That that in turn happens to to be pushed down on district administration. That's their job also to bring information to the board. So working together to ensure that fiscal stability is one of the most important things that can happen. So that's that first level of fiscal oversight. The second layer is the county office. And so again, they're they're hopefully being seen as a helper and they're giving you good information. Um, we think that that's happening. We didn't hear anything contrary to that. Uh, but the the county office a lot of times will provide uh that common message to all the districts in their county. So, they're providing you direction in terms of what should be included in your budget and and and those kinds of things. Um, and they also act as an intermediary between the district and the state. So you got district level, you got county level, you got state level.
A lot of times if something's happening in a district that the state's going to, you know, ask questions, they'll go to a a county office first instead of going directly to um a a school district. So in terms of indicators of risk or potential insolveny, so these are 20 areas again that that we've identified as the ones that most commonly lead down the road to insolveny. So on our 30 plus years of experience. So in attention to the annual independent audit. If audits are being done late, not timely, if you're not implementing, you know, uh, suggestions in there, that can be a problem. I'm going to just kind of breeze through these. Okay, so budget development and adoption, not having an adequate process for that, insufficient budget monitoring, um, inadequate cash management. I don't think I'm going to read every single one. I think you guys can probably read, but those are the 20 areas.
And in fact, those are the first 10. Here's the next 10. I'm going to tell you that that indicators of risk or potential insolveny that is on our website free for districts to to see and there's some things that go along with that. Our fiscal health risk analysis tool is something that we've had on our website for a number of years. It's free for districts to use on their own. Districts can download the tool. They can go in, they can answer yes, no, or not applicable. Um, and they can complete that themselves. Many districts invite us in just like Apple Valley did um because they want that independent external look. Once you hire us, you don't get to say what goes into our report, right? So, they like that having that um outside perspective. Um it just kind of sometimes gives you a different look.
All right. So, give you just a little bit of an overview on our tool. It consists of 138 yes or no questions. Um, I will tell you that that there's a yes, no, or not applicable. The only time that your risk score starts to tick up is when we answer no to one of the questions. Okay? They are weighted differently. So, if you are in um there are some questions that are high-risk, there's some questions that are low risk. There's some categories that are high risk, some that are low risk. If we answer no to a question that's a high-risisk question in a high-risisk category, that is going to be scored more than if we answer no to a low-risk question in a low-risisk category. So, I just want people to know that that every single no question is not weighted equally. In fact, there is one thing that that um kind of pushed your district from moderate to high, and we'll talk about that in just a minute.
um right there. Um let's see that total risk score categories. If if you actually have the report, it's at the very end of our report. It tells you what the what the scores are. So if you're 40% or more, you're considered high risk. You can see moderate and low risk there. Now, what's interesting is your district, their score in and of itself fell within the moderate category. So when we to tallied everything up, it went to 31.2%. So it put you in the moderate risk for insolveny. What pushed you over is that uh and I'm going to have to refer to the report and I apologize, but at the beginning of the report we have so within those 20 areas there are questions under each of those. We consider some of those questions the ones that we consider high-risisk we have pulled those forward onto pages.
Let me look. Eight and nine that we consider material weaknesses. So those are a greater risk for your district. There is one 8.3 that actually took you if we had answered yes, then you would still be in the moderate risk. That one had a a a large enough waiting that it bumped you into the high category. It disregarded your 31.2% and it put you up there. And that question, I'll just go ahead and read it and we'll talk about it a little bit more when we get there, is if the district has deficit spending in the current or two subsequent fiscal years, has the board approved and implemented a plan to reduce or eliminate deficit spending to ensure fiscal sovereignty? We think that that is one of the greatest risks to any school district out there that if you are deficit spending, and it happens, that you have to come up with a plan and you have to implement a plan because otherwise you're spending down your reserves and you are spending your savings account.
So that particular one um bump bumped you into that category. We used the adopted budget um as the financial reporting period. Um you guys have had an audited actuals but but that had not taken place when we were here for field work. So we have to have a cut off. So we used your adopted budget. So that that's what our answers are based on. We came on site. I think we told you you know your district had to upload all kinds of documents ahead of time for us. I don't know. I'm going to say hundreds of documents. It's a lot. Um and we came on site for those three days and did our interviews, left and did our analysis and then then provided the report. Our report really focuses on on systems and processes, right? So it's looking at those 20 areas and how can you improve in those systems and processes.
