individually. That's a great idea, but at the same token, you're putting a lot of energy out there and you may not be reaching the people that we need to reach. So my suggestion would be to set up a public forum, get the answers to the questions that we know are going to be asked, and then if the people decide to come, they come. If they don't, well, shame on them because it's it's their future. >> It's their tax dollars that we're that we're we're working with.
So our comprehensive plan is a way to allow our community to grow for our diversity, for our economics while recognizing those concerns and finding balance. And that's really what we're trying to say in these two sentences. It's a way to say, "Hey, we heard you. We We heard this theme and we did our freaking best." So, I I don't look at that sentence as some sort of policy decision. We're not saying no more development. What we're doing is we're creating a livable document for the future where we're hearing this concern and and yet here we are developing and growing and how are we going to do that in a livable way? So, I think the prickly sense of this sentence is really mitigated and addressed fully by a two-year process and by the rest of this document. I I personally think the sentence is exactly what we need to do so that the public feels heard.
>> I think, you know, and another I I think a question I would love to know from the community is what kind of information do they need, >> right? >> Like what kind of what kind of questions do they have? What do what do they want to know, >> you know? Um >> I think one one thing I'll mention along those lines is um speaking on behalf of the finance committee. We're anxious to have public engagement because we feel that there is a mirror that needs to be held up to this community and there's nothing emotional in that statement. It's this just that this math eventually if something is not done there is going to be a fiscal reckoning of some kind. That's just a plain that's it. Full stop. I mean, and so, um, I'm not trying to frighten anybody, but a a protracted economic downturn with unemployment and declining home prices and rising interest rates and rising inflation will devastate us.
I mean, if there's real discomfort with it, >> um, >> well, like, is it is it all is it one piece of development that most people were complaining about? Was it all development that people were complaining about? Like, if I was an outsider reading this and I saw that, I would say the town of Ashland doesn't want me developing in this town, right? And that's not I and I don't think that's the message you want to get out there. >> And I don't know if that's the feeling that the town of Ashlin feels. Sure. >> That's why I'm wondering if is is this like one project that everybody really dislikes >> or is it two projects that everybody really disliked or is it a classification of BS that the whole town doesn't like? Like >> so I think the way it reads is exactly how it was heard which is we're growing too fast.
And we're not concerned, finance committee, again speaking on behalf of the committee, we're not concerned about a 2% deficit because we know these guys can sharpen their pencils and they might have to lay a few people off and that would not be great. But we're not worried about that because we know that that can be absorbed more or less and we could probably get by with minor disruption. A systemic disruption though 10%. We're not ready for that. And it's we're not doing this more or less for the residents that are even living here today. We're looking at doing this for the people who are going to be here 10 years from now. That might not be you. It might not be me, but that's the fiduciary responsibility we have to the town. So I I hear and respect everything everybody's saying, but to a certain degree I and I want community involvement, but there needs to be a unified leadership here because if we go into this divided or if people are wishy-washy or and you're entitled to your opinions, I don't mean that in a bad way, but if we're not approaching this in a way that uh is backed by the data, the reality, and holds that mirror up, it will not work.
There's too much development period. No more development. I I think that's what the what I think um maybe what Scott is saying I'm not trying to put words in his mouth that but that um if we got more specific about it >> there's probably a lot of those same people we're okay with the school which is development >> and and which we're and we're okay with the public safety building which is development >> okay with the YMCA which is development and so and so it does kind of put a very very heavy blanket statement. Which is why I'm wondering if just a one-word softening such as often, like often unwanted, leaves a little glimmer in there that hey, there's some things that a lot of people who would vote down every 40b but would still want the YMCA, you know, to allow that little bit of flexibility in there.
>> And uh I I I'm nervous about what that means for our future. Yeah, I think it's Oh, I'm sorry. >> Please. No, >> I was just going to say I think for the purposes of how do we move forward from tonight? Um I personally would like to see us commit to a meeting in December where we talk about um here's the different options if we choose to move forward with an override. Of course, with the option of not moving forward with an override also on the table. What does it look like with that $1 million figure that you said? What does it look like with the $3 million figure that you said in terms of how would that impact the school's budget? how would it impact the town budget? Um, and if we don't do it, what exactly does it mean? And so by and and I would like to see us commit to a meeting in December because it took us three months to put this on the calendar and we can't do that again.
Um, and >> how about off and welcome? that that could be too. I think it's softening it further, which may not be um >> I think the word often is sufficient to soften without changing unwanted. I I will tell you if you read the entire document, which is 47 pages, I I don't think there's going to be a developer out there who's going to read that one sentence and say, "Oh, Ashlin doesn't want my my money." Um I really don't think so. I think the entire 47 pages is full of thoughtful, livable development that is strategic and thoughtful. >> This is this is the opening >> in light of how aggressively we're developing. I don't think you have to worry about that. C >> could I just intervene with with a quick question with respect to this is a dedication statement which has nothing to do with the actions of the plan itself.