All right, here are the areas that when we went to, you know, because you can look through here and see all the no answers and those are the ones honestly I would I'd concentrate on. Um, but when you go to page 10, see I need my glasses again on that one. It gives you a score breakdown by section. So basically these are just kind of like your your your top five in terms of um you know having a greater risk. So budget monitoring and updates, collective bargaining agreements, deficit spending, general fund, current year, internal controls and fraud prevention. I do want to make one thing clear on the fraud prevention. So this is an area that we have um batted around as a staff for quite some time. Uh because the thing that made you high-risisk in that area, I want to be very clear there's no fraud or anything like that that nothing like that came up.
But but when you uh one of the questions asked, do you have um how is it even working Jen? So yeah, a reporting system, an anonymous reporting system. Do you have a process for for actually working through those things that have been reported? So what it does is it encourages people to come forward. We think that that is very important and we and we express that to the district. Okay. So that that's why that particular area is is high um is because people weren't aware. Now, it's come to our attention after the fact that I think you have some we tip posters that are, you know, throughout the district and I think maybe one or two people may have mentioned the Wii tip, but making sure that that's part of your message, right? So, every year when you guys come back to school and you have your annual, you know, whatever, however you do that, make sure people are aware of that.
Make sure that your principles are making their staffs aware of it so that everybody departments are making people aware of it so that so that that is something that is encouraged so that if somebody sees something they're they're going to say something right. Uh it ensures that the district's um it it it just helps people to come forward and it ensures that the district um resources don't get compromised, right? So it also protects your employees too. You never ever want to put your employees in that situation where they're being accused of something. So I just wanted to make that clear on that. Okay. So we're gonna next we're going to get into the summary of current addition or current conditions. So I think we hit this home in our first presentation. Deficit spending absolutely is probably one of your largest risk indicators. Um this this particular slide only shows you know the last three years.
So it shows how you ended in 2324. Yep. you were 1.7 million uh deficit spending and at the end of 2425 you were 6.4 million deficit spending and this year at adopted budget you were projected to deficit spend 5.7 million. So we can see what that looks like. Now we did go back and take a peek at 2122 and 2223. You guys were not deficit spending then right? So something changed something changed that that increased your deficit spending. that this is an area um definitely that you need to look at and you have to get that board approved plan in place. Not only that does the board need to adopt a plan but then you need to implement that plan. You actually have to take that and put it into action to get rid of that deficit spending otherwise that will take you down the wrong road.
That is definitely one of the things um that we see over and over again. So, as of the the adopted budget this year, even though there was not or there was deficit spending in the current year, when we look at your outy years on your multi-year projection, you were actually projected to increase 2.6 million in 2627 and almost little under 4.6 in 2728. That is mainly due to one little box that's on your multi-year projection and it's called B1D and it's one of those funny things on the SAX form. I will tell you what the district has done is they've put a number in there. They were very transparent with their number, but they put 3.5 million in 2627 and a million in 2728. We see this up and down the state and I'm going to tell you my boss Mike Fine has done a little campaign to get rid of box B1D so that districts can't use it.
Um but we see districts doing this over and over again. So sometimes districts are going to put something in there that they um let's say that they had some one-time funds. They had some temporary employees associated with those onetime funds. they decided they've already taken action that those employees at the end of that one-time funding is going to go away. You could put an adjustment in there that's going to account for that in your outy years. Okay. The district has put those numbers in there and then in their explanation in box F, we put it as a a little point there. In box F, they identified reductions that need to happen in order to realize those savings. So, they're giving the they're giving a heads up in the sax form in the budget. Okay. In, you know, and that's where I have my notes and I apologize.
You think so? I apologize. I had my notes down. What side are we on? Let's see if I can tell you what was said in there. Okay. Next paper. So, so like for 2627 there was an estimated attrition reduction of $1 million. That's listed in the assumptions. An estimated certificated staffing reduction of 2.5 million and and so on. An estimated So, what they're saying is that that dollar amount that's going to put you positive in that future year, we would need to make these kinds of reductions. So, they're shining a light on it. But, but here's what we would say. Our suggestion would be that you don't use that unless the board has taken action because you don't know that you're actually going to realize those savings. So we we gave the district that feedback during interviews, right? We identified that and said this is something that needs to change.
Don't put a number in there and solve it because you haven't solved it quite yet. Make sure that it falls out and it shows an accurate picture. So because if you remove that 3.5 million then that year is going to look very different, right? and that's also affects future years. So, we've made that that suggestion to the district. Um, and and we think that that needs to happen. >> Yep. I'm going to add something to that. I'm going to come over here. So, a lot of districts um do this. Yes. >> Again, because they've been in the they've been in the position for a really long time, right? and they know that these are the reductions that need to take place that like she said the temporary contracts and what have you. So, we're fixing the problem. We know that there's discussions that going to that are going to happen, but it's also because now we're going to certify positive, right?
So, first and second interim budgets, you have a positive qualified or negative certification. And so, it's in there. It's very blatant, very transparent that this reduction is going to happen. Um and so now we have a positive certification. So in our conversations with the district is that again recommending not putting in the dollar amounts there and let it fall to the pro to the bottom so that you see what your deficit spending and selfqualify. So there is nothing wrong with the district submitting a qualified budget. Uh a lot of districts do not want that. But you are recognizing as a district that we have a structural deficit and it needs to be addressed. And so again, we as business people, we want to fix the problem. We know that these temporary funds are going to go away and so we know that we're going to fix it and so we put the put the numbers in there, but we're not driving the conversations necessarily that way.
And so again, it's a different thought process because a lot of districts always want to certify positive because it's a negative connotation to be qualified, but that's not the case. Self-qualifying real shows that you guys realize that there is a structural deficit and that conversations are going to start happening. So I would encourage that. And I'll just add on to that, the one thing you don't want to do is to to not recognize that problem and then have the county office downgrade you. That that definitely, you know, that I will say is is one of the greatest risks too if a district is not recognizing where you are. And and so you don't ever want to get into the position where your county office then is required to downgrade you because they see things differently than you do. So we would just encourage you to do that.
All right. Did we already do this one? And I lost track of where we were. Okay, next up is collective bargaining. Collective bargaining, yes, was one of the highest areas of risk. Um, you know, we we didn't see disclosure documents being prepared for agreements outside of the normal represented group. So, when you guys um would settle with one of your bargaining units, we saw the AB1200 disclosures, but but we saw manyus and things that had a fiscal impact. So, you know, one that comes to mind is, and I think we may have referenced it somewhere in the report, is, you know, there was oneouou that took some classified staff and totally redid ranges. That definitely had a fiscal impact on the district. So, you know, we just encourage the district anytime that you have a aou or a tenative agreement, anything to go ahead and and um create the AB1200 disclosure so that you can make sure that you can afford it, right?
it it discloses that information. I apologize for hitting that. [clears throat] And and the ones and and one more thing that really kind of increased your risk in this particular area is that the disclosure documents that we did review often cited um your unreserved unreserved general fund in excess of the reserves. So So basically it meant that you were using your reserves. So you were using one-time funds. That wasn't everything in there. So, it also cited some other things that you were going to use, but we saw that in many of the AB1200 disclosures as a way to pay for that salary increase. It it it said that you were going to be using that. So, again, the one-time resources should not be used for ongoing expenditures. And so, that's one thing that really bumped up your um score in that particular area. And and we all can acknowledge that those onetime funds really kind of muddied the waters, right?
it presented districts in a much more favorable light than they actually were as you were going through many of those things. So, um, one thing that we recognize, the board's taken action to offer an early retirement incentive. This is your second one, um, within just a few years. So, hopefully is going to bring you some additional savings. We don't think that looking at the state outlook that that is really going to offer much relief. So, we really think that the solutions are going to need to be at the local level and it's going to be about the things that we've already talked about, right? In terms of coming together, prioritizing, looking at what are your goals and your priorities for the district and being able to maintain those things, but again, reduce that deficit. All right. So, in terms of next steps, we've already talked about some of these, you know, continue your efforts to address your structural deficit.