We and we we have to be mindful of we have to we have to commit to that and I think we need to at least figure out the next steps of how do we move this conversation forward? And I think that's the next piece in terms of that very specific data. What would those different options look like? How would they impact the town? And if if the decision is no, what does that look like? >> To that to that point, I my recommendation is everyone pulls out their calendar because I mentioned this to Michael. I said, can we put on the agenda that we put a date for our next meeting because to your point, it took us three months to get this one. And this is important. I mean, if we all think this is important enough, we think this is important enough to meet together.
Is that would that would that be a fair assessment? >> Yes. >> So the concerns that you all received from the residents themselves, which is what you were saying, Anna, is that these are the sentiments you heard from the residents of Ashland, not ne necessarily mean it's every resident from Ashland, but the residents who took the time to participate in the conversations that you all had. Those are the feelings that you had. How does that affect the implementation of this plan heading going forward? I don't think it does. >> I don't think it does either. I think the whole plan has strategies that the implementation committee is going to work with. I'm confident in the implementation process the same themes will arise because that's what our community is experiencing. Um, this sentence is simply a way to recognize that this is a tension point in our community that seem to be coming up in every not every but the majority of >> the majority and right now unfortunately because of the uh the environment that we're in currently that's this is in the forefront.
you know, um I was talking to someone from another community. Their tribe board meets on a quarterly basis. Every three months, their three boards sit together and I think it's something that I think it would be positive for us, especially with these things that we're looking at to do that. So, one, I would, you know, recommend let's pull out our calendars and try to find a date in December because if we try to do a doodle poll, that could take weeks. >> It's great. Just >> sorry, just just before I forget about it, one of I think the variables that I think needs to be on the table is just a timeline. That's what made me nervous about what what's shown up there is like, hey, we're going to do this at this time. Let's commit to the work and then if the work says, hey, we're not quite ready, but we will be, we'll be able to bridge to the next one, right?
>> But to be clear, the comprehensive plan does not say no development. The comprehensive plan does not change zoning to to stop development. The comprehensive plan, in my opinion, creates livable, strategic, thoughtful growth and development in parts of our community while preserving open space and a community feel to the best of our ability as a committee, which is exactly what those two sentences say. Okay. I think Michael is off his hand is off the screen so I I can never see him. But I I do so I'll let him speak in a minute, but I do want to make sure that we can you know I would like to know if there there there is no it sounds like Anna to you there is no compromise. There is no >> the word often is fine with me. If there's strong feeling uh in the room that we need to soften it I think often is as soft as we need to go.
So, let's scrap we need to have some idea of a timeline to to work towards. Sure. But let's make sure our messaging isn't like, hey, we're racing towards that data because that doesn't give us a lot of time to do the work and do some good, you know, if if we had a few more months, it might feel a little better, but I just think that needs to be one of the variables that we're we're exploring, too. The only the only thing I would say to that, Paul, is you know, yeah, you don't want to say we're racing through this, but we we know we have guidelines based on our charter and I bylaws of when things have to happen, right? When we have to vote things when things have to fiscal year, the next fiscal year. Something that says, hey, we know working back from those dates, if we want it at this time, we need to do it then.
I still don't think it's necessary at all and I don't think developers are going to be like, "Oh, good. Often is there." >> I really think we're overthinking this, >> Michael. >> Yeah. I mean, I'm I'm happy to I think revise my letter to reflect often unwanted. I I think I understand everybody's points. Um, you know, like I said, I do think what is originally stated in there is does capture what we did hear from people who did participate, but um it it is strong and I think often is a nice way to soften it without necessarily losing the color associated with it. >> Roberta, is that those are is that often. Okay. >> Acceptable. >> Thank you for asking. >> Okay. If >> anyone else out there on the comprehensive plan that want to put in their two cents. >> I just have one question.
But I'm saying um >> we should have started having this discussion after our budget in the spring, right? When we used $2 million in surplus funds to cut close our budget bud budget gap, right? And we knew that when we had our tri board meeting, we were talking about how we need to start the discussion sooner rather than later. And because of different things, we didn't. We waited until, you know, October 21st to start this discussion. Mike, what just this all this talk about time frame and stuff, right? I mean, you you guys are the ones who ultimately have to put forth the effort to build out the plan and tell us what you think, right? I mean, from a time frame perspective based on everything that would be involved to taking it up to a vote. Can you just get get a thought on like what we need to have done by when?
So, I mean, I'm looking at the full So, are you shortening the letter or is it being adjusted how it fits on the page or you're just adding these or because it's pretty it's a pretty long letter to begin with, right? >> It's one of mine, Yolanda. Of course. No, >> I'm just wondering how it fits on the page. That's all >> that page I'll say on the comprehensive plan has a big image and I can just slide the image over a little bit to make room. So, whatever um the final draft is will fit with the design. >> Chuck has come to the podium in the room. I just wanted to say that um you know I I'm not of the view that we should stop development. I think it's absolutely nuts raider, but that's what we heard. We heard small town feel all the time, you know, and to sort, you know, the in your future decisions, you can say, well, that's not realistic.